Our favorite J.P. Crawford moments

ANAHEIM, CALIFORNIA - SEPTEMBER 16: J.P. Crawford #3 of the Seattle Mariners smiles during the seventh inning against the Los Angeles Angels at Angel Stadium of Anaheim on September 16, 2026 in Anaheim, California. (Photo by Melina Pizano/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Unless something big changes, J.P. Crawford will not be a Mariner in 2027. It’s a sad ending considering how the 2026 Mariners went out; Crawford told the media in his season postmortem that he felt like, as one of the de facto team captains, he failed, despite what his teammates had to say about him in their own autopsy interviews. So let’s take a moment to celebrate, instead, our favorite J.P. Crawford moments. Please hop into the comments and leave your own favorites.

If you’re looking for more, here are some of our favorite J.P.-centric pieces of writing we’ve had on the site over the past eight years:

Kate: signing the camera after his walkoff

The post-Griffey pre-J.P. Mariners didn’t just suffer a playoff drought; they suffered a drip drought. J.P. brought color to the Mariners like Dorothy stepping into Oz, from his purple cleats to his rasta bat wrap to the gold beads studding his (always impeccable) dreads.

After a two-run walkoff single to defeat the Rangers in Game 159 in 2023, keeping the Mariners’ slim playoff hopes alive [ed. note from ZAM: this hit had the greatest cWPA of any regular season plate appearance in team history], Crawford delivered what I would argue is the most electric postgame interview in Mariners history, helicoptering around his dreads to shakeout the walkoff shower, exhorting the crowd with an epic F-bomb, and then signing the camera, winking on his way into the dugout.

Everything about this moment is so quintessentially J.P., from his dripping-wet dreads to his untucked shirt to dropping an F bomb on TV to the saucy little wink at the end.

Speaking of those dripping-wet dreads, this was also the walkoff celebration that gave us one of the most epic, memorable shots by the incomparable Steph Chambers – I only have a still but Steph published this as a series of photos that work as a gif that’s truly spectacular. There are so many great J.P. walkoff moments it could be its own article, but this one, to me, is the peak J.P. walkoff moment.

It’s important to remember Crawford didn’t come to Seattle this swagged-out. Phillies-era J.P. was dreadless, more buttoned-up, baby-faced and closer to the high schooler he was when the Phillies drafted him 16th overall. It was in Seattle that he grew into the player, team leader, and father he is now, his external glow-up matching his internal one. Signing the camera felt like a love note to all of us – the fans, his family, his former and future selves.

Eric: Saying goodbye to two Mariners legends

I’m tempted to pick from his best plays at shortstop, but an enduring memory I have of J.P. is how the look on his face during Felix’s last mound visit was such a soft moment of understanding. 

And then two seasons later, his heart-rendering tears for Kyle Seager, the man he called his captain, during Seager’s final curtain call. 

Somewhere during and in between those two moments, it felt to me like something was set in stone for J.P, and for many Mariners fans: J.P. was going to stop at nothing to drag this team back to the playoffs. For the fans, for his teammates past and current, and for himself. Hats off to a player who found a new home, became a leader, and went out as the heart and soul of the Mariners teams of the 2020’s.

Ryan: Captain Clutch

If you were to have looked up the best batters in “high leverage” at this time last year, you would have found J.P. Crawford in the top 10 by wRC+ this century. After a down year in 2026, he’s now merely 34th on that leaderboard with a 142 wRC+ in high leverage, alongside names like Alex Rodriguez and Larry Walker. Regardless of the exact placement, Crawford’s tenure in Seattle was marked by big moments at the plate.

Perhaps none was bigger than his walkoff home run on Aug. 1, 2025. The Mariners were in second place, having wandered aimlessly out of the All-Star break. They were essentially tied with the Rangers entering the series. With the Mariners down 3-2 in the bottom of the ninth, Dominic Canzone led off with a single to bring the winning run to the plate. 

T-Mobile Park, of course, knew this well. They rained down the chants for “J! P! J! P!” and only grew louder as Crawford got ahead in the count 2-0. Then he got his pitch, the one he always seemed to hunt against lefties: a fastball on the inner third. Crawford leaned on it and crushed it out to right. Seattle went ballistic. 

The walkoff began what would eventually be the best homestand in team history. The Mariners took the four-game set from the Rangers, then swept the White Sox, then swept the Rays on Ichiro weekend. It was the most enjoyable baseball the Mariners have played in my lifetime, and it was probably the most crucial, as it ultimately secured the AL West. It all started with a moment from Captain Clutch himself.

John: Sliding and Soaring

J.P. Crawford’s achievements in Northwest Green have often been individual, as baseball demands. The bat flip big flies, the diving plays, the marathon plate at bats. But the man who brought Mr. Rager back for the 2025 stretch run has shined most as a member of a team. And the moment he will evoke most for me is Game 161, 2021. It’s not his most impactful hit as a Mariner, which likely was the similarly-quintessential blooper in Game Two of the AL Wild Card series to clear the bases, decimate George Springer and Bo Bichette, and stun the favored Toronto Blue Jays. It’s not even his hit, as he’d been intentionally walked to load the bases two batters prior. A Ty France fielder’s choice had forced the M’s against the wall, needing to win to stay alive and having seen Paul Sewald uncharacteristically blunder the 8th inning 3-1 lead into a 4-3 deficit against the Angels.

I don’t need to describe the play. The drama. The ebullient Dave Sims unfolding the fine china as he does in the biggest moments to will Haniger’s single through the left side. Bauers scores. J.P. scores. J.P. soars.

This is J.P. Crawford to me. Sliding into home for the most important run of the season, popping in a single motion into a jump of jubilation. J.P. Crawford’s game was, at its best, a remarkable exercise in control. He makes great swing decisions. He makes mostly soft and medium contact, ambushing a pitch only here and there when he’s laid the trap just right. At his best, Crawford was like Kyle Seager, not the rangiest or the rocket-armed, but a player whose mechanics and athleticism were honed to a magnet for his teammate’s gloves.

And yet, the fervor was always clear. The care. The choice to sign an extension and stay, the effort on good days and frustration in the difficult ones. If you could imbue a baseball playing style in a child, you couldn’t do much better than Crawford’s as a Mariner. He gave it his all. He found ways to adapt at the plate and improve. He volunteered to move positions to help the team. And if there is one more image for Crawford, one which at last surpassed futile Games 161, it is a celebration set at home once more.

Isabelle: The Victory Dance

Will there be a victory dance next season? Born out of that young, drought-busting 2022 team, it’s become as much a part of a Mariners win as the echo of fireworks throughout T-Mobile Park. To my knowledge, there’s never been confirmation of a singular composer, but the first iteration of the infield win dance came in the first win after J.P.’s suspension. Hardly seems to be a coincidence, particularly not as you watch the stilted shuffling of his infield compatriots compared to Crawford, beaming with his shoulders thrust confidently back.

(Pardon the Tommy Milone jump scare.) 

This piece could have been an unwieldy tome of a thing, so entangled is J.P. in every high and low and silliness of this decade of Mariners baseball. But the dance, to me, encapsulates the magic of watching him in Seattle for all these years; the levity and discipline, and the steadfast commitment to coming together as a team. This is a goodbye that aches deep in the soul, in that chunk of your being that you’ve given over in exchange for loving this game.

James: Delivering the dagger

In the penultimate week of the 2025 regular season, the Mariners were visiting Houston for a pivotal series that would swing the division title odds in favor of the victor. Having taken the first two games already, the M’s were in firm control of first place but were looking to deal what would effectively amount to a final blow for their tormentors of the previous decade. No Mariners fan was going to be comfortable until the division title was entirely locked up, and dropping the series finale might have left a tiny glimmer of hope for the Astros.

What Crawford did in the third game of the series didn’t clinch the Mariners’ first AL West title since 2001, but it came pretty close. In the second inning, with the Mariners already up a run, J.P. launched a no-doubt grand slam into the right field seats at Daikin Park to open up a near-insurmountable lead in both the game and the division.

The Mariners would win the game, decisively sweeping the series in front of a stunned Houston crowd and a national TV audience on Sunday Night Baseball. They would go on to clinch the division in their following game back in Seattle. It’s only fitting that Crawford would be the one to deliver the dagger — he was one of the first acquisitions at the beginning of the rebuild in 2019 and grew into an unofficial team captain role as the Mariners built back up. Would the Mariners still have won the division without the grand slam? Probably. But the symbolism and catharsis of the moment cannot be denied. I will always look back on it fondly.

Jake: A Menace Against the Astros

Ryan and James already mentioned it above but J.P. had a penchant for dramatics in high-leverage situations. For me, the most memorable of those high stakes moments always seemed to come against the Astros. There was his home run off Justin Verlander in Game 1 of the 2022 ALDS, his game-tying three-run double during that wild series in May 2023, the grand slam James wrote about above, and his walk-off single during the four-game sweep back in April.

