2026 Dodgers minor league review Emil Morales

GLENDALE, AZ - MARCH 21: Los Angeles Dodgers shortstop Emil Morales (96) runs to third base against the Chicago White Sox in a Spring Breakout Game on March 21, 2026, at Camelback Ranch at Glendale, Arizona. (Photo by Brian Spurlock/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

The Dodgers’ primary infield prospect, Emil Morales, carried on his outstanding development trajectory with an irrepressible 2026 campaign, which even earned him an early promotion from the Ontario Tower Buzzers to the Great Lakes Loons. Morales opened the season in the California League, and he needed just over 30 games to prove he was too dominant for that level, earning a call-up to the Great Lakes squad, where he didn’t skip a beat.

In a season in which multiple Dodger prospects won MVP awards at their respective leagues—including Morales’ teammate Charles Davalan—few were as impressive as Morales. He tackled the challenge of facing multiple levels in the same seamless fashion he has every other obstacle thrown his way up to this point.

The crown jewel of the Dodgers international free agent class back in 2024, Morales made a mockery of the Dominican Summer League as a 17-year-old with a .691 SLG in 46 games. Last season, he smashed Rookie ball enough to earn a late-season call-up to Low-A, producing a .968 OPS in 30 games in the California League. That exposure and the high bar he set allowed the Dodgers to aggressively promote him as a 19-year-old this year after just 36 games in the California League.

One subtle adjustment, if we can even call it, came on the defensive side of the ball. Early in the year, Morales was switching more regularly from short to third in Low-A, featuring in the hot corner in nine of his 36 games with the Tower Buzzers. After his call-up, Morales played basically exclusively short, appearing at third in just one of 81 games. At 6’3 and known primarily for his offensive potential, Morales naturally carries some questions about his long-term defensive positioning, but the initial plan is clearly to try and develop him as a shortstop, one that has yet to face any issues.

Held quiet in a four-game series at home to begin his Loons career, Morales gave his welcome card in his first road game in the Midwest League, going deep twice against the Dragons, including a grand slam.

Averaging a little over one RBI per game (84 in 81), Morales still managed to lead the Loons in runs batted in over the likes of Davalan and Eduardo Quintero. An incredible achievement, accounting for the fact that not only did they spend the whole season with the squad, but both had dominant performances.

On a rate basis, Morales was terrific, leading all shortstops in the league with a .914 OPS. He impressed so much to earn All-Star nods in the Midwest League, and might’ve given Davalan a run for his money in the MVP chase had he been with the squad the whole season.

Ranked as the Dodgers’ fourth-best prospect, trailing only the outstanding outfield trio of Josue De Paula, Eduardo Quintero, and Mike Sirota, Morales sits 22nd overall in MLB’s top 100 prospects. Alongside Roch Cholowsky and Sebastian Walcott, he is one of three shortstops 6’3″ or taller in the top 25.

2026 particulars

Age: 20

stats: .295/.382/.546, 26 HR, 119 RBI, 34 2B, 80 R, 117 G (81 games in High-A and 36 in Low-A)

Game of the year

There were a few strong contenders for this selection, like the two-HR, six-RBI game he had in a Loons blowout win over the Dayton Dragons in May—Dragons, who, by the way, were on the receiving end of two of Morales’ three multihomer games in 2026. However, the winner came in a road win in early September against the Lake County Captains. Morales had a five-hit performance, scoring three and driving in four as the Loons battered the Captains 13-7.

Kyle Schwarber wins Silver Slugger; Bryce Harper robbed

The Silver Slugger Award is given to the best offensive player at each position in the NL and AL, and this year’s award winners were announced on Tuesday. Kyle Schwarber won his second Silver Slugger as a Phillie (and also the second of his career), beating out Shohei Ohtani in the DH category.

He becomes the third current Phillie with multiple SS awards since signing here, joining Bryce Harper (3) and J.T. Realmuto (2). Harper and Realmuto each also won once with their previous teams. Before this current group, the last Phillie to win the award was Chase Utley in 2009. Utley won a total of 4, and the only other Phillies with multiple awards have been Mike Schmidt (6) and Manny Trillo (2):

It may be somewhat surprising that Schwarber has only won twice, but it’s worth remembering he’s been a better hitter as a Phillie (.857 OPS, 132 wRC+) than he had been previously (.836 OPS, 119 wRC+), and he has also had the misfortune of competing with some of Ohtani’s best seasons at the plate.

The other time Schwarber won the award was in 2022 as an outfielder. Calling the top vote getters “finalists” began in 2023, and he wasn’t among the outfield finalists that year. Nor was he a finalist in his first season as a DH in 2024, when both Ohtani and Marcel Ozuna had much better seasons. He hit 56 HRs in 2025 and had the best season of his career, but Ohtani was still better, with 55 HRs and much higher OPS and wRC+.

The Phillies could have easily had two winners this year. Matt Olson was voted the winner at First Base, though by any comprehensive hitting stat he was not one of the NL’s 3-4 best hitters at the position in 2026.

Jake Bauers was arguably the NL’s best-hitting first baseman, but he also played enough at multiple other positions (left and right field) to qualify as a “utility” player, a position category that was added for the award in 2022. He deservedly won a Silver Slugger award, but it was at that Utility spot.

Bauers led all NL first basemen in wRC+ (143), and OPS (.874), but since he won as a Utility player, these were the leaders among the other first basemen:

wRC+: Rafael Devers (136), Harper (135), Alec Burleson (125), TJ Rumfield (124), Olson (122)

OPS: Devers and Harper (.865), Rumfield (.843), Olson (.823), Burleson (.816)

Harper and Devers were essentially tied at the two key comprehensive stats, but Harper led all first basemen (including Bauers) in Runs Created, and Runs Above Average.

Coaching staffs saw most of the players on the ballot at most 6 or 7 times this year, so presumably they based their votes on their impressions from that handful of games, buzz about their seasons, and presumably most voters also looked up their stats at the end of the year. Assuming stats were a substantial factor in the voting, managers and coaches apparently dig the long ball, especially when it comes to First Base. Olson’s 41 HRs led all NL first basemen, 4 ahead of Devers. It also helped Olson that his best hitting was in the first half (.873 OPS and 135 wRC+), which propped up his season’s stat line and the buzz about his season even as he struggled in the second half (.751 and 102).

Olson did not deserve the Silver Slugger as the best hitter at the position — either Harper or Devers did.

To be fair, a similar argument could be made for Shohei Ohtani over Schwarber. Ohtani had the higher OPS (.889 to .857) and higher wRC+ (139 to 130).

