KANSAS CITY, MISSOURI - MAY 23: Cole Young #2 of the Seattle Mariners is tagged out while trying to reach third base by Maikel Garcia #11 of the Kansas City Royals during the game at Kauffman Stadium on May 23, 2026 in Kansas City, Missouri. (Photo by Jamie Squire/Getty Images) | Getty Images
The Mariners made a move this week that few saw coming as they sent Bryce Miller, Logan Evans, and Jose Ferrer to the lower midwest in exchange for Gold Glove winning third baseman Maikel Garcia and two fair-to-middling relievers. You can read all about the details and early analysis of the trade here and here. However, today’s post is meant to get y’all contemplating your orbs and looking into the future to see how this trade shakes out five years down the road or more. Let’s prognosticate!
Here are some prompts to answer in the comments:
Who ends their career with higher WAR: Bryce Miller or Maikel Garcia?
Does Logan Evans become the underrated gem in this trade by having a breakout season for Kansas City in 2027 or even 2028?
How will losing Ferrer effect the Mariners bullpen?
Are Miller’s struggles mental, physical, both, or neither?
Assuming full health or close to it, what is Garcia’s slash line for the Mariners in 2027? And how many stolen bases?
As much as it pains me to give up on Bryce Miller when there is still a chance he puts together the kind of season that had me picking him as my dark horse Cy Young candidate before the 2o25 season, bringing in a Real Life Third Baseman who can also hit a bit does fill me with optimism. After all, enduring the left side of the Mariners infield in 2026 was like a viewing of “Salò.” Absolutely punishing and deeply unpleasant. No one wants to see either of those things more than once, so a healthy Garcia plus a healthy Colt Emerson at shortstop all season could make for a distinctly more enjoyable viewing experience. If Miller ends up an ace in KC, I’ll be happy for Cowboy Bryce, but hopefully the revamped infield defense is enough to overlook the regret of seeing Miller put it all together for another team.
What do y’all think? Let’s hear your answers to the prompts in the comments, plus any other trade hot takes you want to share.
ATLANTA, GA - JULY 31: Elieser Hernández #57 of the Atlanta Braves pitches in the seventh inning during the game against the Washington Nationals at Truist Park on July 31, 2026 in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Matthew Grimes Jr./Atlanta Braves/Getty Images) | Getty Images
One of the more interesting mini-plots of the 2026 Atlanta Braves season was Elieser Hernández’s journey up and down, and all around, the Gwinnett Express. He’d come up, pitch some big innings, get designated for assignment shortly afterwards, return to Gwinnett, and do it all over again at some point down the road. It’s time to examine how this journey went for him.
How Acquired
Hernández inked a minor league deal with the Braves last November and began the season with the Gwinnett Stripers in Triple-A. It took Hernández all the way until late July for the Braves to call him up to the bigs and boy, did he end up coming through in a big spot for Atlanta.
What were the expectations?
For the first five years of his career, Hernández was an up-and-down arm with the Marlins. He did make 48 starts, 42 relief appearances, and log over 280 innings, but they came with a -0.7 fWAR. Things weren’t much better in 2024 as the Brewers and Dodgers took a brief flier on him, but he ended up pitching in Korea with the LG Twins for part of that season, as well as 2025.
All that meant was that when the Braves added him back to an MLB organization after the 2025 season, the expectations were that he would provide depth for Gwinnett, with no real assumption of any kind of usefulness or quality if anyone bothered to call him up to the bigs.
2026 Results
But, the Braves did call him up!
Hernández pitched in his first big league game since 2024 on July 24, which is when Walt Weiss called his name in the seventh inning of a game where the Braves were trailing the Orioles by one run. Hernández then proceeded to face 13 batters and ended up clearing three innings as a result, which helped get the Braves into extra innings and eventually ended up earning him the pitcher win after the Braves broke out for four runs in the tenth inning of that one. This was a fantastic result for Hernández and his reward was getting designated for assignment and eventually electing free agency before returning to the Braves organization by July 28.
By July 31, Hernández got called up again and once again, he proceeded to throw three more innings for the Braves. This time, he essentially gave the rest of the bullpen the night off after a six-inning stint from Bryce Elder by pitching the final three innings and picking up a save as a result. He did give up one run on five hits this time around, but he struck out four batters along the way and the Braves cruised to victory thanks to his efforts. This was another fantastic result for Hernández and his reward was getting designated for assignment and eventually electing free agency before returning to the Braves organization by August 4.
Once September rolled around, Elieser Hernández got another chance with the Braves. For the third straight time, Hernández entered the game and gave the Braves another three solid innings. This time, he entered the game while it was still scoreless in the fifth inning and proceeded to keep the Nationals scoreless for three innings while his teammates gave him six runs of run support. Once again, Hernández ended up getting his name in the box score with his second pitcher win of the season and his reward was that he got to stay with the big league squad for another day! Hooray!
Indeed, Hernández got to spend nearly a whole entire week with the Braves during this stint — though it did take him six days to make his next appearance. He got the nod for another multi-inning appearance and this time it was against the Rays. Once again, Hernández was called upon to finish a game but this time, it was pure mop-up duty as the Rays ended up being the ones who gave the Braves a beating and they also scored two runs on three hits while he was the pitcher of record. He did strike out four batters while he was out there (tying a season high) but it wasn’t enough to keep him from getting DFA’d for a third time.
Hernández stayed with the organization via free agency and made one final appearance on the final day of the regular season, no less. He pitched a scoreless inning during a 5-3 loss to the Marlins and sure enough, he got DFA’d for a fourth time. This time, Hernández decided that he wasn’t going to stick around for the Postseason and eventually elected free agency on October 1.
Put this all together, and it was a bit silly. Hernández logged five appearances and 12 innings, and collected -0.1 fWAR with a 54 ERA-, 143 FIP-, and 114 xFIP-.
