Update on Which Diamondbacks Outfielder Will Most Exceed Expectations

Corbin Carroll. (Photo by Norm Hall/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Before reading this update, you may want to look at this preseason article.  It looked at six outfielders who could most exceed expectations.  It concluded that Corbin Carroll was the most likely and that maybe two would exceed expectations.

Current status of the players. Jordan Lawlar broke his wrist.  Waldschmidt stayed in the minors.  So four players remain.

Corbin Carroll is the right fielder, and Alex Thomas is the center fielder.   Tim Tawa and Jorge Barrosa are playing the in the outfield to make up for Lawlar’s absence.  Let’s look at those four players to see whether they are exceeding preseason expectations.

Corbin Carroll.  My preseason expectation was high.  That expectation was the same OBP, SLG, and OAA as last season, and 34 homers (3 more than last season).  Also, there are concerns about his recovery from the broken hamate bone.

Batting. His OBP and SLG exceeded my high expectations.  He is on track for more homers than last season.  In addition, he hit two triples in the first ten games.  His impact went beyond expectations.  In four of the Diamondbacks first five wins, his RBIs made the game-winning difference.  The WPA totaled 1.02 for his top-ten plate appearances.  He is playing at an All-Star level.

Let’s look at those four games:

  • 30 March, 4 RBIs, D-backs won 9-6.
  • 31 March, 2 RBIs, D-backs won 7-5.
  • 1 April, 1 RBI, D-backs won 1-0.
  • 5 April, 1 RBI and two singles where he crossed the plate, Dbacks won 6-5.

Defense.  He is accumulating OAAs at a pace much higher than last season.  Perhaps he will be a candidate for a gold glove. 

Alek Thomas.  My preseason expectation was batting as good as the 2025 league average OBP and SLG, and 6 OAA (the average of his 2023 and 2024 seasons). 

Batting.  His OBP and SLG are less than past seasons, and lower than 2025 league averages.  On the other hand, his potential can be seen because his 4 RBIs are tied with Fernandez and Vargas for second highest on the Diamondbacks.  His top-four plate appearance have a WPA totaling 0.26.

Defense.  He is accumulating OAAs at a pace much higher than his excellent 2023 and 2024 seasons.  His defense in center field is making a huge positive contribution to the Diamondbacks.

Jorge Barrosa.  My preseason expectation was batting as good as the 2025 league average OBP and SLG, and 2 OAA

Batting.  His .462 SLG is exceeding preseason expectations.  His .231 OBP is close the expectations.  So far this season, his SLG and OBP are higher than Tim Tawa’s SLG and OBP.  His two doubles added a total of 0.14 WPA.  Although he received no added WPA for crossing the plate, in the tenth inning of the game on 5 April, as the ghost runner he scored the winning run.

Defense.  So far, Baseball Savant shows zero OAA.  However, that zero may only indicate that he has not yet accumulated more than 0.5 OAA.  It is too soon to draw conclusions about his defense.    

Tim Tawa.  If he becomes an everyday player, then he will exceed my preseason expectation of a bench player.  Before looking at his actual innings played per game, I decided that averaging 0.7 innings per Diamondbacks game would exceed expectations.  Tim Tawa started the season as a bench player, averaging 1.8 innings per game.  In games 6 through 10, he averaged 6.0 innings per games, very close to being an everyday player.  Currently, he is close to exceeding preseason expectations.    

The following table compare the four outfielders. Data from Baseball Reference, Baseball Savant, and MLB com.

Summary.

Corbin Carroll is exceeding preseason expectations for batting and defense.  In four of the Diamondbacks first five wins, his RBIs made the game-winning difference.  Also, he may be a candidate for a Gold Glove. 

Jorge Barrosa’s SLG is exceeding preseason expectations.  It’s too soon to decide on his defense. 

Alek Thomas’ defense in center field is exceeding preseason expectations.  His defense in center field is making a huge positive contribution.    

Tim Tawa is close to achieving everyday player status, which would exceed preseason expectations.

Braves Minor League Update: Who’s hot, Who’s not

Apr 18, 2025; North Augusta, South Carolina, USA; Augusta GreenJackets Ethan Bagwell (18) pitches during the Augusta GreenJackets and Myrtle Beach baseball game at SRP Park. The Augusta GreenJackets unveiled their new Augusta Azalea uniforms. Mandatory Credit: Katie Goodale - Augusta Chronicle/USA TODAY NETWORK | Katie Goodale / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Introducing a new weekly series where we review what we’ve seen, and heart from the latest week of minor league action. This past weekend we saw all the full season teams start their yearly grind so let’s take a glance at what happened.


Who’s Hot

Ethan Bagwell – 6IP 0H 0R 1BB 6K, 16 whiffs

Ethan kicks off the series with an outstanding season debut for the Augusta GreenJackets against the Fredricksburg Nationals. Ethan utilized a four pitch mix: four seam, cutter, sweeper, changeup. His four seam fastball averaged around 94 MPH and maxed out at 96, a pitch he threw 21% of the time. His cutter had an average of 93 MPH, and he threw it 15% of the time. It was his sweeper that did a majority of the heavy lifting as he utilized it an astronomical 59% of the time. Finally, he showed four changeups. Ethan was in control from the very start of the game as he retired the first 12 batters that he saw. He commanded his pitches, pitched to weak contact, while also registering whiffs (16). It was a dominant start by every definition of the word.

JR Ritchie – 5IP 4H 0R 3BB 5K, 8 whiffs

While it was not on the same level as Ethan, JR Ritchie rebounded nicely after a bit of a disaster opening day (3.2IP 5H 2ER 3BB 3K). He was able to shutout the Round Rock Express across five innings of work. The command is still not quite there, as he still had an uncharacteristic three walks but did register 8 whiffs. JR utilized a five pitch mix of his four seam, two seam, curveball, changeup, and sweeper – getting whiffs on his changeup (1), four seam (1), curveball (3), cutter (1), two seam (2).

Didier Fuentes – 3.2IP 1H 0R 1BB 7K, 12 whiffs

Didier Fuentes continued his hot run of play with 3.2 fantastic innings against the Round Rock Express. He generated 12 whiffs, while primarily utilizing his four seam and slider. His four seam average 97 miles an hour, maxing out at 99 (multiple times), with -9.3” of horizontal break – which he used 57% of the time. His slider, averaged right around 86 miles an hour and moved a lot like the Lara slider/cutter, with just 4” of horizontal movement and 0.1” of vertical break. Fuentes also utilized his changeup (splitter), but he threw it just five times and it was not really a factor. That said, he got up to 72 pitches and looks to continue to build his arm strength until he is back in the starting rotation.

Owen Murphy – 5.2IP 3H 2ER 2BB 10K, 15 whiffs

It was a terrible start as Owen surrendered a homer and a triple to begin the game, but he settled in and turned in yet another very strong start while collecting 15 whiffs. Owen utilized a four pitch mix: four seam (91 MPH), slider (84 MPH), curveball (77 MPH), and a splitter (85 MPH). That said, he was still primarily 4s (54%), and slider (34%).