Harper’s 2026 was only slightly better than the 2025 season that prompted Dave Dombrowski’s comments about him being “elite” — he raised his OPS from .844 to .865, and his wRC+ from 130 to 135. Both were still below his career averages of .902 and 140, though that’s not unexpected for a 33-year-old player, even a highly paid one.

Nevertheless, Harper was good enough to win the NL’s Silver Slugger Award.

Guardians Season in Review: Jo Adell

ST. PETERSBURG, FL - OCTOBER 19: Jo Adell #7 of the Cleveland Guardians looks on prior to Game Six of the American League Championship Series between the Cleveland Guardians and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field on Monday, October 19, 2026 in St. Petersburg, Florida. (Photo by Rob Tringali/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images

We had only about two and a half months with Jo Adell in Cleveland – what did we learn?

The Guardians landed Jo Adell at the trade deadline to add some needed thump to their lineup, especially against LHP. Adell ended up playing almost every day, as the Guardians elected not to give Kyle Manzardo or Cooper Ingle a second look to play DH against RHP, and, instead, chose to see what Adell could offer in a full-time role. How did it turn out? Adell was an incredible addition vs. LHP – he had a 206 wRC+ and a .358/.443/.660 slashline during the regular season which carried into the playoffs where his wRC+ was he had a 219 wRC+ vs. LHP. Adell mashes lefties and that is something the Guardians needed and continue to need. BUT Adell put up a 66 wRC+ against RHP and a .197/.273/.315 slashline with Cleveland, which carried into a 34 wRC+ and a slashline of .176/.216/.286 against RHP in the playoffs. Adell is a career 81 wRC+ against RHP and a 125 wRC+ against LHP, and this isn’t a small sample now with over 2,300 plate appearances.

I have two big questions for the Guardians and Adell as we approach tomorrow’s non-tender deadline. First, with Adell projected to receive $9 million in arbitration, are the Guardians willing to pay that much for a player who is most likely a weak-side platoon option with extreme defensive limitations? Cleveland repeatedly chose to play a (clearly) physically limited Chase DeLauter in right field over Adell in the playoffs, illustrating their lack of trust for him in the corner outfield. Second, has Cleveland seen enough to conclude that Adell is a lefty-masher who should get around 350-400 plate appearances, rather than the 660 he received between the Angels and Guardians last season? Finally, is Adell ok with this adjustment in his role?

I am a firm believer that the Guardians SHOULD bring Jo Adell back for 2027 (if a season takes place). In their incredibly left-handed hitting-heavy lineup, Adell serves an incredibly useful role. I also suspect that the $9 million figure is a litle inflated, and they’ll get him somewhere around $7-8 million. But, it is important that the team 1. admits that Adell is a platoon player, 2. has a plan to pair him with a good partner who hits from the left-side of the plate, and 3. has communicated to Adell about this plan for the upcoming season.

I have long enjoyed watching Adell and it was very fun to see him enjoy playing on a winning team and come up with some big moments:

With that said, I am thoroughly convinced that bringing him back with the anticipation of him being a full-time hitter would be a mistake. Embrace that Adell is an incredible option as a lefty-masher and utilize him in that role to the fullest extent. I suppose there is a chance that Cleveland, as a new organization for Adell, sees an adjustment he can make that he did not make in Anaheim to increase his effectiveness against RHP, but I don’t want this to be plan-A for the team as a full-time DH. Let it be plan-B and something that Adell can earn through capitalizing on limited opportunities against RHP early in the season. But, with all that said, I will be very disappointed if the Guardians non-tender Adell tomorrow; he has a very useful skill of demolishing southpaws. Keep that on hand for as long as you can swing it.

Athletics 2026 Season In Review: Yunior Tur

SACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA - SEPTEMBER 26: Yunior Tur #70 of the Athletics pitches in the top of the eighth inning against the Houston Astros at Sutter Health Park on September 26, 2026 in Sacramento, California. (Photo by Justine Willard/Athletics/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The Player Review Series continues this morning with a look at a former top-20 prospect in the system. Right-hander Yunior Tur was a well-regarded prospect that made his big league debut this past season. How’d it go?

How was he acquired?

Tur was signed during the 2023 signing period out of Cuba. Inking his deal at 23 years old, Tur spent the majority of his early professional career exclusively as a reliever, but got an extended look in 2024 and 2025 as a starter. That helped him rise to 20th in Pipeline’s A’s top 20 prospects to enter the year.

What were the expectations?

Entering the year the right-hander began the season in the Las Vegas Aviators’ bullpen, which was viewed as his best spot long term. The hope was that by shifting his attention to relief on a full-time basis that he could really unleash his fastball in short bursts and perhaps turn into a solid middle reliever for the big league team sooner rather than later. Anything more than that would have felt like striking gold, but just solid production out of the bullpen would make a roster spot worthwhile.

2026 Results

Tur spent the first three months in Triple-A with the Aviators with up-and-down results. The hitter-friendly environment of the PCL, his first taste of Triple-A, was a mixed bag. While he was showing off his strikeout potential, he was also issuing far too many walks, a common problem for him as he’s risen the minor league ladder.

Still, with the big league team desperate for some sort of spark in their bullpen they turned to Tur, giving him his first call up to The Show on July 15th. His first stint with the A’s was, to be kind, dreadful. In Tur’s first career appearance he got rocked for six earned runs on seven hits and a walk in a blowout loss to the Nationals, then got tagged for eight runs in less than a full inning a few days later against the Diamondbacks. Needless to say that wouldn’t cut it and he’d find himself soon back in Las Vegas after those two tough appearances.

Tur would have another brief one-game stint with the club in August in which he improved by allowing just three earned runs in two innings before spending September with the A’s. He’d give up six earned runs in five games, ending his season on a down note to be sure. Overall he pitched 12 2/3 innings with the Athletics and gave up 23 (!) earned runs. With the Aviators it wasn’t much better as he posted a 5.87 ERA in 34 games in Triple-A.

2027 Outlook

The A’s only just recently made a tough roster call with Tur. The new-look front office decided to cut ties with last year’s #20 prospect, designating the righty for assignment just a couple of days ago. Makes sense after his tough overall season. His stock is low and after getting shelled in his brief time with the big league team he’s likely to be non-tendered on Friday. Perhaps he rejoins the club on a minor league deal but we’ll have to wait and see if Taylor Smith and co. want the now-27 Tur back in the fold.

Player Review series continues tomorrow!

2026 Atlanta Braves Player Review: Reynaldo López

Reynaldo López was one of many 2026 Atlanta Braves pitchers afflicted by the injury bug this season. Injuries are brutal, because not only do the afflicted players miss time, but they also tend to perform worse before going on the shelf, or as they ramp back up to “game speed” after being activated. Something like this was the case for López, whom the Braves hoped would have a solid rebound season in 2026 after his fantastic 2024.

