The All-Star break is winding down, and the "second half" of the baseball season is about to begin, which feels like a fitting time for an update to my starting pitcher rankings.
Back in May, I published my final preseason version of these rankings, so you can reference that if you want to see how much my opinion on certain arms has changed. While some of the familiar names are at the top, a handful of young guns like Jacob Misiorowski, Chase Burns, and Cam Schlittler have vaulted among the league's elite arms. I have an article in the works (that likely won't come out until the end of the season) on why certain of our young preseason favorites hit and others (Eury Perez, Nolan McLean) didn't, but the short takeaway is that I may have previously focused too much on pure stuff and not enough on the effectiveness of that stuff, i.e. command. I think I remedied that a bit in this update.
It’s important to note that, even in a midseason rankings update, I only partially use surface-level stats when constructing my rankings. Yes, a pitcher's ERA, WHIP, or even SIERA is important in determining how well they have done and impacts, partially, how well we should expect them to do. However, I don't think we should ignore K-BB%, swinging strike rate (SwStr%), Ideal Contact Rate (ICR), or individual pitch efficiency in projecting how these pitchers will finish the season.
As always, the pitchers are split into tiers, and the tiers themselves are more important than the rankings inside the tiers, so I wouldn’t split hairs over a few spots in the rankings.I’ve also ranked these pitchers as if I’m doing a 12-team league, so safe but boring low-end starters take a hit in value, etc. Also, since there is much going on right now (and I have a weekly podcast with Nick Pollack where I discuss most of these pitchers), I'm not going to be able to give detailed blurbs on WHY each pitcher is ranked where they are.
OK? Ok, so let’s get started.
Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitcher Mid-Season Rankings 2026
| Rank | Player | Team |
Top of the Line Aces |
| 1 | Jacob Misiorowski | Brewers |
| 2 | Tarik Skubal | Tigers |
| 3 | Cristopher Sanchez | Phillies |
| 4 | Paul Skenes | Pirates |
Yes, this hasn't been the season you were hoping for from Tarik Skubal or Paul Skenes, but they remain top-tier starting pitchers, and you'd struggle to find starters you'd truly rather roster than them the rest of the way. Skenes saw his fastball velocity and spin rate go back up in his last start, so maybe we can close the book on that narrative. I know Cristopher Sanchez got hit hard in the All-Star Game and his final start before it, but we can't ignore what we'd done the past two years or what Jacob Misiorowski has done so far this season. This is the cream of the crop.
Aces |
| 5 | Chris Sale | Braves |
| 6 | Jacob DeGrom | Rangers |
| 7 | Zack Wheeler | Phillies |
| 8 | Dylan Cease | Blue Jays |
| 9 | Cam Schlittler | Yankees |
| 10 | Chase Burns | Reds |
| 11 | Joe Ryan | Twins |
| 12 | Yoshinobu Yamamoto | Dodgers |
| 13 | Logan Gilbert | Mariners |
You'd be pretty happy with any of these guys as the ace of your fantasy team. There isn't a lot of analysis to do here, and if you wanted to shuffle their names around in a different order, I think that would be warranted. The bottom line is that I don't believe these guys have the peak of the top four, but I think they are safer and potentially more dominant than the next tier. And I can't believe Zack Wheeler is here after that surgery, but he is, and kudos to him.
MLB returns to NBC and Peacock in 2026! In addition to becoming the exclusive home of Sunday Night Baseball, NBC Sports will broadcast MLB Sunday Leadoff, “Opening Day” and Labor Day primetime games, the first round of the MLB Draft, the entire Wild Card round of the postseason, and much more.
SP2 Studs |
| 14 | Hunter Greene | Reds |
| 15 | Braxton Ashcraft | Pirates |
| 16 | Bryce Miller | Mariners |
| 17 | Jesus Luzardo | Phillies |
| 18 | Drew Rasmussen | Rays |
| 19 | Logan Webb | Giants |
| 20 | Bryan Woo | Mariners |
I'd rather have these guys as my SP2 in a 12-team league, but they have the upside of aces as well, so they will work in a pinch or a deeper format. Braxton Ashcraft is maybe the most shocking name on this list, but the addition of the sinker gave him another weapon to hide his average four-seam fastball, and the breaking balls are really good. He told me that pitching out of the bullpen last year helped him to dial in his command and his ability to get strike one, and you can see that playing out this year. He looks great. As does Bryce Miller, and maybe I was too focused on last year's elbow injury.
Hunter Greene has been back for two starts, and the second one looked electric. Remember that his surgery was to have bone spurs removed, not because he had ligament damage or anything like that. Bryan Woo is here as more of a hope than anything, but I truly believe he is too good a pitcher not to rebound into a top 20 arm.
