Carson Coleman knew what was happening. It was hard not to know.
He was aware as he entered the game on June 5th at NBT Bank Stadium in New York against the Syracuse Mets that teammate and Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders starting pitcher Brendan Beck had not allowed a hit through the first seven innings. Although the other relievers in the bullpen were trying to honor that baseball superstition of not mentioning a no-hitter, subconsciously they were talking about it.
Coleman got a groundout and two strikeouts in the bottom of the eighth to take the no-hitter into the ninth. There, he retired the first batter on a groundout, then walked the next batter. But his first pitch to Kevin Parada was hit on the ground to shortstop George Lombard Jr., who flipped to second baseman Jonathan Ornelas, who threw to first baseman Seth Brown for a game-ending 6-4-3 double play.
The seventh no-hitter in Scranton/Wilkes-Barre franchise history was complete.
“Doing it for two innings was definitely more nerve-racking,” Coleman said. “At the end of the day, you just go out and treat it like any other outing. It was awesome, exciting, especially for it to end on a double play and then celebrate with the guys and Beck. It was an awesome accomplishment for him.”
This was the second no-hitter Coleman was involved in as a member of the New York Yankees organization. On Sept. 28, 2022, he got the final three outs for the Double-A Somerset Patriots as they won the third and deciding game of the Eastern League Championship Series over the Erie Seawolves with a 15-0 victory.
That one was a little less stressful because of the lopsided margin. Starting pitcher Randy Vásquez went eight hitless innings with one walk and eight strikeouts. The Patriots scored nine runs in the bottom of the first inning to seize immediate control. Jasson Domínguez led the offense, going 3 for 4 with two walks, two home runs and six RBIs. Coleman entered in the top of the ninth and, although he hit the first batter he faced with a pitch, he got a fly out, popout and strikeout to end it.
“It had been a really good season for me that year. I was more excited to hopefully be the guy to finish our championship, let alone a no-hitter,” Coleman said. “I just went out there and made pitches the best that I can and hopefully it came to fruition. Obviously, there can be a jam-shot single which you, as a pitcher, that’s not a bad thing, but it’s a hit. That’s baseball. There’s a lot of luck to it.
“But the championship was a lot of fun, especially throwing to Austin Wells as the catcher. Me and Austin both signed in 2020 and he’s one of my best friends. To finish off the no-hitter with a strikeout in the championship game and embrace one of your best friends and celebrate with that team which was a great group of guys was a lot of fun. Probably the best baseball memory I have. But the one with Beck is still awesome.”
The Tampa Bay Rays selected Coleman in the 33rd round of the 2019 MLB Draft out of the University of Kentucky, but he did not sign with them. The Yankees signed him in 2020 as a nondrafted free agent and he pitched for Low-A Tampa in 2021 before splitting time in 2022 with High-A Hudson Valley and Double-A Somerset.
Coleman underwent Tommy John surgery in 2023 and missed all of that season. In 2024, he was taken in the Rule 5 Draft by the Texas Rangers. However, he never threw a pitch for them. At the end of his rehab from the right elbow surgery, he had a hard time recovering from workouts or bullpen sessions. It turned out he had a rare nerve entrapment issue and needed another surgery that put him out for 10 more months, causing him to miss all of the 2024 campaign as well.
When Texas didn’t keep him on its roster, the Yankees had first dibs since he was a Rule 5 selection and they took him back.
“I think they were excited to have me back, I was excited to be back,” Coleman said. “I love this organization, they’ve been more than great to me. I definitely am going to give my whole heart to this organization, I owe a lot to them. I’m trying to make them as proud as possible. Obviously I wish things would have worked out in Texas because it was a big-league opportunity. But it’s exciting to be back.”
Last season was the first time he was back on the mound since closing out that no-hitter in the championship game for Somerset in 2022. Coleman appeared in a combined 17 games at four levels and had two saves, one hold, a 1.59 ERA and struck out 15 in 17 innings.
“It was great. I felt so happy to be out on a baseball field,” Coleman said. “Rehab is lonely and it’s a long road. Going back out, I could have gone five innings and given up 40 runs and obviously would not have been happy, but that’s where my head was at. I was back on the mound and that was such a big accomplishment after two and a half years. And last year went really well. I only threw like 20 innings and gave up just a run or two. All things considered, that was really good getting back into it.
“First time in Triple-A this year. First normal spring training I’ve had since 2022. New level, new challenges, so it’s been a good experience. It’s been a dream.”
Since combining with Beck on the no-hitter in Syracuse, things have been spotty for Coleman. He retired all four batters he faced to get the win in relief at Indianapolis on June 23rd and threw two scoreless innings to earn a save against Norfolk on June 30th. But in six appearances and 8.2 innings, he has allowed seven runs and 11 hits with six walks and eight strikeouts.
For the season, Coleman is 1-0 with one hold, two saves, and a 4.73 ERA in 24 games. He has 32 strikeouts in 32.1 innings. He has inherited 18 runners and allowed just three to score. Since April 18th, none of the seven runners he has inherited have scored.
“Until the month of June, overall I felt like I was making some good steps,” Coleman said. “I’ve kind of been like a coin flip this last month. A lot of it is the game of baseball. After missing a lot of time due to injury sadly last year and early this year, I think a lot of it is getting my feet back underneath me. So I’ve kind of been mindful of that. Now it’s just learn from your failures and try to do better. Take it a day at a time and try to stack some good outings together. That’s the game of baseball, especially as a reliever.”
The best advice Coleman has received in baseball was to leave it in the showers, whether it was a good outing or a bad one.
“Despite any rough outing that’s discouraging, I know it’s part of the game,” Coleman said. “If you get two outings a week and they both don’t maybe go the way you want, it obviously can get you in the dumps sometimes. But I can’t even tell you what I did in my last outing.
“When I was in college or even now, in the role of a closer, say I had a save. I’d see my parents and they’d be so happy and like ‘Great job!’ and I’d be not in a bad mood, but even keel. They’d be like, ‘What’s wrong?’ and I’d be like, ‘It’s good, it’s over with, I’ve got to do it again in two days. Maybe even tomorrow.’ Move on, it’s not worth taking home with you.”
Coleman is continuing to work on the little things that make the difference between a good outing and a rough one.
“It’s a long year – 150, 162 games,” he said. “As a reliever, maybe you’re going to get 50 outings. Just try to make the most of those 50 outings as good as possible.”
