Jacob Misiorowski versus Chase Burns was rightfully billed as one of the season’s top pitching matchups. And we did get to see a bunch of really good pitching from both pitchers. But one ill-timed and uncharacteristic mistake from Misiorowski cost the Brewers, while the bottom of the Reds’ order did a whole bunch of damage today and gave Burns more than enough of an early cushion to lead Cincinnati to a comfortable win.
Surprisingly, it was the Reds who jumped out to an early advantage. After Misiorowski started the game with a three-pitch strikeout of Elly De La Cruz, Sal Stewart pounced on a 102-mph, 1-2 fastball that didn’t quite get high enough in the zone and hit it out to right-center. Credit to Stewart — players just haven’t been able to barrel up Misiorowski’s fastball this year, and Stewart caught one. Misiorowski proceeded to strike out both of the next two hitters to end the inning, but Cincinnati handed Burns an early lead.
Burns didn’t get off to an ideal start either, as his afternoon began with a four-pitch walk to the scuffling Christian Yelich. Burns recovered and got Jackson Chourio to pop out to first base, and Brice Turang struck out, though Yelich stole second base on the last pitch to Turang. William Contreras had a chance with a runner in scoring position and two outs, but he struck out on three pitches, and the inning ended.
Misiorowski started the second with his fourth strikeout, and then finally decided to mix it up by getting Noelvi Marte to ground out. A strikeout of Edwin Arroyo ended the inning and gave Misiorowski five Ks through two innings.
Jake Bauers crushed a line drive to start the bottom of the second, but he hit it right at the first baseman, Nathaniel Lowe, for a tough-luck out. Garrett Mitchell had a nice at-bat too, and drew a seven-pitch walk, but then had a brain fart; Sal Frelick hit a ball to fairly deep right-center, but it was pretty clearly catchable, and Mitchell forgot how many outs there were. Frelick’s fly ball was just the second, but Mitchell was at third base when the catch was made, and he was casually doubled off.
Jose Trevino started the Reds’ third with a single just past a diving David Hamilton at third. TJ Friedl followed with a bunt that might’ve gone for a hit, but Hamilton made a nice bare-handed play, and then Bauers made a great pick on the throw over to first to secure the first out. De La Cruz hit a fly ball to medium left that became the second out, and with Trevino still at second base, Stewart struck out on an unsuccessfully checked swing on a 3-2 curveball in the dirt.
Cooper Pratt started the bottom of the third with a solid drive to right field, but Marte was able to make the catch on the warning track. Hamilton was next and hit a ground ball up the middle that Burns knocked down with his glove, which gave Hamilton an infield single. Yelich, up next, jumped on the first pitch and hit a drive deep to left, but JJ Bleday made a jumping catch against the wall (and briefly got his foot stuck in the padding at the base of the wall). With Chourio batting, Hamilton stole second base, but Chourio struck out to end the inning.
Bleday started the fourth with a perfect bunt toward third. Hamilton very nearly made a great play to get him, but Bauers couldn’t hold onto the throw — it wasn’t a difficult play for Bauers, so it was a weird E3. Misiorowski’s tough luck continued when Euguenio Suárez hit a jam-shot pop-up single to shallow right that put runners on the corners with nobody out. Miz took a step toward getting out of it when Lowe, on the first pitch, hit a pop-up to Pratt, but Marte, also swinging at the first pitch, lined a single up the middle for an RBI single. Arroyo struck out, too, but Misiorowski left a 3-2 cutter over the plate, and Trevino hit it just over the wall in the left-field corner for his first home run of the season, a three-run shot that made it 5-0. Given Trevino’s marginal ability with the bat, it was fair — as Brian Anderson did on the broadcast — to question why Misiorowski didn’t just use his fastball on 3-2, but hindsight is 20/20, as they say.
Turang reached on an error by De La Cruz to start the bottom of the fourth, but Contreras flew out, Turang was caught stealing, and Bauers hit one to the warning track in the wrong part of the ballpark in deep center. Through four innings, the Brewers had three of the top five and eight of the top 12 hardest-hit balls in the game, but they had nothing to show for it — almost literally, as only Turang’s error and Hamilton’s infield single were the only of those eight batted balls in which any Brewer reached base.
Miz came back in the fifth with a quick three-up, three-down, two-strikeout inning, but the Brewers needed runs. Mitchell was happy to oblige. He jumped on Burns’ second pitch of the bottom of the fifth and sliced it out to nearly the same place that Trevino hit his, down the left-field line, for a solo home run; that made Mitchell 5-for-5 with four extra-base hits and a walk in his last six plate appearances.
