If you watched the end of Tuesday night’s 2-1 Phillies loss to the Dodgers at Citizens Bank Park, you likely woke up this morning asking the same question you were left with in the aftermath of J.T. Realmuto’s baserunning blunder.
“What on earth was he thinking?”
In case you missed Tuesday night’s gaffe, the Phils were mounting a 9th inning comeback. Justin Crawford was on third base and Realmuto was on second. There was one out in the inning with Brandon Marsh at the plate.
Marsh cued a ball down the third base line which was fielded by Max Muncy. Crawford hesitatingly took off for home, which manager Don Mattingly said was due to Crawford running on contact. However, one should not absolve Crawford of blame because, following the game, he admitted he was told to run on contact if the ball was hit to anywhere except third base. Crawford should have retreated to the bag, leaving runners and second and third with two outs. Once he took off for home, it was inevitable he would be tagged out.
His only choice was to try and stay in a rundown long enough for Realmuto to take his place at third base and for Marsh to try and get to second. That would have given the Phillies 2nd and 3rd with two outs.
Again, not ideal, but still breathing.
Then, with Realmuto standing on third, he suddenly bolts for second base, moving backwards 90 feet. As Crawford was being chased back to third, Realmuto should have just stood his ground and waited for Crawford to occupy the same base as him, rendering Crawford out.
Watching Marsh, it appeared he ran through the bag at first and didn’t make an immediate move to second. In all likelihood, the Phils were looking at first and third with two out.
That is, until Realmuto was tagged out at second.
After the game, the Phils’ veteran catcher admitted he goofed (quotes via MLB.com).
“Just a bad baserunning play, really,” Realmuto said. “We were going on seeing it through there, and once Craw gets in the rundown and I’m on third base, there’s no reason for me to go back to second. Just a lack of judgment. You can’t make two outs on that play. I’ve just to stay in scoring position.
“Just a lapse in judgment. I thought Crawford could get out of the rundown for some reason. The chances of that are so small, you just can’t take that chance there of making two outs on one play.”
In Realmuto’s mind, he thought Crawford could wriggle himself out of his pickle and that, by running back to second, he was giving the rookie outfielder a chance to do that.
This is J.T.’s 13th year in the Majors. He has played in 1,446 Major League Baseball games and hundreds of other games through little league, high school and the minors. He has likely never, in his entire baseball career, seen a player get out of a rundown situation like the one Crawford was in, let alone in the Majors.
And yet, he ran.
Without making excuses for Realmuto, what happened to him has happened to all of us in various scenarios during our lives.
Sometimes, our brains just break.
Most of the time, it’s only for a moment or two. We do something so dumb, so stupid, so against our character, that it’s impossible to explain why we did it after the fact. Our logic, sped up in the moment to a level that triggers a kind of temporary insanity, compels us to do something we know to be dumb, harmful or chaotic.
If you were to put Realmuto in that same spot another 100 times, he likely remains cemented to the third base bag every single time.
And according to the advanced metrics, the Phillies’ baserunning has improved this year. Fangraphs has the Phils with the 4th-most baserunning runs above average this season.
Tuesday night’s blunder calls back to last year’s 9th inning meltdown against the Dodgers in Game 2 of the NLDS where, after Nick Castellanos two-run double drew the Phils to within 4-3, putting a runner on second with nobody out.
The decision for Stott to bunt and get Castellanos tagged out at third for the first out of the inning sabotaged a late Phils’ rally in Game 2.
Tuesday night’s ridiculousness did not have the same stakes, but it did harken back to last October’s brain fart. In this case, Realmuto’s brain simply ran away from him, and a potential Phillies victory along with it.
One the Dodgers were only too happy to accept.