Every day, Pinstripe Alley offers updates on what the Yankees’ top American League opponents are up to through the Rivalry Roundup. The AL East is well-trodden ground there, but with the season at it’s mathematical halfway point, we’re going to take a peek around MLB as a whole and check in with each of the other five divisions. Who’s surprising? Who’s underwhelming? Who’s simply mediocre at the moment? Read on and find out.
(Note: Records and standings are up to date through games played on Tuesday, June 30th.)
First Place: Atlanta Braves (49-34)
Top Position Player: Matt Olson (2.7 fWAR)
Top Pitcher: Chris Sale (2.8 fWAR)
The first-place Braves were sitting pretty for the first two and a half months, but things took a turn for the worse in June. Sitting at 45-21 entering a series with the White Sox on the 9th, they blew a 4-0 lead that night and lost via walk-off in the 10th, sparking a miserable 4-13 slump to end the month that has shrunk their once gigantic 10.5-game lead to just 2.5 games over the surging Phillies.
The team’s most likely All-Stars on the hitting side are perennial stud Matt Olson at first base and the resurgent Michael Harris II. The latter has been a completely different player since facing the Yankees last July, entering that series as one of the worst regulars in the sport, but has now posted a 127 wRC+ across a full season’s worth of plate appearances since.
We’re not getting an MVP-caliber season from Ronald Acuña Jr., but he’s remained a force at the top of the lineup. You look at all the names on this offense and wonder how they’re statistically below average on the year, but the simple answer for that is just how putrid they were in June. The bottom has completely fallen out on Austin Riley’s bat at third base and even the regulars were going into huge slumps.
On the pitching end, it’s all about Chris Sale. The reigning NL Cy Young winner won’t go back-to-back, but it won’t be for lack of trying. His 2.10 ERA across 90 innings with a 23.6 K-BB% would be good enough to potentially start the All-Star Game in the American League, but goes under the radar with the sheer volume of talented arms in the Senior Circuit. Behind him, Bryce Elder and Grant Holmes have given them average production, Martin Perez has been steady as ever, and Spencer Strider continues to struggle with both health and productivity.
The one saving grace of the team in June was that they continued to have the best back-end relief trio in the sport. Robert Suarez, Dylan Lee, and Raisel Iglesias have combined for a 1.05 ERA across 96 innings. When these guys lead after six, the game is all but over. Having Didier Fuentes, Tyler Kinley, and Reynaldo Lopez as middle relief guys is an unreal strength for the best bullpen in baseball (2.76 ERA, 3.44 FIP, 3.8 fWAR)
Second Place: Philadelphia Phillies (48-38)
Top Position Player: Kyle Schwarber (2.6 fWAR)
Top Pitcher: Cristopher Sanchez (4.2 fWAR)
If I had a nickel for every time the Phillies woke up from an early-season stupor with a midseason managerial change, in which they fired one former Yankee for another former Yankee, to be one of the best teams in baseball, I’d have two nickels.
Which isn’t a lot, but it’s weird that it’s happened twice.
Four years after canning former Yankees’ manager Joe Girardi for his bench coach, who also had that role in New York, they did it again. Rob Thomson faced the same fate that Girardi faced, losing his job to his bench coach, Yankees legend Don Mattingly. Since then, they’ve gone 38-19 and have gained eight games in the standings in five weeks with an 18-9 month.
It’s awfully rare for a team to be successful with its most valuable player via WAR being a primary DH, but when that player is on pace to hit 60 home runs, it sounds a lot more reasonable. Kyle Schwarber is worth every penny of his new contract, and he’s finally been joined by some of his teammates with Bryce Harper (143 OPS+) and Brandon Marsh (131 OPS+). Did you know Marsh has one of the highest BABIP in MLB history? If it works, it works.
They’re still not without major flaws offensively, though. Age might finally be catching up to Trea Turner’s bat (for real this time), while Bryson Stott, Alec Bohm, and JT Realmuto have been black holes offensively. Adolis García is done for the year, Justin Crawford can’t hit a beach ball, and they’re gonna need some reinforcements at the deadline to have a chance to compete in October.
Their pitching, on the other hand, can compete with anyone. Cristopher Sánchez’s unreal scoreless innings streak has defined a potential Cy Young campaign, while usual ace Zack Wheeler has looked great since a scary thoracic outlet syndrome injury. The concern is that, beyond Sanchez, Wheeler, and Jesús Luzardo, who else can step up? Aaron Nola’s now in Year 2 of being one of the worst starters in the majors, and Andrew Painter’s rookie year has been a nightmare.
Jhoan Duran leads the National League with 21 saves, and you’ll never guess who’s setting him up. It’s not the struggling José Alvarado; it’s former Yankee Tim Mayza! Orion Kerkering is having a great year after his miscue in the NLDS last year, but the rest of the bullpen is lagging behind. They’ll be looking for upgrades at the deadline.