What went right?
Those first three appearances were absolutely huge and you could really make the argument that Hernández suffered some hard luck in getting DFA’d after those first two appearances. Sure, it was also probably a case of him rolling lucky sevens in the small sample size casino but it was still very exciting to see him come in during that tight spot against the Orioles and do what he did. He definitely got some help from the rock-solid defense behind him to get that game to extras but hey, he was on the mound and got it done.
Though he entered the game in low leverage, he ended up collecting 0.28 WPA in the contest. That was the 27th-highest by any Brave in any single appearance this season, and 11th for a reliever.
His September outing against the Nationals was somewhat similar: he entered in medium leverage and collected 0.14 WPA for his second shutdown of the year. Considering he never had the experience of turning low leverage into a meltdown, it was kind of a cool set of five appearances for him.
Also, some of the numbers he was putting up were actually quite good… even if his peripherals were not so good.
He managed to post a low xERA of 2.79, partly driven by a hard-hit rate of just 36.4 percent. His sweeper and changeup had whiff rates of over 30 percent (meaning that his overall whiff rate was nearly 30 percent), and all three of his main offerings had an xwOBA-against below .300. A lot of this was pretty exciting, even if completely unexpected.
What went wrong?
I again bring up the possibility that Elieser Hernández was getting those results due to the fact that he was consistently hitting the jackpot in the small sample size casino because when you look at his overall velocity, it is a miracle that he was missing as many bats as he did. His four-seamer was nearly three miles below the average for right-handers, his sweeper was also pretty slow and none of his other pitchers were even close to reaching average in velocity. You’d think that this would lead to exaggerated movement due to the added time for the pitches to get to the plate, but both his changeup and sweeper had absolutely horrible depth (as in, a lack of it). If you only saw his pitch data and plots from these five appearances, you’d think he’d have gotten mauled every time out.
And, as mentioned, he kinda did, but not in the results column. He gave up a bunch of walks (11.3 percent of batters faced) and batters had no trouble elevating (33.3 percent grounder rate), but despite those two terrible marks and the lack of anything on his pitches, he got great results for 12 innings.
Still, it didn’t stop the Rays (who finished the season with the fourth-worst Isolated Power number as a team in the American League and the fifth-least homers in the AL as well) from exploiting his issues to great effect during his appearance on September 8. They smacked two dingers off of him with Yandy Díaz and Richie Palacios both recording round-trippers. Sure, you might hit the jackpot sometimes in the small sample size casino but sometimes you’re going to roll snake eyes as well, and Elieser Hernández wasn’t immune to that. Fortunately, the Braves were already getting routed, so it didn’t really affect the game nor our memories of his improbable “success” in 2026. But, nonetheless, those memories are tinged with the reality that Hernández was straight-up lucky to pair his 54 ERA- with a 143 FIP- and 114 xFIP-.
2027 Outlook
Maybe the baseball gods have a cosmic sense of humor and we’ll see him re-up with a minor league deal with the Braves once the season gets close to getting underway. I’d imagine that he will latch on with some organization before next season begins, but he won’t exactly be the most attractive option for any given team. Again, he figured out a way to escape taking a ton of damage while he was on the mound with the Braves, but he was certainly walking the skinniest of tightropes with his propensity to walk a bunch of guys as well as give up fly balls that turn into homers. He’ll do well with a team that has a solid defense, so maybe he’ll end up in a contender’s organization, but disaster could be on the horizon if he doesn’t have the leather behind him to save him.
He’s another guy that projects as replacement level at best, and even that might be generous considering he now has -1.0 fWAR in his career with an ugly 122/136/120 line (ERA-/FIP-/xFIP-).
GLENDALE, ARIZONA - OCTOBER 25: General manager Monti Ossenfort of the Arizona Cardinals watches warm ups before the game against the Denver Broncos at State Farm Stadium on October 25, 2026 in Glendale, Arizona. The Broncos defeated the Cardinals 30-16. (Photo by Chris Coduto/Getty Images) | Getty Images
The Arizona Cardinals are struggling, and the root cause of that struggle can be pinpointed to their inability to get production from their draft picks.
No team since 2023 has had more draft capital than the Arizona Cardinals, and the picks just have not been able to contribute as Gridiron Grading points out.
Most non-QB impact from draft picks on rookie contracts (2023-2026 picks)
That’s why when the Cardinals are relying on bad veterans as starters and street free agents as backups, you end up having seasons that are basically over after nine or 10 games.
When you have a team with your own draft picks struggling to make an impact, you have to fill those holes with free agents. It’s the double edged sword, because then those players get buried behind average to below average NFL veterans and you have a cycle of continued failure.
Look at the grading:
Reason number one why the Cardinals are still one of the worst teams in the NFL.
May 30, 2012; Toronto, ON, CANADA; A wide angle view of the Rogers Centre and CN Tower during a game between the Baltimore Orioles and Toronto Blue Jays. Mandatory Credit: John E. Sokolowski-USA TODAY Sports | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
Today, at 4:00 pm Eastern, the non-tender deadline hits.
The Jays have eight players to make decisions on and what they are projected to make:
Ernie Clement: $7.6 million.
José Soriano: $5.6 million.
Josh Smith: $3.7 million.
Louis Varland: $3.8 million.
Nathan Lukes: $2.1 million.
Spencer Arrighetti: $1.9 million.
Bowden Francis: $1.3 million.
Davis Schneider: $1.3 million
I’d guess that Smith, Francis and Schneider are unlikely to get contracts, but we will find out later today.
Arrighetti wrote a nice message about how much he enjoyed his short time (so far) with the Blue Jays.
