Jun 27, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh Pirates center fielder Jake Mangum (left) and shortstop Jared Triolo (19) congratulate second baseman Brandon Lowe (5) crossing home plate on a three-run home run against the Cincinnati Reds during the third inning at PNC Park. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
The Pittsburgh Pirates were better in 2026. Their 82 wins were the most for the club since 2018. And while they fell short of the playoffs, the offense was much-improved, even if the team’s starting rotation let them down a bit. Well, one popular analytics site has the Bucs pegged for a much better outcome in 2027, as FanGraphs and their ZiPS rating has the Bucs as a Wild Card team next season.
Here’s what FanGraphs has to say about the Bucs after finishing just four games off on their Pirates prediction for 2026.
“When it came to projecting the Pittsburgh Pirates’ 2026 season, ZiPS was grumpier than most other public systems and the FanGraphs staff, forecasting the team for just a 79-83 record in the final preseason standings. The Pirates beat that mark by three wins, finishing at 82-80, for the team’s first winning record since 2018. Unfortunately, that wasn’t enough, as the Pirates finished six back (realistically seven because of tiebreakers) of the Philadelphia Phillies, who grabbed the National League’s final Wild Card spot. However, despite not having snuck into October the way that many thought they would, ZiPS likes the Pirates significantly more this time around.”
The ZiPS rating apparently likes both the offense and the pitching staff, saying this about the plate production in Pittsburgh:
“Going through the lineup, there really isn’t much to hate, though there isn’t much to absolutely love, either. ZiPS still sees age as a big downside risk for Bryan Reynolds and isn’t (yet) buying Esmerlyn Valdez as a 130 wRC+ guy. I think re-signing Brandon Lowe would be a pretty big deal for this team, as he still gets the best WAR projection of anyone on the offense. As with the Brewers, ZiPS believes that Pittsburgh has good depth in the upper minors, though the Pirates lack bonafide future stars on the level of Jesús Made. The projections suggest that the team would be best-served by letting Murf Gray seize the third base job as soon as possible. Plus, Murf Gray sounds like the name of an 1880s superstar who tried to run over Arlie Latham in a Flocken Elektrowagen.
Given their good second- and third-tier talent, if the Pirates are willing to spend some money this offseason — not always a given — I hope they concentrate it in one or two good players rather than spreading it around to veteran memberberries as they have in recent years. I’m just not sure what signing Andrew McCutchen (sorry), Carlos Santana, Marcell Ozuna, or Tommy Pham could have realistically accomplished. If you want to crib from the Brewers, sign a reclamation projection or an interesting 28-year-old, and try to catch lightning in a bottle rather than buying a bottle that’s already free of electricity.“
And they think the pitching staff is due for a rebound and are very high on Mason Montgomery out of the bullpen.
“ZiPS sees the Pirates with a middle-tier offense, but it really likes the pitching staff. I can’t exactly claim that the system is going out on a projection limb, however; our Depth Charts, which are currently Steamer-based, have the Pirates as the game’s no. 3 pitching staff by WAR, behind just the Phillies and Dodgers. Paul Skenes will very likely have a better 2027, and you know you’re a good pitcher when people are down on a 4.2-WAR season. Braxton Ashcraft is a perfect no. 2 starter, and ZiPS puts Jared Jones and Bubba Chandler both safely over the 100 ERA+ line. Even Mitch Keller’s 4.50 projected ERA is a good bit better than his disappointing 2026, and certainly better than par for the fifth-best starter in your rotation.
The bullpen isn’t full of name-brand relievers, but ZiPS still pegs the group as easily among the top 10 in baseball. Mason Montgomery is terrific, and Luke Weaver should be better than he was in his brief Pirates stint this summer. ZiPS thinks Carmen Mlodzinski is just as good as Weaver when used as a reliever, and when deployed exclusively in relief, ZiPS sees the whole ‘pen with ERAs in the 3.00s until you get to Antwone Kelly and Evan Sisk, and even they just barely land on the wrong side of 4.00. Seth Hernandez probably isn’t ready just yet, but ZiPS sees Hunter Barco, Connor Wietgrefe, and Khristian Curtis as reasonable back-end fill-ins, and possibly more if they hit their upside.“
And finally, the prediction for a Wild Card run:
“It’s still early, but as they’re constructed right now, ZiPS sees the Pirates as being in a strong position to make a Wild Card run, even though they’re a tier down from the Brewers and Cubs in the NL Central.“
So what do you guys think of the FanGraphs ZiPS projection? Are they right on? Or way off base? Tell us in the comments what you’re thinking and also your projection for the Pirates in 2027.
In the final week of the Arizona Fall League season, the Peoria Javelinas played two games to finish the regular season and lost one. By losing that game, they dropped out of a tie for first in the league and finished second to the Surprise Saguaros.
By being the top two finishers, the Javelinas and Saguaros both had a bye for the first round of the playoffs. For the semi-finals, the Javelinas played the Salt River Rafters after the Rafters defeated the Mesa Solar Sox the day before.
In their match, the Javelinas won 6-5 and advanced to the final. In the other semi-final game, the Surprise Saguaros defeated the Glendale Desert Dogs 10-4. The two top finishers, who finished a game apart in the standings, met for the championship on Saturday at Peoria Sports Complex in a game televised nationally on MLB Network.
It was never really a contest as the Saguaros’ starter, RHP Justin Lampkin, struggled out of the gate and was backed up by a leaky defense. The Javelinas scored five runs in his two innings, with only one of those being an earned run.
The Javelinas starter, Reds prospect RHP Luke Coleman, was masterful over five innings of work and allowed four hits and no runs with three walks and six strikeouts. He was backed by great defense, with Padres prospect Justin DeCriscio playing second base and being instrumental in many infield outs.
