After a tense afternoon that saw the Tigers forced to come back repeatedly to keep pace with the Mariners, they reached the ninth inning still down a run. The Mariners ran themselves into a pair of dumb outs on the bases with Will Vest on the mound, and that set the stage. The back of the Tigers’ order did a nice job waiting out a wild Andrés Muñoz to draw a pair of walks, and managed to turn the lineup over to star rookie Kevin McGonigle, who had already homered in the game. The kid delivered with a two-run, walkoff single into right field to send the home crowd home in thrilling fashion. What a game.
Jack Flaherty and Luis Castillo locked up in a duel of starters who have struggled this season to date. The Tigers’ right-hander popped up Cole Young to open the game, then dropped a curveball in on Julio Rodriguez for strike three. After Josh Naylor was announced and the crowd booed, a 2-2 fastball locked him up for strike three. It was called a ball, but Dillon Dingler challenged it successfully.
AJ Hinch had Kerry Carpenter in the leadoff spot and he worked Luis Castillo through a long at-bat but flew out. Kevin McGonigle struck out after a foul ball down the left field line that brought Randy Arozarena to the netting, where a Tigers fan offered him a snack in a moment that reminded me of Prince Fielder snatching a tortilla chip from a fan’s nachos. Gleyber Torres, getting a day as the DH, then blew a challenge contesting a called strike three, but he was wrong, striking out and burning a challenge.
Flaherty gave up some hard contact in the second inning, but other than a Luke Raley double off the left field wall, nothing dropped in, and a good fastball whiffed Patrick Wisdom to end the inning.
For all Luis Castillo’s struggles this year, we weren’t seeing any signs of them here. He couldn’t spot the changeup, but the slider was sharp and the right-hander was hitting 96-97 mph with good fastball location. Riley Greene struck out on a fourseamer up to start the bottom of the second. Dillon Dingler hammered a drive out to Rodriguez in center field and Colt Keith lifted a slider to right field but didn’t square it up, sending us to the third inning.
Colt Emerson started the third by drilling an 0-2 slider to right for a double. Jhonny Perada grounded out, moving Emerson to third. Cole Young followed with a hot ground ball into right field for an RBI single, and it was 1-0 Mariners. Flaherty tied up Rodriguez with a high fastball and got a routine fly ball to Carpenter in right field. That left it up to Naylor who popped out to Colt Keith in foul territory.
News came through prior to the game that Casey Mize would make a rehab start on Tuesday with the Single-A Lakeland Flying Tigers. Meanwhile, Tarik Skubal was getting underway in West Michigan in a High-A rehab outing against the Dayton Dragons. The left-hander struck out two in the first inning, getting a grounder for the third out. He needed just nine pitches, sitting 96-97 mph.
The Whitecaps roster was having a good day courtesy of the two-time AL Cy Young award winner.
Spencer Torkelson flew out to start the bottom of the third and Zach McKinstry struck out. Wenceel Pérez fought off a bunch of two strike pitches, including one that he chopped right back into the family jewels. That required a little time to shake off. Eventually he dug back in and drilled a single that Wisdom couldn’t handle, but Carpenter popped out to end the inning.
Jack Flaherty’s slider was coming around, and as he dialed it in the whiffs piled up. He got Arozarena swinging over the slide piece for strike three to start the fourth. Raley suffered a similar fate, and Dominic Canzone grounded out to McKinstry at second base.
Kevin McGonigle led off the bottom of the fourth, and he got a 1-0 slider up in the zone and crushed it to right field for his fourth home run of the season. Tie game.
Gleyber Torres grounded out for the first out of the fourth. Riley Greene gave the ball a ride to deep right center field, but Raley ran it down. Dingler grounded out to third, and we were onto the fifth.
Wisdom opened the fifth inning with a line drive over Colt Keith at third, positioned toward second base, for a leadoff single. A high fastball from Flaherty dusted Emerson for his sixth strikeout on the day. Perada lined out to Carpenter, and Cole Young whiffed on a high fourseamer for strike three. Nice job stranding the runner after a leadoff single.
Colt Keith grounded out and Spencer Torkelson struck out to start the bottom of the fifth. A Zach McKinstry grounder to Wisdom was thrown wide of Naylor at first and he couldn’t pick it as the ball skipped into foul territory. McKinstry never stopped running, cruising into second base. Unfortuantely, a soft liner from Pérez went right to Naylor for the final out of the inning.
Julio Rodriguez lined a single into left field to start the sixth. Riley Greene picked it up, spun, and tried to fire to second to prevent a double, but Rodriguez had actually started to hold up. The throw was wide, and so Rodriguez was handed second base on the throwing error. Naylor pulled a hot grounder off the glove of a diving Torkelson and down the right field line for an RBI double. The Tigers were down a run again. Arozarena worked a full count, and Flaherty bounced a curveball to walk him, and so his day was done with no outs, a run in, and runner on first and second in the top of the sixth.
Lefty Drew Sommers took over from Flaherty against Raley. Mariners’ manager Dan Wilson elected not to pinch-hit, and instead had Raley bunt the runners over. He did so, with Keith making the play for the first out on the inning. Sommers has shown much better command so far this year, albeit in a very small sample, and he carved up Rob Refsnyder for the second out. Hinch called for the intentional walk to the right-handed hitting Wisdom to load the bases. Wilson gave them a gift with the sac bunt, but it turned out that the intentional walk was the gift to the Mariners, as Sommers hit Colt Emerson with a 2-2 sinker, forcing in a run. 3-1 Mariners. Arrgghh.
