Giants' fizzling lineup continues to struggle vs. fastball as strikeouts pile up originally appeared on NBC Sports Bay Area
SAN FRANCISCO — The Giants had a clear approach to the MLB draft this year, and that continued at the trade deadline. At every turn, they are trying to add hitters who are into bat control and limit strikeouts.
It will take a while, though, to change the makeup of the big league roster, and right now this is a group that’s big on swing-and-miss. It’s a major reason why their season has spiraled in recent weeks.
The lineup struck out 12 times in Tuesday’s 5-1 loss to the San Diego Padres, reaching double-digits for a fifth consecutive game and the eighth time in the last nine games. They have exactly 100 strikeouts over those nine games, and it’s not because they’re working deep counts or playing a “three true outcomes” brand of baseball. They have 16 walks during that span.
Manager Bob Melvin found it jarring last Monday when Yu Darvish opened his night with nine consecutive fastballs. The trend has continued, and thus far, the Giants haven’t found an answer.
Asked about it late Tuesday night, Melvin pointed out that the lineup is without Matt Chapman, who has the highest walk rate of any of the regulars who have been here all year. The Giants also traded away Mike Yastrzemski, who struck out a fair amount, but countered that by drawing plenty of walks.
With Yastrzemski gone and Chapman (hand) and Willy Adames (side soreness) both out Tuesday, Melvin had just one player (Rafael Devers) in his lineup who has walked in more than 9 percent of his at-bats this season.
“It’s a little bit different in the personnel right now,” Melvin said. “We’re trying to catch up to some fastballs and get ahead a little bit earlier and you try to hit the fastball. So it doesn’t look as good as far as the walks go.”
For a team that is trying to adjust on the fly, Nick Pivetta was just about the exact opposite of who they needed to see on the mound Tuesday. The right-hander has tremendous carry on his fastball and gets good extension. His four-seamer ranks as the second-best in the big leagues by Run Value, and he used it 48 times Tuesday. Six of his 10 strikeouts came on a fastball.
The Giants once hoped to use these two August series against the Padres as a way to get back into the MLB playoff race. Instead, they’ve dropped four of five to the division rival, striking out 50 times.
“This team does have a lot of guys that throw hard, and they throw at the top of the zone and they know where the top is,” Melvin said. “That’s something we have to solve, is when you go after it up there and when you don’t. [It was] 24 vert today from Pivetta — I don’t know that I’ve seen that before. We’ve seen some 21s, 22s … It looks good at certain levels, and when you have that kind of vertical [break] it’s easier said than done to stay on top of it and get it.”