Five Phillies prospects worth protecting ahead of Rule 5 deadline originally appeared on NBC Sports Philadelphia
The Phillies have a few difficult decisions to make before Tuesday’s 40-man roster protection deadline, with several prospects looking to secure their futures in the organization.
Bryan Rincon appears to be the obvious choice. But how many other prospects are worthy of a roster spot?
Players signed at age 18 or younger must be added to their organization’s 40-man roster within five seasons, while those signed at 19 or older must be protected within four. Otherwise, they become eligible for the Rule 5 Draft, where another organization can select them with the requirement of keeping them on its major league roster for the following season.
Philadelphia currently lists 38 players on its 40-man roster, leaving two vacancies before the 6 p.m. ET deadline. Adding more than two players would require corresponding roster moves, potentially putting several members of the organization on the chopping block. Right-handers Andrew Hoffmann and Grant Holman, along with outfielder Colby Thomas, are among the players whose spots could be vulnerable.
The Phillies claimed infielders Brett Harris and Shay Whitcomb off waivers from the Giants on Nov. 2. Both occupy spots on the 40-man roster. And with the Phillies still expected to explore free agency for outfield, infield and pitching help, preserving flexibility will be important throughout the offseason.
Brad Keller, who is expected to miss most of 2027 following elbow surgery, could eventually be transferred back to the 60-day injured list. But that option won’t become available until spring training.
With only two openings on the 40-man roster and more offseason moves expected, the Phillies must decide which prospects are worth protecting now, even if it means parting with players already in the organization.
Here are five who have made their cases.
Bryan Rincon, SS
Rincon has made this decision relatively simple. The Phillies’ No. 4 prospect enjoyed a breakout season with Double-A Reading, hitting .267/.410/.517 with 26 home runs, 67 RBIs and 30 stolen bases in 118 games.
His .927 OPS was among the best in the Eastern League, and his 26 home runs matched his total from his previous professional seasons by a considerable margin. Rincon also drew 95 walks, providing additional evidence of an advanced offensive approach.
The 22-year-old switch-hitter was named the Phillies’ Paul Owens Award winner as the organization’s top minor league position player. His ability to play shortstop provides additional value, especially with questions surrounding Trea Turner’s defensive future at the position.
The sure-handed Rincon could find himself competing for a major league opportunity in 2027. Leaving him unprotected would give another team the chance to acquire one of Philadelphia’s most promising young players.
Aroon Escobar, INF
Escobar’s 2026 season wasn’t the step forward many anticipated. After hitting .270 with a .774 OPS across three minor league levels in 2025, the 21-year-old spent the entire 2026 season with Reading. He hit .230/.332/.347 with 12 home runs, 69 RBIs and 27 stolen bases across 132 games.
His production declined, particularly in the power department. But his underlying numbers weren’t without encouraging signs. Escobar walked 67 times against 92 strikeouts in 569 plate appearances, maintaining solid plate discipline despite the offensive struggles. He also finished the season on a high note, hitting .372 with three home runs and a 1.134 OPS in 12 September games.
The Phillies sent Escobar to the Arizona Fall League for additional development. Through 14 games with the Surprise Saguaros, he hit .250/.383/.375 with two stolen bases. Escobar, ranked sixth in Philadelphia’s system, has received work at second base, third base and first base.
His struggles at Double-A make his immediate major league readiness questionable. But his age, positional flexibility and offensive potential remain intriguing. Even if Escobar doesn’t factor into Philadelphia’s long-term infield plans, he could become a useful trade piece as the Phillies look to improve their major league roster. Protecting him would ensure they retain control of that decision rather than risk losing him in the Rule 5 Draft.
Mavis Graves, LHP
Few pitchers in the Phillies’ system had a more encouraging finish to 2026 than Graves. The 22-year-old left-hander began the year in High-A Jersey Shore’s rotation, posting a 4.78 ERA with 86 strikeouts in 58⅓ innings across 16 starts. His season took a significant turn following a promotion to Double-A Reading in late July.
