Veteran lefty Wandy Peralta turns in mediocre season

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA - SEPTEMBER 22: Wandy Peralta #58 of the San Diego Padres pitches during the fifth inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Dodger Stadium on September 22, 2026 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Katelyn Mulcahy/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Welcome to our series grading every member of the San Diego Padres’ 40-man roster. The roster being evaluated is current as of Oct. 18, prior to the end of the World Series. Because of that, it will include players who will be free agents once the postseason concludes. Each player will be graded on their performance in the 2026 season, including the playoffs. That performance will be weighted based on how much time the player spent with the team (availability is the best ability). 

Wandy Peralta

Heading into the 2024 season, the Padres signed Peralta to a four-year, $16.5 million deal. That felt warranted at the time. Peralta had just polished off back-to-back sub-3.00 ERA seasons with the New York Yankees. He was 32 years old, but there was a belief that he would remain useful in the San Diego ’pen. He struggled in his first year (3.99 ERA) before improving in 2025 (3.14 ERA).

Overall Grade: C+

2026 was somewhere in between. Peralta covered a career-high 77 1/3 innings, authoring a 3.61 ERA, 1.32 WHIP and .271 opponent batting average. None of those numbers are particularly phenomenal, but Peralta was at least able to eat innings for San Diego. With their beleaguered rotation, the Padres were in desperate need of arms to cover multiple innings. Peralta did that.

That being said, his underlying metrics don’t paint a much better picture. Peralta posted a 114 ERA+, making him 14 points better than league average. But his 3.99 FIP shows a different story. Peralta struggled to limit base traffic. He allowed 26 free passes (23 BB and 3 HBP) and 79 hits. That resulted in 9.2 hits per nine innings rate, or just over one hit per inning.

Peralta opted in to his 2027 contract with the Padres. The left-hander will fill out bullpen depth for San Diego on a relatively inexpensive deal ($4.45 million). If he can replicate his production from 2025-26, Peralta could be a truly capable relief option for the Friars in the coming year.

The White Sox should “zig where others zag” for 2027 rotation

Jun 24, 2026; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago White Sox pitcher Erick Fedde (47) pitches against the Cleveland Guardians during the second inning at Rate Field.
Erick Fedde is an example of an under-the-radar signing who (twice) has paid off in the White Sox rotation. | Patrick Gorski-Imagn Images

It’s hard to complain about the 2026 White Sox season. Not many teams go from record-breakingly bad to World Series contenders in two years. And when they got eliminated by the Guardians in the ALDS, it was a 2-0 loss where the Sox struck out an MLB-record 21 times.

It was not Chicago’s pitching that was the main factor in that elimination game, but the rotation definitely hurt the team throughout the year. Their offensive lineup isn’t perfect, but the White Sox have a pretty competitive group of hitters to bring out for 2027. Meanwhile, they don’t have a real rotation to speak of — Sean Burke is good, Davis Martin can be good. Anthony Kay is still under contract, and he’s not really a bad pitcher, but he didn’t instill confidence last year. Grant Taylor is a good reliever, being converted to a starter. And then there are the pitching prospects, who all have potential, but all struggled last year.

So there are viable options, but other than Burke, none of these pitchers are reliable.

The front office, if it’s smart, will look to add rotation options. It has not been overly upfront about any strategy to upgrade, but Chris Getz has implied the obvious, that they’re looking at starters. But that could be a problem — free agent contracts are getting more overblown than ever, pitchers are inherently high risk and the Sox don’t have a ton of player depth for high stakes trades.

This problem exists for every team, but the Sox, pushing through a rebuild, are maybe affected by it more. They obviously aren’t making a bid for Tarik Skubal, but could they shoot for Michael King or another big-name pitcher? And, more crucially, should they?

Using King as an example, Spotrac expects him to get a five-year, $150 million contract; the entire 2026 Sox payroll was about $102 million. Their current most expensive player is Luis Castillo, who is owed $24.15 million in 2027. The Sox grabbed Castillo from the Mariners at the trade deadline, hoping to improve their rotation; he gave them an 8.42 ERA over nine games and six starts, and was moved to the bullpen and eventually off the active roster entirely.

I’m not saying the Sox should absolutely not sign a star starting pitcher, or even two starters. But I do think they need to be careful — and that there’s a potentially better way to approach the offseason.

The Sox were able to revamp their roster and create a formidable lineup, without spending crazy money or waiting years for draft prospects to develop. And a lot of that came from identifying under-the-radar talent.

Tristan Peters had played for three organizations when the Sox traded for him. He had a total of 12 major league PAs for the Tampa Bay Rays, where he went hitless and walk-less. After Tampa DFA’d him, the White Sox brokered a trade that was just a step above of straight waiver claim: a trade for cash considerations or a player to be named later. Basically, the Rays got back whatever they could get for him, likely spare change in one of the White Sox couches. Miguel Vargas, a former top prospect, had been deemed expendable by the Dodgers, and came to Chicago as their best return in what seemed to be a poorly-executed three-team trade. Munetaka Murakami got a ton of hype when he was posted, but no one wanted to roll the dice on him due to poor contact rates and rumors he would not be able to meet the challenge of the heat of MLB pitching.

The Sox were smart — they acquired talented players and gave them a real runway to succeed — and each player capitalized on it.

It’s a bit of risky gambit, and it’s impossible to say how it plays over time, as every ballplayer has inherent risk. The White Sox seem to be improving at player evaluation and development; the results spoke for themselves in 2026. And while their 2025 season was less successful, there were signs of this late in that year, too. Movable, affordable players can be less risky than big contracts, especially if your most realistic big-name acquisitions are the Castillo’s of the world.

The Sox have technically tried the “zig-where-other-teams-zag” strategy with their pitching, and with less success. Kay and Erick Fedde were aging journeyman who had done well internationally. Neither have been outright bad for the Sox; Fedde was a good innings-eater, out of the pen or rotation, while Kay was generally at least available, which is worth something on its own. But neither were ideal long-term options. Shane Smith, selected in the Rule 5 draft, was very good in 2025 and, as the Opening Day starter in 2026 there was an expectation that stardom was on the horizon. Instead it was the opposite, and Smith spent the season languishing in the minors when healthy, and generally posting worse numbers as time went on.

But there are some under-the-radar starters the Sox could try out for 2027.

Brendan Beck was a Yankees second round pick in 2021. Two elbow surgeries cost him all of 2022 and 2024, and he didn’t play a full minor league season until 2025. The 2026 campaign was his age-27 season, and he spent it in Triple-A Scranton, where he made 25 starts with a 2.93 ERA. Beck made his major league debut as well, and got banged up (14 runs over 12 ⅔ innings). That’s not inspiring, but the Yankees don’t have the easiest rotation to carck. Beck had a 1.058 WHIP in Scranton, with a 2.7 BB/9, and he pitched four scoreless, hitless innings in the WBC. His command is excellent, and you could see him being a really good arm in the right environment.

If the White Sox are willing to make a trade, they could probably get Tobias Myers from the Mets for a pittance. Myers spent eight years bouncing around the minor leagues, until he eventually made Milwaukee’s rotation in 2024. In 25 starts and two relief appearances, he posted a 3.00 ERA. His 2025 season was disrupted by injury, but he still managed a 3.55 ERA in 22 games (six starts). He was traded to the Mets in 2026 and struggled in a bullpen role; he finished the season with a 5.53 ERA in 32 games, and spent a large portion of the year in Triple-A (where he also struggled, but finished with a non-terrible 3.72 ERA). He spent a full year as a successful major league starter, so I’m optimistic he can be much more than the Triple-A mop-up man he was in 2026. Myers never has been considered a long-term starter, but he had a rookie year many starters would dream of — that has to count for something.

Or the White Sox could roll the dice on Kaima Taira. He would be more expensive than Beck or Myers, but probably not terribly so. He’s not really an under-the-radar option, as he’s considered a prominent free agent being posted out of Japan. But some teams are concerned that his height will be a disadvantage, and he’s being discussed as a bullpen piece. However, Taira has been a really successful NLB starter, and the Sox could look past the doubters and try him out. Sound like a familiar story from 2025, only now on the pitching side?

Obviously, any of these three individual pitchers are unlikely options, except maybe Taira, who any team has a decent chance at grabbing. But there is some obscure talent the White Sox could scout out — young pitchers, rather then veterans entering (or past) their age-30 seasons. Pitchers who could be on the upswing rather than the downswing, who won’t be expensive, and who fit into a philosophy that’s worked for the Sox before.

Is this the safest route? Not at all. Am I convinced that under-the-radar finds are the best option for a team with scant payroll? Not really. But it’s worth discussing as an alternative to a risky free agent contract.

Meet the Players: Emmaline McGeary

I come from New Jersey, which makes the White Sox an unlikely choice geographically. I’m from a family of Mets fans and grew up as one, and I continue to be a fan of them as well. My interest in baseball grew steadily. When I was a young kid, we’d go see Phillies games when they played the Mets, and my sister and I were told to “pretend” to root for the Fightin’ Phils, so we wouldn’t anger the fans at Citizens Bank Park.

