Dodgers have depth in the starting rotation, but bullpen is a work in progress

Dodgers pitcher Yoshinobu Yamamoto pitches against the Cincinnati Reds at Dodger Stadium during a game on Sept. 9.
Dodgers pitcher Yoshinobu Yamamoto pitches against the Cincinnati Reds at Dodger Stadium during a game on Sept. 9. (Robert Gauthier / Los Angeles Times)

It’s been a newsy week in baseball, between owners meetings, Tarik Skubal’s free agency, and the deadline to protect prospects from the Rule 5 Draft.

The Dodgers had a meeting scheduled with Skubal, put four prospects on the 40-man roster and announced that reliever Seth Halverson had undergone Tommy John surgery.

With all that action, and end of the current CBA fast approaching on Dec. 1, it’s a good time to evaluate the Dodgers’ pitching staff:

Starting rotation

Returning: Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Shohei Ohtani, Blake Snell, Tyler Glasnow, Roki Sasaki, Justin Wrobleski, Emmet Sheehan

Free agent: Tarik Skubal, Eric Lauer

Additional depth: Gavin Stone

Skubal essentially replaced Ohtani, limited by injuries to his left knee and right biceps, in the rotation when the Dodgers acquired the left-hander at the trade deadline. But if they don’t re-sign Skubal, it won’t be as simple as Ohtani tagging back in. The Dodgers still have to work out his workload for next year, as he returns to two-way duties.

The Dodgers do have pitching depth, with a promising trio of Sasaki, Wrobleski and Sheehan rounding out the back of the rotation, and Stone expected to be healthy next year, but the Dodgers’ commitment to a six-man rotation requires a wealth of options. They also aren’t looking to coast after an NLCS exit. And raising the bar from 2026 could mean supplementing the rotation, whether that be with Skubal or another starter via free agency or trade.

“Do you need it? I don’t know. Do you want it? Maybe,” general manager Brandon Gomes said at the MLB general manager meetings last week. “You may not know that you need it until it’s too late. … The floor right now is really high. We do have a good amount of depth in our pitching, so now it’s just taking into account what makes sense for us based on different avenues of how things shake out.”

Bullpen

Returning (min 10 IP in 2026 season): Edwin Díaz, Tanner Scott, Edgardo Henriquez, Jack Dreyer, Will Klein, Brock Stewart, Kyle Hurt, Landon Knack

Out: Evan Phillips (signed with Braves), Seth Halvorsen (Tommy John surgery)

Free agent: Alex Vesia, Blake Treinen, Brusdar Graterol, Kris Bubic

Phillips’ three-year, $35-million deal helped set the early bullpen market. He returns to the Braves, the team that drafted him in 2015, after six years with the Dodgers.

It was always clear that the Dodgers would have work to do this offseason reinforcing their bullpen, a common winter project for most teams around the league. Though the Dodgers have signed closers (Scott and Díaz) in back-to-back offseasons, both of whom remain under contract, manager Dave Roberts regularly leaned on Phillips and Vesia in high-leverage situations.

Treinen hurt his shoulder during the last series of the regular season, and Graterol hasn’t thrown in a major-league game since the 2024 World Series due to injuries. Bubic has traditionally been a starter, but after the Dodgers acquired him at the trade deadline, while he was still on the injured list, he worked back as a reliever to shorten his return timeline.

Halvorsen, the hard-throwing right-hander who the Dodgers acquired from the Rockies in late July, only made 11 major-league appearances with the Dodgers, but the 26-year-old showed plenty of potential. After undergoing Tommy John surgery on Tuesday he’s expected to miss the 2027 season.

The reliever market started moving early, in an offseason that’s expected to go into an indefinite hold when MLB owners impose a lockout, likely on Dec. 1.

40-man roster additions

In the face of a looming lockout this year, it’s unclear whether there will actually be a Rule 5 Draft, which is typically held during the Winter Meetings in December. The last MLB lockout — which lasted 99 days, from December 2, 2021 to March 10, 2022 — completely wiped out the Rule 5 Draft.

Still, teams had to prepare this week as if it would happen. On Tuesday, the Dodgers added right-hander Christian Zazueta and left-handers Jackson Ferris, Adam Serwinowski and Luke Fox to the 40-man roster. To make room for them, the Dodgers designated right-handed pitcher Jake Cousins and infielder Christian Cairo for assignment.

Zazueta (No.5), Serwinowski (No. 14) and Ferris (No. 17), are all ranked by MLB Pipeline among the top 20 prospects in the Dodgers’ system, and Zazueta is ranked No. 33 in MLB.

Sign up for more Dodgers news with Dodgers Dugout. Delivered at the start of each series.

This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.

Should the Red Sox consider a reunion with free agent pitcher Nick Pivetta?

SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA - OCTOBER 6: Nick Pivetta #27 of the San Diego Padres stands on the mound during Game Three of the National League Division Series against the Milwaukee Brewers at Petco Park on October 6, 2026 in San Diego, California. (Photo by Matt Thomas/San Diego Padres/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Welcome to the 2026-27 edition of Smash or Pass, in which we examine potential free agent and trade targets to determine whether the Red Sox should pursue them and what it would take to land them. Today, in the wake of an effective veteran pitcher departing for Minnesota, we continue the series with an old friend.

Who is he and where does he come from?

He’s Nick Pivetta. But you know him already. He might as well be from South Boston, but he’s actually from the opposite side of the continent, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. After starting his career in Philadelphia, Dave Dombrowski dealt him to us to get his old reliever Brandon Workman back; the Red Sox would eventually end up with both on the squad, and the deal is widely regarded among Chaim Bloom’s best as Chief Baseball Officer. That’s not because Nick Pivetta was a world-beater, as I’ll get into in just a moment, but he did give the team five very dependable years before heading to San Diego and pitching like a Cy Young Candidate.