The Phillies shifted the 6-foot-6 southpaw into a bullpen role, where he recorded a 0.96 ERA, 31 strikeouts and 14 walks in 18⅔ innings across 14 appearances. Graves didn’t allow an earned run in his final 13 regular-season outings, a stretch spanning 17⅔ innings with 29 strikeouts. He added another 3⅔ scoreless innings during Reading’s postseason run, helping the Fightin Phils capture the Eastern League championship.
Graves isn’t an overpowering pitcher in the traditional sense. His fastball generally operates in the low 90s, but his ability to generate movement and spin on his secondary pitches has helped him miss bats. He features a sweeping breaking ball, a harder cutter-like slider and a changeup. His breaking pitches have been a particular point of emphasis in the organization’s development of the young left-hander.
Graves is ranked No. 26 among Phillies prospects, and his late-season transition gives him a potentially clearer path to the major leagues. His command remains an area for improvement, but the success he found in relief makes him an intriguing candidate for a club seeking inexpensive left-handed bullpen help. That’s also what makes him a player Philadelphia should consider protecting.
Wen-Hui Pan, RHP
Pan’s 2026 season was particularly encouraging considering where he stood a year earlier. The Taiwanese right-hander underwent Tommy John surgery in November 2024 and missed the entire 2025 season. He returned this spring and worked his way through three minor league levels, appearing in 38 games and posting a 3.10 ERA with 48 strikeouts in 40⅔ innings. Pan went 5-0 with six saves.
His most dominant stretch came at High-A Jersey Shore, where he recorded a 0.82 ERA, 13 strikeouts and two walks over 11 innings. He reached Reading in June and finished with a 3.52 ERA in 23 Double-A appearances, striking out 21 while walking nine in 23 innings. In July, Pan was selected to represent the organization in the All-Star Futures Game at Citizens Bank Park.
His season ended on an encouraging note. Pan made three scoreless appearances during Reading’s postseason run, allowing no hits and striking out six across four innings.
The 24-year-old has the type of power repertoire that could attract attention from other organizations. His fastball can reach the upper 90s, complemented by a splitter that has traditionally been his most effective secondary pitch. The question is how consistently he’ll command his arsenal as he continues working his way back from surgery.
Pan, ranked No. 20 in the Phillies’ system, has yet to pitch above Double-A. But his ability to miss bats and his experience in relief give him a conceivable path to a major league bullpen. Given the Phillies’ need for relief pitching, protecting Pan would also preserve a potential internal option for the future.
Raylin Heredia, OF
Heredia isn’t among MLB Pipeline’s top 30 Phillies prospects, but his production at Reading deserves attention. The 23-year-old outfielder hit .278/.317/.473 with 23 home runs, 74 RBIs and 25 stolen bases across 135 games. His 151 hits led Reading, while his combination of power and speed made him one of the club’s most productive offensive players. Heredia spent the entire season at Double-A after playing just 71 games with High-A Jersey Shore in 2025.
There are concerns with his offensive approach. Heredia struck out 147 times against just 25 walks in 577 plate appearances at Reading. His .317 on-base percentage also raises questions about how his offensive production would translate against more advanced pitching.
Still, the power-speed combination is difficult to overlook. Heredia was eligible for the Rule 5 Draft last offseason and went unselected, but another full season of Double-A production could make him a more appealing target. For an organization searching for outfield help, keeping a productive young outfielder in the system is worth considering.
More uncertainty ahead
Protecting all five players would bring the Phillies’ 40-man roster to 43, requiring three corresponding moves. That’s a substantial commitment for a club looking to remain active this offseason.
Philadelphia has also reportedly agreed to minor league deals with Max Kranick, Bryan Ramos and Geoff Hartlieb, adding organizational depth without occupying 40-man roster spots. Kranick, who posted a 3.65 ERA with the Mets in 2025, is among those who could compete for a major league role next spring, potentially creating another roster decision.
There is also uncertainty surrounding the Rule 5 Draft itself. With MLB’s collective bargaining agreement expiring Dec. 1, a potential lockout could prevent the major league portion of the draft from taking place. The Phillies must decide whether protecting additional prospects is worth the roster commitment, particularly if those players could be prevented from participating in minor league activities during a work stoppage.
The Phillies don’t have to protect all five. But with two open spots and several fringe players already on the roster, there’s an argument for keeping more than just Rincon out of other organizations’ hands.