We eventually got tired of risking life-and-limb to drive home on I-95 after the games. We started watching Double-A ball instead, and after that, I basically followed MiLB closer than I followed the majors. I didn’t fully internalize the “pretend” part of rooting for the Phillies, especially because they always seemed to win, and they were secretly my favorite team until I learned to appreciate the Mets for what they were, turning into a real Mets fan.

My initial interest in the White Sox came from their history. I really just followed the minors when I was young, but I became a fan of baseball history when I got older. All the historic teams were my favorites. The story of Shoeless Joe Jackson stuck with me, as did the stories of many of his teammates — who aren’t as well-remembered, often with good reason, but they had interesting backgrounds.

In 2024, when the Sox were having their historically bad season, I started following the team in real time. I was curious whether they’d beat the 1962 Mets historic W-L record. I became interested in the team for real, though, at the worst possible time, and became invested in their (seemingly futile) success. But my respect for the club grew in the offseason, when they seemed to have a pretty good rebuild plan.

I kept following them through their 2025 improvements, and then their awesome 2026 season. I had to respect that every move they made was really quite smart, and they brought a lot of talent to their team. Everyone, myself included, was surprised by their 2026 run, but in some ways I thought we were wrong to be surprised — their roster was pretty good, even when the season started and some of the rookies weren’t on the team yet.

I majored in history in college at Northern Arizona University, picking that major by default. But then I realized I could learn and write about baseball history, which changed my whole perspective on things. I played around with a couple different pursuits, but realized all I really wanted to do was write about baseball, so when I graduated, that’s what I started looking to do.

I’ve written some articles for Diamond Digest, Mets360, and Southside Showdown, as well. I still like the Mets and White Sox more than any other team. I still find minor league ball to be one of the best aspects of the sport, so I enjoy reading about prospects and writing about them. But the best part of baseball is the stories (especially when things go wrong), and the fun part writing about “original” MLB teams is that their history stretches even longer.


Hometown I live in Kingwood Township, New Jersey, where I was born and raised.

How did you join South Side Sox? I got DM’d by Brett! Apparently I’m the first acquisition through Instagram DMs.

What is your favorite type of writing or coverage at SSS? I like the prospect writeups, and the recaps of games. Ranking 100 prospects is no joke, and the game stories are always fun.

If you could have any job in baseball, what would it be and why? I suppose the general manager or president of operations, I suppose. It’s a boring title, but I always have opinions on what the guys with those jobs “should” be doing; it seems to dishonest to give a different answer.

White Sox fan since  I liked the team since I was a kid because of their history, but I didn’t get really interested in the modern team until their awful 2024 season. I couldn’t believe a team could fall so far, and as a Mets fan, I wanted to see whether they’d beat the Mets’ 1962 W-L record. I ended up getting hooked and rooting for the Sox, and when they started to really improve, I was impressed, so one thing led to another.

First White Sox memory When I was a kid, my dad told me the story of the Black Sox Scandal. That was probably the first time I really learned anything about the team. I was pretty in awe of the story, as most people are, and it definitely gave me an interest in the franchise’s overall history (ironically, given their role in that story).

Favorite White Sox memory Following the White Sox 2026 postseason run with my dad. I don’t think he cared much about the team one way or another before that, but I got him into it.

Favorite current White Sox player I’m gonna go with Sam Antonacci. Munetaka Murakami is a close second, but I like players who are pros at both getting on-base and converting that into runs. Antonacci’s a true run-scorer, and he plays old-school, “real” baseball.

Favorite White Sox player ever That would be Shoeless Joe Jackson. His story stuck with me, and it’s what created my interest in the team.

Next White Sox statue It’s too early to say, but I hope Murakami’s career works out and he gets there one day.

Next White Sox retired number I would retire #18 for Red Faber. I really like pitchers who grind through innings, and he had a 352 inning season. I know he didn’t keep the number for very long, but who cares?

Future White Sox Hall-of-Famers?
Mark Buehrle? Totally. He could grind through innings almost like Faber
Joe Jackson? He would be my No. 1 pick
Paul Konerko? I’d put him there
Chris Sale? He has 159 wins, not all with the Sox, but it’s still good enough for me.
Wilbur Wood? Just his name should get him in. Fortunately, he was also a great pitcher
Nancy Faust? That would be awesome

Go-to concession food at Sox Park To be honest, I haven’t actually been there. But at ballparks in general, it has to be peanuts and Cracker Jack. And I mean that for real.

Favorite Baseball Movie Field of Dreams

Favorite Ballpark This is a minor league park, but the Trenton Thunder Ballpark. It’s a small park that didn’t have a very good net for a long time — balls would fly up there. And they have dogs come retrieve the bats, instead of bat boys.

South Side Sox on the Field Never played. But I throw lefty and I don’t have a strong arm, so I suppose I’d play first base. Hopefully I’d be one of those range-y first basemen.

True or false: Every jumbled pile of person has a thinking part that wonders what the part that isn’t thinking isn’t thinking of. I’m not sure I understand the question, but I’m gonna go with yes. Everyone has wondered what an inanimate object is thinking — this seems like the same idea.

2027 BBWAA Hall of Fame ballot released

LOS ANGELES, CA - OCTOBER 16: Pitcher Joakim Soria #48 of the Milwaukee Brewers reacts after getting the third out to end the seventh inning during Game Four of the National League Championship Series against the Los Angeles Dodgers against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Dodger Stadium on October 16, 2018 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Jeff Gross/Getty Images) | Getty Images

If you’ve been around here a few years, you might know that I’m a Hall of Fame junkie. That makes today a big day on the calendar for me: the Baseball Writers Association of America has revealed the 2027 Hall of Fame ballot.

Next week, I’m going to give you my hypothetical ballot, were I given a chance to vote, so I’ll go more in-depth on those players then. Today, I’ll do a quick rundown of everyone on the ballot, both new and returning players, and give a quick thought about their chances of getting into the Hall of Fame this year.

A quick reminder of the rules: a player must get 75% of the votes to gain enshrinement. If they fail to receive 75% in 10 years, or they get less than 5% of the vote, they fall off the ballot.

New Players

Jake Arrieta, Starting Pitcher

Arrieta pitched for 12 years in a career that began in Baltimore but peaked with the Cubs in Chicago. In 2015, he won the Cy Young Award when he went 22-6 with a 1.77 ERA and led the league in shutouts (3), hits per nine (5.9), and homers per nine (0.4). He was particularly good after the All-Star break: Arrieta allowed only nine earned runs over 107 1/3 innings (0.75 ERA) in the second half, an MLB record for a starting pitcher post-All-Star break. While he had a few other solid seasons, none was anywhere close to 2015, and he finished his career with 115 wins and a 104 ERA+, and 22.7 bWAR. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.

Jay Bruce, Outfielder

Brewers fans will remember Bruce well—it felt like he was constantly hitting homers against them. And it’s kind of true: 35 of Bruce’s 319 career homers came against the Brewers, 12 more than against any other opponent. Bruce was a fairly one-dimensional player but hit over 300 homers and made three All-Star teams. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.

Asdrúbal Cabrera, Infielder

Cabrera’s best seasons came in Cleveland, where he spent the first seven-and-a-half years of his career and made his only two All-Star teams. At his best, Cabrera had some real pop—he hit 25 homers in 2011 and won a Silver Slugger. But he was a mediocre-at-best defensive infielder, so most of his 30 career bWAR came from offensive value. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.

Starlin Castro, Infielder

Ah, another Brewer nemesis. Castro joined the Cubs just after his 20th birthday, and in his second season, at 21, he led the league in hits, made the All-Star team, and got down-ballot MVP votes. He made three more All-Star teams over the next six years, though the last of those was when he was a Yankee; Castro wasn’t a very good defensive shortstop and he had a career walk rate of just 5.1%, so advanced stats aren’t especially kind to him. Still, he had 1,722 career hits, a big number. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.

Wade Davis, Relief Pitcher

Davis was a mega prospect as a starting pitcher, reaching as high as #17 on Baseball America’s top prospect list prior to the 2008 season. But he wasn’t great as a starter when he debuted with Tampa Bay in the early 2010s, and in his third full season, they moved him to the bullpen, where he was really good. After that season, he was included in the massive James Shields/Wil Myers swap with the Royals; Kansas City tried him as a starter, too, but it went very badly. In 2014 they moved him to the bullpen, and for the next four years Davis was an absolute Hall-of-Fame level reliever: in 244 games he had a 1.45 ERA. He shone brightest at the biggest moments, too: in 12 postseason appearances in 2014, he allowed one earned run and struck out 20 in 14 1/3 innings as the Royals won the AL. The next season, when the Royals finished the job, Davis didn’t allow a run and struck out 18 in 10 2/3 innings. Hall of Fame chances: Zero, but he was at the right level for a few years.