I’d offer Varland a little more than that, just to tell him how much he’s appreciated. I see Clement’s name mentioned in trade rumors a bunch. I’m not a fan of trading low. I’d bet he will have a better year next year, but then it might come as a utility infielder, instead of full time second baseman.
The Jays also made a roster move yesterday, picking up Christian Cairo off waivers from the Dodgers. Chase Lee was DFAed to make room on the 40-man.
Cairo is 25. He’s a good glove/not so good bat infielder. Last year he his .230/.381/.300 in Triple A, mostly for the Phillies farm club. He was drafted by Cleveland in 2019 and was in their system until last year. Since then he has been with the Phillies, Mets, and Dodgers. He does take walks and steals a bit, 25 last year. I imagine the Jays will DFA him off the 40-man and hope to keep him with the Bisons at some point this winter.
I’m sure the Jays will try to keep Lee as well. He has an option year left.
And Hazel Mae’s book is at the top of the non-fiction best sellers list. I haven’t read it yet, but I’ll likely get to it around Christmas. Congratulations to her.
Toronto Star bestsellers: Sports broadcaster Hazel Mae tops non-fiction lists with her memoir https://t.co/mXKfNuXLbX
We have about ten days until the lockout starts, so there will likely be a flurry of free agent signings leading up to that. I’d imagine the Jays will make a signing or two.
LOS ANGELES, CA - JULY 31: Will Klein #61 of the Los Angeles Dodgers pitches during the game between the Boston Red Sox and the Los Angeles Dodgers at UNIQLO Field at Dodger Stadium on Friday, July 31, 2026 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Nicole Vasquez/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images
On a cold Los Angeles night on Monday, October 27, 2025, the Dodgers were locked in a stalemate against the Toronto Blue Jays in Game 3 of the World Series. Entering the top of the 15th inning, the Dodgers were down to their last reserves, and only one available option out of the bullpen remained: Will Klein.
Klein tossed a career-high 72 pitches over four shutout innings, helping the Dodgers ultimately win 6-5 in the bottom of the 18th inning and helping solidify his name as a folk legend within Dodgers history. It also helped him ensure a stable spot in the bullpen for the 2026 season.
2026 was the first spring training that Klein spent with the Dodgers after two previous spring invites with the Seattle Mariners and Kansas City Royals in 2025 and 2024 respectively. Across 9 1/3 innings in camp, Klein allowed just two earned runs while striking out 10 and walking three. For the first time in his young career, Klein was named to the opening day roster.
The bulk of the first month of the regular season saw Klein in a middle relief role, mainly being deployed for the sixth, seventh or eighth innings. That was until he made his first start as an opener on May 15 against the Angels, where he tossed a pair of scoreless innings in Anaheim. His next two appearances saw him pitching in the ninth inning for the first time, which featured his first career save coming against the Padres in a 5-4 win in San Diego on May 19.
Klein was mostly consistent throughout the first half of the season, as he went into the All-Star break with a respectable 2.41 ERA and 2.94 FIP despite being dealt the loss in his final two appearances of the first half. The second half got off to a turbulent start, as he allowed a season-high four earned runs against the New York Mets on July 28 before allowing three more to score against the Boston Red Sox on July 31. In just four appearances to finish the month of July, Klein was charged with a 14.54 ERA and 7.58 FIP.
Klein didn’t get a chance to reverse course entering the final two months of the regular season, as he was placed on the 15-day injured list on Aug. 1 due to right elbow discomfort. He was then transferred to the 60-day injured list on Sept. 2 and was unavailable for the remainder of the regular season and the team’s postseason run.
Although Klein finished on a whimper before injuries derailed the rest of his season, two key components that stood out were his average fastball velocity and his extension. Klein averaged 97.5 miles per hour on his fastball, putting him in the 91st percentile, and he used his 6’5” frame to generate 6.9 feet of extension, placing him in the 85th percentile. Klein was also one of the best pitchers when it came to keeping the ball on the ground, as his 56 percent ground ball rate led the entire Dodgers pitching staff and ranked 18th among all pitchers with at least 40 innings of work.
Klein’s best performance came in a 3-0 shutout win over the San Diego Padres on July 4, as he completed a scoreless ninth inning while facing the minimum and striking out two, earning his second and final save of the season.
Klein has 1.081 years of service and is on the Dodgers 40-man roster. He has one available option and is eligible for arbitration after the 2028 season.
The Royals just traded three players to Seattle and got three back, and the question is whether Kansas City won on quantity or quality. Jacob Milham and Jeremy Greco ask Kate Preusser of the Meet at the Mitt Podcast, who sees it from the Mariners’ side. Maikel Garcia, James MacArthur, and L.P. Langevin head west, while Bryce Miller, Logan Evans, and José Ferrer come to Kansas City.
Kate has the scouting notes on each arrival. Evans is a ground-ball starter coming back from Tommy John surgery who could fit at the back of a rotation. Ferrer is a ground-ball arm who could benefit from a stronger infield defense. Miller is the big one, and she explains why his relationship with the Mariners soured, why she still believes in him as a pitcher, and why he is funnier than his persona suggests. With Garcia gone, the hosts also ask who plays third base and whether Miller could grow into a leader on the staff.
The rest of a busy week is on the table too. Kyle Isbel was designated for assignment, which puts the center field options under the microscope, and Randy Dobnak avoided arbitration at $1.35 million. Zack Greinke and Eric Hosmer are now in the Royals Hall of Fame, and Jeremy has thoughts on who is still waiting. Carter Jensen’s Silver Slugger snub gets a stat-by-stat argument against winner Dillon Dingler.
If you want to know whether this trade makes the Royals better, press play, then tell us who won it.
