
Can you believe we even get to think about something like this?
I don’t remember when I gave up hope for the first time, but I’ll tell you I was pretty close on July 29th, a 4-2 loss to the Los Angeles Dodgers. That game marked the first day that FanGraphs had the Mariners playoff odds below 50%. Their record was 53-56.
It certainly was before the Mariners low-water mark this season. On August 11th, 3 days after the club’s 50th anniversary fanfare and pageantry (another embarrassing loss), Seattle lost to the New York Yankees 4-1, dropping their record to 56-64. FanGraphs had their playoff odds at 23.9%.
They lost the next day, too. Then, over their next 13 games, they won 8 games and 3 series (and did it with a total run differential of -29) while Houston went 4-7 and Texas went 6-7. Cal Raleigh went and hit 4 home runs in two nights, and I found myself looking at squiggly lines with hope in my heart again, like an idiot.

As of this morning, with 28 games left to play, Seattle is 64-70, 2 games behind Texas and 2.5 games behind Houston in the division, 4 games behind Cleveland for the third wild card spot (lol) and have playoff odds of 42.1%.


Mariners fans’ hearts have historically strong when presented with reasons to hope, but the last few years of sporadically good baseball may have melted some of our resolve. One simply must wonder: can this team do it?
The staff weighed in on their personal Hope/Cope-ometer placement, with the scale below for reference, and our composite final, official hope ranking at the end. -NV

John:
There’s a mantra in scouting, on the 20-80 scale, that a grade of 65 is utter cowardice. With a 50 as big league average, most players will see their skills fall between a 40-60. Standard deviations, bell curves, things of that nature. So when you see something more impressive than most, you should be confident. The Mariners are playing like they were expected to most nights, they have a strong setup for the home stretch, and the teams they are chasing are donkeys in dumpsters. More to the point, if the Mariners are to make the playoffs, it will only be possible by playing at a caliber befitting of a playoff running club.
Hope Rating: 8
Isabelle:
When I take longtime former roommate and CTA (certified troublemaking asshole) corgi, Cedar, on walks, we only ever stroll peacefully and in unison for a handful of minutes. The rest of the time is spent with him yanking repeatedly at the leash to get closer to whomever or whatever he’s screaming at, or dragging him bodily up hills (no corgis were actually harmed on any of these walks) because he’s petulant about the direction we’ve gone/the fact I yelled at him about hollering at an ancient Labrador/how I deprived him of enough sniffing time/any myriad of other wrongdoings. This is the closest comparison I can make for this season to something I have actively experienced. I imagine it’s also not dissimilar to when you bungee jump off a bridge and do that painful-looking ricochet up and down a few times due to said bungee.
All that to say, I’m a 6. Please know that prior to attending Tuesday’s game, I had this as a 4. (Oh god, there comes the ground.) Maybe I’ll change it back again before it actually pubs. (Oh wait, now we’re soaring back up to the sky.)
Nicky V:
It feels as though we live in a pessimistic world at times. Call it the new media environment, call it the rise of social media, call it the reality of being a Mariners fan, but regardless of what’s to blame, I can’t say that watching this season of Mariners Baseball has often been an exercise in escapism, or has made me feel, like, better than I did before turning on the game. It’s been comfy, though! Bad Mariners baseball feels like home, an unfortunate & revealing wound on my/our collective psyche.
Even more unfortunate, Cal Raleigh hit 4 home runs in the last two days (as I write this), George Kirby looks vintage, Canzone is out of platoon jail, so goddamnit, I’m starting to believe in the Seattle Mariners. They don’t have to do much over this final stretch to beat out Houston and Texas and put the West back in the AL West. I think they can do it. The Mariners might win every series the rest of the season with an average run differential of minus-8 per set, and win the AL West.
Hope Rating: 7/10. I think they make a decent run and lose in 5 in the ALDS.
Kate:
In scouting they call a 45 a coward’s grade: you don’t think the prospect is bad, exactly, but you don’t think they’re good, either; some scouting departments think any grade that ends in a 5 is cowardly, trying to split the difference between projections (“fringe-average” rather than just “average” or “below average”). Typical Kate behavior, yes, why pick one thing when can pick two.
I fully acknowledge that a 5/10 is a coward’s grade to put on the old Hope-o-meter, resting exactly in the middle. But that’s not my fault, that’s the fault of the 2026 Seattle Mariners, who have Lucy-and-the-footballed me all year, seeming to promise to turn things around only to sink back down in the offensive doldrums. I’m on the record as having complained about this team’s lack of consistency all season, and while occasionally that helps them – like bouncing back for a win after getting the stuffing kicked out of them the night before – it also makes it hard to project this team putting together any kind of run going forward, which is what it would take for them to make it to the playoffs. But since no one seems to have any interest in winning the AL West, I can’t go much below 45 – and hey, Emerson Hancock was a 45 grade as a prospect, so maybe there’s hope yet.
Hope Rating: 5/10

