Welcome back to my annual, unrequested article for Covering the Corner. Below are parts 3 and 4 of my mid-May roster review for the Lake County Captains. I’m also going to organize this mess into a list for reference. I hope that you get some value out of this thought exercise, and that my perspective gives you something to consider. Maybe you’ll find a future favorite player in the weeds here, or a new least-favorite prospect evaluator.
On we go:
The Infield: Class of 2025 on the Left Side
NOTE: All the infielders on this team throw right-handed.
Dean Curley, SS/2B/3B: 6’4”, 230, Bats R, DoB 4/15/2004 (22 yrs. old), Tennessee (CB-A pick, 2025 Draft).
Hit: 45/50, Power: 50/55, Run: 55/50, Field: 50/50*, Arm: 60/60
Dean Curley looks like the prototype. He is strong, fast, and light on his feet. His plate patience and discipline has led to many, many walks. Already, it is clear he needs to see better pitchers to determine if his patience is merely passiveness. When he does swing, Curley makes good contact, and he possesses power to all fields. He can identify and attack mistakes in the zone, and he can get to fastballs of any velocity. However, he does swing and miss in the zone a bit more than you would like. Additionally, I have his defense as a present 50, but Curley is prone to throwing errors due to issues with his arm slot and mechanics required to get to a comfortable throwing angle. His arm is strong, but he struggles to make accurate throws while moving to his left. Still, I believe he has the movement skills and athleticism to stick at shortstop, and that this issue can be resolved with continued reps.
Verdict: Curley is a mature, powerful hitter and a prototypical athlete who belongs on the left side of the infield. He may Knoblauch, but there is reason to believe he can develop into a fine defender. FV: 45+.
Luke Hill, SS/2B/3B: 5’11”, 193, Bats R, DoB 4/9/2004 (22 yrs. old), Mississippi (4th Rd, 2025 Draft).
Hit: 40/50, Power: 40/45*, Run: 55/55, Field: 45/50, Arm: 60/60.
Hill is a solid infielder who can play competently at shortstop, although he is a much better fielder at second or third base. Hill has hit well through his first few months at High-A, showing patience and the ability to recognize pitches he can attack. Like Curley, he has also shown power to all fields despite his smaller frame, currently leading the team in home runs. He has had some impressive exit velocities to all fields.
Verdict: Hill may pan out to be a nice surprise in the early-middle rounds of the 2025 draft. I had him pegged as a utility infielder, but he may become more. Monitor him as he gets promoted, because the early sample is very promising. FV: 40+.
Bennett Thompson, C: 5’9”, 201, Bats R, DoB 12/16/2002 (23 yrs. old), Oregon (13th Rd, 2024 Draft).
Hit: 55/55, Power: 30/40, Run: 30/30, Field: 35/40, Arm: 30/35.
Bennett Thompson is a bat-first catcher with a precocious feel for the zone and a compact, line-drive oriented swing. He is very likely to hit as he moves up, although he is not likely to impact the ball much. However, he is not a smooth operator behind the plate. He often struggles to move in front of pitches, and his arm is middling. This pitching staff is hard to catch, but teams run wild on Thompson no matter who is throwing.
Verdict: Thompson is not a Cleveland type of catcher, at least with the defensive expectations they have. However, the bat and the approach will play, and I am sure there will be interested teams that are willing to let him try catching. FV: 40+.
Nolan Schubart, 1B/LF: 6’4”, 227, Bats L, DoB 5/10/2004 (22 yrs. old), Oklahoma State (3rd Rd, 2025 Draft).
Hit:30/35, Power 60/70, Run 25/25, Field 30/40, Arm 50/50.
Schubart is a three-true-outcome player on offense, and he is learning first base on the fly. His swing is powerful and pretty, but it is also a bit grooved with a permanent uppercut. He generates incredible power, and he knows the zone well enough to wait out his pitch. Too often, he misses his pitch (you will hear this again in the outfield section). As he ascends the ranks, he needs to be able to consistently hit pitches in the middle of the zone, but he shows an approach that can allow him to succeed if he does manage to make just a bit more contact.
Verdict: Schubart is boom or bust. When he gets hot, he can carry an offense, but he needs to be able to survive pitches he can’t handle in the zone to have a more consistent impact. In acknowledging the volatility, FV: 35++.
