Category: MLB

As Spring Training kicks into second gear, we have our first game of the season to look forward to on Saturday. It will be our first glimpse of the arms, the bats, and the gloves that our hopes and dreams this season will rest upon…but no pressure guys. There has been a flurry of ‘minor signings” that may add some competition that we didn’t see coming, but I think we’ll largely see what we expected come opening day with a few interesting twists. Of course, the qualifier that always comes into play is real, and that is “barring injury.”

An early projection for A’s Opening Day roster

Last week, A’s Beat Writer Martín Gallegosgave his thoughts on the opening day lineup. With all due respect for a guy who knows this team better than anyone, there are no bold or wild predictions, just solid insights into the roster skipper Mark Kotsay will likely use to start the season.

No surprises at catcher, we can expect Shea Langeliers to be the starter with veteran Austin Wynns serving as primary backup.

First base belongs to Rookie of the Year Nick Kurtz. If heathy, I expect a monster year with no sophomore slump in sight.

Second base will surely go to one of this off-season’s trade acquisitions Jeff McNeil. Coming over from the Mets, he brings a multi-positional resume but will be a real upgrade offensively and defensively over Zack Gelof so until something drastically changes the job at second is his.

The biggest battle this spring will be for third base. We can expect a true competition between Max Muncy, Darell Hernaiz, and Brett Harris. My gut tells me that before his sweet contract extension expires that we might see Jacob Wilson over at third, but I seriously doubt that it will be this season.

Jacob Wilson is pretty much a lock for starting the season at shortstop. The ROY runner-up put together a solid season at the plate and should build on that for 2026. His range is somewhat limited so he may not be there forever but expect him to play a solid short and contribute nicely to the ever-improving offense.

I think we can safely expect Tyler Soderstrom, Denzel Clarke, and Lawrence Butler to roam the outfield on opening day. Soderstrom’s defense was one of the biggest surprises of 2025 having just moved from first base and yet being a finalist for a Gold Glove award. Clarke is a walking highlight reel in centerfield and if he stays healthy will be web gem superstar. Butler is evolving into a team leader and with more plate discipline will continue to grow as an offensive asset to this team. Expect three additional names to battle for the backup outfield roles: Carlos Cortes, Colby Thomas, and Junior Perez.

Veteran Brent Rooker will likely have a lock on the Designated Hitter role, his job for all but twenty-seven games in 2025. With McNeil likely leading off and setting the table for him, I expect Rook and Kurtz to drive in more runs this year than last.

With Andy Ibáñez picked up off waivers from the Dodgers, Max Schuemann was traded to the Yankees. That likely means that Ibáñez will take over the role of super-utility guy for Kotsay.

The starting rotation is far from settled, but all indications are that Luis Severino, Jeffrey Springs, Luis Morales, Jacob Lopez, and recent acquisition Aaron Civale will be the starting five. Civale effectively bumped J.T. Ginn to the bullpen, but it’s a long season so he may still get his shot.

The bullpen will have two fresh faces to start the season. We’ll see Mark Leiter Jr. and Scott Barlow join with Hogan Harris, Justin Sterner, Michael Kelly, Tyler Ferguson, Elvis Alvarado, and Jack Perkins. No closer has been officially named so we can expect a closer-by-committee at least as the season opens.

Only time will tell if this is truly how the A’s start the season, but the great news is, the first pitch is just three days away!

A’s Coverage

• Can Kurtz get his glove to match his monster bat?
• Zack Gelof: Outfielder?
• Athletics 2026 Top MLB Prospects Deep Dive
• A’s Community Prospect List: Baez Takes 13th spot
• Waiting For Gelof: What Do We Do?
• “Relievers Are Volatile”… But Why?
• A’s Trade Mitch Spence to KC Royals in exchange for minor leaguer
• Diamondbacks Claim Grant Holman
• Darrell Hernaiz to play for Team PR in WBC
• Are The Final Two Rotation Spots Really Up For Grabs?
• Story Lines To Watch As Spring Training Unfolds
• A’s Sign Starter Aaron Civale
• Athletics add developmental leaguer in trade with Yankees
• Little Signings Everywhere
• A’s Non-Roster Invites to Keep an Eye On
• A’s prospect Jump impressing in first big league camp
• What to know as A’s head to spring camp with high hopes for ‘26
• A’s Claim Andy Ibanez, Add Scott Barlow In Busy Roster Shuffle
• Extensions For Everyone! (Except Kurtz)
• Managers & Top Front Office Executives On Expiring Contract
• De Vries (No. 4 overall) leads Athletics trio on Top 100 Prospects lists

MLB News and Interest:

• All eyes on Verlander as throwing work begins again in Tigertown
• MLBPA leader Tony Clark resigns after revelation of inappropriate relationship
• Twins right-hander Pablo López has major elbow injury that likely will need season-ending surgery
• Phillies’ Trea Turner Reveals ‘Phone Never Rang’ Despite Interest In Playing for Team USA at WBC
• Bo Jackson rips modern MLB’s home run obsession over batting average
• Buehler joins Padres after years with Dodgers: ‘It feels a little weird’
• Phillies and 11-year-old shortstop reportedly agree on historic $1.8 million deal
• Corey Seager Discusses Rumors of ‘Toxic’ Marcus Semien Relationship After Mets-Rangers Trade
• Steven Cohen: Mets will never have captain while I own team
• Diamondbacks sign veteran starter Zac Gallen to one-year contract
• Cubs ink reliever Shelby Miller to one-year pact
• Bryce Harper addresses comments Dombrowski made about him
• Machaco embraces Dodgers’ big spending ways
• Boone: No restrictions for Judge this spring
• Castellanos embracing move to first base with Padres
• Roki Sasaki working on 3rd pitch
• A.J. Preller agrees to multiyear extension with Padres
• MLB TV strike zone box won’t indicate whether pitch is ball or strike due to ABS system
• Today in Baseball History

Best of X

Sneak peek 🫣 pic.twitter.com/uS7Zx4u4xw

— Athletics (@Athletics) February 18, 2026

Gage Jump vs. Tommy White. Battle of LSU Tigers. pic.twitter.com/h2F3tidKBr

— Martín Gallegos (@MartinJGallegos) February 18, 2026

A full circle moment for the Biggio family 🧡 https://t.co/MjMW2spvWbpic.twitter.com/mRBphbaE8Z

— MLB (@MLB) February 18, 2026

At the end of January, I wrote an article about the Kansas City Royals potentially moving a starting pitcher for prospects. The Royals have enviable depth, and I think there are six guys – Cole Ragans, Seth Lugo, Michael Wacha, Kris Bubic, Noah Cameron, and Ryan Bergert – who really should be in an MLB starting rotation on Opening Day. Stephen Kolek, the Royals’ presumptive #7 going into next season, would be a great back-end of the rotation guy for other teams as well.