Bee:
I have never had an interest in rooting for a super-team. Yes, comfortable wins are nice, and I would like the Mariners to win more than they lose. Someday I would like to see that culminate in a World Series win. But… I don’t need it. What I need is for baseball to be fun, for it to feel like the team at least has a chance. When that chance has been slim, the odds stacked against them? Those have been my favorite moments of Mariners success. When the deck seems stacked against a gritty team of grinders, and the hard effort, the heart, wins the day.
Admittedly, because of my own life issues putting me on the IL of baseball fandom, I didn’t watch as much of the first half of the season as I would have liked. My first recap of the year was only just over a week ago, game three against the Houston Astros. Even from a distance I could tell the first half of the season was a bit of a miserable slog for all of those involved. Whether because of that or despite it, after re-engaging with following the team the last several weeks, I actually have a lot of hope for them trending upward through the rest of the season. That’s because, often for better and sometimes for the absolute, truly, terribly, the worst, the team has been fun in that time. The remaining twilight of the season grows dimmer, but the team genuinely feels like it is starting to play like they realize it. It’s easy to and is often said as a Mariners fan that it would be just like the team to make the playoffs, or win it all, in the most bizarre and possibly stressful way possible. Usually, it rings of grief; the most common way it is said is to inject acceptance, or maybe it is bargaining. I choose to embrace it. This team is weird, and kinda broken… and that’s where they thrive. The whole AL West is broken, sure… but we have home field advantage.
Hope Rating: 6.9/10
Anders:
It’s pretty wild we’re having the playoff conversation at all considering this is probably the worst vibes season since…2019? There’s absolutely zero reason that the Mariners deserve to make the playoffs, and yet here we are.
It’s pretty upsetting to consider the AL West might send a below .500 team to the playoffs. One time when I was in a high school musical competition, the judges ruled that nobody was good enough to win. They straight up refused to name a winner. Can we not do that here? Because even if this Mariners team technically has a good shot to make it, I’m not sure I want them representing the organization or division in this capacity.
I exaggerate, of course. I would be thrilled if they won the division even if it felt icky. And honestly, with how they’ve been playing over the last week (games started by Bryce Miller notwithstanding), and looking at their September schedule…I dunno, guys! Besides, this is the hope score, not the worthiness score. There’s enough to legitimately hope for with a month to go.
Hope Rating: 5/10
Eric:
During the 50th anniversary golden turd jubilee weekend where the Mariners got swept by the Rays, I was finally ready to give up on any playoff hopes for this team. Even with the mostly soft September schedule, they just seemed far too hurt and mostly listless to imagine them turning it around. Randy and Cole Young cannot will this offense to the postseason by themselves, although Randy is trying his damnedest.
But given their recent week-ish stretch of much improved play (blowouts aside), Kade Anderson’s excellent debut, J.P. returning from the IL, Julio warming up, and Cal’s four dingers in 2 games…well…

My playoff mustache is in effect and I’m keeping hope alive until they’re dead. Go Mariners.
Hope rating: 6/10
James:
If you asked me to rate my hope before the start of the Cubs series, I probably would’ve landed somewhere between four and five. Though I am cautious to jump to any conclusions based on only a few games, I do feel like the last several days have helped me better envision the September run that will be necessary for the Mariners. I think many people, myself included, were beginning to accept 2026 as a lost season for Cal; if a late-season turnaround continues to materialize, then that changes the outlook quite a bit in my view.
After next Wednesday, the remaining games are as follows: 14 games against the bad teams in one of the worst divisions in baseball history, five games against your similarly mediocre counterparts in one of the worst divisions in baseball history, and three games against the Colorado Rockies. As long as the Mariners don’t dig a much deeper hole in the coming week — and the way they’ve played in recent days has helped quell that fear — their season will ultimately come down to divisional games. They are already 20-13 in such games this year and have held the best intradivision record in the AL West each of the past three seasons. I’d argue they also have the most upside of the contenders. While they aren’t out of the woods yet and probably enter September trailing, it seems more likely now than a couple of weeks ago that the division title will remain within reach in the final month.
Hope rating: 6/10
ZachMason
My head looks at how badly this team has played despite its talent and potential and tells me they’re more likely to miss the playoffs than make them. But no matter what I think, I can’t escape how I feel when Julio’s bat connects with the ball. Playoff odds are over at FanGraphs. You asked for a hope rating, and hope lives in the heart.
Hope rating: 8/10
Ryan
I don’t think the Mariners are good at hitting, pitching, fielding, or base running, and I think they deserve their place at six games under .500. But they have the weakest strength of schedule remaining, according to FanGraphs. That also implies their schedule to this point has been rather difficult. Over the last few weeks, they’ve played the best, second best, third best, fifth best, sixth best and seventh best teams in the majors – pretty much every team that figures to matter in October. Maybe we’ll feel different about this roster after they get a chance to beat up on some bottom dwellers. The snarky Mariners-fan in me wants to say, “maybe we’ll feel much, much worse.” But I kind of don’t think so. I think they’ll finish out the year strong and win the division. And from there, who knows.
Hope rating: 7/10
Composite LL Staff Hope Barometer: 6.5/10
You heard it here first: The Looking Landing staff believes the Mariners are going to make the playoffs. We’re coping here, folks. Are you?





















