The Season That Was: Andrés Giménez

ARLINGTON, TEXAS - SEPTEMBER 19: Andrés Giménez #0 of the Toronto Blue Jays swings his bat during the sixth inning against the Texas Rangers at Globe Life Field on September 19, 2026 in Arlington, Texas. (Photo by Sam Hodde/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The Jays traded for Andrés Giménez (along with Nick Sandlin) on December 10th, 2024, sending Spencer Horwitz and Nick Mitchell to the Guardians.

  • Mitchell played Double-A this year, hitting .261/.361/.362 split between the Guardians and Nationals systems. He was one of four players shipped to Washington for Foster Griffin, who made 9 starts for Cleveland, with a 5.19 ERA. He had a 3.48 ERA in 10.1 innings in the playoffs.
  • Horwitz was flipped to the Pirates. He’s hit .258/.348/.398 in 222 games for the Pirates, with a 1.4 bWAR. Not quite the numbers you want from a first baseman.
  • Sandlin pitched 16 innings for the Jays in 2025 and 8 for the Angels in 2026.

Giménez played 101 games for the Jays in 2025, hitting .210/.285/.313 (with occasional streaks of power) and playing terrific defense at second base. .

This year, he moved to shortstop after Bo Bichette left as a free agent.

Standard Batting Table
AgeWARGPAABRH2B3BHRRBISBCSBBSOBAOBPSLGOPSOPS+GIDPHBPSHSFIBB
271.1148508468381142519592041794.244.291.359.64978716252
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 11/9/2026.

Baseball Reference had him at a 1.1 WAR. FanGraphs liked him more, with a 2.8 WAR, giving him a value of $22.4 million to the Jays.

Andrés had a .286 wOBA and a 81 wRC+.

His walk rate was way down from last year, 3.3% (from 6.8). The strikeout rate was up 18.5% (from 17.9).

Giménez’s line-drive rate was down a bit (21.0% from 22.4). The ground ball rate was up (44.2% from 42.6). Fly balls was about the same (34.8% from 35.0). About the same percentage of his fly balls left the park (7.0% from 7.6).

Soft contact was up a bit (18.4% from 17.2), and hard contact was up (25.2% from 22.5).

Last year, Andrés hit right-handers much much better than left-handers. This year he was almost equal against both (RHP .249/.295 /.365, LHP .231/.280/.343).

He was about the same at home (.251/.300/.345) as on the road (.236/.281/.373). Last year he was much better at home.

He was about the same in the first half (.232/.277/.363) as the second half (.263/.313/.352).

Giménez by month:

  • April: .267/.291/.429 with 3 home runs, 4 walks, 16 strikeouts and 4 steals in 29 games.
  • May: .153/.223/.271 with 3 home runs, 4 walks, 19 strikeouts and 2 steals in 28 games.
  • June: .301/.342/.425 with 1 home run, 1 walk, 20 strikeouts and 4 steals in 25 games.
  • July: .200/.234/.250 with 0 home runs, 2 walks, 10 strikeout, and 2 steals in 22 games.
  • August: .278/.333/.367 with 1 home run, 3 walks, 17 strikeouts and 7 steals in 24 games.
  • September: 258 .319 .379 with 1 home run, 3 walks, 11 strikeouts and 1 steal in 20 games.

He was .259/.296/.357 with RISP.

Giménez much the same in high leverage spots (.236/.273/.382) as medium (.275/.325/.371) and a little worse in low leverage spots (.219/.269/.338).

Defensively?

He played 148 games at short with 7 errors for a league high .985 FA (league average .976). Fanraphs has him at a +19 Outs Above Average second in the league to Bobby Witt, Jr. at 24.

As a baserunner, he was a +0.7. He was a good percentage basestealer, so he must not have been a great baserunner the rest of the time.

Spot in the Batting Order:

  • 5th: 1 start: .000/.000/.000.
  • 6th: 15 starts: .254/.281/.407.
  • 7th: 20 starts: .213/.263/.253.
  • 8th: 62 starts: .238/.283/.371.
  • 9th: 33 starts: .295/.344/420.

Last year he hit in every spot in the order.

Favourite team to face? He hit .455/.500/.727 with 1 home run in 6 games against the A’s.

Least Favourite? He hit .105/.100/.158 in 6 games against the Angels. Well, he was also 0 for 8 in 3 games against the Nationals.

Times facing a starter:

  • First: .265/.310/.427.
  • Second: .265/.288/.363.
  • Third: .308/.357/.462.

Swinging at the first pitch, he hit .412/.446/.627.

The Jays were 63/68in his starts.

His longest hitting streak was 7 games. Longest on base streak was 14 games. Longest without a homer 36 games. Longest hitless streak was 6 games.


After years of watching Bo Bichette at short, and I’m not trying to complain about his defense, watching Giménez play short was a bit like mental whiplash. Oh, that ball is going to be in the outfield….nope. You did have to reset your expectations.

But then, he was a different guy at the plate too.

We are paying him $23,571,429 for the next three seasons (well, one of them is $23,571,428, dollar discount year). And then there is an option year (where they will pay him $2.5 million not to play). The Jays traded for him thinking they could unlock the bat that hit .297/.371/.466 in 2022, but I’m fairly certain that player doesn’t exist anymore. When one season stands out so much, you have to figure it isn’t likely to happen again.

But then, he’s only 28 next season, right in his prime; maybe he has another year like that in him. No, I don’t think so either.

I guess we’ll have to enjoy his defence and maybe get up for a drink when he’s at bat. Or be happy with the occasional good at-bat and not expect too much. Thank goodness we are not watching him in the cleanup spot anymore.

Current state of the Tampa Bay Rays 40-man roster

Aug 11, 2026; West Sacramento, California, USA; Tampa Bay Rays pinch hitter Carson Williams (7) rounds the bases after hitting a three-run home run against the Athletics during the eighth inning at Sutter Health Park. Mandatory Credit: Dennis Lee-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The MLB offseason is off to its typical slow start but things should start ramping up as soon as this weekend with the conclusion of the General Manager meetings.

Tuesday, November 17th, is the deadline for teams to add players from within their organizations to their 40-man roster and thus protecting them from the Rule 5 draft. Just a few days after that on Friday, November 20th, the non-tender deadline will pass; this is when teams must make a decision to offer contracts to all of their arbitration eligible players.

Of course there is also the looming threat of the MLB offseason being halted by the expiration of the current Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) and thus a lockout. When the previous CBA expired on December 2nd, 2021, the free agency market moved with rampancy that was unprecedented and many expect for the same thing to happen again.

Comings and Goings

Once the World Series concluded, the following players left via becoming free agents: Freddy Peralta, Gavin Lux, and Jorge Mateo. The Rays declined their mutual options on Nick Martinez and Cedric Mullins, making them both free agents. Nick Madrigal and Jonathan Heasley were outrighted from the 40-man roster while Alexander Alberto and Jack Suwinski were both added.

Tampa Bay also had to activate all of their players from the 60-Day Injured List, placing Jacob Melton, Edwin Uceta, and Ryan Pepiot back on the 40-man roster. That gives the Rays a total of 39 players on their 40-man roster.

