Where Phillies could shop this winter: 20 free-agent targets to watch originally appeared on NBC Sports Philadelphia
The Phillies do not have one singular offseason need.
Baseball’s free-agent market opened to all 30 clubs Monday at 5 p.m. ET, beginning an offseason with an unusual clock attached.
The current collective bargaining agreement expires Dec. 1, and a work stoppage could freeze transactions immediately afterward. That gives teams and players less than a month to decide whether to act early or wait for a new agreement.
Five years ago, several prominent free agents signed shortly before the lockout. A large portion of the market remained unsigned until business resumed in March. It is too early to know which direction this offseason will take, adding another variable to every contract projection.
The Phillies do not have one singular need.
They need a catcher capable of reducing J.T. Realmuto’s workload, at least one infielder, an everyday outfielder with right-handed power, protection behind their five starters and multiple relievers.
Their rotation and closer are set. Almost everything around them carries some uncertainty, giving president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski several ways to divide the payroll.
Some additions could alter the shape of the lineup. Others would fill clearly defined roles around the existing core.
Here are 20 free agents who could fit at different prices, organized by position with their age for the 2027 season:
All ages are for the 2027 season. Contract projections are FanGraphs estimates where available and our estimates for players outside its top 50.
Catchers
Dombrowski wants Realmuto to catch fewer games after the 35-year-old finished the season feeling “more mentally drained.” Realmuto still made 122 starts behind the plate, while Rafael Marchán and Garrett Stubbs combined to provide little offense.
Stubbs has since elected free agency after being designated for assignment. The Phillies need someone Don Mattingly will trust enough to start regularly. Otherwise, reducing Realmuto’s workload will remain more of an idea than a plan.
Carson Kelly, C (32)
2026: 121 G, .258/.336/.376, 10 HR, 58 RBI, .712 OPS
Projected contract: One year, $10 million
Kelly offers the clearest path to a true catching tandem.
The right-handed hitter produced a .871 OPS against left-handed pitching last season and owns an .822 mark in those matchups throughout his career. He also controlled the strike zone, finishing well above average in chase, whiff and strikeout rate.
Kelly graded well as a blocker but struggled to control the running game. His throwing ranked near the bottom of the league and opponents were successful on 89 percent of their stolen-base attempts.
That weakness would have to be weighed against the offense he could provide. Kelly is capable of starting against left-handers, catching two or three times per week and allowing Realmuto to receive a full day away from the lineup. The challenge may be convincing him to accept that role when other teams can offer more playing time.
James McCann, C (37)
2026: 52 G, .282/.311/.455, 7 HR, 28 RBI, .766 OPS
Projected contract: One year, $4 million
McCann would provide experience at a much lower price.
He performed well in limited action for Arizona, producing his highest OPS since the shortened 2020 season. He also has familiarity with Dombrowski, who selected him in the second round of the 2011 draft while running the Tigers.
McCann would not represent a long-term solution, but the Phillies are not searching for one after signing Realmuto through 2028. They need a catcher who can handle an experienced pitching staff and provide more offense than they received from the position last season.
His production came in only 166 plate appearances, so the Phillies could not expect the same rate across a larger workload. Still, a one-year agreement would give them a veteran partner for Realmuto without requiring a substantial commitment.
Infielders
Bohm, Luis Arraez and Edmundo Sosa have reached free agency, leaving the Phillies with several possible alignments.
Bryson Stott can play second or third. Trea Turner will receive an opportunity to remain at shortstop, although Dombrowski made clear that his defense must improve. Aidan Miller has worked at shortstop and third base but played only four regular-season games in 2026 because of his back injury.
The Phillies also declined to extend Bohm the $23.15 million qualifying offer, allowing him to enter the market without draft-pick compensation attached.
They could pursue an established third baseman, add a second baseman and move Stott or sign a versatile player who keeps several alignments available.
Gleyber Torres, 2B (30)
2026: 96 G, .260/.364/.363, 8 HR, 38 RBI, .727 OPS
Projected contract: Two years, $28 million
Torres would give the top of the Phillies’ lineup a different look.
