We are now past the halfway point of the 2025-26 NBA season, and what started as a year of heightened expectations and optimism for the Knicks has quickly torpedoed in the last 10 games.
After winning the NBA Cup, completing an incredible comeback on Christmas Day and closing 2025 strong, New York has gone 2-8 since New Year’s Eve, falling from the clear No. 2 seed to a game ahead in the third spot entering play Monday.
Fans have suffered whiplash from the shift in quality of play from dominant contender to lottery fodder, but it’s important to keep context from the whole season, understand that even the best teams go through bad stretches, and remember the sample of New York outperforming is much larger.
To help us do that and take objective stock on where the team is at the midpoint, let’s give out midseason grades to each member of the rotation.
Jalen Brunson: B+
New York’s captain is having a career offensive season, averaging 28.2 points and 6.1 assists on some of the most efficient shooting of his career. He immediately bought in to Mike Brown’s new system and has once again proved himself one of the clutchest players in the league when the Knicks get down to the wire.
However, his defense as a whole this season has been worse, which has impacted the team at large. And when the last 10 games of shlock can be largely attributed to a lack of effort, energy and focus, that falls on the team’s leader.
In his defense, Brunson missed three of these losses, but it’ll be on him to help right the ship down the stretch.
Karl-Anthony Towns: C+
Towns is having a bad season. We always preach patience, but 42 games is more than enough sample to call it what it is, and Towns has simply not found any consistent comfort this year.
Perhaps it’s the new offensive system, the layers of added defensive complexity, injuries, or a mix of the above and more. But Towns’ scoring is near all-time-lows, his efficiency is already there, and the defensive end looks worse than ever after a promising start.
Now, a bad season from Towns will likely still result in an All-Star appearance, and he’s putting up 20 and 12 with the occasional breakout shooting night. But this remains a departure from previous Towns seasons, a departure from what we should expect given he’s fighting for the best shot at his first ring, and it needs to turn around fast.
OG Anunoby: B-
Anunoby looked like a top performer on the team, embracing the new offense to the fullest and making a case for a long-deserved Defensive Player of the Year award on the other end. Unfortunately, a hamstring injury sidelined him for nine games in late November, and his impact hasn’t been the same since.
He was hitting 39 percent of his threes before the injury, and is only converting 30 percent since returning, while his defense has slipped as well. We’ve seen similar, recurring short-term dips from Anunoby, so he should recover quickly to get his season back on track.
Mikal Bridges: B-
Welcome to Year 2 of the Bridges enigma, where he’s spending another regular season with perfectly valid production on impressive efficiency and few mistakes to really gripe about — yet it remains some of the most frustrating basketball to watch. The reason being, for all his talent (and the cost to acquire it), his day-to-day impact feels marginal when he could be much more aggressive, especially now that his team needs him.
The other issue is Bridges seemed to be one of the loudest voices opposite Tom Thibodeau’s last season, and for the new head coach New York’s brought in, Bridges still isn’t looking for layups, or getting to the free throw line, or showing any additional physicality. Chances are fans will be calling his name for a trade up until he makes all his value up in the postseason again, but in the meantime, it’s difficult not to feel mixed emotions about his play.
Josh Hart: A
Hart’s quietly had a career year and perhaps the best individual season of any Knick thus far. After a bad first four games, Hart has averaged 13.5 points, 7.9 rebounds and 5.6 assists, injecting energy as a starter or reserve, and most shockingly hitting 42.1 percent of his threes on over four attempts a night.
Miles McBride: A-
Those hoping McBride would develop more of a handle or penetration game to give the Knicks some extra points in their guard rotation may be disappointed, but McBride’s seemingly doubled down on the things of which he’s already great. His three-point shooting is up to a sizzling 43.4 percent on over seven tries a game — numbers met only by Jamal Murray, Sam Merrill and Kon Knueppel, and he remains one of the team’s most valuable defenders.
Mitchell Robinson: B-
Robinson’s consistently been putting in a good effort in a new system amidst fluctuating teammate availability, without getting increased touches, and while still dominating the glass unlike anybody but few in the league. He also took a few weeks to find his legs defensively and is at a new low from the charity stripe, but however his regular season ends up grading out, his true value is realized in the playoffs.
Jordan Clarkson: B
These grades are relative to expectations, and if you expected more or less from Clarkson than a nice handling-plus-scoring spark off the bench at unimpressive efficiency with high highs (NBA Cup) and low lows (pick a random game of the week), you were bound to be disappointed.
Tyler Kolek: B+
You really wish you’d seen more of it this past month, but Kolek’s emergence into a reliable backup guard that closes big games for the Knicks this season, including the NBA Cup, was the development of the year. If he can shake this downturn off, it will do much to restore the confidence of Knicks fans.
Landry Shamet: A
Stepped into a more consistent bench role and hit 40 percent of his threes, defended hard and put up a big 36-point game before getting injured. He’s back in uniform now and hopefully won’t need much time to get back in rhythm.
Guerschon Yabusele: F
New York’s biggest signing of the offseason has been their biggest disappointment of the regular season thus far. It’s beyond adjusting to scheme and playing into shape — Yabusele hasn’t looked the part anywhere on the court, seemingly only getting minutes over unproven rookies to try to build some trade value.
Mike Brown: B
The Knicks’ new head coach and their controversial decision to remove their previous one after a Conference Finals trip will ultimately be judged on one thing: whether or not they win a championship. If you want to judge the first half of this season as a marker for how things are going, there’s been more good than bad.
Until lately, New York was in control of the standings and had great team numbers, even winning the NBA Cup on the heels of experimentation, thoughtful adjustments, and the newly integrated offense. The bad news has centered around Towns’ season and the last 10 games, setting up Brown’s latest and greatest challenge as coach.
How he and the team respond will ultimately decide how the regular season plays out and beyond.