High-End SP2 w some volatility |
| 21 | Gavin Williams | Guardians |
| 22 | Nathan Eovaldi | Rangers |
| 23 | Max Meyer | Marlins |
| 24 | Shohei Ohtani | Dodgers |
| 25 | Nolan McLean | Mets |
This is a tier of pitchers who have clear ace upside but plenty of question marks either about health, team context, or inconsistency. Shohei Ohtani would be higher, but I need more information on this knee issue. All we heard was that imaging on his knee came back clean, but he has discomfort, and it's the same knee he's previously had surgery on. If he were on another team, I wouldn't mind so much, but it's the Dodgers, and they don't need him to pitch every 5th or 6th day right now. They need him in October. I could see a world where they are extremely cautious with him on the mound, and he doesn't make as many starts the rest of the way as the guys above him.
Max Meyer and Gavin Williams appear to have taken another step in their development, and I still think it's there for Nolan McLean.
Floor SP2 Plays |
| 26 | Hunter Brown | Astros |
| 27 | Gerrit Cole | Yankees |
| 28 | Parker Messick | Guardians |
| 29 | George Kirby | Mariners |
| 30 | Kevin Gausman | Blue Jays |
| 31 | Sonny Gray | Red Sox |
| 32 | Framber Valdez | Tigers |
| 33 | Sandy Alcantara | Marlins |
These are all pitchers that I like more as SP2s right now because I don't think they have ace-tier upside anymore. Gerrit Cole and Hunter Brown don't look like the same aces they were before their respective arm injuries, but they are both clearly talented pitchers. The same goes for Sandy Alcantara, who has rebounded into a solid mid-rotation fantasy starter. Sonny Gray, Kevin Gausman, and Framber Valdez are all veterans who we've seen do this before. There will be bad starts, but you will get mostly solid performances, and Parker Messick just feels like one of the safest floor arms out there.
I gave a presentation at First Pitch Arizona in November, and I said George Kirby was a fringe top 25 pitcher, based on his pitch mix and swinging strike rate concerns. I then proceeded to rank him 12th before the season because I'm an idiot. I've corrected that now.
Strikeout Upside With Some Volatility |
| 34 | Eury Perez | Marlins |
| 35 | Payton Tolle | Red Sox |
| 36 | Ryan Weathers | Yankees |
| 37 | Kyle Bradish | Orioles |
| 38 | Emmet Sheehan | Dodgers |
| 39 | Shota Imanaga | Cubs |
| 40 | Nick Lodolo | Reds |
| 41 | Logan Henderson | Brewers |
All of these guys have the upside to finish inside the top 20 overall starters, but also have clear warts or a lack of track record, which adds some volatility. I wrote about Emmet Sheehan as one of my favorite second-half bounceback starting pitchers, and Logan Henderson just returned from the injured list to a Brewers rotation that really needs him (and his new sweeper). Eury Perez has also flashed his upside since coming back from his hamstring injury, and Nick Lodolo has looked good when his blister issues allow him to pitch. Kyle Bradish was ranked too aggressively because we forgot that his last healthy season didn't have the strikeout upside we saw last season, and Shota Imanaga has major home run issues, while Ryan Weathers and Payton Tolle are both learning and growing as pitchers but have the upside for truly dominant performances.
MLB returns to NBC and Peacock in 2026! In addition to becoming the exclusive home of Sunday Night Baseball, NBC Sports will broadcast MLB Sunday Leadoff, “Opening Day” and Labor Day primetime games, the first round of the MLB Draft, the entire Wild Card round of the postseason, and much more.
Security Blankets |
| 42 | Shane McClanahan | Rays |
| 43 | Ranger Suarez | Red Sox |
| 44 | Foster Griffin | Nationals |
| 45 | Griffin Jax | Rays |
| 46 | Troy Melton | Tigers |
| 47 | Trevor Rogers | Orioles |
| 48 | Justin Wrobleski | Dodgers |
Sometimes you just need a starting pitcher that feels safe. That's what these guys are. I don't think Foster Griffin, Ranger Suarez, and Justin Wrobleski will pitch as well (stats-wise) as they did in the first half, but I think all three are rock-solid starting pitchers who will give you length and solid ratios. Griffin Jax and Troy Melton were two of the pitchers I was trying to add most often on the waiver wire weeks ago, and I love how they've developed lately.
Can You Trust the Flashes of Upside? |
| 49 | Cade Cavalli | Nationals |
| 50 | Jared Jones | Pirates |
| 51 | Freddy Peralta | Mets |
| 52 | Joey Cantillo | Guardians |
| 53 | Casey Mize | Tigers |
| 54 | Reid Detmers | Angels |
| 55 | Michael King | Padres |
| 56 | Gage Jump | Athletics |
| 57 | MacKenzie Gore | Rangers |
| 58 | Landen Roupp | Giants |
These guys have all flashed upside at times this year, but have either struggled with consistency (MacKenzie Gore, Michael King, Reid Detmers, Landen Roupp) or a return from injury (Jared Jones) or their home park (Gage Jump) or have started to turn a corner because of a pitch mix change (Joey Cantillo, Casey Mize, Cade Cavalli). Then you have Freddy Peralta, who has just looked bad, but we've seen him look bad in the first half before, and he seems to always bounce back. I just can't put him any lower.