My thought when writing the article was that no major league help was coming in a trade for a starting pitcher, and that the Royals would not consider using a six-man rotation during the year. Royals manager Matt Quatraro, however, revealed to Jack Johnson that the team has at least held discussions about using a six starters during the upcoming year:

Asked Q about a potential 6-man rotation:

“Yeah, it’s certainly something we talked about this offseason. It’s tough to manage when you don’t have a ton of relievers to option. But it is something we’ve talked about, especially in longer stretches of games.” #Royals

— Jack Johnson (@JohnyJ_15) February 18, 2026

Quatraro’s answer on this is interesting for multiple reasons. Regardless of whether the Royals decide to try out a six-man rotation this year, it’s great that the team is having the conversation about it and is willing to be transparent with the public that they are thinking through these things. As someone who thinks about the Royals probably more than I should, I’m comforted by the fact that the people running the team are thinking about them even more.

So what would be the potential upside of a six-man rotation? In theory, the starters would be more effective when they pitched and able to go deeper into games. Mike Petriello pointed out at the beginning of 2025 that more pitchers are pitching on five days rest than four days rest anyway, even if a few teams are actively employing a six-man rotation. The Los Angeles Dodgers are planning on using a six-man rotation this year, as that helps Shohei Ohtani manage his two-way load while also being more familiar with World Series MVP Yoshinobu Yamamoto. The Houston Astros are also considering using a six-man rotation throughout the season, particularly in their jam-packed beginning of the year. The Astros will be incorporating Tatsuya Imai from the NPB to their team, and pitchers in NPB pitch once a week, so a six-man rotation should make his adjustment to MLB smoother.

The 2024 Royals showed how valuable having starters able to be effective and go deep into games was, as that proved to be a key ingredient to the team’s success. The 2025 rotation battled more injuries, particularly at the top of the rotation, and was saved by Cameron’s remarkable rookie season. Can Ragans and Lugo be more effective than they were in 2025 and remain able to pitch all year if they get an extra day of rest between starts? If you are just trying to get your best 26 players on the team, can you really leave out a healthy Bergert?

The potential downside of a six-man rotation is that your best pitchers get fewer starts and have less ability to positively impact your season. Ragans is likely to get five fewer starts in a six-man rotation, assuming that every guy goes on five days’ rest in order. Cameron and Bergert are both great options for the back end of a rotation, but a healthy Ragans is still bette,r and your team is likely to win more games with Ragans starting. In a winnable AL Central, every game matters, which might make the Royals loath to have their best guys pitch less frequently.

Quatraro also mentioned that it is difficult to manage the bullpen if you have six starters and not a lot of relief pitchers with minor league options. Right now, Roster Resource projects the Royals to have eight relievers and five starters; teams are only allowed to carry thirteen pitchers on their roster. Of the eight relievers that Roster Resource projects to make the Opening Day roster, only three have options remaining: Lucas Erceg, Daniel Lynch, and Alex Lange. Something will have gone terribly wrong if the Royals are sending Erceg to Omaha. So if you have seven relievers instead of eight, presumably one of Lange or Lynch will be in Omaha to start the year, and the other one is the only guy who could safely go down if you need more bullpen help.

Roster Resource does project Bailey Falter to make the team, and he is out options, so if the Royals really wanted a six-man rotation, they might have to try and sneak Falter through waivers or be willing to let another team claim him for their staff. An extra pitcher in your starting rotation should make the long reliever more of a luxury than a necessity. The Royals, however, were very willing to shuffle out the back end of the bullpen in 2025 and clearly would like to be able to do so again in 2026.

I did think it was interesting that Quatraro mentioned that the Royals might use a six-man rotation during longer stretches of games. Bergert, Cameron, and Kolek (along with newly acquired Mason Black) all have options remaining and could stay stretched out in Omaha when the Royals have more off days. The Royals have an early stretch, from April 5th to April 27th, where they play 21 games in 22 days. It’s early in the season, so rainouts are certainly possible, but that’s a long stretch right out of the gate. More pitcher injuries happen before the season and early in the season rather than later in the year, so keeping your starters from overtaxing themselves and getting hurt right out of the chute could be a prudent choice. The team also plays 29 games in 31 days from the end of May to end of June, which seems like another stretch where the team could consider going to a six-man rotation.

It’s certainly possible that injuries will render this entire conversation moot. It’s also possible one of the starters will struggle and no longer be deserving of a rotation slot. Still, I’m glad that the team is talking about a potential six-man rotation, and I will be very curious to track if we see one during the busiest stretches of the season.

6. Robert Calaz (470 points, 19 ballots)

At the end of 2024, Calaz seemed to be on a rocket ship toward the big leagues after a season in which he was named the MVP of the Arizona Complex League and tore up the Low-A California league in a small sample. Instead, the 2025 season saw the 6’2” toolsy right-handed 20-year-old Dominican outfielder repeat in the California League and perform at an above-average (but not elite) level as one of the youngest players in the league. Calaz, who was 24th on MLB.com’s international amateur free agent prospect rankings for 2023, received Colorado’s top international signing bonus in the 2023 January period at $1.7 million, which is similar to what fellow PuRP Sean Sullivan received as a second-round pick in the 2023 MLB Draft.

Calaz began his professional career with a bang in the Dominican Summer League, producing a 149 wRC+ and playing center field with a bit of right field mixed in. In 2024, Calaz came stateside to play with the Arizona Complex League and flat-out murdered the ball. In 210 PA with the ACL team, Calaz hit ten homers among his 27 extra-base hits with 12 steals in 13 attempts en route to a monster .349/.462/.651 line, good for a 172 wRC+. He led the ACL in several major offensive categories (AVG/OBP/SLG/OPS/HR/RBI/TB) en route to a well-deserved league MVP award. The Rockies promoted Calaz to Low-A Fresno after the ACL season in early August, where he was 3.1 years younger than league average. That didn’t stop Calaz — he hit .327/.386/.571 with two homers, two triples, two doubles, and three steals in 57 plate appearances (147 wRC+).

In 2025, the Rockies chose to send Calaz back to Fresno for a longer run, where he was still 2.2 years younger than league average. The season started inauspiciously, as Calaz suffered an injury in the first game of the season that knocked him out for three weeks. In 424 plate appearances, Calaz hit .259/.338/.399 with ten homers among his 29 extra-base hits. Calaz performed above average offensively (105 wRC+), but not nearly as high as Rockies fans were expecting considering his performance in 2024 at the same level.

Additionally, Calaz struck out in 26% of plate appearances (9% walks), which is pretty high for low minors pitching (though he improved his contact % from 66% to 70% year over year). It is of course important to remember that Calaz only faced a younger pitcher than him in 6% of plate appearances in 2025, but at some point Calaz will need to figure out how to beat upper minors pitching that can execute a scouting report. In the field, Calaz split time between right field (71 games, five assists, nine errors) and center (25 games, two errors).