Brett Gardner, Outfielder

Gardner spent his whole 14-year career with the Yankees. He was, according to OPS+, an exactly league-average hitter during his career (100 OPS+, 1,470 hits, 139 homers in 1,688 games) but was good on the basepaths (274 stolen bases) and was arguably one of the best defensive corner outfielders of all time. Because of that combination of things—average hitting, great defense, good baserunning—he accrued a lot of career value, with 44.3 WAR via Baseball Reference. (FanGraphs doesn’t value his defense as highly and he only has 37.3 WAR via their version of the stat.) Hall of Fame chances: Zero, but he might get a handful of votes.

Jon Lester, Starting Pitcher

Finally, we’ve reached a player who we really need to discuss. Lester pitched 16 years, won 200 games, had a really good 117 career ERA+, pitched over 2700 career innings, and had almost 2500 strikeouts. He was the Cy Young runner-up in 2016 (with the Cubs) and had two additional fourth-place finishes when he was with the Red Sox. He’s got a human-interest story, given that he overcame cancer as a young man. And, the big one, he’s a postseason legend: he won World Series twice with Boston and once with the Cubs, and he’s got a career 2.51 ERA in 154 postseason innings (compared to a 3.66 career ERA during the regular season). He was the NLCS MVP during the Cubs’ run in 2016. Hall of Fame chances: I don’t think I’d vote for him, but he’s got a shot long term.

Andrew Miller, Relief Pitcher

Miller, like Davis, dominated the conversation for a bit as a fantastic, Hall-of-Fame level reliever. Like Davis, Miller was a major prospect as a starter (BA had him 10th before the 2007 season), and like Davis, he did not work out as a starter; the first six years of Miller’s career are really rough, in which he had a 5.79 ERA in 359 innings. He first pitched out of the bullpen full time with Boston in 2012 and immediately saw results, and he’s got a six-year run that, like Davis again, is as good as it gets for relievers. From 2012-17, Miller had a 2.01 ERA in 350 appearances, made a couple of All-Star games, and finished in the top 10 in Cy Young voting a couple of times. His biggest moment came in the 2016 postseason with Cleveland, when he started the playoffs with 16 straight scoreless innings—a streak that Aaron Ashby broke this season. Hall of Fame chances: Zero, but he was at the level for a few years.

Buster Posey, Catcher

Posey is, in my opinion, the only player with a shot at a first-ballot Hall of Fame induction this season, but it’s far from a given. By rate stats, Posey is clearly one of the best catchers of all time. Among retired catchers who played after 1900, only Hall of Famers Mickey Cochrane and Johnny Bench accrued bWAR at a higher rate; no catcher with significant games played in the history of baseball has a higher fWAR rate than Posey. His 2012 season, in which he won MVP and then helped the Giants win the World Series, is one of the top-five seasons ever by a catcher, in my opinion. Posey also won a Rookie of the Year, made seven All-Star Games, and won two additional World Series.

There might be some hangups over counting stats, though. Posey really only played 11 years (if we leave out the seven games he played in 2009) and had some injury issues at times, so he’s only got 1,371 career games played—that’s fewer than the Hall of Fame candidates who we always think of as too injured to make it, like Nomar Garciaparra, Dustin Pedroia, and David Wright. Posey only had 1,500 career hits (amongst catchers, that’s fewer than Thurman Munson, Javy López, Brad Ausmus, and Brian McCann) and 158 homers (fewer than Terry Steinbach, Charles Johnson, and Cal Raleigh, who is 29 years old). Hall of Fame chances: I think he’s pretty obviously a Hall of Fame catcher, but I don’t really know what his first ballot will look like. Could be anywhere from 40% to 80%.

Pablo Sandoval, Infielder

Posey’s teammate in San Francisco, “Kung Fu Panda” and his, ahem, somewhat round physique delighted fans for 14 years, the best of those coming by the Bay. In his first five seasons, Sandoval had two All-Star appearances and a couple of times showing up on MVP ballots, finishing all the way up at seventh in 2009, and he won three World Series in his first seven years. But conditioning issues hampered his longevity; Sandoval played seven years after 2014 but never again had more than 1.4 WAR. He finished with 1,279 hits, 153 homers, and a 111 OPS+. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.

Ervin Santana, Starting Pitcher

Santana was just a solid pitcher for a long time in semi-obscurity with the Angels, and he had a bit of a career renaissance in his 30s while pitching with the Twins. Santana appearaed in over 400 games in his career and threw almost 250 innings, and while he was rarely a star, he was just a solid pitcher for a long time. He finished in the top seven in Cy Young voting in 2008 and 2017, which were also his two career All-Star appearances. He finished his career with 151 wins and just shy of 2,000 strikeouts. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.

Kyle Seager, Third Baseman

Kyle is perhaps most well-known for being Corey’s older brother, but he was a heck of a player in a way that was easy to miss. The elder Seager quietly went about his business in Seattle, and that business was playing good defense and hitting homers. Seager was sort of a 21st century Graig Nettles, in that he never hit for much average (career .251 hitter) but he was a good home-run hitter (242 career homers while playing in the toughest homer park in the league) who walked a decent amount. Seager retired relatively young, at 33, and made just one All-Star Game, but he was a bit of an analytics darling; from 2013-17, he averaged over 5 bWAR per season. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.

Joakim Soria, Relief Pitcher

We’ve made it to one of the two Brewers on the ballot! Soria had most of his career success early: over his first four seasons, he had a 2.01 ERA (218 ERA+) in 255 innings and saved 132 games for the Royals, including two seasons over 40 saves. But after a rough season in 2011, he missed all of 2012 with an injury, and struggled a bit to find it upon returning. He had his moments, but was much more inconsistent than he’d been in his mid-20s. After a good start with the White Sox in 2018, the Brewers acquired the then-34-year-old reliever at the trade deadline; judging by his FIP/ERA split, he had rotten luck as a Brewer, but a 4.09 ERA in 26 appearances isn’t great. He pitched seven times for the Brewers in the postseason but allowed four earned runs in 4 2/3 innings. Soria finished his 14-year career in 2021 with 229 saves and a 137 ERA+. Hall of Fame chances: Zero, but Soria has a case as a top-35-ish reliever of all time.

Ryan Zimmerman, Third Baseman

Zimmerman was, for many years, the face of the fledgling Washington Nationals after they made their move from Montreal. He made his debut in 2005, the Nationals’ first year in Washington, and he spent his whole career there, finishing with 1,846 hits, 284 homers, and 417 doubles in 1,799 games. He got down-ballot MVP votes four times, won the 2019 World Series, won two Silver Sluggers and a Gold Glove, and at his peak (2009-10) was in the discussion as the best third baseman in the league. He’s a bit below Hall of Fame level, but he’s a franchise legend for sure. Hall of Fame chances: Zero, though he could get some votes.

Returning Players

For returning players, I’ll list the player, their position, their vote percentage last season, and their year on the ballot.

Chase Utley, Second Baseman, 59.1%, 4th year

As I’ve written before, Utley is a litmus test for whether you believe in analytics or not. He finished his 16-year career with 1,885 hits, 259 homers, 411 doubles, and 154 stolen bases at an astronomical success rate, with a reputation as a decent defensive second baseman. Those aren’t really Hall-of-Fame numbers on the surface. But if you believe the analytics, Utley was actually one of the best second basemen in the league, a superb all-around player whose peak was as good as any second baseman this side of Joe Morgan. (If you’re a Brewer fan, get on the hype train, because if Brice Turang is ever going to have a Hall-of-Fame argument, it’s likely to look like Utley’s.) Hall of Fame chances: He jumped almost 20 percent last year, and it seems inevitable that he’ll get there. It might be this year, it might not be, but I’m pretty sure it’s coming.

Andy Pettitte, Starting Pitcher, 48.5%, 9th year

Pettitte has a strong-ish case if you just look at the numbers: 256 wins, a 117 career ERA+, five World Series wins, and more wins and innings pitched than any pitcher in baseball history. He’s got nearly 70 fWAR. He would be an easy choice, if not a first-ballot one, in most circumstances. But Pettitte is also an admitted user of HGH, which has kept his vote totals low, even if he’s not nearly as reviled as the Barry Bonds/Roger Clemens/Álex Rodríguez triumvirate. He made a real jump last season—over 20%—but it’s probably too little too late, as he’s got to make up another 27 percent in two years. Hall of Fame chances: Low. No steroid user has broken through; it’d be weird if it was Pettitte.

Félix Hernández, Starting Pitcher, 46.1%, 3rd year

Hernández won a Cy Young in 2010, finished second twice, and finished fourth another time. From roughly 2009-2014 he was, anecdotally, one of the best pitchers in the league, and his Cy Young win—in a season in which he went just 13-12—is viewed as a watershed moment for the analytics movement. Hernández also made a massive jump in vote percentage last year, about 26%, and given that he’s a fan favorite who does not have the steroid questions that Pettitte does, and that the way we evaluate starting pitchers’ careers is changing, it seems likely that Hernández is going to make it eventually, despite just 169 career wins.