He walked in 13.6 percent of his plate appearances and chased only 19.2 percent of the pitches he saw, one of the lowest rates in baseball. Even during a season interrupted by two oblique injuries, he reached base at a career-best .364 rate.
That patience comes with tradeoffs. Torres hit for little power, did not steal a base and finished with minus-5 Outs Above Average at second. His value would come almost entirely from his bat.
Unlike Arraez, Torres does not have to hit his way on base. He works deep counts and forces pitchers into the strike zone, which could make him an option to hit first or second. Signing him would likely move Stott to third base and give the Phillies an on-base threat without committing to another corner infielder.
Ildemaro Vargas, UTIL (35)
2026: 130 G, .254/.298/.377, 9 HR, 67 RBI, .675 OPS
Projected contract: One year, $5 million
Vargas would give the Phillies a switch-hitting utility option at a modest price.
He batted .321 with a .347 on-base percentage, .500 slugging percentage and six home runs against left-handers. He rarely missed, finishing in the 94th percentile in whiff rate and 98th percentile in strikeout rate.
Vargas is aggressive. His chase rate ranked near the bottom of the league and he produced only a .580 OPS against right-handed pitching. That limits him to a platoon or utility role.
He appeared at all four infield positions and left field for Arizona, allowing Mattingly to rest veteran players without losing much defensively. Vargas would not carry the upside of a larger acquisition, but he could replace Sosa’s at-bats against lefties while covering more positions.
Teruaki Sato, 3B/RF (28)
2026 in Japan: 143 G, .306/.383/.609, 39 HR, 106 RBI, 8 SB
Projected contract: Five years, $110 million, plus posting fee
Sato would give the Phillies the greatest opportunity to reshape their lineup.
He won the Central League Triple Crown by hitting .306 with 39 home runs and 106 RBIs. That followed a 40-homer season in 2025, when he was named the league’s Most Valuable Player.
His power is not subtle. Sato produced a 56 percent hard-hit rate in Japan and recorded a maximum exit velocity of 116 mph. Munetaka Murakami and Kazuma Okamoto combined for 68 home runs during their first major-league seasons in 2026, further demonstrating how Japanese power can translate.
There is considerable swing-and-miss in Sato’s game. He struck out 164 times last season, and FanGraphs projects a strikeout rate above 30 percent in the majors. Evaluators also differ on whether his throwing will allow him to remain at third base, although he won a Gold Glove there in 2025 and has experience in right field.
The Phillies have scouted Sato and need to establish themselves in the Japanese market. His left-handed bat would not improve their lineup balance, but his power would give them a dimension Bohm did not.
Mauricio Dubón, UTIL (32)
2026: 153 G, .276/.321/.399, 12 HR, 73 RBI, 10 SB, .720 OPS
Projected contract: One year, $8 million
Dubón could cover several positions while the Phillies wait to see when Miller is ready.
He started games at second, third, shortstop and all three outfield positions for Atlanta. He’s on track to win his third Gold Glove as a utility player and struck out in only 11.8 percent of his plate appearances.
Dubón does not walk often or provide substantial power, but he makes consistent contact, plays elite defense and would allow the Phillies to change their alignment without making another move.
He could open the season at third base, move to second if Stott shifts across the diamond or play the outfield when Mattingly wants to rest one of his regulars. If Miller forces his way to the majors, Dubón could move into the utility role he has handled throughout his career.
Outfielders
The Phillies have struggled to find sustained production in right field since Bryce Harper moved to first base.
Justin Crawford and Brandon Marsh give them left-handed options in center and left field. That leaves an opening in right for a hitter who can provide power from the right side and control the strike zone. The Phillies would also prefer to avoid platooning at all three outfield positions, as they did at times last season.
Randy Arozarena, LF (32)
2026: 154 G, .281/.381/.484, 26 HR, 79 RBI, 26 SB, .865 OPS
Projected contract: Three years, $69 million
Arozarena put together the best regular season of his career before reaching free agency.