So with all that being said, let’s take a look at the current state of the roster and who may be on the move and who is likely to stay, at least for now.

Who is on the bubble

There is a lot to be said for where the Rays could make marginal improvements throughout the roster despite this being a team that made it to the World Series. The team could use more impact players on the offense. With the departure of Nick Martinez and Freddy Peralta and the uncertainty regarding the health of Ryan Pepiot and Shane McClanahan leaves the starting rotation in disarray. Top prospects like Carson Williams, Brody Hopkins, and Jacob Melton who were expected to become key cogs of the 2026 Rays roster didn’t pan out. That doesn’t mean any of those five players are at risk to leave the organization yet.

Pitchers on the bubble: Alexander Alberto, Joe Boyle, Garrett Cleavinger, Alex Cook, Jesse Scholtens, and Edwin Uceta

Alberto and Boyle both have Major League arsenals but Alberto only just reached Triple-A this past season, his 6th year in professional baseball while Boyle has some of the worst command in the game.

Cleavinger went from being one of the top relievers in the Rays bullpen in 2025 to being among their least dependable in 2026. He is projected to make $3.7M in his final year of arbitration eligibility.

Cook was a 40-man roster addition last November and made a handful of appearaces for Tampa Bay this season.

Scholtens served as depth for the Rays this season, with the team calling upon him whenever they needed innings whether they were competitive or not. He had a 5.45 ERA over his final 10 appearances (38 IP) of the season.

Uceta was the de facto Rays closer in 2024 in a breakout campaign but lost some of that polish in 2025. There was hope he could refind that success this past season but he was never able to get started as he dealt with a shoulder issue early on. Uceta did begin a rehab assignment but was not able to recover from his injury. Following the season, the Rays announced that Uceta had undergone surgery and would be out for at least the first couple of months of the 2027 season.

Position Players on the bubble: Jadher Areinamo, Carson Williams, and Nick Fortes

Fortes was the Rays primary catcher for the majority of the 2026 regular season and performed well for the team. However, the Rays made a major upgrade at the trade deadline, acquiring Liam Hicks from the Miami Marlins and Fortes was relegated to backup duties. The backup catcher role fits Fortes perfectly, but the soon to be 30-year old backstop is projected to make $3.4M in arbitration this offseason while Kenny Piper is seemingly ready to take over that role.

Areinamo was a 40-man roster addition last November, despite having just reached Double-A that season. The infield prospect was talented enough that the Rays believed a team would take him in the Rule 5 draft. However, his offensive production took a step back in 2026 while his K% soared. There is still reason to believe in him going forward as will only turn 23 a few weeks from now.

Carson Williams was supposed to be the shortstop of the future for the Rays, but he has squanded the limited opportunities thus far presented to him. He was called up to the Rays active roster three different times in 2026 but only started in 11 games and hit .108/.154/.216 over 40 PA. Late in the season, when the Rays were pushing for the playoffs, the team signed Jorge Mateo and relied on him over Carson Williams.


Yankees Birthday of the Day: Jack Clark

(Original Caption) 5/11/88-New York, New York- Yankees' designated hitter Jack Clark (r) is met at home plate by teammate Don Mattingly after Clark knocked him in with his sixth home run of the season to put the Yankees up 2-0 in the first inning against the Chicago White Sox, 5/11.

There is no worse time to hit free agency than while major league owners are colluding to hold down player salaries. And that’s awful luck. Because normally, there is no better time to hit free agency than after the best season of your life. For Jack Clark, who enjoyed a Hall of Very Good career, that confluence of circumstances is how he ended up in the Bronx.

Clark had a monstrous 1987 season with St. Louis, leading the majors in walks, on-base percentage and OPS+. Despite the larger environment working against him, he parlayed that outstanding season into a two-year free agent deal that brought him to New York. He had a productive, though controversial 1988 campaign in New York before the Yankees dealt him to San Diego.

Name: Jack Clark
Born: November 10, 1955 (New Brighton, PA)
Yankees Tenure: 1988

Clark debuted with the San Francisco Giants in 1975 as a 19-year-old and spent nearly a decade on the West Coast. During that time, he made a pair of All-Star games and earned MVP votes in three seasons.

Prior to the 1985 season though, the Giants dealt him to St. Louis. Great timing for Clark. One thing he’d never done was play in the playoffs. Thanks in no small part to Clark, who earned his third All-Star game nod and won his first Silver Slugger while manning first base, the Cards won 101 games and the NL East.

Clark hit .381 for the Cards in the NLCS, which they won in six games over the Los Angeles Dodgers. And it was Clark who propelled St. Louis to the World Series. He came to the plate in the top of the ninth in Game 6 with two runners on, the Cards trailing 5-4.

Clark’s three-run home run won the game and the pennant for St. Louis, sending them to the World Series against Kansas City. Unfortunately for Clark, his Cardinals came up on the losing end of a seven-game series. Worse, he was on the wrong end of a couple of controversial plays in the ninth inning of Game 6, with St. Louis needing three outs to win it all. Jorge Orta, leading off the inning, hit a grounder to Clark, who shoveled the ball to pitcher Todd Worrell, covering first base. In a time before instant replay, if an umpire missed a call, there was no recourse.

Shortly after, Clark and Cards catcher Darrell Porter let a ball fall between them in foul territory (Porter later said he’d called Clark off). Eventually, two runs scored and the Royals evened the series, before blowing the Cards’ doors off in an 11-0 Game 7 rout to win the World Series.

Injury cost Clark the bulk of the ’86 season but he bounced back in a big way in 1987. Amid a baseball-wide offensive explosion, Clark put together the best season of his career. He set career marks in walks, on-base percentage, slugging percentage, and OPS+, won his second Silver Slugger and finished third in NL MVP voting. It was his 10th consecutive season (he went on to have 14 such) with an OPS+ of at least 116, a testament to his consistent offensive excellence.

That offseason, unable to get a deal done with St. Louis, Clark inked a two-year pact with the Yankees for $3 million, with another $1 million in incentives. Clark’s deal broke a spending freeze amid what we now know was a collusion-riddled era. Gene Orza, associate counsel for the MLBPA, threw cold water on the idea that Clark’s signing meant there was no collusion happening.

“Collusion is price-fixing, not location-fixing,” he said. ”Collusion takes different shapes. Why aren’t a lot of clubs interested in Jack Clark? Why aren’t they fighting to get him? Sure, Jack Clark moved. But he moved at a price that was fixed. Clubs are making offers, but they’re all the same offer. The Basic Agreement between the clubs and the players is based on the premise that there will be competition for a player’s services. The numbers aren’t competitive; they’re orchestrated.”

With the move to the American League, Clark found himself a designated hitter for the first time. But that summer, the Yankees dealt for Ken Phelps from Seattle. When Clark walked into the Yankee dugout in late July and saw his name penciled in to left field for the first time in over a decade, he lost his temper, yelling “What kind of —- is this?!” in front of a crowd that included sports writers.

Eventually, Clark made it clear he wanted to be traded, preferably back to the National League. Yankee owner George Steinbrenner publicly agreed in September to move Clark after the season ended, which is exactly what happened. The Yanks dealt Clark to San Diego a little over a month later.

