
Welcome to the 2026 edition of Ranking the Rockies, where we take a look back at every player to log playing time for the Rockies in 2026. The purpose of this list is to provide a snapshot of the player in context. The “Ranking” is an organizing principle that’s drawn from Baseball Reference’s WAR (rWAR). It’s not something the staff debated. We’ll begin with the player with the lowest rWAR and end up with the player with the highest.
No. 21, Brett Sullivan (0.3 rWAR)
In 2026, we learned a lot of things about Colorado Rockies backup catcher Brett Sullivan.
For starters, he apparently shares the same name as the person who directed the live capture of the Broadway musical Hadestown. (I asked him about it in August, and he asked if that’s why he kept getting randomly tagged in things on Instagram.)
Secondly, the 32-year-old somehow became the Rockies answer to Shohei Ohtani, falling 12.1 innings short of two-way player status.
Sullivan became a true triple threat in 2026, but instead of those threats being acting, singing, and dancing, his are hitting, pitching, and leadership.
Here’s how he fared under each threat in 2026.
Hitting
Sullivan played in 82 games in 2026, batting .225/.238/.390 with 13 doubles, one triple and seven home runs. He recorded 33 RBI, one stolen base in three attempts, and accumulated a wRC+ of 65. The numbers might not be the flashiest, but considering he played more games in 2026 than he did in his previous three seasons combined, it’s not surprising.
He did have some excellent moments, though, such as becoming the first pitcher not named “Ohtani” to record a home run on May 26th at Dodger Stadium:
That home run also broke an 0-for-26 stretch that he’d been on since May 2nd, and an overall stretch of 27 consecutive hitless at-bats. In the entire month of May, Sullivan went just 3-for-37 (.081).
After the Rockies batted around, he nearly hit a grand slam off Miguel Rojas, but it was caught just shy of the warning track.
Sullivan broke out of his funk in early June, going 7-for-16 from May 26-June 11. And some of that he credits to a wardrobe change suggestion from Mickey Moniak:
Sullivan ended up going 7-for-27 in June with three homers and four RBI. He continued playing well in July, going 8-for-27 (.296) with two doubles and a triple. He fell back down to earth a little bit in August, and then — much like the rest of the team — fell off in September, hitting just .188 over the final month.
Pitching
Sullivan really found his stride as relief pitcher in 2026. He made his first appearance on May 19th against the Texas Rangers, where he pitched a scoreless ninth in the 10-0 loss.
Sullivan made four appearances in May totaling 4.1 innings, and didn’t allow a run until May 31st against the San Francisco Giants. But that outing ended up being his worst (1.1 IP, 5 hits, 2 ER, 1 HR, 1 K). He allowed one run in each of his next two outings, but finished strong with a scoreless two-thirds of an inning against the Cleveland Guardians on August 21st.
At the end of the season, Sullivan had a 4.70 ERA and 1.70 WHIP. He allowed 11 total hits, four runs, one home run, two walks and one strikeout. He threw 94 total pitches (including his elusive “air cutter”).
He needed 20 innings and 20 games batting to reach official two-way player status, and he finished with 7.2 innings alongside 84 games batting. But he still gave Ohtani a run for his money!
Leadership
One of the most underrated traits of a veteran player, especially a backup catcher, is their leadership. Sullivan is truly a journeyman, considering he is 32 and this was his first full season in MLB. And that kind of journey provides good experience to relay to young players cutting their teeth, even if he was experiencing a long major league season for the first time himself.
“It’s been great,” Sullivan said at the end of the season. “I think being here in Colorado with this team, this organization — especially the coaching staff — it’s been what you you want since you start playing baseball.
“And shoot, I haven’t taken a day for granted at all, but there’s also a sense of comfortability,” he continued, “and when you show up, you believe in the guys, and they believe in you. And maybe that’s something I haven’t had. So I’ve absolutely loved it this year with this group of guys, and I still think there’s a lot more we can do.”
But there are still lessons to be learned, even in leadership.
“From the baseball side and this team side — the record may not be what we want it to be, but I want to say there’s been 42, 43 games where we’ve lost by one or two runs,” Sullivan said. “A huge lesson is every game matters, every inning matters. There’s going to be mess ups. There’s going be hiccups. Every one of us is gonna do it. But if you can really focus and on today — this game matters. Not this series or this week, it’s ‘Hey, today is the biggest day.’ I think you might come out on the better end of some of those.
“And and just saying that out loud — 42 games with two runs or less losses — I mean, we’re in it each game, or at least we believe we’re going to be in it,” he continued. “And so [the] biggest lesson is taking it day by day and showing up, saying, ‘Hey, today we’re going to win, and that’s all that matters is right now.’”
Sullivan’s leadership was on display when he announced Hunter Goodman as the Rockies’ All-Star.
Manager Warren Schaeffer said he spoke to the club first, but Sullivan took over the announcement because “he’s basically our team spokesman.”
“Every night that we win, Brett Sullivan speaks to the group,” Schaeffer said, “might as well do it in that big moment, too. He’s a fellow catcher. It’s their team — it’s the players’ team — so better a player do it than me.”
And some of that leadership comes with knowing when to take one for the team, such as becoming the de facto position-player pitcher. Or even being on camera more:
What’s next
Sullivan just completed his first full year in the majors, so he still has two more years before he is arbitration eligible. What the Rockies decide to do with Hunter Goodman will likely determine Sullivan’s fate in 2027 (and Braxton Fulford’s as well). But given his steady work and veteran presence, he will likely remain with the Rockies for another year.
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
- Fewer ads
- Create community posts
- Comment on articles, community posts
- Rec comments, community posts
- New, improved notifications system!
Please keep in mind our Purple Row Community Guidelines when you’re commenting. Thanks!