Looking at his splits against opponents, he slashed .249/.356/.363 against Houston through his career, a tOPS+ of 104. He hit six home runs against the ‘Stros, his second highest total against any opponent. Those aren’t wildly impressive overall numbers, but it seemed like he made it count when the game was on the line. I will always appreciate J.P. for his efforts to bring down the M’s most hated rival.

Bee: Fundamental, Throw and Through

My absolute favorite J.P. moment now is exactly the one Kate chose, and for all of the reasons stated. There was a before favorite moment, however. Before all of the clutch hits and hype aura moments, we had The Throw.

It’s an impressive play just from the effort of the moment alone. A diving stop down the line towards third, with a jump throw that perfectly finds its target. What makes it most impressive to me is the no-look aspect of it though. That moment was only achievable because Crawford clearly had practiced the fundamentals to the point of muscle memory. An infield player, especially a shortstop, needs to be hyper aware of their field position at all times. In relation to the ball, in relation to the runner, and in relationship to all three bases. To go from diving the other direction, to a one-foot, mid-air, no-look jump throw that arcs perfectly to first? It’s the equivalent of a turnaround no-look jump shot three pointer in basketball, only with having to pick yourself off the court first.

Nothing in particular about that moment held any lasting significance for the team, except for all the ways it showed us exactly what we would see in Crawford for these seven years since. A player who embraced the fundamentals of the sport both on and off the field, who during his tenure was likewise fundamental to their success.

Zach: J.P. Crawford is our shortstop

When the Mariners reimagined the roster after 2018, it began with an exercise in which every member of Jerry’s brainstrust was given a piece of paper with 25 blank lines on it. The only name that every single person wrote down was J.P. Crawford’s. A former top prospect who’d struggled to establish himself in the big leagues was in danger of drowning in the waters of Philadelphia’s merciless fan base, and J.P., who was still a young man, found himself in “a dark place.” But after signing an extension with the Mariners before the first home game of 2022, J.P. told Ryan Divish that “getting traded was the best thing that ever happened to me.”

In April 2023, he made his first trip back to Philadelphia, and the fans were not happy to see him. They booed him throughout the first game. But in his first at-bat of Game 2, he sent the ball flying 420 feet, one of the longest of his career, and he did it with the bases loaded. It was his only home run I ever got to see in person. The crowd booed him all around the bases, but he couldn’t have looked happier.

This was the memory that came to mind when I saw J.P. in that letterman’s jacket at the 50th Season Celebration this August. He deserved that honor and probably deserves to be in the Mariners Hall of Fame; he ends his Mariners career in the top 10 in franchise history in games played, walks, runs scored, walk-off hits, and assists. He was a Seattle Mariner, damn it. He came up in Philly but grew up here, and thousands of Northwesterners wear his jerseys with pride. In the meme, the emphasis is either on “J.P. Crawford” or on “shortstop.” But to me, the most important word there is “our.” J.P. Crawford was our shortstop.

The Curious Case of Ryan Walker

PHOENIX, ARIZONA - JULY 01: Relief pitcher Ryan Walker #74 of the San Francisco Giants walks off the field after a pitching change in the eighth inning against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Chase Field on July 01, 2026 in Phoenix, Arizona. The Giants defeated the Diamondbacks 6-4. (Photo by Chris Coduto/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Earlier this week, the Brewers acquired right-handed reliever Ryan Walker from San Francisco in what Brew Crew Ball’s own Paul Dietrich called a “classic Brewers move.” Walker was reportedly set to be designated for assignment this offseason before the Brewers swooped in, sending two minor league pitchers (28-year-old reliever Blake Holub and 2026 11th-round pick Gavin Perry) to acquire him.

So why would the 65-win Giants move on from Walker, a high-leverage reliever in 2024 and 2025? Simple: he fell off a cliff in 2026, posting a 7.16 ERA and 5.52 FIP in 32 2/3 innings in between Triple-A stints.

While he was still serviceable in 2025, that season already brought up some red flags; namely, Walker’s ERA more than doubled, although his FIP (3.30) suggested that things were still mostly good under the hood. Walker himself attributed his decline in 2025 to mechanical issues, telling reporters that he believed he was “over-rotating” during his unique crossfire delivery, causing issues commanding his sweeper. He’s a two-pitch pitcher (sinker and sweeper), so being able to throw both pitches for strikes is paramount to his success; if he can only locate one pitch, hitters can sit on it and tee off.

Most articles written about Walker echo Walker himself, chalking his decline up to continued control issues that have made it easier for hitters to sit on pitches in the zone. When you look at his walk rate in 2026 (12.3%), it’s easy to come to that conclusion, but the advanced stats paint a more complicated picture.

Walker’s edge rate (42.4%) and first-pitch strike rate (62.1%) both improved from 2025, showing that his command did, in fact, get better. It’s not like he couldn’t find the zone last year. The bigger problem was that hitters stopped chasing and stopped swinging and missing at his pitches.

Chase Rate by Season:

2024: 29.2%

2025: 26.1%

2026: 24.9%

Whiff Rate by Season:

2024: 28.6%

2025: 21.6%

2026: 14.9%

These stats don’t show a pitcher who lost his ability to find the zone; they show a pitcher whose stuff stopped fooling hitters. Walker did walk far more hitters in 2026, and some of that is simple math, since pitches just off the plate become balls when hitters stop chasing. But his zone rate also fell (52.9% to 49.9%), as did his meatball rate (9.6% to 8.2%), which suggests he may have been pitching around hitters rather than trusting his stuff in the zone.

So, why did his stuff stop fooling hitters?

The sweeper actually gained nearly two inches of sweep (horizontal break), and his sinker has kept roughly the same shape since 2024, save for an extra inch of arm-side run. Unless the increase in movement has made the pitches easier to identify, it stands to reason that it’s not the shape of the pitches that has made them more hittable.

One potential contributing factor is velocity. Although Walker’s velocity hasn’t exactly cratered, both pitches have gotten slightly slower: the sinker dropped 0.5 mph and the sweeper 0.7 mph. Still, that’s not a big enough drop to be the whole reason.

The more compelling explanation is that Walker became predictable. His sinker usage climbed from 54.7% in 2024 to 65.2% in 2026, while sweeper usage fell from 44.8% to just 30.7%. It’s very, very hard to be successful when you’re throwing the same pitch almost two-thirds of the time and you only have one other pitch.

This conclusion is also supported by the advanced stats; in 2024, hitters made contact on fewer than half of the pitches they chased (49.4%). By 2026, it was nearly three-quarters (73.7%). His zone contact rate also increased nearly 10 percentage points, from 80.6% in 2024 to 89.7% in 2026.

It’s also worth mentioning that Walker’s 2026 season was worse than his expected stats would suggest. While his ERA was an astronomically high 7.16, his xERA was only 4.45; bad, but not “DFA him” bad. Some of that may have had to do with the Giants’ defense, which was pretty bad last year. Also, he was way worse against lefties (2.70 WHIP) than righties (1.41), and lefties did most of their damage against his sinker (-3 run value vs. -1 against righties). That’s a usage fix the Brewers can make immediately.


In short, the stats show that there’s still something to work with, making this a “classic Brewers” pitching lab reclamation project. It didn’t cost much to get Walker, and the Brewers will have some work to do (tinker with his pitch selection, maybe add a third pitch, and make sure that mechanical inconsistencies no longer remain), but they’ve done this before.

The nearest example might be Rob Zastryzny. Zastryzny leaned on a sweeper that worked as a chase pitch but struggled against opposite-handed hitters, so he added a cutter that he could throw in the zone (as detailed in Brewer Fanatic). A similar fix could be in order for Walker, who has played around with both a four-seamer and a changeup before. A four-seamer would give hitters a different look up in the zone, while a changeup would give him something slower that fades away from lefties. Either one would make his sinker and sweeper less predictable.

So, keep an eye on Walker in spring training. There are three things to watch: whether he adds a third pitch (or at least throws the sweeper more), whether his whiff rate rebounds, and whether his walk rate comes back down. Any of those would be a good sign that the Brewers are getting something closer to 2024 Walker than 2026 Walker.

2026 SnakePit Awards, Game of the Year: 7/19, From Funeral to Fiesta

PHOENIX, ARIZONA - JULY 19: Max Kepler #22 of the Arizona Diamondbacks celebrates with teammates after hitting a walk off RBI double against the St Louis Cardinals during the tenth inning at Chase Field on July 19, 2026 in Phoenix, Arizona. Diamondbacks won 8-7. (Photo by Norm Hall/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The voting

Voting for this was pretty interesting. It initially looked like Waldy’s walk-off versus the Cubs was going to prevail. But then the 1-0 bullpen shutout roared back into contention, before overcoming the seven-run deficit mounted a challenge on the rails. At one point, indeed, there was a three-way tie between those contests, and I was unsure what to do. Fortunately, I got distracted yesterday by non-tenders and the Oviedo trade. By the time I’d got back to check, somebody had cast a deciding ballot, to give the 7-run deficit victory by a single vote. So, whoever that last person to vote was… it’s all on you!