Is he any good?

He can be, but there’s a catch. At the age of 33, Pivetta has just sustained his first long-term injury of his entire career. The bad news is, it’s a continuation of an injury he suffered as a member of the Red Sox to start off the 2024 season; this time, the right flexor strain kept him out for five months. So, the jury is out on if he will pitch well in 2027. But, he played meaningful games in October and was one of the best starters in baseball in his last full season in 2025.

The best ability, as we saw from this depleted pitching staff in the late summer, is availability, and Pivetta has had that in spades through his entire career, save for 2026. From 2021-2025, he had an ERA of 4.00 (a 4.04 FIP), a WHIP of 1.18, and 895 strikeouts across 804 2/3 innings. That’s pretty much exactly what you’d be looking for in a back-of-the-rotation starter, though he did have a glaring hole: he allowed home runs and hard hits an alarming rate, and he allowed among the worst rates in baseball (~10th percentile) in barrel percentage for his entire time in Boston. This reared its head in a major way in 2023, when Pivetta was demoted to the bullpen, where he looked like a different guy before winning a rotation spot back, all prior to heading for the west coast in free agency on a 4-year, 55 million dollar deal with opt outs after two years after initially turning down a qualifying offer from the Red Sox. And, after that second season, here we are!

Tl;dr, just give me the 2026 stats.

Remember, that flexor strain kept his season dramatically short, so here’s his last two campaigns.

2025: 13-5, 181 2/3 IP, 190 K, 50 BB, 2.87 ERA, 3.49 FIP

2026: 3-2, 34 2/3 IP, 42 K, 8 BB, 2.86 ERA, 2.21 FIP

Why would he be a good fit for the Sox?

With Sonny Gray going to the Twins, they’re in the market for a right-handed pitcher. Pivetta is four years younger than Gray. He also has been healthy for a good amount of his career; he even made 33 starts in 2023. He knows the team, and was even on the team for the first part of Craig Breslow’s time with the organization. Need I remind everyone how awesome this post-season relief appearance was where he struck seven Rays out in four innings in extras?

We all know how John Henry operates, so maybe the most important thing: he’s also likely to be cost-effective. That plays a huge part for a pitching staff that needs not only depth and dependability, but financial pliability. Payton Tolle is going to need money soon. Garrett Crochet already got paid. Jake Bennett could be a part of this rotation for a while and has a definitively higher ceiling than Pivetta’s, though that’s comparing apples to bananas. Ranger Suarez looked awesome for much of last season. Then there’s Brayan Bello. Fact of the matter is, Pivetta gives a short-term lilypad for this frog of a roster to jump to the next lilypad without having to pay a guy 27 million dollars a season.

Why wouldn’t he be a good fit for the Sox?

First of all, maybe the rotation is already too cluttered, though that argument may have flown the coop once Jedixson Paez took the mound on a September evening in the middle of a playoff push. You can almost not have too much depth. There are two more important concerns: one is obviously that right flexor. It was an issue two seasons ago, and it kept him out for most of this past season. Now, he posted a 1.45 ERA in five starts once returning from this injury to end 2026 and was healthy enough to take two starts in the postseason, but none of those reached the end of the fifth inning, so it’s equal parts likely it’s going to be an reoccurring issue that just happens as a pitcher ages, or a reason to not invest in him at all. At 34, it may be better to be cautiously pessimistic, knowing you have an effective rotation already.

What would it take to get him?

The Padres declined a $14 million club option, so the Padres don’t want him at that number, but most estimates (including my own, based off of seeing that Gray deal) place him at around $16-17 million AAV and most have him getting a 3-year deal. I’d imagine that this would include opt outs after each year given the recent injury and Pivetta approaching 35 before Opening Day 2028 (Valentine’s Day, to be exact.) Recall that Sonny Gray, who was lights out for the whole season, cost the Red Sox $21 million net after the Cardinals sent money the team’s way to acquire him, and also factor into the equation that a Tolle deal is on the horizon… somewhere. There are other options, like Michael King, Nick Martinez, and Casey Mize, but if Dustin May’s 3 year, 52.5 million deal is any indication of what these guys will cost, Pivetta will be more cost-efficient.

Smash or Pass?

I’m smashing if the thought process is securing Tolle to a long term deal, and that Garrett Crochet reemerges as the pig he was in 2025, and Ranger Suarez is sorted onto this 2027 squad as arguably the best third man in all of baseball. Nick Pivetta could easily be a fifth man in this rotation, and, as we know, the allotment this year may be even tighter than most, especially given a couple of dominos have already fallen: I’d rather use his limited allotment to bolster a lineup to gather some run support for a rotation that was not the biggest issue for a playoff squad and stick to a lower-risk addition we already know well.

The Washington Nationals seem unlikely to spend big yet again

CINCINNATI, OHIO - SEPTEMBER 17: Brady Singer #51 of the Cincinnati Reds prepares to pitch against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Great American Ball Park on September 17, 2026 in Cincinnati, Ohio. (Photo by Justin Casterline/Getty Images) | Getty Images

This morning, Spencer Nusbaum came out with an article that I frankly found depressing. He went over some of the Nats top pitching targets, and to say they were uninspiring would be putting it lightly. According to him, the Nats have shown interest in Kris Bubic, Brady Singer and Kona Takahashi. Out of those three, Bubic is the only one I would have real interest in.

