Dodgers pitchers and catchers have their first official workout at Camelback Ranch one week from today, so let’s look at the primary backstops for Los Angeles, after previous looks at the infieldersand outfielders.
40-man roster catchers
- Will Smith
- Dalton Rushing
Things to watch
Under the radar? Will Smith hit the championship-winning home run in the 11th inning of Game 7 in Toronto, just the second go-ahead home run in the ninth inning or later in Game 7 of the World Series (along with Bill Mazeroski in 1960). But it feels like that homer hasn’t been talked about nearly as much as the game-tying home run by Miguel Rojas in the ninth inning of Game 7. There’s room for both, to be clear, but maybe this was more about Rojas exceeding expectations while it’s now the norm that Smith is considered one of the best players in the sport. Smith was an All-Star for a third straight season in 2025 and made his second All-MLB second team, and led all National League catchers in OPS (.901), on-base percentage (.404), batting average (.296), wRC+ (153), and fWAR (4.1).
Another way to frame it: While Smith is one of the best offensive catchers in the sport, he’s devolved defensively, going from average to above in his early years to one of the worst in baseball in framing the last two seasons. By catcher framing runs, Smith in 2024 was 18 runs below average, 55th among 55 qualified catchers; in 2025 Smith was 10 runs below average in framing, 56th among 57 catchers. That’s been part of the cost in Smith improving in throwing out runners. Factoring that all in, by catcher defense added at Baseball Prospectus, Smith was 7.8 runs below average in 2025, 32nd among 35 catchers, after 7 runs below aveage in 2024, 31st among 35 catchers.
Second time the charm? The Dodgers last May cut the cord with 11-year vet Austin Barnes, which opened up a chance for Dalton Rushing to make his major league debut. Rushing played intermittently as the backup catcher over the final four-plus months and struggled mightily at the plate, hitting just .204/.258/.324 with a 37.4-percent strikeout rate. There’s plenty of room for improvement for the 25-year-old whose bat has been his calling card ever since he was drafted.
Testing the depth: Smith has been one the most durable catchers in the sport, since 2021 second in the majors in games, starts, and defensive innings behind the plate, trailing only JT Realmuto. Smith’s 97 starts last season were his lowest in five years, mostly because he took a foul ball that broke a bone in his right hand which sidelined him for about a month in September and into October, not starting again until Game 3 of the NLDS. Rushing fouled a ball off his shin on the same cursed road trip in September and landed on the injured list as well, giving the Dodgers a rare test of their catching depth. From 2020-24, only 10 times did a catcher other than Smith or Barnes start behind the plate. But in 2025, the Dodgers needed 18 starts from catchers other than Smith, Barnes, or Rushing, 17 of which came from Ben Rortvedt. As of now, Smith and Rushing are the only two catchers on the Dodgers’ 40-man roster.
Another depth question: If Smith is hurt for any extended amount of time, ideally that would be a chance for Rushing to seize the reins behind the plate. The only problem is he’s never really had that kind of workload as a pro. The night be fouled a ball off his shin on September 5 in Baltimore was the first time since getting drafted in 2022 that Rushing caught in a game three days in a row. He started 45 games behind the plate in both 2023 and 2024 before starting 55 games at catcher last year between the majors and minors. In the minors, Rushing stayed in the lineup by playing games at first base, left field, and designated hitter. It’s unclear if those chances at other positions will arise with the Dodgers.