Here is a look at Calaz from 2025 in Fresno, including some slow-mo looks at his swing:

Keith Law of the Athletic ranked Calaz 11th in the system earlier this month:

Calaz got a lot of attention after he hit .349/.462/.651 in the Arizona Complex League in 2024, but he did so mostly on physical ability rather than a feel for the game, and that deficiency caught up to him in Low A last year. Still just 19, he hit .259/.338/.399 in Fresno with a 26 percent strikeout rate driven by high whiff and chase rates, including a 34 percent swing-and-miss rate just on fastballs. He wasn’t ready for the level and probably needed short-season ball — he would have put up stupid numbers in Grand Junction — so take some of that with a grain of salt, but his baseball instincts just aren’t that advanced yet. He’s going to be big and strong with 30-homer upside in an outfield corner, with a lot of work to do on approach to get there.

Baseball America recently ranked Calaz 9th in the system:

Calaz stands 6-foot-2 with room to add more strength to an already-mature frame. He brings explosive raw power to the plate, though his game remains a bit unrefined. Swing-and-miss concerns have followed him since signing—a common caveat with young, power-first hitters—but they’ve become more pronounced. Calaz’s swing starts with an extremely high hand-set, and he sometimes rests the bat on his shoulder before using a waggle to start his trigger.

Baseball Prospectus put Calaz 49th on their pre-season top 101 prospects list last January on the strength of that breakout 2024. That ranked third in the system, where Calaz was given a 60 OFP grade by Jeffrey Paternostro:

Calaz seemed a pretty easy scout last year, but nevertheless we underranked him. He hit the ball incredibly hard for a 17-year-old, but his contact rate in the DSL suggested better pitching would really undo his swing. Well, he came stateside and hit the ball incredibly hard for an 18-year-old, but made more contact than we expected in the process, making it all the way to full-season ball by the end of the 2024 season. It’s a pretty simple setup with a high back elbow creating a steep swing path that can really do damage in the air when he barrels one in the zone, but while Calaz’s ‘A’ swing is impressive, there’s really no ‘B’ swing a lot of the time, which can lead to in-zone whiff if the pitch isn’t where he expects, or topped/mishit contact even when he tracks it all right.

The thing is, even Calaz’s mishits sound loud, and there just aren’t a lot of teenaged prospects with this combination of damage potential and minor league production, even if it’s come only in the complex and Cal League. I think there is more in the tank here, too. Calaz has already reshaped his body some from last season—not really a surprise for a 17-year-old getting his first couple seasons of professional S+C work—and I’m more confident he will add even more strength and stick on the grass than I was at this time last year. It’s far more likely to be right field than center—he split time at both in 2024—but that’s better than first base or DH, and while the contact rate is still concerning, if he can maintain even this for another year at a higher level, Calaz will be one of the premier outfield prospects in baseball.

Calaz continues to show impressive power for his age, now we just need to see if he can hit upper-minors pitching in a year or two. That’s not that hard, tell ‘em Wash.

MLB Pipeline ranked Calaz fourth in the system as a 50 Future Value player last year, highlighted by a 55 power grade and 50 grades on every other tool:

[Calaz] managed to win the ACL Triple Crown without really having an idea of what he’s doing at the plate yet. Already strong and physical, Calaz hits the ball about as hard as anyone in the system, posting elite-level exit velocities, with tremendous raw power he’s still learning to tap into. He draws walks but still needs to tone down his swing tendencies as he is susceptible to breaking stuff away and out of the zone in particular.

The Rockies feel like Calaz is starting to show the makings of being a five-tool player and he’ll continue to get reps in center field. Most feel that his 6-foot-2 frame will continue to fill out and he’ll slow down more, necessitating a full-time move to right field, where his power production should profile perfectly.

Eric Longenhagen of FanGraphs ranked Calaz as a 40+ FV player (eighth in the system) last January, highlighted by a plus-plus future grade on his raw power, a plus arm, and even a plus future fielding grade:

The power aspect of Calaz’s profile is for real. Perhaps what is most absurd is how much thump he can generate without a leg kick — he starts with a very wide stance and uses just a little toe tap to get going. A very loose athlete, Calaz rotates with verve and ferocity, but in order to do so, his hips often clear very early, leaving him vulnerable to sliders away from him. This is a pretty serious issue already. Calaz ran a paltry 66% contact rate in 2024, worse than all but one qualified big leaguer (Zack Gelof). There are a handful of very toolsy whiff-prone power hitters in that contact rate area, including Christopher Morel and Logan O’Hoppe, both of whom are sound build/frame comps for Calaz. And Calaz projects to have raw power similar to other players in that group, like Brent Rooker and Adolis García. There’s 35-homer ceiling here, but there’s also a lot of bust risk because of how many rookie-level strikeouts we’re talking about.

Calaz is settling more into a right-field role than center and has some big contact rate questions. Still though, plus right-handed power is tough to come by, and the big signing bonus Calaz got is proof positive of its market value. Calaz is clearly a high-ceiling player who at least a couple years away (my bet is a late 2028 debut at age 22) and we’ll see how his plate approach develops as the opposition improves. The recently designated for assignment Yanquiel Fernández has some similar traits and in multiple cases took steps forward in repeat assignments.

Calaz will likely spend 2026 in High-A Spokane as a 20-year-old. I ranked Calaz fourth on my list as a 45 FV player because of the performance, signing bonus, and his ability to stick in the outfield, though I am leery of the contact rate struggles.

---

Please keep in mind our Purple Row Community Guidelines when you’re commenting. Thanks!

Young Giants left-hander Carson Whisenhunt shows off big jump in velocity originally appeared on NBC Sports Bay Area

SCOTTSDALE — Carson Whisenhunt has felt strong all spring, and since the start of camp, he has talked about his optimism that he’ll look much sharper than he did as a rookie. But early in a simulated game Thursday, a pitch felt different coming out of his hand. It felt just a bit better than the others, and he snuck a peak at the scoreboard.

“I was like, ‘I kinda want to see where I’m at,'” he said later. “I was not expecting to see 97.”

There were a lot of 97 mph fastballs for Whisenhunt in two innings against teammates, along with plenty at 96. As a rookie last year, Whisenhunt hit 95 mph just once, topping out at 95.3 mph but averaging 92.6 in five starts. 

The velocity Thursday opened plenty of eyes in the seats behind home plate, where just about the entire front office was sitting. Even Whisenhunt was surprised. His velocity had been good in bullpen sessions, but he planned to be sitting around 95 mph in the simulated game. 

“That was a little different,” he said, smiling. “I’m feeling a lot better than I did last year. I’m moving better (and) the mechanics, especially — everything is kind of flowing right now. I’m trying not to overdo it but it came out hot today.”

Whisenhunt dealt with a back strain late last season, but in the offseason he focused on making sure he was physically ready for what will be an important spring. He also made some mechanical adjustments to tap into more of the velocity he had in the minors. He was 94-97 mph throughout his first full professional season and topped out at 98. 