Padres No. 13 prospect RHP Kannon Kemp came on in the sixth inning in relief of Holman and struggled with his pitches against the first batter. Kemp features tremendous stuff. His four-seam fastball sits 96-99 mph with movement. His sinker runs in the same range; his hard slider sits in the high 80s, and he adds a high-80s changeup. His command is the issue after missing time in the past two seasons with injuries.
After walking the lead-off man in the sixth, Kemp got outs on a ground ball double-play and a strikeout. He also pitched himself into trouble in the seventh inning with two walks and a single to load the bases but then got three infield outs to strand the runners. Commenting on the broadcast for MLB Network were Jim Callis and Dan O’Dowd wtih Callis the prospect expert and O’Dowd the former GM of the Rockies. They agreed Kemp has great stuff but inconsistent command. He profiles as a high-leverage reliever if the Padres want him to move quickly but could also be a starter if he gets better command of all his pitches.
RHP Francis Peña came in to protect the lead in the ninth inning. He allowed a run on a walk, a hit, a grounder, and then a sac fly before retiring the side on another groundball to end the game.
On the offensive side, 2B DeCriscio went 1-for-3 with an RBI. He walked and struck out for his three appearances. OF Alex McCoy was 0-for-3 with a run scored after being hit by a pitch in his first at-bat. He also struck out twice.
For the two playoff games, Peña pitched in both for 1.2 innings with one run and two hits. He finished the AFL with a 1.59 ERA in 11.1 innings for the regular season, second to Luke Holman. The starter for the final game pitched 13 innings for the entire AFL season with a 0.69 ERA. He then went five innings in the final game to shut out the Surprise team.
Padres prospects in the AFL
Kemp finished the season with a 7.71 ERA in 14 innings with nine walks and 16 strikeouts. His command issues were the culprit for his high ERA. LHP Igor Gil finished with a 3.86 ERA in nine innings pitched with 10 walks and 13 strikeouts. RHP Winyer Chourio also featured inconsistent command and finished with a 4.60 ERA in 15.2 innings pitched with 14 walks and 13 strikeouts. RHP Jordan Valenzuela had difficulties and only appeared in seven games with 6.1 innings pitched and had a 9.95 ERA with seven walks and six strikeouts.
Outfielder Qrey Lott was a late addition to the Javelinas roster and only appeared in two games with four at-bats and one strikeout. He was added on Nov. 9, just for the last two games of the schedule. Lott played in 95 games for Low-A Lake Elsinore in the 2026 season.
McCoy finished the six weeks with a .250/.372/.578 line and was noted to have tremendous power by the commentators on the broadcast but struggles versus breaking balls and that leads to a high strikeout rate. They noted his ceiling to be high if he can learn to handle breaking balls to go with his power.
Utility man DeCriscio was drafted as a defense-first shortstop in 2025. He has since been used by the Padres as a super utility player. For the Low-A Lake Elsinore Storm, DeCriscio played all over the infield except first base and also played the corner outfield spots. He was promoted to Single-A Fort Wayne in May and finished the season with Double-A San Antonio. In the AFL, he played second base for the Javelinas. The second baseman finished the AFL season with a .288/.403/.519 hitting line and then hit .600 in the playoffs with a strong defensive effort.
Catcher/DH Ty Harvey played in 20 games for Peoria with a .241/.389/.276 line. He had two doubles and no home runs for a player drafted with plus power. He lost a lot of the regular season to injury and needed the AFL for reps before the offseason began. His lack of power could be a reflection of his loss of strength from a broken hand.
HR Derby and Fall Stars
The previous weekend featured the AFL Home Run Derby and Fall Stars game. OF Alex McCoy participated in both, while 2B Justin DeCriscio was one of the final two added to the team by fan vote. RHP Kannon Kemp was also selected for the game.
McCoy was eliminated in the first round of the derby but distinguished himself by hitting a ball 503 feet in the elimination round. That was the farthest home run of the night.
In the Fall Stars Game, the NL defeated the AL in a 7-4 final. McCoy was inserted in the seventh inning as a pinch hitter and DH. He had two at-bats and went 1-for-2 with a run scored. DeCriscio was a sub and had three at-bats going 1-for-3 with a bunt single that drove in the go-ahead run in the fourth inning.
The two players to benefit the most from the AFL for the Padres were DeCriscio and Peña. They both distinguished themselves with their performances and made a case for Peña to be added to the 40-man roster. DeCriscio will be a fun watch as he works his way through the minor league system.
Padres News:
Fernando Tatis Jr. had a strange start to his season, but he rounded into form over the second half. He did well enough to be named to the All-MLB First Team and like many of his teammates he also received a grade from Lincoln Zdunich of Gaslamp Ball.
Baseball News:
The Milwaukee Brewers made a trade with the San Francisco Giants for reliever Ryan Walker.
MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA - SEPTEMBER 27: Corey Seager #5 of the Texas Rangers celebrates his two-run home run against the Minnesota Twins with teammates in the ninth inning at Target Field on September 27, 2026 in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The Twins defeated the Rangers 6-4. (Photo by David Berding/Getty Images) | Getty Images
Good morning.
Considering they’re apparently trying to unload their own Tarik Skubals this winter, ESPN’s David Schoenfield places the Texas Rangers in the not likely to sign Skubal tier while suggesting a reunion with Tyler Mahle as a backup plan.
MLB dot com’s Max Ralph checks out the reliever market which is of note as the Rangers will be pretty much purchasing an entire bullpen for a third consecutive winter.
Mark Feinsand writes that Corey Seager is Texas’ prime trade candidate this offseason, with Jacob deGrom, Nathan Eovaldi and Brandon Nimmo also holding expensive deals that they’d probably love to move.
