SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA - OCTOBER 06: Nick Pivetta #27 of the San Diego Padres pitches in the first inning against the Milwaukee Brewers in game three of the National League Division Series at Petco Park on October 06, 2026 in San Diego, California. (Photo by Orlando Ramirez/Getty Images) | Getty Images
Welcome to our series grading every member of the San Diego Padres’ 40-man roster. The roster being evaluated is current as of Oct. 18, prior to the end of the World Series. Because of that, it will include players who will be free agents once the postseason concludes. Each player will be graded on their performance in the 2026 season, including the playoffs. That performance will be weighted based on how much time the player spent with the team (availability is the best ability).
Nick Pivetta
When the Padres signed Pivetta heading into the 2025 season, he was the last solid starting pitcher left on the free agent market. No other reliable options remained. San Diego signed him to a backloaded deal in order to maintain payroll flexibility. Pivetta turned in the best season of his career, earning some down-ballot Cy Young votes. He was expected to anchor the rotation alongside Michael King in 2026.
Overall Grade: C-
Things didn’t go according to plan. Pivetta made just four starts before hitting the injured list and remaining there for almost five months. He exited a start against the Colorado Rockies early and was later diagnosed with flexor strain in his throwing elbow. He ended up making just eight starts in total for the Friars due to several setbacks during his rehab assignments.
But, when he was on the mound, it was a thing of beauty. Pivetta pitched to a 2.86 ERA in those eight starts (34.2 IP). He was even better after returning from the IL, posting a 1.45 ERA in the month of September. His overall ERA was only so high due to a rough Opening Day performance (6 ER, 3.0 IP). Removing that first outing, Pivetta holds a 1.42 ERA across 31 2/3 innings of work.
He just didn’t pitch enough. The injury concerns led the Padres to decline his $14 million club option for the 2027 season. Reportedly, the two sides are still seeking a reunion. Had the Friars picked up Pivetta’s 2027 club option, he would have acquired an $18 million player option for 2028. San Diego probably didn’t want to be on the hook for that much if Pivetta’s arm gave out a second year in a row.
Welcome to our series grading every member of the San Diego Padres’ 40-man roster. The roster being evaluated is current as of Oct. 18, prior to the end of the World Series. Because of that, it will include players who will be free agents once the postseason concludes. Each player will be graded on their performance in the 2026 season, including the playoffs. That performance will be weighted based on how much time the player spent with the team (availability is the best ability).
Samad Taylor
When Taylor was drafted in 2016, it was believed that he could develop into a contact-hitting utility player, similar to Luis Arraez or Steven Kwan. Instead, he became a minor-league journeyman. From 2016-2025, Taylor played on four different organizations. He never quite broke out onto the big-league scene, with three short stints from 2023-25. In early January, the Padres signed Taylor to a minor-league deal with a non-roster invite to Spring Training.
Overall Grade: B+
He started off hot. In the first week of Cactus League play, Taylor batted .556 with an almost impossible-seeming 1.278 OPS. He cooled down significantly after that, finishing the spring with a .233/.265/.300 slash line. That led to Taylor missing the Opening Day roster and spending some time in Triple-A El Paso. He played quite well in the minors, slashing .307/.397/.482 with 19 extra-base hits.
That production (along with left fielder Ramón Laureano’s season-ending hip surgery) earned Taylor a call up to the big leagues. At the time, the Padres were floundering. They had just gone 13-15 in the month of May on the backs of a lackluster offense. Taylor batted .329 in the month of June, sparking the offense to life. He then missed time due to an oblique strain before returning down the stretch. He was just as good after returning, posting a .297 batting average through the end of the season.
Perhaps the biggest question surrounding Taylor is sustainability. His expected batting average (.256) is a good deal lower than his actual (.316). That’s likely due to his reliance on speed. Taylor ranks in the 93rd percentile in sprint speed. Jase Bowen is the only player on the Padres’ 40-man roster faster than Taylor. If he can utilize those tools again in 2027, he will certainly provide value for San Diego.
With the season moving forward at a breakneck pace, it can be difficult to find the bandwidth to focus on anything else. But for people like us, and hopefully many of you reading this, there’s no better time to appreciate the moments and players who got us to this place than when the planted seeds are finally bearing fruit.
And with Anthony Edwards’ explosive start to the season, where he placed third on the MVP ladder and was heading the scoring race before unfortunately being sidelined by injury, there is no better place to start than with the Timberwolves’ sole MVP.
We think there has been some anger from fans recently about how Garnett seems to embrace his Boston Celtics career, but we believe that some love remains from older fans who remember how great KG really was.
On the other hand, there are likely newer fans who don’t understand the extent of KG’s dominance. In this article, we offer an impassioned defense of why Kevin Garnett peaked as the best player in the world and arguably a top-five player ever.
The easiest place to start is a catch-all. We find it the easiest heuristic to understand exactly what we are dealing with. Regularized Adjusted Plus-Minus (RAPM) uses on-off data adjusted across thousands of possessions to attempt to find how much value a player adds over a variety of lineups.
This is then converted into how many points of value a player adds over 100 possessions. Any guesses how much utility Garnett generated during his prime?
In that MVP season in 2003-04, Garnett added NINE POINT EIGHT points per 100, which ranked first in the league and second all time, only trailing 2016-17 LeBron James. This type of impact is easily understood when we look at the team context.
KG came into the NBA as a wiry high schooler, with extreme energy and length that would later make him one of the best defenders we’ve ever seen. But his feel is largely unappreciated, as he excelled as one of the best ancillary offensive weapons of the 21st century. He is one of the most multiplicative pieces in history, as represented by some truly tremendous lineup data.
In the 2003-04 season, Garnett was off the court for a total of 715 minutes. During those possessions, the Wolves — a 58-win team — put up a net rating 10.3 points below the league average. In the 3,235 minutes that KG played, the Wolves rocketed up to a relative net rating of +9.6.
The obvious response to this is that Garnett was boosted by playing with the starters. After all, the Wolves employed Sam Cassell at the time, a player who earned second-team All-NBA honors that season. And it is true that when Garnett and Cassell played together, the Wolves put up astounding numbers.
Minnesota put up an explosive +11.5 net rating in the 2,535 minutes — 4,760 possessions — that the duo spent together. When both of them were off the court in 403 minutes, the Wolves fell to a precarious -15.8. Similarly, in the 313 minutes Cassell was on without Garnett, the team sported a -4.4 net rating.
However, there were 700 minutes, or 1,288 possessions, if you’re picky, that KG played without Cassell. The team’s net rating during those minutes? +4.3.
No matter who was on the court during KG’s time at the top of the basketball world, they did little to stifle his ability to impact the game at a historic level. His defensive superpowers made him one of the greatest game-changers in the league, but also a team-building cheat code.
Although KG wouldn’t officially receive the DPOY honor until his later years in Boston, we refuse to allow this lack of an accolade to diminish how impactful he was at his best in Minny. KG was truly one-of-one, a reactive, processing octopus who would use his tentacles to reach out at any shot attempt and stamp it.
What is lost in KG having so much length is that he also had some of the most miraculous hand speed ever for someone his size. The way he snaps his arms up to block passes or shots looks like a glitch in the system sometimes.
Garnett’s intersection of reaction speed, length, and movement let him be one of the best rim protectors ever while being able to guard at the point of attack when switched onto guards or in space when put into the pick and roll.
One area where he struggled, and where his contemporaries, such as Tim Duncan, were able to pass him up, was in strength-based stoppage. I am not explicitly arguing KG over Duncan in this article, but I use Duncan as the other dominant figure at the power forward position in the NBA to illustrate Garnett’s strengths. While no one truly stopped the once-in-a-lifetime Shaquille O’Neal, there is a gap in the work Duncan was able to do over Garnett, with both being incredible defenders.
However, Garnett makes up ground through his ability to play in different schemes, compared to Duncan’s traditional drop coverage. For example, the greatest offensive engine of their era, Steve Nash, found success solving these coverages in 2007, although his team ultimately fell short.
It is hard to compare because we do not have any Phoenix Suns playoff series against Garnett to compare with, nor was Duncan at his peak when they played, but it is one signal that matches up with the eye test that Duncan’s main points he held over Garnett were strength-based, while Garnett held more movement and versatility advantages.
KG getting into a defensive stance | FOX Sports
Garnett’s ability to move his feet, atypical for a big, allows for more aggressive and versatile coverages. For example, trapping or hedging toward the ball-handler is much easier when the center can recover quickly. It also enables switching and denies mismatch hunting.
These traits would translate incredibly well to the modern era, but that’s not to say he didn’t already put up monstrous defensive performances in his own time period. It is unfortunate that we do not get many playoff series from KG after 2004, but he puts up remarkable defensive signals in all of them.