“Last year I was sinking into my back hip a lot more and getting lower and I feel like it was kind of blocking velo, so to speak,” he said. “Now I’m a little more upright, not sinking as much, but still trying to get in my back hip a little bit, and then just kinda throwing the s— out of it. That’s the best way to put it.”

With the first spring games two days away, there is no obvious spot for Whisenhunt on the initial roster. The rotation is currently full and he’s probably too good of a starting prospect to be put in the bullpen in April. The Giants likely would want him to stay stretched out, and they have enough lefty relief options in camp at the moment. 

But Whisenhunt certainly made a statement Thursday about how ready he might be when a starter is needed. In addition to the fastball, he showed off what has long been one of the best left-handed changeups in the game, getting three strikeouts on the pitch. He also mixed in his new cutter, a pitch he learned from assistant pitching coach Christian Wonders.

“I’m just trying to get a little bit more feel with it,” he said of the cutter. “It’s still new so I’m playing around with the grip a little bit and finger pressure on certain aspects of it. But it was good today.”

Download and follow the Giants Talk Podcast

The San Diego Padres have not added a big-name pitcher since the re-signing of Michael King earlier this offseason. Instead, the Padres have picked up players on one-year or minor league deals seemingly hoping that quantity will deliver quality. The Padres added Griffin Canning, German Marquez and Walker Buehler. Lincoln Zdunich of Gaslamp Ball believes that San Diego is looking for at least one of these arms to play a significant role in 2026.

Padres News:

• Projected rankings for the Padres as a team and the individual players came out and Cheri Bell of Gaslamp Ball thinks San Diego may be being overlooked. In almost all areas the 2026 team has improved over the 2025 team that finished second in the NL West and made the postseason. The Padres have a chance to prove the projections wrong if they can make a return to the playoffs as they are not expected to do so.
• The Padres had a busy holiday weekend making additions to the roster and extending general manager A.J. Preller and AJ Cassavell of MLB.com provides a recap of all the moves now that all the players have shown up in Peoria, Ariz.
• Catcher Luis Campusano is out of options and potentially out of time with the Padres. HE has the support of new manager Craig Stammen, and the belief is that he has the support of his teammates as well. If Campusano can produce at the major league level he could have a significant role this season, but if he cannot, he may find himself with another organization.
• Kevin Acee of the San Diego Union-Tribune points out the fact that Walker Buehler in brown and gold is an odd sight considering all the time he spent in Dodger blue, but Acee also believes the Padres coaches and players are hoping Buehler can make the rotation. Although it will be strange to root for a player the Friar Faithful vehemently rooted against not too long ago, the odds of Buehler making the team could receive a boost if San Diego employs a six-man rotation.
• Front office executives from around MLB were apparently not fans of newly acquired Nick Castellanos. Jayson Stark of The Athletic wrote an article where he spoke with executives about which player subtraction would benefit their former team. The answer he got was Castellanos and this poll was conducted prior to him being released by the Philadelphia Phillies.

Baseball news:

• With the unceremonious departure of Tony Clark as the head of the MLBPA on Tuesday, the need for a new executive director became evident. The MLBPA named Bruce Meyer as the interim executive director, Wednesday.
• The Atlanta Braves are already absorbing injuries to their pitching staff, and they have yet to play their first game of the spring. Spencer Schwellenbach had surgery to clean up his elbow which will land him on the 60-day IL. Hurston Waldrep is expected to have the same procedure and he rook will start the season on the 60-day IL.

There was a long stretch of Red Sox history in which you could roll into spring training and write down the guy who would dominate the DH position in permanent ink.

For 14 years from 2003 through 2016, it belonged to David Ortiz. Then, after he retired and the Sox tried Hanley Ramirez there for a season in 2017, J.D. Martinez took over and led the team in games played from the position for five years from 2018 through 2022. Basically, if you wanted to get in the lineup and your last name didn’t end in a z, you’d better have a glove, and you better have spot where you could play every day.

But those days, much like the balls those guys hit, are long gone. Starting with Martinez’s final year in Boston in 2022, the Red Sox have now had four different guys lead the team in games from the DH slot in the last four seasons. And given the makeup of this roster going into 2026, we might be about to go five-for-five.

First up, here’s the guys who have played the most games at DH for the Red Sox over the last four years:

• 2022: J.D. Martinez (139 games)
• 2023: Justin Turner (98 games)
• 2024: Masataka Yoshida (101 games)
• 2025: Rafael Devers (RIP) (73 games)

Secondly, as a quick side note, not have having a permanent DH really changes the way you build a roster. Back in the days of Ortiz and Martinez, any other everyday position player signed or traded for had to make sense in some specific spot. But now, you can have overflow — because hey, “if both guys are good and you have extra at-bats, the other guy can just DH. Problem solved!”

Well, Craig Breslow and company have taken that theory and pushed it to its limit as, right now, I don’t have a clue who is going to get the most at-bats at DH in 2026.

It could be Jarren Duran, who might get displaced from the outfield for most of the season if Roman Anthony, Ceddanne Rafaela, and Wilyer Abreu stay healthy and anchor down at their positions.

It could be Masataka Yoshida, who, if healthy, may bounce back offensively and doesn’t have anywhere to go defensively on this roster.

It could be Triston Casas, who still has serious upside power after a pair of injury plagued seasons and is now a less obvious fit at first base with Willson Contreras on the roster.

It could even be Kristian Campbell, who, unlike the other three guys I just mentioned, is right handed. He might work his way into the lineup against left-handed starters if his retooled swing sticks better than his glove at any one position.

Or who knows — it could be somebody else who gets shuffled in the deck we’re not even thinking about right now. Who do you think will lead the 2026 Red Sox in games played at DH?

Talk about this and whatever else you’d like, and, as always, be good to one another.

So much kvetching about the state of the rotation, which is understandable given the injury news before Spring Training games have even begun.

But, let’s pivot slightly: we know the deals that have already happened. Which ones should the Braves have made?

The list of signed free agent starters is here: https://www.fangraphs.com/roster-resource/free-agent-tracker?sign=signed&pos=sp

For me, the big money deals were too big and inflated for the production they offered, but that shouldn’t be surprising at this point. The played-in-another-league-last-year deals (Tatsuya Imai, Cody Ponce) are a lot more modest, but still fairly risky — I would’ve preferred them be more like pillow deals.

That said, a lot of mid-tier deals, I think would’ve been good to make. Sure, the Braves may not want to add a mid-tier guy, but I don’t see those deals as substantially constraining flexibility. We’ve talked at length about Chris Bassitt at this point, and his salary is pretty reasonable. Steven Matz looks like he has a great chance to produce surplus on his contract. I’m not very excited about the Justin Verlander, Nick Martinez, and Dustin May deals, but they’re not terrible.

Foster Griffin was an interesting signing for the Nationals given the low, short commitment. Wouldn’t have minded that one.