How Acquired

On November 20, 2023, the Braves signed López to a three year guaranteed contract with a club option for a fourth year. The deal was technically a $26 million deal, but it had a $4 million buyout should the club decide to decline the $8 million option for 2027.

Then, on November 2, 2024 the Braves restructured, the contract making it fully guaranteed through the 2027 with an AAV of $10 million. The deal also shuffled cash away from 2025 and into 2026, which may have helped the Braves in some minuscule way. The restructuring resulted in an additional $4 million guaranteed for Lopez, so it wasn’t a big deal and was more a show of good faith in his talent.

What were the expectations?

López has had a long career full of twists and turns. Once a top-30 prospect that wowed with his fastball-curve combo and figured to be an above-average starter in the majors, he was an up-and-down guy without much success in his rookie season, and then again in his sophomore effort after he was traded (with Lucas Giolito and Dane Dunning) in the Adam Eaton deal.

López never really met his expectations as a starter in Chicago. He was okay in 2018-2019, but that okay-ness was highly dependent on a lower-than-average HR/FB rate. After a 2020 to forget, he was then okay as a swingman in 2021, and then busted out with a 2.0 fWAR relief season in 2022. He maintained a quality relief pace in 2023 while pitching for three different teams, but it was just an 0.7 fWAR season as he couldn’t carry his 2022 dominance forward.

All of that brings us to 2024, where the Braves clearly liked what they saw, and agreed to both sign López and entertain his desire to return to the starting rotation. That ended up working out great, at first: López ended up with a career year (3.6 fWAR, 48 ERA-, 73 FIP-, 85 xFIP-) and his arm mostly held up (25 starts, over 130 innings, two Injured List stints). While he was again helped by HR/FB and his ERA was a farce, it looked like he had finally grown into the expectations from about a decade ago.

But, things quickly turned sinister. The throwing shoulder inflammation from 2024 that lingered into 2025 eventually became arthroscopic surgery, and López’ 2025 consisted of a single, poor start.

Where did that bring us for 2026? It was unclear. Would López be healthy, and if he were healthy, would he even be able to do what he did in 2024? Or, had that ship sailed, and he now needed a diminished role to go with diminished expectations? It was certainly a point for debate, but the debate also felt kind of moot because it wasn’t clear whether he’d even be able to take the field.

His projections varied from very effective swingman (ZiPS, 2ish WAR in 100 innings) to a quality part-time starter (Steamer, 2ish WAR in 150 innings).

2026 Results

Safe to say that due to injuries and a bunch of other stuff, he did not meet those projected central estimates. Like much of his career, López’ season was one of twists and turns, but mostly not the good kind.

After a reasonable Spring Training, alarm bells started to sound when his velocity dipped towards the latter end of March. The team explained this as “mechanical adjustments,” which made little sense, but, lo and behold: López showed up and danced through the raindrops in his first two starts (good results, bad peripherals) and then looked a lot more like his 2024 self in the two after that (worse results, better peripherals). But, he then had some kind of horrendous physical-slash-mechanical issue in his fifth start, and was moved to the bullpen, where he spent the next two months pitching what was basically and nearly exclusively mop-up work for an inning or two at a time.

The Braves then reinserted him into their tattered rotation, and he was… fine. A knee injury knocked him out for about six weeks, he returned with two more unimpressive outings, and then shoulder inflammation ended his season in mid-September.

In total, López had 13 starts and 13 relief appearances in 2026, combining for 79 1/3 innings. His pitching slash line was blah: 108 ERA-, 106 FIP-, 105 xFIP-. That’s a below average-ish starter, but since a lot of that came in relief, it is considerably less impressive or useful. He earned 0.6 fWAR for his efforts. While he was there for most of the season, he didn’t really do all that much to contribute to the Braves’ 94-win campaign.

What went right?

Well, he was healthy enough for those 13 starts, 13 relief appearances, and 79 1/3 innings. He wasn’t healthy enough to make it through the season as a starter, nor to avoid two different stints on the shelf — nor to stop the shoulder inflammation from cropping up again.

If we’re looking for positives, there are a few. For one, though it’s not clear he had much to do with it, batters didn’t make hard contact off him. Both his hard-hit rate and his exit velocity-against were quite low… though that’s more the province of batters that face him than anything he’s doing.

His fastball command was pretty good. His curveball, which he threw only about 11 percent of the time, had a very nice xwOBA-against (.236) as batters failed to do much with it.

His return to the rotation after pitching in relief was pretty decent: a 92 ERA-, 94 FIP-, and 95 xFIP- in six starts. If he could keep that up over much of a season, he’d be an asset to the team. Unfortunately, he couldn’t even last five starts before having to move to the bullpen for various reasons earlier in the year, and his knee gave way after this six-start stretch. His last outing in this span was probably his standout work of the year: 5 2/3 innings with a 6/1 K/BB ratio and no runs charged to his ledger in Baltimore. (The Braves won 3-2 in 11 innings.) He also had a similar outing against the Cardinals with another 6/1 K/BB ratio in five innings, where he was charged with a run in the first but then breezed the rest of the way. Would’ve been nice to see that sort of thing for more than six starts, though.

What went wrong?

Injuries, to start. The knee injury ended that nice span of starts, and shoulder inflammation ended his season. But, there were a lot of other disappointing things.

His velocity was incredibly inconsistent. It was in the 94-95 range in his first three starts, then dipped a few ticks, and then it bounced around hard while he was a reliever. When he returned to starting, it went back to 94-95, but then dropped off again.

Whether related to that inconsistency or not, his inability to provide useful relief was an issue. His xFIP barely declined as a reliever (4.38) relative to what it was for the season when starting (4.45). The Braves used him in lower leverage, and he still blew up sometimes. He also blew up as a starter here and there, and it seemed to be health/mechanics-related as much as anything else, so it was hard to trust him or know what you were going to get on any given day.

López struggled horribly with locating his slider basically all year, as it ended up in the dirt over and over. It did get a lot of whiffs because it was hard to hit when thrown around the shoetops, but it also made it fairly easy for hitters to just avoid spinny stuff.

And, of course, sometimes it all just came together to ruin his day. One of his worst starts of the year came against the Padres during his overall successful pitching stretch, as he gave up two homers in 4 1/3 innings (6/3 K/BB ratio) in a blowout loss.

2027 Outlook

The 2027 season, as it will be, could go in pretty much any direction for López. Is he going to be a starter? Reliever? Will he be healthy? If he is healthy enough to play but not to start, will he actually be a useful reliever? Steamer’s central estimate is down to around 0.5-1.0 WAR in 100 innings as a swingman who mostly serves as a relief role. That’s a big drop from what the central estimate was a year ago. The same can be seen from ZiPS (1.0 to 1.5 WAR in 100 innings). Basically, it seems like whereas the 2026 central estimate was that Lopez would be useful in an uncertain role, he’s now down to “a role player with an uncertain role.”

