How Red Sox can buy and sell at trade deadline without wrecking season originally appeared on NBC Sports Boston
A few weeks ago, there was no doubt: The Red Sox would have to be sellers at this year’s trade deadline.
Yet after an absurd stretch of winning (10 straight and 15 of 17 entering Friday night), that plan is on hold as everybody in baseball — and the Red Sox themselves — assess just how good this year’s team can be.
With the winning has come calls for Breslow to buy at the deadline and supplement a roster that could use some offensive help. Doing so, however, would prevent chief baseball officer Craig Breslow from trading away some veteran assets that could help bring some players to Boston who could help this year and beyond.
Or would it?
MassLive’s Chris Cotillo laid out a plan on Early Edition that could simultaneously accomplish multiple goals for a Red Sox team that will surely want to stay in playoff contention for the rest of the year.
That plan would involve trading away starting pitcher Sonny Gray (age 36 years old) and closer Aroldis Chapman (38) and bringing in offensive help from a player (or players) who are under contract beyond the 2026 season.
“The reason I think that’s important is that the free-agent class this year is horrible for bats. Jazz Chisholm is like the best one. It’s not a market where you can go and pay for a bat,” Cotillo explained. “So if a Byron Buxton is available or a C.J. Abrams in a blockbuster, probably worth investigating now because the options aren’t gonna be there in the winter.
“And I think, honestly, that shouldn’t preclude them from cashing in on a chip like Gray or Chapman. They’re in their late 30s, they’ve had unbelievable seasons so far, especially Gray. And I think you’re gonna get a premium for those guys.”
Cotillo noted that the rise of Jake Bennett (who improved to 5-3 with a 2.35 ERA on Friday afternoon) along with the consistency of Payton Tolle and Connelly Early could allow the Red Sox to withstand a loss of Gray — especially if Garrett Crochet is able to return at some point. He also added that the bullpen could survive with Garrett Whitlock in the closer’s role instead of Chapman.
“So it’s a cop-out to do a little of both sometimes. They’re just in such a unique situation where they can add a controllable bat — I think they’ll try to do that — and then also, if the prices get to a certain point, it would be stupid not to listen on Gray and Chapman, considering what they are and their contracts and all that,” Cotillo said.
While there would certainly be quite a bit of pushback from fans who might interpret such moves as giving up on the season, Cotillo said that such a slightly longer-term approach could put the Red Sox in a better position in the coming years.
“I think it would be a smart hedge, honestly, to do both,” he said. “Heart of hearts, I think the smart thing to do would be a little buying, a little selling, set yourself for next year in the lineup, move a piece of your roster that you can get by without. … But easier said than done, as always, this time of year.”