Friday Rockpile: The legacy of Wade Davis and his impact on the Rockies

WASHINGTON, DC - JULY 25: Wade Davis #71 of the Colorado Rockies pitches during a baseball game against the Washington Nationals at Nationals Park on July 25, 2019 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Mitchell Layton/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Dating back to 1871, over 23,000 people have played Major League Baseball. Of those, 281 players have been granted admission to the Baseball Hall of Fame (354 total people, including managers, pioneers, executives and umpires).

It’s an elite group that includes Rockies legends Larry Walker and Todd Helton, who both were honored with statues outside of Coors Field this season. Jim Leyland, who managed the Rockies in 2024, was also elected in 2024 with Helton.

The next likely candidate with a chance to get 75% of the vote is eight-time All-Star Nolan Arenado, but it will be five years after his playing days end before he is eligible.

But there’s another former Rockie on this year’s ballot who deserves some praise.

Wade Davis, a three-time All-Star reliever, was a member of the “super bullpen” the Rockies brought in before the 2018 season. The infamous trio didn’t live up to its billing, but Davis still had a tremendous career that’s worth recognizing.

Earlier this week, Davis was named as one of 14 new players added to the ballot for the HOF class of 2027. The list is highlighted by catcher Buster Posey and pitcher Jon Lestor, but doesn’t include any runaway first-ballot inductees. They will join 13 holdovers from previous years, including Chase Utley, who earned 59.1% of the vote last year.

Although he was eligible, former Rockie outfielder Dexter Fowler was left off the ballot. He’s certainly worth an honorable mention here, as he was a fan favorite, and he remains the Rockies single-season leader in triples (15 in 2011). Journeyman catcher Jonathan Lucroy, who played with the Rockies in 2017, had a distinguished 12-year career with nine teams, but also didn’t make the cut, despite being eligible.

The Baseball Writers’ Association of America will fill out their ballots between now and Dec. 31, and the results will be announced on Jan. 19. The Hall of Fame Induction Weekend is slated for July 23-26.

As for Davis, he was a shutdown pitcher from 2009-2017. With four years on the Tampa Bay Rays, four more with the Kansas City Royals, and another with the Chicago Cubs, the righty posted a 12.2 rWAR. In 393 appearances, including 88 starts, he posted a 3.45 ERA with two complete games, 79 saves, 768 strikeouts and a 59-39 record.

Davis was a starter for his first three MLB seasons with Tampa Bay and then transitioned mostly to reliever in 2012, his last year as a Ray. That season, he made 54 appearances out of the bullpen, posting a 2.43 ERA in 70.1 innings. After All-Star nods for three straight years (2015-2017) and winning a World Series with the Royals in 2015, Davis established himself as one of the most dominant relievers in the game.

In December of 2017, the Rockies signed Davis to a three-year, $52 million deal. Fellow relievers Bryan Shaw and Jake McGee each signed three-year, $27 million deals to make up the hope-inspiring super reliever trio that ended up being a bust.

The acquisitions were a sign that Dick Monfort & Co. wanted to build off their first playoff appearance and construct a serious contender. Greg Holland posted 41 saves and was a significant part of the team’s 87-75 record, but he opted for free agency after the Rockies lost to Arizona in the one-game NL Wild Card series.

Enter Davis, who very much did earn his paycheck in 2018.

He recorded 43 saves, a Rockies single-season record that still stands. His 43rd save, which was also a career-high, came on Sept. 28 against the Washington Nationals that clinched a playoff berth for the Rockies. Davis did it by striking out Bryce Harper — looking.

Davis, 32 at the time and wielding an arsenal largely consisting of a four-seamer, cutter and knuckle curve, ended his first season in Colorado with a 0.9 rWAR, a 4.13 ERA, a 29.9% strikeout rate and a 10% walk rate in 63 appearances.

Things went downhill in 2019. He missed about three weeks over May and June with an oblique strain, but before that Davis posted a 2.45 ERA in 14.1 innings. He returned on June 7 and notched a 10.45 ERA in the month to bring his season total to 5.76.

And it just kept getting worse. By the end of the season, Davis’ ERA more than doubled to 8.65, and his rWAR dropped to -1.5. His strikeout rate nearly dropped by a third to 20.4%, and his walk rate increased 4%.

Then came the COVID-shortened season of 2020. In five appearances over 4.1 innings, he surrendered 10 runs with three homers, three walks, and three strikeouts. He threw 2.2 innings before he moved to the IL with a right shoulder strain on Aug. 2. He came back in mid-September, tossed 1.2 innings, giving up five runs — and that was the end for Davis. He was designated for assignment on Sept. 19 and released on Sept. 21.

Davis signed a minor league deal with Kansas City, returning home for his last season, which was filled with injuries, but at least his 6.75 ERA in 40 appearances in 2021 was an improvement from his 20.77 ERA in five in Colorado in 2020.

While his career dropped off and his time in Colorado certainly hurt his Hall of Fame qualifications, Davis was still a very good baseball player. Unfortunately, he also joined a list of pitchers who sign with Colorado only to see their careers nosedive. It has left a legacy that has tempered the Rockies willingness to sign pitchers to expensive deals and, seemingly, made more pitchers hesitant to come to Colorado.

Hopefully, Thursday’s trade with the Chicago White Sox to acquire RHPs Luis Castillo and Davis Martin shows the end of the “super bullpen” fallout. After all, Colorado is now a very different organization than it was in 2019 and 2020. It is led by a new front office, a new coaching staff, especially on the pitching side, an actual analytics team that uses advanced equipment and technology, a performance lab, and support staff that includes a performance dietitian. Perhaps Davis’ story would have played out differently if he had those resources and staff to help him. Of course, we’ll never know, but it’s interesting to consider.

The Rockies are putting in the infrastructure to support players in the modern game, while also trying to help pitchers combat the challenges of going back and forth to play in the Mile High City. Those are things Davis didn’t have. It’s still no easy task to pitch for the Rockies. But —  just maybe — that’s a narrative that can change.


Join the conversation!

Sign up for a user account and get:

  • Fewer ads
  • Create community posts
  • Comment on articles, community posts
  • Rec comments, community posts
  • New, improved notifications system!

Download the SB Nation app on iOS or Android. 


Please keep in mind our Purple Row Community Guidelines when you’re commenting. Thanks!

One-game Cubs, 2026

Owen Miller | | Getty Images

This is going to be an unusual article.

Why? Because usually, there are one or two guys who appear for the Cubs in only one game in any specific season, perhaps a couple more. From 2022-23, there were five total (four in 2022, one in 2023). In 2024, there were just two (though one, Gavin Hollowell, has appeared in more games since for the Cubs). Going back a bit farther, in the entire decade of the 2010s there were just six — and just nine in the 40 seasons from 1970-2009.

Last year, there were none.