Throughout his career, from 1997 to 2014, KG maintained an opponent-adjusted relative defensive rating of -6.4 when he was on the court, which is remarkable for someone who came into the league so early and left so late. If you isolate from 2004 onwards, he put up marks of:
-5.6 (2008)
-8.4 (2010)
-6.8 (2011)
-8.8 (2012)
-13.5 (2013)
-16.4 (2014)
Unfortunately, KG peaked in the pre-tracking era, so we don’t have many individual metrics that represent this impact, but the ones we have are extremely helpful. In his 2004 season, KG averaged five stocks per 100, split between three blocks and two steals. 67% of his blocks were recovered by his own team, which helped Garnett force 0.3 more turnovers per 100 than the league average, an 84th percentile mark.
Furthermore, KG had a 4% STOP% this season, with a stop being any action you take that causes a change in possession (eg. steals, blocks recovered, charges drawn), which ranked in the 97th percentile. Combine these stats with the holistic impact Garnett showed on his teams and the versatility that he could offer to any team that acquired him, and you get one of the best defenders to ever touch the hardwood, period.
Defense is based on three things: eliminating the offensive possession through forcing a turnover, Suppressing the offensive possession through forcing a hard look, and ending the offensive possession through a defensive rebound.
Garnett was one of the best ever at the first two, but adding in that last bit gives him a case for being the GOAT. From 2003 to 2007, KG led the league in defensive rebounds. For five straight years, his lowest defensive rebounding total was 9.2 per game, and in all four other years he maintained an average over ten.
The all-time defensive rebounding leader, with 11,453 in his career, didn’t play during the tracking era, but the signals we have from the end of his career are incredible. In his 2014 season, ten years past his peak, he had a 27.9% defensive rebound percentage, which was in the 100th percentile. 100th!!! 32.2% of those rebounds were contested.
He maintained that already ridiculous rate of 26.6% defensive rebound percentage in the playoffs, with a 45.6% contested rebound percentage. Even past his physical prime, KG was still a monster on the defensive glass.
While we already mentioned his portable qualities, Garnett was still a one-man army on defense. In his 2004 season, he carried a defense 2.4 points better than the league average (a 7.5-point swing compared to when he was off), which represents the level of defensive help his teammates provided.
DARKO, an all-in-one metric that combines the box score and lineup data to estimate a player’s performance, views the players put around Garnett as, on average, a -1 boost to his defense — in other words, they returned negative defensive value.
Garnett was simultaneously a wrecking crew by himself and one of the most multi-faceted, ecosystem-building defensive players ever.
Often, defenders come with warts on the other side of the ball, especially when it comes to big men. That is being seen with another one of these all-time defenders who resides in Minnesota right now, Rudy Gobert. Fans despair over the lack of an offensive game, but this was never the case with KG.
KG was, in the truest sense, a unicorn in both ability and responsibilities. This may be easily said about players of the past in retrospect, but KG’s abnormal offensive duties on his teams didn’t go unnoticed at the time either.
Chris Broussard, in his 2004 article for the New York Times (the headline of which really says it all), recounts Game 4 of the Western Conference Finals, in which KG, flanked by an injury-depleted and underperforming Wolves roster, was left to face down the Kobe-Shaq Lakers “virtually by himself”. He played a game-high 47 minutes, which he himself felt wasn’t enough. Broussard notes that with lead guard Sam Cassell out, KG had become a “7-foot point guard, igniting the offense, then attempting to be a low-post presence as well.”
The article quotes Wolves head coach Flip Saunders as saying: “We’ve never asked [KG] to do more than he’s doing right now.” And although this was true, it was a temporary exacerbation of a preexisting problem – KG, as a Timberwolf, was systematically overtasked on offense.
In 2004, KG carried a 29.6% usage rate (an estimate of the percentage of total team plays a player used). For comparison, Steph Curry, in his 2014-15 MVP campaign, posted a 28.9% usage rate. He put up 30.2 true shot attempts per 100 (basically how many offensive possessions did he end up taking a shot, combining field goal and free throw attempts), which was in the 98th percentile. And he did this with efficiency 2.9% better than league average — 91st percentile. He also averaged 6.8 assists per 100 – 99th percentile. Overall, he created 47.9 points per 100 – 100th percentile.
Garnett bringing the ball up the court | Icon Sports Media
This was not a one-season phenomenon. From 2003 to 2005, for three seasons straight, KG was in the 100th percentile positionally in points created per game and in points created per 100. Nobody at his position was asked to create offense at a higher volume on a game-to-game or possession-to-possession basis. From 2001 to 2007, a seven-season stretch, the lowest he ever dropped was 97th percentile in either per-game or per-100 points created.
During that span, the highest offensive rating the Wolves posted in a single season was in 2001-02 – a 109 ORTG, good for fourth in the league. Their highest playoff ORTG during that span was in 2003: 106.2, good for ninth out of 16 playoff teams.
Across all games in that span, regular season and postseason, when KG was on the floor, the Wolves ORTG sat at 107.2, a mere 2.4 points above league average. When he went to the bench, however, the offense dropped to an abysmal 97.3, a 10-point swing that saw them plummet to 7.6 points below league average.
Certain fair criticisms can be levied against him, as a handful of limitations prevented him from carrying the Wolves to greater playoff heights on offense.
He lacked the dominant low-post game that many fetishize in older bigs, which suppressed his overall rim scoring. In his ‘04 MVP campaign, he put up 4.7 rim attempts per 75 (56th percentile positionally), shooting 67% on them. 6’2 Tyrese Maxey so far in the 2026-27 season is averaging 5.8 rim attempts per 75 and shooting 71.4% on them. To be fair to KG, he got his in the height of the dead-ball era.
Hindered by his comparative stringiness and higher center of gravity, his post-up possessions more often than not ended with a tough jumper instead of a layup or dunk. He looked almost anemic at times, trying to create quality looks against contact.
His jumper-heavy diet limited his free-throw rate. He peaked at 6.7 free-throw attempts per game in 2005, though a high conversion rate of 81.1%, especially for a big, stemmed the bleeding. It also reduced his offensive rebounding opportunities. And of course, his penchant for long twos instead of threes suppressed his scoring efficiency.
Garnett skying for the dunk (per <em>Wikipedia</em>)
All this is true, and yet he remains one of the most unique, offensively impactful big men we’ve ever seen.
KG was ahead of his time. He possessed a genuine center’s frame with agility and ball-handling reminiscent of a wing, along with a silky, soft touch that led to some of the most prolific jump-shooting seasons we’ve ever seen from a big. If he played in today’s era, these qualities would no doubt translate beautifully.
In 2004, 74% of his field goal attempts came from either the long or short midrange, 42% from long midrange. Dirk Nowitzki, in the same season, shot 62% of his field goals from either the long or short midrange, and 46% from long midrange. They were similarly efficient.
KG was as versatile a scorer as any big ever. A capable play-finisher, he frequently scored on hard rolls, short rolls, pops, spot-ups, lobs, and other miscellaneous catches with layups, dunks, and jumpers.
Out of the low post and mid-post, although he could get his way to the rim, usually against smaller players, his bread and butter was a lethal midrange game. He could face up and just shoot it, but more often, he would turn and fade, from a variety of spots over both shoulders, off the catch or off the dribble, as he pleased and as the situation called for. He could also go to a hook shot over the top.
He had the stride length and quickness to drive by his man and take it to the rim with an open lane. He could also run the floor in transition or push the break himself off a rebound, which not only helped him score but also led to easy playmaking opportunities.
He was a tremendously gifted, versatile passer for a power forward. At his size, he could see above and pass over smaller defenders, and his ball handling, agility, and ability to process the floor let him pull the trigger quickly when an opportunity presented itself. He could ignite breaks with outlet passes off his rebounds. He could make passes off the dribble to shooters or streakers in transition. He could pass on the roll. He could spray it out of the post when he drew extra attention from help defense, even skipping it cross-court at times to the opposite corner or wing. He could zip it to a cutter or flashing big on the block for easy scores.
In each of the four seasons from 2002-05, KG was 100th percentile at his position in assists per game, and averaged just 2.7 turnovers per game and 5.5 APG over the whole stretch – doubling his assist-to-turnover ratio.
When he wasn’t doing the shooting, KG was cleaning up on the offensive glass, grabbing three per game from 2002 to 2005.
KG was a tremendous offensive player during his Wolves peak – not a flawless one, but extremely talented. He consistently found himself in the low-to-mid 20s PPG band, maybe only a tier or two below the upper echelon of big man scorers like Shaq or Dirk and in the same range as someone like Tim Duncan, while being a strong contender for the best big man passer on the planet.