Below is how voting ended, at the point I deleted the poll, because I needed to start writing up the damn article! I note that all six candidates received at least one one, and I’m not sure we’ve ever had many categories won with a figure as low as 26% of votes. Goes to show the lack of clear contenders in this category, though I am pleased that, unlike 2025, we did not also need to have an additional category for Loss of the Year! Anyway, with all that said, onto the game!

Digging the hole

This was only the second time in franchise history the D-backs had come back from a deficit of seven runs, and you could argue this one was more dramatic. The previous occasion, in August 2022 (which, understandably, also won the Game of the Year category), the team’s Win Probability bottomed out at 2.7%, when the Phillies had the bases loaded with two outs in the top of the fourth, or when Josh Rojas grounded out to lead off the bottom half. But this year’s version had the seven-run deficit later, and Arizona’s WP was barely half that, at 1.4% as we went into the sixth inning. On the other hand, the 2022 version saw the D-backs score thirteen unanswered runs, rather than the bare minimum eight here.

It began with a rare stinker by Eduardo Rodriguez. Over his previous nineteen starts, he had a 2.29 ERA, and had gone less than five innings only once in that time. But tonight, he just didn’t have it, and couldn’t get through three frames. Rodriguez needed forty pitches to record two outs in the third before being lifted. The Cardinals sent eleven to the plate in the frame (including a pair of walks to future D-back, Lars Nootbaar), scoring five times. A two-run single off Philip Abner in the top of the fifth padded the score to 7-0. Though such was the state of the game by that point, that the additional pair of tallies only increased St. Louis’s win probability by 3.6 percent.

Fighting back

Things started to turn around for the Diamondbacks in the 6th. Three hits to start the frame got Arizona on the board, and they then took advantage of a lack of control from the Cardinals. The home side drew three walks, including two with the bases loaded, to make it 7-3. Sloppy defense helped Geraldo Perdomo to an inside-the-park homer in the seventh, a two-run “shot” that at 242 ft was Arizona’s shortest home-run in the Statcast era! A more conventional two-run home-run by Nolan Arenado in the eighth tied the game, and it remained there until the bottom of the tenth. With one out, Max Kepler doubled, scoring the Manfred Man for the wildest walk-off of the year.

While Kepler may have got the glory, let’s not forget the role played by Arizona’s bullpen pitching and defense. Philip Abner, Taylor Clarke, Ryan Thompson and Juan Morillo combined to throw 5.1 shutout innings, in a contest where every run mattered. It wasn’t easy. The Cards had men in scoring position in the 7th, 9th and 10th (obviously!) innings, but all were stranded. None was bigger than the tenth, when a lead-off hit gave St. Louis men on the corners with nobody out, and a renewed Win Probability of 67.7%. But Perdomo took full advantage of a base-running gaffe to turn a double-play, and that allowed Arizona to complete one of the greatest escapes in the history of the franchise.

What they said

  • “All the credit to the coaches. We didn’t have enough energy until the sixth — until we pissed off Mac (First Base Coach Dave McKay). After that, I think we got some energy, and things started getting better.” — Geraldo Perdomo
  • “Obviously, we needed it as a team. Just a well-fought game for us, just to come back like that was incredible. Arguably, our best win of the year, but just to see us — the way we fought and didn’t give in, we could have easily done that. We didn’t, so that was great.”— Nolan Arenado
  • “What a great team win. I watched player after player make a sacrifice, and a commitment to one another to go out there and win inches all over the field. When it seemed like we were flatlined, we just gave ourselves a little bit of life… Everybody from that point forward fought to win a baseball game, and that’s what is super inspiring to me.” — Torey Lovullo
  • “After spending most of the afternoon convincing everyone they were dead, the Diamondbacks objected vigorously once the burial arrangements had been finalized… For six innings, the Diamondbacks were left for dead. By the eighth inning, the deceased was sitting up in the gurney. By the tenth, it was walking around greeting fans.” — JustRonM guest recap
  • And if you want the very definition of “a roller-coaster of emotions”, read the comments in the Gameday Thread over the course of this one!

Extended highlights

Previous winners

Not “If” But “Who” — Today’s Hypothetical Sophie’s Choice

SACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA - SEPTEMBER 25: Henry Bolte #33 of the Athletics reacts after hitting a two-run triple in the bottom of the sixth inning against the Houston Astros at Sutter Health Park on September 25, 2026 in Sacramento, California. (Photo by Lachlan Cunningham/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The A’s know they have very limited ways to improve their starting rotation given the limitations their current home field, recent records, and still modest payroll create. They also know they won’t compete for anything until they vastly improve their pitching.

This dilemma gives the new front office one tempting but dangerous choice: to dip into their pool of talented position players in order to land a quality SP. This, of course, weakens the lineup and while at a glance the lineup looks “pretty good” in fact their away splits reflect that when not in a hitter’s paradise this group performed poorly, literally last in all of MLB in BA, OBP and OPS.

Some of this can be attributed to how many scrubs they wound up starting in place of injured players, but even when the full group was on the field they were about league average. So it’s unclear how wise it would be to subtract a key player from this group and some of it depends on how confident you are about the would-be replacement.

Here’s a breakdown of the A’s options as I see it, listed in alphabetical order.

Henry Bolte

Butler and Gelof have demonstrated how quickly a player can vacillate between “untouchable” and “afterthought” but it’s hard to imagine the A’s dealing Bolte and getting better when they have such difficulty attracting stars and could have one under their fingertips.

Bolte proved to be a true center-fielder, putting up impressive metrics in his rookie season (+5 DRS/+5 OAA) and his hitting appears to have only scratched the surface — yet his BA and OBP were excellent at .277 and .359. Bolte is also just 23 with 6 years of contract control left.

To trade Bolte would mean losing the only CFer they have who can hit a lick and the only true lead off hitter they have. Now would you trade that for an actual “ace”? Maybe so, but with still only 119 big league games under his belt Bolte is unlikely to bring back an ace. He would, however, garner quite a sizable return — and leave the A’s with a sizable gap in the outfield.

Lawrence Butler

Butler is the most enigmatic of the group having been arguably the worst player in MLB the first half of 2026 but turning it on to approximate the brilliance of 2nd half 2024 after the All-Star break (he batted .280/.357/.496, 130 wRC+).

As a result it’s honestly hard to assess what his trade value is. His contract, which has 5 years and $60M left on it, along with a $4M buyout, creates some liability and yet if he’s performing well it’s a very team friendly deal.

Still the contract, along with the huge swings in performance, lower Butler’s trade value considerably and so he’s not likely to return the A’s a quality SP in any deal. As a result he’s probably the wrong guy to move until he has a strong start to 2027 and rebuilds his value as being truly a 130 wRC+ type of hitter.

As far as replacements go, if you trade Butler he’s most likely being replaced soon by the up and coming Devin Taylor, who could well match Butler’s hitting and doesn’t have a huge bar to reach to match Butler’s fielding. So that part might be tempting if the A’s believe Taylor is close to being ready for the big leagues.

Zack Gelof

Gelof gets a fair amount of play in trade rumors, partly because one MLBTR writer predicted he would be the Yankees starting 3Bman in 2027 (just a throwaway line of a guess) and mostly because so many on AN had written him off, he was “good as gone” in a lot of people’s minds anyway.

What has emerged about Gelof is that he can excel defensively at multiple positions. He is a plus defender at 2B who acquitted himself very well at 3B, the position he was playing when the A’s drafted him. He also looked very solid in CF, so much so that if the A’s were to trade Bolte, Gelof would be a natural replacement for an every day gig. He was also good in LF when he wasn’t being attacked by vicious wires.

At the plate Gelof seemed to finally cure what ailed him. He’ll always strike out a bit but his .256/.322/.475 line was very comparable to his burst-onto-the-scene rookie season (.267/.337/.504). And his 24.6% K rate was the lowest of his career.

Because of his positional versatility and because his excellent defense means his bat doesn’t have to be spectacular for him to be a positive contributor, one can imagine teams are willing to give up a fair bit to acquire Gelof.

How much would the A’s miss Gelof if they used him to get a quality SP? Some of that depends on health because if you aren’t losing infielders and outfielders left and right you can probably do without a Gelof better than if you constantly need to slot a player in somewhere without missing a beat — something Gelof allows you to do because he has mastered so many positions.

