37 Years Ago Today
This is one of my all-time favorite games, played in 1989. But then any game where we beat the Red Sox is a favorite game.
The Blue Jays defeated the Red Sox 13-11 in 12 innings.
After six innings, the Red Sox led 10-0.
Alex Sanchez started for the Jays. He was the team’s first-round draft pick in 1987 and quickly advanced through the minors—perhaps too quickly. Player development has evolved significantly since then. In 1988, his first full season of professional baseball, Sanchez threw 207 innings—a workload unheard of by today’s standards. Minor league seasons are shorter now, and no pitcher, especially a first-year pro, would ever throw 200 innings (very few throw 200 innings in the majors these days, only three in 2025). For comparison, in 2019, Yennsy Diaz led the Fisher Cats with 144 innings, which was likely the most by any Jays minor leaguer that year.
Sanchez made three starts and one relief appearance in 1989, his only season in the majors. This game marked his final start; he recorded just one out while allowing three hits, a home run, three walks, and five earned runs.
Xavier Hernandez entered to stop the bleeding in the first inning. He surrendered a run in each of the next three innings and two in the sixth, but managed to eat up innings, pitching 6.2 frames while allowing eight hits, five runs (two earned), three walks, and striking out two.
Hernandez was also a rookie that year, appearing in seven games for the Jays. After the season, he was claimed by the Astros in the Rule 5 draft. He went on to enjoy a 10-year MLB career, pitching in 463 games, mostly as a reliever.
The comeback began in the seventh. The Jays scored two runs after Red Sox starter Mike Smithson walked Lloyd Moseby and Ernie Whitt to start the inning. Bob Stanley entered in relief and walked Rance Mulliniks to load the bases. Nelson Liriano grounded into a double play, scoring one, and Junior Felix followed with a ground-rule double to bring in another. It still felt like a missed opportunity.
In the eighth, the Jays put up four more runs. With one out, George Bell, Fred McGriff, and Moseby hit consecutive singles to score two. After another out, Mulliniks doubled in another run, and Liriano singled, making it 10-6.
In the ninth, Toronto scored five runs. Tony Fernandez singled, Kelly Gruber walked, and Bell doubled, making it 10-7. After Moseby walked to load the bases, Whitt delivered a grand slam, putting the Jays ahead 11-10.
Unfortunately, Tom Henke surrendered a run in the bottom of the ninth, sending the game to extra innings.
Dennis Lamp pitched scoreless tenth and eleventh innings for the Red Sox, but Duane Ward matched him for the Jays.
In the 12th inning, Tom Lawless led off with a single, Liriano bunted him to second, and Felix followed with a home run. 13-11, Jays.
Ward pitched a perfect bottom of the 12th to secure the win.
Jays of the Day: Whitt (.612 WPA, mainly for the grand slam); Ward (.375, for three innings of no-hit relief); Felix (.298, 3-for-7, including the game-winning homer); and David Wells (.113, who recorded the final out of the ninth).
Other Award: Henke (-.405, for the blown save); Sanchez (-.358); and McGriff (-.144, 1-for-6 on the day, with three errors—two on a single play after mishandling a ground ball and then making an errant throw in an attempt to recover).
The Jays improved to 23-31, second-last in the AL East, while the Red Sox dropped to 24-27, third in the division. Toronto finished strong and claimed first place by season’s end, but ultimately lost to the A’s in the ALCS.