President Trump posthumously pardons baseball's hit leader Pete Rose

President Trump posthumously pardons baseball's hit leader Pete Rose originally appeared on NBC Sports Boston

President Donald Trump on Thursday said he had posthumously pardoned Pete Rose more than two years after the baseball star’s death and a year after he was reinstated by Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred.

“I have just given a Complete and Total Pardon to the Late, Great Pete Rose, a true Baseball SUPERSTAR & LEGEND,” Trump posted on social media.

Rose, baseball’s career hits leader at 4,256, entered guilty pleas on April 20, 1990, to two counts of filing false tax returns, admitting he failed to report $354,968 during a four-year period. That was about eight months after Rose agreed to a permanent ban from baseball.

″I know I’m not a bad person, but I did make some mistakes and it’s in the eyes of the judge,″ Rose said that night during his weekly talk show on WCKY-AM in Cincinnati. ″All you can say is it’s up to the judge.″

The pardon comes after Manfred issued a sweeping decision last May that opened a pathway for Rose to be considered for baseball’s Hall of Fame. Manfred declared that individuals on MLB’s permanently ineligible list would have their statuses restored at death, a ruling that impacted 17 people, most notably Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson.

Under a rule adopted by the Hall’s board of directors in 1991, anyone on the permanently ineligible list can’t be considered for election to the Hall. The earliest Rose or Jackson could now be inducted would be in 2028.

Rose agreed to his permanent ban in August 1989 after Major League Baseball investigator John M. Dowd concluded he bet numerous times on the Cincinnati Reds while playing on and managing his hometown team from 1985-87.

Facing a sentence of up to six years in prison and $500,000 in fines, Rose was sentenced on July 19, 1990, by U.S. District Judge S. Arthur Spiegel in Cincinnati to five months in prison. He also was fined $50,000 and ordered to perform 1,000 hours of community service as a gym teacher’s assistant with inner-city youths in Cincinnati as part of a one-year probation period. The first three months of the probation were to be spent at the halfway house.

Rose repaid the Internal Revenue Service $366,042.

“History and the tincture of time will decide his place among the all-time greats of baseball,” Spiegel said. “With regard to Pete Rose, the individual, he has broken the law, admitted his guilt, and stands ready to pay the penalty. Under our system of law and sense of fairness, when he has completed his sentence, he will have paid his debt to society and should be accepted by society as rehabilitated. Only time will tell whether he is to be restored to his position of honor for his accomplishment on the ball fields of America.”

Rose reported that Aug. 10 to the U.S. Penitentiary Marion Camp in Illinois, a minimum security facility, and was released Jan. 7, 1991. He entered Talbert House to start serving his probation and departed on April 5.

A 17-time All-Star during a playing career from 1963-86, Rose was the 1963 National League Rookie of the Year, 1973 MVP and 1975 World Series MVP. A three-time NL batting champion, he broke the prior hits record of 4,191 set by Ty Cobb from 1905-28.

Rose played for the Philadelphia Phillies from 1979 through 1983, winning the World Series with the Phils in 1980.

AP Baseball Writer Jay Cohen contributed to this report.

Zack Greinke, Eric Hosmer to be inducted into the Royals Hall of Fame

Apr 5, 2023; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Kansas City Royals starting pitcher Zack Greinke (23) warms up prior to a game against the Toronto Blue Jays at Kauffman Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jay Biggerstaff-USA TODAY Sports | USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Con

Yesterday was a pretty busy news day for the Royals with Maikel Garcia sent to Seattle in a six-player trade. But I didn’t want to overshadow the other Royals news of the day – that Zack Greinke and Eric Hosmer will be inducted into the Royals Hall of Fame in 2027. The club will announce induction days at a later time.

Zack Greinke was originally drafted by the Royals with the sixth overall pick in 2002 and made his major league debut in 2004. He quickly established himself as one of the team’s best young pitchers, but his breakout season came in 2009, when he won the American League Cy Young Award. Greinke went 16-8 with a 2.16 ERA and 242 strikeouts, leading the league in ERA, earning his first All-Star selection, and finishing sixth in MVP voting. Greinke was traded to Milwaukee after the 2010 season, and spent time with the Angels, Dodgers, Diamondbacks, and Astros but returned to Kansas City in 2022 for his final two seasons.

Greinke has the best strikeout-to-walk ratio of any pitcher in club history. He is fourth among all Royals pitchers in career strikeouts with 1,101. His 29.8 rWAR ranks fourth among all pitchers in Royals history, and he remains the last Royals pitcher to win the Cy Young Award. He finished his Royals career with 66 wins and a 3.93 ERA in 266 games.

Eric Hosmer was the third overall pick in the 2008 draft and debuted in 2011 by hitting .293/.334/.465 with 19 home runs, finishing third in Rookie of the Year voting. He developed into one of the best defensive first basemen in baseball, winning four Gold Glove Awards with the Royals. He earned his first All-Star selection in 2016 and was named All-Star Game MVP after hitting a go-ahead home run in the eighth inning. His most memorable moment came in the 2015 World Series, when his aggressive dash home on a ground ball to first base tied Game 5 in the ninth inning and helped the Royals eventually clinch the championship.

In 2017, he played in all 162 games and hit career highs in batting average (.318), on-base percentage (.385), and tied his career-best with 25 home runs. He earned a Silver Slugger Award and finished 14th in MVP voting. He went on to play for the Padres, Red Sox, and Cubs before retiring after the 2023 season. Among all Royals career leaders, Hosmer is fourth in home runs (127), ninth in RBI (566), eleventh in hits (1,132), tenth in runs scored (547), tenth in total bases (1,751), and tenth in extra base hits (349).

Greinke and Hosmer were both nominated for the first time, and were part of a list of 11 candidates that included Carlos Beltrán, Billy Butler, Lorenzo Cain, Wade Davis, Alcides Escobar, Ian Kennedy, Kelvin Herrera, Greg Holland, Mike Moustakas, and Joakim Soria.