Unfortunately (Wolves fans may not want to hear this), he wasted the better part of his prime on a subpar roster, forced into a suboptimal role. It is partially his fault for not being a dominant force in the low post and taking too many long twos, but he was also no doubt bogged down by the constraints of his teammates. Whatever the cause, he was routinely inefficient in the playoffs, and from 2001-2004, the Wolves never achieved even a +3 opponent-adjusted relative ORTG in the playoffs with him on the court.
Once he moved onto greener pastures in 2008, even though he had started to slip out of his physical peak and his creation volume dipped, his true shooting percentage reached near-career highs, from 53.9% in 2007 to 58.2%. Having more real shooters and playmakers alongside him replaced his tough post-up possessions with easier looks. His rim FG%, which was at 63.3% the year before, leaped to 71.2% on higher frequency. His short and long midrange FG%, which were at 46.1% and 43% respectively the year before, jumped to 49.8% and 47.7%.
There was improvement at the team level too. In 2008, the Boston Celtics posted nearly a +6 opposition-adjusted rORTG in the playoffs with him on the court. Evidently, KG is someone who, while capable of bringing poor offensive teams to somewhat competent heights as a first option, thrives when he is not tasked with being a primary creator for himself. And it seems his team thrives as a result.
Many may look back at the KG years with mixed emotions: They were never able to get over the hump, but it is one of the true exalting feelings of being a sports fan to have the best player in the world playing for your team.
In the same way, Garnett was much of a mixed bag. He lacked some of the things you’d like from a traditional 2000s big man. He didn’t have the size or the post game to assert his will on the game through physicality. But he made up for that and then some with a generational motor and other physical tools.
He was never able to carry his team to the championship as the number one option, but he demonstrated an ability to do so, while perhaps being better suited as the number two, pushing the Celtics team to historic heights.
But one thing is for certain if you are a fan of Minnesota. One of the best players to ever touch the rubber ball called this place home. Perhaps another is doing so right now. Sometimes, even with the new era roaring in your face, you can sit down and look at the fields of fruit in front of you and think about the one great tree that was here at the start.
MIAMI, FL - NOVEMBER 18: Giannis Antetokounmpo #7 of the Miami Heat handles the ball during the game against the Milwaukee Bucks on November 18, 2026 at Kaseya Center in Miami, Florida. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and or using this Photograph, user is consenting to the terms and conditions of the Getty Images License Agreement. Mandatory Copyright Notice: Copyright 2026 NBAE (Photo by Joe Murphy/NBAE via Getty Images) | NBAE via Getty Images
On a momentous night when the Milwaukee Bucks and Giannis Antetokounmpo faced each other for the first time, the Miami Heat pulled off a 137-130 win. Frankly, the final score flatters the Bucks, who spent most of the game down ~20 as Giannis diced them up from all over the court and finished with a near triple-double. As for interesting interactions between former teammates on both sides, there really wasn’t much to report. Tyler Herro got booed pretty mercilessly, while the reaction to his other three former Heat teammates was pretty lax. Giannis barely interacted with anyone from the Bucks (other than a brief joking interaction with Jericho Sims after Sims fouled him). Frankly, it looked a little awkward for everyone involved. Read our full summary of the game here and catch a six-minute audio recap on the Bucks+ podcast, Bucks In Six Minutes, below.
Herro was awful, yet again. Insipid on defence and unable to do anything with the Heat’s quick, physical guards as they hounded him up and down the court. I was desperately hoping for a snarling, trash-talking Herro who gave the Heat the business, but he went out with a whimper with the team looked better with him on the bench.
Jaquez was fine. He had his usual backbreaking turnover or two, but otherwise he was kinda just out there and made little impact, positive or negative.
Credit where it’s due: Kuzma was fantastic. Milwaukee would have lost this game by at least 30 if not for Kuzma’s work on both ends. He was about as good as anyone could have asked for as one of two primary defenders on Giannis, and his ability to keep the scoreboard ticking—even if it came drawing a BS foul—was crucial in slowing the Heat’s barrage of scoring runs.
Turner didn’t do anything that stood out as actively detrimental to the team, but he wasn’t a major plus either. Based on our lowered expectations for the big man this season, I would say he played fine. They kept Turner away from Giannis as much as possible, and I thought he did a solid job as a weak-side rim protector.
I mean, Ware got most of his when the game was, for all intents and purposes, over, scoring four of his five buckets in the second half. Still, I liked the way he ran the floor and kept his hands ready. I will say that whenever Giannis had a chance to go at Ware, you could almost hear his inner monologue saying, “BBQ chicken.”
Burries was great, especially in the third quarter, when he was the only guy who wanted to play with a spark, scoring 12 points on 4/6 shooting, including a sequence where he scored a layup, stole the inbounds pass, and flipped it to a streaking Kuzma for another layup. I thought his defence was a major plus too, as he fought over and under screens on the Heat guards.
Jakucionis with his second consecutive great game. Once again, his pace and burst were far more useful than Herro’s finesse. KJ’s second-half line is insane: 5/5 from the field, 3/3 from three, and 5/6 from the charity stripe with four assists, two steals, and no turnovers. He made several great passes out of the pick-and-roll, showcasing his ability to create a two-on-one and read the help defender.
Ament wasn’t overly involved in the first half, missing both of his three-point attempts. However, there were some encouraging signs in the second half. One facet of Ament’s game that’s evolving is his feel. They had him sprint up to set middle and side ball screens to see if he could catch it on the slip when the defence was switching, and he got a nice scoring opportunity doing exactly that. Interestingly, they also used Ament a bit as a passing hub at the top of the key as screening actions occurred around him; he hit LeVert on a nice dime while playing that role.
Sims was the other primary defender on Giannis (along with Kuzma), and he was solid enough. Attacked the rebounds hard and even made some nice passing reads.
Grade: C+
AJ Green
14 minutes, 11 points, 3/5 FG, 3/5 3P, +17
Green got most of his opportunities off roll-and-replace actions, where the point guard (mainly Jakucionis) created a two-on-one in the pick-and-roll, forcing Green’s man defender to rotate over and tag the roller, leaving him open for a split second from three.
Grade: B-
Taylor Jenkins
Obviously, the game plan centred on defending Giannis. I have always said that the first step to stopping Giannis is having a defender who can at least trouble him one-on-one, and then you’re able to help opportunistically as opposed to every time down. The Bucks don’t have that guy, so their plan was basically to turn GA into a passer, and he wrecked them doing exactly that. There’s nothing you can do about that, but I at least liked that Jenkins chose to take something away and didn’t let him score and pass; he shot just four times in the first half. I also suspect Sims started the last game to prepare for this one—and that starting won’t be regular—but I could be wrong.
Grade: C
Garbage Time: Caris LeVert
Inactive: Kam Jones, Cormac Ryan, Pete Nance, Ousmane Dieng, Bogoljub Markovic, Ryan Rollins
What We Learnt
The Bucks do not have a passable Giannis defender on their roster. Kuzma and Sims did their best and competed admirably, but neither was enough to really make him work.
Bonus Bucks Bits
Jericho Sims still has a major issue with illegal screens.
I hate to say it, but the Heat’s GTA-themed court looked stunning (see below). This was a one-night thing; we won’t see it ever again.
Unlike last season, when they were among the top teams in shooting percentage, the Bucks this season cannot seem to find a rhythm, and it is frustrating. Shot 15/43 in the first half last night and rank 29th on the season (42.9%).
Giannis did not shake hands with any members of the Bucks at the end of the game. A few nights before, he said this was “just another game.”
When asked, Giannis Antetokounmpo said he didn't think the Bucks' significant roster changes since the team won the championship in 2021 had anything to do with easing any awkwardness or tension in playing against his former team.
Kris Bubic could give the Sox the best bang for their buck if they move quickly to sign him. | (Jay Biggerstaff/Getty Images)
It’s no secret that the rotation was one of the weakest parts of the White Sox’s 2026 roster. Chicago’s starters had the fifth-worst ERA (4.60) and the sixth-fewest wins (39). They also made the fewest starts on more than four days’ rest (84) and the most starts on fewer than four days’ rest (24). At the GM meetings in Las Vegas, general manager Chris Getz announced that Grant Taylor will move into the rotation next year, but that’s just the beginning of the rotation renovation.
Getz isn’t cooking up his free-agent signings in a silo like a mad scientist, especially now that he’s hired former Brewers assistant director of scouting Matt Roffe as the White Sox director of scouting. Here are a few guys Getz should have on his radar.
Kris Bubic
If the Sox are ready to pay up for a starter and want someone they know well, Bubic could be their guy. He pitched for the Royals for five and a half years before being traded to the Dodgers in August. In 13 games against the Sox since 2020, he’s posted a 2.60 ERA and allowed 19 earned runs, eight home runs and 24 walks. It shouldn’t take a scout to know that a pitcher who can repeatedly shut down a division rival should be near the top of the free-agent list.