There were a handful for quantity-for-quality-ish trades of starters. In particular, Shane Baz and Ryan Weathers come to mind. Those moves would’ve been the opposite of Chris Bassitt in a way since they wouldn’t necessarily add a reliable arm, but would just diversify a high degree of risk further. Even the MacKenzie Gore deal, while on the pricier side because Gore is a pricier pitcher production-wise, seemed okay.

I think that’s largely where I come out — either one of the Bassitt/Matz/Griffin deals, or one of the Baz/Weathers/Gore deals would’ve been nice. I don’t think the Braves have much interest in Zack Littell, but maybe if they give him a pretty cheap deal, that could be Bassitt-lite. They probably don’t have interest for the same reason they apparently had little inclination to engage on Bassitt, though.

Today marks one week that the marriage between the Phillies and Nick Castellanos officially came to an end. Both sides have since appeared to move on, as the Phillies look to their new starting right fielder in Adolis Garcia and Castellanos has agreed to a deal with the San Diego Padres. The end of the Castellanos era certainly was messy, with the details of the Miami incident finally becoming known as well as many other reports about Castellanos’ behavior from Phillies sources in Matt Gelb’s now infamous article.

It’s not a stretch to say that Castellanos never quite lived up to expectations in Philadelphia. He was brought in on a five year, $100M contract with the hopes that he would provide the middle of the order right-handed bat the Phillies have been starved for. However, Castellanos was just never able to come close to his 2021 season with the Reds where he hit 34 home runs with a .939 OPS. His best season in Philadelphia was 2023 where he was named an All-Star after a strong first half but ultimately ended up hitting .272 with a .788 OPS. Over his four seasons with the Phillies, Castellanos slashed .260/.306/.426 and had a 100 OPS+, meaning he was exactly league average. That was coupled with being one of the worst defenders at any position in baseball for the overwhelming majority of the deal.

But it’s also fair to say Castellanos had his moments. Despite his disappointing offensive season in 2022 and defensive struggles, he made numerous game changing or saving catches during the run to the 2022 World Series. The Phillies also may not have won the 2023 NLDS over the Braves without Castellanos, as he slugged four home runs in four games, including two off of Spencer Strider in the clinching Game 4.

In any case, Nick Castellanos’ Phillies career is over. It was an eventful one, for better or worse. How will you remember his time in Philadelphia?

• Livingston have lost 21 of their last 23 meetings with Rangers in all competitions (D2) since a 1-0 league victory in September 2018.
• Rangers have won 10 of their last 11 visits to Livingston in all competitions, including their last seven in a row (all in the league) since a goalless draw in August 2020.
• Livingston are winless in their last 12 home league games (D4 L8), the longest run by any side within a single Scottish Premiership season since Hamilton in March 2016 (also 12), while the last to go longer within a single campaign were St Mirren from August to February 2015 (14).
• After winning just one of their opening eight league games of the season (D6 L1), Rangers have since won 14 of their 19 league fixtures under Danny Rohl (D4 L1). Indeed, since his first Scottish Premiership game in charge on October 26th, the Gers have earned 46 points, at least nine more than any other side in the competition (Celtic second with 37), and 11 more than league leaders Hearts (35).
• Rangers have won each of their last 11 league games against opponents starting the day bottom of the Scottish Premiership since a 1-1 draw with Hamilton in February 2021.

For most of the 2025 season, the Yankees' bench was one of the weakest in baseball.

GM Brian Cashman's additions helped lift an uneven, light-hitting bench to allow manager Aaron Boone to navigate the second half of the season and postseason. 

It didn't result in a championship, they performed well enough that they brought back most of those bench options from a year ago. 

While that may signal that there aren't many spots open on the bench for Opening Day, there are still options the Yanks will have to sift through this spring.

Here's a breakdown of all the potential bench options...

---

The Locks

Health is a big part of this, as Anthony Volpe will begin the season on the IL. That elevates a 2025 bench player into the starting shortstop role, but also opens up the backup infielder role.

Here are the sure-fire picks for the Yankees bench on Opening Day -- if everyone remains healthy:

Amed Rosario
Paul Goldschmidt
J.C. Escarra

Jose Caballero will be the everyday shortstop to start the season, and Boone and the organization will have to sort through that position once Volpe returns. Caballero's backup could be Rosario, who has experience just about all over the field. However, Rosario will be the backup to Ryan McMahon at third base when they take on southpaws.

Rosario's versatility will give Boone enough experience at multiple infield positions that he can prioritize others, like the outfield.

Goldschmidt will back up Ben Rice, who is set to take the majority of the starts at first base, while Escarra will give Austin Wells a spell once in a while as the team's backup catcher. 

Martian Left Behind?

One of the biggest stories this spring is what the Yankees plan to do with Jasson Dominguez.

The young outfielder started the 2025 season as the team's everyday left fielder, but he was overtaken by the surprising Trent Grisham to the point where Dominguez became the fourth outfielder as Grisham, Cody Bellinger and Aaron Judge roamed the outfield for most of the second half and the postseason.

And, unfortunately for Dominguez, all three outfielders are projected to be the Opening Day outfield when the 2026 season starts. So where does that leave Dominguez?

The organization has teased that Dominguez's role in 2026 will be reduced, and it seems likely he starts the year in Triple-A. In 2024, the last time Dominguez was in Triple-A, the outfielder slashed .309/.368/.480 with seven homers and an OPS of .848. Perhaps some more seasoning in the minors can help him on the defensive end and when it comes to hitting from the right side of the plate.

But Dominguez can also kill it this spring and force the Yankees to bring him along. That feels less likely at this juncture. 

Fourth Outfielder Options

Aside from Dominguez, New York has a few options to fill that fourth outfielder role.

Veteran outfielder Seth Brown was invited as an NRI, and his lefty swing would be perfect for Yankee Stadium. He did have career-lows last season with the Athletics, playing 38 games before being released. It's an intriguing prospect to bring Brown to Opening Day, but the team is already too left-handed, especially in the outfield.

Marco Luciano is a right-handed hitter who was invited to camp on a minor league deal and is a former top prospect. While he hasn't played in the majors in a couple of years, he could potentially show enough to break camp.

And then we have Oswaldo Cabrera, the Swiss-Army Knife of the Yankees the last few years. Cabrera broke camp last season as the starting third baseman before a season-ending injury forced a slew of moves -- from moving Jazz Chisholm Jr. to third to eventually trading for McMahon. Cabrera will look to prove to the Yanks that he's healthy. If he is, he should have the inside track to be a bench piece.

Many forget Cabrera has experience in the outfield -- as does Rosario -- so he could be used in a variety of ways. 

Spencer Jones

Jones took a massive step in his development in 2025, dominating Double-A pitching and carrying that over into Triple-A. Between the two levels, the young slugger slashed .274/.362/.571 with 35 home runs, 80 RBI and an OPS of .983. That production elevated Jones from an afterthought to on the doorstep of a promotion to the big leagues.