Previous elections to the Royals Hall of Fame:

1986: Pitcher Steve Busby and Outfielder Amos Otis

1987: Manager Dick Howser, Second Baseman Cookie Rojas and Pitcher Paul Splittorff

1989: Pitcher Dennis Leonard and Designated Hitter Hal McRae

1992: Club President Joe Burke, Pitcher Larry Gura and Shortstop Fred Patek

1993: Owner Ewing Kauffman

1994: Third Baseman George Brett

1995: Second Baseman Frank White

1996: Royals First Lady Muriel Kauffman and First Baseman John Mayberry

1998: Relief Pitcher Dan Quisenberry

2000: Manager Whitey Herzog and Outfielder Willie Wilson 

2003: Pitcher Jeff Montgomery

2004: Radio Announcer Denny Matthews

2005: Pitcher Bret Saberhagen

2006: Pitcher Mark Gubicza

2008: Scout Art Stewart

2011: Pitcher Kevin Appier

2012: Groundskeeper George Toma

2015: First Baseman/DH Mike Sweeney

2023: Manager Ned Yost

2024: General Manager Cedric Tallis, General Manager John Schuerholz and Outfielder Bo Jackson

2025: Outfielder Alex Gordon

2026: Player/Coach/Manager/Broadcaster/Scout John Wathan

Free agent poll: Bryan Abreu

ARLINGTON, TEXAS - OCTOBER 20: Adolis Garcia #53 of the Texas Rangers argues with Martin Maldonado #15 of the Houston Astros after being hit by a pitch by Bryan Abreu #52 of the Houston Astros during the eighth inning in Game Five of the American League Championship Series at Globe Life Field on October 20, 2023 in Arlington, Texas. (Photo by Carmen Mandato/Getty Images) | Getty Images

You want another free agent poll? You got another free agent poll.

Today we are looking at righthanded reliever Bryan Abreu. I don’t have to tell you who he. He’s a fan favorite around these parts.

Baseball America projects 1 year, $12.5 million for Abreu. The projections at Fangraphs have Abreu at 2 years, $18 million from Ben Clemens, and 1 year, $8 million from the median crowdsource. Kiley McDaniel projects Abreu at 1 year, $10.5 million. MLB Trade Rumors has Abreu at 2 years, $22 million with an opt out.

We shall use the Clemens projection.

Should the Rangers sign Bryan Abreu to a 2 year, $18 million deal?

Cast your vote below…

Should Pirates trade Carmen Mlodzinski this offseason?

DETROIT, MI - SEPTEMBER 26: Carmen Mlodzinski #50 of the Pittsburgh Pirates pitches during the game between the Pittsburgh Pirates and the Detroit Tigers at Comerica Park on Saturday, September 26, 2026 in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo by Izzy Rincon/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images

The Pittsburgh Pirates had a crowded rotation during the 2026 season, which included Carmen Mlodzinski.

Mlodzinski, 27, was a starter to begin the season, but he found himself relegated to the bullpen in June as the team utilized him more as a long reliever. That could make him a trade candidate for the Pirates this offseason as teams in need of starting pitching could take a chance on him.

“As things stand right now, Mlodzinski would be on the outside looking in at a rotation that includes Skenes, Bubba Chandler, Jared Jones, Braxton Ashcraft and Mitch Keller. The Buccos could keep him as a swingman, but he may prove more valuable as a possible trade piece,” Bleacher Report contributor Tim Kelly wrote.

“Mlodzinski has a 3.53 ERA in 146 MLB games over parts of four seasons, including 29 starts. A team needing starting-pitching depth might be able to help the Pirates plug another hole on their roster (second base?) if they’re willing to take on Mlodzinski’s three remaining arbitration years.”

Mlodzinski is on the outside looking in on the starting rotation, and he has made it clear in interviews that he would prefer to be a starter instead of a bullpen arm. Mlodzinski would welcome that opportunity if it were to come, but the Pirates shouldn’t trade him this offseason unless the right deal comes along.

BD community, how do you feel about the possibility of the Pirates trading Mlodzinski during the offseason? Let us know in the comments section below.

2026 Dodgers season review: Ben Rortvedt

DETROIT, MICHIGAN - AUGUST 30: Ben Rortvedt #47 of the Los Angeles Dodgers plays against the Detroit Tigers at Comerica Park on August 30, 2026 in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo by Gregory Shamus/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Ben Rortvedt for a second straight year started his season elsewhere but ended in the Dodgers organization. But the path this year for the veteran catcher was much more circuitous.

The break-in-case-of-emergency security blanket with the fan-friendly nickname — “Benny Biceps” — had the misfortune of being out of minor league options, making him harder to stash as depth because he’d have to pass through waivers to be sent to the minors.

With over three years of major league service time last offseason, Rortvedt was eligible for salary arbitration, and the Dodgers avoided a potential hearing with an early November deal, inking the backup catcher for $1.25 million for 2026. But with Will Smith and Dalton Rushing in the fold, keeping Rortvedt would mean sending him down to the minors. The Dodgers tried to send him outright to Triple-A in November 2025, but the Cincinnati Reds claimed him off waivers.

Cincinnati tried a similar gambit three months later, but the Dodgers claimed Rortvedt back, at the expense of lefty reliever Anthony Banda, another out-of-options player who slipped further down the depth chart and was designated for assignment.

Rortvedt’s LA return this time lasted only nine games before the New York Mets claimed him on February 15. Rortvedt was down the depth chart in New York as well and was designated for assignment once opening day rosters were set on March 25, but this time the catcher cleared waivers and he hit .239/.319/.414 with six home runs in 48 games for Triple-A Norfolk.

In 2025, Rortvedt’s time came as both Smith and Rushing were hurt in September, and he ended up even starting four postseason games before Smith’s hand injury was fully healed. In 2026, Smith missed three months with a neck injury and Rushing injured his elbow on August 1. The timing of the latter was fortuitous, with two days before the trade deadline. After dalliances with Chuckie Robinson and Eliezer Alfonzo as backup backstops, the Dodgers traded for old friends Rortvedt (from the Mets for pitcher Chayce McDermott) and Hunter Feduccia (from the Rays with pitcher Jacob Kmatz for outfielder Jack Suwinski).

The month of August was essentially the Feduccia and Rortvedt show behind the plate, with Rortvedt starting nine games.

Though he helped hold down the fort for four weeks, including throwing out three of 12 runners trying to steal, Rortvedt was once again on the outside looking in on the depth chart once Smith returned from the injured list on September 1. With Feduccia entrenched as the backup at that point, Rortvedt was once again designated for assignment.

“Ben’s a great teammate, he’s a major league player,” manager Dave Roberts said when Rortvedt was designated for assignment. “And I’ll always be grateful because he helped us win a championship last year. Great guy.”

Rortvedt cleared waivers and stuck around, accepting a minor league assignment on September 3. By that point, he couldn’t have signed anywhere else and been eligible for the postseason. So his sticking around just in case would have been Rortvedt’s only path to October this year. But that just in case never happened.