Álex Rodríguez, Infielder, 40.0%, 6th year

There’s obviously no question about Rodríguez’s ability—he’s probably one of the 30 or so greatest baseball players in history. But he’s a weirdo who everyone dislikes who definitely did lots of steroids, so his 3,115 hits, 696 homers, 2,086 RBI, three MVPs, and two Gold Gloves will just be memories, as far as the Hall of Fame goes. Hall of Fame chances: I think it’s safe to say zero, unless something crazy happens in the next five years.

Bobby Abreu, Outfielder, 30.8%, 8th year

Abreu is one of these guys who people just can’t really believe: in a seven-year stretch from 1998-2004, Abreu averaged—averaged—5.9 WAR, 23 homers, 94 RBI, 29 stolen bases, 41 doubles, and six triples per season while hitting .308/.416/.525. No one noticed, because he was playing the corner outfield for a bad team in Philadelphia. By the time he was under much brighter lights in New York and Los Angeles, he was on the wrong side of 30, and while still a solid player, was no longer a star. Still: 60.2 bWAR, 2,470 hits, 288 homers, 400 stolen bases and a 128 career OPS+. Abreu suffers from this idea that he was “not a big enough star,” and okay, whatever. Hall of Fame chances: Pretty low. Three years left and a lot of ground to make up. I think he deserves it, though.

Jimmy Rollins, Shortstop, 25.4%, 6th year

The third of four prominent Philadelphia Phillies in this group, Rollins played 17 years, accrued 2,455 hits, had over 500 doubles and 115 triples (a huge number for a modern player), hit with pop (231 homers), stole bases (470 steals), played good enough defense to win four Gold Gloves, and won an MVP in 2007 when he led the league in runs scored and triples, hit 30 homers and 38 doubles, stole 41 bases in 47 tries, and won a Gold Glove. Analytics are not especially kind to Rollins; he had just a .324 career OBP and 95 career OPS+, and while his counting stats look pretty solid, he spent much of his career in one of the biggest offensive eras in league history and thus doesn’t look as good when comparing to his peers. Hall of Fame chances: Not zero, but not very good.

Cole Hamels, Starting Pitcher, 23.8%, 2nd year

The last of the Phillies here, Hamels has a surprising amount of bWAR (59, which is 19 more than Lester, for example). It’s interesting to compare him to Hernández; King Félix is pretty universally considered a better pitcher, but Hamels had basically the same number of wins (163) and had a 123 career ERA+ compared to Hernández’s 117. Hamels was basically just never bad, and though he never rose to Cy Young levels (he never finished higher than fifth), he just had a long, productive career. He also had a legendary postseason run in 2008, when he was the MVP of the NLCS and the World Series; in three starts in those two series, he went 3-0 and allowed just three runs in 22 innings. Hall of Fame chances: It depends a lot on this year, I think—he needs to make a big jump, but 23.8% is a really good showing in his first season.

Dustin Pedroia, Second Baseman, 20.7%, 3rd year

Pedroia’s career is viewed by many to be too short to be a Hall of Famer, but as mentioned, he played over 100 more games than Posey did. Pedroia has over 50 career WAR, he won an MVP and a Rookie of the Year, and won three Gold Gloves and a Silver Slugger. It was basically over at age 33, but prior to the injuries that plagued him after his 30th birthday, Pedroia was cruising toward 3,000 hits, 600 doubles, and a first-ballot situation. I’d make a strong argument for him, which I might do next week. Hall of Fame chances: Low, but not entirely nonexistent.

Mark Buehrle, Starting Pitcher, 20.0%, 7th year

Buehrle is kind of a favorite amongst the people who cheer for him. He, like Hamels, had 59 career WAR; he won over 200 games, was the best pitcher on a team that cruised to a World Series, he threw a perfect game, and he made five All-Star teams and won four Gold Gloves. But his number one trait is his consistency: no pitcher in modern baseball history can boast the consistency with which Buehrle did his job. From his first full season in 2001 until his last year in 2015, Buehrle never made fewer than 30 starts, and the only time he missed 200 innings pitched was in his last season… when he had 198 2/3. Hall of Fame chances: Almost zero, but he rules, and I think you can make a case.

Omar Vizquel, Shortstop, 18.4%, 10th year

Vizquel looked to be on his way to the Hall, and then there were gross allegations and his support tanked. I’m good with that for reasons both personal and baseball: as a baseball player, he did get up to 2,877 hits and he was one of the great defensive shortstops, but he was a bad hitter (career 82 OPS+) who got to the numbers he did simply by playing for an immense amount of time (24 seasons). Vizquel only topped four WAR once in his career, and that’s just not a Hall of Famer for me. Hall of Fame chances: Zero, at least via the BBWAA. Could see a committee put him in some day.

David Wright, Third Baseman, 14.8%, 4th year

Wright, like Pedroia, has what I consider a real case despite the general feeling that his career was too short because of injuries. From 2005-2013 he was one of the best players in the league, and had three seasons of at least 6.9 WAR, topping out at 8.3 in 2007. He won two Gold Gloves and two Silver Sluggers, and I think in retrospect that he deserved the 2007 MVP (he finished fourth). He finished with 1,777 hits, 390 doubles, 242 homers, 196 stolen bases, and a 133 OPS+, but that’s too little for most voters. Hall of Fame chances: Basically zero, but I kind of disagree.

Francisco Rodríguez, Relief Pitcher, 11.8%, 5th year

Here is the second former Brewer on the list! K-Rod has his own off-the-field issues, but he’s sixth all time with 437 saves, and the 62 saves he had in 2008 are five more than anyone else has ever had in a season. I’d put Rodríguez in the top 12-or-so relievers of all time, but… how many relievers should really be in the Hall of Fame? It’s a tough question. Hall of Fame chances: He’s not going to make it, but it makes sense that he’s sticking around the ballot.

Torii Hunter, Outfielder, 8.7%, 7th year

Hunter has a great qualitative case. He hit 353 homers, had almost 2,500 hits, and was known in his time as one of the best, if not the best, defensive center fielders in the game. But analytics haven’t been so kind to Hunter: he’s got only 50.6 career bWAR, mostly because 1) he didn’t walk much and 2) his defense was probably not quite as good as we all thought it was. Mileage varies on those conclusions, though, so he’s stuck around for seven years, though this could be the year he falls under 5%. Hall of Fame chances: another one that a committee could do something surprising with one day. Heck, he’d be a better inductee than Harold Baines.

Offseason open chat and discussion: November 16th

The 2026 season has come and gone for the Atlanta Braves, but that does not mean that the action is done. The team has already made a notable signing of Evan Phillips.

Some fans may not remember how dominant Phillips was simply because he missed time due to injury. However, he was a force when healthy and MLB Trade Rumors had him ranked as the 29th best free agent available.

Currently the Braves project to have the 7th highest payroll in MLB. This could potentially limit them in more spending, but considering they just ponied up for an RP when the relief arms they had were already a strength, it points to them potentially adding more.

Ideally a shortstop and an SP would be a great place to start. What are some options maybe have not floated around the internet that make sense for the Braves? Let’s go over them in the comments.

The Arizona Diamondbacks dismal history of turning Japanese

TOKYO, JAPAN - MARCH 10: Teruaki Sato #7 of Team Japan hits a double in the first inning during the 2026 World Baseball Classic Pool C game between Czechia and Japan at Tokyo Dome on March 10, 2026 in Tokyo, Japan. (Photo by Toru Hanai/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Have you heard? The Diamondbacks are in on Teruaki Sato! The third baseman batted .306 with thirty-nine home-runs for the Hanshin Tigers, and was made available through the MLB posting system at the start of November. Sure would be nice to have him in Sedona Red, and that would take care of the hot corner in Arizona for the foreseeable future. But let’s pump the brakes here. Not least because the root of this speculation is basically a single sentence from Ken Rosenthal on Wednesday. This is what it said.

The Diamondbacks are doing their due diligence on Japanese slugger Teruaki Sato, according to people briefed on their plans.

“Due diligence”. I would certainly hope that’s within the front office’s remit, but it’s considerably less exciting than the way it has been spun in some (though to be fair, not all) places. Everything else in the report is basically speculation – albeit of a reasonable kind, noting how Sato would fit the team’s need for left-handed power. Sure. Though are there any major-league teams out there who could not find room for a player with a projected 143 wRC+ and 5.5 WAR? Don’t all rush.

A little further was this report from the Arizona Republic, the following day. But, again, this provided nothing more definitive than “The Diamondbacks are expected to pursue slugger Teruaki Sato,” followed by more or less the same speculation about him filling a position of need. Though I do trust Nick Piecoro more than Rosenthal when it comes to the local franchise, and when Nick says, “sources confirmed,” I believe it. But, still: there’s a gulf between that and anything of genuine note. I could issue a formal press release telling people I am “expected to pursue” Salma Hayek, but I doubt this would lead to anything beyond a stern rebuke from Mrs. SnakePit.

You’ll also forgive me if I feel a little gunshy about this kind of rumblings. If previous history tells us anything, it’s that Arizona acquiring Sato would probably require all other 29 teams to engage in a lock-out, while the D-backs blithely continue business as usual. But if you’ve forgotten, let’s review some of the previous times the D-backs were connected to one of the hot Japanese players, and what happened as a result [spoiler alert: nothing].

