Joe Mazzulla has stuck to his guns with his starting lineup and who he plays off of the bench.
Well, expect a for at center but that is a different story.
The Celtics have started the same five of Derrick White, Jaylen Brown, Sam Hauser, Jayson Tatum and Neemias Queta in all 6 games of the first round. That lineup is -15 in 58 minutes in the series.
All season, Mazzulla was flexible with his rotations, starting Josh Minott, Jordan Walsh and Baylor Scheierman for different stretches this season and now that we have reached the playoffs, he’s been fairly rigid. Why is that?
Hugo Gonzalez and Ron Harper Jr. just cannot get on the court and Scheierman has been the seldom used 9th guy the entire series. These are guys who played roles throughout the regular season because they all played very well for the Celtics. They have all shown they are solid NBA players.
I don’t know that I love the Tatum at center look but that is another thing that Mazzulla hasn’t tried it at all.
What advantage has Hauser given them in the starting lineup? What advantage has any of their bigs given them?
The Celtics best lineup in Game 6 was Payton Pritchard, Harper Jr., Scheierman, Walsh and Luka Garza, they were a +6 in 9 minutes. Sure, it was at the end of the game and that lineup isn’t sustainable, but Philly had their starters out there for a bit with those guys on the floor and they played well.
They are good players who played the brand of basketball you played all season, the brand of basketball that won you 56 games and took a 3-1 lead in this series.
No, you can’t pull Derrick White. He hasn’t played well but he is apart of the fabric of everything they do, they need him. However, they don’t need to go down on the Sam Hauser ship.
Yet, we need to question if it really matters. Is Harper, Scheierman, Gonzalez or anyone else really going to change anything? These are role players. If the Celtics best players don’t play well, it really doesn’t matter who plays or how much they play.
Before the playoffs, I wrote about how this was Jaylen Brown’s moment to prove he is one of the best players in the NBA, but he has more turnovers than assists in this series.
It is easy for us to look at a coach who keeps putting the same players on the court when it is not working and tell him to change it when there is a reason he started off with the guys on the court.
Yet, when you look back at the 2023 2nd round when the Celtics were down 3-2 heading to Philadelphia and Mazzulla made a change to his starting 5 by putting Robert Williams in there for Derrick White, it worked. When it stopped working in the Miami series, Joe went back to White and it worked until Jayson Tatum rolled his ankle in Game 7.
I do think Joe has been too stubborn with his rotations in this series. I do think he should have tried different guys as it became increasingly clear that what he has been trying have not been working.
Now, the Celtics are on the verge of being the 14th team in NBA history to blow a 3-1 lead. While it isn’t entirely due to Mazzulla not changing up his starting 5 or rotations, the Celtics are on the ropes and it is time for Joe Mazzulla to do something different.