In his lone season in the Bronx, Clark hit 27 bombs, drove in 93, and walked 113 times. The dingers and free passes led the Yankees, while only Dave Winfield drove in more runs. Clark was good for a 113 OPS+ and 2.8 rWAR, but the decline in numbers across all he board from his career year in ‘87 combined with his somewhat-surly nature to cast him as a bit of a disappointment in the minds of fans of that era.

Clark continued to rake in San Diego, where he played through the 1990 season. He then signed with Boston, where he played for two seasons. His 1992 campaign was awful, possibly influenced by ongoing bankruptcy proceedings. He signed with Montreal before the ’93 season but ultimately retired.

Shortly after retirement, Clark’s financial problems were solved. Years earlier, in November 1990, arbitrators ruled that the owners had colluded to suppress free agent salaries in 1985, 1986, and 1987. Among those affected was Jack Clark. After settlement negotiations, Clark received $4.4 million. The settlement, along with liquidating assets, allowed Clark to pay all of his debts.

After retirement, Clark ended up back in the majors, as the hitting coach for the Dodgers from 2001-03. He also dabbled in broadcasting, working for the Cardinals in 2009 and 2010.

Jack Clark was not a Yankee for long. And in a world without the 1980s collusion scandal, maybe he never ends up a Yankee. But in this world, he had a heck of a career, coming oh so close to becoming a World Champion whilst a Cardinal. Happy 71st birthday, Jack Clark.


See more of the “Yankees Birthday of the Day” series here.

Free agent poll: Carson Kelly

TOKYO, JAPAN - MARCH 16: Carson Kelly #15 of the Chicago Cubs plays catcher during an exhibition game against the Yomuri Giants at the Tokyo Dome on March 16, 2025 in Tokyo, Japan. (Photo by Matt Dirksen/Chicago Cubs/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Well, yesterday’s free agent poll certainly generated a bunch of activity. Let’s see what y’all have to say about this one.

The Rangers currently have two catchers on their 40 man roster — Danny Jansen and Logan O’Hoppe. Jansen is a free agent after the 2026 season, and O’Hoppe is a work-in-progress as far as his defense goes, so the expectation is that the Rangers will need to add a catcher this offseason.

So how about Carson Kelly? He’s 32, so not ancient, though he is older than Jansen. Briefly a Ranger, when he slashed .235/.291/.343 in 31 games over the final two months of the 2024 season. Coming off two of the best seasons of his career with the Chicago Cubs, for whom he slashed .254/.335/.402 in 2025-26 over 846 plate appearances. A pretty solid offensive option behind the plate, as long as you don’t play him in September.

As far as the projections go, Baseball America has Kelly at 3 years, $32 million. Over at Fangraphs, both Ben Clemens and the median crowdsource have Kelly at $10 million per year, but Clemens says one year, $10 million, while the crowdsource says two years, $20 million. Kiley McDaniel has Kelly at 2 years, $17 million. MLB Trade Rumors has Kelly at two years, $20 million.

Let’s go with the two years, $20 million figure.

Would you want the Rangers to sign Carson Kelly to a 2 year, $20 million deal?

Cast your vote below…

Bob Boone, World Series champion and part of 3-generation baseball family, has died. He was 78

Washington Nationals v Philadelphia Phillies

PHILADELPHIA, PA - AUGUST 07: Former MLB player Bob Boone #8 of the Philadelphia Phillies sales the crowd prior to the game against the Washington Nationals at Citizens Bank Park on August 7, 2022 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The Phillies defeated the Nationals 13-1. (Photo by Mitchell Leff/Getty Images)

Getty Images

PHILADELPHIA (AP) — Bob Boone, the catcher on the Philadelphia Phillies’ first World Series championship team who won seven Gold Gloves and was part of baseball’s first three-generation family, has died. He was 78.

Boone’s son, Bret, announced his father’s death Tuesday on social media. No cause of death was announced.

“He was a man of great integrity. He was a great dad, husband, and patriarch. It was a privilege to call him my father. Baseball lost a great one today,” Bret Boone wrote.

Boone spent his first 10 seasons with the Phillies, played seven with the California Angels and two with the Kansas City Royals. He also managed the Royals and Cincinnati Reds.

His father, Ray, played 13 seasons in the majors and was a two-time All-Star with the Detroit Tigers. Bob Boone’s two sons both enjoyed long baseball careers. Aaron Boone played 13 seasons in the majors and played for the Reds when Bob managed the team. Aaron now manages the New York Yankees. Bret Boone was a three-time All-Star over a 14-year career spent largely with the Seattle Mariners. A third son played in the minor leagues. Bret’s son, Jake Boone, works in the New York Mets’ front office after playing at Princeton and briefly in the minors.

Bob Boone was a sixth-round draft pick as a third baseman out of Stanford in 1969. He was converted to catcher in the minor leagues and caught 1,095 games with Philadelphia, second on the Phillies’ all-time list to Red Dooin (1,124). Boone caught 2,225 games overall in 19 big league seasons.

He was the first Phillies catcher to win a Gold Glove (1978, 1979) and led the Phillies with a .412 batting average in their 1980 World Series win over the Kansas City Royals.

Boone made NL All-Star teams in 1976, 1978 and 1979. He set the record for career games caught by a catcher with 1,919 in Kansas City. He was 41 years old when he won his final Gold Glove with the Royals in 1989. Ivan Rodriguez and Carlton Fisk have since passed Boone on the career games caught list.

Boone caught the final out of the 1980 Game 6 clincher when Tug McGraw struck out Willie Wilson to win the World Series. Boone was involved in a more famous play earlier in that inning when he ran after Frank White’s foul pop near the home dugout in Veteran’s Stadium. The ball bounced off Boone’s mitt and straight into Pete Rose’s glove for an out — a catch played on countless highlight reels through the decades in Philadelphia.

He was added to the Phillies’ Wall of Fame in 2005.

Boone won four more Gold Gloves, made another All-Star team and twice led the Angels to the playoffs. He went 10 for 22 (.455) with a homer and two RBIs against Boston in the 1986 American League Championship Series.

Boone went 371-444 overall as a manager, spending three seasons with the Royals and three with the Reds. He joined the Washington Nationals front office in 2005.

Washington won the World Series in 2019, the first championship in franchise history. Boone resigned in 2021 rather than comply with the organization’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate.

Cubs free agent target: Randy Arozarena

Let’s switch gears for a moment from the pitchers I’ve been looking at and instead check out one of the top outfield free agents, former Mariners outfielder Randy Arozarena.

No question, Arozarena has talent. He’s a solid 3 or 4 WAR outfielder, generally good for 20+ home runs and 20+ stolen bases every year.

The red flag here is that 2026 was his best season. He batted .281/.381/.484 and led the American League in runs scored with 113, which was by far a career best (95 was his previous best). The .381 OBP was also a career high (except for .382 in only 76 PA in 2020).

Why a red flag? Because Arozarena’s going to turn 32 in February. Would you give a guy like this a four-year deal coming off his best overall season? MLB Trade Rumors has him projected for four years and $100 million and The Athletic has Arozarena at essentially the same, four years and $108 million. Interestingly, the article in The Athletic has Seiya Suzuki projected at the same figures. Suzuki is a few months older than Arozarena, as is Ian Happ.