He set career highs in average, on-base percentage, slugging and runs while recording his sixth consecutive 20-homer season. His combination of 26 home runs and 26 stolen bases would make the Phillies more athletic without sacrificing power.
Arozarena also owns a .946 OPS with 12 home runs in 45 postseason games. That experience will appeal to an organization that has repeatedly seen its offense slow down in October.
His defense is better suited to left field, and he received a $23.15 million qualifying offer from Seattle. Signing him would require the Phillies to surrender draft capital on top of a significant contract.
He would still provide the right-handed presence the lineup lacks, with enough on-base ability to hit near the top and enough power to remain in the middle.
Ian Happ, LF (32)
2026: 156 G, .218/.326/.412, 24 HR, 68 RBI, .738 OPS
Projected contract: Two years, $30 million
Happ’s batting average and strikeout total will receive the most attention after he hit .218 and struck out 189 times.
The larger record is steadier. Happ has appeared in at least 148 games in six consecutive full seasons, reached base at a .341 career rate and hit between 21 and 25 home runs in each of the last four years.
The switch hitter has been considerably better from the left side. He produced only a 36 wRC+ against left-handed pitching last season, meaning he would not completely solve the Phillies’ need for right-handed production.
He would provide power, walks and Gold Glove defense — four of those already on his mantle — in left field. Happ also did not receive a qualifying offer from Chicago, removing the draft-pick cost attached to Arozarena and Suzuki. He represents a less expensive way to improve the outfield without relying on a one-year rebound.
Taylor Ward, LF/RF (33)
2026: 143 G, .225/.359/.311, 7 HR, 37 RBI, .670 OPS
Projected contract: One year, $10 million
Ward would be the buy-low option of this group.
One year after hitting 36 home runs and driving in 103, the right-handed outfielder finished with seven homers and did not hit one after Seattle acquired him at the deadline. He batted .125 with a .386 OPS in 32 games for the Mariners.
His understanding of the strike zone remained elite. Ward chased only 14.9 percent of pitches outside the zone and drew 99 walks, keeping his on-base percentage at .359 despite the loss of power.
He also provided solid defense in left field before the trade, giving him value even while his offensive results declined.
Because Ward changed teams during the season, he was ineligible to receive a qualifying offer. A one-year contract would allow him to rebuild his market while the Phillies bet that some of his 2025 power returns at Citizens Bank Park.
Seiya Suzuki, RF (32)
2026: 143 G, .270/.368/.473, 26 HR, 86 RBI, .841 OPS
Projected contract: Four years, $108 million
Suzuki may be the cleanest offensive fit available.
The right-handed hitter has recorded an OPS above .800 in four consecutive seasons and owns an .823 mark since arriving from Japan. He chased only 22.5 percent of pitches last season and improved his contact rate inside the strike zone.
Suzuki also made progress defensively. After spending considerable time at designated hitter earlier in his Cubs tenure, he became a Gold Glove finalist in right field.
His combination of patience, power and defensive improvement would give the Phillies an everyday answer at a position that has remained unsettled. He would also become their first Japanese-born major leaguer since So Taguchi played for the club in 2008, potentially helping future pursuits in that market.
Chicago extended Suzuki the qualifying offer, and he should receive one of the largest contracts in this class. The price will be substantial, but so is the fit.
Starting pitchers
The Phillies do not need to promise another pitcher a permanent rotation spot.
They need someone capable of working multiple innings from the bullpen and making a start when one of their five becomes unavailable. Philadelphia went 2-14 in games not started by Zack Wheeler, Cristopher Sánchez, Jesús Luzardo, Aaron Nola or Andrew Painter last season.
Dombrowski has already said the organization will add more starting depth. These four names were examined more extensively here.
Ryan Yarbrough, LHP (35)
2026: 38 G, 2 GS, 63⅓ IP, 3.69 ERA, 1.22 WHIP, 49 K
Projected contract: One year, $4 million
Yarbrough offers the clearest low-cost solution.
