Jose Caballero made himself the answer to a trivia question on Opening Day in what would be a 7-0 Yankees win.
The Yanks shortstop entered the history books by simply tapping his head after taking a first-pitch strike in his second at-bat of the season.
With New York up 5-0 after a five-run second, the history-making moment occurred with the first pitch of the top of the fourth inning when San Francisco Giants starter Logan Webb tossed a91 mph sinker that was up-and-in and called a strike by home plate umpire Bill Miller.
"I wanted to go for it," Caballero said after the game.
The umpire got the call right as the pitch clipped the inside corner and the top of the strike zone, as confirmed by the quick review.
"It was really close. I didn't have an issue with that one," manager Aaron Boone said of the challenge after the game.
Caballero said he was a "little bit" surprised he didn't get the overturn. "I thought it was a little higher than what it showed, but at least it was close."
Despite the strike call on the challenge being upheld, Miller was far from perfect on the night. The very next pitch was a sinker that was well off the inside corner and called a strike. Caballero clearly looked perturbed, but didn't challenge. Had he lost it – he wouldn't have – that would have been it for the Yankees for the rest of the game.
Caballero, who knocked in the first run of the season with an RBI double to left, would ground out on the next pitch.
On the ABS system, Caballero said he thinks it will be good as it will "keep everyone accountable."
"It gives us a chance to really see if we are good with the zone or not," he said after his 1-for-4 day.
Of course, it was "cool" to make baseball history, but Caballero said he just wishes "it was the other way around."
Jose Caballero loses the first ABS challenge in Yankees and MLB history
— Talkin' Yanks (@TalkinYanks) March 26, 2026
Yankees have one incorrect challenge remaining pic.twitter.com/kSUFIqRSgD
The shortstop was the first to take the leap, but there were a few chances earlier in the game.
To name a few, on the second batter of the game,
In the second inning, Judge took a 1-0 fastball above the zone for a called strike that shouldn't have been. He later struck out as he started the day going down on strikes in his first four times up.
Giants third baseman Matt Chapman took a first-pitch cutter above the zone in the top of the first inning from Max Fried that was above the zone. Chpman would ground into a fielder's choice to short, with the Yanks getting an out at second base.
San Francisco catcher Patrick Bailey missed the biggest chance in the home half of the second with one out and a runner on first base when he was called out on strikes by Miller on a Fried fastball that was well off the inside corner.