Expecting Bubic to pitch at his 2025 level after a rotator cuff strain and a sore elbow was a tall order, but he didn’t disappoint. In 55 innings as a starter and reliever in 2026, he posted a 3.76 ERA, held opponents to a .202 batting average, struck out 56 and allowed just four home runs. That versatility could make him the perfect Swiss Army knife for Will Venable.
The Sox need a dependable lefty with experience, and they don’t have to look far. Spotrac estimates Bubic’s market value at $17.4 million per year, nearly the same as the $17.5 million the Sox owe Munetaka Murakami in 2027.
Cal Quantrill
If Getz has already identified Taylor or Sean Burke as his ace for 2027, bringing in an arm like Quantrill may make sense. After an up-and-down three-year stretch, Quantrill bounced back from minus-0.7 WAR in 2025 to 2.0 in 2026. He lowered his ERA below 3.00 and his WHIP below 1.10 and finished with a winning record. He thrives on inducing soft contact and limiting walks, and his 5.6% walk rate ranked in the 92nd percentile among MLB pitchers in 2026. That combination could make him a good fit at the back of the rotation.
Even as he approaches the age when many free agents peak, Quantrill is showing that age doesn’t dictate development. The Sox should take advantage of his late bloom and rocky past to get a fair deal. A two-year contract worth $20 million to $24 million would be appropriate.
Griffin Canning
If Venable continues to mix and match with his pitching staff, Canning could be a good fit for the Sox. He split his time almost evenly among starting, pitching in middle relief and closing in 2026, but he was most effective out of the bullpen. He posted a 4.23 ERA and a .323 BABIP across all his relief outings, compared with a 6.79 ERA and a .338 BABIP as a starter. The Sox might bring him in as a starter and make a few mechanical tweaks, but Canning’s bullpen experience and success make him a viable swingman when plans go awry.
The Sox need guys who can eat innings, pitch in a setup role and bring it home. Canning can do all three. His track record doesn’t jump off the page, but at Spotrac’s estimate of $4.5 million a year, he’d be a low-risk addition.
Yes, Paul Goldschmidt, currently, is not the player he was when he looked like a HOF shoo-in several years ago. But he’s not a scraping-the-bottom-of-the-barrel player when he platooned, either. He hit .252/.313/.452 overall in 2026, but .299/.393/.573 and 11 of his 18 homers against LHP. It seems like platooning is a situation he’s acceptable to do. He had a $4 million contract this year. The Cubs could try that at one-year, or maybe $6 million, two-year contract with incentives.
He is not near the top of the list at all — just someone mentioned below with whom the Cubs might strike lightening once again. I know there’s a six-year difference in age, but maybe Goldschmidt will have a Michael-Conforto-like renaissance himself on the North Side. Just a thought.
I appreciate your reading.
*means autoplay on, (directions to remove for Firefox and Chrome). {$} means paywall. {$} means limited views. Italics are often used on this page as sarcasm font. The powers that be have enabled real sarcasm font in the comments.
More of the same ol’, same ol’?:
Matthew Trueblood (North Side Baseball): Tuesday’s Market Constrictions Force Cubs to Ratchet Up Urgency—and Projected Spending. “The best available catcher, the best available relief pitcher and the hardest-throwing right-handed starter on this winter’s free-agent market all came off the board Tuesday. The way each happened left little doubt that the Cubs’ needs will be expensive ones to fill.”
Free Agency/Trade Stories — Pitching:
Brett Taylor (Bleacher Nation): BREAKING: Sonny Gray to the Twins. “I do wonder where this leaves the Cubs. No, not because too many options are off the board – there are still LOADS in this tier – but instead because I’m wondering about the prices.”
Brett Taylor (Bleacher Nation): Remember Frankie Montas? He’s Back to Throwing for Teams. “I share this not because there’s a specific or explicit connection to the Chicago Cubs, but instead because (1) the Cubs have deep needs for SO MANY pitchers that they are probably considering all types and levels, and (2) the Cubs are not averse to a reclamation situation.”
Kenneth Smith (Just Baseball): Top Landing Spots for Free Agent Shane Bieber. “(The Cubs) need to explore just about every potential avenue for improving their rotation, and this is precisely what could make Bieber one of the more intriguing fits for Chicago.”
Evan Altman (Cubs Insider): Cubs Could Kick Tires on Japanese 3B Teruaki Sato. “Virtually nothing has been said about the Cubs being interested in third baseman Teruaki Sato, who many believe is the third-best position player on the market after Seiya Suzuki and Randy Arozarena.”
Brett Taylor (Bleacher Nation): White Sox Reportedly Signing Dustin May to a Surprisingly Ample Three-Year Deal. “$50+ million is a very healthy bet on a guy who hasn’t actually shown yet that he can be a pitcher of that caliber. There’s a reason the projections were more like $15 to $18 million per year for around two years.”
Matthew Trueblood (North Side Baseball): Ranking Cubs’ 7 Best Options for Right-Handed First Base and DH Help. “With much bigger fish to fry, the Cubs can’t allocate a large share of their offseason resources to adding a platoon partners for Michael Busch and a part-time designated hitter. They do have to find such a player, though, so let’s run down some options.”
Brett Taylor (Bleacher Nation): Who Wants to See Cade Horton Throwing a Baseball? “That was a sad, sad day in April, not realizing that we were about to be Horton-less for a very long time. Baseball is frequently surprising and uncharitable.”
Matthew Trueblood (North Side Baseball): Cubs Add Jaxon Wiggins, Brody McCullough to 40-Man Roster. “However uninspiring his 2026 season was, Jaxon Wiggins remains the top pitching prospect in the Cubs organization. Unsurprisingly, the team added him to the 40-man roster at Tuesday evening’s deadline to do so, protecting him from this year’s Rule 5 Draft.”
Paul Sullivan (Chicago Tribune {$}): Column: A fine time to be a member in good standing of Chicago’s Rat Pack. “Chicago’s very own version of the Rat Pack — Caleb Williams, Pete Crow-Armstrong, Connor Bedard and Matas Buzelis — has a lot in common. The four friends — who added Bulls rookie Caleb Wilson to the club this summer — are all prominent Gen Z athletes trying to navigate the pitfalls of being a rich, young celebrity in a sports-crazed town.
Food For Thought:
Booker T. Jones is an American multi-instrumentalist, songwriter, record producer, and arranger. Best known as the front man of the band Booker T. & the MGs, he has worked with countless award-winning artists of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries and has earned a Grammy Award for Lifetime Achievement. Along with the band, he was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1992. Jones continues to record and tour internationally, both as a solo artist and as head of Booker T.’s Stax Revue.
From midcentury Memphis, where the brutality of segregation was a stark backdrop to the loving, supportive family and community in which he was raised, to the creative hotbed of Beale Street, the Harlem of the South; from his early friendship with figures such as Maurice White (who went on to form Earth, Wind, and Fire) to the complicated dynamics of the racially mixed MGs—Jones not only was a witness to revolutions but also wrote their soundtracks. His musical legacy includes enduring compositions such as “Time Is Tight,” “Hip Hug-Her,” and the oftensampled “Melting Pot” and collaborations with the likes of Otis Redding, Wilson Pickett, and Sam and Dave—and later Neil Young, Bob Dylan, Barbra Streisand, Carlos Santana, and Willie Nelson.
As part of the first house band for Stax Records, he formed the category-defining group Booker T. & the MGs, whose first recording, “Green Onions,” was an international sensation, selling more than one million copies and winning a place among Rolling Stone’s top five hundred songs of all time. Not stopping there, Jones continued to push soul music’s boundaries, refining it to its essence and then injecting it into the nation’s bloodstream.
Please be reminded that Cub Tracks and Bleed Cubbie Blue do not necessarily endorse the content of articles, podcasts, or videos that are linked to in this series.
DENVER, CO - SEPTEMBER 17: TJ Rumfield #7 of the Colorado Rockies prepares for a pitch at first base in the first inning against the San Diego Padres at Coors Field on September 17, 2026 in Denver, Colorado. (Photo by Justin Edmonds/Getty Images) | Getty Images
Good morning, Purple Row!
Here’s what’s going on with the Colorado Rockies and the rest of Major League Baseball.
TJ Rumfield looks back at his rookie season in this piece from Thomas Harding. The Rockies first baseman may not have ended up winning any awards, and he seems determined to change that next year. Considering the solid foundation of a season that Rumfield will be building from, it will not take much improvement to start seeing some national recognition given his placement as a Gold Glove finalist.
The Rockies signed a free agent! Obviously, it’s not a super notable deal, but the team decided to bring back right-handed reliever TJ Shook on a minor-league deal. Joe Rutland provides an overview of Shook and where he fits into the Rockies plans heading into 2027.