Even in the column about Bubic, Nusbaum wrote that he could be “driven out of the Nats price range”. If we can’t financially compete for Kris Bubic, we are in big trouble. Based on the article, expect more of the same dumpster diving as previous offseasons.

That is honestly a big disappointment. I was not naive enough to expect a Tarik Skubal signing and even thought a Michael King type deal was unlikely. However, I expected them to shoot a bit higher than they did in previous offseasons. This is a team that showed way more promise in 2026 than they did in previous years.

The offense was elite in 2026 and the team made an 11 win improvement. A lot of the Stephen Strasburg money also comes off the books this year. The fact there is still seemingly not going to be any spending is really sad. Nats fans have been let down by ownership so much since winning the World Series in 2019. Based on their actions, this ownership group just seems checked out.

Heading into this offseason, the Nats have the lowest projected payroll in the sport. Despite that, it does not seem like there will be any real push to improve the roster by outside spending. Even with the improvement last year, it is tough to buy into the Nats competing in a tough division with this little help from ownership.

On to the pitchers that were listed, and it was a mixed bag. Honestly, I would be happy with a Bubic signing. The fact he would be the biggest ticket item would be disappointing, but I think he is a talented pitcher. We wrote about what makes him a great fit for the Nats. 

The injury history makes him a risky signing, but whenever Bubic is on the mound, he is good. If you can even get 110-120 innings out of Bubic, he would likely make his contract a valuable one. Ideally, you could get him on a 1 or 2 year deal with some sort of option attached.

I am pretty out on Brady Singer though. He is just this year’s version of Miles Mikolas or Zack Littell. Singer is very durable, but posted a 5.85 ERA with bad underlying numbers. That would honestly be a slap in the face to Nats fans. He was better when he worked with Simon Mathews in 2025, but his stuff is bad and it is trending in the wrong direction.

Kona Takahashi is a somewhat interesting profile, but also just a bit underwhelming. He throws in the mid-90’s, but was more of a pitch to contact guy in Japan. The 30 year old made improvements in 2026, but he still profiles as a back of the rotation innings eater.

Foster Griffin was also mentioned, but at this point, he is likely to be the biggest fish they shoot for. I loved Griffin last year, but the way he ended the season was a bit worrying. Obviously, I would take him, but I think he is closer to a number 4 starter than a number two.

Walker Buehler was also mentioned as a candidate, after having a slight bounceback with the Padres last year. He is more of a back-end starter than the ace he once was, but I have always liked him. I would certainly take him over a Singer.

One part of the article that made me quite angry is when Nusbaum questioned whether David Peterson or Jack Flaherty would be too expensive for the Nats. That honestly just made my blood boil. This is a team with hardly any money on the books, and you are telling me they can’t afford David Peterson? It is easy to see why fans are so frustrated with ownership.

Since 2021, the Nats have not given out more than $15 million to a free agent. It seems like there is a real possibility that does not change this offseason. If you are not spending with money off the books and a roster on the rise, when will it ever happen?

This was the franchise that gave Max Scherzer a $210 million contract and paid Jayson Werth to jump start a rebuild. However, those days seem to have died with Ted Lerner. Instead, the Nats are just dumpster diving and hoping they can find value that they can trade at the deadline.

It truly is a sad state of affairs. Obviously, things could change and the offseason has just begun. However, the early reports are not promising if you wanted to see the Nats spend money. This team has obvious holes to fill on the pitching staff, but are not willing to do what it takes to fix them.

Obviously, most of this is on ownership, but there was also a part that mentioned the Nats are not looking into moving prospects. If you can’t spend money, I think it would be a smart play to trade from your position player prospect stockpile to get an arm. This is especially true if you want to keep CJ Abrams, which seems to be the case.

If you are not trading Abrams, but also not surrounding Abrams with talent to win while he is under contract, what are we doing? At the end of the season, Nats fans were more optimistic than they had been in a while. This offseason seems like it will bring us back to reality though. I really hope that is not the case.

Thursday Morning Links

ARLINGTON, TX - SEPTEMBER 06: Logan O'Hoppe #4 of the Texas Rangers runs to first base during a game against the Tampa Bay Rays at Globe Life Field on September 06, 2026 in Arlington, Texas. (Photo by Bailey Orr/Texas Rangers/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Morning, all!

The Rangers are looking for center fielders to share duties with Evan Carter but the options aren’t particularly sexy.

Kennedi Landry wonders if Logan O’Hoppe will be the catcher splitting time with Danny Jansen in 2027.

While an isn’t on-the-field position, Texas has hired aMichael People as their Director of Pit bing, a position that did not exist in 2026.

By trading Maikel Garcia, the Royals got different, not better

SEATTLE, WASHINGTON - MAY 02: Maikel Garcia #11 of the Kansas City Royals throws the ball to first base for the final out of the game against the Seattle Mariners at T-Mobile Park on May 02, 2026 in Seattle, Washington. (Photo by Olivia Vanni/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Yesterday, the Kansas City Royals engaged in a bit of surprising and eyebrow-raising offseason action, trading Maikel Garcia—alongside James McCarthur and minor leaguer L.P. Langevin, to the Seattle Mariners. In return, they received a trio of pitchers headlined by Bryce Miller and including Logan Evans and José Ferrer.

It would be accurate to call this a stunning trade. Prior to literally a few hours before the trade, nobody thought Garcia was on the trade block. And per general manager JJ Picollo, Garcia wasn’t on the trade block. Rather, the trade was something that developed after the GM meetings a week ago, and it finally reached fruition:

“When you have a good player and he was willing to sign an extension with us last year, [trading him] is hard,” Picollo said. “It is a difficult thing to make that jump, but again, our job is to make our team as competitive as it can be.” 