Hiroki Kuroda, 2007

To find the first time we were seriously teased by the prospect of a Japanese star coming to Arizona, you need to go back to the middle of the Josh Byrnes era, when he was coming off a successful season, flush with winning the NL West. The D-backs were one of the teams to bid on this pitcher. MLB Trade Rumors said their first offer was 3/$27m, and was then increased, though Jack Magruder’s sources called that initial report “inaccurate.” The Dodgers, Mariners and Royals also had offers on the table, and – stop me if this sounds familiar – Los Angeles won out, with a 3/$35.2m offer. Kuroda had an 111 ERA+ and 6.8 bWAR in those three seasons.

Masahiro Tanaka, 2013

The SnakePit got particularly excited about this possibility, writing an entire article projecting how the pitcher might do in the majors, and trying to crowd-source a potential contract. The D-backs actually made an offer to Tanaka, reported as being around $115 million for six years. Polite laughter behind the hand likely ensured on receipt of this suggestions, because Tanaka ended going to the Yankees for more years (7), and an oce-lot more money ($155 million) than AZ offered. He was decent, with a 114 ERA+ and 17.4 bWAR over the course of the contract, but not really worth what New York shelled out. The Arizona estimate was likely closer to his true value.

Kenta Maeda, 2015

“I love Maeda. I love him. We have a lot of video and film, and we have people who have seen him. We think that he’s got a chance to be very successful in Major League Baseball. We’re going to try to be in on the market when he does post, if he does post.” — Arizona GM Dave Stewart.

This might have been the most aggressive the team was in their pursuit of a Japanese star – at least for a while. The team lost out on the top free-agent, Johnny Cueto, and then Dave Stewart switch focus to Maeda, with the team scouting the pitcher. MLB Trade Rumors went as far as predicting the D-backs would sign him, paying the $20m posting fee, plus a five-year, $60 million contract. Nope. They got Zack Greinke instead, with Maeda instead signing a very incentive-heavy, eight-year deal with the Dodgers. He only got half-way through it before going to the Twins, and all told, this Japanese player fell well short of the hype.

Shohei Ohtani, 2017

Amusing to note that the first reply under this Tweet, was from Jack Sommers, with a pithy “Lol.” Were they ever reallyin the running? Well, perhaps for about an hour. Because earlier that afternoon, a Tweet reported Yankees’ GM Bryan Cashman as saying, “If he was a West Coast team in a smaller market, he’d be excited right now.” Of course, about a week later, that turned out to be the Angels.

Yoshinobu Yamamoto, 2023

Initially, it didn’t seem like the Diamondbacks were interested in Yamamoto. But in mid-November, Jon Heyman wrote a piece stating that the D-backs and Tigers were among the suitors – as well as every big market team. That generated a flurry of excitement in Arizona, coming off the back of their unexpected run to the NL pennant – including World Series starter Joe Mantiply… So, acquiring starting pitching did make sense. However, the price for Yamamoto’s services quickly escalated far beyond the point where the D-backs could compete, the pitcher instead becoming part of the Dodgers ludicrous spending spree that winter. Three years and 12.7 bWAR later, he has likely been worth it so far.

Roki Sasaki, 2024

There were initial hopes Arizona might actually have a chance here. Because Sasaki was posted at 23 years old under international amateur bonus pool restrictions, it wasn’t just a case of who had the most money. Team executives traveled to Japan to watch him pitch in the 2024 campaign, and his agent said, “I think there’s an argument to be made that a smaller mid-market team might be more beneficial for him.” But in late December, when Sasaki narrowed the list of suitors for face-to-face meetings, Arizona were on the outside once again. Sasaki went to the Dodgers. There’s a shocker. So much for that “mid-market” thing, eh?

The signed

It hasn’t been entirely negative, although reliever Yoshihisa Hirano is the only time where the D-backs have succeeded in recruiting and signing a player directly from NPB to a Major League contract. The 33-year-old Orix Buffaloes closer agreed to a two-year, $6 million deal in December 2017. He was very good in 2018, posting a 2.44 ERA. But that almost doubled the next year, ballooning to 4.75. After one more season in America (with the Mariners), he turned to Orix in Japan, and indeed, pitched for them as recently as this season.

There was also left-handed pitcher Yuhei Nakaushiro, signed as a prospect out of the minor leagues there, after failing to make an impact in NPB. He was known as “The Japanese Big Unit” for his fastball/slider combination, though even when signed, expectations were low, one Japanese writer saying, “The odds for Nakaushiro to make any impact for the D-backs are slimmer than an upcoming Apple product.” So it proved. Though his overall numbers weren’t bad, with a 2.95 ERA across 131 minor-league innings, an ugly 2018 with a 5.29 ERA as a 28-year-old in Double-A saw the D-backs release him. Naksushiro returned to Japan, retiring after the 2019 season.

Conclusions

Basically, the Diamondbacks have been “in” – for some loose definition of the word – on just about every big Japanese star to become available. Absolutely none of them have landed in Arizona. There’s little or no reason to think that Teruaki Sato will be any different. On the last ep of Snakes Alive, Jack put the odds of him coming here at ten percent. I think that’s probably optimistic. Given there’s thirty teams, even if you cut out ten who couldn’t find space for him, that still leaves 20 possibilities. There’s no reason to think the D-backs will be better than average among them, which would give them just a five percent shot. With the likes of the Yankees, Mets, Phillies and Dodgers reportedly in pursuit… Yeah, nah.

Of course, I’d love to be proven wrong!

MLB free agents: Who should San Francisco Giants target?

The San Francisco Giants have major work to do in the offseason after a lackluster 2026 season.

The Giants' season started full of optimism with a first-year, first-time MLB manager, Tony Vitello, leading the way. The high hopes quickly turned to despair in The City as San Francisco's record was pummeled, finishing at the bottom of the National League at 65-97.

Small wins came throughout the season, but mostly misfortune, due to a combination of losing streaks, lack of production, and injuries to some of the highest-paid players, including Harrison Bader's scooter accident, which made the contracts seem like an overpay.

San Francisco didn't have the offensive explosiveness that experts expected going into the season and one of their biggest questions, defensively, was their bullpen. Teams have asked about their ace pitcher Logan Webb, but the Giants will not trade Webb, "no matter how many teams continue to ask", according USA TODAY Sports baseball insider and columnist Bob Nightengale.

Nightengale wrote that San Francisco wants to add starters, but is interested in seeking at least two free-agent starters, and that Tarik Skubal's price tag, which seeks to exceed $325 million, is too high for their liking.

San Francisco announced James Rowson as their new offensive coordinator on the Major League coaching staff under manager Tony Vitello to help with the Giants' hitting woes.

Rowson, 50, spent the last three seasons as hitting coach with the New York Yankees who finished second in the Majors with 223 home runs, sixth with a .409 slugging percentage and tied for ninth with 739 runs scored. It's an area that Rowson can help San Francisco with in 2027. The 2026-27 offseason is their opportunity to improve.

Here are free agents the San Francisco Giants should look to target during the offseason:

San Francisco Giants free agent targets

The Giants need consistent hitters if they're going to build their core with Rafael Devers and rising star Bryce Eldridge. But they also need to focus on defense and the bullpen is a major concern. With money tied to Devers, Willy Adames, Matt Chapman, Jung Hoo Lee and Bader, they will have to prioritize one or the other.

Here's who San Francisco should target during free agency in the 2026-27 offseason:

SP, Freddy Peralta

Freddy Peralta, 31, is the reigning ALCS MVP and with lots in the tank at 31-years-old. Through 169 innings pitched, Peralta finished last season with 156 strikeouts and 63 walks, with a 4.42 ERA and 1.33 WHIP. If the Giants are serious about improving their pitching, Peralta - coming off a World Series appearance - is a pickup that could change things for San Francisco. The starting pitcher would immediately bring credibility to the Giants and would be a great way to begin free agency.

SP, Michael King

San Diego Padres starting pitcher Michael King chose to opt out of the final year of his contract and test the market instead. Teams in the market looking to improve their bullpen would love him. King, 32, is coming off a career-year with 185 innings pitched, he held a 3.21 ERA. He was a huge lift for the Padres in the NLDS. His services would bring experience and consistency to a team like San Francisco.

OF/3B, Teruaki Sato

The next Japanese star is coming to MLB. Teruaki Sato officially began a 45-day negotiation window after a Nov. 1 announcement that the 27-year-old left-handed slugger hit the MLB post system as a free agent. Sato played for the Hanshin Tigers of Nippon Professional Baseball, Japan's top professional baseball league.

He's played there the previous five seasons and hit 163 home runs. He won back-to-back Central League MVP. Last season, he won a Triple Crown with .306 average, 39 home runs, and 106 RBIs. Sato is athletic and has a strong arm, making him switchable between third base and outfield. He's already being sought out by other MLB teams; San Francisco should get in line.

2B, Jazz Chisholm Jr.