The highlight of Rockies baseball for the past couple months was the standout performances by Rockies prospects in the Arizona Fall League. Now that the 2026 AFL season has concluded, four Rockies farmhands have been awarded designations as amongst the best performers in the league. Jared Thomas (No. 8 PuRP), Sean Sullivan (No. 21 PuRP), and Fidel Ulloa were named as honorable mentions for their posistions, and Jack O’Dowd was tabbed as the number one catcher.
The offseason’s first blockbuster trade was reported on Wednesday afternoon! Going to the Seattle Mariners is a three player package headlined by third baseman Maikel Garcia. The Kansas City Royals return for Garcia was three pitchers with Bryce Miller being the most well known among them. It’s a big deal that fits both teams needs, but Ben Clemens argues is more likely to look good for the Mariners.
The Minnesota Twins are reuniting with starting pitcher Sonny Gray on a two-year $55 million deal. This comes just a day after catcher Ryan Jeffers accepted the teams qualifying offer to return to the team on a one year pact. Gray pitched for the Twins for two seasons back in 2022/2023 and obviously enjoyed his time their well enough to make a return to the suddenly high-spending Minnesota team.
The pre-lockout posturing between the owners and players union continues. Commissioner Rob Manfred spoke at length Wednesday about the current state of negotiations (essentially no tangible progress towards a deal that both sides would plausibly agree to) without offering any tangible alternatives to the binary question of a salary cap which the MLBPA has continuously stated it will never approve. There isn’t much new here, just reiterating the same points that have already been discussed for months.
Due to the impending lockout, the Major League portion of the Rule 5 Draft may or may not actually occur this winter. If it does, however, teams will have an interesting assortment of unprotected players to select from. Ryan Finkelstein and Jay Staph took the time to dig through the prospects that would be available in in the event the Rule 5 Draft does occur and highlight ten potentially interesting players for teams to target.
SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA - JULY 26: Casey Schmitt #10 of the San Francisco Giants throws for an out at Oracle Park on July 26, 2026 in San Francisco, California. (Photo by Godofredo Vásquez/San Francisco Giants/Getty Images) | Getty Images
It’s been a funny few days for Casey Schmitt and the San Francisco Giants social media team. On Tuesday, just a few minutes after the deadline had passed for teams to protect prospects from the Rule 5 Draft, the Giants had not yet announced any moves … but posted a video to Twitter that was a montage of Schmitt dingers.
It wasn’t meant to be a trollish move, but it expertly was nonetheless.
What followed was even better: A report that Schmitt was being dangled in trade talks … and a nearly 10-minute video uploaded to YouTube of all his highlights from a spectacular breakout 2026 season.
It’s a fun highlight reel. Use it to amp yourself up for Casey Schmitt, starting left fielder, or Casey Schmitt, starting second baseman, or maybe Casey Schmitt, starting third baseman with Matt Chapman playing for someone else, or, as feels increasingly likely, Casey Schmitt, Forever Giant/former Giant.
SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA - OCTOBER 06: Nick Pivetta #27 of the San Diego Padres pitches in the first inning against the Milwaukee Brewers in game three of the National League Division Series at Petco Park on October 06, 2026 in San Diego, California. (Photo by Orlando Ramirez/Getty Images) | Getty Images
One of the big needs for the 2027 Baltimore Orioles is starting pitching. They need two pitchers to round out their starting rotation, which currently consists of Kyle Bradish, Shane Baz, and Brandon Young. Their starting pitching wasn’t the worst thing about the 2026 team, but the potential loss of Trevor Rogers would be huge.
One possibility to fill a spot is right-handed pitcher Nick Pivetta. Pivetta, who turns 34 years old on Valentine’s Day, is coming off of two seasons with the San Diego Padres, after five seasons with the Boston Red Sox.
Pivetta was disappointing in his time with the Red Sox. He had good strikeout numbers, decent fastball velocity, and good peripheral stats. But he struggled with walks and home runs and never got his ERA out of the 4’s. He became a free agent after the 2024 season with a 4.29 ERA in 131 games with Boston. In five seasons, he gave up 103 home runs, which is 1.5 home runs per nine innings. That’s a lot.
Before the 2025 season, the Padres signed Pivetta to a four-year, $55 million contract. The final two years were options. The Padres declined his 2027 option a couple of weeks ago, once again making him a free agent.
The declination was not based on performance. Pivetta was fantastic with the Padres. In 2025, he made 31 starts with a 2.87 ERA. He cut down his home run total quite a bit and also got his walks under control. He just allowed fewer baserunners, period. His WHIP came in just under 1.
Then came 2026. Pivetta missed most of the season with an injury. He made four starts in March/April and four starts in September. In between, he missed five months with a flexor strain in his right elbow. That’s not great. But his results didn’t suffer after his return. In those four September starts, Pivetta allowed just three earned runs in 18.2 innings (1.45 ERA). He made two starts in the postseason, one each against the Cubs and Brewers. The Padres won both games.
There was some surprise initially when the Padres declined Pivetta’s option, but it was reported to be because the Padres were concerned about his elbow and didn’t want to commit. The reports were also that the Padres may be interested in signing him to a new deal that gives them more protection in the event the injury pops up again.
MLB Trade Rumors predicts he will get a two-year, $26 million contract. But they noted that he may end up settling for a one-year contract due to his age and injury concern.
So why is Pivetta a good option for the Orioles? First, the Orioles need to add multiple starting pitchers for next year and the free-agent pitching class isn’t especially deep. The idea of signing Pivetta to a short-term deal would go hand in hand with the Orioles acquiring another, longer-term pitcher. The Orioles can’t, or won’t, sign multiple starting pitchers to long, expensive contracts. There are just too many other investments that Orioles need to make.
If a pitcher of Pivetta’s caliber can be had for a two-year contract, it’s a risk worth taking. He pitched like a top-half-of-the-rotation pitcher with the Padres and would instantly elevate the Orioles’ rotation. And if he misses time with injury or pitches more like he did with the Red Sox, there will be fewer resources tied up in his contract. That ideally would give the Orioles flexibility to pivot to a new solution if necessary.
On top of his on-field performance, Pivetta has experience pitching for winning teams. It’s debatable how valuable that is, but with the talk about the Orioles and their team chemistry, knowing how to win, etc,. he could serve as an important veteran presence.
It seems most likely that Pivetta will return to the Padres. He found his success there and the Padres are reportedly interested in bringing him back. But nothing is done until it’s done, and it would behoove the Orioles to go after a guy like Pivetta. It would be one check box in the long list of needs the Orioles have this winter.
ST LOUIS, MISSOURI - SEPTEMBER 20: Iván Herrera #48 of the St. Louis Cardinals hits his second home run of the game against the Washington Nationals in the eighth inning at Busch Stadium on September 20, 2026 in St Louis, Missouri. (Photo by Dilip Vishwanat/Getty Images) | Getty Images
I want to take a break from the transactions. Just like the Cardinals, am I right? (Is this thing on?) I want to talk about the current roster. But not the normal way we talk about the current roster. The fun way. Well, ideally it’s fun, the results may not be as fun as I’m imagining right now. I want to look at the current roster and see who they compare most to at this point in their career.
It does mean something, although not a lot. I talk a lot about projections, and one tool that a projection will use is to incorporate at least a little how similar players did in the past. Of course that only goes so far. Just because you look like JD Martinez at 35 does not mean a projection system is going to say your career is going to be over after your age 36 season. But it could at least be interesting to see how a Cardinals career might go based on similar players.
For this I will be using Baseball-Reference’s similarity score. If you haven’t played enough innings or taken enough plate appearances, they won’t have a similarity score section. So apologies to Cade Winquest, you are not eligible for this game. Pretty much anyone who has played a full season will be on this list. Let’s go in alphabetical order.
Justin Bruihl
Most similar at 29: Danny Coulombe
This comp is a mixed bag. Coulombe is undoubtedly a better pitcher than Bruihl, but he didn’t actually become a better pitcher until his 30s, when he was an oft-injured, but effective lefty out of the bullpen – until last year. But Coulombe spent his entire age 29 season in the minors, so at this point in time, this comp is saying he’s not MLB caliber. So good pitcher to be compared to, but not at this particular time in that pitcher’s career.
Best outcome of top 10: Matt Thornton
Thornton’s career started very late, and although Bruihl debuted at a fairly young age, he did establish himself late. Thornton turned into a fantastic reliever, delivering 10.7 fWAR after his age 29 season. As a reliever. Starting at age 31, he had 5 straight 1+ fWAR seasons.
Worst outcome of top 10: Sean Gilmartin
I mean I had a couple options, but the gist is that this guy’s career is essentially over. We’ve seen their best and it’s all downhill from here.