So let’s lift a glass to the one-game Cub Class of 2026, which has EIGHT members! And an honorable mention to Vince Velasquez, who looked like he would join that club with his single appearance in April, only to be recalled one more time to throw in a blowout win over the Brewers in June.

Of the eight, only one (Luke Little) was originally drafted and signed by the Cubs organization and only one (Braxton Garrett) will have any impact on the team going forward.

The reason all this happened should be pretty obvious: The failure of Jed Hoyer to assemble a proper bullpen. In addition to that, multiple pitching injuries meant juggling the waiver wire and 40-man rosters all season. All this led to a franchise record 39 pitchers being used in 2026 (not counting three appearances on the mound by catcher Carson Kelly).

Here are the eight one-game Cubs of 2026, in chronological order of appearance.

Charlie Barnes, April 13

Barnes had pitched briefly for the Twins in 2021, then spent four years in KBO in Korea before the Cubs signed him to a minor-league deal in January. They added him to the 40-man and active rosters April 12 when Phil Maton went on one of his multiple IL stints.

The next day, Barnes entered a game the Cubs were losing 9-2 to the Phillies in the sixth. He quickly made it 12-2 in that inning, then the Phillies scored off him again in the seventh. The Cubs pushed across five runs in the eighth to make it sort of a game, but with the Cubs short of pitchers, Barnes threw the eighth, where he retired the Phillies in order. Here he is getting J.T. Realmuto on a fly to center [VIDEO].

Barnes was optioned to Triple-A Iowa the next day. He was recalled again April 26, but did not appear in a game before being optioned back the next day. On May 13 the Dodgers claimed him on waivers and he made four appearances for them, three of which were scoreless. In the other one he allowed seven runs in seven innings to the A’s, including three home runs. The Dodgers released and re-claimed him three times in July and August. He’s now a free agent again.

Barnes might very well qualify for a postseason share from both the Cubs and Dodgers this year.

Luke Little, April 15

Little, a well-liked guy by players and fans alike, had talent. Could throw hard. Just couldn’t throw strikes. If he could have harnessed the fastball he might be a closer by now. But he couldn’t.

His one 2026 appearance was pitching the ninth inning of a game the Cubs won 11-2 over the Phillies. And he didn’t walk anyone! He did, however, serve up a home run to Bryce Harper [VIDEO].

Little was sent back to Iowa, where he walked so many guys (23 in 23.1 innings) that he was demoted to Double-A Knoxville, where he again had a high walk rate. He was claimed off waivers by the Royals Aug. 6, where he … walked a lot of guys (12 in 11.1 innings). He’s now a free agent. I wish him the best.

Yacksel Rios, April 26

The Cubs signed Rios to a minor-league deal January 26, with a Spring Training invite… then he missed pretty much all of spring camp as part of the Puerto Rico World Baseball Classic team. He pitched in three WBC games, throwing 3.2 innings, allowing one unearned run and striking out five.

Returning to the Cubs organization, he pitched at Iowa in early April and then was added to the 40-man roster April 26, same day as Barnes was added.

Rios pitched in the game that day against the Dodgers, throwing 1.2 scoreless innings. Here he is striking out Teoscar Hernández on a 97 mile per hour sinker [VIDEO].

Rios was designated for assignment May 3, sent outright to Iowa May 6, and released June 1 to pitch in Korea.

Ty Blach, May 18

Blach was once a pretty good prospect in the Giants organization and had a couple of fifth-starter type years for them in 2017 and 2018. After that he bounced around to the Orioles, Rockies and Rangers organizations before the Cubs signed him to a minor-league deal April 14.

Added to the active roster May 17, he pitched the last three innings of a 9-3 blowout loss to the Brewers the next day, allowing just one hit. Here he is striking out Brice Turang [VIDEO].

Blach was DFA’d the next day, re-signed a minor league deal with the Cubs and made a few appearances at Iowa before he was released Aug. 1.

Andrew Wantz, July 28

Wantz had a couple of decent relief years for the Angels between 2021 and 2023, but missed most of 2024 and 2025 with elbow issues, for which he was reported to have had a “procedure” that was not Tommy John surgery.

The Rays picked him up for 2026 and he made one appearance for them in late May before they let him go. The Cubs signed him to a minor-league deal June 6 and he made 14 appearances (nine starts) for Iowa before being added to the active roster when the team let Jameson Taillon go.

Wantz pitched the last two innings of a 10-2 blowout win over the Cardinals, allowing one run. Here’s the ground out he got from Jimmy Crooks to end that game [VIDEO].

Wantz was DFA’d the next day, re-signed a minor-league deal with the Cubs Aug. 6 and made several more appearances for Iowa through the end of the season. He’s currently a free agent.

Antoine Kelly, July 31

Kelly, a Chicago-area native (Maine East High School) was originally drafted by the Brewers out of Wabash Valley Junior College in 2019. He spent time in the Brewers, Rockies, Rangers and Dodgers organizations before the Cubs acquired him for cash considerations June 7. He pitched in 13 games at Iowa before being called up July 31. He appeared in that day’s game against the Yankees, and actually pitched in a fairly high-leverage situation: Two runners on and two out in the top of the eighth with the Cubs trailing 2-0.

Kelly struck out Ben Rice on a slider to end the inning [VIDEO].

Kelly was optioned back to Iowa two days later and finished the year there. He was let go at the end of the season and signed a minor-league deal with the Guardians with a Spring Training invitation.

Owen Miller, Aug. 17

Miller had played reasonably well as a backup infielder for Cleveland and Milwaukee from 2021-23. But by 2026 he was one of those “break glass in case of emergency” infielders, and that’s why the Cubs signed him to a minor-league deal before Spring Training.

He was called up Aug. 17 when James Triantos was returned to Iowa.

This is perhaps the shortest of all of these one-game appearances. In the ninth inning of this game against the White Sox, with the Cubs trailing 5-4, Tyrone Taylor was sent in to run for Alex Bregman. Taylor eventually scored the tying run, but the game went to extras. At that point, Pedro Ramirez moved from second base to third base and Miller took over at second in the top of the 10th.

Miller was not involved in any plays in that 10th inning, but you can see him running in the background as this inning-ending ground ball was handled by Jacob Webb and Michael Busch [VIDEO].

That’s it. That’s Owen Miller’s Cubs career, one inning of defense. And even though there’s no real video available of Miller, that’s a photo of him at the top of this post, standing in position at Wrigley Field during that inning.

That was the game PCA won with a leadoff homer in the bottom of the 10th.

Miller was DFA’d on Aug. 21, outrighted to Iowa Aug. 24, and was granted free agency on Oct. 5. If nothing else, he’s a good Immaculate Grid answer.

Braxton Garrett, Sept. 27

Here’s the one guy among these eight who will likely have a large impact on the Cubs going forward. They acquired him from the Marlins by trade at the deadline for Jonathon Long and Jace Beck, and knew at the time he probably wouldn’t contribute much, if at all, in 2026 due to recovery from Tommy John surgery.