Third Place: Miami Marlins (46-40)
Top Position Player: Otto Lopez (3.6 fWAR)
Top Pitcher: Max Meyer (2.3 fWAR)
Whoa, where did this come from? For the second straight year, the Marlins have awoken from an early-season slump to go ballistic in the summer. Once sitting 26-34 at the end of May, they’ve secured just their second 20-win month in franchise history (May 2012, 21) and suddenly find themselves in the thick of the wild card race. However you feel about Peter Bendix and his analytical approach, he’s put a destitute franchise on the path to success with no financial backing.
They’ve done it without 2025 breakout star Kyle Stowers as the focal point, as he’s been limited to decent production across 62 games. Xavier Edwards has been over .300 all season and is emerging as a top shortstop in the game, while Otto Lopez has been a WAR machine, leading MLB in hits with stupendous defense and baserunning. Recent call-up Joe Mack is starting to find his stroke behind the plate, while Liam Hicks has been an All-Star caliber DH for them.
It’s been a real breakout campaign for Max Meyer, who’s having an extremely quiet All-Star campaign with a 9-0 record and a 2.60 ERA. The 27-year-old has taken the mantle of ace from Sandy Alcantara, who’s been better than last year but remains a traditional workhorse with average numbers. Eury Perez has been up and down to complete their Big 3, but they’re looking for someone else to step up with an injury to Janson Junk and the failed Chris Paddack experiment.
The one thing holding them back, though, might be the fact that their closer’s ERA is nearly seven. Pete Fairbanks has been a disaster since coming over from Tampa, and even with four extremely productive set-up options in Michael Petersen, John King, Calvin Faucher, and Lake Bachar, they’ve refused to take him out of the closer’s role. You have to think the leash is being shortened with the team’s sudden playoff aspirations.
Fourth Place: Washington Nationals (44-43)
Top Position Player: James Wood (3.0 fWAR)
Top Pitcher: Cade Cavalli (2.1 fWAR)
Another pleasant surprise, the Nationals are above .500 entering July for the first time in almost a decade. We’ve heard about the baby steps for the last few years of developing a core that can figure things out, but the new regime really seems to be making strides in player development to put this franchise on the right path.
James Wood’s strikeouts continue to be a major issue, but he’s shaken off an early rut to once again be among the NL’s best outfielders. Keibert Ruiz has suddenly found the ability to hit after entering the year with a career 87 OPS+, Curtis Mead is finally living up to his prospect billing in his third stop, and Luis García Jr. had a surprising amount of pop in June. But no player has been more impressive than CJ Abrams, who despite defensive limitations, has been one of the best hitting middle infielders in the game this year.
The rotation starts strong, but drops off fast. Foster Griffin has come out of nowhere to lead the Nats, and Cade Cavalli is undergoing a major breakout of his own, but they’re followed up by the badly struggling Zack Littell, Jake Irvin, and Miles Mikolas. Cavalli, a former first-round pick in 2020, made news for the wrong reasons to close the month due to a spat with Boston’s Willson Contreras.
If anything can hold this Nationals team back from making a return to the postseason, it’s their depressing bullpen. They’re 26th in bullpen ERA at 4.99 and can’t seem to find anyone to effectively pitch in high-leverage situations. They had some impossible chokes this month against San Francisco and Philadelphia, as it seems like everyone but PJ Poulin and Brad Lord just can’t seem to get three outs.
Fifth Place: New York Mets (36-50)
Top Position Player: Juan Soto (2.6 fWAR)
Top Pitcher: Nolan McLean (1.8 fWAR)
What a mess. Injuries have certainly taken a toll on how awful this Mets season has been, but when you’re finding a way to bum out a city that enjoyed an NBA championship this month, that’s bleak. Carlos Mendoza paid for their sloppy, uninspired play with his job late in the month after Dansby Swanson and the Cubs swept them into the Stone Age.
The offense has been horrendous. Francisco Lindor just now returned from his second major injury of 2026, and his supporting cast has been abysmal. The progress Brett Baty showed in 2025 has been erased. Mark Vientos looks so lost compared to his 2024 form. The regressing bat of Marcus Semien didn’t improve at all. Luis Robert Jr. and Jorge Polanco are still on the shelf. Rookies AJ Ewing and Carson Benge can only do so much, as can Bo Bichette’s improved June after his disastrous first two months. The one guy who’s not slumping? The inevitable Juan Soto.
The rotation was never going to be the team’s strength, but they certainly expected a lot more from Nolan McLean (3.78 ERA, 3.58 FIP) and Freddy Peralta (4.53 ERA, 4.17 FIP), who were both expected to be ace-caliber arms this year. Clay Holmes will be out for a while with his broken leg, so while Christian Scott has done admirably since his promotion, Kodai Senga and David Peterson’s struggles are further accentuated. Well, I guess just Senga now, as Peterson got sent off to the Cubbies.
In the bullpen, a lot of Yankees fans have kept one eye on Devin Williams and Luke Weaver after they jumped ship in the offseason. While Williams has experienced the same ups and downs on a much less competitive team, Weaver has fully shaken off the struggles he had last year with 24 consecutive scoreless innings. He’ll be a high-leverage arm sold off at the deadline. Huascar Brazoban and Brooks Raley will also be enticing pieces for contenders who need bullpen help.
Yandy Diaz
Shohei Ohtani