Rortvedt did catch six games down the stretch for Triple-A Oklahoma City, and played in the first game of the Pacific Coast League championship series. In the latter, Rortvedt reached base four times with a double, single, and two walks, with a pair of runs scored plus a run batted in.

2026 particulars

Age: 28

Stats: 16 games, 5 for 27, .185/.185/.185, RBI, 9 strikeouts, sacrifice bunt

Salary: $1.25 million

Game of the year

Rortvedt singled home a run in the fifth inning on August 13 against Milwaukee Brewers left-hander Shane Drohan at Dodger Stadium, his only major league RBI of the season.

Roster status

As someone with at least three years of major league service time who was sent outright to the minors during the season, Rortvedt had the right to elect free agency after the season, and exercised that right on October 17.

Rays considering trading DeLuca

ST. PETERSBURG, FL - OCTOBER 26: Jonny DeLuca #21 of the Tampa Bay Rays takes the field during player introductions prior to Game Three of the 2026 World Series presented by Capital One between the Milwaukee Brewers and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field on Monday, October 26, 2026 in St. Petersburg, Florida. (Photo by Daniel Shirey/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images

The Tampa Bay Rays are reportedly considering trading center fielder Jonny DeLuca.

During the General Manager meetings held several days ago, Ken Rosenthal and Will Sammon of The Athletic reported that Tampa Bay might consider moving on from their 28-year outfielder.

In a thin market for offense, Tampa Bay might consider trading Jonny DeLuca to open center field for Victor Mesa Jr., according to people briefed on the Rays’ thinking who were not authorized to publicly discuss the team’s plans.

DeLuca has been with the Rays since the team acquired him along with RHP Ryan Pepiot during the 2023-2024 offseason in exchange for Tyler Glasnow and Manuel Margot. When healthy, DeLuca has looked like a star but staying on the active roster has been a struggle. Since joining the Rays, DeLuca has only played in 239 of the Rays 489 regular season games, spending roughly half of his time with the organization on the Injured List (DeLuca only played in 20 games during the 2025 season).

This past season, DeLuca hit .266/.300/.429 with 11 HR and 17 stolen bases, registering a 102 wRC+ over 370 PA while his plus defense allowed him to accrue 2.4 fWAR over 112 games. Among 142 outfielders with at least 300 innings played last season, DeLuca was tied for the 3rd highest OAA with 13.

DeLuca enters arbitration for the first time this offseason and is projected by MLB Trade Rumors to make $1.7M in 2027; DeLuca is still under team control for three more seasons, entering free agency under his current contract following the completion of the 2029 campaign.

2026 Phillies Report Card: Bryson Stott

PHOENIX, AZ - AUGUST 31: Bryson Stott #5 of the Philadelphia Phillies celebrates in the dugout during the game between the Philadelphia Phillies and the Arizona Diamondbacks at Chase Field on Monday, August 31, 2026 in Phoenix, Arizona. (Photo by Brendon Baranov/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images

In a roster full of big names and large contracts, it’s sometimes the smaller players who make the biggest difference. For a large part of this season, the Phillies had one of those difference makers in Bryson Stott. Offensively, he was around league average, but where he really provided stability and dependability was with his glove at second base.

Perhaps he was snubbed of a Gold Glove nomination at second base, but if so only the Phillies are to blame for moving him to third.

Let’s take a look at Stott’s 2026 season.

2026 Stats: 155 Games; .256/.334/.401; 10 HR; 6 3B; 67 RBI; 27 SB (0 CS); 16.4 K%; 10.2 BB%; 102 wRC+; 3.8 fWAR

What went right

Stott was one of the best defenders at second in all of baseball this season. His .998 fielding % topped all qualified players at the position, and his FRV of 4 placed him in the top 10. Had he played the full season at second, he likely would have been at least a finalist for the Gold Glove award, if not the winner.

He also went a perfect 27 for 27 in stolen bases, providing an additional level of small-ball offense to a roster designed primarily for the long ball.

What went wrong

The acquisition of Luis Arraez at the trade deadline really hurt the view of Stott’s overall season. Prior to 2026, Stott had played a grand total of 15 innings at third base in his Major League career. For that reason, I’ll give him a little slack. But the decision to move their best defensive player from his position to one he’d barely played at this level was a bad one. While Stott committed just one error at second base in 116 games, he committed four at third base in 43 games.

I won’t harp on him for a poor decision made by the powers above him, but at the end of the day Stott is not, and should not be, a third baseman. While I personally like Arraez (and don’t fault him for this decision either), I simply do not understand the decision to acquire someone who forces you to move a potential gold glove finalist out of position to somewhere else. It was a confounding move that hurt the integrity of the infield in more ways than one.

Final Grade:B

Stott wasn’t great at the plate this season, but he certainly wasn’t a major problem. Between that and his obvious threat to steal bases, he was around average, if not slightly above offensively. For that, I started him at a B/B- grade. Had he played the entire year at second base, it might have been enough to bump him up to an A this season. Unfortunately, his time at third base hurt his overall score and kept him in the B range.

Yankees Birthday of the Day: Everett Scott

Baseball and its fans tend to revere the history of the sport. Not that there aren’t arguments in other sports, but things like Hall of Fame debates tend to linger longer than ones in other sports. There are several records that baseball fans can name by heart.

One of those is Cal Ripken Jr. and his 2,632 consecutive games played. When he was closing in on that record, his chase of Lou Gehrig’s record was national news. Gehrig himself was revered for holding that record, both for his legendary career and the ALS battle that caused him to eventually end the streak.

The man who held the record before Ripken or Gehrig doesn’t have the level of fame that they do. However, he was a notable player in his own right, even being a teammate of Gehrig on the Yankees when The Iron Horse’s streak began.

Lewis Everett Scott
Born: November 19, 1892 (Bluffton, IN)
Died: November 2, 1960 (Fort Wayne, IN)
Yankees Tenure: 1922-25

Everett Scott was born and raised in Indiana. He attended Bluffton High School in the town where he was born, graduating in 1909. Later that year, his baseball career began when he caught on the Kokomo (IN) Wild Cats. He spent the next couple years playing for various minor league teams around Indiana and Ohio. Scott was playing for a team in Youngstown, OH in 1912 when he was noticed by Red Sox co-owner Jimmy McAleer, a Youngstown native. A couple other MLB teams had taken notice, but it was McAleer and the Red Sox who ended up winning Scott’s signature.

After signing with Boston, Scott spent the 1913 season with the St. Paul Saints. After a solid season there, the Red Sox brought him up to the bigs for 1914, fending off advances from the new Federal League. Scott pretty quickly impressed and locked down the Red Sox shortstop job for the next several years.

