
It’s been a little more than 12 hours since the Guardians walked off the White Sox in yet another heartbreaking loss, but despite having their backs against the wall in the AL Central race, they still control their destiny from here on out.
The Good Guys hold the tiebreaker over Cleveland after Monday’s win, but walking away with a series victory would really help keep the South Side train on the tracks in the stretch run. Lefthander Anthony Kay is on the mound for the White Sox, making his 29th start (31st appearance) of the season in what is likely the most important game he will start in 2026.
Prior to the South Siders dropping today’s lineup, the White Sox announced a few roster moves to round out the 40-man roster after José Urquidy was designated for assignment yesterday. Righthander Drew Thorpe has officially been cleared from the 60-day IL but was optioned to Triple-A Charlotte, once again not getting the call back up to the big leagues. It’s possible the Sox would rather Thorpe fully work through his rehab and be fully ready for next season, which is likely why Noah Schultz a call up yesterday instead.
On top of that, outfielder Tommy Pham was suddenly reactivated from the 10-day IL, and will shockingly get the start as a DH while batting … cleanup. No, I am unfortunately not making this up. With this move, Edgar Quero was optioned back down to Charlotte, leaving the South Siders with a standard amount of catchers (two) on the roster, with Kyle Teel and Jake Rogers.
The legend has it that Pham ran into GM Chris Getz on the elevator last night and said he was “ready” … and now is batting cleanup in today’s crucial intradivisional game. Those who have been mostly riding the bench perhaps have done themselves a disservice if they’ve been taking the stairs lately! One elevator conversation was apparently all it took — and if we know anything, Tommy approached Getz with enormous clarity and decorum —and now Pham is batting in the 4-hole despite only taking ONE major league at-bat in the last several months.

Simply because I, and many others, are complaining about Pham being in the lineup for no reason at all for a crucial game, he’s surely going to go 3-for-4 with a homer. And if so, bravo. But let it be known that the process is bogus from the start.
On the bright side, Kay has been excellent in three starts against Cleveland, and owns a 1.69 ERA across 16 innings. The Guardians own just a .182 batting average against the lefty, who holds an 89.7% left-on-base percentage (LOB%), so he’s been efficient at stranding the few Clevelanders who even make it on base. Kay owns a 4.53 ERA this season, but has struggled a bit in his last few starts, reaching a 6.17 ERA across his last 35 frames with 24 earned runs at a 1.40 WHIP. His two September starts have been a bit rough, and in his two starts so far in September (8 1/3 IP), the lefty has accumulated an 8.64 ERA. Kay has been known to lock in and work out of jams this season, however, so with his success over Cleveland so far I am feeling positive about him today.
The same can’t be said (for me) about the batting order. The top looks solid, knowing that Chase Meidroth, Randal Grichuk, and Miguel Vargas have been seeing the ball really well lately, and the three tagged five RBIs in Tuesday’s game. I’ve yapped enough about how dumb it is that Pham is hitting cleanup, so I am just going to bypass that. Whatever.
Munetaka Murakami is getting a much-needed break after striking out four times in yesterday’s game, and three more times Monday. With that, Vargas will take over at first today while Colson Montgomery slots in at third, batting seventh, and Luisangel Acuña will play in back-to-back games at shortstop. Brenton Doyle is also back int he lineup, but batting sixth this time around, which is probably fine considering he actually made contact with the ball yesterday. The South Siders desperately need an offensive breakout game, and only time will tell if this lineup can beat lefthander Parker Messick.
Chicago White Sox Lineup
Similar to Kay, Messick has been excellent against the South Siders, just as he has been the entire season. In 29 starts (172 1/3 innings), Messick owns a 2.51 ERA, and has struck out 178 batters, which ranks 16th across MLB. In three starts against the White Sox, the lefty owns a 2.29 ERA and has surrendered just five runs against them, allowing just a .169 batting average. In 12 hits, the South Siders have mashed three bombs and struck out 21 times, essentially living and dying by the long ball — as they have for a good chunk of the season. I’d take a few bombs, today, however.
The Guardians are rolling with a near-identical lineup as yesterday, and the Good Guys need to just take it one at-bat at a time and maintain clean defense. Despite the left-handed hitters struggling a bit against left-handed pitching, that essentially gets thrown out the window when Cleveland plays the Sox. Travis Bazzana and Steven Kwan both own two of the top-four batting averages against White Sox lefties, so it’s best not to assume that because their splits say so, they might not hit well today.
Cleveland Guardians Lineup
First pitch will take place at 12:10 p.m. CT, but will be airing on ESPN this time around. Nothing like a good ole’ national TV broadcast with Tommy Pham batting cleanup! You can also tune into the radio broadcast, still at ESPN Chicago AM 1000. Hopefully when we’re back together later, I’m writing up a less sad article than I did last night. Time for a series W against the Guardians.
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
- Fewer ads
- Create community posts
- Comment on articles, community posts
- Rec comments, community posts
- New, improved notifications system!
