Alex Lodise – 13 AB, .385/.429/.462

Alex Lodise is off to a sizzling start as he’s hit the ball hard, registering a max EV of 109 on an opposite field hit. Keeping in mind that Lodise walked just fives times in 25 games last year, he’s picked up a walk and struck out just twice so far to start the season. The biggest thing to monitor is the lack of chasing especially at the top and bottom of the zones for Alex. While he has expanded a bit, he’s showing a much more promising approach at the plate and looks to be recognizing breaking pitches significantly better. While he still will go high in the zone, the fact that the chasing looks significantly better is very promising. Also of note, he hasn’t been chasing slider aways either – another very promising trend to monitor the rest of the year.

John Gil – 10 AB, .300/.417/.600

The promising 19 year old continue his strong play, collecting a 1.017 OPS through the first three games of the season. John also had five successful stolen bases often resulting in non-competitive throws. John also showed off the improved power as well, hitting a three run homer with an exit velocity of 104 MPH.

Isaiah Drake – 12 AB, .333/.429/.833

Isaiah Drake is off to an absolutely scorching start with a 1.262 OPS across the seasons first three games. Isaiah has continued his patience at the plate, not expanding the zone – with just two strikeouts while also walking a pair of times. Like Gil, Drake is also perfect on the base pads with 3 stolen bases and 0 caught stealings. He’s also collected two homers already, and has put up extremely strong exit velocity numbers. On April 3rd alone, he had exit velocities of 100, 103, 105, 97, and 101 MPH, going 2-for-5 in that game. There are a lot of positive trends to take from Isaiah’s opening weekend and if he continues to hit at a rate remotely close to this, there will be a lot of chatter about him being a Top 100 prospect.

Nick Montgomery – 5 AB, .600/.778/1.200

Nick appeared in just a pair of games for the GreenJackets but boy did he show out – with a 1.978 OPS during the opening weekend series. Nick showed patience at the plate, not expanding the zone and walking four times in the two games while striking out once. His homer was a barreled, coming in with a 99 MPH EV. The selectively at the plate was a welcome sign for the power hitting catcher as he really struggled at the plate last season. While it’s early, it’s a very positive trend that will hopefully continue through the season.

Who Has Struggled Out the Gate

Nick Montgomery

As good as Nick was at the plate, it was a bit of a disaster behind the plate. In a single game he had a pair of throwing errors, as well as a passed ball that allowed a runner to score. High school catchers are notoriously some of the slowest developing players so it’s important to stay patient with Nick, however hopefully the play behind the plate improves to allow him to stay at the position where his power is on another level.

Cody Miller – 12 AB, .083/.083/.167

It’s been an odd start to the season for Cody who seems to be pressing quite a bit at the plate. Through the first three games of the season Cody has just one hit, and has struck out an uncharacteristic five times with zero walks. He’s expanded his zone as he’s pressed for more contact and the result has been poor quality at bats.

Jose Perdomo – 6 AB, .000/.000/.000

In a big year where health is of the highest interest to this writer, Jose Perdomo suffered an injury when he slipped running out of the box. He was down for a bit with trainers looking at his knee before he was able to get to his own feet and walk off the field. While there hasn’t been any concerning updates regarding the injury yet, it is yet another non-contact injury that has gotten in the way of his development. Hopefully Perdomo has avoided significant injury and will be back on the field sooner than later.

Weekly Pebble Report: Cole Carrigg is honing his professionalism

SCOTTSDALE, ARIZONA - MARCH 12: Cole Carrigg #86 of the Colorado Rockies runs to third base during the seventh inning of the Spring Training game against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Salt River Fields at Talking Stick on March 12, 2026 in Scottsdale, Arizona. (Photo by John E. Moore III/Getty Images)
SCOTTSDALE, ARIZONA - MARCH 12: Cole Carrigg #86 of the Colorado Rockies runs to third base during the seventh inning of the Spring Training game against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Salt River Fields at Talking Stick on March 12, 2026 in Scottsdale, Arizona. (Photo by John E. Moore III/Getty Images) | Original photo by John E. Moore III/Getty Images, March 12, 2026

We’ve talked at length about how Cole Carrigg (No. 4 PuRP) is the definition of a “super-utilityman,” having played every position on the field at least once while also switch hitting. However, in spring training, he also worked on honing his off-the-field skills. 

Carrigg has always been an aggressive player, as evidenced by his stealing home in Saturday’s Isotopes game:

Last August, he notoriously stole second, third and home in the same inning.

“I’ve had a tendency to play, not necessarily over the top, but I just play 100% all the time,” he said during spring training. “That’s what I’ve been taught growing up by my dad and my brother. The only way I know how to play the game is a fully-competitive, 100% nature.”

However, that comes with some drawbacks.

In 2025, Carrigg posted a 33% chase rate – one of the highest in the minor leagues. That was the biggest on-field skill he worked to develop during spring training: trying to harness his “competitive nature” and learn a more patient approach.

“I’m just trying to do a lot a lot of the time, and sometimes that can get in the way,” he said. “But for me, it’s just knowing what I’m looking for and knowing what I can handle the best, and not trying to do too much at times.

“I’ve definitely taken some strides in that area,” he continued. “(I didn’t have) a lot of walks this spring, but I feel like I put myself into good counts. But putting the ball in play and playing hard is never a problem.”

That said, with the Rockies focus on versatility at all positions, why isn’t a guy like Carrigg being looked at more closely? It might be more related to off-the-field things.

“Probably handling failure like a professional,” Carrigg said of his next step, “getting rid of that immaturity and just letting them know that. If I do come up to the big leagues, I’m sure it’s not always going to be great – hopefully it’s awesome and I do well, but there’s going to be tough times. And being able to handle that like a pro and not bring the club down in any sense, and having any bad attitude or whatever and just being a good locker room guy… I felt like I did a really good job this spring. Granted, it went well so it’s a lot easier to be happy when things are going well. But just handling more of that type of thing like a professional.”

In addition to an extended look at big league spring training, Carrigg also got the opportunity to represent Team Israel in the World Baseball Classic.

“Getting a little week break to go play with the WBC was super cool,” he said. “I played short there and got to represent Israel, and I had four really good games out there. We went 2-2 – it wasn’t the result that we wanted, but it was still really fun to win a couple games, get them their berth for the next WBC. And then getting back into camp and hitting the ground running, and just playing some good ball and enjoying it while I could. I had a real blast.”

And the adjustments made things interesting down the stretch.

“It was a pretty unique experience going from camp to the WBC,” Carrigg said. “There’s a few big leaguers on our team – actually, quite a few, to be honest – so it kind of felt almost similar to spring training. We got to play against the Marlins at their spring training and we played against the Mets at their spring training, so for the most part, it kind of felt just like big league camp. But it was pretty cool – we stayed in a super awesome hotel with great food. It was pretty top notch. And then coming back, obviously, everything we have here is top notch, as well. And I got to see all the fellas again, so it was really good.”

