With October ahead, how will things shake out for the Phils? originally appeared on NBC Sports Philadelphia
With the Mets in town and the air a little more crisp in the second week of September, it’s easy to think about the postseason.
The Phillies currently hold an eight-game lead in the National League East. The remainder of this four-game set against New York could take a great deal of pressure off the Phils as October approaches.
Making the postseason is basically a given at this point, with their magic number sitting at seven, it’s much bigger than simply clinching.
With the recent injuries to Trea Turner and Alec Bohm, the optimal scenario is giving both former All-Stars time not only to regain rhythm, but also to get as close to full health as possible.
Turner’s case is especially critical. His game is built on speed, and more recovery time can only help come October.
After Monday night’s win over the Mets, he emphasized his hurry to get back and make an impact: “As soon as possible, obviously, but more importantly for the playoffs is the most important. So trying to find that fine line of trying to get ready for that, but also not rushing it back and coming back for no reason.”
So how can Turner return to his do-it-all self?
The Phillies can help themselves by locking in a top-two seed among National League division winners. That would give them an automatic ticket to the Division Series, bypassing the grind of a best-of-three Wild Card round.
Not only would that aid Turner’s recovery, it would also give a breather to a bullpen that has carried a heavy load in the second half.
The Phillies currently hold a four-game lead over the NL West-leading Dodgers. Next Monday’s three-game set in Los Angeles is a control-your-own-destiny opportunity for both clubs — and could be the difference in who skips the Wild Card round.
What will the postseason rotation look like?
There’s no debate about the first two names: Cristopher Sánchez and Ranger Suárez will headline.
From there, it gets more interesting.
Jesús Luzardo seems to have earned the No. 3 spot. He leads the team in starts and wins this year, and while his postseason résumé is rocky, his velocity and swing-and-miss stuff should play. His first October in 2019 with Oakland — three scoreless innings out of the bullpen in a Wild Card game — showed his potential, but he has since struggled.
The question is whether the Phillies would run out three consecutive lefties in October against righty-heavy lineups like Milwaukee or San Diego.
That makes the fourth spot even more intriguing.
Aaron Nola’s Monday night gem against the Mets was his first scoreless outing since May. It reminded fans what he can still bring, even in a season marred by injuries and inconsistency. His 10 postseason starts and 4.02 ERA make him a trusted option in October.
Beyond that, there are situational options.
A bullpen game could work if the Phils are up in a series.
Taijuan Walker looks more likely to serve as a long reliever.
And the long shot?
Walker Buehler.
His 2025 regular season has been underwhelming, but his 3.04 career postseason ERA over 19 appearances speaks for itself.
The lineup picture
If Turner and Bohm return, the lineup sets itself. If not, Rob Thomson has shown he’s willing to experiment.
Bryce Harper led off Monday night, and Harrison Bader is hitting first Tuesday. If Turner can’t go, Bader could be an option against lefties — and his October history makes that exciting.
The Bronxville, New York native carried the Yankees in 2022 with five homers in nine games, proving he can step up.
The rest of the outfield mix is battle-tested. Max Kepler, Brandon Marsh and Nick Castellanos are all in rotation, but Castellanos is the one to watch.
He’s been vocal and mature about the playing-time shuffle, and he’s delivered when it matters. You have to love this season’s storyline too.
After struggling in the 2022 postseason, he’s posted an .898 OPS in his last 17 playoff games.
He has to be out there.
The bottom line
It’s early, but not too early. October is 22 days away.
Some say the Phillies’ championship window is closing. Without Zack Wheeler, the road ahead will be rough, but baseball history is loaded with teams that won without their ace.
It’s baseball. Anything can happen.