Many might be out on Jazz Chisolm Jr. after a down year for his standards, but a change of scenery to a place where he's more appreciated could help. Chisolm, 29, brings at least, a really really good baserunner. He stole 41 bases in 2026. At bat, obviously not his best recent season with 19 homers but a turn around can happen. It's baseball. It wasn't long ago that Chisolm put together a season where he hit 30 home runs and stole 30 bases with a .800 OPS. That version of Chisolm still exists.

RP, Adrian Morejón

Adrian Morejón is a 27-year-old relief pitcher in his prime. He spent his entire career with the San Diego Padres but it's time for a change. The Giants should see if he's interested in staying in California, up north, of course. Morejón pitched 86 innings and had three saves, posting a 2.83 ERA with 107 strikeouts and 28 walks in the 2026 season. He joins Mason Miller, Tyler Rogers and Cade Smith as the only pitchers to allow less than 3.0 ERA in at least 60 innings. San Francisco needs a bullpen, Morejón would help Webb out tremendously. Although he would be an expensive signing.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: MLB free agents: Who should San Francisco Giants target?

'Bar-B-Cast': Top questions for all 15 American League teams

The offseason sparks a flurry of speculation and strategic maneuvers across Major League Baseball, and this winter feels even more charged with a possible lockout looming on Dec. 1. For all 15 American League clubs, significant questions hang over their rosters. The conversation between Yahoo Sports’ Jordan Shusterman and Jake Mintz on the “Baseball Bar-B-Cast” podcast focused on these pivotal uncertainties as each team plots their path forward in a rapidly shifting landscape.

As clubs maneuver through Rule 5 protections, Tuesday’s qualifying offer deadline and ownership meetings this week, every American League franchise finds itself at a crossroads, their major questions shaping their futures and the complexion of the entire league heading into an unpredictable 2027 season.

A key theme that emerged was whether new leadership under Ken Babby and Patrick Zalupski would ramp up spending after a World Series run. The Rays already exercised a record $20 million option on Drew Rasmussen. Is this a sign of bigger investments to come, or will they remain conservative?

Will their current offensive group — featuring Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, and a newly entrenched Spencer Jones in center — remain intact or are significant changes on the horizon? The infield, especially third base, remains unsettled due to a weak market, raising concerns about an impactful addition.

How will the team resolve its outfield and first base surplus?

Jarren Duran and Masataka Yoshida are potential trade or non-tender candidates, and it remains to be seen if Boston will find creative ways to move underperforming or expensive players while integrating new signings like Jake Bowers.

There’s urgency to capitalize on a competitive window with Gunnar Henderson approaching free agency. Will the Orioles aggressively pursue top-tier pitching, or make more conservative additions, as they consider how to surround Henderson and newcomer Pete Alonso with enough support?

The primary question centers on rejuvenating the offense. With a right-handed heavy lineup and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. needing a rebound, what path — free agents like Seiya Suzuki or major trades — returns Toronto to contention? Budget constraints and disappointing contracts complicate matters.

Will the surprising deadline aggression seen last season spill into the winter, or will the club revert to its usual penny-pinching? Further, is a trade of outfielder Steven Kwan possible, or will Cleveland finally spend on outside talent?

The central challenge is balancing vibes from a surprising postseason run with the need to fix a high-strikeout offense. How will Jerry Reinsdorf’s approach as team owner shape spending on much-needed upgrades, especially in the rotation?

Does Joe Ryan return as a trade chip?

The front office sits at a crossroads: try to capitalize on a transitioning division or move key assets for a longer-term reboot? The next steps remain murky with no clear direction emerging.

Will the organization make even a token effort to re-sign Tarik Skubal, or is its participation in his sweepstakes a mere façade to appease fans? The expectation seems to be the latter.

A surprising statistical revelation suggested their offense performed better than expected, masked by horrendous pitching. Can the Royals meaningfully improve their woeful rotation, or will they waste these under-appreciated bats for another year?

With Carlos Correa returning and an infield overloaded with talent, will the Astros finally break up their core for roster balance — or stubbornly try to make it work again?

Which pitcher do they trade, and what do they get in return? The Mariners’ rotation depth is enviable, but an upgrade to their right-handed hitting — especially around the infield —might come through only a bold deal.

Are they actually about to pull the trigger on a Corey Seager trade, and if so, does it signal a full rebuild or just a retool? Their direction is pivotal for the division’s power balance.

Will new leadership do what it takes to attract legitimate MLB talent, perhaps handing out an over-market contract to anchor their staff? The uncertainty around location and ambition leave the A’s with more questions than answers.

What is going on? Uncertainty abounds as the team awaits sale finalization to Stan Kroenke — a situation that may consign the Angels to weeks of inactivity and indecision at just the wrong time.

🖥️ Watch this full episode on YouTube

Check out all episodes of Baseball Bar-B-Cast and the rest of the Yahoo Sports podcast family at https://apple.co/3zEuTQj or at yahoosports.tv.

Hall of Fame ballot revealed for 2027, including several ex-Mets

NEW YORK, NY - SEPTEMBER 8: David Wright #5 of the New York Mets, who has not played for the Mets for over two years because of back and neck medical problems and is looking to make a return to the Mets, gets hugged by former teammate Asdrubal Cabrera #13 of the Philadelphia Phillies after he was batting in a simulated game before an MLB baseball game against the Philadelphia Phillies on September 8, 2018 at Citi Field in the Flushing neighborhood of the Queens borough of New York City. Mets won 10-5. (Photo by Paul Bereswill/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Earlier today, the Baseball Writers’ Association of America revealed their 2027 Hall of Fame ballot, and there are 27 hopefuls vying for their chance to be immortalized forever among baseball’s greatest players.

Of the 27 players who are looking to be enshrined in the Hall of Fame, 13 are returning to the ballot for another year. Of those, three have ties to the Mets. Most notably, David Wright will be back for his fourth go-around on the ballot. He narrowly escaped dropping off the first by securing 6.2% of the vote. He picked up 8.1% of the vote in 2025 and nearly doubled it in 2026, earning 14.8% of the vote. The Mets legend, who had his number retired by the organization in 2025, has a long way to go, but he has gained some traction in recent years. Still time, is not on his side, as he has seven more chances to pick up a deficit of around 60% in the voting.

Beyond Wright, Francisco Rodríguez and Bobby Abreu also called Queens home for parts of their respective careers. Rodríguez served as the team’s closer for parts of three seasons from 2009-2011 and was named an All-Star in 2009. He has failed to gain traction since joining the ballot in 2023, debuting with 10.8% in 2023 before dipping to 7.8% in 2024. He bounced back with 10.2% in 2025 and 11.8% in 2026, but that only represents a 1% gain since his first year on the ballot. Abreu, meanwhile, played the final season of his career in New York and posted -0.2 fWAR after posting 59.7 fWAR in his career, most notably with the Phillies. This is the outfielder’s eighth year on the ballot, and he made his largest leap last year, jumping from 19.5% in 2025 to 30.8% in 2026. Still, with three years, left, he has a steep hill to climb to make it to Cooperstown.

The remaining 14 players are first-timers. This includes two players have previously suited up for the Mets: Jay Bruce and Asdrúbal Cabrera

Jay Bruce

Bruce is a two-time Met who had little impact at the plate but was involved in some big moves. He was brought in from Cincinnati ahead of the 2016 trade deadline in exchange for Dilson Herrera to fortify the team’s lineup and help their push for the postseason. However, the outfielder struggled in his new setting, slashing .219/.294/.391 with eight home runs after being named to the NL All-Star team with Cincinnati earlier that year. He stuck around the following season and had his best stretch in New York, posting a 121 wRC+ and hitting 29 homers in 103 games before being placed on waivers and traded to Cleveland for Ryder Ryan in the great sell-off of 2017.

Bruce found his way back to New York in 2018 on a three-year deal worth $39 million but was dealt away one year later as part of the Edwin Diaz/Jarred Kelenic trade. Overall, he posted a 106 wRC+ and slugged 319 home runs in his career, with most of his impact coming as a member of the Reds. As a Met, he posted a 103 wRC+ and hit 43 home runs with a .754 OPS and 1.3 fWAR in 247 games.

Asdrúbal Cabrera

You could make a real argument that Asdrúbal Cabrera is one of the more underrated and beloved Mets of that mid-2010s. He signed a two-year contract before the 2016 season and had a really strong campaign to help the team earn a Wild Card berth. His most iconic moment came when he slugged a walk-off three-run home run in the 11th inning of a critical game against the Phillies on September 22, which resulted in one of the most memorable bat flips in franchise history.

Cabrera stuck around for the entirety of the 2016 and 2017 seasons and for part of the 2018 campaign before he was sent to the rival Phillies for Franklyn Kilome. In total, he hit .279/.339/.464 with 55 home runs in 374 games for the Mets. For his walk-off home run alone, he will always be have a special place in Mets fans’ hearts.