His replacement would likely be Joshua Kuroda-Grauer in an every day role and Denzel Clarke forced to be the primary CFer if Bolte goes down. At some point, of course, Leo De Vries is expected to join the big leagues but his timeline was severely impacted by his shoulder surgery.

So with only Gelof, Wilson, Kuroda-Grauer currently in the 2B-SS-3B mix, the A’s infield really isn’t so deep as to be able to absorb a big loss until De Vries arrives.

Shea Langeliers

Langeliers’ name probably comes up the most here, possibly in part because his name has come up repeatedly in rumor mill/reporting sites like MLBTR. One of the obvious pluses is that Langeliers, considered one of the top overall catchers in the AL, would command a significant return with 2 full years still remaining on his contract.

The knee injury put a wrench in things. If the A’s were considering dealing him at last year’s trading deadline, those conversations were tabled when Shea went under the knife. He returned in September running like he never left so his trade value likely isn’t diminished by fears that he hasn’t returned to 100% health.

The biggest problem for the A’s is that they simply don’t have a replacement for a primary catcher, not now and not for a while. Cole Conn and Davis Diaz are both interesting and alliterative, but both profile not really as primary starting catchers so much as versatile part-time catchers. Conn is closer but to deal Langeliers is to accept a huge drop at the catcher position for the known future.

Langeliers is also not without fundamental flaws that could mitigate a ginormous return. While Shea is well regarded around the league, his blocking is well below average and though he was torrid with the bat in April and July, very good in May, he was also terrible in June and September.

That September line (.250/.294/.292) could be some cause for concern as he came back from a knee injury to slug just .292. But likely any team pursuing Langeliers would be prepared to give up the kind of quality SP (or SP prospect) the A’s are seeking. It’s just a matter of whether it’s worth it to weaken the catcher position so much.

Brent Rooker

Rooker is one of the A’s biggest clubhouse leaders and for that reason alone he is likely not being moved anytime soon. But he also may not have the kind of trade value he had after his spectacular 2024 season. Since then he has had an “ok” 2025, a disastrous start to 2026, and a season ending surgery.

Just as importantly, Rooker is a DH who plays the outfield like my Aunt Bertha plays the bass guitar. Keep in mind that my Aunt Bertha can’t even get her arms around the instrument and you’ll understand how bad Rooker is in the OF.

Teams are going to be rightly hesitant to presume Rooker’s bat will revert back to his 2024 prowess and he has no positional value. As a result he has more value to the A’s than he has trade value to other clubs. With his contract, recent performance, and recent injury, I very much doubt any team will dangle the kind of pitching the A’s covet.

Tyler Soderstrom

Soderstrom is a somewhat natural choice because he has generally performed when on the field, Taylor waits in the wings to replace a corner outfielder, and with a fair contract (6 years/$80M left) that has team control through at least 2032 his trade value should be high.

A big unknown, though, and one which could impact his trade value, is his outfield defense. Soderstrom was a gold glove finalist in his first year playing LF, but dropped considerably in 2026, from +10 DRS to +3 DRS and from +5 OAA to -8 OAA.

If the hip impingement is thought to be the sole cause and if Soderstrom is deemed to be 100% healthy going into 2027, perhaps teams will view him like a gold glove finalist. But the questions currently remain unanswered and there could be teams that want to see him perform for a couple months post-surgery before pulling the trigger on a sizable return.

There is also the reality that the A’s core is somewhat RH heavy with Rooker, Gelof, Langeliers, Bolte, Wilson, Clarke and Kuroda-Grauer all RH batters. Other than Soderstrom only Butler and Kurtz offer a LH bat. That being said, you know who else bats LH? Devin Taylor.

Jacob Wilson

Wilson is another core player often discussed on AN as a potential trade chip to acquire starting pitching. He was the starting shortstop in the 2025 All-Star game, is currently carrying an ongoing MLB record for consecutive errorless games at SS, is on a reasonable contract (6 years/$69M left plus a buyout), and probably has a lot of trade value.

Yet every day fans know that Wilson’s stubborn lack of plate discipline and limited range make him a flawed player as currently constituted. For all his talent Wilson had put up just an 83 wRC+ when he hit the IL for the season.

The idea of Wilson as a trade chip seemed more viable when Leo De Vries wowed everyone at spring training and looked like he was very much in line for a call up sometime in 2026. Then he had a finger injury followed by continued shoulder problems, had surgery on the shoulder and won’t be back even to the minors until around mid-May.

So similar to trading Gelof, moving Wilson means leaving the infield quite short-handed. The A’s do at least have a true SS in Kuroda-Grauer, but that leaves a hole somewhere on the infield at 2B or 3B. And that’s before any injuries.

How’s that for some in-depth analysis trying to be objective and not leaning in any particular direction. Reading through all this, is there one of these players you think the A’s should use as a chip to significantly bolster their rotation? Or should they stand pat with the core and add pitching in other ways?

Without question it’s a tough call for Taylor Smith and Cam Castro, with any trades needing to be made in November — or they may have to wait until March.

Are the Red Sox already better in 2027 than 2026?

We are still 10 days from the start of the lockout, but the Red Sox have already done plenty of mild impact wheelin’ and dealin’ in offseason roster moves. 

They’ll still have more to do on the other side of the lockout, but Boston has been productive in its work so far in November. To recap, here are the transactions you’ve missed or need to fully remember: 

ADDITIONS

Jake Bauers (Free agency – 4-year, $58 million deal) 

Nick Fortes (Trade) 

Kenya Huggins (Trade) 

Jack Pineda (Trade)

Luke Dotson (Trade)

SUBTRACTIONS

Sonny Gray (Free agent – 2-year deal with Twins) 

Connor Wong (DFA)

Raymond Burgos (Trade) 

Eduardo Rivera (Trade) 

Angel Roa (Trade) 

Angel Bastardo (Trade) 

Johan Oviedo (Trade)

Now, most of those were minor-league transactions to work out the 40-man roster – though keep an eye out for an eventual bullpen role for Huggins, who won Arizona Fall League Reliever of the Year recently. 

At the big-league level, the Red Sox have their designated hitter for the next four years in Bauers, the reigning NLCS MVP. His keen on-base abilities boost the belief that his breakout on the other side of age-30 is sustainable, with reasonable pop to the tune of 26 home runs and a .874 OPS this past season. Boston also upgraded the backup catcher spot with Fortes behind Adley Rutschman. The former Tampa Bay Ray has a solid defensive background and will produce with the bat at a higher level than Wong. While the finality of the disastrous Mookie Betts trade is here with the entire return gone from the Red Sox organization, Boston is a better team with this swap behind the dish. 

Losing Sonny Gray felt inevitable, but the Red Sox can still check off his successful one season in Boston as a success. They’d be better with him, but the ascension of Payton Tolle and a full healthy season of Garrett Crochet at the top of the rotation equal out the loss of the veteran right-hander. Boston should feel great – though top-loaded with southpaws – about the trio of Crochet, Tolle and Ranger Suarez leading the staff into 2027. 

There are plenty more decisions to make this winter before we can really make this verdict. But given the lineup struggles that derailed the conclusion to 2026, the Red Sox are already in a better situation for 2027. 

Secure the bullpen, trust a depth starter internally or externally, find a new home for Jarren Duran and act decisively at shortstop. Those moves will mark necessary change to translate into a meaningful step forward in 2027.

Gavin Sheets returns to San Diego Padres with $11 million, 3-year deal

Gavin Sheets is staying with the San Diego Padres after agreeing to an $11 million, three-year contract Friday.

Sheets signed a minor league deal with the Padres in February 2025, and the slugger has become a fan favorite and strong clubhouse leader in his two seasons with the club. He has hit 36 homers and driven in 119 runs with a .731 OPS as a key left-handed bat for San Diego while playing extensively at first base, in left field and as a designated hitter.

The 30-year-old Sheets gets a $500,000 signing bonus within 30 days of the contract’s approval by the commissioner’s office, and he will make $2.5 million in 2027. The contract has player options for 2028 and 2029 at $4 million apiece.

The deal also includes $1.5 million in annual performance bonuses. Sheets will get $250,000 for his 400th plate appearance in each season and an additional $250,000 for every 50 plate appearances up to 650.

Twins deal once-prized prospect Royce Lewis to Dodgers for pitcher Bobby Miller and minor leaguer

MINNEAPOLIS — The Minnesota Twins traded infielder Royce Lewis, the first overall pick in the 2017 amateur draft, to the Los Angeles Dodgers on Friday for right-handed pitcher Bobby Miller and minor league catcher Francisco Espinoza.

Lewis, drafted as a shortstop out of JSerra Catholic High School, has struggled with injuries and inconsistency at the plate in the major leagues. He will return to his Southern California roots for a fresh start in the National League.