The Cubs activated Garrett for the last game of the season against the Red Sox and he threw five really good innings, allowing three hits and one run and striking out two. Here’s one of those K’s, of Ceddanne Rafaela, on a nasty slider [VIDEO].

Garrett had a really good year as a starter in Miami in 2023, posting a 3.66 ERA and 1.146 WHIP, with 4.3 bWAR in 31 appearances (30 starts). Yes, it’s four years and one TJS later, but if he can recover that form the Cubs might have a pretty good starter in 2027.

Mariners News: Luis Castillo, Darwinzon Hernández, and Jonathan Loáisiga

CHICAGO, ILLINOIS - SEPTEMBER 20: Luis Castillo #58 of the Chicago White Sox delivers a pitch against the Detroit Tigers at Rate Field on September 20, 2026 in Chicago, Illinois. (Photo by Jayden Mack/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Good morning friends and happy Friday!

The free agent market continues to hum along as we approach the likely lockout. Here’s everything you may have missed from yesterday.

In Mariners news…

  • If you want more analysis from the Mariners’ acquisition of third baseman Maikel García, we’ve got a pair of Meet at the Mitt episodes for you. In the first, Kate and Evan briefly talked with Jeremy Greco of Royals Review to break it down from both sides (Apple link, Spotify link). Then, Kate, Evan, John, and Max took a deeper dive into the swap between the M’s and Royals (Apple link, Spotify link).
  • Patrick Dubuque at Baseball Prospectus provided his two cents on the big deal for the Mariners. ($)

Around the league…

Anders’ pick…

  • Public transportation afficionados, feast yer eyes.

2026 Royals season in review: Bobby Witt Jr.

Sep 22, 2026; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Kansas City Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. (7) reaches for a throw at second base during the first inning against the Chicago White Sox at Kauffman Stadium. Mandatory Credit: William Purnell-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

2026 was a good year for Royals superstar Bobby Witt Jr. The 26-year-old shortstop maybe didn’t play up to his best, but even in a “down” year for him, it’s still a career year for others.

Witt missed some time with some low back tightness from July 22 to August 4, resulting in him playing a career-low 143 games as a big leaguer. However, he still slashed .281/.359/.441, smacking 33 doubles, a triple (career low), 18 homers (career low), and 54 RBI, a career low. However, he had a career high 67 walks, while striking out 109 times. He stole 45 bases. All that makes up a 6.7 WAR season for the phenom. He won his third Silver Slugger Award.

Witt really struggled in the month of July, hitting just .196/.250/.286, which you know was because of the back tightness, because he hit at least .264 every other month. Defensively, Witt was a stud, I don’t know how he wasn’t a Gold Glove winner. But he had 10 errors, which ties his career-low in the category. He posted an absurd 24 Outs Above Average. His range on Baseball Savant was listed in the 100th percentile. His arm strength is well above average as well. His defensive run value number was +17, the second best of his career. He is a wizard out there.

Bobby Baseball made his third consecutive All-Star appearance and was named to the All-MLB First Team for the third time this season as well.

It was obviously another great season for Witt, so am I off base for saying I thought it was a down year for him? It could be as simple as me holding him to a very high standard, because of what he did in 2024. But it felt like in some of the bigger moments this season, Witt didn’t come through which was odd to see. Clearly, everyone doesn’t always come through – they are humans after all – but it felt like more times than not, at least early in the season, Witt failed to come through at the plate in the clutch.

Some of my thoughts are backed up statistically, as you can see above with some career low numbers this past season for Witt. And again, as I mentioned above, a “down” year for him is a great year or even a career year for many other ballplayers. That’s why my judgement might be a little off, with me holding him to too high of a standard.

When looking at the Baseball Reference page for Witt and his splits, in what they categorize as “Clutch Stats” his worse attempts came with 2 outs and runners in scoring position, where he hit a measly .212. In every other clutch situation, he hit at least .250. In their leverage category, he hit .265 in high leverage spots, .285 in medium and .284 in low leverage.

So again, if you say I’m off base in my assessment of Witt, that’s fine. But again, to clarify, he had a GREAT season. It just felt like a down year for him personally. Anyways, here are some of his best moments at the plate this season.

What do you think of Bobby Witt Jr.’s 2026 season? I give him an A.

Yankees 2026 Roster Report Cards: George Lombard Jr.

NEW YORK, NY - SEPTEMBER 30: George Lombard Jr. #96 of the New York Yankees looks on from the on deck circle during the game against the Boston Red Sox at Yankee Stadium on September 30, 2026 in New York, New York. (Photo by New York Yankees/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Few positions, or the players manning them, have been debated as intensely as shortstop for the New York Yankees over the last several seasons. Heading into 2026, many fans hoped the club would find a way to move on from the Anthony Volpe experience. However, the club made no external moves and started the season with José Caballero slotted in at the position as the team waited for a rehabbing Volpe to return.

Along the way, injuries and performance, both struggles by the incumbents and red-hot play in the minors, led the Yankees to hand the reins at shortstop over to 21-year-old George Lombard Jr. The rookie would spend August, September, and October at shortstop for the Yankees in what really is the throne of NYC. 

In terms of how it went, the staff here at PSA averaged out to a B-minus. In academic speak, that would mean Lombard understood the core material and performed above average, but did not master the assignment.

Grade: B-

2026 Stats: 42 G, 166 PA, 23 R, 36 H, 4 2B, 1 3B, 7 HR, 22 RBI, 2 SB, .237/.285/.414, 92 OPS+, 93 wRC+, 0.4 fWAR, 1.1 bWAR.

2027 Contract Status: Pre-arbitration eligible.

Before reaching the show, Lombard was on an absolute tear in the minors. Starting the season in Double-A, he hit .312 with a .971 OPS in 20 games, which earned him a ticket to Scranton. Lombard’s season looked like it might be coming off the rails after an adjustment period, and then he sprained two fingers, which sidelined him for a month and caused him to miss the MLB Futures Game. However, he came back in mid-July and forced the Yankees’ hand right before the Trade Deadline, going on a 14-game heater to the tune of a .377 average, .477 OBP, and 1.081 OPS.

On August 4th, after surviving the Trade Deadline himself, and with the Yankees not acquiring an outside option at shortstop, the club called Lombard up to the show. The kid finished the minor league season slashing .284/.411/.498 with 12 home runs. This performance led Baseball America to name him the Yankees’ Minor League Player of the Year for 2026.

Lombard’s 2026 season at the professional level, and the basis for our grading, really is a story of three parts. The first was a euphoric honeymoon stage. Lombard committed just one error in his first 14 games and racked up eight Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) in his first 100 innings, looking like a potential Platinum Glove winner. This all came as he homered in his first pro at-bat and slashed .320/.393/.560 with a .953 OPS across his first 25 at-bats. It was too good to be true.