Both Happ and Suzuki are better defenders than Arozarena, and at those figures I’d certainly rather have either of the two departing Cubs back than Arozarena, despite Arozarena’s base-stealing ability. Regarding that, here’s an interesting note from the MLBTR article:

Arozarena runs quite a bit more than Suzuki but is actually a good bit slower in terms of average sprint speed; Statcast measures Suzuki with a sprint speed of 28 feet per second, in the 63rd percentile of big leaguers. Arozarena is at 27.1 ft/sec, down in the 40th percentile. He’s an aggressive baserunner, however, and that’s manifested in the form of six consecutive 20-steal seasons.

I imagine Jed Hoyer and his baseball ops staff will have a look at Arozarena, who’s been a fan favorite everywhere he’s been. Ultimately I think they’ll probably pass on him, and that’s what I would do as well.

2026 Atlanta Braves Player Review: Anthony Molina

ATLANTA, GA - JUNE 17: Anthony Molina #61 of the Atlanta Braves pitches in the eighth inning during the continuation of a game from June 16 against the San Francisco Giants at Truist Park on June 17, 2026 in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Jack Casey/Atlanta Braves/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Sometimes in baseball, you get a rare trade that’s a win-win for both clubs. Anthony Molina’s 2026 consisted, in large part, of appearing to be part of one of those trades, as the Atlanta Braves only got a few innings out of him before eventually shipping him off to San Francisco so that they could get Tyler Mahle at the Trade Deadline.

Now it’s time to figure out what the Giants saw in Molina during his time in Atlanta that convinced them to send Mahle down South.

How Acquired

The Braves claimed Molina off of waivers back in December of 2025. They then outrighted him to Triple-A Gwinnett, which is where he started the season before eventually getting added to the big league roster to begin the month of May.

What were the expectations?

Simply stated: to provide a right-handed, low-leverage option out of the bullpen for a short period of time. Things didn’t go particularly well for Molina during his two-season stint with the Rockies (a combined -0.4 fWAR in a long relief role), so it wasn’t as if he was expected to come in and be lights out coming out of the ‘pen for Atlanta. As long as he could come in and eat an inning or two, everything would be A-OK for Molina and the Braves.

More broadly, Molina had two different-yet-similar seasons in Colorado before getting the boot. In 2024, he had a low strikeout rate, a not-so-good walk rate, but managed to avoid getting bricked by homers despite the whole Coors Field thing, leading to a bad-but-not-abominable 146 ERA-, 97 FIP-, and 110 xFIP-. In 2025, it looked like he made huge strides in avoiding walks… but it was really just because guy were blasting moonshots off him before he could walk them. His strikeout rate didn’t budge, and his pitching line was a 153 ERA-, 160 FIP-, and the same 110 xFIP-.

While there was the hope that the Braves could somehow fix him, there was little reason to expect him to serve as more than organizational depth.

2026 Results

Molina made a grand total of four (4) appearances for the Braves. He only made two appearances at Truist Park and one of those two appearances was actually a start — for the San Francisco Giants, after the Braves ended up trading him out West in order to acquire Tyler Mahle in what wound up being a very good trade for the Braves.

Anyways, the Giants figured out something with Molina (and the Braves did not) when it came to him being a starter as he actually finished the season having made a few really good starts for them, so this wound up being a bit of a win-win deal. Our old friend from McCovey Chronicles, Grant Brisbee, wrote a piece on how well Molina was doing for the Giants, in case you’re interested. It’s a gift link, so enjoy.

Anyways, as far as his stint in Atlanta went, it wasn’t exactly spectacular. He did pitch two scoreless innings against his old mates, the Rockies, on May 1, but he got dinged for two runs on three hits against both the Mets on June 14 and those very same Giants on June 16. Perhaps San Francisco saw something during that appearance that they liked because two weeks later, he was on the mound in Cobb County against the Braves.

All in all, Molina put together a 129 ERA-, 133 FIP-, and 97 xFIP- for the Braves in those three outings. Replacement level? Sure. But it was also better than the very low bar he’d set for himself in 2024-2025. The Braves had him substantially increase his curveball and changeup usage, and perhaps it helped a little.

The big thing, though, was that Molina went to the Giants and looked like a legitimate major leaguer. His fastball got tweaked, and he threw it a bunch more. He made five starts and one long relief appearance for the Giants, and four of those outings were fantastic. His line with his new team was a sparkling 91 ERA-, 64 FIP-, and 87 xFIP-, and he collected 0.9 fWAR in 29 innings. Wow.

Despite it being just 29 innings, Molina kind of had it all. He was throwing 96 mph as a starter, not walking guys, getting whiffs on his curveball, and even managing contact. It’s all certainly fascinating, and the Giants get to enjoy whatever Molina may turn into going forward, instead of Atlanta.

What went right?

Well, those two innings that Molina pitched in his Braves debut against his old friends from Colorado ended up being sneakily crucial, as Molina’s appearance bought the Braves some time and kept the deficit at 6-1 in the sixth inning and 6-2 in the seventh before the Braves turned it around late and ended up winning 8-6 in dramatic fashion. It’s the little things, sometimes.

Also, again, the Braves got Tyler Mahle for him in a trade, so that was cool for the Braves. And, Molina’s turnaround was very cool for him and the Giants.

What went wrong?

Molina ended up getting plenty of strikeouts for the Giants but that certainly wasn’t the case for Atlanta. Molina struck out two Mets batters during his appearance on June 14 and those wound up being the only two strikeouts that he would rack up during his time as a Braves pitcher. He was charged with more runs than he tallied strikeouts while a Brave, which isn’t exactly something that warms the heart.

His last outing with the Braves, which came against the Giants, was somewhat bizarre in that he somehow faced nine batters in two innings and avoided walking any of them while also not striking out any of them. He did get tagged for a homer by eventual teammate Willy Adames, so that probably wasn’t fun.

It’s possible to view the change of scenery as a sour grapes thing — why couldn’t the Braves have sent over someone but Molina, or figured out how to unlock Molina the way the Giants did — but we probably need to see him keep it up over longer than 29 frames before we can really get salty about it.

2027 outlook

While Molina pitched well down the stretch for San Francisco, he’s still going to be fighting for a rotation spot when (maybe if) Spring Training rolls around. It’ll be highly unlikely that the Braves get him back for a reunion, so that’s about it!

29 innings isn’t much, but he was so good that his early Steamer projection has bumped him into the generic “everyone’s a fourth-starter quality swingman until proven otherwise” tier. That’s quite a jump from organizational depth / replacement level arm, so hats off to him and the Giants. We’ll see if he can keep it up.

2026 Phillies report card: Rafael Marchan

After a couple of years of sharing backup catcher duties with Garrett Stubbs, the Phillies hoped that in 2026 Rafael Marchan would be able to handle the job full time. Perhaps he could even help ease the burden on overworked, aging starter J.T. Realmuto.

That did not happen. Marchan was completely inept at the plate, got injured, and eventually supplanted once again by Stubbs.

The stats: .099/.137/.165 AVG/OBP/SLG, 2 HRs, 6 RBI, -0.7 WAR

What went right

Marchan graded out well defensively. He was above average in blocking, framing, and pop time.