First timers on the ballot:
Jake Arrieta
Jay Bruce
Asdrúbal Cabrera
Starlin Castro
Wade Davis
Brett Gardner
Jon Lester
Andrew Miller
Buster Posey
Pablo Sandoval
Ervin Santana
Kyle Seager
Joakim Soria
Ryan Zimmerman

Players returning to the ballot:
Bobby Abreu
Mark Buehrle
Cole Hamels
Félix Hernández
Torii Hunter
Dustin Pedroia
Andy Pettitte
Alex Rodriguez
Francisco Rodríguez
Jimmy Rollins
Chase Utley
Omar Vizquel
David Wright

Votes are due in by December 31, and results will be revealed on January 19. Players must earn at least 75% of the vote to be enshrined in the Baseball Hall of Fame. The induction ceremony will take place on July 25 in Cooperstown.

2027 Willie McCovey Memorial Community Prospect List No. 9

Gavin Kilen making a throw.
RICHMOND, VA - AUGUST 09: Gavin Kilen #7 of the Richmond Flying Squirrels throws during the game between the Reading Fightin Phils and the Richmond Flying Squirrels at CarMax Park on Sunday, August 9, 2026 in Richmond, Virginia. (Photo by Matthew Mitrani/Minor League Baseball via Getty Images)

We’re so close to a top 10! As the holidays approach, the 2027 Willie McCovey Memorial Community Prospect List grows, as we seek to rank the top 44 prospects in the San Francisco Giants organization.

Our latest vote was a landslide: 72 community members voted on the four-name ballot, and 53 of those voters chose one player. That player? Shortstop Gavin Kilen, who has been voted as the No. 8 prospect in the system. That’s a drop of one spot for Kilen, who debuted on the CPL at No. 7 a year ago.

Kilen, a left-handed hitter, was taken by the Giants in the first round of the 2025 draft, with the 13th overall pick. His debut last year, in Low-A, was brief (10 games), limited by injuries, and not that great. Despite that, the Giants had Kilen — who played college ball for Tony Vitello at Tennessee — open the 2026 season with High-A Eugene.

He needed exactly one game to justify that decision. In the Emeralds’ season-opener, Kilen smashed not one, but two home runs, including a walk-off two-run shot. That kicked off an outrageous opening week for Kilen, who turned 22 in late March. Over his first five games at the level, he recorded 10 hits, five extra-base hits, and 10 runs batted in, while drawing three walks.

Eventually he came back to earth, but he maintained strong performance all the way to the All-Star break, hitting .282/.350/.462 for an .811 OPS and a 112 wRC+ in 78 games. That earned him a promotion to AA Richmond, though an injury limited him to just 33 games there. But he posted a five-game hitting streak to start his tenure in the Eastern League, and ended his stint there with a .297/.343/.469 slash line, resulting in identical overall numbers to his time in Eugene: an .811 OPS and a 112 wRC+.

As advertised, Kilen’s contact skills were among the best in the system. In addition to his .286 batting average across the two levels, he struck out just 14.2% of the time. His power was modest — he had 11 home runs in 492 plate appearances — but he showed a lot of line drive ability, as he hit 37 doubles on the year, which was tied for fifth in all of the Minor Leagues (interestingly, the Giants had four of the eight most prolific doubles hitters in the Minors this year).

Kilen has always been viewed a bit more as a high floor prospect than a high ceiling one, and both sides of that coin were shown this year. The contact skills certainly look like they can play at any level, and he’s defensively sound. On the other hand, he’s almost certainly headed for second base sometime between now and his MLB debut, is mediocre on the power front, and stole just one base this season. As is, he’s a quite good prospect … but if he can address one of those areas, he could become a very good one.

One of the questions entering 2027 is where Kilen will start. He played well in AA, but were his 33 games there enough for the Giants to feel comfortable moving him up to AAA? Logistically, that would be ideal, as it would allow he and Jhonny Level to play shortstop everyday, rather than split duties in AA. But it would also make sense if the Giants want him to get a little more seasoning in the Eastern League.

Either way, he’s in prime position to start making a case for a big league debut. If not at the beginning of the year, Kilen will certainly be in AAA at some point, and then he’s only one call away from the bigs, where the Giants currently have a few question marks at second base, his likely future position. He’s one to watch, that’s for sure.

Now let’s add to the list, and we’ve got some new names to vote on. As a reminder, voting takes place in the comment section now.

The list so far

  1. Josuar González — SS
  2. Jackson Flora — RHP
  3. Luis Hernández — SS
  4. Jhonny Level — SS
  5. Ramon Marquez — RHP
  6. Bo Davidson — OF
  7. Jacob Bresnahan — LHP
  8. Gavin Kilen — SS

Note: Clicking on the above names will link to the CPL where they were voted onto the list.

No. 9 prospect nominees

Carson Bolemon — 19.7-year old LHP — yet to debut

ArgenisCayama — 20.1-year old RHP — 4.87 ERA/4.27 FIP in Low-A (57.1 IP)

TrevorCohen — 23.0-year old OF — .803 OPS/117 wRC+ in High-A (380 PA); .736 OPS/99 wRC+ in AA (228 PA)

ParksHarber — 25.1-year old 3B — .879 OPS/131 wRC+ in AA (298 PA); .739 OPS/98 wRC+ in AAA (250 PA)

JonielHernandez — 17.8-year old SS — .978 OPS/132 wRC+ in DSL (238 PA)

DakotaJordan — 23.5-year old OF — .879 OPS/125 wRC+ in High-A (355 PA); .697 OPS/87 wRC+ in AA (88 PA)

HenryLalane — 22.5-year old LHP — 2.74 ERA/2.63 FIP in Low-A (62.1 IP); 3.86 ERA/4.78 FIP in High-A (37.1 IP)

KeynerMartinez — 22.3-year old RHP — 4.61 ERA/4.77 FIP in Low-A (93.2 IP)

Note: Each player’s first name links to their Baseball-Reference page, and their last name links to their Fangraphs page.All stats are from the 2026 season.

Pirates sign former Astros outfielder to one-year deal

BALTIMORE, MARYLAND - AUGUST 22: Chas McCormick #20 of the Houston Astros bats against the Baltimore Orioles at Oriole Park at Camden Yards on August 22, 2025 in Baltimore, Maryland. (Photo by G Fiume/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The Pittsburgh Pirates have agreed to their first free-agent contract of the offseason.

Pittsburgh has signed outfielder Chas McCormick to a one-year, minor-league contract for the 2027 season. Ari Alexander of 7News Boston first reported the deal on Monday afternoon.

A longtime member of the Houston Astros, McCormick totaled 502 games over five seasons (2021-2025), including the 2022 World Series Champions. He slashed .247/.321/.413 with 52 doubles, five triples, 56 home runs, 196 RBIs, 37 steals, and a .734 OPS before departing the organization two years ago. 

McCormick signed a minor-league deal with the Chicago Cubs in January, was released in July, re-signed three days later, and was once again a free agent at the beginning of the 2026-27 offseason. 

In a strong season with the Iowa Cubs, McCormick earned a .285/.383/.468 slash line with a .851 OPS over 102 games. The right-handed bat totaled 101 hits, 23 doubles, 14 home runs, 59 RBIs, stole 17 bases, and played all three outfield spots in 2026. He did not appear in a game for the Cubs this season.

McCormick is a native of West Chester, Pennsylvania, and a Millersville baseball alum. The Astros selected him in the 21st round of the 2017 MLB Draft. That round no longer exists after MLB shrank the draft from 40 to 20 rounds in 2021.

The 31-year-old veteran will receive an invite to spring training, whenever that may be. 

MLB and the MLB Players Association have until December 1 to agree to a new CBA, which looks significantly unlikely, and a certainty that MLB will lock out the players in a matter of weeks.

The Pirates could use McCormick in a fourth outfielder role or as a depth piece in case of injury. 

Ben Cherington said at the GM meetings last week that most of Ryan O’Hearn’s reps will be split between first base and DH. That opens the door for Esmerlyn Valdez and Jake Mangum in right field, testing the Pirates’ depth. McCormick adds to the room as the first move of the offseason.

Braves prospect Owen Carey makes Baseball America’s AFL Hot Sheet

UNITED STATES - OCTOBER 21: Isaiah Drake #4 and Owen Carey #9 of the Glendale Desert Dogs pose for a photo in the dugout prior to the game between the Desert Dogs and the Javelinas at Peoria Sports Complex on Wednesday, October 21, 2026 in Peoria, AZ United States. (Photo by Jill Weisleder/Minor League Baseball via Getty Images)

On the final hot sheet of the 2026 Arizona Fall League season, Atlanta Braves outfield prospect Owen Carey has played his way onto the list. Carey hit .444/.688/1.132 with a homer, double, four runs scored, and eight batted in to put himself on the list as the #6 prospect of the week.

For his entire time in the AFL Carey hit .328/.438/.492 with three doubles, a pair of triples, and a home run with 10 walks to just seven strikeouts over his 73 plate appearances. Carey started out a bit slow in the AFL, but ended very strong to post that stat line.

