The Mets created a bit of baseball trivia with this wild baseball riddle in the first two innings of Monday's 2-1 win over the San Diego Padres at Citi Field.
First, the riddle: How can the Padres get five hits, walk twice, add a hit-by-pitch, and go 3-for-4 with runners in scoring position, but score only one run on a sacrifice fly?
The answer is the bit of trivia from a pair of rookies, as right fielder Carson Benge became the first Mets player to record two outfield assists at home plate in the same inning, doing it on back-to-back plays to close the first inning, before left fielder A.J. Ewinggunned down a runner at home to end the second.
Since at least 1920, there had been no other team that recorded three outfield assists at home plate in the first two innings of a big league game.
Tack on Nolan McLean getting a 1-2 putout in there and three rookies recorded four of the first six outs at the plate, and that proved to be crucial as the Mets grabbed a fourth straight win and another win in a one-run ballgame.
“Without those kids on the corners, we don’t win that game,” interim manager Andy Green said. "Nolan doesn't get to settle in and pitch six strong innings for us. That game coulda spun wildly different without them playing the outfield so well."
McLean's night got off to an unlucky start with consecutive one-out bloop singles to put runners on first and second. A third straight bloop to right started the history, as Jake Cronenworth got an ever-so-subtle wave from San Diego third base coach Bob Henley that proved to be most ill-advised as Benge got the Padres runner by at least a dozen feet thanks to a throw he uncorked at 99.9 mph. (h/t Sarah Langs)
"Haven't they gotten the scouting report?"
— SNY (@SNYtv) August 17, 2026
Carson Benge with his 8th outfield assist of the season! pic.twitter.com/VpXgrx73iu
Four pitches later, Jackson Merrill rocketed a ball (105 mph off the bat) for a base hit to right, and Manny Machado looked primed to score the first run of the ballgame until Benge's throw was perfect and Francisco Alvarez tagged the runner out to end the inning.
After the game, Benge said he wasn't too surprised the Padres decided to test him. "Not really," he said. "I just looked up and threw the ball. I'm not worried about if they're running or not; I'm just trying to throw it as hard as I can to make him stop or get him out."
He is now the fourth player in the last 30 years to have outfield assists at home plate on consecutive batters, according to Langs.
And this throw from Benge was even faster than his first: 103.9 mph, the third-fastest throw on an outfield assist since Statcast tracking began in 2015 and the fastest of the 2026 season, per Langs. The rookie also became the first outfielder with two assists thrown at greater than 99 mph in an inning in the Statcast era.
The arm strength isn't too surprising as the one-time two-way player was "throwing 95, 97 [mph] off the bump," the interim skipper said.
“Special athlete, really confident,” Green said, relaying that Benge once said, “When you don’t have to strike a batter out, it's actually really easy to throw it over the plate.”
Benge, with his 98th percentile arm strength, per Statcast, now has nine assists in his first 119 career games, good for fourth most among MLB outfielders. But it isn't just about arm strength, as Green credited Benge's work with the club's developmental staff to speed up his release time, which has “turned him into a different kind of elite.”
“It’s been ridiculous, honestly,” Green said. “It just doesn’t happen at this rate; you don’t get these opportunities, and then you don’t execute perfectly every time the way he has.”
Which throw did Benge like better? "Probably the second one, even though they both took a run off the board," he said.
So despite the Padres grabbing four straight hits in the top of the first, they scored zero runs as they made two outs on the bases.
"ARE YOU KIDDING ME, STOP RUNNING ON HIM!"
— SNY (@SNYtv) August 17, 2026
Carson Benge nails back-to-back runners at the plate! pic.twitter.com/E0BTOphs2Y
All of the Mets' reactions to Carson Benge's back-to-back outfield assists in the first inning pic.twitter.com/QCkbBPUwXD
— SNY Mets (@SNY_Mets) August 18, 2026
McLean, who threw just two balls in the first inning, lost his command to start the second, issuing two walks that sandwiched a hit batter to load the bases. After Fernando Tatis Jr. just missed a grand slam, getting under the ball for a 359-foot warning-track sac fly, Cronenworth grounded a sharp single to left that Ewing was charging all the way, and he got Xander Bogaerts by just a touch at the plate.
For Ewing, whose arm is not nearly as strong as his counterpart across the outfield – he's just in the 92nd percentile for arm strength – the run-saving play was his fifth assist in his 84th big league game.
It was a bang-bang play where the Mets got the call, and there was no challenge by the visitors.
This is the 13th time the Mets have recorded three outfield assists in the same game, a feat most recently accomplished by Mark Canha when he recorded all three (including two at home plate) in a game on July 23, 2023, while playing in front of the Green Monster at Fenway Park.
A.J. EWING'S TURN!
— SNY (@SNYtv) August 17, 2026
The Mets have thrown out three Padres at the plate in the first two innings! pic.twitter.com/XmKj8ZlDgS

















