It's a cliché because it's true: You can never have too much starting pitching. And the reality is, a vast majority of Major League Baseball clubs are in need of more than one.
Yes, free agent season is largely pitching reloading season, and the relative dearth of starting pitchers out there can ratchet up the anxiety for executives and fans - particularly as the expected lockout looms Dec. 2, adding urgency to fill holes before the industry re-starts.
There's all kinds of price points available beyond luxury item Tarik Skubal, who is expected to set a record for value of a pitching contract. Yet as early action on the market has indicated, prices aren't going to be cooling. With that, USA TODAY Sports breaks down the top 35 starting pitchers available:
Ages as of April 1, 2026
1. Tarik Skubal (LHP, 30, Dodgers)
Still the one. Skubal’s elbow procedure in May and his decent but not indomitable playoff stint after a trade to the Dodgers might cool his market a tad, but he’ll easily sail past the $325 million record for a free agent pitcher. Expect him to sign shortly before the lockout plug is pulled.
2. Michael King (RHP, 31, Padres)
Yeah, this free agent class is a little short on star power. King will make someone happy, though: In 77 starts over three seasons in San Diego, he pitched to a 3.15 ERA, a 1.19 WHIP and struck out 436 in 432 innings. A solid No. 1, an excellent No. 2 for a team with playoff aspirations.
3. Freddy Peralta (RHP, 30, Rays)
What a roller-coaster for ol’ Fastball Freddy, who seemed to jeopardize eight seasons of greatness with one half of terrible with the Mets. Yet Peralta reignited his value with an increasingly electric three-month stint in Tampa Bay, capped by a postseason in which the Rays won the first four games he pitched in before running into the Brewers. That run likely brought him back into the nine-figure contract club.

4. Clay Holmes (RHP, 34, Cubs)
Again with the reliable if not dominant right-handed starters. Holmes re-made himself very nicely with the Mets, stretching out to become a starter again and he was bound for an All-Star bid before a comebacker resulted in a freak broken bone in his leg. Still, he posted a 3.26 ERA over 40 starts there and has a knack for suppressing the home run.
5. Trevor Rogers (LHP, 28, Orioles)
Rogers’ up-and-down stint in Baltimore after a 2024 trade ended on a very high note, as he pitched to a 2.89 ERA and 2.90 FIP in his final 20 starts. His age and apparent remaining upside make him a nice fit for a club that fancies itself pitching savants.
6. Nick Pivetta (RHP, 34, Padres)
A flexor strain cost him five months of this season, but he looked crisp in his return and brings to the market a nice two-year sample in San Diego: A 2.87 ERA over 216 1/3 innings and a 0.99 WHIP. Durability concerns might force him to accept a deal laced with some incentives, but Pivetta and his signing club will feel pretty good betting on each other.
7. Foster Griffin (LHP, 31, Guardians)
Talk about a winning bet on yourself: Griffin came back from Japan and posted a 15-6 record and 3.60 ERA with the Nationals and Guardians, appearing in three playoff games for Cleveland. Griffin’s eight-ish pitch mix makes him tough to square up, even if his 8.2 strikeouts per nine innings may give pause to clubs obsessed with swing-and-miss.
8. Nick Martinez (RHP, 36, Rays)
Speaking of first-time All-Stars who induce weak contact, Martinez had an extremely precise season with the Rays: A 1.09 WHIP despite just 109 strikeouts in 180 innings. But Martinez was extremely valuable in the rotation and clubhouse for Tampa Bay and, like many pitchers on this list, might not be a bona fide No. 1 but can make a decent rotation playoff-caliber.
9. Matthew Boyd (LHP, 36, Cubs)
Boyd backslid a fair amount from his 2025 All-Star campaign, his ERA bumping from 3.21 to 3.91 and his FIP from 3.65 to 4.21. Boyd required surgery on his meniscus after a mishap playing with his children and also had a biceps issue, but in 61 starts over three seasons has a 3.41 ERA. Quality you can rely on.
10. Shota Imanaga (LHP, 33, Cubs)
He pitched last year after accepting the qualifying offer and had a Shota-esque year, dominating in six April starts before blowing up in May and August, landing on a 3.77 ERA overall. His three major league seasons have had similar roller coasters, and the Cubs have lost both playoff games he’s appeared in before staying away from him in the 2026 wild card series. Still, the stuff is good and he’s posted a 1.04 career WHIP.