Carrigg was not optioned to minor league camp until March 19 – the same day as Charlie Condon (No. 1 PuRP). Last year, he was reassigned on March 5. That goes to show how much closer Carrigg could be to the big leagues.

“I guess I did what I needed to do to stay longer,” he said. “Last year was a little shorter stint and I didn’t really play all that great. I guess you could say I forced the hand a little bit more this year, and I guess I just showed what I could bring to the table and bring to the team, and hopefully that’s some winning baseball.”

In his first week in Triple-A, Carrigg has gone 8-for-33 (.242) with one double, one triple, two RBI and two walks. He also has six strikeouts, but has stolen six bases in seven attempts. 

Carrigg might be a player that fits the new Rockies archetype, so hopefully he can gain a little more control in order to put himself in a place to be called up to the bigs.


Weekly Pebble Report: March 30th-April 5th

Triple-A: Albuquerque Isotopes (3-6)

The Isotopes welcomed the Reno Aces (Arizona Diamondbacks) for their first homestand of the season. Albuquerque managed to snag two wins in the series, thanks largely in part to their pitching staff, with the starters in particular compiling a 1.99 ERA in 22 1/3 innings with six walks and 25 strikeouts. Pitchers as a unit have allowed three or fewer runs in four of the first nine games in the 2026 season.

Unfortunately, the offense has struggled quite a bit to put runs on the board. The Isotopes tied a team record by going six consecutive home games without a home run, dating back to last year’s season finale, before new minor league free agent addition, Andrew Knizner, connected for a home run on Sunday. During this series, the Isotopes posted a .209/.308/.280 slashline with just 10 extra-base hits (eight doubles, one triple, one homer).

It’s also worth noting that it was shared on Sunday that Charlie Condon (No. 1 PuRP) has been absent for the last few days after having a cyst removed, but it’s expected he’ll be able to get back to action in a few days.

⬆️ Stock Up: Top Marks for the Professor

Gabriel Hughes (No. 12 PuRP) came up big on the mound in both of his appearances during the series. In total, Hughes worked 10 1/3 innings with five hits and three earned runs allowed. During his start in the Home Opener last Tuesday, Hughes allowed just two runs on three hits while striking out eight batters against just two walks. During Sunday’s finale, Hughes entered the game after Parker Mushinski served as the “opener” and proceeded to allow one run on two hits with six strikeouts and just one walk. In that outing, he threw 56 of his 77 pitches for strikes.

Hughes fits the mold of a pitcher that the new front office is emphasizing. He offers a varied arsenal and has the mental aptitude to experiment and handle the mental approach to pitching at a higher elevation. He is, of course, a person who reads philosophy books for fun in his spare time. Hopes are high that Hughes will be able to make his big league debut at some point this season, and his showing an ability to handle the extreme conditions of the Pacific Coast League draws that day ever closer.

⬇️ Stock Down:Veen Struggling in the Duke City Scene

Officially activated from the injured list and optioned to Triple-A, Zac Veen (No. 9 PuRP) has struggled since joining the Isotopes on March 31. He is just 2-for-18 to begin the season with seven strikeouts and a pair of walks. He went 1-for-3 with an infield single and a walk in the series finale, marking the first time he reached safely multiple times in a game this season. He deserves some grace as he missed the last few weeks of spring training, but Veen has a lot to prove and will need to find his footing to put pressure on those above him on the depth chart.

Upcoming

The Isotopes kick off their next six-game series Tuesday by heading south to face off against the El Paso Chihuahuas (San Diego Padres).

Double-A: Hartford Yard Goats (2-1)

The Hartford Yard Goats started their tenth anniversary season as the Yard Goats with a 2-1 series win over the Chesapeake BaySox (Baltimore Orioles) at their home stadium of Dunkin’ Park. Although their season opener was marked by high strikeouts (14) and not taking advantage of scoring chances (2-for-12 with runners in scoring position), the Yard Goats rattled off back-to-back victories to take the series. In Game 2, the offense roared to life, beating down the BaySox 10-2 after plating five runs in the sixth inning.

⬆️ Stock Up:Shining, Wimmering, Splendid.

Anyone not named Braylen Wimmer might have been surprised to see the 25-year-old super utilityman on the field this spring. After suffering a seizure during the Arizona Fall League in November, Wimmer underwent a surgical procedure called an awake craniotomy to remove as much as possible of a large, cancerous brain tumor called an astrocytoma. No one would have blamed him for sitting even part of this season out.

Yet Wimmer suited up as the Opening Day center fielder for the Hartford Yard Goats and played in two of their first three games. Not only did he play, he excelled. Wimmer went 4-for-7 at the plate, drove in four runs, scored three times himself, went a perfect 2-for-2 stealing bases, and walked twice.

⬆️ Stock Up:Brooks Gets It Done

When the Rockies parted ways with Bradley Blalock this off-season, they obtained 24-year-old right-handed pitcher Jake Brooks from the Miami Marlins in the process. Brooks—a former 11th round pick from the 2023 draft—ended his last season in the Miami organization with Double-A Pensacola. This season he is starting the year in Double-A and had a strong debut with the Rockies organization. Brooks worked five scoreless frames against the BaySox while allowing just two hits and setting down nine batters via the punchout.

Upcoming

The Yard Goats are off to Reading for a six-game set against the Fightin’ Phils (Philadelphia Phillies) for their first road trip of the season.

High-A: Spokane Indians (2-1)

The Indians took two of three in their opening series against the Everett AquaSox (Seattle Mariners). On Friday, they won convincingly 4-1; on Saturday, they lost a close 3-2 game; and on Sunday, they outslugged the AquaSox 10-9.

Jackson Cox (No. 16 PuRP) was the only starter to pitch more than three innings, and he only allowed one run — a solo homer — on three hits with one walk and seven strikeouts in his start on Saturday. The Indians used three pitchers in that game, while they used four on Friday and six on Sunday. While the pitching staff has punched out a lot of batters (30), they’ve also walked quite a few. They’ve given up at least five walks in each of their games, including 10 on Sunday.

⬆️ Stock Up:Fight On! ✌🏻

Third baseman and 2025 draft pick Ethan Hedges (No. 29 PuRP) had a spectacular weekend at the plate. The Rockies’ third-round pick from USC went 6-for-11 (.545) with a double, two homers (both on Sunday), four RBI, one walk and three strikeouts.

Hedges was immediately sent to Spokane after he was drafted, and he hit just .195/.303/.234 in 20 games.

⬇️ Stock Down:Zero degrees Kelvin

Shortstop Kelvin Hidalgo struggled this week, going hitless (0-for-13) in three games with four strikeouts. He only reached (and scored) because he was hit by a pitch on Sunday. Of the prospects who have yet to record a hit, Hidalgo is the only one who started all three games.

Upcoming

The Indians head out for their first road trip, heading down to Hillsboro, OR to take on the Hops (Arizona Diamondbacks) for six games.

