
Over the next couple weeks, we’re going to take a look around the Brewers’ roster and think about how, or if, the Brewers would consider upgrading at those positions and who might be available via free agency or trade. Before getting into that, though, we should go position-by-position through the Brewers’ roster to examine how things look going into the offseason—particularly in the wake of Jake Bauers’ deal with the Red Sox.
Given that the Brewers just won the World Series and, aside from Bauers, they didn’t have any big losses, we shouldn’t expect any major surprises. But it still gives us an opportunity to look to the future and imagine some unlikely scenarios.
Catcher
The Brewers have picked up the option on William Contreras’ contract, which buys out his last year of arbitration at $15.5 million. Barring an extension, Contreras will be an unrestricted free agent after the 2027 season. The Brewers declined a mutual option on backup Gary Sánchez, so he’s a free agent; other catchers on the 40-man roster include Bo Naylor, who came over in a trade on August 1st but who played only three times with the Brewers, and Jeferson Quero, the former-top-prospect whose 2024 shoulder injury has put his future as a catcher in doubt (though Matt Arnold reiterated this week that they see Quero as a future catcher).
The answer here might be very simple: the Brewers might just go with Contreras on an expiring deal and Naylor as the backup. Naylor struggled badly at the plate in 2026, and he’s always been a pretty bad hitter, but he has well over 1,000 major-league plate appearances and has a lot of experience catching good pitching staffs in Cleveland. Given how much Contreras plays, I suspect the team is okay with Naylor as a backup.
The questions come in when considering the future beyond 2027. After his World Series MVP award, much of the Milwaukee fanbase feels that the team should make Contreras the next Brewer to receive a lucrative contract a la Ryan Braun and Christian Yelich.
With projections coming in around 5 years and $115 million or so, the Brewers could certainly afford it, but two questions follow: first, would Contreras take it? He might be dead set on reaching free agency where richer teams than Milwaukee—notably, the Yankees, who have struggled to find a reliable catcher in recent seasons—could drive up the bidding for his services. Second, signing a catcher, a position that usually doesn’t age well, through his age-34 or -35 season doesn’t seem like a very Brewersy thing to do.
The answer would be simpler if there were an obvious solution in the minor leagues. But Quero’s future is in serious doubt, and Marco Dinges, the other well-regarded catching prospect in the minor-league system, has barely played above High-A and there are questions about his defensive acumen.
It’s something to keep an eye on, with a lot of moving parts. I’m not closing the door on a possible Contreras extension, possibly even before the lockout begins at the beginning of next month. But I also wouldn’t be shocked if a blockbuster trade occurred, perhaps even followed by another blockbuster trade for a replacement. While there are some things to figure out at first base, the longer-term future at catcher makes this the most in-flux position on the roster at the moment.
First Base
I had a whole bunch of stuff written here about different scenarios with first base, whether Jake Bauers would accept the qualifying offer or whether he’d sign elsewhere, and what would happen in either case. Well, we now know that Bauers will not be back with the Brewers next season—so where does that leave the team?
Andrew Vaughn, who made $7.65 million in 2026 and should make slightly more than that next season, will now likely be back. He’s a right-handed hitter and started mostly only against left-handed pitchers last season, but he’s probably got the ability to start more against righties—he wasn’t too bad against them in 2026.
But the Brewers are likely to add another left-handed bat who could do some platoon work with Vaughn. There are two potential exciting-but-unproven answers in the minors: Andrew Fischer, who led the minor leagues with 48 homers last season while hitting .273/.413/.654 in 126 games between High-A Wisconsin and Double-A Biloxi; and Blake Burke, who hit .285/.367/.603 in 96 games at Double-A before struggling in a short stint at Triple-A Nashville to end the season.
Both players come with real questions. Fischer’s swing-and-miss issues are so worrisome that some question whether he even has a future in the majors, despite his prodigious power. Burke also has a lot of swing-and-miss in his game, but he’s also a guy who chases out of the zone a lot, something that Fischer avoids, and something that Bauers was so good at it bordered on being a superpower.
Luke Adams could’ve been an answer here had Bauers stayed. He’s closer to the majors than either Fischer or Burke and had a good season last year, but his fit on the major league roster alongside Vaughn is complicated. I wouldn’t really expect to see him, at least at the beginning of the season.
