Dave Dombrowski's best and worst deadline deals with the Phillies originally appeared on NBC Sports Philadelphia
As the Phillies president of baseball operations, Dave Dombrowski has plenty on his plate. Every day he makes decisions, both large and small, that impact the fortunes of the franchise. His job is as close to a 365-day vocation as one can have. But for the most part, the only times of year that measurably affect the fans’ collective heart rate is after the World Series, which is open season for free agency, and now, the final week of July, leading up to the MLB trade deadline.
Dombrowski has made some solid moves, both in trades and in free agency, during his tenure in Philadelphia. But his best moves have come during the relative quiet of the offseason, when the results of each transaction aren’t on display later that week. He has added Jose Alvarado from Tampa Bay, Edmundo Sosa from St. Louis, and this past offseason, Jesus Luzardo from Miami, all of whom have been integral in the team’s success since their arrivals.
Comparatively, Dombrowski’s deadline deals lack the impact of those he has made in the winter. It could be the market, or a proclivity to hold onto prospects a bit too tight, or unforeseen factors, but he has yet to make a “lightning bolt” trade, one that immediately energizes and lifts a team to another level.
Let’s examine the best, and the worst, deadline moves during Dombrowski’s time with the Phillies:
Dombrowski’s Best Deadline Deals
- Phillies acquire OF Brandon Marsh from Angels for C Logan O’Hoppe. This can be characterized as a win for both the Phillies and the Halos. Adding Marsh, a young outfielder with decent power, speed and defensive ability, is something the team needs now, and will certainly need for the years ahead. Meanwhile O’Hoppe has been solid, if not spectacular, at the plate (20 HR last year, 18 already this year), but his defense behind the dish needs some serious work.
- Phillies acquire RP David Robertson from Cubs for SP Ben Brown. The Phillies didn’t get too much for their investment the first time they picked up Robertson in 2019. He signed a two-year deal that netted the team just two weeks of Robertson’s services before he needed Tommy John surgery, costing him the balance of his contract. The second time was a charm: pitching to a 2.70 ERA in 22 games down the stretch in 2022, and a 1.17 in eight postseason games during the Phillies’ World Series run.
- Phillies acquire RP Tanner Banks from the White Sox for UT William Bergolla. Banks was added for bullpen depth at last year’s deadline, but is slowly being nudged into higher-leverage situations, both due to his effectiveness and the team’s lack of depth in relief. In 68 games in red pinstripes, he has a 3.44 ERA and just about a strikeout per inning. The White Sox are still waiting for the 20-year-old Bergolla to develop as a hitter. He is currently in double-A.
Honorable Mention: Carlos Estevez from the Angels for minor-league pitchers George Klassen and Samuel Aldegheri. Estevez was strong for the Phillies down the stretch last year, pitching to a 2.57 ERA with six saves in 20 outings, but many remember the grand slam he allowed to the Mets’ Francisco Lindor in the NLDS. (Has that landed yet?)
Dombrowski’s Worst Deadline Deals
- Phillies acquire OF Austin Hays from the Orioles for OF Cristian Pache and RP Seranthony Dominguez. Hays’ two-month run in Philadelphia was forgettable. He suffered a kidney infection that caused him to miss two weeks, and hit .256 with two home runs in 22 games. Pache won’t be missed, but this team sure could use Dominguez right about now.
- Phillies trade RP Gregory Soto to the Orioles for pitchers Seth Johnson and Moises Chace. Speaking for relievers sent to the Orioles! This trade could be graded higher as Chace develops as a back of the rotation starter, and Johnson is trying to find his footing at the big-league level as a reliever. Soto didn’t set the world on fire in Baltimore – like Dominguez, he’s already been traded again – but the Phillies could use an extra lefty in the ‘pen.
- Phillies acquire infielder Rodolfo Castro from the Pirates for SP Bailey Falter. This may not resonate with fans, but would you take a 5th starter with a 3.73 ERA right now? Falter is pitching pretty well the past couple seasons. In fact, he has 15 wins over the past two seasons – same as Aaron Nola – and a better WHIP over that span than Ranger Suarez. Meanwhile, Castro went 3-for-30 following the trade, and hasn’t sniffed the big leagues since.