Now what? Where Phillies could turn as managerial plans reset originally appeared on NBC Sports Philadelphia
For the final two months of the season, almost every conversation surrounding the Phillies’ managerial future pointed toward one person.
That was Alex Cora.
It created what appeared to be an ultimatum for interim manager Don Mattingly. Take the Phillies on a deep postseason run and make a case to stay. Come up short, and the opportunity could disappear.
The latter happened when the Phillies were eliminated from the postseason for the fifth consecutive year. President of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski reportedly went back to Cora, just as he had after the Red Sox fired him in April.
For the second time this year, Cora declined the opportunity.
And here the Phillies are.
The club has yet to hold its end-of-season press conference. If part of the delay involved waiting for Cora’s answer, the Phillies now have it.
The decision extends beyond choosing the next available name. Dombrowski and managing partner John Middleton first must determine what type of manager fits an aging, expensive roster that still expects to contend in 2027.
Do they stay with Mattingly? Do they hire another manager with experience? Or do they turn toward a first-time candidate who could help guide the transition into the organization’s next core?
Here are several directions they could explore:
Don Mattingly
The most realistic option might already be inside the organization.
Mattingly inherited a 9-19 team in late April and led it to a 79-55 record the rest of the way. It was the fourth-best record in baseball during that span. The Phillies reached the postseason despite an offense that ranked 19th in runs and a bullpen that ranked 21st in ERA.
That does not erase another early playoff exit, but it gives Dombrowski and Middleton more to evaluate than the result of one series. Mattingly steadied a season that was getting away from the Phillies and retained the support of the clubhouse. J.T. Realmuto called him “great” after the season ended, while Aaron Nola said, “We love Don.”
Mattingly also remains under contract through 2027 after originally signing a two-year deal to become the Phillies’ bench coach. The front office knows how he operates, and he has already spent a season building relationships with the players.
That familiarity could become more important this winter. Major League Baseball’s collective bargaining agreement expires Dec. 1, creating the possibility of a work stoppage. If that happens, a newly hired manager would have only a brief window to speak with his players before communication is cut off.
Mattingly would not face that introduction period. He managed the club for five months, experienced its late-season slide and went through a postseason series with much of the roster expected to return in 2027.
The Phillies should not retain him solely because he is familiar. Between the team’s turnaround, his standing in the clubhouse and the uncertainty surrounding the CBA, however, Mattingly appears to be the most realistic option now that Cora is unavailable.
If the Phillies decide to look elsewhere, they could choose between managers who have already held the job and longtime coaches waiting for their first opportunity.
Rocco Baldelli
Baldelli offers an uncommon combination of experience and relative youth.
The 45-year-old managed the Twins for seven seasons, won American League Manager of the Year in 2019 and led Minnesota to three division titles. The Twins reached the postseason four times under Baldelli but won only one series before the organization dismissed him following the 2025 season.
Baldelli has since joined the Dodgers as a special assistant, giving him an opportunity to work inside another organization that has continued winning while introducing young players around an expensive veteran core.
He has already handled the daily demands of managing a contender and would not arrive with a previous connection to the Phillies’ front office. Baldelli would give the organization a different perspective without asking a first-time manager to learn on a team still expecting to win immediately.
Brad Ausmus
Ausmus has the clearest connection to Dombrowski, who hired him to replace Jim Leyland as Tigers manager before the 2014 season.
Detroit won the American League Central in Ausmus’ first year but was swept by Baltimore in the Division Series. The Tigers missed the postseason in each of the next three seasons, and Ausmus later spent one year managing the Angels.
He has since returned to the bench, first with Oakland and now as Aaron Boone’s bench coach with the Yankees. He also managed Israel during the 2026 World Baseball Classic.
Ausmus has not managed in the majors since 2019, but his relationship with Dombrowski makes him difficult to ignore. The Phillies’ pursuit of Cora showed that Dombrowski remains willing to turn toward people he trusted during his time in Detroit and Boston.
David Ross
Ross managed the Cubs for four seasons after replacing Joe Maddon in 2020. Chicago reached the postseason during his first year but never returned, and Ross finished his tenure with a 262-284 record.
The Cubs went 83-79 in 2023 and remained in the playoff race until the final weekend. They dismissed Ross shortly after the season when Craig Counsell became available.
Ross has remained interested in managing again. At 49, he could offer a longer-term option than Mattingly or Ausmus, although his four seasons in Chicago produced only one winning record and no postseason series victories.
The Phillies could also move away from former managers and consider someone whose résumé was built through scouting, coaching and player development.
Omar López
Few potential candidates have been as closely involved with the development of a championship core as Astros bench coach Omar López.
López joined Houston as a scout and instructor in Venezuela in 1999. He was among the scouts who recommended signing a little-known, 16-year-old José Altuve and later became Altuve’s first manager in the Astros’ system.
He managed for 12 seasons across Houston’s minor-league affiliates. His 2013 Quad Cities team, which included Carlos Correa and Lance McCullers Jr., won the Midwest League championship. López later managed Alex Bregman, Kyle Tucker and Yordan Alvarez during their climbs through the organization.
He was not responsible for building Houston’s farm system, but he worked directly with several generations of the homegrown players who helped turn the Astros into annual contenders.
López joined the major-league staff in 2020 and won a World Series as Houston’s first-base coach in 2022. He became Joe Espada’s bench coach two years later and strengthened his managerial résumé in March by leading Venezuela to its first World Baseball Classic championship.
The Phillies have not been publicly connected to López. His history with Houston, however, should interest an organization trying to keep its current window open while preparing for the next one.
Rodney Linares
Linares offers experience from two organizations that have consistently developed talent in different ways.
He spent two decades coaching and managing in Houston’s farm system before joining Kevin Cash’s staff with the Rays in 2019. Tampa Bay promoted him from third-base coach to bench coach before the 2023 season.
Linares also managed the Dominican Republic during the 2023 World Baseball Classic. He has never managed in the majors, but his time with Houston and Tampa Bay has exposed him to both a championship organization and a club accustomed to competing with fewer financial resources.
George Lombard
Lombard has served as A.J. Hinch’s bench coach with the Tigers since 2021, working alongside him as Detroit developed a younger roster and returned to contention.
He previously spent five seasons as the Dodgers’ first-base coach and was part of their 2020 championship staff. Before reaching the major-league level, Lombard worked in player development with the Red Sox and Braves.
That background could appeal to a Phillies organization trying to bring Andrew Painter, Justin Crawford and eventually Aidan Miller into a clubhouse still led by its veteran core. Lombard would be managing in the majors for the first time, but he has spent more than a decade working alongside Dave Roberts and Hinch.
The Phillies have rarely made the type of hire that López, Linares or Lombard would represent. Since Charlie Manuel took over before the 2005 season, Gabe Kapler is the only manager they have brought in from outside the organization without previous major-league managerial experience.
Ryne Sandberg, Pete Mackanin, Rob Thomson and Mattingly were promoted from within, while Joe Girardi had already managed for 11 seasons. Choosing a first-time manager from outside the organization would require the Phillies to break from a pattern that has lasted more than two decades.
The Phillies do not need to hire the biggest name available. They need someone who fits where the organization is going.
Cora would have brought a clear change in personality and authority. With that option gone, the Phillies must decide whether Mattingly earned the opportunity to continue or whether their latest postseason exit requires them to try something different.