
Another day, another set of free agent contract projections. Where might the Guardians do some shopping?
MLB TradeRumors released their top 50 MLB free agents list yesterday. You can find our review of FanGraphs’ top 50 here. Today, we are going to look at a different nine free agents (not among the ones we chose to highlight yesterday) the Guardians could look at from MLB TradeRumors’ list, including those players listed just outside their top 50.
Paul Blackburn, RHrP, 2 years/$15M, 32 years old, 1.59 ERA/3.75 FIP in 2026
Analysis: A groundball-heavy reliever, Blackburn seems like he got pretty lucky to be a reliable high leverage arm last season. I have an option I prefer below, but if Blackburn would get down to a one-year deal, he might be a Guardians’ target.
Steven Okert, LHrP, 2 years/$15M, 35 years old, 2.13 ERA/3.23 FIP in 2026
Analysis: At Okert’s age, I don’t think I’d do two years guaranteed, but if he drops to one year, give me his career 3.28 FIP vs. LHH in the bullpen combined with the career numbers he put up last season.
Joc Pederson, LHH DH, 1 year/$14M, 34 years old, 128 wRC+
Analysis: The Guardians definitely looked at Pederson in past offseasons, but were unwilling to meet his agent’s asking price (causing Pederson to call out their ownership as cheap). I don’t find this fit LIKELY, but if the Guardians are done with Manzardo, I think there would be room on their roster to run a quasi-DH/pinch-hit platoon with Pederson and Adell. Because of Adell’s ability to stand in the outfield, they can still get Jose and DeLauter DH days, and bring Pederson off the bench. Again, unlikely, but I don’t think out of the realm of possibility.
Jonathan Loaisiga, RHrP, 2 years/$13M, 32 years old, 2.42 ERA/2.88 FIP in 2026
Analysis: If Loaisiga is going at THIS low of a salary, I’d hope the Guardians would be all over that. He does not get a lot of whiffs… but he gets tons of groundballs and supresses contact. I think his groundball-heavy approach would be a nice change of pace for the backend of the Cleveland pen.
Kris Bubic, LHP, 1 year/$12.5M, 29 years old, 3.76 ERA/3.54 FIP in 2026
Analysis: I don’t want Bubic simply because he had both elbow and shoulder injuries last year. If not for that, I’d bet on the Guardians to unlike the potential he’s always had to be a mid-rotation starter.
Taylor Ward, RHH OF, 1 year/$12M, 32 years old, 102 wRC+ in 2026
Analysis: It wouldn’t be an offseason without me speculating about Ward to the Guardians. But, my passion for the former Angels’ outfielder has mostly passed. Ward had a great season for on-base percentage last season but his slugging dropped immensely. For his career, he hasn’t really hit lefties much better than right-handers. So, I’m kinda out on him… but if the Guardians see some reason for his slugging to rebound to 2025 levels, the 119 wRC+ he put up that season would be a welcome addition. I just don’t see any reason for that to happen, myself.
Shane Bieber, RHP, 31 years old, 4.37 ERA/5.15 FIP in 2026
Analysis: This would be a bet on Carl Willis to get Bieber back to where he gets strikeouts. Is that a good bet? It depends on the cost, but I don’t think there’s a single Guardians’ fan out there who would oppose trying this out.
Alec Bohm, RHH 1B/3B, 30 years old, 90 wRC+ in 2026
Analysis: Bohm will have to accept that he is a lefty-masher, not a starter, to end up in Cleveland. His 120 wRC+ vs. LHP would look great at first base and third base when Jose DH’s against southpaws at the right price.
Patrick Sandoval, LHP, 30 years old, 5.12 ERA/3.74 FIP
Analysis: Sandoval never figured it out in Boston, but his underlying numbers still look solid. How about a pillow deal with one of the best pitching organizations in baseball who have been good (knock-on-wood) at keeping pitchers healthy, Patrick?
What do you think about these options? Let us know in the comments below
