Lewis batted a career-low .227 in 2026 with 15 home runs, 57 RBIs and 130 strikeouts in 463 at-bats. Fully healthy for essentially the first time as a big leaguer after knee injuries had set him back earlier in his career, Lewis lost his swing and was sent to Triple-A for two weeks in late May.

He moved from third base to second to first as the Twins tried different infield combinations, but with Brooks Lee, Kaelen Culpepper, Luke Keaschall and Kody Clemens, the team now has more reliable hitters at every spot around the diamond.

The 27-year-old Lewis, in his second season of salary arbitration eligibility, batted .246 over 383 games with 61 homers for the Twins since debuting in 2022.

The 27-year-old Miller, who made 22 starts for the Dodgers in 2023 in his major league debut but has been hampered by multiple injuries since, appeared in only three games for the club in 2026. The 2020 first-round draft pick could give the Twins a needed boost in the bullpen. They signed starting pitcher Sonny Gray this week to bolster a deep rotation.

Espinoza, 19, batted .317 in 46 games for two Dodgers farm clubs in 2026, finishing with Class A Ontario.

The Twins on Friday also declined to offer a 2026 contract to right-handed starting pitcher Bailey Ober and corner outfielders Trevor Larnach and Matt Wallner. Ober and Larnach were in their final year of arbitration eligibility.

Ober made 139 starts over the last six seasons for the Twins, going 7-7 with a 4.47 ERA over 131 innings in 2026. He became more expendable in the rotation when the Twins signed Gray.

Larnach was Minnesota’s first-round draft pick in 2018. He hit .269 with 13 homers and a .788 OPS in 383 at-bats in 2026, his third season as a regular in the lineup, but the Twins had an excess of left-handed-hitting outfielders. Larnach also recently had a cleanup wrist surgery.

Wallner began last season as the regular right fielder but was sent to Triple-A with a .167 batting average and did not return.

The Twins agreed to 2027 contracts with right-handed relievers Tommy Nance and Cole Sands, avoiding arbitration.

Former Rookie of the Year Luis Gil and 2023 All-Star Josiah Gray among 44 non-tender free agents

Former AL Rookie of the Year Luis Gil was cut loose by the New York Yankees, among 44 players who became free agents when their teams declined to offer 2027 contracts by Friday’s tender deadline.

A 28-year-old right-hander, Gil was voted the American League’s top rookie in 2024 after going 15-7 with a 3.50 ERA in 29 starts. With a four-seam fastball that averaged 96.6 mph, he struck out 171 in 151 2/3 innings but walked a major league-high 77.

Sidelined by a lat strain for much of 2025, he went 4-1 with a 3.32 ERA in 11 starts. Gil spent much of 2026 in the minors and was sidelined by right shoulder inflammation, going 1-2 with a 4.61 ERA in four starts and five relief appearances for the Yankees.

He had a $2,162,500 salary this year and would have been eligible for arbitration.

New York also chose not to offer a contract to reliever Fernando Cruz. The 36-year-old right-hander didn’t pitch after Aug. 25 because of a partially torn ulnar collateral ligament. He said he would try to return from the injury without surgery.

Cruz went 4-6 with a 3.13 ERA and two saves in 61 appearances last season. He struck out 67 batters and walked 32 in 54 2/3 innings.

Washington right-hander Josiah Gray, a 2023 All-Star, also was cut loose. Gray, who turns 29 next month, was limited to two games in 2024 because of a torn ulnar collateral ligament, then was limited to three September appearances this year because of a right flexor strain. He had been designated for assignment on Tuesday.

Others non-tendered included St. Louis infielder Nolan Gorman, Cleveland outfielder/infielder/catcher David Fry, Minnesota outfielder Trevor Larnach and right-hander Bailey Ober, Seattle outfielder Luke Raley, Toronto outfielder Davis Schneider, San Diego left-hander JP Sears, Los Angeles Dodgers right-hander Jake Cousins, Tampa Bay right-hander Cole Sulser and Philadelphia outfielder Bryan De La Cruz.

All those players would have been eligible for arbitration had they been offered contracts but instead joined a market that included 183 players who became free agents after the World Series.

Among players facing the tender deadline, first baseman/outfielder Gavin Sheets agreed to an $11 million, three-year contract with San Diego that allows him to earn $1.5 million annually in performance bonuses for plate appearances. The 2028 and 2029 seasons are $4 million player options that give him the right to terminate the deal and become a free agent.

Players tendered contract offers

Thirty-five players agreed to one-year contracts:

  • Baltimore right-hander Felix Bautista ($2.3 million).
  • Boston second baseman Romy Gonzalez ($1.65 million plus $25,000 performance bonuses each for 300 and 350 plate appearances), infielder Andrew Monasterio ($1.4 million), outfielder Eli White ($1,325,000 plus $25,000 performance bonuses each for 200, 250 and 300 plate appearances) and second baseman Jahmai Jones (the higher of $950,000 or the 2027 minimum plus $150,000).
  • Chicago Cubs catcher Joey Bart ($2.53 million).
  • Cleveland right-handers Colin Holderman ($2,175,000) and Matt Festa ($1.5 million), and outfielder Blake Perkins (non-guaranteed at the higher of $950,000 or the 2027 minimum plus $150,000, with a $500,000 salary while in the minor leagues).
  • Houston shortstop Nick Allen ($1.95 million) and left-hander Bennett Sousa ($1.26 million plus $20,000 performance bonuses each for 30 and 40 innings).
  • Kansas City right-hander Randy Dobnak ($1.35 million).
  • Angels outfielders Jose Siri ($2.5 million) and Alex Call ($2,175,000), left-hander Taylor Saucedo ($1.3 million) and right-hander Sam Bachman (the higher of $1.05 million or the 2027 minimum plus $140,000).
  • Miami left-hander Andrew Nardi (the higher of $900,000 or the 2027 minimum plus $100,000).
  • Milwaukee infielder Joey Ortiz ($2,525,000), left-handers Angel Zerpa ($1,195,000) and DL Hall (the higher of $1,037,500 or the 2027 minimum plus $237,500) and right-handers Ryan Walker (the higher of $1.1 million or the 2027 minimum plus $330,000) and Grant Anderson (the higher of $925,000 or the 2027 minimum plus $125,000).
  • Minnesota right-handers Cole Sands ($1.19 million) and Tommy Nance ($925,000).
  • Mets left-hander Cionel Pérez ($1.95 million) and right-hander Austin Warren ($900,000).
  • Philadelphia outfielder Derek Hill ($1.4 million), left-hander Tanner Banks ($1.3 million), catcher Rafael Marchán ($900,000) and right-hander Jordan Leasure ($835,000).
  • Pittsburgh outfielder Akil Baddoo (non-guaranteed at the higher of $1 million or the 2027 minimum plus $200,000 in the major leagues, $488,557 in minors).
  • San Diego right-handers Jhony Brito ($810,000 in major leagues, of which $300,000 is guaranteed, $300,000 in minors) and Bryan Hoeing ($807,000 in major leagues, of which $403,5000 is guaranteed, $403,500 in minors).
  • San Francisco right-hander Camilo Doval ($6.3 million).
  • Texas catcher Logan O’Hoppe ($2.5 million plus performance bonuses of $100,000 each for 50, 100, 150 and 200 plate appearances and $125,000 apiece for 250 and 300 plate appearances).

Today in White Sox History: November 21

Bubblegum card (by the Bowman Gum Company) features baseball manager Paul Richards, of the Chicago White Sox, 1952.
On this day 118 years ago, managing legend Paul Richards was born. | (Photo by Transcendental Graphics/Getty Images)

1893
Ban Johnson is given control of the reorganized Western League, being named its president, secretary and treasurer. While a minor league in this moment, the WL would transform into the American League by 1900 and ascend to major league status in 1901. A year later, Charles Comiskey left the major league Cincinnati Redlegs to purchase the WL’s Sioux City Cornhuskers and move them to Minnesota as the St. Paul Saints.

The Saints would move to Chicago as part of the WL’s evolution into the AL and the majors. Throughout the early years of the American League, Comiskey was essentially the second lieutenant to Johnson in all matters AL.


1908
Former MLB catcher and clever manager Paul Richards was born, in Waxahachie, Texas. As a player, he was on World Series-winning teams to bookend his career, with the New York Giants in 1933 and Detroit Tigers in 1945. But after 17 years playing and nine managing in the minor leagues, in 1951 Richards got the call from White Sox GM Frank Lane to manage in Chicago, Thus began 17 straight winning seasons, as Richards’ leadership and innovation helped form the Go-Go White Sox.

Unable to get a contract extension/commitment from Lane during the 1954 season, Richards jumped at the chance to run the new Baltimore Orioles franchise as GM and manager.

