
It’s becoming clear again that Cubs left-hander Shōta Imanaga is not going to be able to be trusted with a start in a postseason game.
Imanaga has had his moments on the North Side, to be sure, but Sunday night’s game was not one of them, unless you are a Reds player or fan. Imanaga served up three home runs to the Reds and that turned out to be enough for a 7-5 Cincinnati win.
The game began 25 minutes late due to a late-afternoon round of rain, and in fact, it rained lightly for the first two innings. Raise your hand if you’ve had enough of the rain in Chicago this summer — one of the rainiest I can remember.
The Cubs, though, had the first homer of the game — yet another leadoff blast from Pete Crow-Armstrong [VIDEO].
That ball was crushed! [VIDEO]
Leadoff homer fact from BCB’s JohnW53:
PCA’s homer was the ninth of his career in the first inning with nobody on and nobody out, tying him with Brian McRae for the fifth most by a Cub.
Alfonso Soriano hit 22; Rick Monday, 17; Dexter Fowler, 12; and Ian Happ, 11.
All of PCA’s have come this season, six of them since Aug. 5.
Soriano hit 12 in 2007; Monday, eight in 1976; and Fowler, seven in 2016.
Soriano’s 12 in 2007 is the franchise record for a single season. The MLB record for such things is 15, set by Kyle Schwarber in 2024. Who knows?
The Cubs put another run on the board in the second. Ian Happ led off with a single and advanced to second on a single by Nico Hoerner. Hoerner was forced at second by Pedro Ramirez, with Happ taking third.
This single by Michael Conforto scored Happ [VIDEO].
Imanaga had breezed through the first three innings, but got himself in trouble with a one-out walk in the fourth. One out later, Matt McLain singled and Hector Rodriguez smashed a three-run homer to give the Reds the lead.
The Cubs tied the game up in the bottom of that inning. Happ led off with a walk and went to second on Hoerner’s second hit of the game.
Happ was advancing to third on Ramirez’s deep fly to right, but Rodriguez’s throw got away and Happ scored, making it 3-3.
That lead lasted about five minutes, because Dane Myers led off the fifth with a homer. An infield hit and an out later, Tyler Stephenson smacked a two-run homer to make it 6-3 Reds.
The fifth inning was it for Imanaga; he allowed eight hits and six runs, and the three homers gave him 33 allowed for the season, a career high. He also now leads MLB in home runs allowed. This was after Craig Counsell flipped Imanaga and Kevin Gausman in the rotation to give Shōta an extra rest day. To me, it’s an open question as to what to do with Imanaga the rest of the way, never mind the postseason.
Facts about the three homers surrendered by Imanaga from John:
This was the 24th game of the season in which the Cubs surrendered at least three home runs. They had 26 such games a year ago, 19 in 2024, 21 in 2023, 25 in 2022 and 31 in 2021.
Those 31 are the team record, ahead of 29 in 2000 and 28 in 1999.
The 24 this year are the third most by any team, behind the Athletics’ 30 (including one Sunday) and the Nationals’ 27.
Another not-so-fun fact about all the Imanaga homers:
So the Cubs are down three heading to the sixth. They had the first two runners on in that inning thanks to another Reds error with Alex Bregman batting, and a single by Happ. But the next three Cubs went down in order.
Trent Thornton threw the seventh and retired the first two Reds easily before presumptive NL Rookie of the Year Sal Stewart homered, the Reds’ fourth of the game, to make it 7-3. More dismaying home runs allowed facts from John:
The Cubs now are tied with the Athletics for the most home runs allowed, 208. Both have played 137 games.
They are on a pace to give up 246, which would be the 13th most in any season, two behind the 2017 Reds and 2019 Yankees, tied for 10th.The record is 305 by the 2019 Orioles, then 270 by the Rockies, 267 by the Angels and 260 by the Mariners, all also in 2019.
The Cubs’ high is 235, in 2021, followed by 231, in 2000, and 221, in 1999.
As you can see, the three seasons in which the Cubs allowed the most home runs were all very bad years. Only the very good Cubs offense — leading MLB in runs with 725, on pace for 857 — has prevented this year from being like that.
The Cubs did attempt to mount a comeback. Bregman led off the eighth with a double. He advanced to third on a ground out and scored on this sac fly by Hoerner [VIDEO].
Aaron Civale and Jacob Webb had kept the game (relatively) close with scoreless innings in the eighth and ninth. The first two Cubs went down quickly in the ninth.
And then PCA delivered one last thrill [VIDEO].
The five home runs in consecutive games tied the MLB record for such things. You can see all the players who have done that here. As for Cubs doing that, from John:
Pete Crow-Armstrong is just the fifth Cub to hit a total of five home runs in back-to-back games.
Cap Anson did it Aug. 5-6, 1884 (two and three); Billy Williams, Sept. 8 and 10, 1968 (two and three); Dave Kingman, July 27-28, 1979 (two and three); and Dansby Swanson, June 30-July 1 this year (three and two).
Fun, though too little too late, and Seiya Suzuki flied out to end the game.
PCA now has 38 home runs. It’s worth noting that puts him very close to a pair of Cubs milestones. First, it has been 21 years since any Cub has had a 40-homer season — Derrek Lee hit 46 in 2005. Also, only one Cubs left-handed hitter has ever had a 40-homer season — Billy Williams, who hit 42 in 1970. That’s how special this season is for the Cubs center fielder, whose WAR figures now sit at 8.5 (baseball-reference) and 9.3 (Fangraphs).
Also, he’s also a strong candidate for NL Player of the Week after batting .321/.345/.893 (9-for-28) with a double, the five home runs, eight RBI and six runs scored — and also NL Player of the Month, having batted .283/.372/.726 (32-for-113) in August with six doubles, a triple, 14 home runs, 28 RBI and 28 runs scored, with one game remaining this month.
You’re watching a special season from PCA, one of the greatest years in Cubs franchise history. Savor every moment. One more PCA fun fact:
Here are Craig Counsell’s postgame remarks [VIDEO].
As for the Cubs? They should not be losing series at home to the Cincinnati Reds, but here we are. They are now tied with the Phillies for the top wild card spot, for which, thankfully, they have the tiebreaker. It will certainly be an interesting stretch run, with 25 games remaining.
And it won’t get any easier beginning tonight at Wrigley Field, when the division-leading Milwaukee Brewers come to town to start a four-game series. At eight games behind, the Cubs can probably forget about winning the NL Central and just focus on winning games to keep that top wild card spot. For Monday’s series opener vs. Milwaukee, it’ll be Clay Holmes against Kyle Harrison. Game time is 6:40 p.m. CT and TV coverage will be via Marquee Sports Network.