11. Hiromi Itoh (RHP, 29, Nippon Ham Fighters)
Teams who obsess over strike zone control will love Itoh, who struck out 159 but walked just 34 in 172 innings this past season. The winner of the NPB’s Cy Young equivalent in 2025, Itoh figures to slot as a mid-rotation option in the major leagues.
12. Tyler Mahle (RHP, 32, Braves)
Mahle might want to send a Christmas bonus along to the Braves’ pitching department after his ERA dropped from 5.13 in 18 starts with San Francisco to 1.99 in nine starts with Atlanta. His overall 3.99 mark was probably what was expected all along but Mahle’s strong finish and overall healthy campaign – his 27 starts were his most since 2021 – will ensure a nice payday this winter.
13. Kevin Gausman (RHP, 36, Cubs)
Gausman was weighing retirement this season and then saw his ERA balloon to 4.83 in nine starts after a trade to Chicago. Still, he struck out 10.2 batters per nine for the Cubs and in the right hands can make his fastball-splitter combo bite. If he doesn’t sign before the lockout kicks in, it might be tougher to get out of Dad Mode.
14. Shane Bieber (RHP, 31, Blue Jays)
Still might not be fully ready to hit the market after opting into his $16 million player option for 2026. Lingering effects from a World Series run that followed Tommy John recovery limited Bieber to 11 starts, so perhaps one more short-term deal is in his future. He’s young enough and good enough to cash in once he’s able to go to the post 25 to 30 times.
15. Casey Mize (RHP, 29, Padres)
He looked primed to cash in in a big way after posting a 2.70 ERA in 16 starts with Detroit and then getting swept out of town along with Tarik Skubal, landing in San Diego. But it all went south, so to speak, with the Padres, as he was hammered for 56 hits in 44 2/3 innings and a 7.46 ERA in 10 starts. Given his uneven health history, a make-good situation might be best for Mize, too.
16. Zac Gallen (RHP, 31, Diamondbacks)
He’s been backsliding since 2022, when he led the NL with a 0.91 WHIP and just 5.9 hits per nine innings. Yet his ERA has gone straight up since: From 2.54 to 3.47 to 3.65, 4.83 and finally 6.07 last year, when he yielded 10.9 hits per nine. It’s clear a change of scenery is necessary; the question is how much someone’s willing to pay who believes they can bring back the old Zac.
17. David Peterson (LHP, 31, Cubs)
An All-Star in 2025, when he pitched a career-high 168 2/3 innings, he was more swingman with the Mets in 2026, starting eight games and relieving in eight others before a trade to Chicago, where the Cubs put him back in the rotation. Still, a lefty who can start or go multiple innings retains significant value.
18. Robbie Ray (LHP, 35, Padres)
Like Casey Mize, Ray backslid after a trade from an also-ran to San Diego. Still, there aren’t many more reliable inning-consuming lefties than Ray, who posted a 3.54 ERA over 60 starts for a couple bad teams in San Francisco.
19. Erick Fedde (RHP, 34, White Sox)
Almost the platonic ideal of Modern Pitcher, Fedde can start, open, serve as a bulk guy and get out of the way when needed. His second go-round on the South Side went just fine, even if his 5.01 FIP didn’t reflect it – he was worth 2.0 WAR and posted a 3.83 ERA.
20. Martin Perez (LHP, 35, Braves)
The Braves sneaked him through waivers, dropped him back in the rotation and watched him take down 142 innings for a division-winning team – with a 139 ERA-plus, to boot. Probably not the guy for your playoff rotation, but one who can certainly help you get there.
21. Walker Buehler (RHP, 32, Padres)
It’s been a few years of baby steps for Buehler, and he quietly reached some nice plateaus last year: Thirty-two starts, most since he made 33 and finished fourth in 2021 NL Cy Young voting. His 153 2/3 innings were also highest since he took down 207 2/3 that year. And his 4.63 ERA nearly equaled a quality start, while his strikeouts per nine perked up from 5.3 to 7.7. He’s getting there.