After the rise came the fall, as Lombard slumped with the glove and bat. In late August, Lombard made the wrong kind of history, committing an error in six straight games and tying a 105-year-old franchise record. With the stick, big league pitchers started getting him to chase and roll over breaking balls, causing his average to sink to .217 by mid-September. The vibes from some fans really went from “next” to “next Volpe.”

To the kid’s credit, he righted the ship down the stretch and saved himself in the third act. From September 9th through the end of the regular season, Lombard’s defense stabilized to league average, and he hit five home runs in his final 16 games. He carried that confidence into the postseason, going 3-for-4 in the Wild Card opener against Boston and finishing October batting .333 (6-for-18), albeit with an error in the ALDS.

I’ll save the hype train for future preview articles. However, despite only having an 86 mph average exit velocity, Lombard finished the season pacing for 27 home runs over 162 games. There’s also a lot of room for growth, as Lombard had a 17.3 percent walk rate at Triple-A and only a six percent rate in the majors through his first 42 games, or essentially a quarter of a season. The defense, especially when playing beside a big league-quality third baseman, was fine for someone who was just a few months into being able to buy an adult beverage.

Lombard’s minor league season was an A+, while his rookie season comes in at a B-. With some growing pains behind us and a few more likely ahead, here’s to hoping Lombard can continue to improve and develop into a difference-maker. What grade would you circle in red for Lombard’s 2026 season, and what do you predict he’s produce next season?


See more of the Yankees Roster Report Card series here.

Elephant Rumblings: Offseason Market Heating Up, Non-Tender Deadline Looms

Jul 18, 2026; West Sacramento, California, USA; Athletics pitcher Luis Medina (46) and catcher Shea Langeliers (23) congratulate each other after their win against the Washington Nationals at Sutter Health Park. Mandatory Credit: Dennis Lee-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Rise and shine A’s fans! Happy Friday.

There was a flurry of activity this week, beginning with Tuesday afternoon’s deadline to protect players from the 2026 Rule 5 Draft.

Free-agent right-handed pitchers Sonny Gray and Dustin May signed new contracts with the Minnesota Twins and Chicago White Sox, respectively.

Additionally, two major trades took place. On Wednesday, the Seattle Mariners sent right-handed pitcher Bryce Miller and two other pitchers to the Kansas City Royals in exchange for third baseman Maikel Garcia and two pitchers. On Thursday, the Colorado Rockies acquired right-handers Davis Martin and Luis Castillo from the Chicago White Sox in exchange for two minor league players.

All of these transactions signal that the offseason market is steadily progressing. However, things could soon come to a halt because of the looming lockout. Some players will likely wait until a new labor agreement is reached before deciding on their next career moves.

According to ESPN reporter Buster Olney’s intel, several players from the top-tier free-agent group, including pitchers Tarik Skubal, Freddy Peralta, Michael King, along with outfielder Randy Arozarena, will secure new deals before the league’s offseason activity comes to a halt.

That doesn’t concern the Athletics, who typically do not compete at this level of free agency. So far, the A’s have focused primarily on organizational depth, signing players with question marks, such as Joey Wiemer and Luke Little, to minor league deals. President of Baseball Operations Taylor Smith and general manager Cam Castro have yet to make their first major transaction in their new roles.

Today, the A’s front office duo will be busy evaluating which players to tender contracts before this evening’s non-tender deadline for arbitration-eligible players. The A’s are expected to tender contracts to the following arbitration- eligible players: pitchers Luis Medina and Hogan Harris, catcher Shea Langeliers and infielder Zack Gelof.

Last offseason, the A’s non-tendered JJ Bleday, who went on to sign with the Cincinnati Reds and earn regular playing time. Which players should the Green and Gold non-tender today? And how should they approach free agency with only a limited amount of time remaining before the lockout?

A’s Coverage:

MLB News & Interest:

Best of X

What sort of trade package would it take for the Athletics to deal their starting catcher, Shea Langeliers?

Crazy! Are there any GTA players in this community?

Do you agree with this person’s opinion? Is there anything that commissioner Rob Manfred can do to salvage his legacy before he retires?

What do you think about this hypothetical trade?

The Washington Nationals will have a competition for the backup catcher spot

DETROIT, MI - SEPTEMBER 23: Harry Ford #17 of the Washington Nationals bats against the Detroit Tigers during the fifth inning at Comerica Park on September 23, 2026 in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo by Duane Burleson/Getty Images) | Getty Images

One piece of news from about a week ago that slid under the radar was that the Nats are going to have an open competition for the backup catcher job. That was something that Spencer Nusbaum reported coming out of the GM meetings. Dylan Crews and CJ Abrams trade rumors took up more oxygen, but this is an interesting development to me.

Before this, I had assumed that the Nats would roll with Keibert Ruiz and Harry Ford as the catching tandem. Ford was not particularly impressive, but he got on base at a solid clip and has plenty of pedigree. He was also a big trade target for Paul Toboni last offseason. I figured that Ford would get another shot.

When push comes to shove, I think Ford will end up with the backup catcher job, but it is clear that it will not be handed to him. Having a competition is a good idea in my opinion. It forces Ford and the other catchers to be at the top of their game entering Spring Training. 

This also sends a clear message to Ford that last season was not good enough. While plenty of Nats hitters broke out in 2026, Ford took a step back. After hitting .283 with an .868 OPS in Triple-A last year, Ford only hit .223 with a .705 OPS in his second stint at the level. Obviously, it is not a good sign to regress while repeating a level.

His power took a major step back in 2026, to the point where I wonder how healthy he was. There were rumblings about a shoulder injury, but he never missed any serious time. While his numbers in AAA were unimpressive, it is worth pointing out they got better each month. That, along with his pedigree is why he got a shot in the second half.

In the big leagues, Ford was not an absolute disaster, but he was not great either. His .190 batting average was terrible, but he made up for that with a solid .314 on base percentage. Ford’s ability to draw walks and work the count is his best attribute. He also showed some real flashes, with a big home run in Sacramento giving fans a strong first impression.

However, the final product was lackluster. A .664 OPS with slightly below average defense is just not good enough. Even still, I think he is the favorite to win the backup job. That is due to him not having much competition. The two primary candidates to take his job are Drew Millas and Maxwell Romero Jr., both of whom have some serious flaws.

Millas was the backup in the first half of the season, but was not very good. While he put up strong framing metrics, he was an absolute zero with the bat and his blocking was suspect. Even for a backup catcher, a .539 OPS is not good enough.

He has also suffered from lingering finger injuries that have ended his season early each of the past two years. That lack of durability is becoming a concern for Millas. While he is your traditional defense first backup catcher, Ford has a lot more upside.

The last option is a bit of a wild card, and that is Maxwell Romero, who had a breakout year in the minors last season. Before last year, Romero just seemed like an irrelevant career minor leaguer. However, Paul Toboni and the new hitting department took his game to a new level.

In 96 games between AA and AAA, the 25 year old posted an .879 OPS and hit 23 homers. Romero is your classic three true outcome hitter. He has big time power and a good eye, but he strikes out a ton. Romero hits the ball very hard at great angles, but it is tough to live with a 35% K rate.

