Ryan Tayman was born San Luis Obispo, California, the son of Lauri Tayman, who played softball at Wilfrid Laurier University during her time there. Growing up in Grover Beach, he attended the nearby Arroyo Grande High School and was a three-year letterman there, mainly playing first base, third base, and catching. In his senior year, he hit .453/.570/.800 in 28 games, logging 8 doubles and 6 home runs while drawing 19 walks and striking out 9 times. He did not stand out much in the baseball hotbed that is California and generated very little buzz among scouts and evaluators. When the 2023 MLB Draft came, his name was not called and he put his professional dreams on hold to attend the University of California, Berkeley, the only D1 team that had tendered a collegiate offered to him.
In his first year with the Golden Bears, Tayman appeared in 21 games, logging 67 at-bats, and hit .254/.306/.552 with 2 doubles, 6 home runs, and 4 walks to 28 strikeouts. Following the conclusion of the season, he got into a few more games with the Santa Barbara Foresters of the California Collegiate League and performed about the same in roughly the same amount of games.
He returned to Berkeley in 2025 for his sophomore season and did a bit better in his second spring in the program. Now a SEC team rather than a PAC-12 team, Tayman appeared in 39 games for the Golden Bears and hit .274/.345/.476 with 8 doubles, 1 triple, 5 home runs, and 9 walks to 35 strikeouts. Once again, he supplemented his playing time by playing on a summer collegiate team, this time the Willmar Stingers in the Northwoods League, where he was an all-star, hitting .324/.402/.533 in 28 games with 7 doubles, 5 home runs, and 14 walks to 21 strikeouts.
Rather than return to Berkeley for a third season, Tayman opted to enter the NCAA transfer portal. He received numerous offers from high profile teams, but the offer from California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo meant more to him than most. Having grown up in San Luis Obispo, spent many summer afternoons and weekends at Baggett Stadium, and attended baseball clinics run by head coach Larry Lee, attending the school that was his #1 out of high school just made sense; the fact that the Mustangs needed a catcher because incumbent backstop Jack Collins had been drafted by the Texas Rangers and was going to sign was just icing on the cake.
Everything clicked for the backstop and his 2026 junior season was truly magical. Appearing in 63 games for his hometown team, with the stands often packed with friends and family, Tayman hit .357/.447/.672 with 19 doubles, 1 triple, 18 home runs, and 31 walks to 50 strikeouts, getting named to the 2026 Buster Posey Award Midseason Watchlist featuring the top 50 NCAA Division 1 catchers in the country.
At the plate, the 6’2”, 225-pound slugger stands slightly crouched and slightly open, holding his hands low at the letters. While with the Bears and earlier in the year with the Mustangs, he held his hands high and wrapped his bat behind his head at 1:30. The changes to his set-up at the plate have helped him unlock a new level of power he had not shown at Berkley. He is shorter and more direct to the ball, and while lowering hands often sacrifices power in exchange for bat control, Tayman has increased the angle of his swing to not lose power. Indeed, in 2026, the backstop had a 17.5% strikeout rate, down nearly 10% as compared to his prior two years, and a 10.8% walk rate, up roughly 5% as compared to the prior two years. While not purely a fastball hitter, he is considerably better against fastballs than he is other secondary stuff, either fishing at pitches outside of the zone or unable to make solid contact and barrel them thanks to his swing plane. Despite that, the changes have certainly been more beneficial than not, as they allowed him to maximize balls hit in the air, especially to his pull side, with his flyball rate jumping over 10% from 42.6% in 2024 and 2025 to 53.1% in 2026, logging a 17.6% HR/FB rate on the year.
Behind the plate, Tayman has had less success. Most scouts and evaluators don’t feel that he will be forced to move off of the position anytime soon, as he is mobile, a good receiver, blocks the ball well, and is adroit at managing pitchers and their strengths and weaknesses, but his arm is below-average for a catcher, lacking arm strength and accuracy; as such, runners attempted to steal on him often, and Tayman managed only a 22% success rate, allowing 60 of 77 runners to successfully steal off of him.