Spring training could be very interesting for Burke and Fischer, but the Brewers might also choose to bring in another player. The two of them have a lot of potential but have very little experience at the highest levels of the majors (Burke played 15 games and struggled, Fischer has not appeared above Double-A), and a good, veteran platoon option on a one-year deal might be attractive to the front office if they want their prospects to cook a little longer.
Infield
Barring a trade, Milwaukee is pretty set in the infield, not just for next season but for a few years. Brice Turang, a super-two player, just had his first of four arbitration years, and while he’s certainly going to get expensive, he’s under team control until after the 2029 season. Cooper Pratt won’t be a free agent until my daughter, who can’t read yet, is a teenager. Joey Ortiz and David Hamilton, who made up the rest of the infield this season, are both entering their first of three arbitration seasons.
It would be easy to send this group back out there. Pratt’s confidence has to be sky-high after he could easily have won the World Series MVP. Turang finished third in MVP voting. While Ortiz and Hamilton both have their offensive shortcomings, both have, for stretches, looked quite good at the plate, and both are reliable (at worst) defensive infielders; Ortiz is one of the best plug-and-play defensive infielders in the league.
I think the most likely scenario here is that the Brewers start the season with Turang and Pratt in their spots and Ortiz and Hamilton sharing a platoon situation at third base, similar to how it was in the postseason. There’s a big shadow on the horizon in the minors, though: the Brewers’ top prospect, considered by many to be the best prospect in baseball, Jesús Made.
Made is still only 19 and doesn’t turn 20 until May. But he’s looking good in winter baseball, and his career has followed a pretty similar path to Jackson Chourio’s, and when Chourio was at the point in his career that Made is at now, he made the Opening Day roster.
I don’t think that’s likely in this case, and certainly will not happen if no long-term extension is in place, like there was for Chourio. But Made isn’t far off, which means the team is probably going to be probing around on trade interest in Ortiz and Hamilton, just in case. Those two guys aren’t the kinds of players who are going to make a bad team good, but they are certainly the types of players who will make good teams better; smart teams should absolutely be interested if the Brewers are shopping them.
Outfield
Once again, on the surface, this seems pretty straightforward: the Brewers have Chourio and Luis Lara on long-term contracts, and Garrett Mitchell and Sal Frelick are both in arbitration seasons on affordable deals; Mitchell is under control for two more seasons, Frelick for three.
Ideally, the Brewers would love more production in right field. Frelick had a poor season, and Lara struggled with the bat after coming up. But Pat Murphy loves Frelick and he really does seem to be an integral part of this team’s chemistry, and there’s no reason not to expect at least a modest bounceback in 2027, his age-27 season. Perhaps he won’t get to his 2025 levels, when he had a 111 OPS+, but I’m sure he can eat into the nearly-60-point drop in batting average and OBP that occurred in 2026.
Lara figures to improve as well, as he gets used to major-league pitching. His offensive outbreak at Triple-A Nashville was something to see: he hit as many home runs (9) in 78 games with the Sounds last season as he had in his first three minor-league seasons combined. That power dried up in the majors, though, where his only home run in 212 plate appearances came off a position player. He may never be much of an offensive plus, but with his defensive prowess, he’ll offer plenty of value if he can get up to league average, particularly if he moves to center field in the next couple of years.
Chourio and Mitchell are both primed for big seasons. Chourio could certainly vault himself into MVP discussions next year, and Mitchell, if he’s healthy, seems to be a lock for at least 3-ish WAR, with some potential remaining for a breakout season in there given how he always seems to make solid contact.
Health will always remain a question with Mitchell, but the Brewers figure to be covered if he, or anyone else in their outfield, goes down. Brandon Lockridge remains under team control, but the more intriguing possibility is that of Josh Adamczewski, who put up some crazy numbers in 50 games High-A Wisconsin before moving up to Double-A, where he had a 125 wRC+ at just 21 years old. He looks like a real find, and while the Brewers will certainly want him to get some reps in Triple-A, he could be ready to fill a major-league role by mid-season if the need arises.