The Nats clearly have some skepticism because they did not protect him from the Rule 5 Draft. There is a strong chance the draft does not happen due to the lockout, but unlike some other Nats prospects, Romero was left exposed. However, I think there is a path to him being a solid backup catcher who can run into homers and play competent defense behind the plate.

In my opinion, Romero is the most compelling candidate to displace Ford. However, the fact he was not protected tells me he is the third guy in this race. Eventually, Ford will win the job in my opinion, but I think it is good to push him after a rough year. The Nats need more from Ford and this competition could be the perfect wake up call for him.

MLB, MLBPA both vow ‘no compromise’ on salary cap/floor

ATLANTA, GA - MAY 13: A locked padlock and chain against two official MLB baseballs representing a potential lockout between Major League Baseball (MLB) and the Major League Baseball Players Association (MLBPA) for the 2027 MLB season, as photographed on May 13, 2026 in Atlanta, GA. (Photo by David J. Griffin/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

At the completion of the Owners’ Meetings in New York on Wednesday, MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred appeared before the media to make a statement and take questions. He took the hardest line so far regarding the owners’ stance on a salary cap and floor as the basis for a new Collective Bargaining Agreement with the MLBPA. Citing the overwhelming support of their fans, Manfred stated that the lack of competitve balance is the only priority and there is room for a lot of compromise between the two sides but there will be no compromise on the cap and floor.

Claiming that the entirety of the business done in the meetings this time was regarding the labor situation, the commissioner reiterated that the owner’s prevailing priority is establishing a salary cap and floor. There was a lot of rhetoric regarding how bad the other side is for their unwillingness to bargain.

While claiming to represent the fans in these negotiations, the owners are trying to sway fan support to their side. The pending lockout is another device used to ramp up pressure on the MLBPA. Using pressure from a lockout and the fans is designed to force the MLBPA to serious negotiations, which they claim has not occurred so far.

On the other side, Bruce Meyer, interim executive director of the MLBPA, issued a response.

“There can be no clearer example of the league’s lack of seriousness than their insistence that they will not negotiate over the economics outside of a radical change to the system that would dramatically reduce overall player compensation for all categories of players and strip fundamental rights from players like the ability to have truly guaranteed contracts,” Meyer said.

“There should be no illusions about the owners’ true motivations in pushing for this system. They want to make more money in profits and franchise values by artificially suppressing player salaries,” Meyer added.

The two sides have been negotiating since May and the rhetoric seems to indicate that no progress has been made. These posturing tactics are not unusual in a situation like this, where labor and management are on opposite sides of a big contract negotiation. The commissioner’s job is to represent the needs and desires of the owners. The MLBPA is the voice of the players.

The problem is that they both claim to represent the best interests of the game and the fans.

Neither is true.

We don’t have a seat at this table. Millionaires and billionaires are fighting over their profits. There is no voice protecting the game or the fans.

It remains to be seen if the two sides are devoted enough to their stances to sacrifice games or the goodwill of the fans.


Padres News:

  • Samad Taylor provided energy and enthusiasm when San Diego needed it most. After spending much of the season in the minors he was called up to the big leagues and made an instant impact and Lincoln Zdunich of Gaslamp Ball put a grade on Taylor’s contributions.
  • The Padres have not yet made the big addition to the roster that shows they are “all-in” but Cheri Bell of Gaslamp Ball takes a look at a couple of minor additions which were necessary to protect these players from the Rule 5 Draft.

Baseball News:

Yankees sign Jonathan Loáisiga to two-year deal

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - OCTOBER 01: Jonathan Loaisiga #43 of the New York Yankees reacts after striking out Wander Franco #5 of the Tampa Bay Rays with the bases loaded to end the top of the seventh inning at Yankee Stadium on October 01, 2021 in New York City. (Photo by Mike Stobe/Getty Images) | Getty Images

So far this winter, the bullpen has been a clear priority for the Yankees, who saw no fewer than four important relievers from the 2026 season become free agents. After re-signing Tim Hill and bringing back David Bednar on the qualifying offer, the team has now made its third addition to the bullpen, coming to terms with old friend Jonathan Loáisiga on a two-year deal with a team option for 2029.

Canal 4 News in Loáisiga’s native Nicaragua had the news late last night, the man himself hinted at it with a picture of the NYC skyline on his Instagram story, and Jorge Castillo of ESPN confirmed it this morning. MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand reported the total outlay of the contract as $18 million across the two years and buyout.

Yankees fans are, of course, very familiar with the man nicknamed Johnny Lasagna. Signed as a minor-league free agent in 2016 after a couple years in the Giants’ organization, Loáisiga spent parts of eight seasons with the big league club, and served as the bullpen’s ace fireman/setup man in 2021 and the second half of 2022. Injuries and ineffectiveness plagued the right-hander for the next three seasons, however, and after a lackluster 2025, the Bombers declined his team option for 2026.

It turned out to be the best thing for him. After sitting on the market for most of the winter, Loáisiga signed a minor-league free agent deal with the Diamondbacks last January. He made the team out of spring training, stayed healthy for a full season for the first time in five years, and put together one of the best seasons of his career, posting a 2.42 ERA in 67 innings. Perhaps more importantly, his advanced metrics were some of the best of his career, and helps explain why there were so many suitors for the recently-turned 32-year-old (the Mets, Phillies, Dodgers, and Blue Jays were all reportedly in on him).

Despite the small time apart, though, Loáisiga is not exactly the same pitcher who Yankee fans remember. Gone are the days where he threw the sinker like Mariano Rivera threw the cutter, i.e., pretty much every pitch. Although it’s still his main offering (he threw it 35 percent of the time last year), that is a far cry from the 54-to-69-percent usage rates from his first Yankees stint; in its stead, he’s upped his changeup, fastball, and cutter.

While nobody would ever consider Loáisiga a strikeout pitcher, these changes oversaw a slight bump in strikeout percentage to 18.4 percent from his 16.6-percent rate between 2022-24 and a slight drop in walk rate to a career-best 5.0 percent, all without sacrificing ground-ball rate. The question will just be how his body holds up after an actual full, healthy season.

Even with Loáisiga, Hill, and Bednar back in the fold, the Yankees are probably not yet done looking at bullpen arms — assuming they ever truly feel like they have enough bullpen arms. At this point, though, the Yankees have successfully turned it from a “need” to a “want,” as they’re no longer so thin out there that Yerry De los Santos and Angel Chivilli were listed as two of the team’s higher-leverage relief arms on the FanGraphs Depth Chart.

One could, of course, absolutely still argue that they still need a big swing-and-miss arm in the ’pen, as they’re still lacking in that regard and not everyone should be a pitch-to-contact guy. As we wait for the league to come to a screeching halt in 10 days due to the owners’ insistence on a lockout, getting some things crossed off the winter to-do list is certainly not a bad thing, and Loáisiga checks another box.