His four-seam fastball averaged approximately 87 mph, but opponents produced a major-league-low 25 percent hard-hit rate against him. Yarbrough changes speeds, varies his shapes and avoids the center of the plate well enough to survive without velocity.
He has made 78 starts during his career and has extensive experience working as a bulk reliever. That would give Mattingly a pitcher who could follow an opener, provide three or four innings during a short start or enter the rotation without changing the bullpen’s entire structure.
The Phillies would not be signing him for dominance. They would be paying for a defined role and a pitcher who has shown he can handle it.
Colin Rea, RHP (36)
2026: 34 G, 19 GS, 137 IP, 4.34 ERA, 1.33 WHIP, 101 K
Projected contract: One year, $6 million
The Cubs declined Rea’s $7.5 million option Monday, placing one of the market’s more experienced swingmen into free agency.
Rea spent two seasons moving between Chicago’s rotation and bullpen, making 46 starts and 20 relief appearances while covering 296⅓ innings. He also recorded two saves last season, reflecting how willing the Cubs were to use him in different situations.
His strikeout rate is modest and his margin for error can disappear when the ball leaves the park. He still offers something the Phillies lacked: the ability to take the ball for five innings without needing a lengthy buildup.
His age should keep the contract within the range Philadelphia can justify for a sixth starter.
Cal Quantrill, RHP (32)
2026: 32 G, 15 GS, 110 IP, 2.86 ERA, 1.04 WHIP, 81 K
Projected contract: Two years, $18 million
Quantrill would be the most expensive pitcher in this group because his 2026 results could lead other teams to view him as a full-time starter.
After consecutive seasons with ERAs near or above 5.00, the right-hander signed a minor-league deal with Texas and rebuilt his value. He posted a 2.47 ERA as a starter and a 3.78 mark in relief.
Quantrill does not miss many bats, but he limited walks and consistently kept the Rangers in games. A lat strain ended his season in September, adding a medical question to an otherwise impressive year.
The Phillies would need to sell him on a fluid role or provide enough money to overcome another club’s rotation opportunity. If they can, he offers considerably more upside than a traditional depth signing.
Erick Fedde, RHP (34)
2026: 33 G, 15 GS, 141 IP, 3.83 ERA, 1.35 WHIP, 99 K
Projected contract: One year, $6 million
Fedde handled the most balanced workload of the four.
He nearly divided his innings between 15 starts and 18 relief appearances for the White Sox, posting a 3.86 ERA from the rotation and a 3.80 mark out of the bullpen.
His 4.79 expected ERA and 16.3 percent strikeout rate indicate that some regression could follow. His value comes from his workload and willingness to pitch wherever needed.
Fedde would not have to be removed from the bullpen solely to cover one start. He could already be stretched to provide several innings, then remain in the rotation if the absence lasts longer. That flexibility would prevent the Phillies from repeating last season’s cycle of openers and short-term call-ups.
Relief pitchers
The Phillies have their closer in Jhoan Duran. What they lack is certainty in the innings leading to him, particularly from the left side.
Bullpen performance has repeatedly influenced their postseason exits, and the club cannot rely on one late-inning arm to cover every close game. This free-agent class includes proven setup pitchers, rebound candidates and several left-handers with swing-and-miss stuff.
Jason Adam, RHP (35)
2026: 38 G, 34⅓ IP, 2.62 ERA, 1.17 WHIP, 22 K
Projected contract: One year, $8 million
Adam has been one of baseball’s most consistent late-inning relievers since joining Tampa Bay in 2022.
He recorded a 2.12 ERA across 197 appearances from 2022-24, then posted a 1.93 mark while making his first All-Star team in 2025. His 2026 season was interrupted by a shoulder strain that kept him out for nearly three months.
The ERA remained strong after his return, but his strikeout rate fell to 15.5 percent. That is a significant decline for a pitcher whose ability to miss bats helped establish him as a high-leverage arm.
Adam’s medical evaluation and velocity will determine the market. A shorter contract would allow the Phillies to add experience without paying exclusively for the pitcher he was before the shoulder injury.