But just like Dominguez, Jones doesn't have a clear path to the bigs. The outfield is crowded, and it may not benefit Jones to sit on the bench and play once a week. Like most of the Yankees' roster, being left-handed also does Jones a disservice, as the team is already loaded with them. 

Jones could potentially play his way to breaking camp with the team, but he'll need to lower his strikeout rate. He fanned 200 times in 124 games in 2024 and 179 times in 116 games in 2025.

Other Infield Options

The Yanks need a fourth outfielder, but they can potentially piece it together with Rosario and Cabrera getting time in the outfield. Even Giancarlo Stanton could see some time in the outfield.

Although it's more likely the Yankees use a traditional outfielder on the bench, there are some infielders who could fill in the role if they play well enough or if Cabrera doesn't prove he's healthy enough.

Jorbit Vivas is one option. The youngster played 29 games in the bigs last season but didn't show much in terms of offense. He was 9 of 56 (.161) with two doubles, one home run and five RBI. He does provide versatility, playing at second and third last season, but would need to show more upside to make the team.

Paul DeJong is an interesting option. The veteran infielder was invited to camp and his experience is something the Yankees could use in a pinch. The 32-year-old played 57 games with the Nationals last year, slugging six homers while slashing .228/.290/.373. 

Meet the Mets

David Stearns was on hand to break ground on the team’s new minor league complex which will almost be entirely paid for by Steve Cohen.

After being acquired in the Freddy Peralta trade, Carlos Mendoza confirmed that Tobias Myers will be on the roster Opening Day but what role he would have remains unclear.

Christian Scott is in camp after losing all of last season to Tommy John surgery and he should provide valuable pitching depth to the team this year.

The team’s top prospects are all in camp and they all have something different they are working on to improve in hope of making the team in the future.

Tom Seaver’s family is auctioning off some of his things including memorabilia from the 1969 season.

Former Met Daniel Murphy is just one of the names that came up as a possible candidate to replace Tony Clark as leader of the MLBPA.

Around the National League East

Braves righty Spencer Schwellenbach underwent surgery to remove loose bodies in his elbow and Hurston Waldrep will undergo the same surgery soon.

Marlins prospect Robby Snelling will get the start to open Grapefruit League action against the Mets.

Bryce Harper praised the Giants hiring of Tony Vitello as their new manager despite lacking major league experience.

Former Met Drew Smith signed a minor league contract with Washington and is hoping to impress the Nationals in camp after recovering from his second Tommy John surgery.

Around Major League Baseball

The Major League Baseball Players Association elected Bruce Meyer as its new interim executive director.

Los Angeles Dodgers reliever Brusdar Graterol will miss the beginning of the season as he continues to recover from surgery for a torn labrum.

Due to his size Aaron Judge might benefit from the new ABS challenge system since umpires call him inconsistantly.

The Mariners signed catcher Mitch Garver to a minor league contract.

Yesterday at Amazin’ Avenue

On the latest episde of A Pod of their Own, broken hamate bones and the controversy of captains were discussed.

Lukas Vlahos previewed Ryan Clifford’s 2026 season.

This Date in Mets History

The New York Mets hosted their first ever spring training workout on this date in 1962.

Ahead of the Dodgers’ first official workout on Tuesday, manager Dave Roberts delivered his annual opening address to the team.

First full squad workout starts with a speech from Doc! #DodgersSTpic.twitter.com/pt1DH3vwM7

— Los Angeles Dodgers (@Dodgers) February 17, 2026

Included during the presentation was asking newcomers Kyle Tucker and Edwin Díaz why they chose the Dodgers. Well, besides the record-setting contractsboth signed.

From Alden González at ESPN:

Their message, Roberts said, centered on the team’s attention to detail, the professionalism with which they play and the way staffers take care of players’ families.

…

“I think one of our most overarching goals is to be a destination spot,” Dodgers president of baseball operations Andrew Friedman said. “Most important, where our own guys don’t want to leave. But where players from other teams are looking longingly, like, ‘Oh, I want to be on the Dodgers’ — that’s our goal. Because we feel like if we’re able to maintain our really talented players, we’re able to get really talented players from other teams, that obviously will help in our ultimate quest to win World Series.”

Roberts on Tuesday also was a guest on the ESPN Baseball Tonight podcast with Buster Olney, talking about Tucker and Díaz, among other things.

"What's makes a good manager – good players, and we got a lot of good players."

Dodgers manager Dave Roberts on the addition of Edwin Diaz and Kyle Tucker | @Buster_ESPN@ESPNLosAngeleshttps://t.co/LvReHHFmwMpic.twitter.com/HEeWF9Eu8h

— ESPN Podcasts (@espnpodcasts) February 18, 2026

---

Christian Zazueta last season won the Branch Rickey Award as the Dodgers minor league pitcher of the year, and figures to open his age-21 season with High-A Great Lakes. The right-hander was listed as one of 10 prospects to watch on the backfields this spring in Arizona by Baseball America.

“Zazueta’s fastball has taken a significant step forward alongside his physical development. The heater now sits around 93 mph and climbed as high as 98 in 2025,” wrote Jesús Cano. “The pitch excels because of his lower release height and excellent extension, allowing it to jump on hitters and generate more impact than the radar gun alone might suggest.”

Old friend alert

Former Dodgers general manager and current Colorado Rockies president of baseball operations talked with Renee Dechert at Purple Row about ‘Moneyball,’ which captured his time with the Oakland A’s under Billy Beane.

The whole interview is worth reading, but I particularly enjoyed this answer from DePodesta on on-base percentage, and how it was portrayed in the book (and movie):

It’s funny. There were a lot of things we were doing at that point that went beyond on-base, but it was in our conversations with Michael is probably the best way to express, at least directionally, what it is that we really were doing. We were trying to find value in the game. And at that point in the game, on-base was something that was probably a little undervalued. Now, in the last 20 years, there have been times where it’s been overvalued, and sort of gone through cycles.

Tom Ricketts is making World Series noises, which ring like endorsing a manager before changing faces. There’s a real spring game tomorrow. Kris Bryant is having a hard time with his chronic pain condition.

*means autoplay on, (directions to remove for Firefox and Chrome). {$} means paywall. {$} means limited views. Italics are often used on this page as sarcasm font. The powers that be have enabled real sarcasm font in the comments.