Scott was never a particularly strong hitter, but he was solid enough for a shortstop of that era. He also gained the reputation as a sterling defender at the position. In Scott’s first season in the majors, Boston went from fourth place to second in the AL. In his second season, they won 101 games and the World Series championship. Scott helped the Red Sox to further championships in 1916 and 1918, which would be Boston’s last for quite a while. (Which we Yankee fans often liked to remind them of.)

As the Red Sox had success on the field, Scott’s desire to be rewarded off it grew. He and the team had salary disagreements at points. However, he always eventually came to terms with Boston. His salary may have played a part in both his and other notable Boston players’ departures.

When the late 1910s/early 1920s came around, the Red Sox made several notable trades with the Yankees that did not end up working out in Boston’s favor. The most notable of which was, of course, the sale of Babe Ruth. Red Sox owner Harry Frazee traded away a lot of players who had helped Boston to those three World Series title, reportedly out of a desire to shed salary to aid his other financial pursuits, mainly his career as a Broadway producer.

Eventually, Scott became one of those who went from Boston to New York. In December 1921, he and pitchers Sad Sam Jones and Bullet Joe Bush were sent to the Yankees for four players and $100,000. The deal didn’t seem lopsided at the time as Roger Peckinpaugh — who had been one of the best Yankees at that time — went the other way, but Boston famously didn’t win a World Series for a long time after that and New York soon won many of them.

With the Yankees, Scott was never a dynamic hitter, but he soon became an important player. Having served as the Red Sox captain back in Boston, he was named as the Yankees’ fill-in captain for 1922, as Ruth was set to serve a suspension. However, Scott ended up holding the role until he departed the Yankees a couple years after that.

Scott also brought his steady defense at shortstop and his reliable presence. Over the course of his time in New York, Scott reached the mark of playing in 1000 consecutive gams, and would eventually reach 1,307 while playing for the Yankees. He also played all but one inning of the 1923 World Series, as the Yankees clinched their first ever championship. Scott scored one of the runs in an eighth inning rally in Game 6, as the Yankees came back and overtook the Giants to seal the championship.

However, Scott was also starting age around that period. Manager Miller Huggins continued to put him in the lineup every day, but the wear and tear of 1300+ consecutive games eventually caught up to him. On May 6, 1925, Huggins opted to end the streak and started Pee Wee Wanninger over Scott at shortstop. Angered by the move, Scott initially left and returned home to Indiana. He eventually came back, but continued to lose playing time. His final appearance as a Yankee came on May 30th. Funnily enough, two days later, Lou Gehrig got the start at first base to begin his streak that would break Scott’s record.

Later in June, the Washington Senators selected Scott off waivers. He played 33 games there and then had brief runs with the White Sox and Reds in 1926. He continued playing in the minors for a few years after that, but eventually returned to Indiana, where he managed bowling alleys and billiard halls. Scott remained there until he passed away in 1960.

Everett Scott will never have the level of recognition that either of the two players who broke his record have. That being said, he was quite the notable player in his own right.

Dodgers have depth in the starting rotation, but bullpen is a work in progress

Dodgers pitcher Yoshinobu Yamamoto pitches against the Cincinnati Reds at Dodger Stadium during a game on Sept. 9.
Dodgers pitcher Yoshinobu Yamamoto pitches against the Cincinnati Reds at Dodger Stadium during a game on Sept. 9. (Robert Gauthier / Los Angeles Times)

It’s been a newsy week in baseball, between owners meetings, Tarik Skubal’s free agency, and the deadline to protect prospects from the Rule 5 Draft.

The Dodgers had a meeting scheduled with Skubal, put four prospects on the 40-man roster and announced that reliever Seth Halverson had undergone Tommy John surgery.

With all that action, and end of the current CBA fast approaching on Dec. 1, it’s a good time to evaluate the Dodgers’ pitching staff:

Starting rotation

Returning: Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Shohei Ohtani, Blake Snell, Tyler Glasnow, Roki Sasaki, Justin Wrobleski, Emmet Sheehan

Free agent: Tarik Skubal, Eric Lauer

Additional depth: Gavin Stone

Skubal essentially replaced Ohtani, limited by injuries to his left knee and right biceps, in the rotation when the Dodgers acquired the left-hander at the trade deadline. But if they don’t re-sign Skubal, it won’t be as simple as Ohtani tagging back in. The Dodgers still have to work out his workload for next year, as he returns to two-way duties.

The Dodgers do have pitching depth, with a promising trio of Sasaki, Wrobleski and Sheehan rounding out the back of the rotation, and Stone expected to be healthy next year, but the Dodgers’ commitment to a six-man rotation requires a wealth of options. They also aren’t looking to coast after an NLCS exit. And raising the bar from 2026 could mean supplementing the rotation, whether that be with Skubal or another starter via free agency or trade.

“Do you need it? I don’t know. Do you want it? Maybe,” general manager Brandon Gomes said at the MLB general manager meetings last week. “You may not know that you need it until it’s too late. … The floor right now is really high. We do have a good amount of depth in our pitching, so now it’s just taking into account what makes sense for us based on different avenues of how things shake out.”

Bullpen

Returning (min 10 IP in 2026 season): Edwin Díaz, Tanner Scott, Edgardo Henriquez, Jack Dreyer, Will Klein, Brock Stewart, Kyle Hurt, Landon Knack

Out: Evan Phillips (signed with Braves), Seth Halvorsen (Tommy John surgery)

Free agent: Alex Vesia, Blake Treinen, Brusdar Graterol, Kris Bubic

Phillips’ three-year, $35-million deal helped set the early bullpen market. He returns to the Braves, the team that drafted him in 2015, after six years with the Dodgers.

It was always clear that the Dodgers would have work to do this offseason reinforcing their bullpen, a common winter project for most teams around the league. Though the Dodgers have signed closers (Scott and Díaz) in back-to-back offseasons, both of whom remain under contract, manager Dave Roberts regularly leaned on Phillips and Vesia in high-leverage situations.

Treinen hurt his shoulder during the last series of the regular season, and Graterol hasn’t thrown in a major-league game since the 2024 World Series due to injuries. Bubic has traditionally been a starter, but after the Dodgers acquired him at the trade deadline, while he was still on the injured list, he worked back as a reliever to shorten his return timeline.

Halvorsen, the hard-throwing right-hander who the Dodgers acquired from the Rockies in late July, only made 11 major-league appearances with the Dodgers, but the 26-year-old showed plenty of potential. After undergoing Tommy John surgery on Tuesday he’s expected to miss the 2027 season.

The reliever market started moving early, in an offseason that’s expected to go into an indefinite hold when MLB owners impose a lockout, likely on Dec. 1.