PHOENIX, ARIZONA - MAY 09: Infielder Ketel Marte #4 of the Arizona Diamondbacks throws past Jazz Chisholm Jr. #2 of the Miami Marlins to complete a double play during the first inning of the MLB game at Chase Field on May 09, 2022 in Phoenix, Arizona. (Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images) | Getty Images
Just for fun’s sake, let’s say the Phillies were actually pursuing one of these two players this offseason. We have seen no indication that they are in on Jazz Chisholm in free agency, nor are they actively looking to make a deal for Ketel Marte.
But this is silly season!
If the Phillies were actually looking to grab one of these two talents, which would be the better fit for the Phillies? Personalities do come into play, which may be neither of them comes to Philadelphia, but more likely there are actual baseball reasons why neither is likely to come here.
SEATTLE, WASHINGTON - SEPTEMBER 23: Randy Arozarena #56 of the Seattle Mariners reacts after hitting a single during the fifth inning against the Houston Astros at T-Mobile Park on September 23, 2026 in Seattle, Washington. (Photo by Jack Compton/Getty Images) | Getty Images
While there is no Pete Alonso in this year’s free agent pool, former division rival Randy Arozarena is the best bet to fix Baltimore’s lackluster offense.
The Orioles had many problems during the 2026 season, but their most drastic shortcoming was their offensive output. Sure, marquee free-agent signing Alonso was awesome and delivered even more than was asked of him. However, the O’s simply didn’t coalesce as a lineup around the Polar Bear.
Before last season, many projected Baltimore to challenge the Yankees for the title of best lineup in the American League. Instead, the Orioles’ 4.46 runs/game was 6th in the AL and just below the Major League average of 4.48 runs/game. The Baltimore lineup often struggled to put the ball in play, finishing with the AL’s second-worst batting average and second-most strikeouts.
Arozarena cannot single-handedly fix all of the Orioles’ offensive problems, but he has the most offensive upside of any bat in the current free agent class. The former Rookie of the Year and ALCS MVP is coming off the best season of his career as the only bright spot in a weak Mariners lineup. In 2026, Arozarena set career highs with a 5.7 bWAR, a .281 average and a .865 OPS. The former longtime Tampa Bay Ray also posted his sixth straight 20-20 season and his fifth season in the last six with 30+ doubles.
The Orioles struggled to make consistent contact as a team last year, an area where Arozarena made big leaps during his second full season in Seattle. The 31-year-old’s career year was fueled by a noticeable drop in his swing-and-miss rate, as he whiffed on a career-low 26.3% in 2026. That translated to a dramatic dip from a 27% strikeout rate in 2025 to a 21.6% strikeout rate in 2026—as Arozarena registered fewer than 150 strikeouts in a full season for the first time in his career.
The Cuban-born, Mexican outfielder can be a better version of what the Orioles got from Taylor Ward, while also giving Baltimore another weapon to deploy against left-handed pitchers. Baltimore’s outfielders only produced a .674 OPS last season, the third-worst mark in all of baseball. Among all qualified outfielders, Arozarena’s .865 OPS was 4th last season, while his wRC+ of 151 was second only to NL MVP Pete Crow-Armstrong.
The O’s have had long and well-documented struggles hitting left-handed pitching. Despite having baseball’s best lefty masher in Coby Mayo, the Orioles against LHPs finished 17th in OPS (.702), 26th in average (.233) and had the most Ks vs. lefties (503). Teaming Arozarena with Mayo would give the Orioles the best pair of southpaw smashers in the majors. The outfielder hit .306 with 11 home runs and a .950 OPS last year vs. lefties, joining Mayo as one of only five players with a .300+ average, 10+ HR and a .900+ OPS against southpaws.
Arozarena would also seamlessly slide into the Orioles lineup next year. Colton Cowser is the only outfielder currently on the roster who seems guaranteed playing time next year. Dylan Beavers had a disappointing rookie year and will probably only play against RHPs until he improves. After playing in only 139 games across two seasons in Baltimore, the oft-injured Tyler O’Neill could be on his way out of the organization. Unlike the infield, where the O’s have too many mouths to feed, it will be easy to find space for Arozarena in the outfield.
The only aspect of his game that makes Arozarena a questionable fit is his defense. Colton Cowser played Gold Glove-caliber defense last year, but the rest of the outfield was subpar. By pretty much every defensive metric, Arozarena is also a below-average outfielder. In FanGraphs’ Defensive Runs Saved, he finished with -2. He finished with -5 Outs Above Average (according to Statcast) while also possessing one of the weakest outfield arms in baseball.
The Orioles have typically been ok with starting at least one defensively inferior outfielder, as the shallow RF in Camden Yards can easily hide weak defenders. Signing a top-tier offensive outfielder like Arozarena might also allow them to call up elite defensive CF prospect Enrique Bradfield while shifting Cowser back to LF.
As arguably the top hitter on the free-agent market, it will likely take another $100M+ contract to secure the services of Arozarena. Last offseason, we saw Cody Bellinger sign a 5-year/$162.5M (32.5M/year) contract to return to the Yankees. As a slightly older player and a far inferior defender, I wouldn’t expect Arozarena to command $30M+/year. However, it wouldn’t be surprising to see him get a contract in the range of $100M/4 years or $125M/5 years.
The Orioles may have to even overpay if they truly want to get in on the Arozarena race. Teams like the Blue Jays, Phillies and Red Sox could all use corner outfield help, and we’ve often seen players choose teams with more recent success over competitive offers from the Orioles (Corbin Burnes in 2025, Kyle Schwarber in 2026).
However, if the Orioles can convince Arozarena to come to Baltimore, it’d be a huge step toward returning this organization to winning ways. Having made the World Series as a rookie with the Rays, led Mexico to a third-place finish at the 2023 World Baseball Classic and gone to the ALCS with Seattle in 2025, Arozarena is used to winning. Adding him to the Alonso-led Orioles offense, along with a potential bounceback from Gunnar Henderson, would give the O’s a batting order that can lead Baltimore back to the playoffs.
ATLANTA, GEORGIA - AUGUST 16: Ketel Marte #4 of the Arizona Diamondbacks returns to the dugout after scoring in the ninth inning of a game against the Atlanta Braves at Truist Park on August 16, 2026 in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Edward M. Pio Roda/Getty Images) | Getty Images
Over the weekend, I read one of the more fascinating grist-for-the-rumor-mill pieces I’ve seen in a while.
Basically, here’s the gist of the Ketel Marte situation.
First: he’s good at baseball. Before 2026, he had three straight years of 4+ fWAR. 2026 was certainly a dropoff year, but part of that drop was a big xwOBA underperformance. He still projects for 4ish WAR in 2027.
Second: he’s signed to a very team-friendly deal. He’s owed only $12 million in 2027, $20ish million the three years after that, and has a player option for $11.5 million in 2031. He made the back end of the Ben Clemens/FanGraphs Trade Value list in the middle of last season.
Third: there are clubhouse issues. He’s had two absences from the team in two years, rankling his teammates. If not for this, trade discussions would probably be laughable — but it seems like his welcome is well worn out at this point.
Fourth: Marte has ten-and-five rights, meaning he can veto any trade that involves him.
So, the Diamondbacks brass are in a really weird situation: they want to trade him, and are talking with teams about trading him, but Marte and his representation won’t give them a clear answer on what trades they will or won’t veto. As a result, the Diamondbacks have to negotiate with basically everyone, not knowing whether the deal they like best is one Marte will agree to… and whether frameworks that were fine as they “move down the list” of acceptable paths forward will remain that way as the timeline for making moves gets ever-compressed ahead of December 1 (and then, potentially, ever-compressed ahead of whatever season restart/modified Spring Training ends up happening).
The Orioles have been linked to Marte, but that’s just media two-and-two-together stuff. There are a bunch of teams that could have at least lukewarm interest in Marte, who would be a hot commodity if not for the situation that’s leading him to get floated in trade talks in the first place. The Reds, Dodgers, and Pirates all come to mind; the Blue Jays and Mets are East Coast teams that I wouldn’t necessarily rule out.
I don’t think the Braves would have any interest in adding to clubhouse volatility given how much they seem to emphasize not that, but Ozzie Albies sure could use a handcuff at this point anyway… even if acquiring Marte wouldn’t be a handcuff but more like a dungeon cell.
ST. PETERSBURG, FL - OCTOBER 26: Jake Bauers #9 of the Milwaukee Brewers runs home to score in the third inning during Game Three of the 2026 World Series presented by Capital One between the Milwaukee Brewers and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field on Monday, October 26, 2026 in St. Petersburg, Florida. (Photo by Mary DeCicco/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images
Happy Monday, everyone! It was a relatively quiet weekend in terms of news, but we’ve still got some stories to get you caught up on the goings on (going ons?) in baseball right now. The Tigers haven’t made any big moves (though hopefully they aren’t done making moves). We’ll touch on some general Tigers updates as well as what’s going on in baseball in general, so grab your coffee or other tasty beverage and let’s get right into it.
A rundown of the Tigers’ international free agent class.
Here is the current compiled Detroit Tigers 2027 IFA Class. (Props to @bkfan09 for the assistance in formulating this list)
Cesar Enmanuel Montero seems to have the current highest pre-agreement of this year Tigers class. Still up in the air on the status of this upcoming period… pic.twitter.com/zkOMLX8gkm
Bauers will be primarily the DH now that he’s with the Red Sox.
Red Sox plan for Jake Bauers is to mostly be the designated hitter while cycling in at first base to get Willson Contreras off his feet more, sources say. The Red Sox want Contreras healthy for 162 and that helps to that end.
BRADENTON, FL - FEBRUARY 14: Baltimore Orioles Executive Vice President and General Manager Mike Elias talks to the media during the 2025 Grapefruit League Spring Training Media Day at Pirate City on Friday, February 14, 2025 in Bradenton, Florida. (Photo by Mike Carlson/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images
Although the looming lockout seems to have the league expecting a flurry of activity before it hits, neither the Orioles nor any other team have started acting like they are feeling that pressure yet, with the thing still just more than two weeks away. That leaves more immediate concerns to deal with, such as tomorrow’s deadline to protect players from a Rule 5 draft that probably won’t end up happening this year.
The Orioles have a large number of players who at some point looked like they might have a good case to make to go on the 40-man roster to keep them safe from the draft. Heading into this season, you could guess at a dozen or even more, depending on how generous you wanted to be in projecting good things for some players. With all affiliated baseball over with for 2026, I think the Orioles have seven guys they’re really going to need to think about.
In this episode, I go through the 40-man math of how many open spaces there are and who could be easy fodder to trim to make room for some of these players. I discuss the seven players who I think should get a lot of consideration and which five of those I think that Elias will choose to protect this time around. We’ll find out what he decides tomorrow. In the meantime, check out my predictions here:
If the above player isn’t displaying, view this article in Incognito Mode or check it out on the show’s page.
This is my weekly podcast about whatever is going on lately with the Orioles. If you enjoyed this episode, please make sure to subscribe. You can get the show on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you prefer to access your podcasts.
How are you feeling about the way things are going with the Orioles as the lockout rapidly approaches? Answers could make it into the mailbag section of a future episode of the podcast.
WASHINGTON, DC - MAY 12, 2022: A closeup view of the New York Mets logo during the fifth inning against the Washington Nationals at Nationals Park on May 12, 2022 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Chris Bernacchi/Diamond Images via Getty Images) | Diamond Images/Getty Images
NEW YORK, NY - SEPTEMBER 24: Luis Gil #81 of the New York Yankees pitches during the game between the Tampa Bay Rays and the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium on Thursday, September 24, 2026 in New York, New York. (Photo by Mary DeCicco/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images
Even the most successful of teams in what they do best will not bat 1.000, and it usually has nothing to do with skill set—it’s just the way things go. The Yankees, who work so well with pitchers of different levels, have not been able to develop Gil the way they’d liked following his Rookie of the Year-winning campaign back in 2024—culminating in a disastrous, injury-riddled 2026 season, one of the most forgettable among all Yankee pitchers.
2027 Contract Status: After making a bit over $2.1 million in his first year of arbitration eligibility in 2026, Gil is set for a minimal raise by the nature of the system alone (assuming the Yankees choose to retain him)
Few players had quite as big an opportunity to insert themselves in the Yankees’ early-season plans during spring training as Gil, but the right-hander was unconvincing, allowing 11 runs in 19.2 innings. Although the strikeouts that had plummeted back in 2025 regained reasonable levels in spring, punching out 24, Gil certainly didn’t generate much confidence in his ability to retain that fifth starter spot before the return of established injured arms.
A scheduling break allowed the Yankees to begin the year with a four-man rotation, sending Gil to the minors and delaying his season debut until April 10th. The hard-throwing righty took the ball against the Rays and got hit with the loss, allowing three runs in four innings. Gil’s third outing sparked a bit of hope, holding the Red Sox scoreless in 6.1 innings, but even that game created doubts about the sustainability of his performance, doing it with three free passes and only two punchouts. (Indeed, Boston was so inherently lifeless at this point that within days, they would part ways with longtime skipper Alex Cora and several coaches.) The Astros knocked him around in his next outing and he was demoted on April 27th.
Luckily for the Yankees, the period between Gil’s demotion in late April and Rodón’s activation in early May was minimal, limiting the negative impact of this lack of a reliable fifth starter. To make matters worse, Gil didn’t even have the opportunity to work on his craft in the minors—shortly after his demotion, he was placed on the minor-league IL with shoulder inflammation, returning only in mid-August, making this an absence of over three months. While Aaron Boone went on the record saying that this injury was unrelated to any problems Gil might’ve been having in the major leagues, it’s difficult to separate the two — especially since his stuff was hardly crackling in a manner resembling the way it did during his breakout 2024.
A little short on bullpen arms, the Yankees quickly recalled Gil at the end of August after he got healthy, handing him the role of mop-up duty as a low-leverage arm—one he fulfilled reasonably well, finishing three straight games in September. While he kept opponents off the board, allowing just one earned run in eight innings out of the bullpen, any thoughts of rejoining the circle of trust for a postseason role, however small it might be, were long gone—the walks remained a problem, allowing seven free passes.
While his salary isn’t an obstacle, acknowledging any raise on the $2.1 million he might get in arbitration will be minor; Gil will be out of options next season, and while the Yankees may be hesitant to commit to a guaranteed roster spot for him over a full season (even in the bullpen), other pitching-strapped teams might not be so picky. It’d be one thing if the results weren’t going his way, but something under the hood made you feel confident in another approach.
From loss of velocity to a complete inability to locate consistently without the strikeout stuff to back up or alleviate a more erratic spray pattern, there is just not a lot of optimism to be had here. Gil’s future may very well be with a different uniform in 2027.
See more of the Yankees Roster Report Card series here.
DENVER, CO - SEPTEMBER 23: Colorado Rockies catcher Hunter Goodman (15) singles in the sixth inning during a game between the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Colorado Rockies at Coors Field on September 23, 2026 in Denver, Colorado. (Photo by Dustin Bradford/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
Earlier this month, Major League Baseball announced their Silver Slugger finalists. That Colorado Rockies catcher Hunter Goodman was one of them came as no surprise, especially to Rockies fans who gloried in the 41 homers their two-time All-Star catcher hit over the course of the 2026 season.
MLB.com’s Manny Randhawa writes of the Silver Slugger,
The Silver Slugger Award is presented to the best hitter at each position in each league annually, and it is voted on by MLB managers and coaches (who are not allowed to vote for players on their own teams). The coveted honor was established in 1980, with new categories for best-hitting utility player (2022) and best offensive team (2023) added in recent years.
Two points here are worth noting:
The award goes to the best hitter.
Managers and coaches cannot vote for their own players.
For me, the first line — “the best hitter” — stands out. That means the Silver Slugger should go to the player who has made the most offensive contributions to his team via hitting — and that doesn’t necessarily mean the most glamorous hits. Rather, it refers to consistent offensive production, so for me, that’s a key consideration.
The first thing to note is that in terms of offensive opportunities, both Moreno and Goodman had very similar years. Moreno played in 130 games while Goodman was in 138. (Both spent some time on the Injured list.) As a result, Goodman had 25 more plate appearances. Still, the comparison between the two players operates under similar sample sizes.
Now to the specifics.
Moreno’s 6.7 rWAR is significantly higher than Goodman’s 2.6 rWAR, an indicator that Moreno was (significantly) the better overall player.
Those numbers are born out in the rest of the data.
Moreno had 20 more hits than Goodman did (147 to 127, respectively), and he had a substantially higher batting average (.311 to .245, respectively). Granted, baseball has developed better tools for measuring hitting, so consider the other numbers.
Goodman outslugged Moreno by a lot — he had 41 home runs to Moreno’s 16 — and finished the season with an impressive .529 SLG compared to Moreno’s .486. In addition, Goodman led in extra-base hits, 63 to 53.
Consider, however, OBP. By that metric, Moreno is clearly the superior hitter with his .388 OBP easily besting Goodman’s .310. Add to that, Goodman’s 30.5% K%, the 10th highest in baseball, compared to Moreno’s 14.6% K%, which is the 27th lowest. Therein lies the biggest contrast: While Goodman hit a lot of homers, it came at the cost of striking out more whereas Moreno traded power for getting on base.
So, who will win?
That depends on what the voters value: Do they value slugging, or do they value getting on base?
OPS+ shows that Moreno was significantly more effective overall — his 143 OPS+ is 28 points higher than Goodman’s 115 OPS+.
Chicks may dig the long ball, but the voters are probably going to value getting on base, which clearly favors Gabriel Moreno.
Baseball: World Series: Milwaukee Brewers Jake Bauers (9) fields a fly ball vs Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field. Game 4. St. Petersburg, FL 10/27/2026CREDIT: Erick W. Rasco (Photo by Erick W. Rasco/Sports Illustrated via Getty Images)(Set Number: X164972 TK1)
Will Sammon and Ken Rosenthal report that the Red Sox knew the cost of Bauers (in draft picks as well as money as he was given a qualifying offer) and decided that Bauers and winning now was worth it. (The Athletic sub. req.) Plus a bunch of other tidbits from the offseason as well as how almost no one is getting ejected for arguing balls and strikes now that we have the ABS system.
Keith Law also applauds the Red Sox for the deal (The Athletic sub. req.) and argues that the Brewers should replace Bauers internally and concentrate on adding pitching this winter.
MILWAUKEE, WI - MARCH 23: Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Blake Holub (96) pitches during a spring training game between the Milwaukee Brewers and the Cincinnati Reds at American Family Field on March 23, 2026 in Milwaukee, WI. (Photo by Larry Radloff/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
Sunday was a good day for a lot of San Francisco Giants fans. In their quest to free spots on the 40-man roster ahead of Tuesday’s Rule 5 protection deadline, the Giants traded reliever Ryan Walker to the Milwaukee Brewers for a pair of prospects.
For some Giants fans, it’s a win because of how much Walker had struggled since his excellent 2024. He regressed to mediocre in 2025, before struggling mightily in 2026, posting a 7.16 ERA and a 5.52 FIP, with 23 strikeouts against 19 walks in 32.2 innings, and spending much of the year in AAA Sacramento.
For other Giants fans, it’s a win because of Walker’s open role in the Pride Night jumble of bigotry in June, where he wrote a bible verse on his cap for his appearance, and doubled down after the game.
But the Walker trade is not just about getting Walker off the team; it’s also about getting some talent back for the Minor Leagues. The Giants got two prospects from the Brewers: Blake Holub, a 28-year old righty who had a strong season in AAA this year, and Gavin Perry, a 23-year old righty taken in the 11th round in this year’s draft, who has yet to make his MLB debut.
So let’s watch some videos of both of them, because that’s all the baseball we’ve got.
Blake Holub recorded the final six outs tonight (see below) to earn his first career Double-A save and help lower Erie’s magic number to 2.
MILWAUKEE, WI - SEPTEMBER 26: Alec Burleson #41 of the St. Louis Cardinals rounds the bases after hitting a solo home run in the third inning during the game between the St. Louis Cardinals and the Milwaukee Brewers at American Family Field on Saturday, September 26, 2026 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. (Photo by Kylie Bridenhagen/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images
I’m not going to completely pivot my articles this offseason – I still want the Cardinals to try to win and will come up with possible ways to do that, however – not to keep going back to our conversation with Derrick Goold last week – knowing the Cardinals probably won’t look at 2027 and judge it by wins and losses, I feel like it would be appropriate to look at a different approach to the offseason as well. If the Cardinals aren’t going to try to improve the team and instead focus on the future, trading players close to free agency would certainly make sense.
And sadly nobody makes more sense than Alec Burleson in that regard. Burleson is in an interesting spot. He may have just had a career year and we don’t know it. Or he hasn’t reached his peak yet. Or what he showed last year is entirely what he is and we can expect that for a few more seasons. Any of these outcomes would be entirely unsurprising. He’s also simultaneously a very reliable and stable player. So when I say he may have just had a career year, if that ends up being true, it’s because he’s about a 2 WAR player instead. And if he hasn’t reached his peak, that likely means 4 WAR is his peak, not MVP contender (notwithstanding that he actually got an MVP vote)
If this were 2002, I’d say trade him absolutely. There is very little chance he repeats his RBI season. He does appear to change his approach based on if there are men on. When nobody is on base, he has a .228 ISO and hit 17 homers. With men on base, it’s a .163 ISO. But, his BABIP was rather extreme. He had a .423 BABIP with runners in scoring position. That seems unlikely to repeat. Most teams will not up their price based on his RBI, so it seems more likely you’d get fair value than a haul.
What is Burleson worth on the market? Let’s calculate. MLB Trade Rumors calculates his 2027 salary at $8.3 million. It will be his second year in arbitration. Let’s say his last year in arbitration is $14 million. That means over the next two years, he’ll be paid $22.3 million. What will his projection be? Steamer projects 2 WAR over 570 PAs. Don’t want to be a biased fan, but I think that’s low. I think I’m going to hang my hat on his xwOBA a little bit, because it was .374, which greatly exceeded his actual wOBA of .353. With a career .291 BABIP, it makes sense why Steamer would project a .294 BABIP, I feel like the contact quality suggests either a higher BABIP in a projection is reasonable.
I also think the PAs is a bit low, which may be why the Fangraphs depth charts section has him with 609 PAs across 141 games. While he had just 546 PAs in 2025, it did come in 139 games. In 2025, 7 of 12 appearances that came with two or less plate appearances were in March and April and all 12 came before the All-Star break. So from a health perspective, he’s a fairly likely bet to appear in 141 games. With the increased games comes 2.3 WAR. I think it’s entirely reasonable to raise that to 2.5 WAR basically because of the xwOBA, which I doubt is factored into the Steamer projection at all. Some version of that might be in ZiPS though. Plus, any team trading for him probably sees him as a 2.5 or better player anyway, and that’s probably how a team will have to see him for the Cardinals to trade him in the first place. I could actually go higher, but I’m trying to keep it in the realm of projection-based rather than hope.
Since I’m slightly fudging the numbers for 2027, at least based on a projection I actually do have (this might actually be low whenever ZiPS releases its numbers), I’m going to have to stick with the half a win decline for his second season. So that’s 4.5 WAR while getting paid $22.3 million. In other words, his trade value, hypothetically speaking, is about $23 million in prospect value and/or established MLB value.
If you were expecting a haul for Burleson, sadly you won’t get one. This isn’t even enough for a top 100 prospect. Fangraphs prospect values are not updated, and won’t be until they release the team lists, so I don’t think I can come up with proposals from other teams that might be realistic. What I can give you is – and I actually think might be more informative – is a Cardinals package equivalent. Basically, if the Cardinals were trading for Burleson, what kind of prospects would they have to give up to get Burleson? Based on the prospects I can come up with in the Cardinals’ system can maybe help you know whether or not you think the return would be worth trading him. Because just about everyone reading this is significantly more knowledgable about the Cardinals’ prospects than any collection of names I could come up with.
Unlike my usual hypothetical deals, I can use any prospect I want. We’re looking for the best versions of these prospects, so it makes sense to present the best possible version of these deals. It wouldn’t make any sense for me to hoard a prospect in a trade that could physically never happen. If the Cardinals trade Burleson, they will want the best possible 45 FV prospect. And the Cardinals certainly don’t have to trade Burleson, so fine if you don’t want to give me that prospect, you aren’t getting him.
Well if we’re trading Burleson, I think I want the centerpiece to be a hitter. I’m kind of satisfied with where the pitching depth is and a lot of the position player depth is farther away than ideal. ORSTLcards highlighted this in his recent article. In addition, to state the obvious, but the Cardinals are trading away a key piece of the offense, so it’d be weird not to get offense back.
So in light of this, my centerpiece of the trade is a 45+ FV, which comprises most of the $23 million. And amusingly, I may have actually come up with a trade people actually want because it just so happens the Cardinals do have an enticing, probably 45+ FV prospect in their system at a position of need and that trading the equivalent of that guy would give the Cardinals two chances at a good CF: Tai Peete. I’m guessing that he’s 45+ by the way. He was 40+ last year, so he’s at least a 45 now.
The second part of this trade is harder. It’s either a 40 FV hitter or 40 FV pitcher. You have two options here – you can go lottery ticket or you can go close to the majors, but not very high potential. For position players, the Cardinals really don’t have any of the latter. Maybe that will change with the update, but anybody who is a 40 FV hitter is not particularly close to the majors. Cesar Prieto was, but I don’t think he is anymore. I’m not really interested in a likely bench player though as the second piece, Cardinals are covered in that area.
Pitching-wise though, it’s a bit more appealing to get someone close to the majors who is largely expected to go to the bullpen. The best and closest version of this kind of prospect is probably Brian Curley. An older draftee acquired in the Lars Nootbaar trade, he struck out 29.5% of hitters in High A, and then wasn’t very good in AA, but it was his first pro season. According to Fangraphs, he has three pitches with the potential to be above average, but they do not think highly of his command. Which is interesting, because walks were not actually his problem in AA. But command is more than not walking guys. I’m not interested in the 40 FV pitching prospect who is far away.
The 40 FV hitting prospect who is far away, however, might have actually potential. But they are incredibly unlikely to achieve that potential. But this kind of prospect is certainly the kind you grab if you want to make a trade look really, really lopsided in the future and not for the team getting Burleson. Hello, Emanuel Luna, come aboard the train. He played in 9 fantastic games in the DSL. He will be 18 next year. So those are your offers. If you were receiving this prospect in return, and keep in mind, you have an attachment to these prospects, so the Tai Peete of another organization will be someone you will be more objective about – would you take a trade like this?
Alec Burleson for Tai Peete and Brian Curley/Emanuel Luna
Who needs a 1B?
How robust of a market will there be for him? Easy way to figure it out is how many teams would be interested. I think most teams will acquire him wanting him to play 1B or DH. If they have a massive amount of money invested in their 1B and reasonable options to play DH, I can’t see them wanting Burleson.
Out
Athletics (Nick Kurtz/Brent Rooker), Orioles (Pete Alonso), Red Sox (they just got Jake Bauers), Astros (they’re paying too much for Christian Walker to be almost average, plus someone has to DH of Carlos Correa, Yordan Alvarez, and Isaac Paredes), Angels (not really trying to win and still going with Nolan Schanuel), Mariners (Josh Naylor just got a big deal and is very similar to Burly), Rays (Yandy Diaz and Jonathan Aranda are still here, and to trade for escalating contract is not Rays at all), Jays (they have so much money tied up in 1B/DH between Anthony Santander and Vladmir Guerrero Jr.)