With Carey spending his last 35 games in Double-A in 2026 and his strong 18 games in the AFL, the expectation for him in 2027 is likely to open back in Columbus with a chance to receive a promotion to Triple-A at some point this coming season. Depending on the status of big league ball and the upcoming lockout, he could be positioning himself to make his big league debut at some point in the next year.

The Top 100 Cubs of all time, No. 93: Vic Saier

Vic Saier in 1913 | | Getty Images

Vic Saier had five really good years for the Cubs, including receiving some downballot MVP votes twice, and you probably have never heard of him.

This is partly because his career neatly fit into a Cubs interregnum. He debuted for the Cubs in 1911, one year after they finished their run of four NL pennants in five years, and was done by 1917, the year before they again were NL champions.

In 1913, Saier, a first baseman, batted .289/.370/.480, led the NL in triples with 21, and stole 26 bases. Incidentally, Saier is the most recent Cub to have 20+ triples in a season (the only other one is Frank Schulte, who had 21 in 1911, when he was league MVP, and we’ll see Schulte later in this series). The only Cub who’s approached 20 since 1911 is Ryne Sandberg, who had 19 in his 1984 MVP season.

Saier also got downballot MVP votes in 1914, but his numbers weren’t quite as good: .240/.357/.415, but with 18 home runs, which was second-best in the NL that year. That was a tremendous number of homers in the Deadball Era, too. Per Saier’s SABR bio:

Four of those homers came against the great Christy Mathewson, who said that Vic had hit some of the hardest balls ever hit against him. The Cubs had fallen apart into warring camps—they weren’t the most harmonious bunch even in the days when they were winning pennants—but in the midst of all the turmoil, the Chicago newspapers lauded Saier as “The Quiet Star.” Vic had a self-effacing personality and went about his business with a minimum of fuss and bother.

Saier suffered a leg injury in 1915, though his numbers were still decent, and he was a solid 2.3 bWAR player in 1916, too. But his career basically ended after this injury in early 1917:

In a game against the St. Louis Cardinals on April 14, 1917, Saier broke his leg in a collision at home plate when he tried to score from second on a single. His season was over after just six games. Vic might not have been ready to come back even in 1918, but we’ll never know for sure because he elected to work at a defense plant to help the war effort instead of playing baseball. The Cubs sold Saier’s rights to the Pittsburgh Pirates, with whom Vic attempted a comeback in 1919. 

Saier batted .223/.306/.313 in 58 games for the Pirates in 1919, then left baseball and returned to his hometown of Lansing, Michigan, where he died May 14, 1967, aged 76. Saier posted 15.0 bWAR in seven Cubs seasons.

One stat that will infuriate you about the 2026 Cincinnati Reds

LOS ANGELES, CA - SEPTEMBER 07: Cincinnati Reds third baseman Ke'bryan Hayes (3) throws to first base during the game between the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Cincinnati Reds on September 07, 2026 at Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles. (Photo by David Dennis/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

The 2026 Cincinnati Reds took the unique route of building up morale and expectations based on unexpected (and unsustainable) early success only to collapse so hard, so far for the remainder of the season that they still finished dead last within their own division. Despite somehow finding themselves 9 games over .500 at 20-11 at the end of April, only the cityless A’s and hilarisad Colorado Rockies finished with a worse run differential than did the NL Central cellar-dwellers, meaning a whole stack of things must have gone catastrophically wrong in the process to get there.

You can point your finger at a number of ends that sunk their ship. They couldn’t hit. They couldn’t field. They couldn’t pitch. They stopped running.

Each of those blanket statements carry a lot of truth, as that’s how you find a team so hopelessly buried in the standings at season’s end. But in digging back through all the gross and negligent numbers posted by that last place attempt at a franchise, one began to stand out to me perhaps more than any other given the previously stated desires and goals of the front office when putting this roster together.

No single player on the Reds roster right now is more emblematic of the gulf between the fantasies of the powers that be and the realities that are (and have been) than 3B Ke’Bryan Hayes. Hayes was not drafted and developed by this front office – they sought him out from a division rival based on everything they thought they’d watched and seen for years. When the cards were in their hands and they could have pursued literally anyone during their unexpected (and unsustainable) run to the final NL Wild Card spot in 2025, it was Hayes they went and acquired, doing so while paying a pretty penny for a piece the most similar franchise to them in the sport could not wait to get rid of.

We need not look each other in the eyes when discussing the offense that Hayes has brought to the table in that time. We can stare at our feet and both mumble that he’s been by far and away the worst offensive player in the sport in that time, posting a stretch of awfulness that rivals the worst by any player who’s ever played before.

We can even hem and haw before talking in theoreticals about how his presence as the team’s targeted 3B altered the entire intended fabric of the infield as it forced Sal Stewart, reigning Rookie of the Year, off of his usual defensive spot and down the spectrum to 1B while still just a budding 22 year old.

Instead of all that, though, there’s one thing in particular that drives me absolutely bonkers regarding the situation, and that’s the defense provided by Hayes. This isn’t me going insane about how bad his defense is, as he’s genuinely (and accurately) regarded as one of the great defenders of his time. He’s got Gold Gloves and Platinum Gloves on his trophy case, and rightfully so – and that is why Nick Krall made a point of going to get him.

As Krall himself stated after canning former manager David Bell after a disappointing 2024 season, “our defense needs to get better across the board.”

That was a fair assessment at the time. It’s probably still a fair one. Still, the concept of going out and getting an elite defender at a niche position has enough nuance to it that simply stating that he’s elite and plugging him onto a roster does not an improved product automatically make.

Football teams don’t go get elite wide receivers if they don’t have a quarterback who can throw them the ball. They don’t go overpay for elite running backs only to throw the ball each and every play. If a sports team is going to go out of its way to track down an elite player with one specific skill at one specific type of action – especially when that team has very limited resources – you’d instead fully expect them to use that player as much as possible.

This isn’t even a critique of the debilitating back injuries that Hayes has dealt with over time, the now 30 year old having missed more time than he’s provided for the Reds. This, folks, is a critique of the entire concept of kneecapping your team’s offense to put an elite defender on a part of the diamond that simply never sees the light of day defensively in the first place.

For ground balls to be a thing that 3B defense eats up, said balls have to be hit on the ground so the 3B can eat them up. During the 2026 regular season, only three pitching staffs produced grounders at a less frequent rate than Cincinnati’s 39.2%. That’s the kind of number that would at least be mitigated slightly a) if Cincinnati’s stadium was large enough that fly balls to the outfield became routine fly-outs or b) if Cincinnati’s outfielders were plus defenders who could go get ‘em with the best of them, but we know that neither is, in fact, the case.

What’s even more troubling is that no team in the sport produced pull contact off right-handed hitters than the Cincinnati Reds in 2026. Right-handed hitters, for whom pulling the ball means literally hitting it down the 3B line, pulled the ball just 38.0% of the time against Reds pitching, meaning no pitching staff induced strong-side platoon bats to hit the ball in the general side of the field as their 3B at a worse rate than the Cincinnati Reds.

The Reds literally went out and bought a beautiful skylight from the Pittsburgh Pirates and then immediately installed it on the north side of their house under a grove of pine trees that never drop their needles. It’s the scene from Raiders of the Lost Arc where they box up the Arc of the Covenant and store it deep in the recesses of a warehouse never to be seen again.

Even if Hayes had been healthy – or ever will be again – the Reds haven’t built-in the proper mechanisms to get the most out of the one way he can truly benefit them. They simply don’t have a staff who produces rollover contact to right-handed hitters despite having a pair of lefties forming 40% of their expected rotation. And while the quick hope at the end of this article would be that the new pitching coach may help them induce more contact that Hayes can gobble up at 3B, the more easy thing to point out is that the Reds should probably focus more on getting better defensively at the positions where hitters do hit the ball off the pitching staff.

Maybe that’s what the front office should have done in lieu of acquiring a player they can’t even use in the first place.

Mets send prospect Juan Arnaud to Rangers for international bonus pool money

UNITED STATES - CIRCA 2000: Workers lay sod on the field as the finishing touches are put on KeySpan Park in Coney Island, home of the Brooklyn Cyclones, the Class A minor league affiliate of the New York Mets. (Photo by NY Daily News Archive via Getty Images) | NY Daily News via Getty Images

According to Francys Romero and Mike Mayer, the Mets have made a deal to send right-handed reliever Juan Arnaud to the Rangers in exchange for an additional $250,000 in international bonus pool money. Arnaud played in High-A for the Brooklyn Cyclones in 2026 for the Mets. He has been assigned to the Rangers’ High-A team as well.

Arnaud has pitched for five years in the minor leagues. He was assigned to the Cyclones during the 2025 season and remained there in 2026 as well. In 42 games in 2026, he posted an ERA of 2.79, but his FIP was 5.13. His record was 4-2, with a K/9 of 12.89 (K% 30.6%) and BB/9 of 6.79 (BB% 16.1%), according to Fangraphs.

Arnaud is also eligible for the Rule 5 draft this year, should it happen, unless he is added to the Rangers’ 40-man roster. The Rule 5 draft is scheduled for December 9. The deadline to sign international prospects is December 15.