
It wasn’t exactly the Mets’ season in 2026, was it? As of August 27, they sit 14 games under .500, 12 games out of a Wild Card spot, and 19 games out of the division lead in the NL East.
But while it’s a bit too late to say “never say never” regarding any 2026 playoff aspirations, it’s never too early to say “there’s always next year.” Luckily for Mets fans, there are quite a few intriguing storylines to watch as this season winds down, from rookies chasing history to prospects gaining power to unexpected names vying for a spot in the Mets’ future plans.
Here are the 10 most important questions for the month of September as the Mets look ahead to 2027.
Note: All stats as of August 28
WILL THE YOUNG STARTERS TIRE?
Nolan McLean, Christian Scott, and Zac Thornton have each put together promising seasons, but all three are either approaching or have already surpassed their previous career highs in innings pitched. The Mets don’t appear interested in fully shutting down any of their young starters, so seeing how they respond when pushed into uncharted territory (something Andy Green will surely monitor from a player development standpoint) will be an indicator of just how much volume to expect from the trio in 2027.
WHO IS LINDOR AT SHORT?
For all the factors that have contributed to the Mets’ 2026 downward spiral, Lindor’s absence–and his defensive regression while on the field–has surely been one of the most critical pieces. Each of the previous four seasons, he posted an OPS+ over 120 with an Outs Above Average in the 89th-percentile or better. This season, while his offensive numbers have dipped (109 OPS+), his defensive numbers plummeted, falling to the 30th-percentile in OAA. He also made a number of uncharacteristic mental mistakes early in the season. But if he continues to flash the leather down the stretch (as he did in the ninth inning against the Brewers on Tuesday night), perhaps he can prove those metrics an aberration rather than a new norm for the former Platinum Glove Award winner.
HOW FAR WILL CARSON BENGE GO?
This entry could have also been titled, “How hard will Carson Benge throw?” But part of the fun of watching Benge this next month will be seeing just how many benchmarks he can reach on all sides of the ball. Will he become the first Mets rookie to record a 20/20 season? Will he overtake Mookie Wilson’s long-held franchise record of 24 stolen bases as a rookie, and if so, will he actually hold the new record (or will that honor go to A.J. Ewing)? Will he make any more history with his dazzling outfield assists, or will teams learn to stop running on him? Perhaps most intriguing, will any of it be enough to make up for the WAR deficit between him and JJ Wetherholt, earning him the National League Rookie of the Year Award and earning the Mets a 2027 draft pick via the Prospect Promotion Incentive?
LAST CALL FOR A PAIR OF BABY METS?
Mark Vientos and Brett Baty, the bell may toll for thee. There have been glimpses of greatness from both former prospects. Vientos went on a legendary tear during the team’s magical 2024 surge to a playoff spot before clubbing five homers in the postseason. Baty put up 3.0 bWAR in 2025 with above-average offensive production and above-average defense at third base. But consistently continues to elude them both. It hasn’t been easy for either player this season, with Vientos battling injuries and Baty being asked to learn several new positions after finding a comfortable home at third last season. But the bottom line is, in over 650 combined plate appearances this season, the duo’s OPS+ is below 80. It’s not inconceivable one or both of them could break out next season, but barring a massive September showing, there’s every chance the Mets part with the homegrown pair this offseason.
WHICH RELIEVERS PITCH INTO ’27 PLANS?
Nate Lavender. Jefry Yan. Daniel Duarte. You probably didn’t know their names a month ago, but after a bullpen shuffle at the Deadline, the Mets have received surprisingly stellar relief pitching from a corps of up-and-comers. Aside from Devin Williams and Reed Garrett, the Mets essentially have no established relievers under contract through 2027, leaving the bullpen wide open for any number of these new names to secure a spot if they keep rolling through September.
JARED YOUNG, IS THIS FOR REAL?
If I told you on Opening Day that the Mets’ primary first baseman would post a 114 OPS+ and neutral Fielding Run Value of 0, you’d probably say, That’s a slightly disappointing but decent season from All-Star signing Jorge Polanco, who is making $20 million this year. But by gosh, those are Jared Young’s numbers! He’s 31 years old, had played in only 44 major league games prior to this season, and is under team control through 2031. Have the Mets hit the jackpot with a reliable left-handed bat for the middle of their order? Or has this stretch from Young been something of a mirage? He’s hitting .303 with an .807 OPS in August, so he’s only getting better with time, but the way he finishes may determine how he factors into the Mets’ 2027 plans.
ANOTHER CHANCE FOR TONG?
This season hasn’t quite marked the step forward some were hoping for Jonah Tong. After winning the Minor League Pitching Prospect of the Year award in 2025, Tong has pitched to a 4.86 ERA in Syracuse, seeing his once-otherworldly K/9 drop to 10.6 and his BB/9 rise to 5.1. But he’s still only 23 years old, and when the Minor League season comes to a close in early September, he could be called upon for another cup of coffee in the majors to absorb more big-league experience. The Mets could place Tong in Robert Stock’s rotation slot, or keep both in a six-man rotation – potentially a way to ease the innings burden on their other young starters, as previously discussed.
IS SENGA A CLOSER?
After three years of tinkering with his mechanics and his pitch distribution, did the Mets and Kodai Senga finally strike gold? Did they uncover the answer? Was he secretly a wipeout closer this whole time? It’s not such a crazy idea. The fastball and forkball can be a devastating 1-2 punch, and if he’s only throwing to batters once per game, two pitches might be all he needs. If Senga gets comfortable in the role over the next month and “Beat It” becomes a ninth-inning mainstay at Citi Field, the question of the back-end of the bullpen since Edwin Díaz’s departure – as well as the multi-year question of Senga’s trustworthiness as a valuable member of the pitching staff – might be answered entering the offseason.
ARE YOU OPT-IN OR ARE YOU OPT-OUT?
The Mets might as well host a “The Bachelor”-style rose ceremony in November. Bo Bichette, do you give this rose to David Stearns? David, do you give this rose to Luis Robert Jr.? A pair of All-Stars who just an offseason ago were blockbuster acquisitions could be on their way out – or returning to Flushing – depending on how the contracts are settled. Bichette would be opting out of $84 million over the next two years, and given recent reporting about his bonds with the Mets rookie outfielders, perhaps the salary and company will entice him to stay in New York despite the team’s relatively gloomy season. As for Robert, the choice belongs to the Mets, who have a club option for $20 million to retain the outfielder through the 2027 season. Robert has shown off his power this year, but he’s also shown his injury proneness. With Soto, Ewing, and Benge undoubtedly set to occupy the starting outfield next season (though there’s certainly a case to be made that Soto should shift to a full-time DH role sooner rather than later), will Robert prove he still has a place on the team?
WHICH PROSPECTS RISE TO THE TOP?
Between hot-hitting draftees and high-profile Deadline acquisitions, the Mets’ minor league system appears to have an influx of talent. Currently, their No. 1 prospect according to MLB Pipeline is Jefferson Rojas, acquired from the Cubs in the Tyrone Taylor/Clay Holmes trade, with southpaw Jonathan Santucci, 18-year-old Elian Peña, and 2025 first-rounder Mitch Voit trailing right behind. Die-hard Mets fan Sammy Stafura, acquired from the Pirates in exchange for Luke Weaver, sits at No. 8, Canadian second baseman Émilien Pitre is listed at No. 11, and Billy Amick – currently seventh among all minor leaguers with 33 home runs – isn’t even ranked in the Top 30. It will be fun to watch how these potential future Mets – the homegrown ones and the newly-added ones – perform over the final weeks of the minor league season as they attempt to separate themselves from the crop entering next year.