Picollo emphasized that the Royals were not actively looking to move Garcia.

“It wasn’t a move we felt like we needed to make,” Picollo said. “We felt like it could potentially be a move that makes our team better, and that’s what we think this did.”

This trade is as complicated to judge as a two-team trade can be. Six players were involved, of which four had injury-plagued 2026 seasons that limited their value. There are a lot of possibilities that could happen here, and with so many players poised to rebound or breakout the error bars around the value are particularly large. There’s also the matter of Seattle taking on $50 million in guaranteed money—not a huge amount by MLB standards, but definitely not nothing. Baseball Trade Values has one of the best publicly available surplus trade value calculation algorithms out there, and they think it was fair if an overpay by Seattle.

That is a totally reasonable take. It is also a reasonable take to side with the Seattle Mariners fans, who seem to be thrilled that they are getting a premium young player and seem to be willing to part with three flawed, more limited players. It depends on how good Garcia is, but of course it does. That’s how trades work.

But “fair” and “good” are two different words to describe the trade. I would easily call this a fair trade. However, I don’t think that I would call this a good trade. What is a good trade? We talk surplus value all the time, and that’s an aspect of it, but a good trade is ultimately a trade that helps you get to where you want to go. You can get fleeced in overall lifetime value but be happy if a trade nets you a trophy.

My issue with this trade is that it doesn’t pass that specific smell test: It doesn’t help the Royals get to where they’re going.

You can’t get to where you’re going without starting somewhere, and the Royals are starting way back in the pack. Look, the 2026 Royals were a disaster. They lost 93 games and were never once relevant in the division, going nine games under .500 barely three weeks into the season and 15 games under .500 by the end of May. They were bad at almost literally everything; they stunk at scoring runs (4.26 per game, 22nd in the league) and couldn’t pitch to save their lives (4.78 ERA, 27th in the league) and ran into outs on the basepaths like it was their job (56, 28th in the league).

At the end of the day, the one and only foolproof roster building strategy is to assemble a team that scores more runs than its opponents. There are a lot of tactics that you can employ: getting a great outfield defense and a bunch of fly ball pitchers, de-emphasizing defense while leaning on strong hitters and high-strikeout fireballers, and so on and so on. But one additional run scored counts just the same as one fewer run allowed.

I say all of this because the Royals aren’t in a position where they can afford how they are winning and losing. They just don’t have enough talent right now, period. I understand the drive to improve the pitching. But in improving the pitching, the Royals are sending away one of their most talented players in Garcia. The math doesn’t work, especially if Garcia puts up 5 or more Wins Above Replacement like he did in 2025. Miller, Evans, and Ferrera would have to be really, really good just to match that, and the Royals’ goal is to improve, not to tread water.

By trading Garcia, the Royals aren’t getting better. They’re getting different. Maybe different eventually could be better. Maybe the Royals have identified that they could get their free agent dollars to stretch further signing position players rather than pitching, and by trading Garcia they get their pitching without paying a free agent premium for it. Maybe Garcia wanted out. There are things that only the front office and coaching staff know, after all.

It’s just, man, I don’t see how this trade helps the Royals win more games next year. The Royals are now even weaker offensively and even more susceptible to left-handed pitching. They’ve got to address those problems now, too, and it’s not like they are clearing space for a hotshot third base prospect. It’s a vote of confidence in Nick Loftin, maybe? I dunno. The wheels just seem a little stuck in the mud.

Mariners News: Maikel García, Sonny Gray, and Nick Fortes

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 30: Sonny Gray #54 of the Boston Red Sox pitches against the New York Yankees during the first inning in game two of the American League Wild Card Series at Yankee Stadium on September 30, 2026 in the Bronx borough of New York City. (Photo by Caleb Bowlin/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Good morning everyone!

The Mariners kicked off the offseason last night with a bang, acquiring Gold Glove third baseman Maikel García from the Royals in a six-player swap that sent Bryce Miller, Logan Evans, and José Ferrer to Kansas City.

Let’s check in on the fallout from that deal and more from around the league.

In Mariners news…

Around the league…

Anders’ pick…

  • With the long-awaited Grant Theft Auto VI coming out last night, the review embargo was lifted during the day yesterday. And folks, it appears we have a masterpiece on our hands.

Making case for moving Padres’ Manny Machado to full-time DH

San Diego Padres 3B Manny Machado (Photo by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Since 2023, Manny Machado and Xander Bogaerts have locked down the left side of the San Diego Padres’ infield. Unsurprisingly, both veterans backed up that reputation with above-average defensive metrics last season.

But the infield defensive alignment needs to get younger across the board, and moving Machado to full-time DH is worth exploring. 

Machado’s days at third base numbered?

With Machado turning 35 in 2027 and showing clear signs of decline, it’s time to build a starting lineup that doesn’t rely on him at third base every day.

Last season, Machado played 139 games at third base and made only three errors with a .990 fielding percentage. However, he graded out poorly with a -8 Fielding Run Value (FRV). At this stage of his career, Machado can field every ball hit directly at him, but his range to cover the line is slipping. 

The move helps solve two growing problems: getting the lineup younger and more athletic while keeping Machado’s bat productive all summer. 

Padres need to preserve Machado’s offensive impact

One of the biggest mysteries of the 2026 season was Machado’s prolonged first-half batting slump. Without his expected production, the Friars’ offense struggled to score runs. 

After a slow start hitting at .226, Machado fell into a deeper slump, batting .127 with 29 strikeouts over 102 at-bats in May. A power surge began in June and continued into July. He raised his slugging percentage to .490. 

