
Like everyone else, the ALDS and the conclusion to the Yankees’ 2026 season left me very frustrated. It just feels like another year of missed chances with a roster that is good, but not good enough as it probably should be. There will always be moves made and unmade that you can look back on that you wish you could go back over. However, there’s no way to really do that… except in the fictional world.
I decided to take out my frustration at the end of the season in the only way in which I have a real way to: using the MLB The Show video game. Messing around with the game, I wanted to see how many pieces the Yankees truly were away from maybe winning the World Series. None of this is completely realistic, but that’s not the point, I wanted to use the Yankees to put a hurt on some teams. With that in mind, here is my experiment.
To start, let’s upgrade the Yankees’ weakest position, both in the game and arguably in real life this year: third base. To do that, we’ll not only add to the Yankees but weaken their biggest enemies this year by taking Junior Caminero from the Rays.

The Caminero addition doesn’t help the Yankees avoid a slow start to the season, as they’re hovering around .500 well into June. However, they play good baseball after that, finishing 91-71 and getting the top AL Wild Card. The Rays are significantly weakened without their star, but the Yankees still fall short of the Blue Jays.

Judge stays fully healthy and hits over 50 homers, with Caminero hitting 41 himself. However, this universe’s Cam Schlittler struggles to a 5.00 ERA, while Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodón both throw less than 10 innings in the regular season due to injury. Max Fried picks up the slack, putting up a nice season though. In the end, this universe’s 2026 ends like the real universe’s 2025: the Yankees lose to Toronto in four in the ALDS. The Dodgers end up completing the three-peat, beating the Royals (???) in the World Series.

For round two, we decide to shore up the designated hitter spot and take the guy who will likely win this year’s AL MVP in Yordan Alvarez.

Despite that, the Yankees again go just 91-71. Alvarez isn’t really the issue, as he posts a .898 OPS with 32 home runs. This time, they’re severely hampered by Caminero missing over 100 games with injury, and Amed Rosario struggles in his place. However this time around, those 91 wins are enough to take the AL East.
This time with home field advantage, the Yankees again take on the Blue Jays in the ALDS. This series goes all the way to Game 5, and features a wild ending. Taking a 2-0 lead into the ninth, David Bednar coughs up three runs to put the Jays three outs away. However, the Yankees rally in the ninth, scoring twice with Austin Wells getting a walk-off, series winning hit to move onto the ALCS.
In the ALCS, the Yankees face the Mariners, who put up the top record in the AL. The series again goes to the final game and is also decided by one run, albeit not in as dramatic circumstances. A 5-4 Yankees win in Seattle sends the Yankees to the World Series, with Bednar recording the save this time around.
In the Fall Classic, the Yankees dispatch the Cubs in five games, winning Game 5 after failing to sweep the series. The latest addition, Alvarez, proves to be a very big one. He goes 3-for-4 with a walk and an RBI in the clinching win. He OPSed .912 in the postseason in general. Cody Bellinger ended up winning the World Series MVP though, having homered and drove home three runs in the clinching Game 5 win.

So that’s what it would apparently take for this Yankees’ roster to get over the hump and win the World Series, but I’m still out for blood. I want to know what it will take for the Yankees to get towards record setting territory. While I’m hopeful about George Lombard Jr., we can still upgrade that spot even if he turns out pretty good. Let’s go get the best shortstop in baseball.

An 8.7 WAR season from Witt — and 6.0 from Austin Wells??? — gets the Yankees to 100-62, but an ALCS loss to the Mariners. Now, it’s time to go in for the kill.





Doing all that apparently only gets the Yankees to 106-56. That may have to do with the fact that somehow Mark Leiter Jr. reappeared on the roster.

While it takes six games, the Yankees do end up taking the World Series over the Brewers.
While the Yankees’ roster is now excellent, the depth still lacks. Plus, we’ve been leaving “budgets” on, and we should not have to follow those. Let’s go truly nuts.




The Yankees now have the top rated depth chart at every position except for first base. As far as that goes, I don’t want to trade Ben Rice, and we can’t upgrade Paul Goldschmidt until June 15th as he was an offseason free agency signing. Once that deadline goes past, I decide to make a further move as the team is still not good enough for my liking.

Finally now have we assembled a truly unstoppable team. It’s baseball, so they still end up losing over 40 games, but this version of the Yankees goes 119-43. They score 985 runs on the season which is over six per game. They drop just four total games over their three playoff series. Two come in the ALCS against the Twins, which seems unrealistic for several reasons. However, I now feel better about things, at least until I turn off my XBOX.



