Diamondbacks off season thoughts, Castillo trade, and more!

PHILADELPHIA, PA - JULY 14: Mascot Dinger of the Colorado Rockies walks the carpet during the 2026 All-Star Red Carpet Show presented by Mastercard at Independence Mall on Tuesday, July 14, 2026 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Mary DeCicco/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images

Diamondbacks News

(Arizona Sports) Nolan Arenado assured Diamondbacks he could win a Gold Glove at first base, GM says

“We agreed to talk through the offseason about what that could look like, and he assured me he would win a Gold Glove if he played first,” Hazen told Arizona Sports’ Burns & Gambo on Friday. “I don’t doubt that. So I just really appreciate that level of — that’s who he is as a guy. That’s who he is as a teammate, and we’re fortunate to have people like that on our team, and I respect that.”

(SI.com) Marte, Free Agency, Pitching: 3 D-backs Thoughts as December Deadline Looms

The problem is a Marte trade feels central to any other additions, and a deal feels more inevitable. Meaning, the Diamondbacks would be wise to get a deal done before making other moves, allowing them to free up payroll and get a clearer picture of their roster.

Arizona is reportedly asking a high price for Marte, but may have to compromise.

It seems more likely than not they’ll have to accept a deal that does not stand out as an elite return, and unless they land major league talent, the trade will both look underwhelming to fans and be relatively inconsequential to their actual 2027 contention.

(Arizona Sports) GTA VI is out after 13 years: What were Arizona sports teams doing when GTA V released?

The Diamondbacks’ starting lineup on the day GTA V hit the market looked like this:

CF Adam Eaton
2B Aaron Hill
1B Paul Goldschmidt
3B Eric Chavez
LF Martin Prado
C Miguel Montero
RF Gerardo Parra
SS Didi Gregorius
P Patrick Corbin

The D-backs lost that game to the Los Angeles Dodgers, 9-3, en route to a second straight 81-81 finish under manager Kirk Gibson. Paul Goldschmidt had a season to remember with 36 home runs and 125 RBIs to finish second for NL MVP (Andrew McCutchen).

MLB News

(CBS Sports) Luis Castillo trade grades: White Sox give up steady back-end starter to offload salary; Rockies get creative

Two days after adding Dustin May to their rotation, the Chicago White Sox have subtracted Luis Castillo and Davis Martin. The White Sox are sending Castillo and Martin to the Colorado Rockies for lefty Sean Sullivan and minor-league catcher Douglas Veliz, reports ESPN and The Athletic. The Rockies will take on Castillo’s entire contract.

(Yahoo! Sports) Sonny Gray returns to the Twins with the belief they’re back on track to contention

The Minnesota Twins under their new leadership have steadfastly expressed a refreshed commitment to contending, including an increase in spending on the roster after rankling their fans with some lean years.

Sonny Gray is firmly among the believers.

“There’s no way I would have come back to Minnesota if I didn’t think we could win. That’s just the honest-to-God truth,” Gray said after signing a $55 million contract to return to the Twins three years after his departure coincided with the payroll cutback. “So I do believe in this group, and I do believe that the future, the near future, is very bright in Minnesota.”

Michael King could replace Trevor Rogers and then some

MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN - OCTOBER 04: Michael King #34 of the San Diego Padres delivers the pitch against the Milwaukee Brewers during the second inning in game two of the National League Division Series at American Family Field on October 04, 2026 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. (Photo by John Fisher/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The Orioles made sizable financial commitments to lock up Kyle Bradish and Shane Baz last year. Depending on your level of trust with Brandon Young, those two represent the only proven starters on the current roster. Young broke out last season with a 9-6 record, 3.56 ERA and 2.3 bWAR. It’s unclear whether the front office fully expects the 28-year-old to replicate his success from last season. Either way, Baltimore should be active in the starting pitching market this offseason.

Trevor Rogers officially rejected the qualifying offer, but the Orioles have not ruled out bringing the lefty back. The organization knows him better than anyone, and it’s up to this front office to determine whether he’s worth the projected four years, $76 million. Baltimore never appeared to make a legitimate extension offer to Rogers despite locking up Bradish and Baz. Take that with however many grains of salt as you’d like.

Pitching costs money, and Mike Elias insists that he has the authority and resources to spend big once again. That notion gained some credibility when the Birds inked Pete Alonso to a $155 million deal, but nobody should expect Baltimore to compete with the game’s biggest spenders. The team probably has the financial ability to sign one top-tier free agent starter that is not named Tarik. Do they want to spend that money or Rogers or someone else?

Michael King is a free agent once again after opting out before year two of a three-year, $75 million contract. King went 12-10 with a 3.21 ERA and 4.3 bWAR last season for the Padres. For context, Rogers finished the season 10-11 with a 4.03 ERA and 2.2 bWAR. King holds a career 3.23 ERA over 193 appearances.

King got his start in the AL East working in relief for the Yankees. New York packaged King and several other players in a deal for Juan Soto and Trent Grisham. Soto spurned the Yankees for their crosstown rival after one season, while King emerged as one of the better pitchers in baseball. He missed time with a shoulder nerve impingement issue in 2025, but he delivered 185 innings over 32 starts last season. He’s posted an ERA of 3.55 or lower every season since 2021.

The Boston College product relies on five pitches led by his 93-MPH sinker. He uses a changeup, four seamer, sweeper and slider in that order. King averaged 94.3 MPH with his four seamer in 2026. The number doesn’t jump off the page, but it represented a slight increase from 2025 (93.7). He’s not a flamethrower, but an increase is better than a decrease. However, his 159 strikeouts in 2026 were down from the 201 he recorded in 2024.

Aside from Skubal, every free agent pitcher will come with a few caveats. It’s up to the Orioles to decide which player comes with the greatest chance of success. King showed up on our wish list last year, but the Orioles went with Zach Eflin and Chris Bassitt. I don’t need to tell you that Baltimore could have used King in the rotation last season.

There’s a legitimate chance that King resigns with the Padres, so he’s clearly not desperate for a change of scenery from sunny San Diego. King opted out because he believes he can get a better deal than the two years and $50 million left on his deal. Signing starting pitchers to large contracts will always be a risk, but is King the guy to take a chance on?

There are only so many “true aces” out there. King, at a minimum, would fit in with Bradish and Baz atop the rotation. He may not start on Opening Day this year, but he could be the guy you had the ball to for Game 1 of a playoff series. The veteran holds a 3-0 record with a 1.86 ERA over seven postseason appearances.

King throws the ball with his right hand, so his signing would leave the rotation without a southpaw. Luis De León made his MLB debut out of the bullpen last season, but the Orioles plan to use the prospect as a starter moving forward. The team would likely prefer a lefty with a little more experience to start the season, so a back-of-the-rotation lefty could join King in Baltimore.