Probably Safe but Maybe Not |
| 59 | Sean Burke | White Sox |
| 60 | Dustin May | Cardinals |
| 61 | Matthew Boyd | Cubs |
| 62 | Emerson Hancock | Mariners |
| 63 | Nick Martinez | Rays |
| 64 | Eduardo Rodriguez | Diamondbacks |
| 65 | Ian Seymour | Rays |
| 66 | Jake Bennett | Red Sox |
I think these guys are safe, but they don't have the safety track record of the Security Blankets tier, so they wind up down here. As of now, I would trust all of these guys to be top-of-the-line streamers or solid "team streamers (h/t Paul Sporer) in most formats. I think Ian Seymour has the most upside, and we're seeing Emerson Hancock start to tire and regress, but none of these pitchers really need to be held if they start to struggle. If the safety seems to waver, move on to somebody else.
Chasing Upside |
| 67 | Jose Soriano | Angels |
| 68 | Trey Yesavage | Blue Jays |
| 69 | Taj Bradley | Twins |
| 70 | Jack Flaherty | Tigers |
| 71 | Robbie Ray | Giants |
| 72 | Will Warren | Yankees |
| 73 | Walbert Urena | Angels |
This tier is all about upside. There is an argument that pitchers in the tier below them are better, and if you're looking for a starting pitcher with a safe floor, they just might be; however, these arms have more upside. We've seen Jose Soriano regress as his four-seamer is getting hit again, but we also saw what he can do in a good 4-7 start stretch. Same for Taj Bradley and Jack Flaherty, who are in the midst of one now.
Robbie Ray and Will Warren are not pitching well right now, and I've lost a lot of faith in Ray, but we're talking about the 70s right now. We know these guys have upside to far outproduce this when they're clicking. Maybe a trade will help Ray. Trey Yesavage is really struggling with his command, but there is talent in that arm. Walbert Urena has been a nice surprise, and that power changeup is legit.
Streamers and 15-teamers |
| 74 | Peter Lambert | Astros |
| 75 | Michael Soroka | Diamondbacks |
| 76 | Shane Baz | Orioles |
| 77 | Michael Wacha | Royals |
| 78 | Andrew Abbott | Reds |
| 79 | Shane Drohan | Brewers |
| 80 | Davis Martin | White Sox |
| 81 | Merrill Kelly | Diamondbacks |
This title is pretty deliberately named, so you know how I feel about all of these pitchers. Davis Martin has already started to regress big time, and I know some people love Andrew Abbott, and he keeps outproducing what we think he will, but he's still a streamer for me. Michael Wacha is Michael Wacha; we know what we're getting by now, and Shane Drohan has been a nice surprise, but he has never thrown a full MLB season, so it's hard to know what to expect down the stretch.
Sure? Let's Give It a Try, but it's Scary |
| 82 | Roki Sasaki | Dodgers |
| 83 | Connor Prielipp | Twins |
| 84 | Aaron Nola | Phillies |
| 85 | Tanner Bibee | Guardians |
| 86 | Bubba Chandler | Pirates |
| 87 | Noah Schultz | White Sox |
| 88 | Christian Scott | Mets |
| 89 | Edward Cabrera | Cubs |
| 90 | Zebby Matthews | Twins |
| 91 | Brandon Sproat | Brewers |
| 92 | AJ Smith-Shawver | Braves |
| 93 | Owen Murphy | Braves |
All of these pitchers have enough upside or potential for success that you can talk yourself into rostering them, but none of them have had consistent success this season, and all of them have the potential to blow up your ratios and crush your roto standings. I want to like Aaron Nola more because the swing-and-miss numbers have been so good, but he has also been getting hit so hard. Connor Prielipp has a blister issue, I was so wrong on Edward Cabrera, and both Christian Scott and Noah Schultz are not consistently going five innings right now. Maybe Bubba Chandler puts it together next season, but he is simply not putting hitters away, and I'm done expecting that to change this year.
Deep League Safety |
| 94 | Reynaldo Lopez | Braves |
| 95 | Noah Cameron | Royals |
| 96 | Andre Pallante | Cardinals |
| 97 | Seth Lugo | Royals |
| 98 | Anthony Kay | White Sox |
| 99 | Luis Castollo | Mariners |
| 100 | Slade Cecconi | Guardians |
These guys round out the top 100 with some relative safety and enough ability to be 15-team viable or streamers in the right matchup.
Injured Top 100 Starters |
| Garrett Crochet | Red Sox |
| Max Fried | Yankees |
| Tyler Glasnow | Dodgers |
| Blake Snell | Dodgers |
| Justin Steele | Cubs |
| Kyle Harrison | Brewers |
| Carlos Rodon | Yankees |
| Connelly Early | Red Sox |
| Kris Bubic | Royals |
| Clay Holmes | Mets |
| Corbin Burnes | Diamondbacks |
| Spencer Schwellenbach | Braves |
I couldn't rank any of these guys because they are all hurt with unclear timelines for return. However, they would all be top 100 pitchers if they were healthy, so maybe they are guys you should stash on the IL. I just can't tell you when they'll pitch for you.