Conclusion
I have to say, I know Baseball-Reference’s similarity score isn’t perfect, but it actually made me more optimistic on Bruihl. It’s like 50/50 on guys who flame out soon after, and then pretty good relievers who stick around forever. Which is a better ratio than I expected! In addition to Thornton, Tim Mayza and Gabe Speier is on this list. First off, represent Gabe. Second, that’s four pretty decent left-handed relievers to be compared to when you throw in Coulombe.
Alec Burleson
Most similar: Nathaniel Lowe
Now that’s a scary one. Trade Burly immediately if you think this is his future. I’m not kidding.
Best outcome of top 10: Eric Karros
I think Brandon Belt might be the better career outcome, but Karros had the better age 28-31 seasons that would be relevant for a possible extension. Karros dropped off hard after age 31 though. Belt remained at least playable, if normally not a great player, for the majority of his career.
Worst outcome of the list: Rip Repulski
Former Cardinal Repulski did not have a good season after his age 27 season. I will say that he may be 4th on the list, because he made an All-Star team at 27, but he did not actually deserve to make the All-Star team. He had 0.8 fWAR and 1.1 bWAR. Bright side is Burly seems a lot better right now, making it less concerning of a comp.
Conclusion: Uh, I mean it’s a list designed to justify trading Burleson quite honestly. Most of them end up falling off very quickly. Josh Naylor is here, and I suppose we’ll see if he bounces back. But that’s kind of part of the problem: even if they remained good, they all spit out a dud season within a few years, most in their age 28 or 29 season!
Hunter Dobbins
Most similar: Cliff Bell
This would be an incredible outcome for Hunter Dobbins. Bell looks like a pretty good pitcher in the Negro Leagues, honestly far better than I think Dobbins could even become. But the low WAR total might be why. They did not play 162 games per season in the Negro Leagues, at least not on the official record.
Best outcome: Chase Anderson
If I knew more context of how good Bell was in comparison to his peers, I might have answered him. But I also wanted a more modern pitcher anyway for a good reference point. Dobbins has a 4 WAR season in his future on the Anderson path.
Worst outcome: Brandon Cumpton
Dobbins would throw in exactly one more game for the rest of his career if he followed Cumpton’s path.
Conclusion: Certainly some good outcomes here. It’s a varied list with two Negro League players, a player from the 1800s, and only four modern players. Ross Stripling would also be a good outcome, Nick Tropeano not so much.
Jose Fermin
Most similar: Greg Litton
On the one hand, Litton has a career year in his age 28 season, which would be a nice outcome for the Cardinals and Fermin. On the other hand, he played in just one more season after that, where he was below replacement level.
Best outcome: Joe Yeager
It was 1904, so the reason could have been tuberculosis or I had to chase an ambulance, tripped and broke my arm, but Yeager did not play at all at age 28 season. He was worth 6.4 bWAR the next three seasons after that, far exceeding anything anybody else did on this list.
Worst outcome: George Decker
I suppose this wouldn’t be the worst outcome for Jose Fermin because Decker played six more seasons in the MLB after his age 27 season. He was just a very bad player though. He was worth -1.1 bWAR in those six seasons in a surprisingly large amount of PAs, although he was also worth -0.8 bWAR prior, so he was never good at any point.
Conclusion
I mean based on this list, best case, Fermin has a fluky good year that he can’t repeat. Well there’s always the guy who played when spiking umps was a regular occurrence.
Ryan Fernandez
Most similar: Rich Croushore
That is not my favorite comparison. He might also be on the worst outcome list. Let’s find out!
Best outcome: Calvin Faucher
The best two outcomes I could find are also to be determined for career, so it might be slightly unfair. Faucher is still pitching and he wins because he has had two good seasons in the bullpen. Grant Anderson has had one good season.
Worst outcome: Take your pick
You want Croushore or Gene Stechschulte, who did not pitch after his age 28 season, a surprisingly common trait of pitchers compared to Ryan Fernandez. Like straight up their MLB career was done. Most barely had a career after even if they did pitch, like Croushore.
Conclusion
Well I know he didn’t have the most encouraging prospects, but I didn’t realize his career was on life support.
Gordon Graceffo
Most similar: Cole Sands
Sands is still pitching, but he didn’t have a particularly good 2025 and he had a bad 2026, the two seasons following his age 26 season. So I would not call this a great outcome.
Best outcome: Kevin Gregg
To be clear, if he mimicked Gregg, Graceffo won’t have a great 2027. But he bounced back the next season and ended up being a closer for about five years.
Worst outcome: Jonathan Hernandez
He is also still pitching in the majors, well maybe, he wasn’t good last year. But he has been below replacement level since his age 27 season. Although to be fair, he hasn’t actually a been a good pitcher since he had Tommy John surgery, which he got when he was 24. So I don’t think this comparison works for Graceffo.
Conclusion
Honestly, really good outcomes here. Nothing mind-blowing, but a few of the bad outcomes I felt weren’t very good comps in the first place because they didn’t have a good age 26 season.
Nolan Gorman
Most similar: Jurickson Profar
What a confusing one. Profar debuted young but took forever to adjust to the MLB. He’s been kind of up-and-down but once he adjusted, he’s been a pretty similar hitter with swings in BABIP. Gorman though is on a downward trajectory and strikes out about double Profar’s K rate.
Best outcome: Howard Johnson
By the way, this is like the opposite of Burleson. I don’t think B-R could quite figure out Gorman to be honest. Most of his comps had a very good age 26 season. I feel like that lowers my belief in these comparisons.
Worst outcome: Pedro Alvarez
Actually it’s probably Christopher Morel, but Alvarez was a lefty third baseman with huge swing and miss with questionable defense, so it felt like a much more apt comparison.
Conclusion
Well, you can tell similarity scores is not trying to project who will be similar in the future, and nowhere is that more true than Gorman’s similar players through age 26, who mostly had great years and would be incredible outcomes for Gorman: Miguel Vargas is here, Oneil Cruz, Ryan McMahon, Isaac Paredes, it’s a bizarrely good list.
Ivan Herrera
Most similar: Ke’Bryan Hayes
You heard it here first folks, Ivan Herrera can play 3B. I mean he’s being compared to Ke’Bryan Hayes, so naturally that means a Gold Glove is in his future.
Best outcome: Eric Soderholm
Also a 3B. This list is mostly 3B. I don’t understand. Good defensive 3B too. Is B-R trying to send a message to the Cardinals?
Worst outcome: Johnny Vergez
Yes, he was a 3B too. There are no catchers on this list. This is the weirdest one so far. Anyway, Vergez had a 3.3 bWAR season at 26, and then below replacement afterwards.
Conclusion
Well B-R has Herrera inputted as a good defensive 3B apparently, because Joe Crede and Tommy Edman are also here. Oh yeah and old nemesis Ty Wigginton is here too. I can’t be encouraged or discouraged, because literally everyone plays 3B on this list, making it confusing.
Kyle Leahy
Most similar: Keegan Thompson
I have a feeling there aren’t going to be many good comps to Leahy, because Thompson is certainly a bad one if you want to look at the future. Thompson wasn’t even starting when he was 29, the Cubs buried him in AAA for the entire year when he was 30, and he pitched 5 bad games for Colorado in 2026. I guess the rest of his career is to be determined.
Best outcome: Shigetoshi Hasegawa
Yeah, there are no starting pitchers in his most similar players, so none of these are all that comparable. But Hasegawa was a rather good reliever for several years, totaling 11.6 bWAR in his 9-year career, albeit 3.1 of it was in his age 29 season.
Worst outcome: Billy Muffett
I was wrong. He was a starter. It did not go well. In 1960 at age 29, he threw 125 innings, making 14 starts out of 23 games pitched. He was worth 3.1 bWAR. The next year, he was worth -1.9 bWAR in 112.2 innings and he threw 4 total innings after that in his career.
Conclusion
I mean you knew Leahy was a bad player for this kind of feature. He has just about zero players with his career path.
Matthew Liberatore
Most similar: Jonathan Sanchez
Oh yeah Liberatore is about to have a career year…. and then immediately break down and be out of baseball within a couple years after that. As long as they trade him, this would be a good outcome for the Cardinals.
Best outcome: Carl Pavano
Pretty easily too quite honestly. Except for the handedness, the comparison fits pretty well, though not perfect. Pavano was a bad pitcher through age 26 except for one random good year when he was 24. He was average at 27, and made an All-Star team at 28…. and then wasn’t actually good for another six years, mostly because he just didn’t pitch much at all.
Worst outcome: Mike Maroth
He is not actually the worst outcome, at least not technically. I mean to be clear, he is definitely a bad outcome. But he would not be my pick if he wasn’t worth -2.4 bWAR in 14 games for the Cardinals.