NEW YORK, NY - SEPTEMBER 20: Chase Shugart #55 of the Philadelphia Phillies looks on during the game between the Philadelphia Phillies and the New York Mets at Citi Field on Sunday, September 20, 2026 in New York, New York. (Photo by Hailey Leonard/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images
After toiling in the Red Sox system for a few years, Chase Shugart made his major league debut in 2024. He was then traded to the Pirates for whom he served in a middle/long relief role in 2025 and was generally decent at it. The Phillies must have liked what they saw, as they traded lottery ticket minor leaguer Francisco Loreto to Pittsburgh to obtain Shugart.
He didn’t make the major league team out of Spring Training but was called up in April and spent most of the season on the roster, appearing mostly in low-leverage situations.
The stats: 46 games, 53.1 IP, 2-1 W-L, 4.02 ERA, 59 K, 20 BB, 0.8 WAR
What went right
The highlight of his season came at the end of April, where he earned a win in both games of a doubleheader against the Giants. (He’s a modern-day Sam Malone, who earned the nickname “Mayday” by earning a save in both games of a doubleheader against the Orioles.)
Last night, Chase Shugart became the third Phillies pitcher in the Live Ball Era (since 1920) to earn the win in both games of a doubleheader. 👏 pic.twitter.com/aiDpwdXAbX
Aside from that, Shugart was mostly used to absorb innings in games that had gotten out of hand or when the Phillies needed to preserve their higher leverage relievers. He generally did an adequate job of this, with the occasional “fuel on the fire” outing mixed in.
Shugart was quietly very good in September. He had a 0.93 ERA in nine games. He did blow an extra inning save against the Braves, but it wasn’t really his fault. He gave up a routine ground ball followed by a routine fly ball, and the ghost runner scored. (This is my biggest complaint about the ghost runner. A pitcher can get two easy outs and blow a save.)
What went wrong
He wasn’t the worst pitcher the Phillies put out there, but his biggest problem is that he simply allows too many baserunners. He’s a fly ball pitcher who sees too many of those fly balls go over the fence.
The future
He will likely be back in camp next season, fighting for one of the team’s final bullpen spots. Maybe his strong finish indicates that he’s capable of taking on a bigger role next year, but considering he’s already 30, it is difficult to have much faith in that happening.
In 2025, the Braves finally seemed to right themselves after a couple of shaky years, winning their division despite a rash of injuries, especially to their starting pitching. However, even after winning their seventh division title in ten years, they ran into the Dodgers who managed to shutdown their bats and knock them out of the postseason in the NLDS 3-1. We talked to Ivan the Great of Battery Power about their takeaways from the 2026 season and what the Braves can look forward to in 2027.
With the 2026 season in the rearview mirror, what do team fans think are the key takeaways, both good and bad on the season?
I think this is one of those things where asking five Braves fans will give you seven opinions. On top of that, the Braves had a very strange 2026 season, which only makes the narrative more complicated.
The good is that the Braves ended up where they were expected to be: lots of wins, on top of the division. There’s still clearly a fair bit of talent in the organization, and there are things the organization does really well, namely in major league pitching development.
The bad is that 2026 was Year Two of “some component of the organization has no idea what to do offensively.” After a very specific offensive approach that we jokingly call “The PowerPoint” from 2019-2024, the Braves pivoted away from it hard in 2025 to disastrous results – and 2026 was a mixed bag of stuff that sometimes looked like 2019-2024, sometimes looked like 2025, and often just felt like flailing for a life preserver. Combine that with blow after blow of pitching injuries, and I think I’d probably list the takeaways as: 1) the team has a lot of good players; 2) the organization is for some reason unsure or incapable of getting the most out of those players on the hitting end; and, 3) the pitching health is always more dire than the organization seems to plan for, such that it’s an ongoing scramble for more arms that feels a bit like juggling chainsaws.
What would you consider the team front office’s priority to be this offseason (assuming we’ll have baseball like normal next year)?
I think broadly, and from a “fill the depth chart” perspective, it’s probably “actually find enough pitching that the chainsaws don’t all fall on your head.” But, things I’ve heard have leaned more towards, “we really gotta figure out the whole offense thing.” It kind of makes sense: the organization has done well with getting guys like Tyler Mahle and Martin Perez to not only not kill the team, but be fine-to-good, and Chris Sale somehow found another gear in his late 30s. But the hitting is… who can say, really. The Front Office seems caught between the personnel acquired and extended during the PowerPoint era and a pivot to a proto-Brewers walks-and-liners, though they’re nowhere near succeeding in the latter. Figuring out what they’re actually going to do offensively, both in terms of which personnel they add for shortstop and left field, and in terms of what they’re gonna work with their hitters on in terms of gameplan, looks like the highest priority.
Who would be the key players targeted in Free Agency or by trade for the team this offseason, and likewise, is there any players you expect to be traded by the team?
I always find this sort of stuff really hard to speculate on. A lot of people are expecting the team to more or less run it back, re-signing Tyler Mahle and Mauricio Dubon and seeing what happens. Personally, I find it really hard to answer these sorts of questions without better understanding what the team wants the hitter core to do next year – are they giving up on whatever was attempted in 2025-2026, or are they going to double/triple down and keep adding Dubon-esque, Ha-Seong Kim-esque, or even Jurickson Profar/Mike Yastzremski-esque guys whose profiles are not “big swing, big boom” but other stuff.
That also goes for trading parts of this roster away. Alex Anthopoulos previously said that he wouldn’t trade a core member that he extended, but Spencer Strider was the rumored return in the nixed Jacob deGrom deal. If the Braves are pivoting their offense again, then sure, I think lots of guys could be on the trade block. If they’re wheeling back to the PowerPoint, then trading those guys makes little sense.
The Braves have had little compunction trading prospects they aren’t high on internally for major league upgrades, so that’s probably what will happen – I just have no idea who those guys are.