Low-A: Fresno Grizzlies (2-1)

The Low-A Fresno Grizzlies kicked off their 2026 season on the road against the Visalia Rawhide (Arizona Diamondbacks) looking to build on their strong 2025 campaign in which they reached the post-season only to be stymied by the eventual California League champion San Jose Giants.

The Grizzlies lost their season opener thanks to six earned runs given up by starter Marcos Herrera and a failure to capitalize on scoring chances by going 1-for-7 with runners in scoring position. The offense also struck out 15 times. However, they quickly found their footing to win the next two games and their first series of the year. Across those two games the Grizzlies scored a combined 12 runs and strong pitching performances from 2025 draft picks Austin Newton and JB Middleton kept the Rawhide bats at bay.

⬆️ Stock Up:Born to Be Wilder

19-year-old third baseman Wilder Dalis (no. 24 PuRP) picked up where he left off after a standout campaign in 2025 across the Arizona Complex League and Low-A Fresno. Dalis went 4-for-10 at the plate to kick off the Low-A season with a double and his first home run of the year. He also drew three walks to just two strikeouts and had two RBIs.

⬇️ Stock Down:Bat Still on Holliday

Top Rockies prospect and 2025 first round pick Ethan Holliday was assigned back to Low-A Fresno to start the season and reportedly is bigger than stronger than ever. Unfortunately, that didn’t necessarily translate to results at the plate. The 19-year-old recorded just one hit in the Grizzlies’ three-game series against Visalia. While he drew two walks, he struck out a whopping seven times in 12 at-bats, including a rough four strikeout game on Saturday.

Upcoming

The Grizzlies head home to beautiful Chukchansi Park for their home opener and a six-game set against the Stockton Ports (Sacramento Athletics)


Join the conversation!

Sign up for a user account and get:

  • Fewer ads
  • Create community posts
  • Comment on articles, community posts
  • Rec comments, community posts
  • New, improved notifications system!

Please keep in mind our Purple Row Community Guidelines when you’re commenting. Thanks!

Mets Notes: 'Playing it safe' with Juan Soto; Ronny Mauricio's role

Mets manager Carlos Mendoza spoke with reporters on Tuesday at Citi Field.

Here are the main topics he discussed...


The plan for Juan Soto

Soto was placed on the IL on Monday, retroactive to Saturday, due to the minor calf strain he suffered this past Friday against the Giants in San Francisco.

Mendoza explained that the decision was basically made on Sunday, and that Soto was fine with it.

While Soto could've conceivably played in the near-term and avoided an IL stint, Mendoza said the team "just wanted to play it safe."

"I've been saying that these are tricky, the calf area," Mendoza explained. "There's no reason for us to continue to go day by day and put him through a series of exercises and make a decision on whether he's gonna be available or not. 

"We just decided, you know what, take your time before we start putting you through a series of things that he has to check all the boxes, right? Give him time, and we'll get him back when we get him back." 

Tuesday is the fourth day since Soto's injury occurred, and he is eligible to return from the IL in one week -- on Tuesday, April 14. 

When the Mets announced the IL move, they noted that a typical return to play for the type of injury Soto has is two-to-three weeks.

"For now, it's just treatment," Mendoza said about Soto's rehab. "I'm pretty sure he's gonna be doing some exercises indoors -- not much baseball activity until the soreness or the tightness goes away. That's the plan for the coming days."

New York Mets shortstop Ronny Mauricio (0) hits against the Miami Marlins during the fifth inning at Clover Park
New York Mets shortstop Ronny Mauricio (0) hits against the Miami Marlins during the fifth inning at Clover Park / Sam Navarro - Imagn Images

Ronny Mauricio's role

Mauricio was called up to replace Soto on the 26-man roster, and Mendoza laid out why, noting that they wanted another infielder/versatile player up given the minor ailments to Jorge Polanco (Achilles) and Brett Baty (thumb).

Mendoza spoke to Mauricio about his role, explaining to the 25-year-old that regular playing time might be sparse while he's up.

"Even though his name is not gonna be in the starting lineup, he's got a pretty important role," Mendoza said. "Coming off the bench, lefty bat, the versatility, defensively, pinch-running if we need to. But also understanding that the playing time part is gonna be limited. But we're not talking about having a case here like last year, where he kind of sat on the bench for a long time."

Mauricio slashed .226/.293/.369 with six homers and six doubles in 184 plate appearances over 61 big league games in 2025.

He has tantalizing potential, but has yet to put it all together at the major league level. 

Mauricio also missed the entire 2024 season and the start of 2025 after needing ACL surgery for an injury he sustained while playing winter ball -- something that slowed his development. 

Cubs vs Rays Prediction, Picks & Odds for Today's MLB Game

Want to get more Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account here.

The Tampa Bay Rays hope to clinch the series with the Chicago Cubs on Tuesday as they host their second game back at the newly-reopened Tropicana Field.

Monday saw the Rays pick up an emotional 6-4 win, and the MLB odds indicate they’re expected to replicate that with Drew Rasmussen on the bump.

My Cubs vs. Rays predictions have MLB picks for the side and total for Tuesday, April 7.

Who will win Cubs vs Rays today: Rays moneyline (-128)

Drew Rasmussen’s increased cutter usage is a key reason for his strong start. He’s picked up a whiff rate of 29.4% with the pitch, utilizing it 7% more than last season.

Tuesday he faces a Chicago Cubs lineup whose .340 xwOBAcon and .213 xBA are fourth-worst in the bigs.

Yandy Diaz is setting the table for the Tampa Bay Rays with a .395 xwOBA and a .489 OBP. As a team, they rank fifth in xBA and wOBA, and sixth in slugging.

They’ll score runs against Javier Assad, making his first start after posting a 4.86 xERA and 4.69 xFIP last season.

Covers COVERS INTEL:Assad got crushed by LHH in 2025, allowing a .293/.339/.552 split and nine earned runs vs. 62 batters faced.

Cubs vs Rays Over/Under pick: Over 7.5 (-115)

Tampa Bay has consistently been going over the total this season, even when the opponent hasn’t been contributing.

Monday’s 6-4 win marked the eighth Over in 10 games to start the season and I expect that trend to continue. Assad will likely get punished by the top of the order, especially if Diaz gets on-base in front of Jonathan Aranda.

The Cubs bullpen has a 4.63 xFIP and 5.41 xERA. Tampa Bay has seen its pen far even worse, with a 4.94 xFIP and 6.08 xERA. Both rank in the bottom third, and late runs will push the total north of the number.

Ence's 2026 Transparency Record
  • ML/RL bets:0-1, -1.00 units
  • Over/Under bets:1-0, +1.00 units

Cubs vs Rays odds

  • Moneyline: Chicago +117 | Tampa Bay -122
  • Run line: Chicago +1.5 (-186) | Tampa Bay -1.5 (+170)
  • Over/Under: Over 7.5 (-108) | Under 7.5 (+104)

Cubs vs Rays trend

The Chicago Cubs have hit the Team Total Under in 20 of their last 26 away games (+13.15 Units / 42% ROI). Find more MLB betting trends for Cubs vs. Rays.

