Sports are a part of our lives that provide us with the best human stories. While we don’t have access to the everyday lives of players we see on the field, court, ice, or diamond every night, those with more access than most have the responsibility to tell their stories. And one of the most curious Yankees stories is David Parrish.
Selected twice by the Yankees, Parrish never took the field in pinstripes despite donning them in the dugout. But his story is still one of the most interesting (and, for many, potentially sad or disappointing): working his way up to the minors, coming up to the major leagues, and sitting in the dugout without any playing time.
David Michael Parrish
Born: June 13, 1979 (Ypsilanti, MI)
Yankees Tenure: 2000-06 (minors); 2004 (called up but didn’t play)
Parrish was born in Ypsilanti, Michigan, and moved to Yorba Linda, California, at a young age. The son of Lance Parrish, an eight-time All-Star, three-time Gold Glove Award winner, six-time Silver Slugger Award winner, and 1984 World Series champion with the Detroit Tigers, David played high school baseball at Esperanza High School. After a successful high school career that put him on the map for plenty of scouts, he was initially drafted by the Yankees in the 10th round of the 1997 MLB Draft, but instead chose to return to Michigan to play for the Wolverines in Ann Arbor.
He didn’t play much in 1998 and 1999, but in his 2000 season, he was the starting catcher for the Wolverines—where future well-traveled big-leaguer Rich Hill was his batterymate—and posted some excellent numbers, including a .432 on-base percentage and a .621 slugging percentage. Along with his .356 batting average, his OPS came out to 1.409 that season, putting him amongst the best college baseball prospects.
The Yankees decided to dip back into the well again under general manager Brian Cashman and select Parrish again, this time in the first round (28th overall) of the 2000 MLB draft, hoping to fare better than they had with their last batch of first-round picks, which were absolutely abysmal. However, he was still considered a reach at the time.
Parrish was a touted pick selected between 1996 (Eric Milton, who was traded to the Twins in the Chuck Knoblauch deal) and 2004 (Phil Hughes). But it would be another pick in a string of many that would turn out poorly for the Bombers. David would never achieve much above A-ball. He finished with a .664 career Double-A OPS and .644 career Triple-A OPS between 2002-08. However, the real story for Parrish comes from his time on the Yankees’ roster from May 13-16, 2004.
On May 12th, Yankees starting catcher and the year prior’s third-place finisher in American League MVP voting, Jorge Posada, suffered a broken nose when he was struck by a thrown ball while trying to break up a double play. Parrish was then called up and assigned uniform No. 57, providing insurance behind backup catcher John Flaherty.
Despite his hopes and dreams of stepping into a major league game, Parrish never got the chance. Yes, he got to exit the Yankees clubhouse and sit in the dugout for major league games. But Posada returned to the lineup on May 18th. And while he was in the dugout for the Yankees through a series with the Seattle Mariners, one of his father’s former teams, his dreams were short-lived. He never appeared in a game, and, according to our site manager who covered those 2004 Yankees with extreme depth, he doesn’t even remember Parrish making a TV appearance. As such, he became a “phantom player.”
The Yankees and Parrish eventually parted ways early in 2006. The team was set with Posada for the foreseeable future, and considering Parrish’s production in the minor leagues, or, rather, lack thereof, there was no reason for them to keep him around with a new crop of players coming in (including Francisco Cervelli). The Pittsburgh Pirates, Colorado Rockies, and San Diego Padres organizations all took a flyer on him, but despite those teams giving him a chance, he never returned to the majors. Parrish eventually retired in 2008 following his age-29 season in Long Beach in the Golden League, where he played only 10 games. In fact, in the last three seasons of his minor league career, he played only 111 games with a collective batting average of .187, almost solidifying that his time playing any sort of professional baseball had come to a close.
Since the selection of Parrish in the first round of 2000, there was mostly a string of disappointing picks for the Yankees. There were picks who drew plenty of hype from the media and those outside of baseball spheres but didn’t end up signing with the men in pinstripes, including Mark Prior and Gerrit Cole, the latter of whom obviously ended up signing with the Yankees as as free agent later in his career, and exciting minor leaguers who never seemed to truly put it together for them in pros such as the aforementioned Hughes, Ian Kennedy, and Joba Chamberlain. But, it’s also important to remember what happened the majority of the time, which was players who just weren’t great picks at all by the Yankees front office and its scouting staff, increasing scrutiny from the fanbase.
Parrish’s story is one that is disappointing, but it’s also a good reminder that not every sports story is glamorous. There are plenty of those who see the light of day for just a moment and are eventually dragged back to what is viewed as the doldrums. Sure, it’s still professional baseball, but it’s very different than walking through the tunnel and into the Yankees dugout donning the pinstripes. Additionally, as the son of a decorated MLB player, there was somewhat of a legacy to live up to. However, Parrish made it as far as he could, and he will forever have the story of sitting in that Yankees dugout for a series, experiencing life as a Yankee in front of fans in The Bronx.
See more of the “Yankees Birthday of the Day” series here.