Starting Pitchers
This young group looks to be in a solid position headed into 2026, particularly with Quinn Priester primed to return from his surgery to correct his thoracic outlet syndrome. Dustin May, acquired at the trade deadline, is a free agent. That means the Brewers, barring injuries, will have this group to choose from:
- Unanimous NL Cy Young winner Jacob Misiorowski, who threw 174 2/3 innings in the regular season and 19 more in the postseason
- Logan Henderson, who had a 2.47 ERA in 98 1/3 regular season innings and threw 12 more innings in the postseason
- Robert Gasser, who threw 109 1/3 innings in the regular season and 15 more in the playoffs, where he had a 0.60 ERA in three starts
- Kyle Harrison, whose second half went poorly but who looked like a co-ace in the first half (he threw a total of 115 2/3 innings in 2026)
- Priester, who when last healthy in 2025 went 13-3 with a 3.32 ERA in 157 1/3 innings
- Shane Drohan and Chad Patrick, who will likely return to swingman roles
- Brandon Sproat, who will probably start the season at Triple-A Nashville trying to figure things out, and Coleman Crow and Colton Gordon, further depth options who will also presumably be in Nashville to start the season
- A wildcard option like Aaron Ashby, about whom we heard whispers that he could be in the running for a rotation spot. I’ll always be skeptical of reports like this, especially when it doesn’t seem to be a major need, but anything can happen
That’s a solid, solid group, but it does lack something: every single pitcher on this list is 28 years old or younger. There’s not a ton of experience, and while I’m not convinced that experience is all that important to winning baseball games (the Brewers were rather short on experience in their pitching options during their dominant World Series run in 2026), it would be kind of nice to have another guy around who you could reasonably hope to get 150-ish innings out of, just to take some pressure off of the younger arms.
Bullpen
Bullpens are notoriously hard to predict, but here’s where the Brewers are at:
- Trevor Megill is a free agent after the 2027 season and it’s certainly not off the table that he gets traded—Jeff Passan reported that Milwaukee will listen on offers.
- Abner Uribe is under team control for four more seasons and has a career 2.20 ERA in 179 2/3 innings. He figures to be a major part of the bullpen for several more years.
- Ashby made a star turn during the postseason, and figures to again play a major role.
- DL Hall also pitched well in the postseason and had a really solid regular season—he should play a big part in 2026 if he stays healthy. He’s entering his first year of arbitration.
- Trade deadline acquisitions JoJo Romero and Antonio Senzatela are both free agents. Romero likely pitched himself into a nice contract during the postseason; Senzatela figures to be on the cheaper side, and it’s possible the Brewers bring him back.
- Ángel Zerpa, who the team acquired in a trade before the 2026 season, had Tommy John surgery in May and could be an option in the second half of the season.
- Grant Anderson is still around, and will likely make the team, given the relative lack of right-handed options, particularly if Senzatela is not back.
- We could see an option from the minor leagues: 25-year-old Cameron Wagoner was awesome in 33 appearances between Double- and Triple-A last season, and one of the team’s more highly regarded pitching prospects, Tyson Hardin, could possibly get some relief work in the majors later in the season, even if he’s viewed as a starter in the long term.
If you assume Megill is back, then I’d say you can consider the Brewers have 12 locks for the Opening Day roster amongst their pitchers: Misiorowski, Henderson, Gasser, Priester, Harrison, Drohan, Patrick, Ashby, Megill, Uribe, Hall, and Anderson. Of course, the likelihood that all 12 of those guys are healthy when the season starts is low. That means there’s room here if the Brewers want to explore the free agent market, though we all know the most likely move is that they’ll acquire someone in some tiny trade who we’ve never heard of who then adds a cutter and turns out to be quite good.
Conclusion
Barring unexpected moves (like what would be a shocking trade of Contreras, or an extension for Made and trade of Ortiz or Hamilton), the lineup looks pretty set everywhere except first base, where Andrew Vaughn will likely welcome a new platoon partner this season. There’s probably a spot in the bullpen up for grabs, and it’s not out of the realm of possibility that there could be an addition in the rotation. But it’s also definitely possible that every opening on the roster at the moment is filled internally. Don’t expect a busy offseason at the major-league level for the Brewers.





