Machado finished the 2026 campaign with a .217 batting average, 57 points lower than his career average (.274). As the season progressed, his bat speed seemed to slow down through the strike zone. Machado posted his highest strikeout rate (21.3%) since 2022. 

Adjusting to a new role may come with early struggles for Machado. Last season as a DH, he batted .158 with one home run in 19 starts. Rather than a permanent position change, Padres manager Craig Stammen may cap his third-base workload at 120 to 125 games to keep his legs fresh.

While Machado still packs plenty of punch as a middle-of-the-order threat, his run production has tapered off. He hasn’t driven in 100 runs in three of the last four years. The Friars are counting on Machado to bounce back and thrive in pressure-packed at-bats.

Finding the right fit matters

Any potential move only works if the Friars land a young infielder with an outstanding glove. The front office will have to look outside the organization since their farm system lacks an in-house candidate. However, if the Padres cannot find a quality trade option, then the club should scrap the idea until 2028. 

This scenario depends on how much the Padres’ new owners, Kwanza Jones and Jose E. Feliciano, are willing to spend to improve the team. It may come down to signing multiple free-agent starting pitchers and keeping the lineup intact for another season.

At some point, the roster needs to evolve. It will be fascinating to see if this suggestion becomes a reality.


Padres News:

  • Nick Pivetta missed much of 2026 with an arm injury, but he returned for the final weeks of the season and performed well. He logged enough innings to receive his grade from Lincoln Zdunich of Gaslamp Ball.
  • The Padres need pitching and they are one of the teams in talks with Tarik Skubal. With new owners and unknown budget, there is no reason to think they could not land the ace.

Baseball News:

Yankees Roster Report Cards: Aaron Judge

NEW YORK, NY - SEPTEMBER 29: Aaron Judge #99 of the New York Yankees looks on after winning Game One of the American League Wild Card Series presented by AbbVie between the Boston Red Sox and the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium on Tuesday, September 29, 2026 in New York, New York. (Photo by Mary DeCicco/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images

In retrospect, it’s really surprising the 2026 Yankees won 93 games. Because if you’d told me a year ago that Aaron Judge would miss 96 games and that, when healthy he would be closer to great than to historically great (his 2026 OPS is the lowest of his career, not counting his 2016 cup of coffee), I would have penciled the Yankees in to win something like 83 games, if not 73.

So, I guess the good news is the Yanks showed themselves able to withstand a prolonged absence of the greatest hitter on Earth (perhaps the greatest right-handed hitter modern baseball has seen?). The bad news is that, after transcendent 2022, 2024, and 2025 seasons (when he was healthy in 2023, he was nigh-unstoppable as well), we might have to start grappling with the idea that Judge’s superhuman peak has passed.

One of my 2027 storylines to watch will be whether Judge’s 2026 was an anomaly or the onset of his decline phase, which has to arrive eventually, after all. Father Time is undefeated. Judge will play next season at 35 years old. And we don’t exactly have a robust sample size of players of a Judgian stature from which to forecast how he’ll age. But his floor is just so damn high that when decline comes, if it’s gradual, he’ll still be a superstar for a while.

I can’t stress enough how much I am rooting for anomaly to win.

Grade: I
2026 Stats: 66 G, 18 HR, 41 RBI, 45 R, .241/.360/.511, 140 OPS+, 140 wRC+, 1.9 rWAR, 2.0 fWAR
2027 Contract Status: Under contract through 2031 ($40 million 2027 salary)

Lest I be mistaken as a downer, I want to be clear. Even an injury-plagued Aaron Judge was really, really good in 2026. We’ve been spoiled by the back of his baseball card in recent seasons, so numbers that 99% of major league hitters would take in a heartbeat look disappointing when they belong to Judge.

His post-rib injury seven game September cameo also drags down his final line. That week was ugly. One home run, a .174 batting average, and a 13:1 K:BB ratio in only 24 plate appearances. It was bad. But Judge was determined to get back and try to help the Yankees down the stretch.

Unfortunately, his season ended in disappointing fashion when he suffered a calf strain against the Twins that ended his season and kept him off the postseason roster – though not without much Shakespearean discussion about his circumstances. “To roster Judge, or not to roster Judge: that is the question.”

Rewinding the clock, Judge had a strong start to the season, though his batting average never reflected that. Considering his 2026 BABIP plummeted 87 points from 2025 when he won his batting title, that shouldn’t be a surprise.

Everything else was still there. He was drawing his walks and hitting home runs. Heading into what turned out to be a fateful game against the Astros on April 26th, Judge had nine home runs and 17 RBI in 27 games. That night, he hit a solo shot to put him in double digits. He also dove for a ball in right field. Little did we all know that defensive effort was the beginning of the end of his season.

Judge gave us no reason to suspect anything. On the contrary. He went on his best offensive tear of the season in the games that followed. Over the next two weeks (13 games), Judge hit .348/.483/.804 with half a dozen dingers and 12 RBI.

But he knew he was hurt. He revealed in early June he’d been playing through pain since the dive in Houston. Crashing into the outfield wall against Baltimore on May 3rd didn’t help anything either. Finally, it became too much. He played the series against the Athletics at the end of May, at which point he finally told manage Aaron Boone he’d been playing hurt. On June 5th, the club placed its franchise cornerstone on the IL.

There’s a conversation to be had here about Judge keeping his injury from the club for as long as he did, and the level of deference the club seemingly shows him. But that’s for another day. He returned for a hot minute late in the season before that aforementioned calf strain ended his campaign for good.  