In a very Tony La Russa 2020s move, new owner Bill Veeck, an admirer of Richards’ brought the manager back to helm the White Sox in 1976 — 15 years after last managing in the majors. It was a disastrous, 97-loss season, and had longer-term ramifications: Veeck asked ace skipper Chuck Tanner to step aside and coach third base for the White Sox during Richards’ return, after which Tanner would resume control of the White Sox. Tanner balked, took a job managing the A’s, and after that won the 1979 World Series with the Pittsburgh Pirates.


1969
Future Hall of Fame outfielder, and stretch-run addition to the 2008 White Sox playoff push Ken Griffey Jr. was born in Donora, Pa. His father, Ken Griffey, had just completed his first year of rookie ball in the Cincinnati Reds organization.

Junior would become one of the greatest center fielders in baseball history (sixth all-time by JAWS measure) but was at the end of his career when acquired by Ken Williams to fill Chicago’s hole in center. His average play (0.4 WAR over 41 games) was nonetheless an upgrade on incumbents Brian Anderson and Nick Swisher. But Griffey went just 2-for-10, with five strikeouts, in the ALDS loss to Tampa Bay.


1970
Luis Aparicio won his ninth and final Gold Glove award at shortstop. In his full career, Aparicio won Gold Gloves in half (nine of 18) the seasons he played; in the decades of the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s; and in seven of his 10 White Sox seasons.

Also that year, outfielder Tommie Agee won a Gold Glove with the Mets. Coupled with his 1966 award with the White Sox, Agee became the first player to win Gold Gloves in both leagues.


1983
Christmas came a month early for the White Sox, acquiring catcher Steve Christmas from the Reds for third baseman Fran Mullins.

Mullins hadn’t been in the majors since making his debut on the South Side during the 1980 season. Christmas would see action in 12 June and September games in 1984, during which the White Sox went just 1-11. He was released two weeks before Christmas 1984 — then signed again by the White Sox in January 1985. His remaining MLB career came in Grinch mode — three games with the Cubs in 1986.


2019
The White Sox announced to the baseball world that they were ready to move on to the next phase of their rebuild by signing All-Star free agent catcher Yasmani Grandal to a four-year deal worth $73 million — the largest in franchise history. 

Grandal was a rare catcher who combined both offensive power and excellent defensive skills, especially in framing pitches. Part of the reason the White Sox were so aggressive, in signing him before the Winter Meetings, was because of how he’d benefit the young White Sox pitching staff.

In the 2021 season Grandal, despite injuries to both knees, slugged 23 home runs, drove in 62 runs and walked 82 times in 93 games. He also tied the team record with eight RBIs in a single game, against the Cubs on August 27. But his final two years would be very poor, almost offsetting his 2021 stardom with -2.1 WAR over 217 games.

Mets sign A.J. Ewing to eight-year, $95 million extension

WASHINGTON, DC - SEPTEMBER 26: A.J. Ewing #9 of the New York Mets celebrates a home run during a baseball game against the Washington Nationals at Nationals Park on September 26, 2026 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Mitchell Layton/Getty Images) | Getty Images

According to SNY’s Chelsea Janes and others, the Mets have inked A.J. Ewing to an eight-year extension with a club option for the ninth year. The deal is reportedly for $95 million. This extension buys out all of Ewing’s arbirtration-eligible seasons as well as his first three years of free agency. According to Jon Heyman, Ewing will get a $2 million signing bonus, and there are ‘escalators’ that could increase the value of the deal.

This is the largest pre-arbitration extension the Mets have ever offered a player, surpassing their $55 million extension of David Wright in 2006.

Ewing, entering his age-23 season, made his big league debut on May 12 of this year, and essentially owned center field for the remainder of the season. While exhibiting excellent outfield defense, Ewing hit .252/.324/.376 with 25 stolen basses, 11 home runs, and 43 RBI in 120 games.

Dubbed one of the ‘psychopaths’ by Juan Soto along with Carson Benge, Ewing makes up two-thirds of an excellent defensive outfield with serious offensive potential as well. There are elements of his game, mainly his strikeouts, that definitely need improvement, but Ewing has already impressed enough with his ability on the field and his demeanor off the field for the Mets to feel confident in extending him this early into his career.

Ewing joins Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto as the only guaranteed contracts on the books after the 2028 season. That likely will change as more free agents sign, but it is a clear sign of the Mets’ belief in Ewing’s abilities.

Mets signing A.J. Ewing to eight-year, $95 million extension to lock up key outfielder

New York Mets center fielder A.J. Ewing (9) reacts after hitting a double in the first inning against the Kansas City Royals at Citi Field, Sunday, July 12, 2026, in Queens, NY.
New York Mets center fielder A.J. Ewing (9) reacts after hitting a double in the first inning against the Kansas City Royals at Citi Field, Sunday, July 12, 2026, in Queens, NY.

Mets fans can get used to seeing A.J. Ewing, who is set to play in Queens for a very long time.

Ewing has agreed to an eight-year extension, The Post confirmed, which buys out all of his arbitration years plus three free-agent seasons.

The deal, worth $95 million, also includes a ninth-year club option.

New York Mets center fielder A.J. Ewing (9) reacts after hitting a double in the first inning against the Kansas City Royals at Citi Field, Sunday, July 12, 2026, in Queens, NY. Corey Sipkin for the NY POST

The 22-year-old center fielder was a bright spot in a dark 2026, earning everyday playing time as a solid defensive outfielder with a .700 OPS and 25 steals.

More to come on this developing story…

Assessing the Tigers payroll in the wake of Troy Melton’s extension

Detroit Tigers CEO and Chairman Chris Ilitch, manager A.J. Hinch and President of Baseball Operations Scott Harris and talk during Spring Training Tuesday, February 21, 2023. Tigers9 022123 Kd3999 | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Co

While the deal isn’t fully official until the medicals are completed, the Detroit Tigers have come to terms with right-handed starting pitcher Troy Melton on a long-term extension offer. The deal reportedly guarantees Melton six years and $46.5 million, with incentives and a club option for the 2033 season that could take the contract to a total of $80 million over seven years.

This is a pretty smart decision from both the Tigers and the 25-year-old Melton. Our thoughts quickly turned to potential extensions for talented youngsters like Jackson Jobe and Max Clark. The club already has AL Rookie of the Year Kevin McGonigle, as well as infielder Colt Keith signed to long-term extensions. It will be interesting to see if the Tigers pursue extensions with their other talented young players prior to the December 1 lockout of the players by MLB owners. They don’t want to get stuck with too much guaranteed money on the books for the long haul, but at the same time these contracts are certainly very team friendly as long as the players involved produce as expected.

Our next thought was how this sets up the Tigers payroll for 2027. The Tigers entered the 2026 season with a payroll that was pushing towards the $244 million luxury tax threshold. However, after trading away three of their most expensive players in Tarik Skubal, Casey Mize, and Jake Rogers, all of whom were in their final year of arbitration eligibility prior to free agency, the final estimated Tigers payroll for 2026 came down to $195 million according to FanGraphs.

FanGraphs’ Roster Resource now estimates the Tigers’ 2027 Opening Day payroll at $169 million in the wake of Melton’s extension. That total would’ve put the Tigers 15th most in payroll in the major leagues in 2026, right in the middle. These are the salaries for their free agent deals and extensions on the books for 2027.

Framber Valdez – $47.5M

Javier Báez – $24M

Emilio Pagán – $11.5M

Kyle Finnegan – $10M

Drew Anderson – $8M

Troy Melton – $7.75M

Colt Keith – $4.77M

Kevin McGonigle – $2.75M

Jacob Waguespack – $1.3M

In addition, the Tigers do have a few arbitration eligible players estimated to make over $5 million in 2027. Riley Greene is estimated to earn $9.3 million, while Spencer Torkelson is estimated at $7.7 million for the 2027 season. Those two players are under team control for 2027-2028, and will then be free agents in 2029.

Zach McKinstry is estimated to make $5 million next season, while both Will Vest and Kerry Carpenter are estimated to make $4.4 million and $4.1 million, respectively.

So, looking forward to the rest of the offseason, the Tigers are still in fine shape to go make a big signing or just continue to build up their pitching staff and possibly hunt for a better bat in a part-time role. Ihey were willing to spend something like $240 million in 2026. That doesn’t mean they’re planning on keeping payroll that high year after year, but it seems likely they could add another $30-40 million in payroll this offseason and still be well short of their 2026 Opening Day payroll projection.

There’s room to spend. It’s more a question of a lack of major impact players that fit this offseason. Presumably there’s also some trepidation about signing any big free agent deals with so much up in the air this offseason. With the CBA negotiations and lockout coming, most teams would prefer certainty as to what the sports rules and payrolls are going to look like under the next CBA before making any huge commitments. Some teams will obviously make exceptions for Tarik Skubal and a handful of other top free agents, but the Tigers don’t seem like they’re going to be involved with those players.