How to watch Cubs vs Rays and game info

LocationTropicana Field, St. Petersburg, FL
DateTuesday, April 7, 2026
First pitch6:40 p.m. ET
TVMarquee, RAYS
Cubs starting pitcherJavier Assad
(2025: 4-1, 3.65 ERA)
Rays starting pitcherDrew Rasmussen
(0-0, 1.80 ERA)

Cubs vs Rays latest injuries

Cubs vs Rays weather

Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

This article originally appeared on Covers.com, read the full article here and view our best betting sites or check out our top sportsbook promos.

MLB Home Run Predictions Today: Best HR Prop Bets, Picks, Parlay & Odds for Tuesday, April 7

Want to get more Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account here.

Dinger Tuesday means backing the hottest bats, even as cooler weather sweeps across the league. Attention turns to indoor ballparks and select West Coast matchups where pricing and opportunity still offer solid value in the home run market and MLB player props.

Junior Caminero made his presence felt at the Trop with a four-bagger yesterday, and I’m counting on him to repeat the performance today.

On top of that, I’m doubling down on Atlanta Braves power with Drake Baldwin and Ozzie Albies, rounding out a four-player home run round-robin in my top home run props and MLB picks for Tuesday, April 7.

  • UPDATE: Added another HR pick + parlay.

Best MLB home run props today

Player to hit a HROdds
Rays Junior Caminero+400
Braves Drake Baldwin+560
Braves Ozzie Albies+520
💲Today's HR parlay+17633

Junior Caminero (+400)

With the temps dropping to the 40s, finding dingers indoors is the key to a profitable home run card on Tuesday. The Trop is back, and Junior Caminero went deep there yesterday afternoon, which was his second straight game with a four-bagger. He has hits in four straight, and nobody in baseball has a harder hit ball than him, with his league-leading exit velocity of 116.9 mph. 

He faces Javier Assad, who was recalled from Triple-A to fill in for Matthew Boyd and Cade Horton. In his last minor league outing, Assad allowed two home runs on 11 hits and profiles as a contact-heavy arm.

This shapes up as one of the better hitting matchups on the slate, making Caminero a strong value play at this price in a controlled environment.

  • Time: 6:40 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: Rays.TV, Marquee Sports Network

Drake Baldwin (+560)

Drake Baldwin has already failed me this year, but, of course, he got hot after I bet on him with back-to-back games going deep.

He is currently tied for the league lead with five homers. A price north of +500 in Anaheim, with decent hitting conditions, is putting him back in my trust tree. He is a Top-10 hitter in baseball right now who isn't striking out. 

There are three other Atlanta Braves who have taken Yusei Kikuchi deep over their careers in Ronald Acuna (+360), Matt Olson (+390), and Ozzie Albies (+520), so there is plenty of info for Baldwin, who handles lefties just as well as righties.

This might be a great spot for a two-man Atlanta round-robin homer card with the two shortest numbers making better than 20/1 odds. That's six combinations at doubles. At 0.15 units per bet, that would be a decent winner at less than a unit risk. 

  • Time: 9:38 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: FanDuel Sports Network West, BravesVision

Ozzie Albies (+520)

Let’s keep attacking Kikuchi in a solid hitting environment with Albies at +520.

He’s already part of a four-player round robin I have, but his solo HR prop at +480 or better still carries +EV based on projections. Albies is expected to hit in the three-hole against a lefty, a split where he’s historically been stronger than vs. right-handers.

Kikuchi’s profile is vulnerable to hard-hit fly balls, and Albies has already had success in the matchup, going 3-for-6 with a home run.

There’s also upside beyond the starter, as the Angels' bullpen has outperformed its underlying numbers, carrying a 4.51 xFIP that ranks near the bottom of the league despite a strong ERA. This sets up as a spot where the Braves could generate multiple home runs.

  • Time: 9:38 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: FanDuel Sports Network West, BravesVision
Jinglis' 2026 Transparency Record
  • HR picks: 1-14, -8.8 units

Today’s HR parlay

Rays Junior CamineroBet Now
+17633
Braves Drake Baldwin
Braves Ozzie Albies

Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

This article originally appeared on Covers.com, read the full article here and view our best betting sites or check out our top sportsbook promos.

Will the Orioles get back to at least .500 in April?

Apr 6, 2026; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Baltimore Orioles shortstop Gunnar Henderson (2) crosses home plate after hitting a solo home run against the Chicago White Sox during the sixth inning at Rate Field. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-Imagn Images | Kamil Krzaczynski-Imagn Images

Welcome to SB Nation Reacts, a survey of fans across MLB. Throughout the year we ask questions of the most plugged-in Orioles fans and fans across the country. Sign up here to participate in the weekly emailed surveys.

Last year’s Orioles team never had a .500 or better record after being 3-3 through six games. For a little while in April, they might win a game to at least get within one below, or a couple in a row to get within two below, but they could never get back to an even record and before long they were not even close to it.

The Orioles have played poorly enough over the first couple of weeks of the season to leave people wondering if they’re going to run back that disappointment, only with some different faces involved. Hopefully, they will not do this. Yet we all hoped they would not do it last year either and what did that get us? Nothing except for a July dismantling.

In this week’s survey, I am setting the bar low. It is depressing how low I have set the bar. The question is: Will the Orioles get back to .500 before April is over?

If you don’t see the survey, you may need to open this article in Incognito Mode.

It’s possible that this question will be answered before the results of this survey are even posted. If the Orioles can sweep the White Sox, they’ll be .500 on Friday when I typically get the survey results. They should have a decent chance to do it, since Trevor Rogers and Kyle Bradish are starting the next two games and the White Sox offense is pretty bad. Of course, nothing is guaranteed. The Orioles offense is also pretty bad and the defense and bullpen are both highly questionable.

What do you think? Vote above and let us know your thoughts in the comments below.

A's vs Yankees Prediction, Picks & Odds for Today's MLB Game

Want to get more Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account here.

The New York Yankees will look to continue to build off their 7-2 start when they host the Athletics for an early week series starting tonight.

We like their chances in the opening with one of the most promising young arms in the majors on the mound. 

My A's vs. Yankees predictions and MLB picks break down the matchup and why we're backing a low-scoring New York win on Tuesday, April 7.

Who will win A's vs Yankees today: Yankees moneyline (-230)

There’s been a bit of a rush to fade Cam Schlittler in the market early this season after his postseason accomplishments last year.

In some ways I understand it, but he’s simply responded by being untouchable, allowing zero runs over two starts and, perhaps more importantly, posting an expected ERA of just 1.09 (top 2% of the league). I’m backing him here. 

This is the ideal opponent for his elite chase rate, strikeout build. The Athletics own the highest whiff rate in baseball at 32% and the highest swing rate at 51%. 