Alex Vesia, LHP (31)
2026: 72 G, 58 IP, 2.64 ERA, 1.07 WHIP, 74 K
Projected contract: Two years, $18 million
Vesia would immediately become the Phillies’ most dependable left-handed reliever.
Left-handed hitters batted .138 against him, the lowest average allowed by any lefty reliever who faced at least 100 of them. His four-seam fastball averaged only 92.1 mph but generated 21.2 inches of induced vertical break, allowing it to play above its velocity.
Vesia also expanded his changeup usage against right-handers, giving him a third pitch beyond the fastball and slider. His overall strikeout rate finished at 31.2 percent.
He has pitched in six postseasons and owns a 1.59 ERA across 31 career playoff appearances. His experience, durability and ability to handle hitters from both sides would make him one of the strongest bullpen options on the market.
Paul Blackburn, RHP (33)
2026: 62 G, 2 GS, 85 IP, 1.59 ERA, 1.08 WHIP, 69 K
Projected contract: Two years, $18 million
Blackburn completely changed his market after moving into the Yankees’ bullpen.
The former starter worked 85 innings, made two spot starts and recorded a 1.59 ERA after signing for $2 million. His deep pitch mix allowed New York to use him for more than three outs without exposing him to the same lineup several times.
His changeup held opponents to a .090 average, while his curveball produced a 41.1 percent whiff rate and an .081 opponents’ average. Shorter appearances also helped his sinker average 94.3 mph, nearly two miles per hour harder than the previous season.
Blackburn could provide multi-inning relief when the rotation is healthy and serve as another starting option when it is not.
JoJo Romero, LHP (30)
2026: 49 G, 48⅓ IP, 3.72 ERA, 1.34 WHIP, 46 K
Projected contract: Two years, $16 million
Romero could return to Philadelphia four years after the Phillies traded him to St. Louis for Sosa.
The left-hander developed into a reliable reliever after lowering his arm slot and leaning into a sinker-sweeper combination. He recorded a 2.91 ERA across the last three seasons and consistently generated ground balls.
Romero strengthened his market during Milwaukee’s run to the World Series. He allowed one earned run over eight postseason innings, striking out 11 and walking one.
His 2026 regular-season numbers were not as sharp as the previous year, when he posted a 2.07 ERA. Still, he has shown he can work in the seventh or eighth inning and neutralize left-handed hitters without being restricted to one-batter assignments.
Evan Phillips, RHP (32)
2026: 31 G, 26 IP, 3.46 ERA, 1.08 WHIP, 33 K
Projected contract: Two years, $20 million
Phillips returned from Tommy John surgery in July and gradually regained the form that made him one of the Dodgers’ most trusted relievers.
He generated a career-best 35 percent chase rate, pairing an upper-90s fastball with a sweeper that can move more than 15 inches horizontally. His command was inconsistent at times, and he allowed five home runs in only 26 innings.
The larger record is difficult to ignore. Phillips posted a 2.31 ERA from 2022-25 and has not allowed an earned run in 17 career postseason appearances. He added three more scoreless innings in October this year.
A full offseason removed from surgery could improve his command. The Phillies would be paying for that possibility and for a pitcher who has already handled the type of postseason innings they need filled.
A.J. Puk, LHP (32)
2026: Did not pitch in the majors
Projected contract: One year, $4 million plus incentives
Puk is the greatest risk on this list.
The 6-foot-7 left-hander spent 2026 recovering from an internal-brace procedure on his elbow. He began a minor-league rehab assignment in June but developed a left shoulder capsule sprain and was shut down for the season.
His most recent healthy stretch showed why teams will remain interested. After Arizona acquired him in 2024, Puk recorded a 1.32 ERA with 43 strikeouts over 27⅓ innings. He throws in the upper 90s and has struck out nearly 30 percent of the hitters he has faced as a major-league reliever.
The Phillies could not enter the season counting on Puk as their primary left-handed setup option. Paired with a more dependable addition, however, an incentive-heavy agreement would give them a chance to add a high-end arm without guaranteeing high-end money.