Still it’s interesting to consider the Tigers payroll situation in light of the possibility that the owners do get their way and there’s a cap and floor instituted for 2028 as proposed. Under the owners’ most recent proposal, the floor would be $180.2 million against a hard cap of $258.2 million. Part of that would involve smaller market teams like the Tigers getting more in revenue sharing money, but actually being required to spend up to that $180.2 million level. Since the Tigers were willing to spend roughly $240 million for the 2026 season, with additional league revenue coming in they would likely be in a position to spend close to that level on a yearly basis going forward.

The Tigers have their second biggest annual salary coming off the books after 2027 as Javier Báez reaches free agency. That takes $24 million off the payroll heading into 2028. And, should Framber Valdez bounce back in year two in Detroit with a good season, there’s a fair chance he would choose to decline his 2028 player option with the Tigers, worth $35 million, and head back to free agency. A cap and floor system might have some impact on Valdez’s desire to return to free agency a year early as well. Even so, while the Tigers’ expenses will increase elsewhere as players get raises and then reach arbitration, there is plenty of money bound to come off the books in the next few seasons as well.

Obviously, this is speculative as there’s nothing to suggest the players are going to give the owners what they want in the CBA negotiations. Still, thinking through the general possibilities shows the Tigers in pretty good shape going forward whether a cap and floor system is put in place or not. They could clearly afford even a $400 million offer to Tarik Skubal if they thought that was the best way to allocate their payroll. With several talented younger players already locked up on long-term deals, minimal major commitments to older players, and with a still good farm system brewing up more major league talent to come, the Tigers future looks pretty bright if the front office can finally make the right moves to put them seriously into contention on a yearly basis.

Royce Lewis to the Dodgers

MINNEAPOLIS, MN - SEPTEMBER 27: Royce Lewis #23 of the Minnesota Twins celebrates as he rounds the bases after hitting a solo home run in the eighth inning during the game between the Texas Rangers and the Minnesota Twins at Target Field on Sunday, September 27, 2026 in Minneapolis, Minnesota. (Photo by Andrew Ritter/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images

The Los Angeles Dodgers acquired infielder Royce Lewis from the Minnesota Twins in exchange for pitcher Bobby Miller and minor league catcher Francisco Espinoza in a trade that was reported Friday.

This is an interesting deal to me, in that each team is moving on from a former first round pick and top prospect who has struggled both to stay healthy and to be productive in their time in the majors. Royce Lewis was the #1 overall pick in the 2017 draft out of San Juan Capistrano, California, while Miller was the 29th overall pick in the 2020 draft out of the University of Louisville, after having been picked in the 38th round of the 2017 draft by the Orioles and going unsigned.

Miller moved quickly through the minors, making it to AA in 2021 and splitting the 2022 season between AA and AAA. Heading into 2023, Miller was a consensus top 25 prospect in baseball. Ongoing shoulder issues have plagued Miller since then, however, and after putting up a 3.76 ERA in 22 starts for the Dodgers in 2023, he’s split his time between AAA, the majors, and the injured list the past three seasons. Miller threw only 24 innings between AAA and the majors in 2026 due to a shoulder injury that kept him out until late in the season.

Lewis was a consensus top 10 prospect in baseball after an impressive first full season as a professional split between low-A and high-A, though offensive struggles after that saw him slip a little bit in the prospect rankings before a torn ACL sidelined him for the entirety of the 2021 season, meaning he saw no official game action for two straight seasons, as the 2020 minor league season was eliminated due to the pandemic. He re-tore his ACL in 2022, costing him most of the season, and played in just 58 major league games in 2023 due to injuries, though his .309/.372/.548 slash line as a shortstop fueled the belief he was a star in the making if he could stay healthy.

Unfortunately, while Lewis’s games played per season increased each year thereafter, he still missed significant time due to injury, while his offensive performance slid. The past two seasons, Lewis has slashed .231/.285/.384 in 231 games while manning the corner infield spots.

It isn’t immediately clear where the Dodgers will look to play Lewis, given they currently have Freddie Freeman and Max Muncy in the corner infield spots, and Shohei Ohtani is the team’s DH. I’m guessing Lewis goes into a utility role of some sort, with the Dodgers presumably finding ways to get him into the lineup more often if they can get his bat back to where it was earlier in his career. The Twins, meanwhile, will try to keep Miller healthy, and see where best he fits.

Seeing Lewis dealt prompted me to go back and look at the 2017 draft, and I think it is fair to say that the top of the first round has been a disappointment. Here’s how it shakes out:

#1 — Royce Lewis, 4.9 bWAR. Unable to stay healthy, stopped hitting, traded.

#2 — Hunter Greene, 12.8 bWAR. Looked for a couple of seasons like a legitimate top of the rotation guy, but missed most of 2026 with elbow issues, and then had Tommy John surgery in August.

#3 — MacKenzie Gore, 7.2 bWAR. Tantalizing stuff, inability to actualize it, traded twice.

#4 — Brendan McKay, -0.1 bWAR. Supposed two-way player became solely a pitcher. Underwent Thoracic Outlet Syndrome surgery, then Tommy John surgery, then suffered a flexor tendon strain and torn UCL while on a rehab assignment after TJS. Now out of baseball.

#5 — Kyle Wright, 2.6 bWAR. Stud Vandy pitcher made it to the majors a year after being drafted, bounced between AAA and the majors the next three years, had a breakout 21 win season in 2022, threw just 45 innings between the majors and minors in 2023, and has thrown just 23 innings — all in the minors in 2025 — since due to injuries. Released by the Cubs this past summer without pitching for them in actual game action.

#6 — Austin Beck, N/A. Toolsy high school outfielder drafted by the A’s who didn’t hit, missed all of 2023 due to a torn ACL, and retired late in 2024 after 66 games at AA for the Dodgers.

#7 — Pavin Smith, 0.3 bWAR. First of two consecutive hitters taken from the University of Virginia. Spent parts of seven seasons with the D-Backs, mostly in a bench role. Currently a free agent.

#8 — Adam Haseley, 1.5 bWAR. Second of two consecutive hitters taken from the University of Virginia. Put up 1.8 bWAR as a rookie for the Phillies in 2019 in 67 games, driven largely by his defense. Played just 91 major league games thereafter, largely due to an inability to hit. Traded to the White Sox prior to the 2022 season, non-tendered after the 2023 season, hasn’t signed with anyone since and is presumably out of baseball.

#9 — Keston Huerta, 0.9 bWAR. Like Haseley, put up impressive numbers in a partial season in 2019 as a rookie, though in his case it was offense-driven, slashing .303/.368/.570 in 84 games for the Brewers. Has a .203/.389/.381 slash line in 218 games with a -1.0 bWAR since. Spent 2026 playing for Kiwoom in Korea.

#10 — Jo Adell, 1.3 bWAR. Underwhelming for the Angels from 2020-26, traded to the Guardians at the deadline in 2026 and slashed .244/.324/.417.

After that you had a nice run from #11-13 with Jake Burger, Shane Baz and Trevor Rogers. David Peterson, Tanner Houck and Brent Rooker highlight the rest of the first round, unless you count Drew Rasmussen, who was picked at #31 by the Rays but didn’t sign with them, presumably due to an elbow injury that necessitated Tommy John surgery a few months later. The Brewers ended up signing Rasmussen after taking him in the sixth round in 2018. Rasmussen’s career 15.7 bWAR is the highest of anyone taken in the first round in 2017.

The 2017 draft doesn’t get much better after the first round, incidentally. Daulton Varsho and Griffin Canning are the only players selected in the second round to amass at least 2.0 career bWAR this far. Taylor Walls, Connor Wong, Nick Allen, Keegan Thompson and Riley Adams are the 2+ bWAR guys from the third round, though Wong’s 4.2 bWAR is the second highest of the group. Ernie Clement is the only fourth rounder with a positive bWAR, and only three fourth round picks appeared in at least 30 games.

Only one fifth round pick from 2017 has a positive bWAR. You may have heard of him. He was the Rangers’ closer this year.

Former Phillies’ Hall of Fame chances – Part one: The cameos

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 04: Jake Arrieta #49 of the Philadelphia Phillies in action against the New York Mets at Citi Field on September 04, 2020 in New York City. The Phillies defeated the Mets 5-3. (Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The ballot for the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame was released this week, and there were seven players listed who spent time with the Phillies.

I’m going to take a look at each former Phillies and analyze whether I think they will get in and whether I think they should get in. I will tell you up front that I am an elitist when it comes to honors like retiring numbers and the Hall of Fame, so you may very well disagree with my analysis.

I’ll start with the “cameo” players. They spent time with the Phillies, but most of their career was spent elsewhere, and if elected – barring a major surprise – they would not wear a Phillies hat on their plaque.