If you’re looking for reasons to have faith that Judge can bounce back in 2027 and put together another one of his fantastic seasons, he’s still doing many of the things he does better than almost anyone on Earth. Unfortunately, he’s not doing them as well as he used to.

A couple of examples illustrate this. First, Barrel%. If he’d qualified in 2026, he would have been among baseball’s best at barreling baseballs. Compare that metric to his 2024 and 2025 seasons, however, and there was a clear dropoff – 20.9% versus 27.1% and 24.8%.

HardHit% is another metric that saw a falloff, especially compared to 2024. Though again among baseball’s best, his 57.5% was down from 58.2% in 2025 and from 61.0% in 2024.

It’s hard to know the extent to which any of Judge’s suppressed numbers (outstanding though they are) are due to him playing through a fractured bloody rib for more than a month, or from coming back and struggling for a week before his season ended. Hopefully, any and all decline was injury-related, and we get Historically Unstoppable Aaron Judge back for 2027.

Looking forward to 2027 (and beyond), there is another conversation waiting to be had about Judge’s defensive future, given how important his offensive presence is to the club. But that too is a chat for another time. As far as Judge’s 2026 goes, ultimately it was… Incomplete. And the Yankees were inarguably worse for it.

Would you have done the Sonny Gray deal?

ATLANTA, GA - MAY 16: Boston pitcher Sonny Gray (54) hugs on the dugout rail during the MLB game between the Boston Red Sox and the Atlanta Braves on May 16th, 2026 at Truist Park in Atlanta, GA. (Photo by Rich von Biberstein/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

Sonny Gray signed with the Twins for a $55 million, two-year deal that includes a full no-trade clause, and allows him to opt out after the 2027 season.

Would you, were you in charge of the Braves, have done that deal?

Gray is, at this point, a highly effective elder statesman of a starter. He turned 37 earlier this month, and has been between 3-4 fWAR in each of the last three seasons, albeit with a not-unexpected decline in pitching quality (2024-2026 featured progressive xFIP-s of 70, 75, and then 89). Though in many cases, a projection’s central estimate will reflect something along an average of the last few seasons, Gray’s age is clearly being baked in to the early Steamer release we have: Gray projects for 3.0 WAR over 29 starts (the same start total he managed in 2026).

This creates a bit of a weirdness, as I talked about when I put together those big free agency under/overvalued tables. On paper, a 3-win starter should probably get more than $55 million over two years, opt-out or whatever. But, Gray’s age seems to create a kink in terms of overall expectations, such that it, in theory and in practice, scared teams away from committing what they would to a different three-year starter born a few years later. To wit, before Gray signed, his contract forecasts/guesstimates were:

  • $25 million, one year, from Ben Clemens;
  • $52 million, two years, from the FanGraphs crowdsource; and
  • $55 million, two years (ding ding ding), from MLB Trade Rumors.

Gray clearly couldn’t leverage a third year at a similar annual rate. He did get the no-trade and the opt-out, but not that.

I think I would have made that deal without thinking too long about it. Would you?

The Phillies are reportedly interested in Jonathan Loáisiga. Are you?

PHOENIX, ARIZONA - SEPTEMBER 20: Relief pitcher Jonathan Loaisiga #43 of the Arizona Diamondbacks pitches against the New York Yankees during the eighth inning at Chase Field on September 20, 2026 in Phoenix, Arizona. The Diamondbacks defeated the Yankees 8-4. (Photo by Chris Coduto/Getty Images) | Getty Images

It was first reported over the weekend by Jon Heyman of the New York Post that the Phillies are among the teams interested in free agent reliever Jonathan Loáisiga. Matt Gelb of the Athletic confirmed their interest in a piece about the Phillies bullpen published on Tuesday.

Loáisiga, 31, spent 2025 with the Arizona Diamondbacks and enjoyed a bit of a career renaissance, as he turned in the best season of his nine-year career since 2021. The native Nicaraguan appeared in 67 games for the D-Backs and logged a 2.42 ERA across 67 innings.

It was also the first season Loáisiga, formerly of the Yankees, entered fully healthy since 2023. He first underwent surgery for a bone spur in May of that year before suffering a torn UCL that required Tommy John surgery in April of 2024 that ended his season and delayed his start to 2025. His previous best season came in 2021 with New York when Loáisiga appeared in 57 games with a 2.17 ERA and was worth 3.3 WAR. He regressed in 2022 with a 4.03 ERA and then the injuries wiped out most of the next two seasons, leaving the Yankees to decline his club option for 2026. Arizona signed him to a minor league deal for 2026, and he soon proved that he was not only healthy but effective once again, turning out to be a coup for the D-Backs.

Despite possessing fastball velocity that averages close to 98 MPH, Loáisiga doesn’t miss many bats. His strength is his ability to limit hard contact and generate groundballs with his sinker, a feat he accomplished in 2026 to the tune of a 56.4% groundball rate that was 11th best among all qualified relievers. Loáisiga won’t strike many hitters out, but he also won’t walk many either, as he has a career walk rate of 7.2% and turned in a career-best 5% mark in 2026.

The Phillies are one of many teams shopping for bullpen help this time of year, and Loáisiga is one of the better options on the market. Loáisiga isn’t widely considered a back of the bullpen option, but the Phillies don’t necessarily need that with Jhoan Duran entrenched as closer in addition to Jonathan Bowlan and Alex McFarlane in the fold. However, one thing they could use is another left-handed relief option, and that is also something Loáisiga is not, as he is right-handed. He would be a nice piece that could bring some needed depth in the Phillies bullpen, but it would leave them extremely right-handed, as Tim Mayza is currently the only left-handed reliever projected to be on the Opening Day roster.