Conclusion: Reynaldo Lopez is also here, so I’ll just so that it’s about 50/50 whether not he has another good season in him based on the similarity score. But nobody is reliably good after age 26, it’s usually a season or two.
I wasn’t planning on making this a two-parter, but well I’m only halfway through and this thing is long enough already. I can’t promise the second part will be my next post, if the Cardinals make a trade or signing or even if I suddenly think of an idea I have to write, I’ll probably push it back. But if I’m sitting there Sunday night, and the Cardinals do nothing and I don’t get inspiration elsewhere, I’ll do the second part. What I’m saying is I’ll do the second part (he says, tempting fate)
Book corner
I really expected to have Crime and Punishment finished by now, and I am about 40 pages away, and if it wasn’t late already, I’d just power through those 40 pages to write something here. But that would be unwise for my sleep. So I’m going to use this space for something I really wasn’t intending to use it for, since it involves my own writing.
I am attempting to write a book. Know the rough outlines of my plot, I know my hook, and I have my main character relatively well sketched out. But something happens and without getting into any specifics, they hear a sound nobody else can hear from three different locations, all varying in how close they sound. I had the idea that they could create a formula based on their estimation of how close the sound was in each instance, and triangulate the likely location of that sound.
First off, is that even possible? My instinct was yes, so long as you ascribe some numerical value to the sound. And then you would need to know what I imagine is a complicated formula and then using that formula, you get that classic scene in movies where they draw a big circle over an area where it is, but you don’t actually know where within that circle the sound is coming from. So I need my main character to know how to do that. The easiest solution to this is just make the main character have a job where knowing complicated mathematical formulas is required, whether through schooling or for the actual job. My main character will be recently fresh out of graduate school, so if it’s a job that requires a lot of schooling, that will work.
So basically, what kind of profession can I give them to have them believably do something like this? And hey if what I’m describing is basically impossible, what profession would be foolish enough to think this would work, because I do have a workaround if this isn’t possible. Actually now that I’m thinking about it, I kind of like the idea of it not working a little, because it would be kind of funny if they do all this, have an “I got it” moment, and then learn the real location later, and just go “wow I was way off.” So that’s an option too.
Kansas City Royals third base Maikel Garcia (11) runs past third base against the Detroit Tigers during the third inning at Comerica Park in Detroit on Friday, August 22, 2025. | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Co
The big news yesterday was that Maikel Garcia was traded to the Mariners for Bryce Miller.
The Royals and Mariners swung the first blockbuster trade of the offseason Wednesday, completing a six-player deal that sent All-Star third baseman Maikel Garcia to Seattle in exchange for three Major League pitchers, including right-hander Bryce Miller.
Logan Evans and José A. Ferrer are the other pitchers going back to Kansas City in the deal. The Royals are also sending right-hander James McArthur and right-hander L.P. Langevin back to Seattle.
To make room on the 40-man roster, centerfielder Kyle Isbel was designated for assignment.
The Royals’ new hitting group is seeking improvements on offense in 2027… which just got tougher with Garcia being shipped out.
The Royals are looking to take a more complete approach to generating offense next season.
In 2026, Kansas City finished 22nd in the Majors with 690 runs, despite having an offensive core that included Bobby Witt Jr., Jac Caglianone and Carter Jensen. The Royals hit .243 with a .694 OPS with runners in scoring position and have ranked among the bottom 10 teams in runs scored in 10 of the past 11 seasons.
“We’ve had a hard time scoring runs over a lot of years,” general manager J.J. Picollo said at last week’s General Managers Meetings in Las Vegas. “So while we talk about being a good baserunning team, being a good situational team, we haven’t performed to that level.”
In case you missed it Carson Roccaforte and Lucas Braun were added to the 40-man roster.
On Tuesday, they traded for right-hander Angel Bastardo from the Red Sox for Jack Pineda.
Zion Rose made the 2026 All-Arizona Fall League Team.
The No. 6 overall pick in the Draft, Rose was just one of two members of the Draft class of 2026 to play in the Fall League. With 19 games of pro experience under his belt, Rose looked right at home, slashing .322/.494/.508 to be one of nine qualified hitters to finish with an OPS over 1.000, all while stealing 14 bags in 15 tries.
Preston Farr tries to make sense of the Maikel Garcia trade.
Brian Shrum, of Royals Keep makes a case for why the Royals should pursue Luis Robert.
Matthew Swigonski of Kings of Kauffman gives 3 candidates for third base replacements for Maikel Garcia
Mark Feinsand of MLB.com gives some of the most buzzworthy trade candidates around the league.
Rob Manfred can’t imagine owners ratifying a deal without salary cap and floor
When Nolan Ryan signed with Houston they landed more than a pitcher, they got a living legend who rewrote the team’s DNA. The news rippled through the baseball world fast on November 19th, 1979. Nolan Ryan had agreed to a 4-year deal, paying $4.5 million, becoming baseball’s first million-dollar man.
47 years later, family and teammates alike, reflect on that moment with us exclusively at The Crawfish Boxes.
Reid Ryan
“I was at our home in Alvin. Dad was going back and forth between the Yankees and Astros. We all wanted him to stay in Houston. When it happened and was announced, we were all so pumped. I was only 8 years old and remember it vividly.”
Ken Forsch
“I just remember thinking with Nolan’s addition to our staff that we immediately had a chance to become a World Series contender.”
Art Howe
“Nolan was the most sought-after pitcher in the game of baseball. When we acquired him, it felt like we were actually going to win! (laughs) That was such a wonderful feeling, it was hard to even calibrate the excitement that next season in the clubhouse.”
Enos Cabell
“I couldn’t believe that they spent that much money. Previously, we were owned by a credit company; we didn’t really have an owner before, but it happened because of John McMullen. We already had a good team in 1979 so when we got Nolan, I didn’t think anyone was going to beat us. We had six really good starters. If Cesar Cedeno doesn’t break his angle in game three, we go to the World Series that first year with Nolan but things happen.”
325 days after the initial signing, the dream would be realized when Nolan Ryan took the mound at Veterans Stadium in Game Two of the NLCS October 8th, 1980. Ryan would strike out six over 6.1 innings as the Astros evened up their series. Ryan’s sharpest inning of the evening would be the 6th when he struck out Greg Luzinkski and Garry Maddox. In the 7th, Ryan would draw a two out walk, eventually tying the score after Terry Puhl’s double.
That night served as only a springboard for Ryan. He’d win 106 games in Houston, appearing in a pair of All-Star Games, while also tossing a no hitter against the Dodgers which cemented his legacy forever.
ST. PETERSBURG, FL - OCTOBER 26: MLB Commissioner Robert D. Manfred Jr. presents the Roberto Clemente Award prior to Francisco Lindor #12 of the New York Mets prior to Game Three of the 2026 World Series presented by Capital One between the Milwaukee Brewers and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field on Monday, October 26, 2026 in St. Petersburg, Florida. (Photo by Mike Carlson/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images
We’re now just two weeks away from a projected lockout in MLB, and commissioner Rob Manfred added some fuel to that fire with his comments Wednesday at MLB headquarters in New York City.
“I can’t imagine the owners ratifying a deal that does not include a cap and floor,” Manfred said from the league’s owners meetings.
Evan Drelich of The Athletic covers all of Manfred’s comments here, and poses that there are two reasons for Manfred saying what he said – building leverage, and shifting blame.
“Thirty clubs are 100 percent unanimous in support of the proposals that have been made,” Manfred said later during a news conference at MLB headquarters. “I’m not in a position to speculate about what happens in the event that we don’t achieve our overriding objective, which is to get a cap and floor system that addresses the competitive problem that our fans perceive.”
Manfred went on to say that he believes the MLBPA’s proposals undermine the competitive quality of the game, and that the MLBPA has not made any meaningful move towards the owners.
Bruce Meyer, who is the MLBPA’s interim executive director, put out a statement later Wednesday afternoon –
It is clear that the two sides stay very far apart, and that there doesn’t seem to be much movement from either side towards the middle. It could be a very long winter (and spring) ahead.
PITTSBURGH, PENNSYLVANIA - OCTOBER 27: Blake Lizotte #46 of the Pittsburgh Penguins skates with the puck against Alexandre Texier #9 of the St. Louis Blues in the first period during the gameat PPG PAINTS Arena on October 27, 2025 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Justin Berl/Getty Images) | Getty Images
Who:St. Louis Blues (10-9-2, 22 points, 7th place Central Division) @ Pittsburgh Penguins (7-11-2, 16 points, 7th place Metropolitan Division)
When: 7:00 p.m. eastern
How to Watch: Locally televised game on Sportsnet Pittsburgh and STLNHL, streaming for out of market at ESPN+
Pens’ Path Ahead: The schedule heats up starting today. The Pens head out for a quick road trip to play Nashville on Saturday (note the 6:00pm Eastern start) and then head to Dallas for a Sunday game (7pm start) before coming back home to get ready to face Calgary in the traditional Thanksgiving Eve game.
