LOS ANGELES — Shohei Ohtani was visibly caught off guard when Los Angeles Dodgers manager Dave Roberts informed him that he would not be the designated hitter in the series finale against the New York Mets on Wednesday, April 15.
So much so, that Roberts recreated his expression for reporters when he explained that the two-way superstar's responsibilities would strictly be on the mound as the Dodgers concluded their six-game homestand.
"(He was) maybe surprised, but fine with it, because I've never asked him to pitch and not hit," Roberts said pregame. "Explaining to him why, I think it makes complete sense."
The why was straightforward enough: Ohtani took a sinker from Mets pitcher David Peterson to the back of his throwing shoulder to lead off Monday's 4-0 win and was still dealing with soreness. He was also having issues getting loose to hit after his afternoon throwing sessions, though Roberts said Ohtani is feeling "much better than he did two days ago, and better than he did yesterday."
Shohei Ohtani gets hit up and high in his first at bat by David Peterson
— js9innings (@js9inningsmedia) April 14, 2026
This breaks up his lead off home run streak. Today, he was looking for 3 in a row to leadoff the game. pic.twitter.com/V5Hnw2jxwu
In Roberts' eyes, the move lets Ohtani focus on one thing and is what he feels is the best way to keep him loose throughout his outing.
"We felt — training staff, pitching coaches and myself — we just thought it was the best thing for him," Roberts said. "So once I told him, he completely understood."
Roberts expects Ohtani to be DHing again and pitching in his next start but didn't close the door on possibly dropping him down from the leadoff spot — or even sit him out of the lineup entirely — on some of his pitching days at some point down the road, if the situation calls for it.
But that's something that Roberts said he won't be necessarily proactive about. After all, anytime you don't have your best hitter in the lineup, it has to be a move that makes sense.
And for Roberts, taking the bat out of Ohtani's hands makes the most sense on Wednesday.
"Specific to today, I think this is the right decision," he said. "This is the best decision, for him not to hit today. Then the question is, when does he hit on days that he pitches? Where does he hit in the order? I think there's fair arguments to both — to moving him down a little bit, to give him a breather, to let him get into the game — I'm not prepared to make that decision quite yet, but it is something that I'm mindful of.
"You can tell (Mets manager) Carlos Mendoza he's an option, though."
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Why Shohei Ohtani is out of the Dodgers lineup vs Mets on Wednesday