22. Jack Flaherty (RHP, 31, Tigers)
Injuries – most notably right flexor inflammation - limited Flaherty to 19 starts, though he was more or less a quality outing (4.48 ERA) every time. He threw his four-seam fastball 49% of the time, second only to 2021 in frequency, even as it averaged a career-low 92.7 mph.
23. Max Scherzer (RHP, 42, Blue Jays)
We’ll always leave the light on for Maxie if the old boy wants to find his way home. The consenting parties would know what they’re getting: An incentive-laden deal with no guarantee of health, but a Hall of Fame presence that can certainly still spin a gem.
24. Chris Bassitt (RHP, 38, Orioles)
Like his pal Scherzer, Bassitt might take it to the house in 2027, but not until fulfilling union duties as an executive council member. Bassitt posted a 3.74 ERA and FIP over his last eight starts in Baltimore after undergoing a mild back procedure.
25. Brandon Woodruff (RHP, 34, Brewers)
Run it back in Milwaukee? The Brewers know Woodruff better than anybody and perhaps nobody was more deserving to earn a ring with them than Woodruff. A moderate base salary and significant incentives will likely be the move, be it in Wisconsin or elsewhere.
26. Michael Soroka (RHP, 29, Diamondbacks)
He really did it: Soroka made it through 21 starts and 116 innings, most since he covered 174 2/3 innings over 29 starts for Atlanta in 2019. Incessant health issues followed, but Soroka posted a 3.19 FIP and 1.08 WHIP for the Diamondbacks and suddenly is a free agent before hitting 30.
27. Patrick Sandoval (LHP, 30, Red Sox)
Provided 13 starts to the Red Sox in the back half of a two-year deal, the first spent recovering from Tommy John surgery. A year removed from that, he can certainly help someone’s rotation.
28. Jose Quintana (LHP, 38, Rockies)
Quintana suffered a left elbow sprain, opted for a PRP injection and lived to tell about it. An injury-plagued year at Coors Field is no great selling point, but the man did pitch to a 3.96 ERA for Milwaukee a year ago.
29. Cal Quantrill (RHP, 32, Rangers)
Limited to 110 innings but made the most of them, making 15 starts and producing a 2.86 ERA. A 135 adjusted ERA yet a 4.01 FIP – he averaged less than a strikeout per inning – makes Quantrill an interesting case.
30. Tomoyuki Sugano (RHP, 37, Rockies)
Sugano and Coors Field looked like a nightmare but the right-hander simply maintained his near-quality start production. Oh, his 5.37 ERA won’t wow anyone, but he still made 29 starts with a 93 adjusted ERA.
31. Brady Singer (RHP, 30, Reds)
One of those rare deals where a guy posts a 5.85 ERA yet is allowed to make 31 starts because, as a Reds exec once suggested, “Where else you gonna go?” Singer led the majors by giving up 102 earned runs yet still got through 157 innings. Can likely benefit from a new environment.
32. Jordan Montgomery (LHP, 34, Rangers)
His three-year nightmare after leading Texas to the 2023 World Series is finally over. A cool free agent period, poor performance and then Tommy John surgery in Arizona sidetracked the big lefty but he did return for 13 relief appearances after sitting out 2025. Intriguing flyer.
33. Kris Bubic (LHP, 29, Dodgers)
You just knew when the Dodgers acquired this dude from Kansas City that he’d be some kind of high upside reclamation project. Sure enough, Bubic needed just five games with L.A. and 14 overall to work his way into their playoff bullpen trust tree. An endorsement from the Chavez Ravine brain trust shouldn’t hurt his cause as he looks to join someone's rotation in 2027.
34. Kyle Freeland (LHP, 33, Rockies)
Freeland made generational money in Colorado, grossing $73 million in salary. You gotta figure he’s wondering how his ERA might look getting out of the altitude. It’s been a rough go since 2022 – a 5.23 ERA in 138 starts – yet Freeland continues taking the ball.
35. Trevor Williams (RHP, 34, Rangers)
Has had endless health woes in recent years but looked decent (3.14 ERA) over 28 2/3 innings with Washington and Texas after his July 29 season debut.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: 35 best MLB starting pitchers available: Skubal leads overheated market