They pair this with the lowest chase contact rate in the league. Schlittler should curve through this lineup, making over strikeouts, outs, and under hits all of interest too. 

Covers COVERS INTEL:The A’s 31.8% whiff rate is the highest in baseball through the first week-plus of the season. 

A's vs Yankees Over/Under pick: Under 8.5 (-118)

This play is mostly a double down of Schlittler having a big-time performance. I made this number 8.1 so I see a decent amount of value getting around the half run. 

We’ve talked about Schlittler enough but I’m a fan of A’s hurler Aaron Civale, too. His groundball rate won’t stay at over 55% all season but for the moment, I’ll respect it and say that’s the profile you want the most when facing New York.

Pairing that with just a 6% barrel rate tells you he limits damage in the air even if he cannot miss bats. The New York Yankees will score but Civale's contact profile keeps balls on the ground.

Hatfield's 2026 Transparency Record
  • ML/RL bets: 2-2, -0.04 units
  • Over/Under bets:4-1, +3.04 units

A's vs Yankees odds

  • Moneyline: Athletics +194 | New York Yankees -203
  • Run line: Athletics +1.5 (-106) | New York Yankees -1.5 (+100)
  • Over/Under: Over 8.5 | Under 8.5

A's vs Yankees trend

The New York Yankees have hit the 1st Five Innings (F5) Moneyline in 31 of their last 45 games (+17.25 Units / 23% ROI). Find more MLB betting trends for A's vs. Yankees.

How to watch A's vs Yankees and game info

LocationYankee Stadium, Bronx, NY
DateTuesday, April 7, 2026
First pitch7:05 p.m. ET
TVNBC Sports California, YES
A's starting pitcherAaron Civale
(1-0, 3.60 ERA)
Yankees starting pitcherCam Schlittler
(2-0, 0.00 ERA)

A's vs Yankees latest injuries

A's vs Yankees weather

Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

This article originally appeared on Covers.com, read the full article here and view our best betting sites or check out our top sportsbook promos.

SB Nation Reacts survey: Who else can the Cubs call on as a replacement starting pitcher?

Jaxon Wiggins | | Cody Scanlan/The Register / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Welcome to SB Nation Reacts, a survey of fans across MLB. Throughout the year we ask questions of the most plugged-in Cubs fans and fans across the country. Sign up here to participate in the weekly emailed surveys.


Cubs fans received some bad news today about Cade Horton; if you haven’t seen it yet, you can read about it here.

Between Horton’s injury and Matthew Boyd missing some time (at least that injury doesn’t sound serious), the Cubs will be employing their sixth and seventh starters this week against the Rays, Javier Assad tonight and Colin Rea tomorrow.

Those guys are both competent starters, but obviously not at the level of Horton or Boyd. Still, the Cubs survived losing Justin Steele for most of last year — and he should be back by late May or early June.

In any case, we certainly hope the Cubs don’t lose any more starters to injury. But if they do, who should they call on as another replacement? Some of the guys listed in the survey below are already in the Cubs organization, some aren’t.

Vote in the survey and I’ll have the responses here later this week.

Giancarlo Stanton’s start almost seems too good to be true

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - APRIL 04: Giancarlo Stanton #27 of the New York Yankees hits an RBI double during the eighth inning against the Miami Marlins at Yankee Stadium on April 04, 2026 in New York City. (Photo by Caean Couto/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The Yankees 2026 regular season and pursuit of another American League East title and, most of all, a World Series championship is underway with about as few hitches as a fan could ask for. Despite a troubling start for the bottom half of the order, the Yankees have managed plenty of runs to win games (seven of their first nine to put them 2.5 games up on the Tampa Bay Rays) through excellent starting pitching and contributions from hitters 1-5 in the lineup.

One player that has really had a hot start (and needed it, after only playing 77 games last season but raking in those games) is Giancarlo Stanton. However, he didn’t get here without some legitimate concerns from those who follow the team.

After suffering tennis elbow in 2025, there were reports that the Yankees slugger couldn’t “open a bottle or a bag of chips” due to the pain he felt. So, there were questions about whether or not Stanton would be able to return to baseball at all, let alone be his normal self. And while 2026 hasn’t looked the same so far in terms of the power Stanton has provided, he has still proven to be useful in the top part of the order.

Stanton currently sits with a slashline of .394/.429/.545 for an absurd 182 wRC+ and 0.4 fWAR through eight games. And, yes, that’s a very small sample, but when someone like Stanton is leading the team in batting average, hits, and OPS, even for a short time, it’s something that’s noteworthy given how far that strays from his normal archetype.

As for how Stanton has managed these hits, it’s primarily due to a different approach at the plate, one that’s focused on making contact instead of swinging for the fences.

A look at Stanton’s Statcast page on Baseball Savant suggests an approach that includes slowing the bat down, making contact through the zone, and hitting the ball in the air. Stanton’s bat speed is down 1.4 mph since last season, leading to a lower average exit velocity and a max exit velocity down almost two mph from last year, but he’s getting the ball off the ground, sitting with a 72% air rate compared to a 28% groundball rate. And given his frame, he’s still able to swing the bat at a fast pace and give the ball a good trip to the outfield when need be. He’s barrelling the ball fewer times, but he also has his highest solid contact rate since 2021.

Even if Stanton has slightly altered his approach, it is only a matter of time before he returns to Earth, or at least stops hitting almost .400 without much power. And, at 36-years-old with bad elbows, there’s likely only so much his body can do, and it’s worth wondering if he’ll be able to get to as much power as he has even in recent years. Generally speaking, it’s likely he will still be an above-average hitter and hit for some insane power on occasion, but there’s still some concern in the lesser bat speed and thump that he’s shown thus far, as you need a guy like Stanton to have the potential for home runs every time he steps up to the plate.

While Stanton’s injuries weren’t something that could keep him off the field, they seem to be having an effect on his ability to swing the bat with the same inhuman force that he has for his whole career. An alternate approach is working for now, but the Yankees will probably be best off if Stanton shows off the form he had in their 2024 run to the World Series and for most of his time on the field last year. What he’s done so far might be too good to be true, as Stanton isn’t going to be a guy who hits above .300 without driving the ball harder than anyone else. We’ll see in the coming weeks how his swing, and his production, start to stabilize.

Yankees At-Bat of the Week: Ben Rice (4/3)

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - APRIL 03: Ben Rice #22 of the New York Yankees hits a home run in the seventh inning against the Miami Marlins during the home opener at Yankee Stadium on April 03, 2026 in the Bronx borough of New York City. (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images) | Getty Images

While it was the pitching staff that carried the team through the first week of games, the offense began to break out scoring 23 runs in their three-game set against the Marlins. The unit is still far from firing on all cylinders, Aaron Judge yet to truly ignite his season. Instead, they’ve had to rely on the contributions of a different pair of sluggers, Giancarlo Stanton picking up this season where he left off last year while Ben Rice looks poised to break out as the league’s next offensive juggernaut.