Thoughtful answers from new Miami Marlins Outfielder Owen Cassie who was traded by the Cubs to Miami in the offseason Cabrera deal. Says he felt somewhat blocked in Chicago, now gets a fresh opportunity this Spring. pic.twitter.com/Psao9prsEV

— Craig Mish (@CraigMish) February 16, 2026

• Marisa Rodriguez (WGN9*): Chicago Cubs to drop life-sized bobbleheads across city on Thursday with a chance to win game tickets. “According to the Cubs, the first 150 people who find a bobblehead or bobblehead box will win a pair of tickets to a regular season game.”
• Maddie Lee (Chicago Sun-Times* {$}): Cubs react to Tony Clark resigning as MLBPA executive director: ‘The strength of the union is in the players’. “With the collective-bargaining agreement expiring Dec. 1, the timing isn’t ideal.”
• Meghan Montemurro (Chicago Tribune* {$}): ‘We have to win more World Series’: Chicago Cubs’ Tom Ricketts has high expectations for 2026 and beyond. “I mean, it’s about winning. All this other stuff, it all leads to one thing, and that’s about winning. We just have to put the kind of teams on the field that can be in the playoffs every year and get back on top.” More from Sahadev Sharma{$}.
• Jordan Bastian (MLB.com*): Veteran-laden Cubs could ‘do something really special’ after reaching NLDS in ’25. “They expect to make the playoffs this year and hope there is a World Series trophy at the end of the ride.”
• Sahadev Sharma (The Athletic {$}): A look at what three pitchers are working on as the Cubs build rotation depth. “Once a team starts to feel settled, that is usually the moment something goes awry.”
• Randy Holt (North Side Baseball*): Cubs’ bullpen will be better because the Front Office abandoned their usual practices this offseason. “Typically building out a relief corps via waiver claims, reclamation types, and low-risk signings, will the Cubs’ different approach to their bullpen yield anything more in 2026?”
• Maddie Lee (Chicago Sun-Times* {$}): How USA Baseball shaped Cubs’ Pete Crow-Armstrong long before his first WBC. “… it won’t be the first time he dons Team USA’s stars and stripes. He has been in USA Baseball’s system since 12-and-unders.”
• Jordan Bastian (MLB.com*): Shaw’s focus on basics — and the right glove size — easing move to OF. “… the Cubs are confident that the 24-year-old Shaw will take to the outfield just fine.“
• Maddie Lee (Chicago Sun-Times* {$}): Could Cubs’ Seiya Suzuki carry postseason momentum through WBC for hot start to 2026? “Suzuki is set to represent Japan in the World Baseball Classic, where he’ll play center field. He leaves Monday to join his national team.” More Suzuki from Forbes* {$}.
• Tommy Birch (Des Moines Register* {$}): Marty Pevey returning for 14th-straight season managing Iowa Cubs. “The winningest and longest tenured manager in Iowa Cubs history will be back in Des Moines this year.”
• Brett Taylor (Bleacher Nation*): Kris Bryant talks about his pain, and what comes next. “Some days it’s hard to grab the toothpaste in front of me. It’s not like that every day, but those days it’s like you just wish you had some type of answer.”

Food For Thought:

Please be reminded that Cub Tracks and Bleed Cubbie Blue do not necessarily endorse the content of articles, podcasts, or videos that are linked to in this series. We will not wittingly publish A. I. – driven articles or clickbait, and insist on unimpeachable sources.

It’s funny that Tanner Franklin ended up at 12, because that’s about where I thought he’d end up when we started this, and yet it took him a rather long time to actually be added to the voting because he lost two initial votes to players who still haven’t been selected to the top 20. That’s a little odd, and tells me there are certain players where the head-to-head against individual guys may not exactly tell me about his chances to be added to the top 20. Franklin must just be a unique enough pitcher that normal voting rules don’t seem to apply. The current top 20 stands at:

1. JJ Wetherholt
2. Liam Doyle
3. Rainiel Rodriguez
4. Quinn Mathews
5. Jurrangelo Cjintje
6. Joshua Baez
7. Leonardo Bernal
8. Jimmy Crooks
9. Brandon Clarke
10. Tink Hence
11. Tekoah Roby
12. Tanner Franklin

Comparable Player Poll

We’re going to stick to the same theme as yesterday’s polls and run three outfield prospects together and see which player ends up on top. It’s an easy way to turn three potential names that I am considering adding and making it just one name. Makes my job easier later.

Won-Bin Cho has seen some ups and some downs in his short pro career. Things started well enough. He hit reasonably well with a great approach in both the complex league and Low A. He’s had a lot more trouble at High A. He whiffed like crazy and had no power in his first attempt. In his second attempt, his approach was much better, but the results weren’t quite there until a very strong finish to the season. He will either repeat High A with the intention of a quick promotion so long as results are there or he’ll start the year in AA. He’ll be 22.

Colton Ledbetter was the third piece of the Brendan Donovan return. Drafted 55th overall in 2023, Ledbetter played well enough in that draft season at Low A to start his first full pro season in High A. He played there well too, albeit with some strikeout issues. With his promotion to AA, he may have made an emphasis on cutting down his K rate, which he did, but he did see a noticeable drop in power while still managing an above average hitting line. He will be 24 and probably in AAA.

Zach Levenson was drafted in the 5th round of the 2023 draft. While he did well enough in his initial debut season at Low A, he was not particularly impressive in his first attempt at High A. It was almost an average line, but he repeated High A in 2025. This time, he was quite good thanks primarily to an excellent K/BB ratio. He finished the season in AA with a strong showing in 26 games. He will be 24 and probably repeat AA.

VOTE HERE

New Add

There are obviously still prospects who could arguably be on the poll, but I think we’re in a good place where there’s nobody missing that I feel is kind of egregious. That means I think it’s okay to re-add Ryan Mitchell back to the voting. I think he’s going to be on the voting for good and considering everyone on the current list got at least 9 votes, I feel like there’s no real contenders left who could get removed. Never say never, but I probably won’t have to go to that well again just because honestly there won’t be much time to do it.

Jesus Baez, IF – 21

Stats (High A): 416 PAs, .244/.327/.397, 10.3 BB%, 18.5 K%, .153 ISO, .270 BABIP, 116 wRC+, 121 DRC+

Scouting (FG): 30/45 Hit, 35/50 Game Power, 50/55 Raw Power, 40/40 Speed, 40/45 Fielding

The biggest weakness, near as I can tell, is that Baez is immature. He is also about to be 21-years-old. I’ll be very interesting to see how Baez pans out specifically because I kind of want to know how much weight to put on when a scout like Keith Law essentially goes after his character. It’s one sample, so I shouldn’t use his example for all prospects like him but nonetheless I really am not sure how to handle it.

Nathan Church, OF – 25

Stats (AA): 129 PAs, .336/.380/.563, 6.2 BB%, 7.8 K%, .227 ISO, .327 BABIP, 157 wRC+, 136 DRC+

AAA: 242 PAs, .335/.400/.521, 9.9 BB%, 10.3 K%, .186 ISO, .338 BABIP 144 wRC+, 132 DRC+

MLB: 65 PAs, .179/.254/.250, 4.6 BB%, 27.7 K%, .071 ISO, .237 BABIP, 46 wRC+, 78 DRC+

Scouting: 55/55 Hit, 35/35 Game Power, 40/40 Raw Power, 55/55 Speed, 45/45 Field

I know that scouts can’t constantly update their numbers, but I feel like you are clearly out of date if you’re giving Nathan Church a 45 fielding grade. You don’t want to overrate the small sample of fielding numbers that Church currently has, but I will say when a player posts an 84 percentile sprint speed, has a 92 percentile arm speed, and posts a fairly high OAA, we can probably write off him being a below average fielder. That doesn’t feel like asking much. I’m not convinced he’s as good as his numbers were, mind you, but I am convinced he’s an above average fielder at the least.

