What we learned: Chad Tracy made bad call on Payton Tolle in Game 1 loss originally appeared on NBC Sports Boston
No matter which way you look at it, Game 1 between the Red Sox and Yankees was about one person and one person only: Cam Schlittler.
The soon-to-be Cy Young winner was dominant, allowing just two hits and one walk while striking out 10 Red Sox over 6.1 innings. He looked like a man amongst boys, and the Red Sox — who were dominated by Schlittler in last year’s playoffs and again in the regular season this year — had no answers.
Perhaps, then, it’s trivial to dissect and linger on anything else from the game. Wipe the slate, move on to a must-win Game 2, and see what happens.
But … that’s not how postseason baseball works. And the Red Sox didn’t make the playoffs by accepting defeat.
So it’s only fair to look back at a decision made by manager Chad Tracy in his first postseason game that immediately backfired.
It came in the bottom of the fifth, with starter Payton Tolle at just 83 pitches. Tolle had just retired Paul Goldschmidt on one pitch for the second out of the inning. He wasn’t dominating, but he was rolling, only allowing one run while working around five hits and a walk.
Tolle threw more than 83 pitches 20 times during the regular season. Yet Tracy decided on this night, in this spot, it was time to take out the man that he chose to be the Game 1 starter in the postseason.
It was a puzzling decision in the moment, one that you figured would at the very least come back to bite Boston later in the game when they had run out of their top bullpen arms early.
Yet as it turned out, it backfired immediately.
Tracy opted to replace the lefty Tolle with … the lefty Erik Miller, the Marcelo Mayer trade return who got off to a great start in Boston but fizzled significantly late in the year. Miller posted a 12.46 ERA and a 2.538 WHIP over his final five outings in the regular season, clearly losing whatever effectiveness he had when he first arrived in Boston.
And it only took three pitches for that to become clear, as Ben Rice — the man Tracy selected for Miller to erase in the fifth — clobbered a 97 mph fastball, sending a solo homer to straightaway center field.
The pitch was at the belt and split the plate in half.
The solo shot doubled the Yankees’ lead, and while Schlittler was in the midst of a special pitching performance, that extra cushion gave him an added margin for error in a game where the Red Sox really couldn’t afford to give him any more advantage than he already had.
What would have happened if Tolle had stayed in the game to at least get through the fifth and perhaps into the sixth (on a night when his counterpart set a career high with 117 pitches and made it into the seventh), nobody can say for sure. But the Red Sox certainly would not have been turning to career minor leaguer Alec Gamboa in the bottom of the seventh. (And the 29-year-old would have been spared from earning himself an ERA of infinity.)
In a season that was at times quite charmed, this decision by Tracy was distinctly the wrong one.
And in what is perhaps a perfect picture of how vastly things have changed in Boston, Tracy was asked nine questions before facing the obvious one: Why did you take Tolle out of the game?
“Not necessarily just the pitch count, but you’re trailing already, you’re moving through [the lineup for] the third time. [Ben] Rice had already hit a double in the gap off of him, and you have a nice lane there for for Miller. And obviously, he got him,” Tracy said. “So, just felt like it was a time to go.”
One of the main reasons Tolle was given the Game 1 start over Sonny Gray was his emotional disposition. Giving him the hook with nobody on and two outs in the fifth was deflating in and of itself. The homer that followed felt like a knockout blow.
Here’s everything we learned from the Yankees’ 9-0 win over the Red Sox in Game 1 of the Wild Card Series.
Roman Anthony got hurt
Despite an unimpressive and injury-plagued season, the Red Sox turned to Roman Anthony as the leadoff man for the playoffs. That postseason lasted all of two at-bats before he left due to injury.
Anthony struck out on a check swing in the first inning, and he struck out on another check swing in the third inning. He didn’t come out for his next at-bat, instead replaced by Andruw Monasterio.
Tracy confirmed postgame that Anthony got hurt on a check swing, injuring the same hand that kept him out of the lineup all summer. Anthony landed the injured list this year due to a check swing in Detroit in late May, tearing a ligament at the base of his ring finger that kept him out until Aug. 30.
Tracy said the hand “flared” on Anthony “and it got uncomfortable.” Tracy added that Anthony has felt occasional shots of pain in that injured hand but in this case, “some stuff happened that was more serious and was uncomfortable.”
He batted .245 with a .735 OPS in 55 regular-season games this year. Still, the Red Sox — who started Nick Sogard, Trevor Story and Jarren Duran in Game 1 — can’t afford to lose any bats, even if those bats are more about potential than production at this point in time.
Cam Schlittler used curveball to keep Red Sox guessing
Cam Schlittler is going to win the Cy Young this year, and it’s not because of his curveball usage. Schlittler primarily used his fastball, his cutter, and his sinker this season, using the curveball as his fourth pitch. It wasn’t all that successful either, with batters hitting .250 on the curveball. (They hit .162 on his fastball, by comparison.)
But in Game 1, Schlittler was using his curveball at an unheard of rate, and doing so with effectiveness. Schlittler threw his curveball 27 percent of the time in Game 1, compared to 10 percent on the regular season, with a 50 percent whiff rate when the Red Sox swung (8-for-16).
It was a wrinkle that allowed Schlittler to simply dominate Boston bats. The Red Sox mustered just two singled and a walk in 6.1 innings from Schlittler, who struck out 10 batters while setting a career high with 117 pitches.
