In case you missed it yesterday, MLB Players’s Association (MLBPA) Executive Director Tony Clark resigned abruptly on Tuesday after an internal investigation found evidence he had an “inappropriate” relationship with his sister-in-law, who was concurrently employed by the union starting in 2023. Clark, a former MLB player, had held the position since 2013, when he became the sixth-ever director of the MLBPA (often called the “player’s union” or just “the union”) and the first former player.
It’s the latest firestorm for Clark, who is, along with the MLBPA, also under investigation for…they’re not using the e-word in the articles I read so let’s call it Financial Impropriety. Prosecutors in New York are looking into whether a joint venture between the MLBPA and its NFL counterpart was being used to enrich union leaders, while the feds are investigating an MLBPA-owned youth baseball organization that has some…let’s call them questionable accounting practices. This is what I get for writing late at night when our LLegal CounseLL is already asleep.
While the MLBPA is led by its executive director, there is an eight-player executive subcommittee, and it’s that player subcommittee that reportedly voted to ask for Clark’s resignation after hearing evidence of the alleged inappropriate relationship. The current committee consists of Marcus Semien, Brent Suter, Tarik Skubal, Chris Bassitt, Jake Cronenworth, Pete Fairbanks, Cedric Mullins, and Paul Skenes.
This is especially poor timing for another scandal to hit MLBPA, especially one that is such a needless distraction, as MLB and the MLBPA seem to be headed for a contentious collective bargaining agreement (CBA) re-negotiation and potential lockout following the end of the 2026 season. If you were following baseball closely in 2022-23, you probably remember the last time the CBA expired and the 99-day lockout that resulted and how we were all so so bored we actually did become a volcano blog for a little while.
The player subcommittee was also instrumental during that lockout; however, only Semien and Suter remain from that group. Three players left, and another three – Lucas Giolito, Jack Flaherty, and Ian Happ – were voted out after an attempt to oust Clark’s chief negotiator, Bruce Meyer, and replace him with Harry Marino, a former minor leaguer and labor champion who was instrumental in helping minor leaguers receive union benefits. The attempted coup failed, and now Meyer, who led negotiations during the previous bargaining period, will reportedly remain in place to continue in his role as Senior Director of Collective Bargaining.
But beyond this interpersonal drama (and the alleged Finance Crimes, I guess), inheriting the MLBPA right now is a little like being handed a bag of wet hornets. And also the bag is on fire. And also you are on fire. While being dropped blindfolded out of a plane towards a bullseye labeled “CBA NEGOTIATIONS.” The bullseye is also on fire. The biggest issue in the upcoming CBA negotiations will almost certainly be a salary cap. The owners and MLB want a cap on player earnings just as desperately as the players do not want it, and have indicated their intent to lock the players out for the 2027 season to try for the umpteenth time to demand it. But there’s no shortage of other things to fight about: there are also arguments to have about how arbitration works – or doesn’t work, from team’s perspectives, as players continue to score in arbitration hearings this winter like The Monstars – as well as revenue sharing. And if there’s time, maybe a fight about an international draft or maybe expansion. For fun.
It’s a grueling road ahead, and even if you think Clark was ineffective or even a figurehead who didn’t do the nitty-gritty numbers stuff, the MLBPA does find itself wrong-footed at a crucial moment. So while we wait for all this drama to play out, a thought exercise: Assuming there would be no negative influence on their career, if you could nominate anyone in baseball to serve as a singular voice for the player’s union, who would you pick? Feel free to think expansively about what “in baseball” means. Also we’ll allow current and former players too, I know one or several of you want the Greinke there. And for bonus points, who is on your dream eight-player executive subcommittee?