Going into spring, which prospects, if any, look like they’ll have a real chance to start the year with the major league club?
The Braves don’t mind stuffing their pitching staff full of arms that flash positive results in Spring Training (the year that Jared Shuster and Dylan Dodd won starting spots in Spring Training and then also lost them even faster comes to mind). JR Ritchie is no longer a “prospect” but across him, Owen Murphy, and guys like Garrett Baumann who are in the higher minors, it really could be another situation where a good run in the Grapefruit League gives them a shot. I do think most prospects that fans are excited about are a bit further away.
What would team fans consider the elements of a successful 2027 season going forward, whether it is just positive steps forward all the way to winning the World Series?
Again, five fans, seven opinions. There will be some who expect a deep playoff run, for whatever reason. There will be others who jive more with how the team is run, i.e., lots of wins and a playoff berth is what the team is aiming for, so it feels off to judge success by anything other than criterion. For some, it might just be a better short- and medium-term plan on offensive approach and managing pitching staff health.
And a fun little exercise; you’ve been named GM for the team. Tell me the four biggest (and at least vaguely realistic) moves you make this offseason?
Again, I think this is very difficult to make “vaguely realistic” without knowing how the team plans to approach the offense. But, sure, let’s say some stuff and provide commentary… blasphemous as it may be… this isn’t really the “me as GM offseason” but more the “I attempt to thread the needle between what’s out there and what the team might be thinking given their past actions”
Sign Luis Arraez. Look, if you wanna go slappy, you’ve got a prime opportunity to go slappy. Plus, he provides a handcuff to an aging and honestly, no longer particularly effective Ozzie Albies. This is, in some ways, the anti-Braves move… but the Braves are teetering on the verge of being anti-Braves themselves.
Sign Sonny Gray. The Braves got a lot of mileage out of another aging, but highly effective starter. Gray’s combination of durability and quality suggests he should probably get a longer deal than most teams would be comfortable given the year of his birth, and that fits right into the Braves’ wheelhouse of preferring higher-money, shorter deals.
Sign a to-be-improved starter like Foster Griffin or David Peterson. This shores up the “our guys keep getting injured argh” issue with the rotation a bit more, while trying to leverage the actual ability to improve major leaguers that the Braves have showcased. Peterson clearly has more to optimize and should come much cheaper, so he’s probably the more realistic play here.
Trade for Otto Lopez. Okay, this one is only “at least vaguely realistic.” But, it fits the slap requirement, it fills the shortstop hole, it adds talent that should more than compensate for the human heart being in conflict with itself as represented by what will be a half-slap, half-slug lineup… and honestly, the Braves have a shortstop hole that they will need to get really creative to fill unless they just re-sign Mauricio Dubon and park him there.
ST PETERSBURG, FL - SEPTEMBER 28: John Gibbons #5 of the Toronto Blue Jays looks on during the second inning in a game against the Tampa Bay Rays on September 28, 2018 at Tropicana Field in St Petersburg, Florida. (Photo by Julio Aguilar/Getty Images) | Getty Images
Eleven Years Ago
We traded Liam Hendriks to the A’s for Jesse Chavez. At the time, opinions were divided—some fans approved, while others were skeptical.
In hindsight, the trade turned out poorly for us.
During his first four years, Liam was a swingman and part-time starter, posting a 5.80 ERA. In 2015, the Blue Jays moved him to the bullpen, where he excelled with a 2.92 ERA over 58 appearances.
The A’s kept him in the bullpen, where he was solid for three seasons (4.01 ERA in 148 games). In 2019, he emerged as their closer and quickly became a star, posting a 1.80 ERA with 25 saves. He maintained that dominance during the shortened 2020 season. Before 2021, he signed a major free-agent deal with the White Sox.
Throughout his 13-year career, he has pitched in 476 games (44 as a starter), recording a 3.82 ERA and 116 saves—the vast majority coming between 2019 and 2022.
As for Chavez, he posted a 4.43 ERA with us before being traded to the Dodgers for Mike Bolsinger in August. Since then, he has bounced around the league, pitching for the Angels, Rangers, Cubs, Braves, and making multiple returns to some of those teams.
In 2021, he appeared in seven playoff games for the Braves, not allowing a run during their World Series-winning campaign.
Overall, Chavez has played in 17 MLB seasons, appearing in 653 games (85 starts) with a 4.24 ERA. Now 41, it’s unclear if he’ll pitch again next year, but he had an impressive 2024.
The Jays brought back John Gibbons as manager for a second stint, following John Farrell’s departure to his ‘dream job’ with the Red Sox—a move that didn’t work out as he’d hoped.
Gibby led the team for six seasons, guiding us to the playoffs twice. Known for his fan-friendly personality and entertaining interviews, he compiled a 793-789 career record—all with the Jays—including a 488-484 mark in his second stint.
Fresh off completing one of the worst contracts in the history of baseball, the third baseman has returned to his alma mater Rice to complete his degree, The Rice Thresher reported.
His return to college life reportedly includes him participating in a softball Lifetime Physical Activity Program class — where he bats left-handed to even the odds.
Los Angeles Angels’ Anthony Rendon fields a ground ball hit by San Diego Padres’ Matthew Batten on Friday, March 24, 2023, in Tempe, Ariz. AP
“I would carry a backpack all through my career when we traveled, but you know it was an iPad to watch movies … it was snacks, it was a water bottle,” Rendon told the outlet.
“Now it’s like, the intent is schoolwork.”
Rendon, 36, had an interesting MLB career that started on such a promising note before ending with him being considered one of the worst free-agent signings ever.
He emerged as one of the sport’s most underrated players from 2013-19, an everyday third baseman who could both hit and field and helped the Nationals win the World Series in 2019.
That led to him signing his mega-contract with the Angels, and he appeared in just 257 games with the team while missing the last two seasons.
