The Yankees overturned a six-run deficit with a barrage of home runs, including a go-ahead two-run shot from Luis Garcia Jr. in his Bronx debut, but the bullpen collapsed in the eighth as New York fell 13-7 to the St. Louis Cardinals on Monday night.
Cam Schlittler struggled for command and lasted just three innings and it looked like it wouldn’t matter as the Bronx Bombers clobbered five home runs. Unfortunately, the visitors hit five bombs of their own, including three by Alec Burleson, and used a seven-run eighth to land the knock-out blow.
The Yankees, after a brisk 3:25 game, fell to 63-50 (26-24 at home) and will end the night 3.5 behind Tampa Bay in the AL East. The Cards improved to 56-57 (28-25 on the road).
Here are the takeaways...
- While the Yanks’ starter struggled early, St. Louis’ Michael McGreevy retired the first seven batters he faced on 40 pitches. The home side finally broke through as JoséCaballero worked a walk and Austin Wells lined a basehit up the middle, but the first runners of the night were left stranded.
Down 6-0 with a runner on first in the fifth, Wells got a McGreevy sinker out and over the plate and drilled it into the seats in right for a 394-foot two-run homer to put the Yanks on the board. It was his eighth homer and gives him 16 RBI on the year. He finished 2-for-4 with a strikeout. (He also did well behind the plate, going 4-for-4 on ABS challenges.)
St. Louis went to the bullpen after the Wells homer, but Trent Grisham greeted lefty reliever Justin Bruihl by taking a 1-2 sweeper into the seats in right for back-to-back homers to make it a 6-3 game. His 355-foot homer, which was just 90.9 mph exit velocity, gave him 12 on the year and 43 driven in.
Grisham, who flied out to the wall in the right-center gap his first time up, went 2-for-5 with a strikeout and a hustle double with one down in the seventh.
- Ryan McMahon jumped on the second pitch Ryne Stanek threw for a 410-foot home run to start the seventh, giving him 10 on the season. Two pitches later, Caballero drilled a fastball 400 feet to left to give him 12 on the year and the Yanks back-to-back homers for the second time.
McMahon, who struck out swinging his first time up, dropped a single into right to start the fifth and came around to score on the Wells homer to finish 2-for-3.
Caballero finished 1-for-3 with a walk and two strikeouts swinging.
- Garcia hit the ball hard his first time up (102.4 mph off the bat) but got under it for a 351-foot fly out to center. He dropped a single into center to start the fourth for his first hit with the new club.
But with a runner on second and two down in the seventh, Garcia had what looked to be the signature moment in his debut: golfing a changeup 424 feet into the Yankee bullpen to erase the six-run deficit and put the Yanks ahead with his two-run shot. His 24th homer of the year, on the sixth pitch of a tough battle with George Soriano, was 109 mph and got out on a line.
He finished 2-for-4 and also had a couple nice throws to second on double plays.
- Schlittler didn’t have his normal sharpness, issuing a four-pitch walk to start the game. He paid the price for it as he left a 97 mph fastball over the outside corner toBurleson, who he yanked the 1-2 offering for a 350-foot, two-run shot that just snuck over the short porch in right. After a second walk and a single put two aboard, Schlittler got help from his defense as Jazz Chisholm Jr. started the rare 4-3-6 double-play as the Cardinals ran themselves out of the first inning.
The righty found himself in trouble in the second as another leadoff walk came around to score when José Fermín smoked a ball that got past Jasson Dominguez for an RBI double. Schlittler recovered to get past a one-out walk with three strikeouts.
Schlittler tied his career high with his fifth walk of the game to start the third, but struck out the next two to give him six on the night, but Nathan Church got a fastball up and shot it the other way to left for an RBI single. The night nearly got worse, but Fermín didn't have enough pop in his bat, flying out to the warning track in left on a first-pitch sinker over the plate.
That ended the righty's night: 3.0 innings, four runs on four hits and five walks with six strikeouts on 83 pitches (51 strikes).
- Out of the bullpen, Tim Hill retired the first two men he faced before Jordan Walker dropped a single into right and Burleson struck again, this time driving a sinker on the inside corner (108.3 mph off the bat) for a 365-foot two-run shot to right.
Hill got the first out of the fifth before Kervin Castro took over, getting a strikeout and walk that was erased by a Wells caught stealing to end the fifth. Castro got the first 1-2-3 inning of the night in the sixth. After a Walker infield hit to start the seventh, Garcia was lifted for lefty Ryan Yarbrough, who entered and got a 3-6-3 double-play and a pop out.
Pitching with a lead for the first time of the night, Yarbrough got stung for a pinch-hit triple to center by pinch-hitter Blaze Jordan to leadoff the eighth. Angel Chivilli, who had been warming in the bullpen before the inning, walked the first man he faced to put runners on the corners and left a changeup over the plate that Church lined 355 feet to right for a go-ahead three-run homer. The Cards weren't done as Fermin singled and Jimmy Crooks clocked a first-pitch fastball 376-feet into the second deck in right for a four-run lead. After JJ Wetherholt singled and Walker flied out, Burleson took a slider on the eighth pitch of the at-bat 418 feet deep into the second deck in right to complete his hat trick of homers.
Fernando Cruz needed 10 pitches for a 1-2-3 top of the ninth with two strikeouts.
- Domínguez shot a single through the right side against a lefty with one out in the sixth and looked to have stolen second, but after replay review he was called out for having lost contact with the base. He went 1-for-4 with two strikeouts looking.
- Ben Rice flied out the first four times he was up, the second to strand runners on first and second and the fourth with a runner on second in the seventh.
- Spencer Jones went hitless in four times up with two strikeouts.
- Chisholm Jr. was 0-for-4 with a trio of groundouts.
- Ahead of the game, Carlos Rodon threw a 40-pitch live BP at the stadium, which manager Aaron Boone said was encouraging and could see him in line to pitch in a rehab assignment on Saturday. Giancarlo Stanton had another “good week” that saw him hit off Rodon and do some running in the outfield that has the skipper “encouraged about where he’s moving.” Clarke Schmidt is expected to throw around 45 pitches on Tuesday and is “close to being in the mix,” with him eventually heading for a rehab assignment potentially in the near future.
Highlights
Luis García Jr. gets his first hit as a Yankee pic.twitter.com/wdutyjnLSQ
— SNY Yankees (@snyyankees) August 4, 2026
Austin Wells gets the Yankees on the board with a two-run homer! pic.twitter.com/cTrDFbsPRY
— SNY Yankees (@snyyankees) August 4, 2026
Now a solo home run from Trent Grisham! pic.twitter.com/40bAX2R79l
— SNY Yankees (@snyyankees) August 4, 2026
Ryan McMahon with the solo shot! pic.twitter.com/UJcPpcgaY5
— SNY Yankees (@snyyankees) August 4, 2026
José Caballero makes it a one-run game!! pic.twitter.com/riwivfVNth
— SNY Yankees (@snyyankees) August 4, 2026
LUIS GARCÍA JR. GIVES THE YANKEES THE LEAD WITH A TWO-RUN SHOT! pic.twitter.com/OUQRrRDT5T
— SNY Yankees (@snyyankees) August 4, 2026
What's next
The series continues on Tuesday night with a 7:05 p.m. first pitch.
Ryan Weathers (3.99 ERA, 1.243 WHIP in 115 innings) will make his 2nd start for the home side. The Cardinals have yet to name a starting pitcher.