If anything can pierce through the droning noise of JJ Wetherholt and Sal Stewart's names as they're muttered over and over as the supposed leaders in the National Rookie of the Year race, perhaps it is the sound of Mets right fielder Carson Benge's throws to home plate made on Monday night at Citi Field as they whizzed through the air.
In the first inning against the Padres, Benge came up firing from right field twice. On both occasions, he nailed a San Diego runner trying to score. His second outfield assist, which was clocked at 103.9 mph, capped the frame and sent the crowd of just over 27,000 into a frenzy.
The reaction from Gary Cohen up in SNY's TV booth was a mix of excitement and bewilderment: "Are you kidding me? Stop running on him!"
As a former pitcher, Benge's arm in the outfield is a serious weapon.
His arm value is in the 95th percentile, with his arm strength in the 99th percentile, via Baseball Savant. And it's Benge's arm that has been grabbing most of the headlines lately.
But he's also been doing serious damage at the plate, hitting .304/.368/.461 (.829 OPS) in 212 plate appearances over the last two months while raising his OPS for the season to .750 and his OPS+ to 109.
So why is Benge viewed as being a distant third in the Rookie of the Year race?
The odds via BetMGM look like this:
JJ Wetherholt: -160
Sal Stewart: +140
Carson Benge: +1400
The betting market and narrative don't align with what's actually happening on the field, with Benge having a higher OPS+ than Wetherholt (109 to 107) and closing in on Stewart (119 OPS+), who doesn't provide nearly as much value defensively as Benge and Wetherholt.

When it comes to Wetherholt, it seems like he was simply anointed the winner after a hot start with the Cardinals that resulted in having an .856 OPS at the end of April.
But since May 1, Wetherholt is hitting just .239/.338/.340 (.678 OPS) in 399 plate appearances.
What makes Wetherholt a unique candidate for ROY is that his second base defense has been spectacular, with him in the 100th percentile and worth 22 OAA, via Baseball Savant -- albeit at a position that is not valued very highly.
As far as Stewart, his power is his best attribute, and he's already smacked 26 homers in 125 games for the Reds. But like Wetherholt, Stewart's offense has taken a step back since a hot start that had his OPS sitting at .943 entering May.
Since then, Stewart is slashing .251/.320/.442. That's still strong production, especially for a rookie catcher. But like Wetherholt, Stewart's hot start built the Rookie of the Year narrative for him.
Defensively, Stewart has been a tick above average when it comes to OAA (+1), but his arm strength (20th percentile) ranks near the bottom of the league.
Benge's season -- at least offensively -- has been the opposite of Wetherholt and Stewart, with him starting incredibly slowly before coming on strong.
After his first three weeks in the majors, Benge was struggling badly, with a triple slash of .136/.219/.197. And he looked a bit overmatched. But the Mets chose to let him work through it instead of sending him to the minors, and the results have spoken for themselves.

Since April 23, Benge is hitting .296/.355/.452 (.807 OPS) with 13 homers, 15 doubles, 46 RBI, and 57 runs scored. So while he's taken it up another notch since June 18 (as mentioned above), Benge has been terrific offensively for roughly four months.
Benge's arm has rated nearly as well as Wetherholt's range/OAA does, but Benge's range/OAA has been just a tick above average (in the 54th percentile), due in part to some misplays earlier this season. That number has improved recently, and better play from Benge in that area down the stretch would make his ROY case even stronger.
Another key metric to watch in the ROY race is wRC+, which measures a hitter's overall offensive value while taking his contributions at the plate and translating them to his impact on runs created for his team.
Here's how things break down in terms of wRC+:
Sal Stewart: 114 Carson Benge: 112 JJ Wetherholt: 107
Given the narrative surrounding the award, it might take a continued surge by Benge and more regression from Wetherholt and Stewart in order for Benge to snag it.
But Benge's name should be firmly in the conversation with the two of them -- not some kind of distant afterthought.









