The piggyback situation remains an uncomfortable – and I would argue, untenable – situation for Luis Castillo and Bryce Miller, but both of them pitched through that tonight and did their jobs, pitching all nine innings without touching the bullpen, giving up two runs (both Miller’s) with a combined 10 strikeouts to just two walks (both Castillo’s). Meanwhile, the offense jumped on A’s starter Aaron Civale, lighting him up for six runs in one inning alone en route to a 9-2 series-opening win.
The box score for today’s game says “Wind, 18 mph” and where it would normally say a direction instead just says “varies.” Seems rude to ask Luis Castillo to both step into a new role and be all four of the Anemoi, but this is just another thing The Rock must absorb with dignity and grace. The wind early in this game was enough to shake the center field camera significantly and provide a uniquely unpleasant viewing experience that had me reaching for Dramamine (or at least hum the Modest Mouse song). Initially it seemed like it might be affecting Castillo, who walked his leadoff hitter on some fairly significant misses, but was able to lock things down after that, as he did for the rest of his outing.
Meanwhile, the Mariners were able to finally stack up some runs using their (almost) fully-operational lefty lineup. Lefties are hitting almost .300 off Aaron Civale this year, and after getting some traffic on early, the Mariners were able to finally break through in the third during the lefty-heavy portion of their programming. Colt Emerson, continuing to show maturity at the plate, led off with a five-pitch walk and then moved to third on a Julio Rodríguez single. Civale leaned heavily on his cutter, as he did last year, but the Mariners hitters seemed ready for it – Civale had struck out Julio on the cutter in the first inning, and tried to go to it again on the single, but Julio was able to adjust. Josh Naylor knocked Emerson home on a would-be double play that was luckily mishandled by the A’s infield to give the Mariners their first run of the game, and Randy Arozarena pounced on a first-pitch curveball for a double – also mishandled by Carlos Cortes in the outfield, allowing Naylor to score. How fun when it’s not the Mariners making defensive miscues and instead punishing other teams for theirs.
Civale then tried to get a first-pitch cutter past Luke Raley, who intercepted the pitch at the bottom of the zone and squeaked it over the right field fence to double up the Mariners lead – “squeaking” not being a way we’re used to referring to Raley homers, but we’ll take it. Cole Young followed that up by doubling on a splitter, poking it down the right field line, and then Dom Canzone saw a first-pitch fastball to his liking for a decisive homer to right-center, opening up a 6-0 advantage.
It’s a good thing the Mariners built Castillo that cushion because the bottom of the third started with some patented Sutter Home Park Silliness as nine-hole hitter Darell Hernaiz got a leadoff “double” on a ball that first got grabbed by the wind and then bounced in the outfield like an eight year old at a trampoline park birthday party. Castillo, to his credit, cleaned things up and didn’t let that runner score. Carlos Cortes, who is Annoying, hit a ball hard but not home run distance, enough to move Hernaiz to third. Castillo then pitched carefully to Nick Kurtz, walking him, but was able to attack the other head of the monster in Shea Langeliers, getting him to expand off the plate for a swinging strike three on a fastball. He then got Brent Rooker on three pitches, none of which were on the plate, as Rooker continues on a rough start to the season.
In the fourth, J.P. Crawford accidentally made himself the story of the inning, hitting a solo shot to make it 7-0 but throwing the ball away on what should have been an easy groundout to open the bottom of the inning. Once again, Castillo was forced into cleanup duty, striking out rookie centerfielder Henry Bolte looking, getting my personal enemy Jeff McNeil to pop out, and then striking out Zack Gelof looking on a pitch that was probably outside a hair but since the A’s were already down to one challenge, went unchallenged.
The Mariners’ early onslaught of runs forced the A’s into their own piggyback situation, bringing out Jack Perkins as their own second starter, but the real storyline here wasn’t on the field but in the Mariners dugout, as Dan Wilson was seen deep in conversation with Luis Castillo, who looked visibly displeased to be told he would be departing the game in order for Bryce Miller to come in. Considering Luis defeated the A’s hitters, the haunted tuna can of Sutter Health Park, the wind, and his own infield defense, it seems only fair he’d be given a win for that outing. But with the lineup turning over, Wilson opted to go to Miller.
Miller, presenting a completely different set of looks to the A’s hitters, was able to work the back five of the game, allowing Dan Wilson to keep his bullpen in bubble wrap for another day. A brief moment here to also appreciate catcher Jhonny Pereda, who had to prepare for two different starters in this game with two vastly different arsenals.- during Miller’s first hitter Pereda had to burn a mound visit after Miller shook him three times in succession – but guided his two starters through the game. Miller came out throwing hard although slightly less hard than his last outing, touching 98.2 in his first inning of work before settling in at 96.5. The standout for Miller today was his splitter, which looked sharper than his last outing; three of his four strikeouts were on the pitch. Miller was also mostly successful throwing his slider, although he did hang one to Langeliers for a homer for the A’s first run of the day in the eighth.
But Randy Arozarena got that run back plus one, finally getting to Perkins in the ninth with two outs, scoring Naylor, on base with a Naylor Special (a base hit to left off a pitch up and away).
The A’s would claw one more back off Miller off a couple of objectively stupid hits as the A’s were in swing mode down big in the ninth. Tyler Soderstrom led off with a double on a curve that he didn’t hit so much as vaudeville hook into left, then advanced to third on an infield hit. A run did score when Jeff McNeil grounded into a double play – niftily handled by Naylor, who managed to both tag speedy rookie Henry Bolte and touch first before McNeil creaked his way down there, setting up a game-ending strikeout of Zach Gelof. Since Miller didn’t get the glamor of being the opener this time, we’ll give him the honor of closing out the recap – just don’t look too carefully at the win dance, which is a little messy; appropriate, given the situation.
Eric Samulski
James Schiano
