The Penguins finished the 2024-25 season with just 80 points in the standings, good for only seventh place in their division and 13th in the Eastern Conference.
Fast forward a year, and Pittsburgh was up to 98 points, a second place finish in their division that ranked seventh in the conference. Where did that turnaround happen? Let’s check the team performance split by opponent over the two seasons.
The highlighted segment of division opponents tells the tale at large. The Pens were just 9-13-4 against Metropolitan Division opponents in 2024-25. That turned completely on its head this past season by the tune of a 13-4-9 record in 2025-26. That’s as many wins as total losses but avoiding regulation losses is the name of the game – getting to OT against these opponents serves to cheapen the impact of their win. Two of the regulation losses were to the Capitals at the tail end of the season after Pittsburgh had clinched a playoff berth and iced less-than-competitive lineups to make the record that much more impressive for the games that matters.
To go from a full-season point pace of just 69 in 2024-25 when playing teams in the division to turn it into a pace of 110 in 2025-26 really sums up the Pens’ turnaround from one year to the next. It’s really about all that needs to be said, dominate the division and you are likely headed to the playoffs. Play horribly and it’s the draft lottery.
Improvements weren’t limited to the division, Pittsburgh managed a 15-15-2 record against the Western Conference in 2024-25, that improved to a 15-9-8 record this past year. While they didn’t add to the win total, avoiding regulation losses was once again a key to results, the pace difference from year-to-year was 82 to 97, showing just how critical picking up the so-called ‘loser point’ can be. They add up in the standings column just the same.
One area where results were a little less favorable was against the Atlantic Division, where Pittsburgh put up a 12-11-1 record. Somehow, Toronto dummied the Pens all season long (shakes fist at William Nylander) despite the Maple Leafs having a rotten year otherwise. Coming into the season, a season-sweep of Florida would have sounded more impressive than it ended up being at the finish of the year, the Pens did it anyways (3-0-0). Pittsburgh also helped sink the Yzerplan by going 3-0-0 against Detroit. At the same time, the Pens took a step back against Montreal (1-2-0 record after sweeping the Habs in 2024-25) and – as usual for Pittsburgh – continued to have trouble winning games against Ottawa and Boston.
The Pens’ performance against the two Stanley Cup Final teams of Carolina and Vegas show how they are so close, yet so far away. Pittsburgh took a 2-2-2 record against the two, losing four of the six games. However, the wins (5-1 over the Hurricanes on December 30th, 5-0 over Vegas on March 1st) were two of their more impressive games of the season. The regulation losses (5-1 to Carolina and 6-2 to Vegas, both in March) were extremely humbling experiences. The two extra time losses (both to Carolina) were back-and-forth battles where Pittsburgh erased third period deficits to earn a point. In the end, they didn’t quite have enough.
For next season, the Penguins will have to be looking to accomplish the same results against the Metropolitan Division to have a strong season. The NHL is tacking on two more games, and both are against division opponents. That means that one-third of the 84 game schedule (28 games) will be against rivals. 2025-26 showed that performing well in those games will set a team up nicely to qualify for the postseason. It’s easier to read a map than actually tread it, but the message and results are clear for division performance making Pittsburgh one of the worst teams in the league in 2024-25 when they struggled in that area, compared to being one of the better teams in 2025-26 when they were able to excel against their most important foes.