What went wrong

He hit a home run in his first game of the season.

That turned out to be in no way predictive of the season he would have. He was incapable of reaching base the rest of the year, recording just nine hits (with zero doubles or triples) and two walks.

He did hit one more home run, which oddly landed right next to someone who was wearing a replica of his jersey. (Why?)

As he often does, Marchan spent time on the Injured List, suffering from tendinitis in his knee. By the time he returned in September, Stubbs had established a role as Aaron Nola’s personal catcher. Despite Marchan providing little value at that point, the Phillies kept him on the major league roster for the rest of the season which serves as a damning statement at the quality of reserves the Phillies had to choose from.

The future

The team will wisely look at alternatives for the backup catcher spot in the offseason. Marchan is still under team control, so he’ll likely be back with the Phillies in camp, though it is possible he gets dropped from the 40-man roster and winds up elsewhere. His defense is good enough to stick at the major league level, but even the best defender needs to have an OPS higher than .302.

Final grade: F

When the bar to clear is Garrett Stubbs, and you can’t clear it, you have failed.

Guardians News: Messick Finishes Second in AL Rookie of the Year Voting

Aug 20, 2025; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Cleveland Guardians pitcher Parker Messick (77) reacts against the Arizona Diamondbacks in the first inning at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Rick Scuteri-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Tigers’ Kevin McGonigle and the Reds’ Sal Stewart won the AL and NL Rookie of the Year awards yesterday, respectively.

Chase DeLauter finished sixth and Travis Bazzana finished 11th. A good year for Guardians’ rookies, to be sure! You can view the vote totals here.

The Guardians will receive a compensatory pick at the end of the first round because Messick was on the Opening Day Roster and ranked in top 100 lists prior to the season.

Tonight is the Manager of the Year Awards, then Cy Young Awards Wednesday night (as well as Reliever of the Year), then MVP awards Thursday night.

If the Orioles want to get cute, they can sign Adrián Morejón and make him a starter

MILWAUKEE, WI - OCTOBER 03: Adrian Morejon #50 of the San Diego Padres pitches during Game One of the National League Division Series presented by Booking.com between the San Diego Padres and the Milwaukee Brewers at American Family Field on Saturday, October 3, 2026 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. (Photo by Rob Tringali/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images

One way that a team like the Orioles that’s in need of starting rotation help could address their problem is to just sign a pretty good starting pitcher who is, as much as can be believed about any pitcher, a decent bet to continue being pretty good. Mike Elias has steadfastly refused to do this even when it seemed absolutely necessary to the Orioles fortunes, attempting a variety of other schemes. There’s one that he hasn’t pulled off yet: Signing a reliever and turning that guy into a starting pitcher. This winter affords the opportunity to do that in the form of recent Padres pitcher Adrián Morejón.

If old rumors were to be believed, the Orioles had some interest in trying to pull off this caper after the 2024 season. That winter, then-Yankees closer Clay Holmes became a free agent and ended up signing a two-year, $26 million contract with the Mets, who turned him into a starting pitcher. The results went well for the Mets, with Holmes going on to a 3.44 ERA in 51 games; they traded him for a prospect when they were out of the race at the deadline this year.

Morejón enters this winter as one of the game’s potentially elite relief free agents. He’s on a three-year heater in terms of his results with the Padres, dropping a 2.58 ERA and 1.088 WHIP over the past three seasons combined. In 2026, this included a number of multi-inning relief stints – he threw 86 innings, which isn’t exactly a starting pitcher’s workload but is closer to the way there than a lot of relievers. He had been a starting pitcher in the past, before early 2021 Tommy John surgery.

In contrast to most of the high-end pitchers on the free agent market this offseason, Morejón is still fairly young. He’ll only be heading into his age 28 season next year, so the fear of decline in the back years of a contract will be less than it might be for some others. He should be able to keep up what he’s got for a few more years.

The Statcast page for this player is a thing of beauty. Look at all that red! He throws the ball hard. He’s got a great changeup. He gets batters to chase, he gets them to whiff, he gets a lot of ground balls, he doesn’t give up hard contact. Atypically for a reliever, he has a four-pitch mix – which is another part of why there are those who imagine him as a starting pitcher. Morejón has done it before. He might have the ability to do it again.

A willingness to convert Morejón into a starter could be something that will give a bidding team an edge over others, assuming that’s something that he wants to do. (I don’t know if it is.) It’s unlikely the Orioles will really outbid the field – but they do have opportunity in their rotation that other bidding teams may not. They don’t have an ace, they didn’t have a #2 caliber starting pitcher in 2026, and they don’t have a major league-caliber lefty ready to step into the rotation in any capacity.

There are varying opinions about just how much Morejón will cost. At MLB Trade Rumors, the projection is a five-year contract worth $80 million. That’s between Kyle Bradish and Shane Baz money. Those are big bucks for a reliever, especially one who isn’t even racking up saves. Not bad at all to get a good starting pitcher. FanGraphs projected three years and $72 million – a shorter deal with a much higher AAV. That makes him either a cheaper AAV than guys like Trevor Rogers, Michael King, and Freddy Peralta, or a much shorter contract term, lessening the back end risk.

On top of the money, there will be a draft pick penalty tied to signing Morejón. The Padres extended him a qualifying offer, one of two relievers to receive one heading into this offseason. That means that if the Orioles sign Morejón, they’d also give up their third-highest pick in next year’s draft, which would most likely be a mid-second round selection. The likely departure of Rogers will give the Orioles a compensation pick at the end of the first round.

I’d rather see the Orioles just get Rogers. The thing about that is, as we are all well aware in Birdland, that Elias hasn’t spent at the high end of the free agency market for pitching before. Even after making the big splash for Pete Alonso last offseason and making a couple of modest splashes with those Baz and Bradish extensions, it’s tough to imagine him ponying up for the Rogers level.

It’s not as hard to imagine Elias trying one of his galaxy brain ideas – signing Morejón because he’ll be cheaper or take fewer years than Rogers or Peralta or King – and turning him into a starting pitcher. If he doesn’t want to pay up for a proven starter, if he doesn’t want to bundle a bunch of prospects for a speculative upside play that doesn’t hit the upside while one of the prospects dashes from Low-A to Triple-A in one year, Morejón is there.

This wouldn’t be some completely out-of-nowhere idea on Elias’s; Morejón is bandied about as a possible starter conversion in basically any article about this year’s free agent class. There are also analysts out there, such as FG’s Michael Baumann, who think Morejón retains more value as a multi-inning reliever. Whether the Orioles need one of those is debatable, but I don’t think they’ll be spending $16-20 million per year for one in any case. Getting a discount off the market rate for a roll of the dice where if it doesn’t work out, any idiot could have told him ahead of time that this would be a bad idea? Now that’s speaking Elias’s language.