So, are you interested in Jonathan Loáisiga? If so, what type of contract would you be willing to offer? Where do you see him fitting into the Phillies bullpen?

Mets Morning News: Skubal sweepstakes heating up

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA - OCTOBER 03: Tarik Skubal #29 of the Los Angeles Dodgers reacts against the Atlanta Braves in game one of the National League Division Series at Dodger Stadium on October 03, 2026 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Luke Hales/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Meet the Mets

The Mets are expected to be all-in on Tarik Skubal and should be among the final teams in the running but they will have competition for signing the Cy Young winner.

The Mets are interested in right-handed Japanese pitcher Kaima Taira and the two sides will have a virtual meeting soon.

Former Mets reliever Lance Broadway unexpectedly passed away at the age of 43.

Around the National League East

The Braves left a few notable prospects unprotected for the Rule 5 Draft should a draft actually happen.

The Marlins and the Players Alliance donated $62,000 in baseball equipment to two local high schools.

The Phillies made a flurry of minor league signings to bulk up the system before a potential lockout occurs.

The Nationals signed righty Hagen Danner to a minor league deal.

Around Major League Baseball

During a press conference Commissioner Rob Manfred said that the owners will not agree to any Collective Bargaining Agreement that doesn’t include a salary cap and salary floor.

The Players Union responded to Manfred’s press conference with a statement of their own accusing the owners of wage supression.

The Twins signed Sonny Gray to a two-year deal worth $55 million.

The sale of the Angels to Kroenke Sports and Entertainment is expected to close in January for $4 billion.

The Mariners acquired third baseman Maikel Garcia, James McArthur and prospect L.P Langevin from the Royals in exchange for Bryce Miller, José A. Ferrer, and Logan Evans

Former Met Frankie Montas has generated interest around the league after his last throwing session.

Yesterday at Amazin’ Avenue

The finalists were announced for this year’s AAOP.

This Date in Mets History

On this date in 1979, the Mets were for sale for the first time in its history after Joan Payson’s daughter and the team’s board of directors announced their intention to sell the team. Of course it was Nelson Doubleday and Fred Wilpon who ended up buying the team.

Free Agent Poll: Adrián Morejón

MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN - OCTOBER 03: Adrian Morejon #50 of the San Diego Padres pitches against the Milwaukee Brewers during the seventh inning in game one of the National League Division Series at American Family Field on October 03, 2026 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. (Photo by Patrick McDermott/Getty Images) | Getty Images

We have been doing this for a few years now: looking at the top free agents, using the contract Ben Clemens suggests he’ll get, and asking whether you would like the Jays to give him that contract. This year, the lockout makes it a little more complicated. Keith Law’s list is here. Ben Clemens’ is here.

Adrián Morejón is number 8 on Ben Clemens list and number 19 on Keith Law’s.

Morejón is a left-handed reliever. He’s 27, 28 at the end of February, young for a free agent.. He’s pitched eight seasons in the MLB, all for the Padres, but the first five of those he totaled just 50 games. But, in the last three, he’s pitched in 211 games, with a 2.58 ERA. In 223.1 inning he’s allowed 177 hits, 66 walks with 248 strikeouts and a 5.5 bWAR. He’s been one of the best relievers in the game.

Baseball Savant says he’s in the 99th percentile in expected ERA, 98th in Fastball Velocity and 99th in Chase Rate. He’s also been 98th in Ground Ball % and 99th in Barrel %.

His sinker averaged in 99.5 mph and his four seamer 99.3 mph last year.

Keith Law said:

By fWAR, Morejon is the best reliever available in free agency this year, producing 2.8 fWAR across 86 innings with a 2.37 FIP that put him in the top 10 among all MLB relievers in 2026. The Cuban southpaw will pitch at age 28 next year, which also makes him one of the youngest free agents available. He held left-handed batters to a .180/.234/.227 line this year, and was still effective against righties, who hit .222/.307/.302 off him. He’s mostly sinker/changeup now, as he’s shelved the curveball he used in the minors. His slider has strong “shape” characteristics that should make it effective, but hitters disagree, hitting it harder than any of his other weapons this past year. He’s lowered his arm slot about 10 degrees over the past few seasons, which could be part of why he’s stayed healthy for three seasons after elbow and shoulder injuries afflicted him for several years before that.

Clemens:

By fWAR, Morejon is the best reliever available in free agency this year, producing 2.8 fWAR across 86 innings with a 2.37 FIP that put him in the top 10 among all MLB relievers in 2026. The Cuban southpaw will pitch at age 28 next year, which also makes him one of the youngest free agents available. He held left-handed batters to a .180/.234/.227 line this year, and was still effective against righties, who hit .222/.307/.302 off him. He’s mostly sinker/changeup now, as he’s shelved the curveball he used in the minors. His slider has strong “shape” characteristics that should make it effective, but hitters disagree, hitting it harder than any of his other weapons this past year. He’s lowered his arm slot about 10 degrees over the past few seasons, which could be part of why he’s stayed healthy for three seasons after elbow and shoulder injuries afflicted him for several years before that.

Ben figures he’ll get a three-year contract at $24 million per year for a total of $72 million.

Veteran righty pitches lights-out despite injury-plagued 2026

SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA - OCTOBER 06: Nick Pivetta #27 of the San Diego Padres pitches in the first inning against the Milwaukee Brewers in game three of the National League Division Series at Petco Park on October 06, 2026 in San Diego, California. (Photo by Orlando Ramirez/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Welcome to our series grading every member of the San Diego Padres’ 40-man roster. The roster being evaluated is current as of Oct. 18, prior to the end of the World Series. Because of that, it will include players who will be free agents once the postseason concludes. Each player will be graded on their performance in the 2026 season, including the playoffs. That performance will be weighted based on how much time the player spent with the team (availability is the best ability). 