Milwaukee unfortunately couldn’t build on the momentum of Mitchell’s homer. Frelick grounded out to second, Pratt flew out to right, and Hamilton struck out. The Brewers were on the board, but still had a long way to go.
Misiorowski was pulled after five innings, perhaps a strategic move to manage his long-term workload, given he had thrown only 82 pitches (there was no sign of any injury). Miz made a couple of mistakes, but his defense didn’t help him, and he still showcased what makes him so unhittable. In five innings, Misiorowski allowed five runs (though only one was earned), didn’t walk anyone, and struck out 10.
He was replaced by Grant Anderson, who did a nice job. He struck out Suárez and Lowe, then got Marte to ground out to second for a quick inning. Milwaukee’s offense then kept pecking away in the bottom of the inning. Yelich, after not challenging a 3-0 pitch that appeared to be ball four, flew out to left. But Chourio hit a one-out single on a ground ball up the middle, and Turang followed by slapping a ball down the left-field line for a double, which Bleday misplayed, allowing Chourio to score from first. Contreras was next, and he hit a ground ball back to Burns, who made a heads-up play and, instead of throwing to first, caught Turang too far off the bag at second. After the ensuing pickle, the Brewers had Contreras on first with two out instead of Turang at second, but it didn’t matter anyway as Bauers grounded out. The Reds led 5-2 after six.
Anderson was out for his second inning in the seventh. He got the first two quickly, but the Reds’ nine-hole hitter, TJ Friedl, got a 1-0 fastball right down the middle at 92.7 mph and managed to hit it out to right-center. It was a nice day for five batters for Anderson, but the sixth left a sour taste, and Anderson was pulled in favor of Jared Koenig. De La Cruz, Koenig’s first batter, lined a single into left, and his second batter, Stewart, walked. Koenig got ahead of Bleday 0-2, but followed with four straight balls to load the bases. It wasn’t easy, but Koenig managed to get Suárez to fly out to right to end the inning and strand the bases loaded.
Burns gave way to Sam Moll in the seventh. He finally retired Mitchell, but it took a nice play on a swinging bunt up the first-base line. Frelick was next, and he was hit by a pitch to give the Brewers a baserunner. Pratt, who needs a hit, made good contact, but his line drive was snagged by Stewart — brutal, as Pratt would’ve had extra bases. Instead, the Brewers had two outs and sent Joey Ortiz to the plate to pinch-hit for Hamilton, and he flew out to right.
The Reds added another in the eighth. Joel Kuhnel replaced Koenig and gave up a leadoff single to Lowe. After a couple of fielder’s choice groundouts (including an incredible play by Ortiz), Trevino and Friedl hit back-to-back two-out singles to score the Reds’ seventh run. It could’ve been worse, too, but Frelick made a fantastic diving catch to rob De La Cruz of another run-scoring hit.
Yelich appeared to draw a leadoff walk to start the bottom of the eighth, but an ABS challenge from Trevino reversed the 3-2 pitch by the slimmest of margins. Moll then gave way to Tejay Antone, who got Chourio to ground out and struck out Turang.
For a feel-good moment at the end of a lousy day of baseball, the Brewers handed the almost-29-year-old Garrett Stallings his major league debut in the top of the ninth. Stallings, who was drafted by the Angels way back in 2017 and has been pitching for Triple-A Nashville since midway through the 2024 season, needed just one pitch to get his first major league out when Stewart flew out to left. The next hitter, Bleday, picked up a cheap single off the end of the bat, and Suárez worked a walk. But Spencer Steer flew out to center, Marte struck out, and Stallings had a scoreless first outing.
Brock Burke was the Cincinnati pitcher in the ninth, and the game ended anticlimactically. Contreras grounded out on the first pitch, Bauers struck out looking, and Mitchell lined out to second base to end the game.
It was a dud of a game and a disappointing use of what could’ve been another good Misiorowski start — he really only made the one bad pitch, to Trevino — but it was still a good series for the Brewers, who took three of four and still hold a five-game lead in the NL Central despite the Cubs’ recent hot streak. The Brewers only managed four hits in this game, with the highlights being Mitchell’s home run and Turang’s double.
Flush it and move on to the next one! That next one comes tomorrow night in Arizona, with an 8:45 p.m. CT start.