Mets International Free Agent Profile: Hiromi Itoh

MIAMI, FLORIDA - MARCH 14: Hiromi Itoh #14 of Team Japan pitches in the sixth inning during the game between Venezuela and Japan at loanDepot park on March 14, 2026 in Miami, Florida. (Photo by Gene Wang - Capture At Media/Getty Images) | Getty Images

The son of a fisherman, Iromi Itoh was born on August 31, 1997 in Shikabe, a town in southern Hokkaido. As a young boy, he got his introduction to baseball from Koki Morita, a former relief pitcher in the NPB who happened to be a childhood friend of his fathers and gave him personalized baseball instruction from a young age as a result. He grew up idolizing Hokkaido Nippon Ham Fighters ace Yu Darvish and focused on pitching as a result. He attended Tomakomai High School, the alma mater of Masahiro Tanaka, but the school did not qualify for the Spring or Summer Koshien tournaments at any point while he attended.

After graduating in 2016, Itoh attended Komazawa University, but he dropped out after his first semester there, citing an inability to see himself remaining in school for another four years. After reevaluating his decision with friends and family, he enrolled at Tomakomai Komazawa University but because of college baseball rules, he could not participate in baseball games until a full calendar year passed between when he dropped out of Komazawa University. When he became eligible in his second year, he joined the Komazawa University baseball team and pitched for them for the remainder of his college career.

In October 2020, following his graduation, he was selected by the Hokkaido Nippon Ham Fighters, his local hometown club, with their first-round selection in the 2020 NPB Draft; he was actually the first first-round pick from Hokkaido to be selected by the Fighters since the team moved to the island from Tokyo. The 23-year-old right-hander agreed to terms with the team and made his professional debut a few months later, when the 2021 season began.

The rookie right-hander made his first professional start on March 31 against the Saitama Seibu Lions. He would go on to make 23 more in 2021 and would end the year posting a 2.90 ERA in 146.0 innings, allowing 125 hits, walking 53, and striking out 141. Though he certainly pitched well enough to deserve it, Itoh lost out on the Pacific League Rookie of the Year Award to Orix Buffaloes left-hander Hiroya Miyagi, who posted a 2.51 ERA in 147.0 innings, allowing 118 hits, walking 39, and striking out 131.

His 2022 began inauspiciously, as he contracted COVID-19, but he did not miss any time on the mound and ended up having an all-star season. Making 26 starts, Itoh posted a 2.95 ERA in 155.2 innings, allowing 140 hits, walking 49, and striking out 112.

Following the conclusion of the 2022 NPB season, he was selected to play with the Japanese National Team in an exhibition against Australia, and then a few months later, in the 2023 World Baseball Classic. The right-hander appeared in 3 games for Samurai Japan, all out of the bullpen, and was perfect, not allowing a single baserunner in 2.1 innings, striking out 3 batters. When he returned to Japan for the start of the 2024 season, he struggled and underperformed to the point that manager Tsuyoshi Shinjo considered having him removed from the starting rotation altogether. By May, he started turning things around, and while he ended up remaining in the Fighters rotation all season, it was a definite down year for the right-hander. He made 24 starts in total and posted a 3.46 ERA in 153.1 innings, allowing 147 hits, walking 41, and striking out 134.

Itoh recovered in 2024. He won a pair of Player of the Month Awards, one at the beginning of the season and one at the end, and posted a cumulative 2.65 ERA in 176.1 innings over 26 starts, allowing 150 hits, walking 39, and striking out 161. The Fighters made the postseason, going 75-60 and ending the year in second place in the Pacific League. They faced and beat the Chiba Lotte Marines in the best-of-three first stage of the Pacific League Climax Series, but lost against the league champion Fukuoka SoftBank Hawks in the best-of-six final stage of the Climax Series.

Itoh had been steadily improving, but everything came together for him in 2025. The 27-year-old appeared in 27 games and posted a 2.52 ERA in 196.2 innings, allowing 179 hits, walking 29, and striking out 195, his workload, BB/9 rate, and strikeout total all leading the league. The Fighters once again made the postseason, facing and beating the Orix Buffaloes, but as was the case in 2024, they once again lost to the SoftBank Hawks in the final stage of the Climax Series. While that would be the end of the line for the team, Itoh would still win one more thing. The right-hander won Eiji Sawamura Award by the award selection committee, meeting enough of their benchmarks for it to be awarded to him, unlike the 2024 season, when the committee determined that no single pitcher met enough of their qualifications and did not name an Eiji Sawamura Award as a result.

In spring, the 28-year-old right-hander participated in the 2026 World Baseball Classic. He appeared in two games for Samurai Japan and allowed 5 earned runs in 4.0 innings, allowing 4 hits, a pair of home runs, not walking a batter, and striking out 7. When he returned to Japan for the 2026 Fighters season, appeared in 26 games and posted a 3.18 ERA in 172.2 innings, allowing 184 hits, walking 34, and striking out 159.

The right-hander stands 5’9” and weighs 180-pounds, which is well below the average height for a pitcher (6’2”) and would make him the shortest starting pitcher in Major League Baseball. He would not be the shortest pitcher playing for a Major League Baseball club, as San Diego Padres reliever Yuki Matsui stands 5’8”. While there certainly may be some surface-level concern that his smaller frame might not be able to handle the rigors of the 162-game MLB season, Itoh has been an iron man in Japan, leading the league in innings pitched in 2025 and finding himself in the top 10 in innings pitched in five of the six years he has been pitching for the Fighters- and in 2021, the year he was not in the top 10, he was 11.

Itoh throws from a three-quarters arm slot, dropping and driving off the mound with a fairly small extension and a long arm action through the back. As many Japanese pitchers do, the right-hander features a hitch in his leg lift when the bases are empty, and wraps his wrist during the full extension of his arm circle. His delivery is smooth and balanced, allowing him to repeat his release point well and partially how he has maintained an extremely small walk rate throughout the course of his career.

Itoh’s arsenal of pitches is quite large, consisting of a four-seam fastball, two-seam fastball, cutter, splitter, slider, curveball, and changeup. In 2026, he threw his four-seam fastball 36.6% of the time, his slider 23.7% of the time, his splitter 13.4% of the time, his two-seam fastball 10.4% of the time, his cutter 6.2% of the time, his curveball 5.5% of the time, and his changeup 4.2 of the time. Going back to 2024, he used his cutter and splitter a bit more, but his pitch usage has otherwise broadly remained consistent over the last few seasons. All in all, Itoh is most effective in the shadow of the zone, getting batters to get themselves out by confusing them with his wide assortment of pitches that he is able to spot all over the strike zone.

Itoh’s four-seam fastball averaged 92 MPH in 2026, topping out at 94 MPH. It features above-average arm-side movement and regularly posted above-average 15”+ induced vertical break readings, making it most effective in the upper quadrants of the strike zone. Itoh’s two-seam fastball has similar characteristics, exchanging some velocity for additional arm-side movement.

His slider averaged 83 MPH in 2026, and when the pitch is at its best, it features sharp sweeping horizontal movement in addition to hard vertical break. Itoh either does not always get a good horizontal tilt on the pitch or liberally mixes in a harder gyro slider that minimizes horizontal movement. In 2026, his slider was actually an ineffective pitch, with a slightly negative weighted runs above average per 100, but in 2025 and prior seasons, the pitch was slightly positive.