After posing an .859 OPS with the Nationals, he tallied just a .717 mark with the Angels and earned scorn for saying that baseball “never has been a top priority.”
Rice’s Anthony Rendon smiles as he steps up to bat during a Conference USA Championship baseball game against Marshall in Houston on Friday, May 28, 2010. Houston Chronicle via Getty Imag
The Angels are finally freed of his contract and Rendon’s retirement is starting by returning to the place that helped him earn hundreds of millions of dollars.
Rendon played for the Owls from 2009-11 before being drafted by the Nationals with the No. 6 pick in the 2011 MLB Draft.
He told the student paper that he broke his family’s mold by even attending college, and said he accomplished a lifelong dream by making it to the majors.
In reflecting on his time in the majors, Rendon said he relied on his faith during the lean years.
“Something I had only done my entire life was taken away from me at those moments. And that’s all I knew to do. That’s all I wanted to do,” Rendon told the student paper.
“And then when I’m sitting there in those moments and I can’t walk, can’t play, can’t do anything. What do you do, right? You just reflect.”
Rice’s college return stemmed from his desire to earn his degree, something he wanted to accomplish to serve as a message for his four children.
He reportedly needs roughly 40 credits to graduate, and is also taking a Business of College Athletics class in addition to the activity program.
“How do you break a cycle? How do you break a mold? It starts with you,” Rendon told the Rice Thresher. “So if I want to help turn this cycle around with my family, I got to prove to them, too, down the road, like, ‘Hey, he went to college, she went to college.’”
Anthony Rendon of the Los Angeles Angels lies on the field after an injury during a game against the San Diego Padres in San Diego on Tuesday, July 4, 2023. Getty Images
As expected, Rendon is the top pick for the softball class and his educators told the student paper that he has provided benefits with his presence.
He appears to be enjoying this new yet familiar phase of his life.
“I’m just a man trying to do the right thing, each and every day, trying to be the best that I can be,” Rendon told the outlet. “Follow Jesus, be a good husband, be a good father. Sometimes that always doesn’t work. I have good days, I have bad days, just like everyone else, but I think if my heart and my intentions [are] in the right spot, I’m trending in the right direction.”
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 30: Sonny Gray #54 of the Boston Red Sox walks to the dugout before the game against the New York Yankees in game two of the American League Wild Card Series at Yankee Stadium on September 30, 2026 in the Bronx borough of New York City. (Photo by Caleb Bowlin/Getty Images) | Getty Images
Today is the deadline for teams to tender contracts to pre-arbitration and arbitration-eligible players. Any player who is not tendered a contract immediately becomes a free agent — which is exactly why the Red Sox will not non-tender Jarren Duran, who should be able to bring something back to the Sox in a trade, even though he no longer has a spot on the Red Sox roster. Nevertheless, he has been added to this list of potential non-tender candidates, which also includes some big(ish) names like Jake Burger and Royce Lewis. (Thomas Harrigan, MLB.com)
But what is Jarren Duran’s worth? That’s the question that Matt asked yesterday, and we may soon have an answer, as the Sox are expected to tender him a contract and then explore trade possibilities. One team that’s already been reported to have interest is the Chicago Cubs, who are viewing him as a possible “change of scenery” addition as they prepare to potentially lose Seiya Suzuki, Ian Happ, and Carson Kelly. (Patrick Mooney, The Athletic)
And the reason why everyone is so sure that Jarren Duran will not be on the opening day roster whenever there is an opening day is that the Red Sox lineup already appears to be more or less set in stone. Moreover, with the exception of Caleb Durbin and Trevor Story, every projected starter put up a better than league average OPS last season. (Alex Speier, Boston Globe)
Of course two of the players who put up above average OPS numbers were Jake Bauers and Curtis Mead, and there are major questions about whether either one of them will be able to do it again. But Craig Breslow believes in both. “We are [confident in both of them going forward], and not exclusively because the data tells us so. But I think getting to know the players, talking to our scouts, our evaluators, looking at some of the underlying data, and then being able to identify a real change,” said Breslow. “I think it gives us a little bit of comfort to say Jake is swinging at different pitches. He’s standing in the box a little bit differently. His bat path has changed. And Curtis has moved his point of contact out in front and he’s hitting the ball in the air a little bit more while still making good swing decisions. If we can’t point to something as the reason that is driving this change, it becomes a little bit scarier to bank on it in the future, but being able to identify the difference is really helpful.” (Ian Browne, MLB.com)
Hopefully the move from Milwaukee to Boston doesn’t mess with Bauers’ routine. The fact that he likes the city and calls it “one of those cities where [he’s] always been excited to go” should help. (Boston.com)
Unlike the lineup, the pitching rotation has a few question marks now that Sonny Gray has departed for Minnesota on a two-year deal. The Red Sox did not make any attempt to re-sign him. “As far as a reunion, it never really came up,” Gray said. “I think the times we did have any type of conversations, it never really got close, it felt like, which is completely OK. As far as a reunion, it felt like it was never gaining any traction.” (Chris Cotillo, MassLive)
Los Angeles Dodgers superstar Shohei Ohtani has set records and made history since he signed to play in Major League Baseball. Now the four-time MVP is making endorsement history.
Ohtani has extended his agreement with apparel company New Balance through the remainder of his playing career, a deal that appears to be the first of its kind for an MLB player. In 2023, the 32-year-old Ohtani signed a 10-year, $700 million deal with the Dodgers after spending the first six seasons with the Los Angeles Angels. The deal includes $680 million in deferred compensation.
"There’s a lot of trust," Ohtani told GQ. "We’ve obviously built friendships, as well. They’ve been able to accommodate my requests, the things I’ve asked for, and, like I said, that takes the involvement of a lot of trust. That relationship has been very, very good and smooth. I had no reservations about extending our relationship."