Logun Clark, C: 5’11”, 205, Bats R, DoB 6/4/2003 (22 yrs. old), Taft Union HS (CA) (16th Rd, 2022 Draft).
Hit: 20/30, Power 30/40, Run 40/35, Field 50/50, Arm 60/60.
Clark is a defense-first catcher who is only catching 1-2 times a week at present. He is a reasonable mover behind the dish, an adequate framer, and a talented thrower with a strong arm.
Verdict: Cleveland loves these types of players, but Clark is a true non-factor at the dish. His defensive chops will keep him in this organization, though. FV: 30+.
Garrett Howe, SS/2B/3B: 5’8”, 178, Bats L, DoB 7/12/2002 (23 yrs. old), Samford (11th Rd, 2024 Draft).
Hit:30/40, Power 30/35, Run 50/50, Field 45/50, Arm 40/40.
Howe has occasionally shown a propensity for pulling the ball in the air, maximizing what is an otherwise modest frame. However, the feel for contact has not translated at this level. Defensively, his arm is just good enough to make most throws at shortstop, but he struggles at the hot corner.
Verdict: Howe is almost certainly going to be quality depth for the minor leagues. FV: 30.
Maick Collado, 1B/3B: 5’11”, 185, Bats S, DoB 12/24/2002 (23 yrs. old), Santiago, DR (Int’l free agent, 2019).
Hit:30/40, Power 30/35, Run 40/40, Field 45/50, Arm 50/50.
Collado is already being treated like MiLB floating depth, as he recently spent a few weeks acquitting himself well in Columbus. Collado is not going to wow you at the plate, and he often lacks discipline, but he can occasionally punish a mistake. He is a plus defender at first base, and he makes the occasional flashy play at third base.
Verdict: Collado is already quality depth for the minor leagues, but there is not much of a reason to expect more. FV: 30.
Kevin Rivas, 1B/2B/C: 5’9”, 183, Bats S, DoB 4/7/2003 (23 yrs. old), San Felipe, VZ (Int’l free agent, 2019).
Hit:20/30, Power 30/30, Run 40/40, Field 30/40, Arm 40/40.
Rivas has done everything the team has asked of him. Originally a middle infielder, he converted to catcher to allow the team some flexibility. Catching does not come naturally to Rivas- his games feature many wild pitches and passed balls, and even his bullpen catching leads to on-field delays- but this is the type of player that keeps a minor league system healthy. He has already made cameos at every minor league level above Lake County. He also has a pitching win, thanks in part to his ability to mix speeds and in part to the player below, who hit an improbable 3-run home run to walk off an extra innings game.
Verdict: Rivas is someone the organization values because he can be brought up at short notice. He does that well. These are the kinds of guys that end up coaching. FV: 25.
Jeffrey Mercedes, 1B/2B: 5’8”, 185, Bats S, DoB 10/2/2004 (21 yrs. old), Azua, DR (Int’l free agent, 2022).
Hit:20/30, Power 20/30, Run 50/50, Field 40/40, Arm 30/30.
Mercedes is in an odd situation. He is young for this level, and he looks appropriately overmatched. The team plays him every other day, and the performance often leaves much to be desired. He has been about as effective at the dish as a pitcher, and his glove is limited to the right side of the infield because his arm is underwhelming. For the team to stick a relatively young international signee in High-A would imply that they see potential in him, but there is no doubt that Mercedes is just here to give some guys a breather. On the plus side, he does have a reasonable ERA from the times he has been asked to pitch (although Kevin Rivas has him beat there, too).
Verdict: I’m rooting for him. I call him Jeff. FV: 25.
Part 4: The Outfield Toolshed
Aaron Walton, OF: 6’4”, 218, Bats R, Throws R, DoB 5/14/2004 (22 yrs. old), Arizona (Competitive Balance-B, 2025 Draft).
Hit: 40/50, Power: 50/55, Speed: 60/60, Field 50/50, Arm 50/50.
Surprised at the name? I think many people are, or they will be when they plug in to what Walton is doing. Walton’s performance in High-A has been very strong. He has impacted the ball, hit for average, walked at a healthy rate, and managed his strikeouts to this point. His jumps are reasonable in center field, and he has enough arm to play right field. He is aggressive on the bases, and he moves very well for his size. While Walton appears to be vulnerable to spin in the zone, he does seem to recognize it, and he lays off those pitches enough to get something he can handle. His ability to combat spin will be the key for him going forward.