We join Rice leading off the bottom of the seventh, the cleanup hitter having already endured an 0-for-3 night with three strikeouts. However, the Yankees are winning, and Rice remains one swing away from transforming a stinker of a night into a productive outing.

The Marlins have brought in a fresh reliever for the seventh, the hard-throwing Michael Petersen hoping for a clean inning. He throws one of the best four-seamers in the game when you combine its velocity and movement, so it’s no surprise to see him start Rice with the ol’ No. 1.

Petersen commands this 97 mph four-seamer almost perfectly to the corner down and away and earns the called strike. Statcast reveals that this pitch is out of the zone, but the Yankees have already exhausted both their ABS challenges, and in truth it’s a good take from Rice given how little you can expect to do with a pitch located that well.

Now that Petersen has shown Rice the high velo cheese, he attempts to get him chasing out in front of a changeup below the zone.

You just aren’t going to get Rice to chase a pitch like this. The changeup is a ball out of Petersen’s hand and never looks like breaking toward the zone, making for an automatic take from one of the most disciplined hitters in the league over the last 12 months.

Perhaps Petersen saw that Rice didn’t even flinch at the last pitch, because he ditches the changeup for the four-seamer for the rest of the AB.

This is a helluva four-seamer at 98 mph with an eye-popping 22 inches of induced vertical break (18 inches is considered elite). Petersen throws one of the ten best four-seamers in the league when measuring vertical movement, this barely dropping from its plane during its path to home plate. It’s such a difficult pitch to track for the hitter — with practically any other four-seamer you expect it to drop into the zone but Petersen’s almost rises as it approaches home. Rice can absolutely be forgiven for chasing and whiffing under this almost gravity-defying pitch.

Just like that, Rice finds himself in a 1-2 hole and on the precipice of donning the dreaded golden sombrero. If Petersen can repeat the pitch he just threw, Rice is almost surely toast.

Wait a second. Rice isn’t supposed to be able to pull this pitch into the second deck just foul after getting beaten badly by an identical four-seamer one pitch prior. This is some kind of adjustment from Rice to be able to immediately doctor his swing plane to match the pitch that just beat him.

After watching Rice clobber that elevated four-seamer into the second deck, you might expect Petersen to go with something off-speed to take advantage of Rice’s sped up bat. Instead he tries to sneak another four-seamer by Rice in the same spot.

Bad idea. In addition to this pitch actually being in the zone, Rice has fully adjusted his swing to do damage, and boy does he, lasering a 111 mph frozen rope into the seats in right for his second home run of the season. That’s two adjustments in the course of three pitches — the mark of a hitter who is not only locked in but also fully understands every facet of his own swing.

Here’s the full AB:

Rice alongside Cam Schlittler has been one of the true developmental wins for the Yankees since Aaron Judge ascended to superstardom. His emergence as a middle-of-the-order bat comes at a crucial time for the Bombers as they suffer through fielding the worst six-through-nine hitters in all of MLB

You always knew Ryan McMahon and José Caballero were apt to struggle offensively, but the lack of production from Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Austin Wells has seriously shortened the lineup in the early going. The onus is therefore on the first five hitters to shoulder the majority of the offensive burden. If Rice can continue his own ascent toward becoming one of the most dangerous first basemen in the league, the Yankees should still continue to score runs irrespective of the impotence of the bottom of their order.

We all know about Rice’s batted ball supremacy — over a quarter of his batted balls have been barreled while almost four out of every five is hard-hit. We also know how he has made himself into a strike zone savant, placing in the 90th percentile or better in walk and chase rates. However, this encounter showcases another pair of skills he has developed in his time in the majors. His ability to make adjustments pitch-to-pitch and AB-to-AB is already elite. But perhaps even more impressive, his mentality to immediately turn the page after experiencing disappointment — as evidenced by his home run and two-run double after striking out in his first three at-bats of this game — is what I believe will take Rice into the stratosphere of MLB hitters.

GAME THREAD: Royals at Guardians, game 12 of 162

SEATTLE, WASHINGTON - MARCH 28: David Fry #6 of the Cleveland Guardians at bat against the Seattle Mariners at T-Mobile Park on March 28, 2026 in Seattle, Washington. (Photo by Olivia Vanni/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Here’s the Royals’ lineup:

Here’s the Guardians’ lineup:

Let’s go, Guardians!

Joining in on the extension train with the Phillies

Apr 1, 2026; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Philadelphia Phillies center fielder Justin Crawford (2) in a game against the Washington Nationals at Citizens Bank Park. Mandatory Credit: Bill Streicher-Imagn Images | Bill Streicher-Imagn Images

Spring training is a time for hope. It can come in two forms – fans hope their team will put it all together to make a run at a happier ending to their season than the one before while teams hope their players make it through the gamut unscathed. Injuries are a concern and everyone just wants to make it out alive.

Spring training is also a time for contract extensions. Teams were likely working behind the scenes during the winter to talk to player agents in the hopes that they can get a certain player to extend their stay on the roster. The focus for many of those talks are on players that are either really close to free agency or really far away. These past few weeks around the game has seen teams trying to make sure their young talent that is further away from reaching free agency would agree to a deal that would make them instantly wealthy for an extended period of time while also securing their future at cheap reasonable rates while assuming a decent amount of risk that the deal will bust out. There has been a deal in Baltimore where the Orioles made sure Shane Baz sticks around while the Brewers and Mariners made sure their shortstop phenoms would spend their best years in their cities before even making a major league debut. Konnor Griffin jumped on the extension train hours before his major league debut, so it seems as though there is a pattern. The suspicion of teams getting ahead of things prior changes to the CBA, but for the most part, it’s just good business on the part of the team.

It makes one wonder if the Phillies would consider doing the same.

Right now, there are three contenders for getting this kind of extension: Justin Crawford, Andrew Painter and Aidan Miller. All three would fall into that category of “signing him now to avoid future expense”, but each would be their own special case. Were the team to sign Miller, it would look as though they were just joining in the young shortstop extension fun. With Crawford and Painter, it would be similar in that they were young players the team wished to make sure didn’t get too expensive, but at different positions, it would have a different shade of extension.

Aidan Miller

It seems that the new cool thing to do is signing your young shortstop that has yet to debut. As mentioned before, Pratt, Emerson and Griffin now have their grandchildren’s children set up for life with generational wealth while also preserving the ability to make even more money later on due to their current youth and end date of the contract. Looking down prospect lists and noticing that others might still do the same (Kevin McGonigle, J.J. Wetherholt, Jesus Made to name a few), one might wonder about if the Phillies were interested in doing the same. Where that might end up would depend on a few things.

The first thing to worry about is Miller’s health. They can continue to talk with optimism all they want with regards to his back injury, but those are the ones that scare teams. A lot. Miller would have to prove that he is capable of repeating the kind of season he had in 2025 without the fear that his back was going to give out before the team committed large swaths of money to his future.

