
Does Masyn Winn still have superstar potential? Or is his ability with the bat going to limit him to being merely very good? After a couple of down seasons offensively, I think more and more people are leaning towards the latter. But Winn is still just 24 years old and has shown glimpses of a higher offensive ceiling. He hit 15 home runs as a rookie in 2024 and has popped max exit velocity numbers that would indicate slightly above-average raw power. He has improved his plate discipline each year and now ranks as one of baseball’s more selective hitters. Winn’s contact rate did regress to average last season, but he has shown plus bat-to-ball skills in the past as well. All this to say, he has some tools with the bat and would not be the first player to find a new gear entering his mid-20s.
Jimmy Rollins was a below-average hitter through his age-24 season. He improved to an average hitter the next three seasons and then popped 30 home runs on his way to an MVP award in his age-28 season. That is the thing that is so tantalizing about players with Rollins’ or Winn’s other tools; if the bat can catch up a little bit, you have a true impact player. Rollins isn’t the only example in recent memory of a shortstop following this trajectory. Hitters that were worse than Winn offensively in their age-22-to-24 seasons include Ketel Marte, Edgar Renteria, Geraldo Perdomo, and Dansby Swanson. Maybe these aren’t fair comps, though. Perhaps these players had underlying traits that Winn simply does not possess.
To get slightly more surgical, I pulled in data for all hitters who accumulated over 1,000 plate appearances from ages 22 to 24 since 2015 (the Statcast era). This query yielded 97 results. My objective is to find players with similar underlying metrics to Winn, so I got to work whittling down the list.
Winn’s xwOBA was .293, which would translate to a wRC+ around 90, so I started by removing all hitters with xwOBAs above .315, or roughly all the above-average hitters from the list. This knocked 58 players off our list and took out the Mike Trouts and Juan Sotos of the world. I wanted to make sure we didn’t have any plus raw power bats surviving the purge, so next I removed all the 113+ mph max EV bats. This took another 14 off the list, including the aforementioned Ketel Marte.
Turning to Winn’s good qualities, I further narrowed the field by removing any player who chased more than 32% of the time or made contact less than 77% of the time (Winn was at 27% and 82%, respectively). This knocked out 15 more players, including some good ones in CJ Abrams and Willy Adames.
With the list whittled down to just nine players, including Winn, I did a final check to make sure there were no crazy outliers. Isaac Paredes made it through, but he is not really comparable to the field because of his elite ability to get the ball in the air. His fly ball rate was 6 percentage points higher than the next player on the list. Gone. Maikel Garcia made it through as well, but his HardHit% of 45.8% was more than 10 points higher than the next player on the list, so he is gone as well.
This leaves us with six comps, all with wRC+ totals below 100 through age 24.
Ages 22-24

And here is what they have done from age 25 forward.
Age 25+

This is certainly an encouraging group, with five of the six turning into above-average hitters. I am not jumping to any conclusions about Winn’s future based on these comps, though. This quick filtering exercise is not revealing anything that projection systems are not accounting for. Still, I think it is a worthwhile exercise to look at the changes these hitters made to help envision what an enlightened version of Winn might look like.
Both Turang and Perdomo drastically increased their power output by increasing their bat speed. Turang added 4.5 mph while Perdomo added 1.4 mph. Turang’s increase was the largest for any player in their age-25 season since bat tracking began in 2023. Perdomo’s increase was the 14th biggest jump over that same time period.
Suarez added power as well. His age-25 season was the year he flipped from below-average to above-average pull air rates. Suarez would eventually add exit velocity and become elite at pulling the ball in the air. He also refined his plate approach and started walking much more. I don’t foresee 350+ career home runs in Winn’s future, so I don’t think there is much to take away here. It is a good reminder of how much players can change and develop over time.
Polanco was starting from a higher level than any of the other comps, with a 99 wRC+ through age 24. Polanco’s developments mirrored Suarez’s as he added 3 mph in average EV and became one of baseball’s elite fly ball pullers.
Swanson is notable because he was horrible with the bat, carrying a 75 wRC+ through his age-24 season. He was able to turn himself into a league-average hitter by incrementally improving his plate discipline and increasing his power output in exchange for about 5 percentage points of contact rate.
DeShields did not make the same jump as his counterparts. His advanced metrics were strikingly similar to Geraldo Perdomo’s, pre-breakout, with a bit less contact ability. DeShields is a good reminder of the fine line hitters walk when they lack the ability to hit the ball with authority. It just took a little bit of regression and he was out of baseball.
Alright, back to the hero of our story. Winn has been trending in the wrong direction each of the last two years, but I am inclined to chalk most of that up to luck. He drastically overperformed his xwOBA in 2024 and underperformed it last season, making things look worse than they probably are. Steamer is not overly concerned either, projecting him for a 96 wRC+ in 2027. This may be stating the obvious, but unless Winn unlocks more power, this level of production feels close to his ceiling. There are exactly zero players this century to post a career wRC+ above 100 with a slugging percentage worse than Winn’s career .359 (minimum 1,000 plate appearances).
Why has Winn struggled to produce extra-base hits the last few years? His xwOBA on fly balls last season was just .230 compared to a league average of .411. Given this poor performance, you would think it would help that Winn reduced his fly ball rate by 6 percentage points last season to 34.5%. But a couple of problems came with his change in batted-ball profile. Winn actually hit more fly balls to right field in 2026 than he did in 2025; the reduced overall rate came at the expense of fly balls to left and center that have an actual chance to do some damage. And the reduction in fly balls led to an increase in ground balls, rather than the presumed goal of hitting more line drives. Add it all up, and you are getting the worst of both worlds, sacrificing any chance at power by taking an opposite-field approach, but then hitting more weak ground balls and popups to right.
If I could find an easy fix to Winn’s power problem, I would be employed by a major league team, so I won’t bore you with a long list of suggested adjustments. I will say that if Winn does break out offensively at some point, I think it will come from either a huge increase in strength and power like Brice Turang’s or a more subtle shift like the one Swanson made as he matured as a hitter. It isn’t going to come from turning into Luis Arraez or Steven Kwan. So, Mr. Winn, eat your protein this offseason and let it rip.
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
- Fewer ads
- Create community posts
- Comment on articles, community posts
- Rec comments, community posts
- New, improved notifications system!
















”