Jake Arrieta

Important stats and accolades: 12 seasons, 285 games, 115 wins, 3.98 ERA, 21.1 WAR, 1 time All-Star, 3 top ten Cy Young Award finishes, 1 Cy Young Award

His career: Started out with the Orioles for whom he was a back-of-the-rotation starter. Traded to Cubs for whom he became a star, winning a Cy Young Award and a World Series. That peak didn’t last very long as he soon reverted to being a back-of-the-rotation starter after leaving the Cubs.

His time with the Phillies: Late in the 2017 offseason, the Phillies signed Arrieta to a three-year deal, hoping to add a veteran presence to their rotation.

He’s vilified by some who may have been expecting an ace, but he was largely okay as an innings-eating presence.

Will he get in: No, while he was very good for the Cubs, his overall career was nothing special. He might get a vote or two, but his time on the ballot will likely be short.

Should he get in: No. One great season does not a Hall of Fame career make.

Jay Bruce

Important stats and accolades: 14 seasons, .244/.314/.467 AVG/OBP/SLG, 319 home runs, 19.7 WAR, three-time All-Star, two-time Silver Slugger, two top-ten MVP finishes.

His career: Spent the early part of his career as a middle-of-the-order threat with the Reds, and then bounced around the league, as a dangerous, but not elite slugger.

His time with the Phillies: The Phillies needed another outfielder in 2019 so made an early season trade for Bruce. He was a fun story for a bit and went through a brief period where he was hitting home runs just about every game. Obviously, that didn’t last, and by 2020, he was basically a three true outcome player.

Will he get in: His accolades might be enough to keep him on the ballot for another year or so, but he’ll eventually drop off.

Should he get in: No, he had a very good career, but far from Hall of Fame worthy.

Asdrubal Cabrera

Important stats and accolades: 15 seasons, .266/.329/.423 AVG/OBP/SLG, 195 HR, 30 WAR, two-time All-Star, one-time Silver Slugger

His career: He was a very good shortstop for the Indians at the start of his career before bouncing around the league as a utility infielder.

His time with the Phillies: He was having a very good season for the Mets in 2018 when the Phillies traded for him at the end of July. Both he and the Phillies went into the tank immediately after. (Did they learn their lesson about never making in-season trades with the Mets? Nope!) He put up -0.7 wins above replacement with the Phillies, and the team went 23-38 after he arrived.

Will he get in: No, he was a two-time All-Star, and might get a few votes, but probably won’t be long for the ballot.

Should he get in: He might be my least favorite Phillie of all time, so I think that answers that question.

Next time, I’ll look at the remaining four players on the ballot who made a much more lasting impact with the Phillies.

2026 Atlanta Braves Player Review: Brewer Hicklen

ATLANTA, GA - OCTOBER 06: Brewer Hicklen #53 of the Atlanta Braves bats during Game Three of the National League Division Series presented by Booking.com between the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Atlanta Braves at Truist Park on Tuesday, October 6, 2026 in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Daniel Shirey/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images

If you’ve been around the Braves fandom for a while, you can probably think of at least a handful of minor leaguers whose performance prompted a clamor of “Call him up! Why isn’t he up yet?!” Many of those guys more or less faceplanted when they were eventually called up… if they were called up at all. Brewer Hicklen, though, fell into the category of, “He did alright” once he got called up to the big league club.

How Acquired

The spitting image of a minor league journeyman, the Braves signed Hicklen to a minor league deal in the 2025-2026 offseason. Hicklen had been around various geographic blocks:

  • Drafted by the Royals (2017)
  • Traded to the Phillies for cash (2023)
  • Minor league free agency; minor league deal with the Phillies (ahead of 2024)
  • Traded to the Tigers for cash (2025)
  • Traded back to the Phillies for cash (2025)

And then, as noted, minor league free agency and a minor league deal with the Braves.

What were the expectations?

Up until 2026, Hicklen had only gotten cups of coffee in the majors: four PAs with the Royals in 2022, 5 PAs with the Brewers in 2024, and four more with the Tigers in 2025. He didn’t do anything particularly exciting in those 13 tries, but… it was 13 PAs.

The bigger issue expectations-wise was that he had stopped hitting in Triple-A. Despite the lack of major league exposure, Hicklen had consistently hit well in Triple-A through 2024, but that performance had dipped across the Detroit and Philadelphia organizations in 2025.

As such, it was hard to expect anything but sub-replacement-ish performance, given his status as an outfielder that had most recently not even succeeded at hitting at Triple-A.

2026 Results

Hicklen functionally had two stints with the Braves in the bigs: two weeks in July around the All-Star Break, and then from late August through the end of the year. Before those stints, he was destroying Triple-A: through July 10, he had a 131 wRC+ for Gwinnett; he finished his minor league season with a 134 wRC+. Yeah, he outhit his minor league xwOBA a bit, but it was still a .350 xwOBA.

In the majors, he got a few starts when he was first called up, and straight-up raked in 21 PAs over five games, putting up a 200 wRC+ and a .355 xwOBA (that he outhit by over .100). He then shifted into a pinch-runner/defensive replacement role (nine PAs in ten games) but still held his own offensively (109 wRC+ with wOBA and xwOBA pretty much matching), and then got a few starts down the stretch with worse batting stuff (17 PAs in five games, .209 wOBA, .234 xwOBA).

Put all that together, and Hicklen got 47 big league PAs in 2026, putting up a .348 wOBA (120 wRC+, yay) and a .306 xwOBA (meh), while playing nondescript defense, mostly in right field. He got 0.2 fWAR for his xwOBA-outperforming efforts.

He struck out in his sole postseason PA.

What went right?

He got far more PAs than any team had ever given him before. He hit the ground running when first called up, and his batting line was pretty good, even if it was more fortunate than solid by the end — though it was still far too few PAs to say anything about his ability to hold his own in the majors. He also crushed minor league pitching, which is what got him those big league PAs in the first place, which was an important turnaround from his poor 2025 in Triple-A.

Though Hicklen didn’t get much exposure, he showed some nice building blocks in his PAs. Basically, he was reminiscent of those tools-over-performance prospects whose skillset was really aligned to the 2019-2024 PowerPoint Braves: he ran incredibly fast, he swung hard, swung often (especially early in the count), made relatively a lot of pulled air contact, and focused on quality of contact over frequency of contact. He did all this while barely chasing, which was weirdly impressive given how his swing was imbued with the essence of reckless abandon.

He had a few big hits as a result of his swing-first tendencies. Two that come to mind were his RBI double against the Padres, pushing a 2-1 lead to 3-1 in the ninth, and a different RBI double that did the same thing in the sixth. He didn’t really have a signature hit that turned a game around, but had two games with more than 0.06 WPA (though he also had three games with -0.06 WPA).

What went wrong?

Hicklen ultimately made so little contact, that you can see why he’s been in the minors for so long, even while dominating Triple-A. His z-contact rate was about 71 percent; league average is about 83 percent, and 71 percent is a bottom-five-in-baseball value among anyone with 50 or more PAs (and would be bottom-two behind Munetaka Murakami for anyone with 200 or more PAs). His o-contact rate was a hilarious 23 percent; league average is about 58 percent and was the lowest for anyone with his number of PAs or more. Hicklen’s approach was a refreshing change from a team that seemed unsure about what it wanted to do at the plate, and he somehow avoided chasing while being primed to swing swing swing, but he definitely hit the limit of how little contact you can make and still produce a useful batting line, and then blew right past it.

Some PAs emblematic of this issue:

  • On July 12, in the PA that was his Braves debut, he came up in the second after Dustin May had walked the first two batters of the inning, and a bunt to move them over. He took a strike, fouled off a pitch, and then waved through a fastball in the zone for a strikeout. (The Braves only scored in the frame on a wild pitch, which tied the game. They won by a run late.)
  • On July 21, he struck out three times (and walked once) in a blowout loss to the Padres. Those strikeouts included a three-pitch strikeout with the bases loaded and two out where he represented the tying run in the sixth (fouled off a non-strike, whiffed on a non-strike, whiffed on a pitch in the zone), and two where he fell behind by taking strikes and then waved at strike three.

2027 Outlook

Hicklen remains with the club, hanging out on the 40-man roster. He projects as a 0.5 WAR-ish fifth outfielder right now given his speed and not-awful-in-total 2026 batting line, plus his minor league performance. The Braves could probably do worse given their propensity to carry bench guys that don’t play and wouldn’t offer anything if they did, but he’s also out of options, which limits their flexibility. They could opt for a guy with more roster flexibility, or a guy with a better projection (like a 1.0-1.5 WAR outfielder) for the spot instead.

I do kind of hope they hold on to Hicklen in some capacity, because even if the team veers further away from “swing hard in case you hit it” and “elevate and celebrate,” he’d be a nice throwback whenever he shows up — even if he may be addled in the contact department.