Opponent Track: St. Louis last played on Tuesday, hosting Anaheim and beating them with an 8-6 high-scoring game. Robert Thomas and Logan Mailloux each recorded three points in the victory. Overall the Blues are 3-3-1 in the month of November and before Tuesday scoring goals has been hard to come by lately. STL only scored five total goals in the course of play over four games from Nov 7-16 (not counting the goal tacked on the scoresheet from a shootout deciding goal) before breaking out with the big eight-goal explosion against the Ducks in their previous game.
Season Series: If you like STL/PIT games, good news ahead! The Pens head to St. Louis in two weeks for a game on December 2nd to wrap up the season set.
Hidden Stat: Per Pens PR, the Penguins have six-straight wins against the Blues at PPG Paints Arena, a streak dating back to Dec. 4, 2019. As a trivia note, Pittsburgh only has one longer active home winning streak against an opponent, can you name them? (Answer at the bottom of the preview)..
Aleksanteri Kaskimaki – Pavel Buchnevich – Jonatan Berggren
Dalibor Dvorsky – Pius Suter – Alexey Toropchenko
DEFENSEMEN
Philip Broberg / Logan Mailloux
Justin Barron / Colton Parayko
Cam Fowler / Brandon Carlo
Goalies: Joel Hoffer and Jordan Binnington
Potential scratches: Nathan Walker, Calle Rosen
Injured Reserve: Ross Johnston, Dillon Dube, Tyler Tucker, Torey Krug
Of all the NHL teams, this certainly is one. The Blues have a few nice pieces here and there and have been trying to get younger, which certainly is in effect for the forwards where the average age of the top-12 in the lineup tonight is just over 25.
Mailloux made his season debut on November 10th after missing time with injury, that’s been a big boost for the team (as seen with his three-point game last time out against Anaheim). Even though he’s on the first pair, the Blues can and have been actually playing the veteran Parayko a little bit more, which is probably wise considering Mailloux still only has 79 total games of NHL experience split over four seasons. If he can stay healthy, that progression into an impact player might unfold over the course of this year.
It feels like to me that the Blues main core of wingers is very similar between Snuggerud, Neighbours and Holloway. All are roughly about the same size (a stout 6 foot, 200ish pounds, give or take a little), near the same ages (22, 24, 25) and all are former first round picks. They all have a buzzsaw sort of style and matching complimentary skills, Holloway and Snuggerud even scored a matching 51 points in 2025-26 and both of them have the same 15 point total so far this season. To retrofit an old Jerry Seinfeld bit that comes to mind, it’s like they’re trying to make the whole plane out of that specific type of stocky but skillsy, uptempo young North American modern day power-ish forward. Can’t say I mind that.
The other thought seeing the STL lineup is always one of admiration for pulling off getting Holloway and Broberg for the cost of a second + third round picks. They paid in contracts for the projected upside and were willing to be bold, and that gambit has paid off handsomely, especially since the salary scale has already slid upwards. Always something to be said about an aggressive move made outside the normal lines to attempt to add big talent for a low acquisition cost.
You’re a real one if you know Aleksanteri Kaskimaki. Hand up, I wasn’t familiar with him besides the catchy name. The 22-year old was a third round pick for STL in 2022 and has done well in the AHL (including seven points in six games this season). Overall he’s still getting going in the NHL with 15 career games.
There’s been a changing of the guard in goal, Binnington has been the Blues’ starting goalie since bulling his way to the Stanley Cup as a rookie in 2019. Those days, in St. Louis at least, look to be done. Hofer has been the choice for the main goalie this season (a quick look at the stats clearly shows why) and Binnington is on an expiring contract at season’s end and often in the trade rumors as a potential candidate to be moving on sooner than later.
There hasn’t been a crazy glow-up yet for Mason McTavish (traded for two first round picks over the summer), though he is on pace to set a career-high with 28 goals, so that’s somethin’. He doesn’t look like the type of former high first round pick that’s ever going to pop a huge point total but his size and compete can still make him a valuable player, especially if he’s improving on the goal scoring touch.
Key to the game: Similar teams
As far as shots for and against go, the Penguins and Blues inhibit the same area.
They’re fairly similar in expected goal measures too.
Both teams under-perform results, with decent expectations. The Penguins, for instance are 3rd in the NHL in xGoals for, but 16th in actual goals. The story continues with goal share the Blues go from an 11th expected to 19th actual, Pittsburgh is even worse with a 13th expected down to 24th in results. Both power plays (22 and 24) are meh. The PKs (6 and 12) are a notch higher.
The biggest standout looks to be the porous Pittsburgh defense (23th xGA and 27th in actual results), the worst compartment in a pretty mediocre matchup between STL and the Pens.
And now for the Pens
Projected lines
FORWARDS
Evgeni Malkin – Sidney Crosby – Rickard Rakell
Tommy Novak – Ben Kindel – Egor Chinakhov
Rutger McGroarty – Hendrix Lapierre – Ville Koivunen
Connor Dewar – Blake Lizotte – Nick Robertson
DEFENSEMEN
Spencer Stastney / Erik Karlsson
Sam Girard / Kaedan Korczak
Trevor van Riemsdyk/ Kris Letang
Goalies: Arturs Silovs and Sergei Murashov
Potential Scratches: Declan Carlile, Justin Brazeau, Andrei Kuzmenko
IR: Ryan Graves, Elmer Soderblom, Bryan Rust
Some changes afoot from practice yesterday, the bottom two forward lines shuffled around with Brazeau appearing to be headed for a scratch, Koivunen back in and a swap of spots for McGroarty and Robertson.
The defense appears prime for a change too now that van Riemsdyk was back at practice with Letang. That means tonight could be van Riemsdyk’s first game since his injury back on October 10th. TVR+Letang wasn’t always the smoothest of pairings due to them both being right shots and both being 35+ year old veterans with some mobility issues at times when it comes to trying to race back in open ice, we’ll have to see how this one goes after almost six weeks since they’ve last played together.
McGroarty will presumably be in the lineup for a third straight game, and in a different role from past games where he was the third wheel on the defensive line. This stretch is starting to feel like a bit of an in-progress little audition for McGroarty to show he is ready to make the leap into being worthy of sticking around the NHL lineup, feels like a hugely important game for him to extend that audition for as long as possible.
If the arrow for McGroarty, even tentatively, looks like it’s on the ups, the future of Kuzmenko remains cloudy. GM Kyle Dubas struck a very understanding tone in his press conference yesterday, talking about meeting with Kuzmenko last week and referencing a “human element” of the team wanting to work with Kuzmenko and give him plenty of support. (“I also think we’ve tried to do right on the human level by it. I don’t know that we’ll ever feel like we’re in the wrong for trying to do that, even if it costs us something in the short run as a team or with a specific player. In the long run, just trying to treat someone like that is the way that we want to be here”). That said, Kuzmenko is looking at being a healthy scratch tonight for the fifth time in the last six games and could be on the roster for a while longer as one of the extra forwards. That’s easy to do at this point, less so if/when players like Soderblom and Rust are ready to rejoin the active roster, and assuming, of course, no other forwards get injured in the interim.
Rest vs Rust
The Penguins this season are just 2-4-1 this season in games when they’ve have two or more days off in between games (including one shootout victory). That becomes 1-2-1 when that situation is a home game. Of course, their splits can look poor from any number of different angles given their record and way this season has unfolded but surprisingly enough for a team with some older players in key spots the results have shown that getting longer than normal breaks in the schedule hasn’t resulted in sharp performances when the games pick back up again.
The start of the game could be crucial, the Pens have been outscored by a total of 23-17 in the first periods this year. St. Louis, for their part, has only scored 14 first period goals this season, ranking 29th in the NHL there. (On the other hand, they’ve only conceded 16 first period goals against, too). Pittsburgh is but 1-7-2 in games where they are trailing after the first period. The cliche of getting off to a good start can ring hollow, but it’s also become conventional wisdom due to having some weight behind it. Coming off a long four-day break, after only mustering 17 shots on goal vs Ottawa in the last game, all eyes are going to be on how the Pens look at the start of the game for what likely will be a strong indicator of how the rest of the night is going to go.
Will the rest (most the veterans had two full days off the ice this week) plus refining tactics in practice help make them sharp? Or will the timing look disjointed? So far it’s been mostly the latter, that always interesting theory on rest versus rust will get another chapter added tonight.
Hockey Fights Cancer night
When it comes to fighting cancer, we are all on the same team 💜#HockeyFightsCancer Night is tomorrow night, Nov. 19. Learn more👇