That ended Sommers outing. Kyle Finnegan was warm and he took over to face Perada. Fortunately, he flew out to Pérez to strand the bases loaded, but the damage was done and the Mariners had re-captured the lead.
Castillo was still on the mound in the bottom half of the sixth as Jose A. Ferrer was warming up in the bullpen. Carpenter grounded out to start the inning, but McGonigle drew a one-out walk. Torres got into a 2-0 count, but popped out to Raley in foul territory down the right field line. That was the end for Castillo as Ferrer took over.
Ferrer gave up a walk to Riley Greene to put two on with two outs for the red-hot Dillon Dingler. The Tigers catcher challenged an 0-1 pitch that was called a strike. He was correct, and Ferrer eventually walked him as well to load the bases. Hinch then pinch-hit Jahmai Jones for Colt Keith against the hard-throwing lefty. Instead, Jones popped up a 99 mph sinker to shallow center field to strand three. Woof.
That move caused Zack Short to enter the game at shortstop, pushing McGonigle to third base. Finnegan got Cole Young to fly out to start the seventh. Dillon Dingler burned the Tigers last challenge against Julio Rodriguez, but was incorrect and the center fielder drew a walk. He then stole second base with ease as Naylor took ball one. Finnegan popped up Naylor on a high fastball after setting him up with a couple of splitters. That left it up to Arozarena. Finnegan wasn’t paying Rodriguez any attention, and he stole third base on him without a throw. Arozarena singled in the run, and it was 4-1 Mariners.
Tyler Holton took over to get Raley, and he failed as the outfielder flicked a sweeper into right field for a single. Arozarena went first to third, and Refsnyder dug in looking to expand the Mariners’ lead. He failed, grounding out to McGonigle at third.
So it was 4-1 and the Tigers were running out of time. They seemed to take some urgency, as Torkelson and McKinstry started the inning with singles off of right-hander Cooper Criswell. Wenceel Pérez stepped in and flicked a low changeup into the right field corner for a two-run triple, and it was 4-3 Mariners with Pérez on third and no outs. A tie seemed imminent, but we had to reckon with the Tigers bench.
Dan Wilson turned to lefty Gabe Speier to replace Criswell. Matt Vierling pinch-hit for Carpenter, who as you’ll all recall homered off of Speier in Game 5 of last year’s ALDS Game 5, and Vierling grounded out to Wisdom at third. The third baseman tried to tag Pérez as he got back to the bag, and still had just enough time to throw out Vierling anyway. McGonigle hit a routine fly ball to left field, too shallow to score Pérez. Speier climbed the ladder with a fastball against Torres in a 2-2 count and blew him away. The Tigers had scored two, but stranding Pérez at third with no outs was infuriating.
Drew Anderson took over from Holton in the top of the eighth inning. He quickly struck out Wisdom and Emerson. McGonigle couldn’t handle a chopper from Perada, and Young slapped a curveball into right field as Perada moved to third. The Tigers absolutely had to have an out here to snuff a two-out rally. They got it, as Rodriguez grounded out sharply to McKinstry.
Right-hander Eduard Bazardo entered for the Mariners in the bottom of the eighth. Greene grounded out, and Dingler was locked up by a tough backdoor sinker for strike three. That left Short hitting against a tough right-hander and he flew out to end the inning.
So the Tigers needed two runs to win, and they would have only three outs to come back. They would have Torkelson, McKinstry, and Pérez up in the bottom of the ninth before the lineup turned over, so things looked pretty bleak for a team that cannot afford to lose a series right now. First they needed to keep the Mariners from answering back.
Will Vest took the mound in the top of the inning. In a 1-2 count, Vest tried to go well above the zone, but Naylor was ready and paddled a single to left field to start the inning. Naylor tried to get a walking lead and then broke for second. Vest did a nice job holding and stepped off to fire to second base for the out. The home crowd enjoyed that, at least. Vest then turned the cheers to groans by hitting Randy Arozarena. On an 0-1 pitch for a strike, Dingler tried to backpick Arozarena and fired a strike to Torkelson. A nice swipe tag got the out, though it took a challenge to overturn the initial safe call. Nice work from Dingler and Torkelson there. Vest dropped in a slider for strike three against Raley, and it was last call for the Tigers, needing one to tie and two for a walkoff victory.
The task would be very difficult against closer Andrés Muñoz. Torkelson quickly popped out to Emerson and that did nothing for Tigers fans’ optimism. Muñoz was firing 98-99 mph heaters in there. McKinstry did a nice job taking a couple of close pitches and drew a walk. Muñoz remained a little wild, falling behind 3-0 to Pérez. The Tigers’ outfielder took a heater on the outer edge for a strike, but the next one was again quite wide of the mark and Pérez took first base. So, two on, one out for Vierling and Muñoz missed badly with two more pitches. However, the Mariners closer pulled it together with two good heaters to get back in the count and Vierling chopped one to third. Wisdom could only get the out at first, and so both runners were in scoring position for McGonigle.
Fortunately, Dan Wilson decided not to walk McGonigle. The stage was set. Muñoz missed with a slider first pitch. He came back with a triple digit heater on the inner edge, and the rookie smoked it off the tip of a leaping Emerson’s glove at second base and into right field for a walkoff two-run single. Holy cow. Kevin forever!
The Tigers really needed this one to keep some momentum going, and the rookie delivered in dramatic fashion. They’ll have an off day on Monday before welcoming in the Minnesota Twins on Tuesday. After that three game set they’ll head to Cleveland for three against the Guardians, and based on Tarik Skubal’s rehab outing in West Mchigan, they may well have their ace back on the mound in that series.