
There have been some interesting games on Labor Day over the years. We begin in 2002, with the infamous 19-1 blowout against the Dodgers at Bank One Ballpark, which ended in Mark Grace working the ninth inning. At the other end of the pleasantness spectrum, and also against Los Angeles, we have J.D. Martinez blasting four home-runs against them on Labor Day 2017, in Dodger Stadium. Between those, we had Internet famous (and sadly missed) Arizona resident Grumpy Cat, who along with her owner threw out the first pitch, on this holiday in 2015, paving the way for a 6-1 Diamondbacks victory.
This one likely deserves to be filed alongside them. Despite being a bullpen game for Arizona, it was a taut pitcher’s duel, with both sides failing to score. The Royals left the bases loaded in one inning. The D-backs wasted a situation with men on the corners and no outs. But neither side could score in regulation. So it went to extras, where the D-backs proved to be kryptonite for Craig Kimbrel once again. They scored five runs, and looked to be laughing their way to victory. But Gerardo Carrillo had another nightmare, allowing four runs to score while recording one out. Dennis Santana came in with the tying run on second, but got the last two outs for the save.
If my searching is correct, it’s the first time in National League recorded history (per Baseball Reference) where a game was scoreless through the regulation nine innings, but ended with both teams scoring 4+ runs. It has happened twice in the AL, most recently in April 2015, when Houston beat Oakland, also 5-4. Though the record number of runs scored in a scoreless regulation game is 12. The White Sox and Mariners were scoreless through nine in June 2013. After four more sets of zeroes, Chicago scored five in the top half of the fourteenth – only for Seattle to do the same in the bottom half! The White Sox finally prevailed 7-5 in sixteen innings.
Anyway. A long, long time ago, Derek Law started for the Diamondbacks. It’s not actually his first experience of the role, having been the opener for three games during his time in Cincinnati, three years ago. He filled the same role in Toronto back in 2019. I’d forgotten the concept of the opener had been around that long, but it was started by the Rays the previous season. Today, he worked a pair of scoreless innings, assisted by a nifty unassisted double-play by Ildemaro Vargas. Though really, it was more a case of buzzard luck for the hitter. No change of that kind of thing happening twice in the same game, right? Right?
That was, by and large, the most interesting thing that happened in the first eight innings. Santana was followed by Jose Cabrera, who added three scoreless inning. That did get a little wobbly in the fifth, when he put men on the corner with one out. But in a demonstration of why attempting to bunt isn’t necessarily a good idea, the KC hitter popped it up, for Vargas to catch on the slide. The Royals then loaded the bases, before Bobby Witt Jr. hammered one with an exit velocity of 101.4 mph, sending it 375 feet, but fortunately into the waiting glove of Tim Tawa. Scoreless through five, it was then turned over to the more traditional bullpen.
Taylor Clarke worked the sixth and seventh, giving the team two innings for only the second time this year. The pair of scoreless frames reduced his ERA to 2.45. And, remember – he was tagged for four runs in less than an inning on Opening Day against the Dodgers. Since then, his ERA over 63 appearances and 65.2 innings has been 1.92. Brandyn Garcia struck out two batters in the eighth, and Justin Martinez worked around a walk in the ninth. He also threw a pitch at 103.4 mph, the second fastest ever thrown by a Diamondbacks (he had one at 103.6 mph last month).
The top of the ninth had seen Arizona have their best chance to score. Ketel Marte extended his hitting streak to six games with a lead-off single. A perfectly executed hit-and-run by him and Gabriel Moreno, saw our catcher lace one through Gaby Lane (TM, Berthiaume Productions, Inc.) to put men on the corner with one out. Nolan Arenado then came up, and on an 0-2 count, lined a 99 mph fastball, with an exit velocity of 101.4 mph… Right into the diving glove of the Royals’ third baseman, who was then able to lunge for the bag and double off Marte. He wasn’t exactly far off the bag: it was just the same buzzard luck, which had benefited the team earlier.
It felt like a momentum swing, but Kansas City couldn’t score, and so it was hello to old friend Craig Kimbrel in the 10th. Corbin Carroll was the man on second, having struck out woefully on three pitches to end the ninth. Ildemaro Vargas looked to bunt, and did so perfectly past a lunging Kimbrel, to put men on the corners with no outs. Lars Nootbaar pinch-hit and drove in the game’s first run with a deep sacrifice fly. But Kimbrel and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day continued. Arizona scored four more times with two outs, on RBI by Ryan Waldschmidt, Geraldo Perdomo (+1 on an error) and Gabriel Moreno.
To be fair, Kimbrel had actually been good against us since taking two losses in the 2023 NLCS while pitching for the Phillies. Five scoreless appearances, but that streak died hard today. 5-0 up in the middle of the tenth, with a Win Probability of 97.9% = game over, right? No. Enter Carrillo, whose last outing was also a stinker. Today was worse still. Four-pitch walk, RBI double, HBP, K, three-run double. His ERA has jumped from 1.06 to 4.15 in 0.1 IP. Should Dennis Santana have been up earlier? Well, given the results, I’d say he was up just in time. A fly-ball got the second out, but moved the tying run to third, before the most perfectly placed strike three (above) ended a dramatic inning.
This one seriously reminded me of some of the games in the 2007 campaign. There were a couple against San Diego where we blew a 5-1 lead in the ninth, only to win 9-5; or where Arizona were eight runs up at the stretch, only to squeak out an 8-7 victory. But the win’s the thing: it was the D-backs’ fourth in five games, all of them coming by a margin of one run. We now get to relax, enjoy the rest of the day’s games and engage in a little light scoreboard watching, while we prepare for the long awaited return of Corbin Burnes tomorrow…

Click for details at Fangraphs
The Dignity of Labor: Dennis Santana, +29%
Labor relations: Perdomo, +27%; Moreno, +21%; Cabrera, +18%; Clarke, +17%; Martinez, +14%; Vargas, +13%; Garcia, +11%; Law, +10%
Labor pains: Nolan Arenado, -34%
Labor dispute: Carrillo, -27%; Gurriel, -15%; Lawlar, -12%
To be fair, Arenado doesn’t deserve the blame, considering his double-play ball has an xBA of .530. Gurriel did not look good, in his first game back. Those Reno numbers look painfully real, and he may not see much playing time the rest of the way. 267, increasingly-stressed comments – feels like most of them came after the eighth inning! A number turned Sedona Red, but I’m giving it to chwalter, for one which slipped through the net at the time, but in hindsight proved entirely prophetic.

Tomorrow, the same two teams, albeit at a more civilized hour, with a first pitch scheduled for 4:40 pm, Arizona time. As noted above, it will be the long-awaited return of Corbin Burnes, who last pitched for the D-backs on June 1st 2025…


