New Balance, headquartered in Boston, said that as part of the contract extension, the company will rename its Sports Research Lab after Ohtani.
"When I first joined New Balance, they saw me as more than just an athlete, and that relationship has only grown stronger over time," Ohtani said, via the New Balance website. "There is a lot of trust in our relationship and I’ve always felt like a true partner whether I’m testing products, sharing feedback or helping shape new ideas. I’m excited to extend our partnership for the remainder of my playing career and honored to have the Sports Research Lab carry my name. I look forward to continuing to work together and seeing what we can accomplish."
Last season, Ohtani hit .275 with 30 home runs and 81 RBIs in 135 games, and in 14 starts, went 8–2 with a 1.79 ERA and 95 strikeouts in 85⅔ innings. He finished second in the National League Most Valuable Player race behind Chicago Cubs outfielder Pete Crow-Armstrong.
Why? Because usually, there are one or two guys who appear for the Cubs in only one game in any specific season, perhaps a couple more. From 2022-23, there were five total (four in 2022, one in 2023). In 2024, there were just two (though one, Gavin Hollowell, has appeared in more games since for the Cubs). Going back a bit farther, in the entire decade of the 2010s there were just six — and just nine in the 40 seasons from 1970-2009.
Last year, there were none.
So let’s lift a glass to the one-game Cub Class of 2026, which has EIGHT members! And an honorable mention to Vince Velasquez, who looked like he would join that club with his single appearance in April, only to be recalled one more time to throw in a blowout win over the Brewers in June.
Of the eight, only one (Luke Little) was originally drafted and signed by the Cubs organization and only one (Braxton Garrett) will have any impact on the team going forward.
The reason all this happened should be pretty obvious: The failure of Jed Hoyer to assemble a proper bullpen. In addition to that, multiple pitching injuries meant juggling the waiver wire and 40-man rosters all season. All this led to a franchise record 39 pitchers being used in 2026 (not counting three appearances on the mound by catcher Carson Kelly).
Here are the eight one-game Cubs of 2026, in chronological order of appearance.
Barnes had pitched briefly for the Twins in 2021, then spent four years in KBO in Korea before the Cubs signed him to a minor-league deal in January. They added him to the 40-man and active rosters April 12 when Phil Maton went on one of his multiple IL stints.
The next day, Barnes entered a game the Cubs were losing 9-2 to the Phillies in the sixth. He quickly made it 12-2 in that inning, then the Phillies scored off him again in the seventh. The Cubs pushed across five runs in the eighth to make it sort of a game, but with the Cubs short of pitchers, Barnes threw the eighth, where he retired the Phillies in order. Here he is getting J.T. Realmuto on a fly to center [VIDEO].
Barnes was optioned to Triple-A Iowa the next day. He was recalled again April 26, but did not appear in a game before being optioned back the next day. On May 13 the Dodgers claimed him on waivers and he made four appearances for them, three of which were scoreless. In the other one he allowed seven runs in seven innings to the A’s, including three home runs. The Dodgers released and re-claimed him three times in July and August. He’s now a free agent again.
Barnes might very well qualify for a postseason share from both the Cubs and Dodgers this year.
Little, a well-liked guy by players and fans alike, had talent. Could throw hard. Just couldn’t throw strikes. If he could have harnessed the fastball he might be a closer by now. But he couldn’t.
His one 2026 appearance was pitching the ninth inning of a game the Cubs won 11-2 over the Phillies. And he didn’t walk anyone! He did, however, serve up a home run to Bryce Harper [VIDEO].
Little was sent back to Iowa, where he walked so many guys (23 in 23.1 innings) that he was demoted to Double-A Knoxville, where he again had a high walk rate. He was claimed off waivers by the Royals Aug. 6, where he … walked a lot of guys (12 in 11.1 innings). He’s now a free agent. I wish him the best.
The Cubs signed Rios to a minor-league deal January 26, with a Spring Training invite… then he missed pretty much all of spring camp as part of the Puerto Rico World Baseball Classic team. He pitched in three WBC games, throwing 3.2 innings, allowing one unearned run and striking out five.
Returning to the Cubs organization, he pitched at Iowa in early April and then was added to the 40-man roster April 26, same day as Barnes was added.
Blach was once a pretty good prospect in the Giants organization and had a couple of fifth-starter type years for them in 2017 and 2018. After that he bounced around to the Orioles, Rockies and Rangers organizations before the Cubs signed him to a minor-league deal April 14.
Added to the active roster May 17, he pitched the last three innings of a 9-3 blowout loss to the Brewers the next day, allowing just one hit. Here he is striking out Brice Turang [VIDEO].
Blach was DFA’d the next day, re-signed a minor league deal with the Cubs and made a few appearances at Iowa before he was released Aug. 1.
Wantz had a couple of decent relief years for the Angels between 2021 and 2023, but missed most of 2024 and 2025 with elbow issues, for which he was reported to have had a “procedure” that was not Tommy John surgery.
The Rays picked him up for 2026 and he made one appearance for them in late May before they let him go. The Cubs signed him to a minor-league deal June 6 and he made 14 appearances (nine starts) for Iowa before being added to the active roster when the team let Jameson Taillon go.
Wantz was DFA’d the next day, re-signed a minor-league deal with the Cubs Aug. 6 and made several more appearances for Iowa through the end of the season. He’s currently a free agent.
Kelly, a Chicago-area native (Maine East High School) was originally drafted by the Brewers out of Wabash Valley Junior College in 2019. He spent time in the Brewers, Rockies, Rangers and Dodgers organizations before the Cubs acquired him for cash considerations June 7. He pitched in 13 games at Iowa before being called up July 31. He appeared in that day’s game against the Yankees, and actually pitched in a fairly high-leverage situation: Two runners on and two out in the top of the eighth with the Cubs trailing 2-0.