King does not have a qualifying offer attached to him, so Baltimore could make the addition without losing draft pick compensation. Adding a player without sacrificing a pick, paired with the addition of a pick when another team signs Rogers, feels like something Elias could get behind. However, it’s worth noting that King will be two years older than Rogers on Opening Day.

It’s easy to look at the list of top free agents and tell the front office to go sign one, but that doesn’t mean the organization can simply get it done. I think everyone can recognize that the plan over the last few years has not been enough. The Orioles failed to add a big name starter last offseason. Will they change course this year?

A final look at the Detroit Tigers non-tender candidates

Detroit Tigers president of baseball operations Scott Harris watches practice during spring training at TigerTown in Lakeland, Fla. on Friday, Feb. 13, 2026. | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Co

Friday, November 20 is the non-tender deadline for all arbitration eligible players. By 5:00 p.m. ET, every pre-arbitration and arbitration eligible player must be tendered a contract by their respective teams. Arb eligible players may ultimately turn down the offer and renegotiate or go to an arbitration hearing, typically in February though who knows this year, to decide their 2027 salary, but teams must tender them a contract by the deadline or they immediately become free agents without having to go through waivers.

Often, players who aren’t going to be tendered a contract are just designated for assignment at the deadline to finalize the 40-man roster in advance of December’s Rule 5 draft. That deadline passed on Tuesday, and saw the Tigers trade infield prospect Jace Jung to the Los Angeles Angels for cash considerations to open one spot. Shortstop Trey Sweeney, outfielder Matt Vierling, and left-handed pitching prospect Jake Miller were all DFA’d off the 40-man roster as well. They’ll be non-tendered in the meantime. Free agent acquisition Emilio Pagán, along with prospects Josue Briceño, Max Anderson, and Peyton Graham were all added to the 40-man roster at that point, and the roster now stands at 40 players.

Here are the Tigers arbitration eligible players for 2027, their ages and service time, along with their 2026 salary and finally MLB Trade Rumors arbitration estimates.

Will Vest- Age 31 (5.100 years): $3.950MM —>$4.4MM

Zach McKinstry- Age 31 (5.099 years): $4.2MM —> $5MM

Riley Greene- Age 26 (4.110 years): $5.0MM —>$9.3MM

Spencer Torkelson- Age 27 (4.076 years): $4.075MM —>$7.7M

Kerry Carpenter-Age 29 (4.057 years): $3.275MM —>$4.1MM

Tyler Holton- Age 30 (4.047 years): $1.575MM —>$2.4MM

Beau Brieske- Age 28 (4.007 years): $1.157MM —>$1.5MM

Reese Olson- Age 27 (3.123 years): $818,100 —>$1.5MM

Wenceel Pérez- Age 26 (3.000 years): $803,400 —>$1.4 MM

Parker Meadows- Age 26 (2.169 years): $805,300 —>$1MM

Teams that weren’t going to offer their arbitration eligible players a contract often genearlly, but not always, would have just DFA’d them back on Tuesday to clear space for their additions. On the other hand, waiting does give a few extra days to look through the newly available players for potential upgrades, or to perhaps work out a trade of their own arbitration eligible player instead of just releasing the player outright. Typically this involves a veteran player who underperformed but still has value, but is also due a sizable raise in arbitration. The Tigers don’t really a player who fits that description, though Spencer Torkelson is arguably in that camp, so expect Friday to be pretty quiet unless they’re actively working to trade away one of the players above. Sweeney and Vierling haven’t been claimed as of yet, and so the Tigers will have them on their non-tender list, but they probably won’t have much company.

We’ve wondered if the Tigers might try to deal someone like Spencer Torkelson or Kerry Carpenter for minor league pitching depth as they get a bit more expensive, but there’s nothing to suggest that a trade is coming. Neither is making that much, though Torkelson’s projected $7.7 million is starting to get a little close to his actual projected value for 2027. Scott Harris has continued to speak highly of Torkelson as a piece of the Tigers’ offense, so we’ll assume he’ll be tendered a contract.

Carpenter is still going to be quite cheap, although his status after the past two seasons is pretty uncertain. The injury history and declining recent production makes it unlikely that many teams will be inquiring about the 29-year-old outfielder, though his projected raise to $4.1 million is still quite inexpensive if he can get healthy and start turning things around at the plate. On the other hand, he’s a well liked player in the Tigers’ organization, and if teams aren’t offering anything in trade, non-tendering him would allow him to become a free agent and have some say in choosing his future home rather than exposing him to waivers via a DFA.

Utilityman Zach McKinstry isn’t projected for much of a raise, and his jack of all trades stylings help fill in gaps on the Tigers roster. Still, after a rough year at the plate he’s certainly a possible candidate to be non-tendered too, just as Andy Ibáñez was last year. It’s hard to imagine the Tigers managing to trade him for anything they need. Still, he could be tendered a contract to keep him under club control and then released later if the Tigers sign another free agent or claim a player off waivers before the season begins. At age 31, with minimal trade value, non-tendering him would at least allow him some control over his 2027 landing spot as well.

Finally, while the Tigers will keep Will Vest, right-hander Beau Brieske is out of options and is a pretty good non-tender candidate as well. The right-hander has spent the past two seasons dealing with shoulder issues. He briefly returned in May of 2026 but was roughed up. Still, he eventually got his legs under him and posted a 3.04 ERA and a 3.48 FIP from June 10 until the end of the season. With relief help at a premium, the Tigers might decide to keep him, but ideally they’d just non-tender him now and re-sign him to a minor league deal before the lockout begins. They could still pay him to accept this and stash him in Triple-A to begin the year. Of course, in that case Brieske could just choose to go elsewhere, but it’s not as though his services will be in high demand.

Last year the Tigers non-tendered Ibáñez and six pitchers, but the 40-man roster situation was pretty crowded due to pitcher injuries throughout the season. Tanner Rainey, Sean Guenther, Dugan Darnell, Jason Foley, Jack Little, and Tyler Mattison were all designated for assignment at the 40-man roster last year, and then ultimately non-tendered as well. Rainey, Little, and Mattison all ultimately accepted minor league deals with the Tigers.

The non-tender deadline is always the final Friday before Thanksgiving, per the 2022-2026 collective bargaining agreement. Generally, there isn’t a whole lot of big news, but occasionally a trade or two will go through in advance of the deadline, or there will be a surprise non-tender candidate. With the trade market perking up this week, there’s at least a chance that the Tigers make a small trade and non-tender a player or two to clear space for future free agent signings. Really the interest today is whether teams come to agreements with players quickly, and how the looming CBA fight might affect players’ willingness to actually sign a tendered contract now rather than waiting for an arbitration hearing under a new agreement.

Do you expect anything out of Reynaldo Lopez in 2027?

