
The morning’s undertones told you that the Islanders’ lineup could look different awfully soon. The evening’s overtones told you that might be a good and necessary thing.
As much as the Islanders have every right to be livid with how this game was refereed — from the stripes seeming to miss an Adam Pelech high stick before calling it off the arena video board to Luke Hughes’ brazen trip of Matthew Schaefer that went uncalled seconds before Jack Hughes won it in overtime, not to mention the 4-0 power-play disparity — the fact staring them at the end of this 5-4 overtime defeat was that they were badly outplayed by the Devils.
“Did we deserve a win tonight? Probably not,” coach Pete DeBoer said.

That was the case not only Saturday but also in the first two games of this homestand, both of which ended in defeat.
There were feel-good spots in this subplot-rife game, namely Ilya Sorokin’s 45-save night and Schaefer’s beatdown of Luke Hughes in a gloves-on fight, but the best news the Islanders had all day happened hours before when Mathew Barzal and Matias Maccelli shed their non-contact jerseys at morning skate. Though DeBoer didn’t say whether the pair will travel to California on Sunday, their returns to the lineup are starting to look like a matter of when. They can’t make it back soon enough, and ditto for Ryan Pulock and Calum Ritchie.
As for the lineup DeBoer did have at his disposal, well, it’s never a good thing when pregame line changes get abandoned after one period, as happened here.
The decision to take Scott Mayfield out of the lineup and leave the Islanders short on penalty killers was a head-scratcher as well.
This, though, was much more about the Islanders struggling to get to their game than any coaching decision. The intensity was there and lent itself to the best atmosphere of the season at UBS Arena, but even in getting out to a 4-2 lead, the Islanders never had a forecheck and never put extended pressure on the Devils’ zone.
More than anything, the difference going into the third period was goaltending — one accentuated even more when Sorokin stretched out his right pad to deny Nico Hischier at the backdoor 1:01 into in the final period.

The goaltending from Sorokin, who stuck out the same pad to deny Hischier a second time a little more than five minutes later, was a sign of the chances the Islanders were bleeding. Luke Evangelista cut it to 4-3 on a shift that saw Sorokin make multiple acrobatic saves before the Devils finally stuck one by him at the 6:08 mark.
“It’s fun watching him, but we can’t make him stop those every night,” Schaefer said. “It’s not fair to him. We gotta help him out a little more.”
That wasn’t the only way the Islanders beat themselves Saturday. Their penalty kill held out admirably, but the decision to go one penalty killer short bit them late in the third, along with an in-arena replay that seemed to influence the (correct) high-sticking call on Pelech that put the Islanders at 5-on-3 at 12:35 of the third.
After killing off the two-man advantage, the Islanders — who had leaned heavily on Pelech at 4-on-5 all night along with Logan Stanley — let up a power-play goal on a Dougie Hamilton one-timer that tied the game.
That wasn’t the only way the Islanders beat themselves Saturday. Their penalty kill held out admirably, but the decision to go one penalty killer short bit them late in the third, along with an in-arena replay that seemed to influence the (correct) high-sticking call on Pelech that put the Islanders at 5-on-3 at 12:35 of the third.
After killing off the two-man advantage, the Islanders — who had leaned heavily on Pelech at 4-on-5 all night along with Logan Stanley — let up a power-play goal on a Dougie Hamilton one-timer that tied the game.

The Islanders hung on for a point and felt the second was stolen from them on the uncalled trip of Schaefer. While the crowd was still screaming for a whistle, Jack Hughes had all the time in the world to pick his spot on a 2-on-0 break and score the overtime winner.
“I think it’s an obvious penalty,” Simon Holmstrom said. “If you compare them to the other ones, I think it’s pretty obvious. It is what it is.”
Schaefer was more diplomatic.
“It could’ve gone both ways, but I thought I did [get tripped],” he said. “But they could’ve seen otherwise. At the end of the day, it’s a good hockey game. They fought back. I thought we could’ve had a little bit of a better game leading up to it.”











I spent nearly 20 years in TV news, and he’s getting more airtime than me!” DeMarco wrote.
”