Kelly was optioned back to Iowa two days later and finished the year there. He was let go at the end of the season and signed a minor-league deal with the Guardians with a Spring Training invitation.
Miller had played reasonably well as a backup infielder for Cleveland and Milwaukee from 2021-23. But by 2026 he was one of those “break glass in case of emergency” infielders, and that’s why the Cubs signed him to a minor-league deal before Spring Training.
He was called up Aug. 17 when James Triantos was returned to Iowa.
This is perhaps the shortest of all of these one-game appearances. In the ninth inning of this game against the White Sox, with the Cubs trailing 5-4, Tyrone Taylor was sent in to run for Alex Bregman. Taylor eventually scored the tying run, but the game went to extras. At that point, Pedro Ramirez moved from second base to third base and Miller took over at second in the top of the 10th.
That’s it. That’s Owen Miller’s Cubs career, one inning of defense. And even though there’s no real video available of Miller, that’s a photo of him at the top of this post, standing in position at Wrigley Field during that inning.
That was the game PCA won with a leadoff homer in the bottom of the 10th.
Miller was DFA’d on Aug. 21, outrighted to Iowa Aug. 24, and was granted free agency on Oct. 5. If nothing else, he’s a good Immaculate Grid answer.
Here’s the one guy among these eight who will likely have a large impact on the Cubs going forward. They acquired him from the Marlins by trade at the deadline for Jonathon Long and Jace Beck, and knew at the time he probably wouldn’t contribute much, if at all, in 2026 due to recovery from Tommy John surgery.
Garrett had a really good year as a starter in Miami in 2023, posting a 3.66 ERA and 1.146 WHIP, with 4.3 bWAR in 31 appearances (30 starts). Yes, it’s four years and one TJS later, but if he can recover that form the Cubs might have a pretty good starter in 2027.
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS - SEPTEMBER 20: Luis Castillo #58 of the Chicago White Sox delivers a pitch against the Detroit Tigers at Rate Field on September 20, 2026 in Chicago, Illinois. (Photo by Jayden Mack/Getty Images) | Getty Images
Good morning friends and happy Friday!
The free agent market continues to hum along as we approach the likely lockout. Here’s everything you may have missed from yesterday.
In Mariners news…
If you want more analysis from the Mariners’ acquisition of third baseman Maikel García, we’ve got a pair of Meet at the Mitt episodes for you. In the first, Kate and Evan briefly talked with Jeremy Greco of Royals Review to break it down from both sides (Apple link, Spotify link). Then, Kate, Evan, John, and Max took a deeper dive into the swap between the M’s and Royals (Apple link, Spotify link).
For the second time in less than a year, Luis Castillo is on the move. The right-hander was dealt alongside righty Davis Martin from the White Sox to the Rockies in exchange for left-hander Sean Sullivan and catcher Douglas Veliz.
Lawmakers are introducing legislation to remove MLB’s antitrust exemption in a move that the MLBPA hopes will benefit their play for leverage in the CBA negotiations. Evan Drellich at The Athletic has the report. ($)
Ron Kroichick at The San Francisco Chronicle eulogized the Oakland Coliseum which is almost certainly going away after it was sold to a group of investors.
Sep 22, 2026; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Kansas City Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. (7) reaches for a throw at second base during the first inning against the Chicago White Sox at Kauffman Stadium. Mandatory Credit: William Purnell-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
2026 was a good year for Royals superstar Bobby Witt Jr. The 26-year-old shortstop maybe didn’t play up to his best, but even in a “down” year for him, it’s still a career year for others.
Witt missed some time with some low back tightness from July 22 to August 4, resulting in him playing a career-low 143 games as a big leaguer. However, he still slashed .281/.359/.441, smacking 33 doubles, a triple (career low), 18 homers (career low), and 54 RBI, a career low. However, he had a career high 67 walks, while striking out 109 times. He stole 45 bases. All that makes up a 6.7 WAR season for the phenom. He won his third Silver Slugger Award.
Witt really struggled in the month of July, hitting just .196/.250/.286, which you know was because of the back tightness, because he hit at least .264 every other month. Defensively, Witt was a stud, I don’t know how he wasn’t a Gold Glove winner. But he had 10 errors, which ties his career-low in the category. He posted an absurd 24 Outs Above Average. His range on Baseball Savant was listed in the 100th percentile. His arm strength is well above average as well. His defensive run value number was +17, the second best of his career. He is a wizard out there.
Bobby Baseball made his third consecutive All-Star appearance and was named to the All-MLB First Team for the third time this season as well.
It was obviously another great season for Witt, so am I off base for saying I thought it was a down year for him? It could be as simple as me holding him to a very high standard, because of what he did in 2024. But it felt like in some of the bigger moments this season, Witt didn’t come through which was odd to see. Clearly, everyone doesn’t always come through – they are humans after all – but it felt like more times than not, at least early in the season, Witt failed to come through at the plate in the clutch.
Some of my thoughts are backed up statistically, as you can see above with some career low numbers this past season for Witt. And again, as I mentioned above, a “down” year for him is a great year or even a career year for many other ballplayers. That’s why my judgement might be a little off, with me holding him to too high of a standard.
When looking at the Baseball Reference page for Witt and his splits, in what they categorize as “Clutch Stats” his worse attempts came with 2 outs and runners in scoring position, where he hit a measly .212. In every other clutch situation, he hit at least .250. In their leverage category, he hit .265 in high leverage spots, .285 in medium and .284 in low leverage.
So again, if you say I’m off base in my assessment of Witt, that’s fine. But again, to clarify, he had a GREAT season. It just felt like a down year for him personally. Anyways, here are some of his best moments at the plate this season.