Schlittler has owned the Red Sox since first facing them in the playoffs last year, and he utilized a secret weapon of sorts to keep that going in Game 1.
Caleb Durbin’s redemptive double play in fourth keeps game close
Through all of his ups and downs at the plate this season, Caleb Durbin has played an excellent defensive third base. It was peculiar, then, when he charged a George Lombard Jr. chopper in the fourth and whiffed. The ball took a dead hop off the dirt, and Lombard reached with a leadoff infield single.
Durbin got redemption later in the inning in a big way, though, when he caught a weird infield popup from Spencer Jones and then fired to second base to double up Lombard to end the inning.
The game was a bit shaky at that point, as Tolle walked Amed Rosario after the Lombard single. Erik Miller and Alec Gamboa both got to work in the bullpen, as the game was in danger of being broken open. Durbin’s play — aided by Lombard making a bad read on Jones’ contact — helped keep it a one-run game.
Later in the game, Nick Sogard started a spectacular 4-6-3, albeit when the game felt like it was already slipping away for the Red Sox.
Red Sox’ offensive woes are not Schlittler-specific.
Cam Schlittler shut the Boston bats down, of course, but that’s not necessarily a rare occurrence.
Over their final 21 games, the Red Sox averaged just 2.7 runs per game. They were shut out once, scored a single run five times, and scored two runs in four of those games.
So an offensive dud in this spot — against an elite pitcher or otherwise — certainly did not come out of nowhere.
The Red Sox managed to deliver just three hits in this one: A first-inning bloop single by Adley Rutschman, a seventh-inning single from Wilyer Abreu, and a double from Trevor Story with two outs in the eighth inning, the first and only time the Red Sox reached second base all game.
Brayan Bello had a chance to prove something; he did not
In what’s been a weird season for the Red Sox, nobody’s season has been weirder than Brayan Bello. He was an ineffective starter, he required an opener, he spent an extended time in Triple-A, and he was tremendously effective for a stretch.
When he entered a 4-0 game in the bottom of the eighth inning, the game was well in hand. Still, he had an opportunity to show he could be trusted to get outs in an adverse environment. He didn’t pass the test.
Bello entered the game with the bases loaded and one out, after Wyatt Olds loaded them up with a single and two walks. Needing to get a double-play ball to keep it close, Bello surrendered a sacrifice fly to No. 9 hitter Austin Wells.
A sacrifice fly wasn’t the end of the world, as the score was still somewhat manageable at 5-0. But Bello then walked Paul Goldschmidt before serving up a no-doubt-about-it grand slam to Ben Rice.
A once-competitive game turned into a laugher in a hurry, and Bello’s mystifying season added yet another sour chapter.
Speaking of Ben Rice …
Ben Rice killed the Red Sox in Game 1, going 4-for-5 with six RBIs.
He had three of the hardest-hit balls of the night, as he was all over just about everything he saw — right from the jump, too. His double in the first inning was the hardest-hit ball of the entire game at 110.3 mph. His grand slam had an exit velocity of 108.6 mph, and his solo homer was at 108.0 mph. Rice’s other hit — a single — had an exit velocity of 106.4, harder than all but one ball hit by the Red Sox all night.
So while Schlittler was the Red Sox’ biggest problem in Game 1, Rice was a very close second — and he’s someone the Red Sox will actually have to deal with in Game 2, when their season hangs in the balance.
Wilyer Abreu off the mark with second-inning throw to plate
What the Red Sox lack in offensive oomph they somewhat make up for in outfield defense, as Ceddanne Rafalea and Wilyer Abreu are two of the best outfielders in all of baseball.
Abreu, who will win the Gold Glove for a third straight year, flunked his first chance to show off his defensive prowess in the second inning. Austin Wells singled cleanly through the right side with Lombard on second base. Abreu was able to charge the ball, field it cleanly, and fire home. But his throw sailed up the third base line, allowing Lombard to score easily.
A great throw would have gotten Lombard easily. A good throw would have gotten him, too. Even a decent throw would have had a chance. Unfortunately for Abreu, he simply threw a bad one.
Payton Tolle carries quote from his late mother on glove
Payton Tolle lost his mother to colon cancer in 2024, and he honored her on Tuesday night with one of her quotes stitched into his glove: “You’re so pretty.”
That message is always on Tolle’s glove — it was a message his mother would say to him when he pitched in high school in order to keep him loose — but Tuesday’s start gave it some national attention.
History not on Red Sox’ side
As has been mentioned many times before, only once since the new Wild Card format was adopted in 2022 has the loser of Game 1 gone on to win the best-of-three series. The Red Sox know that history all too well, as they were the lone Game 1 winner to go on to lose the series a year ago in New York.
At the very least, though, they know that losing Game 1 is not a death sentence for the season. And the Sonny Gray-Max Fried matchup is a bit of a fairer fight than anyone vs. Cam Schlittler.
Fried pitched eight shutout innings with nine strikeouts against the Red Sox at Fenway in late April, but he allowed a run on three hits in 3.2 innings in his other start against the Red Sox in late August — his first start after spending time on the IL.
Gray faced the Yankees twice in June, allowing 3 runs in 6.1 innings at Yankee Stadium and pitching 7.1 shutout innings back at Fenway later that month.

