ATLANTA, GA - SEPTEMBER 29: Reynaldo López #40 of the Atlanta Braves smiles before Game One of the Wild Card Series between the Philadelphia Phillies and the Atlanta Braves at Truist Park on September 29, 2026 in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Jack Casey/Atlanta Braves/Getty Images) | Getty Images

A short one, ‘cause it’s Friday. We ran out Reynaldo Lopez player review yesterday. The bottom line is that Lopez didn’t do anything all that exciting in 2026. He was unimpressive as a reliever, and then had a nice six-start run in the summer… but then he got hurt, came back for a couple of games, and then went down with shoulder inflammation.

It wasn’t a totally lost season, but it also wasn’t a useful one. And, because he pitched in just one game in 2025, he’s going to enter 2027 with a very disparate spread in his most recent three seasons: a career year, a season almost entirely lost to injury, and then whatever morass of blah 2026 was.

So, if you need more detail, you can go to the player review — but given that, do you expect anything from Lopez in 2027?

Are there any non-tender candidates you’re interested in?

Today is another minor checkpoint of the MLB offseason, as it is the deadline for teams to tender contracts to those who are eligible for salary arbitration. Any player who is not tendered a contract by 5 pm today will immediately enter the free agent pool. Non-tendered players are generally not exciting, but they could provide their new team immense value on a cheaper cost than they may have made with their old team via arbitration, such as Jonathan Loáisiga did last season for the Diamondbacks.

The Phillies have been no stranger to the non-tendered player market in recent years, as last year they took a gamble on Adolis García who had been non-tendered by the Texas Rangers. Of course, that gamble didn’t pay off, as Garcia hit just .195 with a .599 OPS before a shoulder injury ended his season in mid-June.

That said, it’s very likely that the Phillies will be scouring this market yet again, as Dave Dombrowski has made a habit of signing veteran players to one-year deals with hopes they can bounce back with the Phillies. It has yet to actually happen, but with the Phillies holes being numerous and their spending perhaps reaching the upper echelon of its limits, it’s a market they will have to look torward.

So, are they any non-tender candidates you have some interest in? Is there anyone around the league who could be entering the free agent pool later today that you think could be a steal next year?

In the lab: A look at potential non-tendered outfielders

Detroit Tigers third base Matt Vierling celebrates a play against Guardians in the dugout during the 7th inning at Game 3 of ALDS at Comerica Park in Detroit on Wednesday, Oct. 9 2024. | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Co

“Moneyball” taught us a lot of things. It taught us the importance of on base percentage, but more importantly it helped explain how teams can build themselves in the aggregate. This is particularly true for a team that has limited resources like the Astros. You could blow your wad and sign a big name player or you can spread those financial resources around and fix multiple holes all at the same time. If we consider Yordan Alvarez and Cam Smith as entrenched in the outfield then we could look at three positions that are up for grabs.

Two of those would be part time positions by sheer definition. We aren’t talking about all-stars here. We are talking about incremental improvement. This is where the aggregate comes in. There is a trio of semi-regular players that the Astros will likely try to replace. It pays to look at them individually and in the aggregate. The goal is to get better. In addition to our standard numbers (SLASH, isopow, isopat, ROV, and BPO) we will also add SO%. Keep in mind the players below are just what they produced in 2026.

SLASHISOpowISOpatROVBPOSO5
Taylor Trammel.192/.285/.341.149.093.217.58232.2
Lamont Wade.205/.308/.346.141.103.225.62424.7
Brice Matthews.201/.255/.332.131.054.193.50331.8
Aggregate.199/.283/.340.141.084.212.57029.7

Real offensive value (ROV) is a hybrid stat that aims to put batting average and all of the other elements in the proper context. Yes, batting average matters. It doesn’t matter more than the other aspects of secondary average though. So, averaging them together puts them in their proper context. Simply put, when you have a runner on third base, walks aren’t going to bring him home. They will raise overall run expectancy, but they will not bring THAT runner home. So, batting average matters.

We included strikeout rate because this team was at its very best offensively when it was leading the league in contact. It did so in 2017 when they also led the league in runs scored. The Astros won the team Silver Slugger award for having the most home runs. That’s kind of an empty honor. I don’t want to lead the league in dingers. I want to lead the league in runs scored. You lead the league in runs scored when you lead the league in base runners. You do that when you get on base. You get on base by drawing walks, but you also get there when you make consistent contact.

A 30 percent strikeout rate is dreadful. We could throw Daulton Varsho in here and his time in Houston would look a lot like this. We could throw in some of the others with fewer plate appearances and it would look a lot like this. I can’t say for sure, but I would imagine that Randy Flores will prioritize contact when looking at the free agent market. Below are the seven prominent outfielders listed as non-tender candidates. As I write this, only two have officially been non-tendered, so not all of these names will be available, but they are kinds of players they are likely to consider for depth purposes. The numbers below are career averages.

SLASHISOpowISOpatROVBPOSO%
Luke Raley.230/.313/.428.198.083.256.71931.0
Josh Lowe.242/.300/.405.163.058.232.69428.2
Gavin Sheets.232/.303/.397.165.071.234.63420.4
Jose Siri.212/.268/.403.191.056.230.63333.4
Jo Adell.226/.283/.412.186.057.236.62928.4
Matt Vierling.250/.307/.383.133.057.220.61720.6
Kyle Isbell.235/.284/..357.122.049.203.55421.5

Let’s dispense with a few silly notions first. These are not good baseball players. Good baseball players are not non-tendered. Isbell also is a no go based on these numbers because he is not an improvement over what you had. The others feel like improvements overall, but they offer different strengths and weaknesses. Obviously, there is more to it than simply offensive numbers. There is a question of defensive fits and what any might command on the open market. It isn’t as simple as signing the best hitter and calling it a day.

In general, the debate over the importance and significance of the strikeout is one of the more fascinating debates in the stats world. As a matter of course, it has no direct impact on ROV or BPO. An out is an out is an out. However, a more nuanced approach would allow for some significance here. Any time you see a team strand a runner on third and less than two outs would testify to the idea that contact can be a very important thing in certain situations.

Out of the list above, Vierling and Isbell are the only ones definitely available. Their 2026 numbers look awful, but when you look at Vierling’s statcast numbers, they come pretty close to his career averages. Again, he is not a good offensive player. Under the right circumstances he can be an average offensive player and when you are talking about a part-time outfielder, average is probably as good as you can reasonably do. Gavin Sheets would be the other corner bat that would offer you league average performance and better contact rates.

One of the things we saw with Joe Espada is how he liked to employ what I would lovingly call the “YMCA everyone gets to play day.” Others called it “Sunday Fun Day.” The idea was to empty your bench and rest about half of your regulars on the same day. Naturally, we could debate the positive utility of punting one day a week versus staggering the rest and giving yourself a weaker lineup three or four days a week. I suppose either argument makes sense or doesn’t when you game them out. What you can do is employ as many average players as possible, so that you aren’t sinking your lineup with two or three negative impact bats when you rest your regulars. Picking up a couple of these guys (minus Isbell) would do that and that is especially true when we compare them with last season.