Yhoiker Fajardo, RHP – 19

Stats (CPX): 6 G, 20.2 IP, 31.6 K%, 9.2 BB%, 51.2 GB%, .205 BABIP, 0.44 ERA/2.41 FIP/3.29 xFIP

Low A: 13 GS, 51.1 IP, 27.8 K%, 9.4 BB%, 50 GB%, .326 BABIP, 2.98 ERA/2.50 FIP/3.14 xFIP

Scouting: 40/45 Fastball, 55/60 Slider, 30/50 Change, 35/50 Command

Acquired in the trade for Willson Contreras, Fajardo is an unusual 19-year-old, because he’s already built up his innings to throw 100 or so innings for the 2026 season. He’s also probably going to be in High A and that is a fairly rare group. His next step is maintaining what he’s been doing, because though he’s a hitter, we saw an example of a very young player struggling to get past High A in Won-Bin Cho these past two seasons. Wouldn’t be totally shocking if he had an adjustment period.

Ixan Henderson, 24 – LHP

Stats (AA): 25 GS, 132 IP, 25.2 K%, 9.6 BB%, 37.1 GB%, .278 BABIP, 2.59 ERA/3.16 FIP/4.00 xFIP/4.51 DRA

Scouting: 50/60 Fastball, 45/50 Slider, 30/40 Change, 40/45 Cutter, 40/50 Command

I’m happy that the voting for Henderson seems to have been unaffected by the recent news of him getting shut down for the moment from throwing. I think that’s the right call. Even if he does end up missing a significant amount of time, it’ll feel more like a hiccup than if say, Tink Hence got injured again. It’s not an injury prone guy who can’t stay healthy, but someone going through the typical injury that just about every starting pitcher seems to face at some point.

Cooper Hjerpe, 25 – LHP

Didn’t pitch

Scouting: 55/55 Fastball, 55/60 Slider, 50/50 Change, 45/50 Cutter, 45/50 Command

Good news about Hjerpe: he had Tommy John surgery in April of last season. That is not a statement that is usually said, but basically it means Hjerpe’s Tommy John recovery should put him in line to throw half a season or so of innings. A very reasonable timeframe of returning in fact would have him in line to throw his career high in professional innings. That’s the bad news about Hjerpe: he hasn’t given us a lot of faith in staying healthy.

Brycen Mautz, 24 – LHP

Stats (AA): 25 GS, 114.2 IP, 28.6 K%, 7.1 BB%. 41.2 GB%, .286 BABIP, 2.98 ERA/3.58 FIP/3.20 xFIP/4.54 DRA

Scouting: 45/45 Fastball, 55/55 Slider, 45/50 Curve, 30/35 Change, 50/55 Command

Mautz has reasonably good scouting, but I’ve always kind of felt like he was almost a scouts versus stats prospect where if scouts were more convinced he would start for sure, then his stats would be good enough to become a legit prospect. What I’m saying is that his stats are strong. He struck out guys, didn’t walk much, got enough groundballs. If he has that exact same line in AAA, he’s an MLB caliber starter I would think.

Ryan Mitchell, 19 – OF

I do not have stats to share with you – I’m sure I can find high school stats, but they aren’t a lot of use on this kind of list. It doesn’t appear Fangraphs has given him scouting grades, I can’t find MLB Pipeline (and I don’t like how they give grades anyway, too high generally). I have access to Baseball Prospectus’ top 20, and while they don’t give Mitchell a scouting grade, I thought just sharing their blurb would suffice:

“Mitchell, a toolsy overslot second-rounder, didn’t play after the draft. For much of his high school career, he would rotate so early that he was more or less standing up when making contact, but his swing became one of the most fun to watch in the class. He dips down a bit and explodes from the lower half. There is some risk he won’t be able to get around against higher velocity fastballs, but his contact rates on the circuit were adequate, and there’s enough athleticism, present bat speed, and physical projection to expect some power. Defensively, he has good actions but could be forced to second base in pro ball. There aren’t any elite tools here, but he presents a pretty well-rounded infield profile and had an arrow up coming into the draft.”

Deniel Ortiz, 21 – 1B/3B

Stats (Low A): 320 PAs, .285/.406/.446, 15.3 BB%, 27.5 K%, .162 ISO, .386 BABIP, 145 wRC+, 119 DRC+

High A: 130 PAs, .336/.438/.500, 13.8 BB%, 22.3 K%, .164 ISO, .436 BABIP, 168 wRC+, 97 DRC+

It feels weird that a player as young as Ortiz playing at two separate levels who dominated both levels was not considered a good enough prospect to give an actual scouting report. I feel like the fact that I’m not sharing any scouting numbers with you makes him harder to grade. He has some swing-and-miss and those lines are uncomfortably BABIP-driven, but he was also 20 at High A who had a 168 wRC+.

Yairo Padilla, 19 – SS

Stats (CPX): 38 G, 148 PAs, .283/.396/.367, 12.2 BB%, 14.2 K%, .083 ISO, .340 BABIP, 119 wRC+

Scouting: 25/55 Hit, 20/55 Game Power, 40/60 Raw Power, 50/40 Speed, 30/40 Field

On the flipside of the scouts versus stats is Padilla on the scouting side. Which is slightly misleading, because as you can see, he does actually have good stats. It’s not necessarily a line that would stand out to me, but an 18-year-old shortstop prospect with a 119 wRC+ in rookie leagues would most likely be a prospect in nearly all outcomes. But clearly there is more power expected specifically and that’s where the scouting part of it comes more into play.

Tai Peete, OF – 20

Stats (High A): 529 PAs, .217/.288/.404, 8.7 BB%, 30.6 K%, .187 ISO, .282 BABIP, 79 wRC+, 79 DRC+

Scouting: 20/30 Hit, 30/50 Game Power, 50/60 Raw Power, 60/60 Speed, 45/55 Fielding

And here we have your classic “if only he could make contact a little bit more” prospect. One quick fix and he’s a super prospect. That fix might be the most difficult thing to fix though. Even with his swing-and-miss stuff, he still had 19 homers in 125 games and had a .189 ISO as a 19-year-old playing in High A. That is not that common. Unfortunately, that pesky contact tool. You’ll see that speed and he did steal 25 bases, although he also got caught an unacceptable 11 times. The year before he stole 45 bases and got 6 times. Not really sure why he was such a worse base stealer, but there is base stealing potential in his future.

VOTE HERE