It’s over. We are so back. It’s over. We are SO back. It’s over. We are SO BACK! Like a tennis rally that seems to go on forever and you can only watch in increasing awe as it plays out, the Orioles veered between these two extremes on Wednesday afternoon. They played some absolutely atrocious baseball and deserved to lose, no question. They played some amazing baseball and deserved to win. In the end, as ever, deserve has nothing to do with it. There’s only what happened, and what happened is the Orioles took 12 innings to win a 10-9 game.
All of this craziness occurred in a game that “everyone” expected going in would be a pitcher’s duel. The starting pitchers, back when it began, were Tarik Skubal for the Tigers and Trevor Rogers for the Orioles. Each of these guys has been pitching great for the last little while (Skubal for longer than Rogers) and each is a pending free agent. The losing team would lose the series and be highly likely to trade their guy. That was the narrative going into the game. There were real stakes for these fringe wild card contenders.
The Orioles started sending this thing into “it’s over” in the third inning. After two perfect innings from Rogers to begin the game, the bottom third of the Detroit lineup started a rally, a single and then a double to set up Detroit with no one out and men on second and third. Teams who are not the Orioles often capitalize on such situations. Tigers #9 hitter Javier Báez did so, hitting a single into right field that easily scored a run.
In un-Oriole-like fashion, Tyler O’Neill in right field hit the cutoff man while throwing home and the batter, Báez was hung up between first and second base. Rogers chased Báez into a rundown. Gifted with this “free” out from this rundown, Pete Alonso threw the ball into left field, allowing the runner to score from third base. They held a 2-0 lead and got a third run later in the inning on a sacrifice fly. Three runs went onto Rogers’s ledger, though only two were earned.
Orioles defense struck again in the fifth inning. Leody Taveras played a single into a triple. No error was charged here, but it was an egregious misplay and it gifted Detroit with a runner on third and no one out. Báez cashed that in quickly by hitting a single, and after a double and another sacrifice fly, a fifth Tigers run crossed the plate.
If that wasn’t hopeless enough, more unbelievably bad defense in the sixth inning brought two more Tigers runs home. Christian Encarnacion-Strand and Henderson committed errors on back-to-back plays; both of these guys scored. Rogers pitched through this inning and that closed the book on him with seven runs allowed, only four earned. The Orioles have the league lead in unearned runs and are on pace for possibly the worst defensive season in franchise history by that measure.
The Orioles trailed, 7-0, with Skubal on the mound and cruising into the late innings. There were two outs in the top of the seventh inning, the Orioles had Henderson on third base, and Coby Mayo was at the plate trying to try to do anything to chip away at that massive deficit. The game was so over, and with it, essentially, were their hopes of doing anything other than selling before Monday’s trade deadline.
Then, suddenly, it wasn’t over. Mayo walked and Taveras singled, chasing Skubal, who was at 92 pitches. Detroit brought in reliever Kyle Finnegan, who faced the minimum three batters and retired none of them. Jackson Holliday pinch hit for Chadwick Tromp and delivered a two-run single, then Taylor Ward followed with another single to score two more. Almost in the blink of an eye, the insurmountable 7-0 lead was narrowed to 7-5.
The very next inning saw the Orioles tie it up, with a little help from the Tigers defense. Henderson led off with a walk. Dylan Beavers followed by hitting a grounder to second baseman Gleyber Torres that Torres decided to try to throw to second base instead of getting the sure out at first. He couldn’t beat Henderson to the bag. No outs were recorded on the fielder’s choice.
Eventually, these runners were on second and third with one out. Mayo crushed a pitch to deep center field, like “it would have been a home run in 25 other stadiums” deep center, and this went over the head of Báez in center field. Báez was in a horrible position to play the bounce off the wall and it was ultimately left fielder Riley Greene who threw to third base to try to stop Mayo from safely reaching for a game-tying triple. It didn’t work. Mayo’s hit made it 7-7.
There was still only one out, but neither Taveras nor substitute catcher Yohel Pozo could bring Mayo home. That’s where the score stayed until the game went into extra innings. That’s when things got truly weird.
It’s so over: Beavers popped out on the first pitch, failing to get the zombie runner Henderson over to third base. Encarnacion-Strand hit a line drive to shortstop and Henderson was caught going just a little too far; rookie Kevin McGonigle made the catch and doubled up Henderson.
We are so back: Tyler Wells needed only three pitches in the bottom of the tenth to get a groundout, intentional walk, and ground ball double play. Staying back, the Orioles got two runs in the top of the eleventh. Taveras bunted the Manfred Man over to third base, generally a bad choice for the road team in extra innings and doubly bad when the no-bat catcher Pozo was due up. Pleasantly, Pozo delivered a sacrifice fly, and after him, Holliday slashed a single into left field for a 9-7 Orioles lead.
It’s so over: Manager Craig Albernaz brought in Rico Garcia for the bottom of the eleventh. Garcia served up a game-tying home run to Spencer Torkelson, the first batter he faced. There has been an unfortunate amount of that this week. Remaining in “it’s so over” territory in the top of the twelfth, Alonso struck out and Henderson delivered a fly ball that could only advance the runner to third base with two outs. They were on the verge of failing to score and then having to get who knows what reliever to pitch a scoreless inning.
Then, once more, we are so back: Colton Cowser, maligned (often unfairly) as one of the least clutch guys around, worked a full count before ripping a single up the middle. That made it 10-9 Orioles, which was, at last, the final score. Even this was not without excitement; the speedy McGonigle was the Manfred Man for Detroit, and Grant Wolfram began the inning by walking Ben Malgeri, who I just re-confirmed is a real baseball player. Two outs later, with the runners moved over to second and third, the Orioles turned to Andrew Kittredge to get the last out. He did it. An easy groundout, Henderson to Alonso for the game-ender, no bad throws, nothing else weird, just the end of one of the wildest Orioles victories of the year.
This game went down as just the third time since 2020 that a team came back from a 7+ run deficit in the sixth inning or later. It’s also the largest Orioles comeback win since June 30, 2009, when they mounted a nine-run comeback to beat the Red Sox. The 2026 Orioles have many problems. A lack of fight is not one of them. These guys are really something. That something is not always good, but it’s always something.
The Orioles are still three games below .500 even after all of this. Whether they gain ground in the wild card race depends on whether Cleveland beats the Reds later on Wednesday. There is a lot more work to be done in the standings and they are going to need to find a way to tighten up some of their problems, particularly their defensive problems but also their “bring in relief pitchers because they were good earlier this year even though now they clearly aren’t still good” problems.
If the Orioles had blown this game, it would feel like they had no chance to come back in the standings. Now, they have a chance. It’s a small chance, but still a chance. That’s better than last year. We will have to wait out the Thursday off day and then three games against the Phillies to see where they stand heading down to the deadline.
The Orioles could blow that series and end up sellers anyway. They could play well in the series and have Mike Elias still decide to pull the plug, like he did in 2022. They could play well and have Elias fail to substantially reinforce a contender, or maybe even they could play well and Elias pushes some chips in. Baseball is great and terrible because we don’t know.
A lot is riding on Friday’s game against the Phillies, and Saturday’s, and Sunday’s. Brandon Young is set to start the 7:05 series opener. The Phillies haven’t listed a starter for Friday yet.
**
It is a longtime Camden Chat tradition to proclaim a Most Birdland Player after each Orioles victory. During that June 30, 2009 comeback win I mentioned above, the entire team was proclaimed to be Most Birdland. What is Most Birdland? Each person must decide for themselves. Sometimes, this is the most valuable player of a game. Sometimes, this is not. Let us know your choice in the comments.
COVERS INTEL:
