Orel Hershiser reflects on what Cristopher Sánchez's streak demands originally appeared on NBC Sports Philadelphia
LOS ANGELES — Orel Hershiser remembers the tight games before he remembers the number.
Before the Cherry Hill native became tied forever to 59, there were smaller calculations. A leadoff double. A hitter he wanted to avoid. A one-run lead, or no lead at all, with a Dodgers lineup giving him little room.
That rings true to Cristopher Sánchez’s scoreless stretch.
The Phillies’ ace has gone 44 2/3 consecutive innings without allowing a run. Last Wednesday, he passed Grover Cleveland Alexander for the longest scoreless streak in franchise history. He sits 14 1/3 innings from Hershiser’s major-league record, set in 1988.
Hershiser was a 29-year-old right-hander then. He won the National League Cy Young Award, led the majors with 23 wins, led the NL with 15 complete games and then took home NLCS and World Series MVP honors.
Sánchez is a 29-year-old left-hander now. He finished second in the National League Cy Young Award race last season after going 13-5 with a 2.50 ERA across 32 starts. This year, he has pitched like the favorite, with a 6-2 record, a 1.47 ERA and nine quality starts in 12 outings.
They are the only two pitchers in baseball history to make five starts in a calendar month and not allow a run.
Even so, Hershiser sees more than the chase.
“I think people forget it’s a team,” Hershiser said. “It’s a team record.”
That answer frames Sánchez’s streak better than the number alone.
The Phillies enter Tuesday with one of baseball’s worst offenses, third-worst in OPS and second-worst in on-base percentage. Since Sánchez’s streak began, their pitching staff has ranked third in ERA, though.
They have needed every zero.
Hershiser pitched through a similar season in 1988. The Dodgers won the World Series with a .657 regular-season OPS, the second-lowest by any champion since the Dead Ball Era.
From July 1 through the end of the regular season, they had the worst OPS in baseball. Their pitching staff finished with the second-best ERA in the majors.
The Dodgers scored just 18 total runs in those seven Hershiser starts, a streak that ran from Aug. 30 to Sept. 28.
“One of the things that probably helped me during the streak was our team wasn’t scoring very much,” Hershiser said. “It wasn’t like I had any 6-0 games where I could trade outs for runs.”
A larger lead would have changed his approach. Hershiser would have chased quick outs. He would have treated the game differently.
“I wouldn’t have worried about the streak,” he said. “I would have just said, ‘I want to get this game over with. I want to save my pitch count. I want to pitch nine innings.’”
The Dodgers did not give him that choice.
“Because the games were so close,” Hershiser said, “I think it made it extra special to prevent the run.”
Sánchez has pitched through a similar stretch. His starts have become the surest day on the Phillies’ schedule.
“You can’t go 30 innings,” Hershiser said, “without having a good team.”
He was not talking only about run support.
He meant the catcher. The defense. The positioning. A scoreless streak leaves no margin for sloppiness.
“Somebody’s got to pick the baseball up and throw it to first and not throw it away,” Hershiser said.
He still remembers the plays behind his own streak.
John Shelby made spectacular catches in center. Steve Sax made plays at second. The Dodgers made diving stops. In San Francisco, with runners on first and third, Los Angeles failed to turn a double play. Then the Giants’ Brett Butler was ruled out of the baseline, giving the Dodgers the double play anyway.
Hershiser still recalls it as one of the breaks that kept the streak alive.
He saw similar moments in Sánchez’s last start against San Diego. Balls reached the warning track. Justin Crawford crashed into the wall in center field to save a run.
Sánchez created the streak. The Phillies have defended it.
When asked what holds a scoreless streak together, Hershiser started with the backstop.
“The relationship with your catcher,” he said. “The ability for the data guys now to put the fielders in the right place, too. In my day, I moved the fielders with my eyes and my body language.”
The sport has changed. The work has not.
Sánchez still has to execute.
Hershiser built his streak, and his career, on command, feel and contact. He did not chase strikeouts unless the game called for one.
“I didn’t play go out and dominate,” Hershiser said. “I played hit it early, hit it weakly, hit it at somebody.”
Sánchez works from a similar base, with more swing-and-miss.
His sinker runs. His changeup fades. His arm slot gives hitters a tough look. His delivery hides the ball long enough for the movement to play.
“Deception,” Hershiser said.
The longtime Dodger sees the connection. He also sees the separation.
“He’s a groundball machine, which I was,” Hershiser said. “But he’s a better strikeout pitcher than I was.”
That gives Sánchez another way out of trouble. Hershiser had to choose his strikeout spots. Sánchez creates more of them.
Still, Hershiser values movement over pure velocity.
“A big leaguer can time a bullet,” Hershiser said. “So I would rather you throw the ball 94 with late movement than 99 as straight as a string in the middle.”
Nothing Sánchez throws is flat. His sinker and changeup move late, and they look similar long enough to force early swing decisions.
The modern game adds another layer.
Hershiser finished his streak with 10 scoreless innings in extras against San Diego, an unheard of effort nowadays.
But he does not view the current game as easier. Starters throw fewer innings, but clubs demand more of them.
“They’re also asked to throw at a higher effort level,” Hershiser said. “Everything’s being measured.”
He does not dismiss the information, but he rejects the idea that it captures every decision from the mound.
“From 30,000 feet, [the analytics] might be right,” Hershiser said. “But from ground level, I’m not sure they’re right.”
Sánchez’s streak lives in that gap between what the data says and what a pitcher still has to feel from the mound.
Now he has to see the Padres again on Wednesday to continue the chase.
“It’s not a streak until you start entering into the hierarchy of streaks,” Hershiser said.
Once his name moved up the list, the questions followed. USA Today. The Associated Press. The Los Angeles Times.
Hershiser reduced the job to the next pitch.
“I can throw one more sinking fastball away,” he said. “I can bounce one more curveball when I get ahead.”
Sánchez now faces that same narrow task.
The next pitch.
Dodgers legend Don Drysdale, whose record Hershiser chased, worked around the team then as a broadcaster and mentor at the time. As Hershiser moved closer, Drysdale gave him space.
“He was very much a gentleman,” Hershiser said.
Hershiser now watches from the other side.
Fellow Dodgers Clayton Kershaw, who reached 41 scoreless innings in 2014, and Zack Greinke, who reached 45 2/3 innings in 2015, got close. Greinke stopped almost exactly where Sánchez sits now.
Hershiser said his family and friends root harder against challengers than he does. He does not guard the record like property.
So he watches Sánchez with respect, not fear.
He knows the stress.
“The record is a record,” Hershiser said. “It’s not going to make or break or change my life anymore. It already did.”