Nick Pivetta

When the Padres signed Pivetta heading into the 2025 season, he was the last solid starting pitcher left on the free agent market. No other reliable options remained. San Diego signed him to a backloaded deal in order to maintain payroll flexibility. Pivetta turned in the best season of his career, earning some down-ballot Cy Young votes. He was expected to anchor the rotation alongside Michael King in 2026.

Overall Grade: C-

Things didn’t go according to plan. Pivetta made just four starts before hitting the injured list and remaining there for almost five months. He exited a start against the Colorado Rockies early and was later diagnosed with flexor strain in his throwing elbow. He ended up making just eight starts in total for the Friars due to several setbacks during his rehab assignments.

But, when he was on the mound, it was a thing of beauty. Pivetta pitched to a 2.86 ERA in those eight starts (34.2 IP). He was even better after returning from the IL, posting a 1.45 ERA in the month of September. His overall ERA was only so high due to a rough Opening Day performance (6 ER, 3.0 IP). Removing that first outing, Pivetta holds a 1.42 ERA across 31 2/3 innings of work.

He just didn’t pitch enough. The injury concerns led the Padres to decline his $14 million club option for the 2027 season. Reportedly, the two sides are still seeking a reunion. Had the Friars picked up Pivetta’s 2027 club option, he would have acquired an $18 million player option for 2028. San Diego probably didn’t want to be on the hook for that much if Pivetta’s arm gave out a second year in a row.

Spark plug Samad Taylor set to fill out left field platoon

Welcome to our series grading every member of the San Diego Padres’ 40-man roster. The roster being evaluated is current as of Oct. 18, prior to the end of the World Series. Because of that, it will include players who will be free agents once the postseason concludes. Each player will be graded on their performance in the 2026 season, including the playoffs. That performance will be weighted based on how much time the player spent with the team (availability is the best ability). 

Samad Taylor

When Taylor was drafted in 2016, it was believed that he could develop into a contact-hitting utility player, similar to Luis Arraez or Steven Kwan. Instead, he became a minor-league journeyman. From 2016-2025, Taylor played on four different organizations. He never quite broke out onto the big-league scene, with three short stints from 2023-25. In early January, the Padres signed Taylor to a minor-league deal with a non-roster invite to Spring Training.

Overall Grade: B+

He started off hot. In the first week of Cactus League play, Taylor batted .556 with an almost impossible-seeming 1.278 OPS. He cooled down significantly after that, finishing the spring with a .233/.265/.300 slash line. That led to Taylor missing the Opening Day roster and spending some time in Triple-A El Paso. He played quite well in the minors, slashing .307/.397/.482 with 19 extra-base hits.

That production (along with left fielder Ramón Laureano’s season-ending hip surgery) earned Taylor a call up to the big leagues. At the time, the Padres were floundering. They had just gone 13-15 in the month of May on the backs of a lackluster offense. Taylor batted .329 in the month of June, sparking the offense to life. He then missed time due to an oblique strain before returning down the stretch. He was just as good after returning, posting a .297 batting average through the end of the season.

Perhaps the biggest question surrounding Taylor is sustainability. His expected batting average (.256) is a good deal lower than his actual (.316). That’s likely due to his reliance on speed. Taylor ranks in the 93rd percentile in sprint speed. Jase Bowen is the only player on the Padres’ 40-man roster faster than Taylor. If he can utilize those tools again in 2027, he will certainly provide value for San Diego.

The Day Nolan Ryan Changed Astros History: 47 Years Later

When Nolan Ryan signed with Houston they landed more than a pitcher, they got a living legend who rewrote the team’s DNA. The news rippled through the baseball world fast on November 19th, 1979. Nolan Ryan had agreed to a 4-year deal, paying $4.5 million, becoming baseball’s first million-dollar man.   

47 years later, family and teammates alike, reflect on that moment with us exclusively at The Crawfish Boxes.   

Reid Ryan 

“I was at our home in Alvin. Dad was going back and forth between the Yankees and Astros. We all wanted him to stay in Houston. When it happened and was announced, we were all so pumped. I was only 8 years old and remember it vividly.”    

Ken Forsch 

“I just remember thinking with Nolan’s addition to our staff that we immediately had a chance to become a World Series contender.”     

Art Howe 

“Nolan was the most sought-after pitcher in the game of baseball. When we acquired him, it felt like we were actually going to win! (laughs) That was such a wonderful feeling, it was hard to even calibrate the excitement that next season in the clubhouse.”

Enos Cabell 

“I couldn’t believe that they spent that much money. Previously, we were owned by a credit company; we didn’t really have an owner before, but it happened because of John McMullen. We already had a good team in 1979 so when we got Nolan, I didn’t think anyone was going to beat us. We had six really good starters. If Cesar Cedeno doesn’t break his angle in game three, we go to the World Series that first year with Nolan but things happen.”

325 days after the initial signing, the dream would be realized when Nolan Ryan took the mound at Veterans Stadium in Game Two of the NLCS October 8th, 1980. Ryan would strike out six over 6.1 innings as the Astros evened up their series. Ryan’s sharpest inning of the evening would be the 6th when he struck out Greg Luzinkski and Garry Maddox. In the 7th, Ryan would draw a two out walk, eventually tying the score after Terry Puhl’s double.      

That night served as only a springboard for Ryan. He’d win 106 games in Houston, appearing in a pair of All-Star Games, while also tossing a no hitter against the Dodgers which cemented his legacy forever.