Cubs (ignoring the in-division aspect, Michael Busch and they don’t actually have anywhere for Pedro Ramirez to play), Reds (in-divison + Sal Stewart), Dodgers (Freddie Freeman + Shohei Ohtani), Marlins (I just think Owen Cassie/Kyle Stowers/Griffin Conine and Burleson on the same team makes no sense, and they’re don’t really trade for escalating salaries), Phillies (Kyle Schwarber/Bruce Harper make it hard to see a fit unless they want him in the outfield), Pirates (I think they’re committed to Ryan O’Hearn and Spencer Horwitz, both are left-handed and restricted to 1B and DH), Giants (Bryce Eldridge and Rafael Devers)
Probably out
Tigers (Spencer Torkelson isn’t good, but they seem committed to him plus I don’t think they’re giving up on Kerry Carpenter), Royals (same for Vinnie Pasquatino/Salvador Perez DH’d 82 games last year), Yankees (I know they’ve been thrown as an option purely because of park, but Ben Rice and Luis Garcia make it seem pretty unlikely), Rockies (they could use Burleson, but also they’re not trying to win), Brewers (I mean Burleson could replace Bauers, but this strikes me as very unlikely)
Maybe
Guardians (would be unlike them with Kyle Manzardo and Jo Adell at DH, but neither of them are actually good), Braves (if they are okay with him DH’ing, where they appear weak), Padres (Gavin Sheets is not great and Luis Campusano had what looks like an unsustainably great year with the bat… but maybe they’re okay with these options), Nationals (Andres Chapparo had a great year in half a season, and they have 4 young outfielders that have to play, but also Chapparo probably isn’t going to be good, so if they want to be proactive, they make sense. Chapparo is also right-handed)
Need
Twins (current 1B is… Royce Lewis?), Rangers (Jake Burger/Justin Foscue is their 1B/DH right now on Roster Resource), DBacks (Tim Tawa is projected 1B at the moment. Below average hitter last year), Mets (Jared Young and Jorge Polanco are projected 1B/DH – that’s really bad!)
Of the teams, Diamondbacks and Rangers actually seem like they might be trying to win. Most of the maybe group either isn’t trying to win or is generally pretty cheap, but actually would get a player like Burleson if either of those things wasn’t true. So one of them could be realistic. Market is okay, not necessarily screaming out overpay for Burleson though.
Book Corner
I am making progress on Crime and Punishment. I have read five of the six parts, so I’m hoping to be done by Thursday. The biggest difficulty is the long paragraphs. The translation I am reading is trying to stay true to the words of Fyodor Dostoevsky, but splitting up the paragraphs would make it so much easier to read, it’d be worth it in my opinion. I mean my eyes start glazing over when I get to the second page of the same paragraph and notice that the paragraph doesn’t seem to end on that same page.
Also I don’t know if this is just how Russians speak in the 19th century or a Dostoevsky thing , but man every character goes on these long tangents and I don’t think he does a good enough job of distinguishing them from each other. They all sound like they could be from the same person. I think the characterization of the characters is distinct to be clear, but sometimes when they talk, they talk the same way. A meandering, over-explaining, formal lecture that never ends. I know we have short attention spans, but when we talk to each other, one person doesn’t typically talk for five minutes without the other person saying a word, and that happens all the time in this book.
Part five almost lost me. Not to the point of stopping, but just in terms of “why are you doing this to me?” He just begins part five from a completely different point of view to a character we have barely read about and I am reading this section and thinking “I don’t care about this, why are we making this diversion?” He sort of gets me back, because I learn why. And then the ending weirdly turns full soap opera? A random death out of nowhere and then a genuine “Surprise, but I actually heard everything you said somehow.” I know soap operas weren’t a thing then but it’s still jarring as hell when nothing before this has been soap opera-like at all.
I will finish Part Six and give my final thoughts on Thursday.
KANSAS CITY, MO - APRIL 10: Kansas City Royals shortstop Adalberto Mondesi (27) reacts after flying out to end the fourth inning of an MLB game against the Cleveland Guardians on April 10, 2022 at Kauffman Stadium in Kansas City, Missouri. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
“I think Carter has stepped up into that [primary] spot, and I think what’s best for us is what’s going to be best for Salvy,” manager Matt Quatraro said last week.
That doesn’t mean Perez’s catching days are behind him.
“If Salvy is hitting and producing, he’s shown that he can be a really viable option in the middle of the order, whether that’s DH, play a little first [and] obviously he’s going to catch,” Quatraro said.
Before you delete this email, hear me out. Jazz Chisholm Jr. is, at his best, a dynamic player. He went for 30/30 in 2025 and, while none of the five tools scream elite, they’re more than good enough to be an above average player and an upgrade for the Royals at second base.
He did slump in 2026, with his home run total dropping to 19 and his strikeout rate ballooning to almost 30 percent because he chased out of the zone more than he had ever before.
The problem is, Chisholm doesn’t always seem to be at his best. In fact, he seemed to wear out his welcome in New York. The Yankees didn’t extend a qualifying offer, so he doesn’t come with that baggage. That makes Chisholm an ideal candidate for a short-term “prove it” contract. Dangle two years at $40 million with an opt out and the opportunity to pair with Bobby Witt Jr. up the middle. See if that will motivate him. I think it will.
The Royals ranked 25th in the Majors in rotation ERA (4.58), and while they will surely count on a rebound season from Seth Lugo and they could get Cole Ragans back in the second half, adding an arm or two this winter would seem to be a priority. Soroka posted a 3.41 ERA in 22 outings (21 starts) for Arizona in 2026, topping the 100-inning mark for the first time since his 2019 All-Star campaign. Unlike some other starters on the market, Soroka could fall within the Royals’ payroll range.
The Royals reportedly have interest in left-handed reliever A.J. Minter.
A.J. Minter is among the most popular left-handed relievers on the FA market, coming off one of the best seasons of his career (1.051 WHIP & 5.13 K/BB).
The Blue Jays, Nationals, Phillies, Rangers & Royals are among the teams with interest. @MLBNetwork