His splitter averaged 87 MPH in 2026. The pitch tunnels well with his fastball and features late downward drop. Like his slider, the pitch resulted in a slightly negative weighted runs above average per 100, but in past seasons has fluctuated between being slightly above-average and slightly below-average.

His cutter is thrown hard, averaging 90 MPH last season. Last season, it resulted in the highest weighted runs above average per 100 of all of his pitches and has consistently been one of Itoh’s most effective offerings thanks to its combination of velocity and late darting movement.

Itoh’s curveball averaged 76 MPH last season. The big bender features loopy 12-6 drop and is more of a change-of-pace offering than a real swing-and-miss pitch due to its lack of bite. His changeup, which averaged 84 MPH, is similar. Because it lacks dynamic fade or tumble, the pitch is more of a strike stealer or set up to begin a sequence rather than an effective pitch in and of itself.

On the whole, Itoh does a good job of keeping the ball in the stadium, posting a 22.3% line drive rate, 41.0% groundball rate, and 36.8% flyball rate in 2026, with slight variations in those trends over the course of his career. In particular, his sinker, splitter, and changeup have been effective worm killers.  

All in all, nothing in particular stands out as being decidedly above-average in pitching repertoire, but the right-hander has a high amount of pitchability. He knows when to throw what pitches, all of his offerings have synergy with each other, and he is able able to command them all.

Itoh has the nickname “Mr. White Smoke” stemming from an incident that took place during the 2021 Summer Olympics. Members of the South Korean National Team complained that the amount of rosin that Itoh was using was distracting, and that he was intentionally using so much powder in order to confuse hitters by leaving a lingering cloud of rosin in the air around the mound. Itoh’s response was that he was not intentionally trying to gain an advantage over hitters by making it harder for them to see, but that he simply is a sweaty individual.

2026 Dodgers minor league review: Charles Davalan

GLENDALE, ARIZONA - OCTOBER 15: Charles Davalan #6 of the Los Angeles Dodgers swings the bat during a game between the Surprise Saguaros and Glendale Desert Dogs at Camelback Ranch on October 15, 2026 in Glendale, Arizona. (Photo by Brandon Sloter/Getty Images) | Getty Images

We began this review series of minor league standouts for the Dodgers by highlighting the Ontario Tower Buzzers’ most impactful player in 2026, one Easton Shelton here. From one MVP to another, we have Charles Davalan next on the list, elected the Most Valuable Player in the Midwest League for the 2026 season—the first Dodger to win this award since Andy Pages did it back in 2021.

While perhaps not the highest-rated outfield prospect in the Dodgers farm system, Davalan finished the year inside MLB’s top 100 prospects, landing at 79th overall after a marvelous campaign—sixth among Dodgers prospects.

The Dodgers’ second of back-to-back selections in the Competitive Balance Round portion of the 2025 MLB Draft—picked just outside the top 40 with a competitive balance pick they acquired alongside Mike Sirota in the Gavin Lux trade—Davalan’s first full season in the minors was a glaring success. Advanced enough to be thrown straight into High-A ball after a dominant showing in a mere handful of games in Low-A to wrap up the 2025 campaign, going 17 for 34. Davalan established himself as a staple of the Loons offense.

To claim Davalan hit the ground running in High-A might be an understatement, considering in his third game, the former Arkansas Razorback secured his first multihomer performance as a pro, setting up an opening month in which he batted over .300. The biggest challenge, though, came in the following two months, with a .755 OPS between May and June, but from that moment forward, Davalan became the top hitter in the league—including a .790 OPS in July with 16 extra-base hits in just 20 games, which helped fuel his MVP candidacy.

With the way Davalan wrapped up the season, the Dodgers felt confident enough to promote him to Double-A for the playoffs. While the Drillers were swept in two by the Cardinals, Davalan did his part, securing a hit in both games, including a key home run, his 25th this season.

Having a refined hit tool as one of his calling cards, Davalan had no problems handling left-handed pitchers in his first year as a pro, finishing the year with a .337 batting average across 86 at-bats against same-handed pitchers.

Still on the impressiveness of Davalan’s hit tool, the 22-year-old not only had more walks (63) than strikeouts (57), but he also nearly matched his impressive college feat of more extra-base hits than punchouts, falling one short of it with 56 XBH. He was one of three players to score 100 runs or more in the Midwest League, joined by teammate Eduardo Quintero, and his 128 hits and 29 doubles both led the league.

Heading into the Arizona Fall League, Davalan, alongside Quintero, was probably the most exciting Dodger to feature in the competition. And although his production at the plate has been disappointing (.683 OPS), one key aspect of his development has piqued the interest of those following him closely. After moving between left and center in 2026, Davalan has worked as a second baseman in the AFL, reverting to his early days as a baseball player.

If Davalan can continue to take steps forward at second, the flexibility he would bring to the table will be invaluable to this organization—especially so given all the outfield depth it currently has, both in the minors and majors.

2026 particulars

Age: 22

High-A Stats: .292/.402/.535, 24 HR, 72 RBI, 29 2B, 103 R, 115 G

Game of the year

That two-homer game in his third appearance of the season was one of four multi-homer games for Davalan with the Loons. Although it didn’t represent anywhere near his season-high mark in RBI, the one multi-homer game we’ll highlight here came in mid-August—Davalan added a double and a walk to help propel the Loons to an 8-6 victory at home against the South Bend Cubs.

Elephant Rumblings: Bolte Gets One Fifth-Place Vote For ROTY

SACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA - SEPTEMBER 25: Henry Bolte #33 of the Athletics reacts after hitting a two-run triple in the bottom of the sixth inning against the Houston Astros at Sutter Health Park on September 25, 2026 in Sacramento, California. (Photo by Lachlan Cunningham/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Good morning everyone!

The Rookies of the Year were announced yesterday and predictably standout first year center fielder Henry Bolte did not win the annual award. That honor went to Detroit shortstop Kevin McGonigle, who more than deserved it this year.

That said, Bolte ended up getting just one fifth-place vote, which puts him in a tie for 12th place among AL rookies. It was a strong year all around from the rookies in both leagues so the competition was stiff for Bolte, but it still feels low for him to finish there. Bolte provided solid defense in center field while slashing .277/.359/.405 while getting double digit home runs (11) and stolen bases (21). He was a spark plug atop the lineup that got plenty of rallies going and the energy he brought everyday kept this team from truly bottoming out.

And that’s with not beginning the year in the big leagues. It wasn’t until a few weeks after Denzel Clarke suffered an injury did Bolte finally get his shot and he made the most of it. One can’t help but wonder if Bolte were on a contender if he’d have gotten more points in the overall voting for Rookie of the Year. Not saying he should have won, but A’s fans know how important he was for the 2026 A’s as a rookie.

He’ll be just as important this coming season as he’ll presumably be the starting center fielder beginning his sophomore season. The jury is still out on what the club is planning to do with Clarke heading into next year. Some assumption has been that a change of scenery would be best for both sides with Bolte now the long-term option in center. It’s going to be fun watching Bolte become more confident as a major leaguer and get comfortable. And to think, he’s still just 23 years old.