The second thing is exactly that: do it again. He had a marvelous season in 2025 that catapulted him to the top of the team’s prospect rankings, yet he also was struggling to begin the season. Maybe seeing him repeat what he did last year, to a certain extent, would help soothe some of the fears that he just rode a hot streak, though scouting reports and under the hood numbers suggest he is more than capable of repeating his 2025 year.

Justin Crawford

Of the three players here, Crawford seems least likely to get an extension offer as it really just doesn’t feel like it would be necessary based on his offensive profile.

Why?

Baseball has been trending to power tools being more highly valued over hit tools for quite a while. The ideal is to find a player that can have both and can be developed and refined at the big league level, but if druthers were to be had, the power would be what teams wanted. We’ve already seen flashes of having both skills from McGonigle, who looks to have a preternatural feel for doing both and doing both quite well. With Crawford, his success at the minor league level is something that cannot be denied. He’s produced at every level he has played at, though maybe missing the power that is desired by major league teams. It’s also simply not his game to have over the fence power, but more of the gap to gap variety. Nothing wrong with that as plenty of players have that same kind of game and have found success. The drumbeats of “Crawford needs to hit the ball in the air more” have gotten louder with each rung climbed on the minor league ladder, yet here he is in the major leagues, performing decently in the early going. No one in the organization was going to expect much this year from him, preferring to lower expectations in his first go ‘round.

Yet for an extension, there has to be some kind of “above and beyond” to his game that we haven’t really seen flashes of just yet. It’s still very, very early in the season and he’s doing pretty much exactly what the team was expecting him to do, yet that isn’t the kind of offensive profile that gets one contract extensions. For those that lean on the negative side, there’s might even be the idea that if he were flashing more in his offensive game (more home run power, more balls in the air), there might even be an idea of “show it more than once” before they even thought of talking about an extension.

So while he’s doing well in his first tour around the majors, there still just isn’t enough there yet that shouts “CONTRACT EXTENSION!” for Crawford.

Andrew Painter

Pitching is expensive. We know this.

Starting pitching is really expensive. We know this as well. So why would an extension for Andrew Painter make sense over the other two? The reason is simple: ceiling and money.

Right now, the ceiling that Painter possesses is greater than anyone in the team’s minor league development system. If he reaches that ceiling, the team is looking at having another top tier starter, most days a #2, some days scraping ace-level performances. There might be a few down ballot Cy Young votes along the way, an All-Star appearance or two, all the makings of a very good pitcher. That kind of performance gets paid, handsomely.

Giving Painter an extension now might mean that the team is avoiding those awkward arbitration hearings where players hear how bad they are, contrary to their performance on the field. It would also mean locking in free agent years, however many would be agreed on, at a below market value rate, allowing the team to use possible savings to shore up different parts of the roster. As mentioned before, it makes sense from a roster standpoint so long as the money saved on one player is in turn spent on another (not necessarily a guarantee).

However…

Painter is a pitcher. Pitchers break, as Painter already has. He has made exactly one career start in the major leagues as of this writing (two by the time you read this). That is something teams rarely do for pitchers that have as little experience as Painter has. It’s not to say that teams haven’t given extensions to pitchers with little time. A list of current pitchers are:

  • Brayan Bello: 6 years, $55 million – signed after he had 1+ seasons of experience
  • Spencer Strider: 6 years, $75 million – highest AAV at the time for pitchers of 1+ seasons of experience
  • Hunter Greene: 6 years, $53 million – signed after one year of experience

The list continues, but the theme is the same. The pitchers all had at least a year of experience pitching in the majors before the team agreed to a deal with them.

Painter, while possessing a ceiling that is on par with at least three of these names, hasn’t shown anything outside of at least one decent start that would make the Phillies want to commit long term just yet. Those talks could happen once the season is over provided Painter shows that he is worthy of the deal. There just isn’t any reason for it happen right now.

The team has received an injection of youth from Crawford and Painter so far this year and may get another if Miller proves his talent and health are worthy of a promotion. For now, though, it just doesn’t make any sense to give them guaranteed money without better (and more of a track record of) results on the field.

Mariners Prospect Rankings #4, INF Michael Arroyo

The time has arrived for Michael Arroyo. He’s climbed his way into the upper ranks of this system, and with a debut date rapidly approaching, he’s reached a critical point in his career that will largely signal the future trajectory of his time as a major league baseball player. A tremendously talented player, to what level Arroyo eventually ascends to seems destined to clarify after this season.

Arroyo possesses one of the most complete offensive approaches in all of minor league baseball. A balanced blend of bat-to-ball, OBP, and pop, it’s about as well-rounded as you can get for someone who just started his age 21 season this past weekend. He’s yet to post a season in the minors with an OBP south of .400, and he’s averaging 20 homers a year over the past two seasons, doing so across three different levels. The raw production is immense, even without factoring in the fact he’s accomplished this against players several years his senior.

Analyzing options for where he fits defensively is where things get tricky. Standing at 5’10 (a generous measurement), Arroyo lacks the size of a first baseman, yet his inconsistencies defensively have moved him off his natural shortstop position into a “tweener” 2B/3B profile. Unfortunately, however, his glove is yet to stabilize at either of these positions, and he’s struggled to reliably make plays that need to be clockwork at the big league level. The natural extension would be to move him to a corner outfield spot, but the arm could be a question should he end up making the move. It’s a tricky line to walk that doesn’t have a clean solution at present.

Ty France made an All-Star game as a Seattle Mariner this decade and had similar defensive limitations to Arroyo when he made his way to the organization in the Austin Nola trade. Luis Arraez is playing second base for the Giants right now and has made a mighty fine career for himself despite being a well-below-average glove. Perhaps these “comps” aren’t the most inspiring thing to hear about a player that’s been lauded in this system for years, but Arroyo is capable of putting up a 10 WAR career for the M’s, it has to be considered a development win for both the player and the organization. The bat is more than good enough to get him a shot in the majors some time this season, but finding him a long term defensive home is what will ultimately decide his ceiling as a player. 

Rangers Mailbag: Questions And Beefs

Danny Wild-Imagn Images
Danny Wild-Imagn Images

MAILBAG: This communique from Rangers Fan In Florida – Sir Al Greenberg – points an accusatory finger at Artemi Panarin: 

"Interestingly," says Greenberg, `'the Rangers' late season – and commendable – victory rush coincides with the trading of Breadman Panarin. Considering Artemi's importance to the team, his plus-minus mark of MINUS - 16 hurt the Blueshirts."

Perhaps more than we ever imagined.

Like The Maven, Sir Alan questions aspects of GM Chris Drury's "Retooling" or whatever you choose to call the full-speed ahead youth movement.

"They have a heck of a prospect in (left wing) Adam Sýkora but I'm baffled by the fact that they let him rot in Hartford when he could have flourished in New York. Same with Gabe Perreault, Jaroslav Chmelař and Noah Laba."

Thanks for the "heads-up" Brother Greenberg, too bad you weren't in the general manager's chair; this team could have made the playoffs!