President of baseball operations David Stearns and the rest of the Mets’ front office had a busy trade deadline this season. After acquiring reliever Gregory Soto in the days prior, Stearns landed Ryan Helsley, Tyler Rogers, and Cedric Mullins on July 31, seemingly shoring up any glaring holes on the roster.
But since that day, the Mets have gone 15-26, and with all of the struggles the starting rotation has had since that point, questions have arisen about why Stearns didn’t address the rotation at all at the deadline.
Even before the deadline, there were questions about Kodai Senga, Frankie Montas, and Sean Manaea staying healthy and Clay Holmes’ durability during his first year as a starter.
Hindsight is always 20/20, but Stearns said on Tuesday that he would have done things differently had he known where the rotation would be at this point in time.
“I think if I knew exactly how our season would play out, absolutely (I would have approached the trade deadline differently). No question,” Stearns said. “We make the decisions we make at the time with the information we had. I’m very comfortable with the process we went through that led us to those decisions, but yeah, we did not play well during the month of August, and frankly, to this point through September. We’ve had various segments of our team that haven’t performed certainly to the level that we anticipated as we approached the trade deadline, and had I had that knowledge going in, yes, it would have changed what we did.
“I think we’re always trying to project out various possibilities, and there’s a probabilistic nature to everything we do, and we understand that we’re not going to get everything right. We’re unlikely to predict with perfection what seasons are going to look like, what stretches of seasons are going to look like. So I think certainly we have to learn from this and determine whether there are things we could have seen that we did not, but I am confident in our evaluative capabilities and our work on the whole that we’ve accomplished.”
Helsley has struggled with pitch-tipping and consistency, as evidenced by his 10.29 ERA as a Met, and while Rogers has pitched well and Soto has been up-and-down, Mullins has scuffled, posting a .571 OPS in 34 games as a Met.
"I think Cedric came over to a new team for the first time in his career, adjusting to a new organization, little bit of a different role. Got off to a little bit of a struggle, and sometimes that can put pressure on players, and I think he's spoken about that a little bit, that sometimes you can press," Stearns said when asked about Mullins' struggles. "I do think he's beginning to come out of it. I think we're seeing him have a little bit more productive at-bats, staying in at-bats, getting on time with the fastball little bit better. And so that's a really good sign for us."
The question, then, is a simple one: what exactly went wrong?
“First of all I would say we’re not at the end of the line yet, so there are potentially chapters yet to be written, but to this point it’s a fair assessment that our trade deadline, at least some of our trade deadline acquisitions, have not performed to the level that we expected or the level that they have performed at throughout their careers,” Stearns said. “Part of that is streakiness and randomness, and this happens every year in baseball with some trade deadline acquisitions. Part of it is, we need to look and ensure that we’re doing everything we can to help these guys succeed.
"We take a lot of pride in, when players come here, allowing them to be the best versions of themselves. We’ve talked a lot about that, and so when that doesn’t happen, we need to be honest about that as well and see what more we can do.”
As poor as the Mets have played since the start of August, particularly during the recently snapped eight-game losing streak, the club still currently owns the third and final NL Wild Card spot, sitting 1.5 games ahead of the Arizona Diamondbacks and 2.0 games ahead of both the San Francisco Giants and the Cincinnati Reds.
As Stearns said, the story of the Mets’ 2025 season hasn’t been completed just yet, and all he and the rest of the club can do now is focus on doing whatever is needed to make the dance and play in October.
“I think when you’re sitting where we were in mid-June, we would not have expected to be in this spot,” said Stearns. “There’s no question about that. We’ll have time to evaluate and diagnose and do all of that stuff. For right now, my focus is here from here forward, what can we do to win as many games as possible, and that’s in the regular season and the postseason.”