The dominos keep falling — not quite in the Phillies' favor originally appeared on NBC Sports Philadelphia
In consecutive days, two of the biggest position players on the market signed deals, both landing in the National League.
Kyle Tucker signed a record four-year, $240 million deal with the defending champion Dodgers on Thursday night. Within 12 hours, the Mets pivoted and landed Bo Bichette on a three-year, $126 million contract.
The Phillies were left on the outside.
The move that stings most is Bichette heading to a division rival. Philadelphia had been heavily linked to the Florida native, and the interest appeared to intensify after Tucker came off the board. In many ways, Tucker’s signing is what pushed the Mets toward Bichette.
Steve Cohen has shown a willingness to strike when a top-tier bat becomes available. Last offseason, it was Juan Soto. This winter, it was supposed to be Tucker. When that door closed, Bichette became the pivot.
The Phillies made a real push. It was reported they offered Bichette a seven-year, $200 million deal — a contract that would have made him the highest-paid second baseman in baseball, the position he was best suited to play in Philadelphia. But Bichette chose flexibility, even after requesting the contract structure from the Phils.
His Mets deal includes opt-outs after each of the first two seasons, plus a $5 million buyout after Year 1. That structure allows Bichette, who turns 28 in March, to collect $47 million by the end of 2026 and re-enter the market ahead of his age-29 season — right when the Phillies’ offer would have aligned in total value.
The organization’s stance mattered. The Phillies do not offer opt-outs. That approach has worked for them, but in cases like this, it gives other clubs leverage when flexibility becomes the selling point.
Still, losing Bichette helped clear the path for one of Philadelphia’s top priorities.
The Phillies re-signed J.T. Realmuto to a three-year, $45 million deal. Two days after Ranger Suárez left in free agency for Boston, retaining a leader of Realmuto’s caliber arguably became more important. At 34, he remains central to a pitching staff that has ranked among baseball’s best over the last several seasons.
With pitchers and catchers reporting Feb. 11, there are two ways to view the current state of the roster.
The first is straightforward. The National League got tougher. The Dodgers and Mets added star power. The Phillies improved defensively in the outfield and added bullpen depth, but they did not materially upgrade the offense. The core is a year older, and it is not a young one.
The other view is less emotional but just as valid. This is a team with four straight postseason appearances and back-to-back 95-win seasons. Nothing about the roster suggests it can’t replicate regular-season success. And financially, there is still room to maneuver.
Philadelphia offered Bichette roughly $28.5 million in average annual value. Only $15 million of that went toward Realmuto. That gap leaves open the possibility of another move.
So, what could be on the horizon?
The biggest name
Cody Bellinger remains the most talented position player on the market. The 30-year-old is reportedly seeking a long-term deal and has a reported five-year, $150 million offer from the Yankees.
Adding another left-handed bat would invite criticism, but Bellinger’s numbers complicate that argument. In 2025, he slashed .353/.415/.601 against left-handed pitching, posting a 1.106 OPS — best among qualified left-handed hitters. Kyle Schwarber ranked second at .964. Schwarber led the NL in extra-base hits against lefties; Bellinger led the AL.
Over the past three seasons, Bellinger has averaged a .281 batting average with 29 homers and 107 RBIs per 162 games. Defensively, his versatility — all three outfield spots plus first base — gives him value beyond the bat.
The price is the obstacle. Bellinger will likely command close to $30 million per year, more than the Phillies were willing to offer Bichette. With payroll already sitting near $326 million — beyond the $303 million luxury-tax line that carries a 110 percent penalty — this would be a stretch.
Heart-of-the-order pop
Eugenio Suárez is another name worth revisiting.
Despite a rough finish after a deadline trade to Seattle, Suárez hit 49 home runs in 2025, tying a career high. The swing-and-miss is real — bottom four percent in whiff rate last season — but power would change the Phillies’ lineup.
The Phillies struggled mightily in the cleanup spot last season. Their No. 4 hitters combined for a .720 OPS, 20th in MLB. Realmuto posted a .683 OPS there. Nick Castellanos came in at .651.
A Suárez addition would almost certainly require an Alec Bohm trade. Bohm hit .287 but managed just 11 home runs in 120 games. The Phillies don’t have to move him, but if the goal is improvement in the power department, he remains a place to look.
Another reunion?
Harrison Bader could still be in play.
The 31-year-old outfielder is coming off one of his best seasons: a .796 OPS, 3.9 bWAR and a 117 OPS+. After arriving in Philadelphia, he hit .305 with a .463 slugging percentage and provided energy the club valued.
Durability remains the concern — he’s played more than 120 games just four times in nine seasons — but his postseason toughness stood out. He left Game 1 of the NLDS with a hamstring strain, returned in Game 2 as a pinch hitter and lined a single that sparked the dugout.
If Justin Crawford or Adolis García stumble early, Bader would offer insurance without reshaping the roster.
Buy-low rotation piece
It never felt likely the Phillies would bring back Suárez, but that doesn’t mean the rotation is finished.
Chris Bassitt is one option. The 37-year-old made 32 starts in 2025 with a 3.96 ERA. Over the past five seasons, he has made at least 27 starts each year, posted ERAs under 4.00 in four of them, logged 155-plus strikeouts, and finished top-10 in Cy Young voting three times.
Zac Gallen is another path. The 30-year-old posted a 4.83 ERA last season, his worst as a pro. From 2019 through 2024, he made 143 starts with a 3.29 ERA — third-best among qualified starters in that span. A one-year “get-right” deal in the $13–18 million range could appeal to both sides.
The rotation carries questions. The Phillies believe in Andrew Painter’s talent, but command matters. Taijuan Walker can absorb innings, but consistency remains an issue. Zack Wheeler’s full return to health cannot be assumed.
It’s difficult to believe the Phillies are done.
The market has largely settled. The next move will reveal how this front office views its margin — and how much risk it’s willing to take to close it.