Verdict: Walton is what they look like, and he is my favorite prospect on this team in terms of present tools because he has shown such a feel for hitting. I’m not quite ready to say he is the best position player prospect on the team, but it is tight between him and two others. FV: 45+.
Jace LaViolette, OF: 6’6”, 227, Bats L, Throws L, DoB 12/4/2003 (22 yrs. old), Texas A&M (1st Rd, 2025 Draft).
Hit: 30/40?, Power: 60/60, Speed: 60/50, Field 50/50, Arm 60/60.
Jace LaViolette is a tremendous athlete. If you see him have a good game, you understand why he was a first-round selection. He has tremendous power, he is patient, he moves incredibly well for his size, and he plays a good, comfortable center field. He has everything, and for one game, he will make you think we found a left-handed Aaron Judge with speed.
If you watch one of his bad games, you’ll understand why many analysts were uncomfortable with LaViolette at any spot in the draft. He is currently running a 39%K rate at High-A (it is trending down from a disastrous start to the year). He routinely gets pitches to damage, and he routinely misses them. His swing appears to have a loop, and his operation is stiff. As a result, there is a noticeable hole in his swing, and it happens to be at the center of the zone between the mid-thigh and the belt. He has the whole package except the hit tool. As such, he would be a developmental challenge for any team; but it’s a whole lot of fun when he gets rolling, and it’s hard not to dream on what he could be when you see it all click.
Verdict: LaViolette has tremendous upside, but he also has a subterranean floor. He is easily the second-most exciting prospect on the team in terms of his present tools- because that hit tool is the key between flaming out in the minors and being a star. Accounting for volatility, FV: 40++.
Ryan Cesarini, OF: 5’9”, 211, Bats L, Throws R, DoB 12/16/2002 (23 yrs. old), St. Joseph’s (PA) (14th Rd, 2024 Draft).
Hit: 40/50, Power: 40/40, Speed: 45/40, Field 50/50, Arm 45/45.
Cesarini is an odd case of a player who has put up respectable at-bats, surprising exit velocities, and decent enough defense in the corners. Despite that, he has not received as much playing time as his play seems to warrant. When he does play, he is often a DH, perhaps indicating an injury. His play would not indicate such a thing. Cesarini pulls the ball often, and he sees right-handed pitching very well. He is likely maxed out at 211, and he does seem to be slower than he was last year.
Verdict: There may be something with Cesarini, and it is odd that he is not getting more playing time. Barring a breakout, he will be organizational depth for Cleveland, but I would not be surprised to see a breakout happen. FV: 35+.
Tommy Hawke, OF/2B: 5’8”, 151, Bats L, Throws R, DoB 7/7/2002 (23 yrs. old), Wake Forest (6th Rd, 2023 Draft).
Hit: 40/40, Power: 20/20, Speed: 60/60, Field 50/55, Arm 40/40.
Tommy Hawke can run like the wind, and it’s more about his base running instincts than his natural speed. Unfortunately, his swing is very big, and he tries to slug when he swings at the baseball. This usually does not result in extra bases, but Hawke could easily swipe second and third against this level if he so chose. He is currently playing second base more often than the outfield.
Verdict: Hawke is willing to do the work to remain relevant, and his mentality is a plus for an organization. Still, it’s hard to see him becoming more than depth. FV: 30+.
Esteban Gonzalez, OF: 5’6”, 171, Bats L, Throws R, DoB 3/19/2003 (23 yrs. old), Maracaibo, VZ (Int’l free agent, 2019).
Hit: 30/30, Power: 30/30, Speed: 60/60, Field 50/50, Arm 50/50.
Gonzalez plays baseball with tremendous energy and joy. He is a good outfielder with a decent arm who can play all three positions, and he can occasionally run into one at the dish. However, he is a maxed out 5’6”, and while he can hit the ball hard, he usually does not.
Verdict: He will be around as someone to play the outfield in various affiliates, but Gonzalez is not a developmental priority for Cleveland. FV: 30.
(Editor’s Note: Thank you, Mike, for another great installment of this series on the Captains. We will have Mike’s final installment, a ranking of the prospects in Lake County, tomorrow)