40-man roster additions

In the face of a looming lockout this year, it’s unclear whether there will actually be a Rule 5 Draft, which is typically held during the Winter Meetings in December. The last MLB lockout — which lasted 99 days, from December 2, 2021 to March 10, 2022 — completely wiped out the Rule 5 Draft.

Still, teams had to prepare this week as if it would happen. On Tuesday, the Dodgers added right-hander Christian Zazueta and left-handers Jackson Ferris, Adam Serwinowski and Luke Fox to the 40-man roster. To make room for them, the Dodgers designated right-handed pitcher Jake Cousins and infielder Christian Cairo for assignment.

Zazueta (No.5), Serwinowski (No. 14) and Ferris (No. 17), are all ranked by MLB Pipeline among the top 20 prospects in the Dodgers’ system, and Zazueta is ranked No. 33 in MLB.

Sign up for more Dodgers news with Dodgers Dugout. Delivered at the start of each series.

This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.

Should the Red Sox consider a reunion with free agent pitcher Nick Pivetta?

SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA - OCTOBER 6: Nick Pivetta #27 of the San Diego Padres stands on the mound during Game Three of the National League Division Series against the Milwaukee Brewers at Petco Park on October 6, 2026 in San Diego, California. (Photo by Matt Thomas/San Diego Padres/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Welcome to the 2026-27 edition of Smash or Pass, in which we examine potential free agent and trade targets to determine whether the Red Sox should pursue them and what it would take to land them. Today, in the wake of an effective veteran pitcher departing for Minnesota, we continue the series with an old friend.

Who is he and where does he come from?

He’s Nick Pivetta. But you know him already. He might as well be from South Boston, but he’s actually from the opposite side of the continent, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. After starting his career in Philadelphia, Dave Dombrowski dealt him to us to get his old reliever Brandon Workman back; the Red Sox would eventually end up with both on the squad, and the deal is widely regarded among Chaim Bloom’s best as Chief Baseball Officer. That’s not because Nick Pivetta was a world-beater, as I’ll get into in just a moment, but he did give the team five very dependable years before heading to San Diego and pitching like a Cy Young Candidate.

Is he any good?

He can be, but there’s a catch. At the age of 33, Pivetta has just sustained his first long-term injury of his entire career. The bad news is, it’s a continuation of an injury he suffered as a member of the Red Sox to start off the 2024 season; this time, the right flexor strain kept him out for five months. So, the jury is out on if he will pitch well in 2027. But, he played meaningful games in October and was one of the best starters in baseball in his last full season in 2025.

The best ability, as we saw from this depleted pitching staff in the late summer, is availability, and Pivetta has had that in spades through his entire career, save for 2026. From 2021-2025, he had an ERA of 4.00 (a 4.04 FIP), a WHIP of 1.18, and 895 strikeouts across 804 2/3 innings. That’s pretty much exactly what you’d be looking for in a back-of-the-rotation starter, though he did have a glaring hole: he allowed home runs and hard hits an alarming rate, and he allowed among the worst rates in baseball (~10th percentile) in barrel percentage for his entire time in Boston. This reared its head in a major way in 2023, when Pivetta was demoted to the bullpen, where he looked like a different guy before winning a rotation spot back, all prior to heading for the west coast in free agency on a 4-year, 55 million dollar deal with opt outs after two years after initially turning down a qualifying offer from the Red Sox. And, after that second season, here we are!

Tl;dr, just give me the 2026 stats.

Remember, that flexor strain kept his season dramatically short, so here’s his last two campaigns.

2025: 13-5, 181 2/3 IP, 190 K, 50 BB, 2.87 ERA, 3.49 FIP

2026: 3-2, 34 2/3 IP, 42 K, 8 BB, 2.86 ERA, 2.21 FIP

Why would he be a good fit for the Sox?

With Sonny Gray going to the Twins, they’re in the market for a right-handed pitcher. Pivetta is four years younger than Gray. He also has been healthy for a good amount of his career; he even made 33 starts in 2023. He knows the team, and was even on the team for the first part of Craig Breslow’s time with the organization. Need I remind everyone how awesome this post-season relief appearance was where he struck seven Rays out in four innings in extras?

We all know how John Henry operates, so maybe the most important thing: he’s also likely to be cost-effective. That plays a huge part for a pitching staff that needs not only depth and dependability, but financial pliability. Payton Tolle is going to need money soon. Garrett Crochet already got paid. Jake Bennett could be a part of this rotation for a while and has a definitively higher ceiling than Pivetta’s, though that’s comparing apples to bananas. Ranger Suarez looked awesome for much of last season. Then there’s Brayan Bello. Fact of the matter is, Pivetta gives a short-term lilypad for this frog of a roster to jump to the next lilypad without having to pay a guy 27 million dollars a season.

Why wouldn’t he be a good fit for the Sox?

First of all, maybe the rotation is already too cluttered, though that argument may have flown the coop once Jedixson Paez took the mound on a September evening in the middle of a playoff push. You can almost not have too much depth. There are two more important concerns: one is obviously that right flexor. It was an issue two seasons ago, and it kept him out for most of this past season. Now, he posted a 1.45 ERA in five starts once returning from this injury to end 2026 and was healthy enough to take two starts in the postseason, but none of those reached the end of the fifth inning, so it’s equal parts likely it’s going to be an reoccurring issue that just happens as a pitcher ages, or a reason to not invest in him at all. At 34, it may be better to be cautiously pessimistic, knowing you have an effective rotation already.

What would it take to get him?

The Padres declined a $14 million club option, so the Padres don’t want him at that number, but most estimates (including my own, based off of seeing that Gray deal) place him at around $16-17 million AAV and most have him getting a 3-year deal. I’d imagine that this would include opt outs after each year given the recent injury and Pivetta approaching 35 before Opening Day 2028 (Valentine’s Day, to be exact.) Recall that Sonny Gray, who was lights out for the whole season, cost the Red Sox $21 million net after the Cardinals sent money the team’s way to acquire him, and also factor into the equation that a Tolle deal is on the horizon… somewhere. There are other options, like Michael King, Nick Martinez, and Casey Mize, but if Dustin May’s 3 year, 52.5 million deal is any indication of what these guys will cost, Pivetta will be more cost-efficient.

Smash or Pass?

I’m smashing if the thought process is securing Tolle to a long term deal, and that Garrett Crochet reemerges as the pig he was in 2025, and Ranger Suarez is sorted onto this 2027 squad as arguably the best third man in all of baseball. Nick Pivetta could easily be a fifth man in this rotation, and, as we know, the allotment this year may be even tighter than most, especially given a couple of dominos have already fallen: I’d rather use his limited allotment to bolster a lineup to gather some run support for a rotation that was not the biggest issue for a playoff squad and stick to a lower-risk addition we already know well.