On a day the Dodgers were facing one of their former longtime starters, Dustin May faced the prospect of potentially soon having the same distinction.
In the last week, trade rumors have started to swirl around May, the oft-injured right-hander who is finally healthy this season — but also having an up-and-down campaign in his final year before free agency.
It’s an idea that, on several levels, makes sense to explore: The Dodgers will soon have to demote someone from the rotation (likely May or Emmet Sheehan) to make room for Blake Snell’s return next weekend. And there are few foreseeable scenarios in which May would pitch big innings in the postseason, given his 4.85 earned-run average and the fact that, in his return from a 2023 elbow surgery this year, he is already past his previous career-high for innings pitched.
Read more:Clayton Kershaw can't match Garrett Crochet's consistency in Dodgers' loss to Red Sox
May hardly seemed surprised to see his name mentioned as possible trade bait in multiple reports this week; having long ago grown accustomed to such speculation during his rise as a top pitching prospect.
“Shocker,” he quipped earlier this weekend. “It’s there every year. It’s not anything new.”
While it’s doubtful he alone would net much of a significant return as a rental player who has posted below-league-average production, potential Dodgers trade partners have dedicated scouting attention to him recently, according to a person with knowledge of the situation not authorized to speak publicly.
And given the number of teams still in relative no-man’s-land in the standings (looking to offload some pieces, but still within an arm’s length of a potential wild card spot) the Dodgers could find some interest in him ahead of the Thursday 3 p.m. PDT deadline.
It all made Sunday’s start, against former Dodgers rotation-mate and current Boston Red Sox right-hander Walker Buehler, a pivotal one for the 27-year-old May — providing him one last chance to try and stay in the rotation, and the Dodgers’ front office one more data point to evaluate in the coming week.
The result: An at-times impressive, but ultimately disappointing, effort in which May yielded four runs over five innings in the Dodgers’ 4-3 loss against the Red Sox, largely cruising through the first four innings before getting ambushed in a three-run fifth.
“It’s been like that for a lot of my outings,” May said afterward. “I feel like I get to a good spot then I can’t get through one inning. One-inning blowup. It’s not a fun feeling.”
What comes next remains wholly unclear.
Before the game, manager Dave Roberts said the team would “push” its decision on who to remove from the rotation “down the line a little bit.”
“In all honesty,” Roberts added, “things seem to change a lot each week. So I think that right now I don't want to put anyone into a corner. We'll just kind of read and react after this start."
When May was asked after the game if he felt like he was pitching for his spot in the rotation, he responded, simply, “no.”
“I think in totality he threw the baseball well,” Roberts said. “The line score doesn't show that.”
For a while on a gloomy Sunday afternoon that started with a 40-minute rain delay, May out-pitched Buehler in the latter’s first start against his old team.
Buehler issued three walks in the third, including one to Freddie Freeman with the bases loaded to score a run. He gave up a home run to Michael Conforto (who also had two doubles, but two misplays in left field) to lead off the fourth, before later walking Miguel Rojas (who reached base all four times he came up) and giving up an RBI single to Mookie Betts (making his first start of the weekend at his old home stadium).
Read more:Facing Dodgers for first time gives Walker Buehler chance to reflect on his time in L.A.
May, meanwhile, settled down after giving up a quick run in the first, retiring nine in a row — including five on strikeouts — between the second and fifth innings.
“I felt good in the middle part [of the game],” May said. “Mechanics were in a good spot.”
But with one out in the fifth, Abraham Toro singled, Roman Anthony hit an RBI triple on a shallow fly ball that ricocheted off the Green Monster, and Alex Bregman flipped the game with a two-run homer on a hanging sweeper down the middle, turning the Red Sox’s 3-1 deficit to the Dodgers into a sudden 4-3 lead.
“I know that there’s good stuff is in there,” May said. “It’s just a matter of eliminating the one bad inning.”
From there, the Dodgers (61-45) squandered every chance they had to answer back against Boston (57-50). Rojas and Conforto (twice) were stranded after doubles in the fifth, sixth and seventh innings. They saw a two-on, one-out threat in the eighth extinguish when Teoscar Hernández lined into an inning-ending double-play at second base, where Ceddanne Rafaela stretched to make the catch before beating pinch-runner Hyeseong Kim to the bag with a dive. They again had a runner at second in the ninth, only to again come up empty on a day they finished one-for-11 with runners in scoring position and left 13 men on base.
Read more:Shaikin: Home again? Why Kenley Jansen could be a good trade match for Dodgers
“We created opportunities, which was good,” Roberts said. “But we just couldn't finish off innings today."
As a result, May was left on the hook for the loss, dropping him to 6-7.
Whether or not it will be his last start in the rotation, or final outing of any kind in a Dodger uniform, will remain in question in the days ahead.
Blake Treinen returns
More than three months after sustaining a forearm injury, key reliever Blake Treinen rejoined the Dodgers on Sunday after recently completing a minor-league rehab assignment. The Dodgers also called up Justin Wrobleski in an effort to freshen their bullpen, and optioned Will Klein and Edgardo Henriquez to the minors.
Sign up for more Dodgers news with Dodgers Dugout. Delivered at the start of each series.
This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