The GM meetings continue today in Las Vegas. As does award season. Today the Manager of the Year awards will be dished out to the best skippers in each league. Pat Murphy is a strong contender after leading the Brewers to the #1 seed (and eventually the World Series, but postseason doesn’t count for awards). And in the American League old friend Stephen Vogt could be looking at his third straight award after leading the Guardians to the AL Central title, though Rays manager Kevin Cash could give him a run for his money. We’ll find out tonight!

Enjoy your Tuesday A’s fans.

A’s Coverage:

MLB News & Interest:

Best of X:

Seconded:

True, but not the first time his name has been floated out there, either:

Looks about as big as Sutter Health:

Of course it will:

How did Bolte get one less vote than Eldridge?

The Human Element, the ABS System, and the Royals Hall of Fame

Matt Quatraro, wearing the team’s City Connect uniform, stands in the dugout
KANSAS CITY, MO - SEPTEMBER 25: Kansas City Royals manager Matt Quatraro as seen before a MLB game between the Cleveland Guardians and the Kansas City Royals on September 25, 2026, at Kauffman Stadium in Kansas City, MO. (Photo by Keith Gillett/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

I was recently thinking about an article on my favorite non-Royals Review website, FanGraphs. In it, Ben Clemens goes to great lengths to analyze the old adage – one I’ve often repeated – that if you keep putting new guys in the game, you are eventually going to run into one who doesn’t have it. You really should read the whole thing, but this part has stuck with me:

Second, relievers are more likely to be in good form, too. Six arms means six chances to draw someone who turns in a clunker, but it also means six chances to draw someone who’s red-hot. And while we think of blowups as largely driven by pitchers not having it, the converse is true too. A pitcher who’s really locked in on a given day is less likely to allow a blowup.

He went on the Effectively Wild podcast to discuss his findings, and elaborating that there seems to be an assumption that a reliever will put up zeroes unless they don’t have it. But that’s simply not the case. Reliever ERA in 2026 was 3.48 across all of MLB. That means that you’d expect a run to score in approximately one out of every three innings. The lowest individual ERA among pitchers who threw at least 50 innings in relief was Louis Varland at 1.27. So no pitcher who is perfect – even the best pitchers occasionally allow runs.

And I got to thinking: that applies to managers, too. There is an expectation that managers will never make mistakes. But every manager is going to make a mistake. They’re human. And we have learned over the past few years that even computers can’t be perfect. So why would we expect that from humans?

This is the flowchart too many fans use:

This is the one they should be using.

And even that’s far too simplified, but it’s light-years closer to how we should actually be thinking about things.

One year of ABS challenges is complete

Earlier this year, I engaged in a bit of a debate with Matthew LaMar over whether the Automated Ball Strike System (ABS) was improving the sport of baseball. At the time, I thought it was accomplishing the goal, and I was content to leave it where it was. As the year continued and teams began to figure out how they wanted to implement it, however, a few patterns emerged.

The first was that while some teams, though not all, could be quite aggressive when they had both challenges remaining, the moment they lost their first challenge, the last one would be held in reserve for only the most egregious of calls. This led to a lot of calls still being wrong because teams were afraid of having no challenges in the biggest moments to counter the worst calls. The second thing that changed is that we saw fewer and fewer batters challenging pitches. It turns out that catchers have a much better view of whether a pitch is a ball or strike and could be correct more often, so teams decided that mostly saving challenges for the guys most likely to get it right was the correct way to do things.

This means there is a new advantage for pitchers in a league that’s already so dominated by defense that MLB is testing increasing infield alignment restrictions, adding outfield alignment restrictions, and implementing automated check swing evaluations that are far more lenient than umpires currently allow.* But it also made me think about “the human element.” I came to the conclusion that the human element is important when the thing they are doing is the point. Computers are terrific for filling in the gaps and supporting that. When it comes to baseball, the point is the entertainment of the athletic competition on the field. The only reason umpires ever got involved in the first place was to remove bias and add perspective to facilitate the playing of a fair game. In the case where a computer can perform that sort of facilitation better than a human, we should let the computers handle it.

*I spoke about this on the linked podcast, so I won’t go into too much depth here, but I also think a sport that is dominated by strikeouts should be more lenient with check swings.People complain that swings aren’t properly defined in the rulebook, but the rulebook says that if the umpire determines the player attempted to strike the ball, it’s a swing. Most check swings are decidedly the batter attempting to not strike the ball.We’ve just grown used to it being called differently from what the rulebook says, much like how there was always a length of time allowed between pitches that wasn’t enforced, just in the opposite direction.

There is a reason that we use timers for the pitch clock rather than have the umpires do a countdown themselves. The computers are better at it. Similarly, computers are better at knowing whether a pitch is a strike or a ball, so they should do it. Another similarity between these two things is that the pitch clock timer doesn’t call the penalty on the batter or pitcher; that’s still the umpire’s job. And it should still be the umpire’s job to announce the balls and strikes. He or she should just be getting the answer from the computer instead of making the decision based on a more limited perception. Games should not be turning on whether a team used their challenges at the wrong moments; that’s not what we’re here to see. We’re here to see if a pitcher can paint the black in a key moment or if a hitter can squeeze one through the infield.* The sport should be leaning into the latter thing more.

*That, by the way, is why I’m in favor of extremely limited shifting. I want players to be getting outs because they’re athletic, not because their front office can crunch numbers the best to ensure they’re already standing in the correct place.Players should want that, too. Defensive skill would become much more valuable if it couldn’t be replaced by equations performed in the front office.

Royals Hall of Fame, Part 2

Last week, I wrote a bit about how crowded this year’s Royals Hall of Fame ballot is. I also posted a ranked-choice ballot to allow everyone to rank the case for each player rather than trying to select five. 59 of you responded, so here are some results.

The top five candidates, in order, were Zack Greinke, Carlos Beltrán, Lorenzo Cain, Eric Hosmer, and Wade Davis. I can’t find exceptional fault with those results even though I voted differently. Here’s the full order:

  1. Zack Greinke
  2. Carlos Beltran
  3. Lorenzo Cain
  4. Eric Hosmer
  5. Wade Davis
  6. Mike Moustakas
  7. Greg Holland
  8. Billy Butler
  9. Joakim Soria
  10. Kelvin Herrera
  11. Alcides Escobar
  12. Ian Kennedy

A handful of you figured out that you didn’t have to vote for everyone and could remove candidates from the ballot if you didn’t want them to even receive partial credit. One of you who figured that out voted only for Zack Greinke. Seems like a sad life to me, but as long as you’re satisfied, I guess that’s fine.

Zack Greinke was the runaway favorite, though, and I will be shocked if he isn’t actually elected. After him, Lorenzo Cain actually got the most first-place votes, but Beltrán had so many more second-place votes that he edged him out – I think there’s absolutely a world where both of them get in, too. From there, it was a big jump down in support to Hosmer and Davis, then another big jump down to Moustakas, another to Holland and Butler, and then big leaps down the rest of the way.

Based on this, I kind of expect everyone under Holland, at least, to fall off the ballot this year. That sucks for Herrera and Butler especially, to me. But that’s what the Veterans Committee is for. I expect both would get in eventually via that committee; I just don’t know how long it will be before that happens.

Mariners News: Kevin McGonigle, Sal Stewart, and Ketel Marte

DETROIT, MICHIGAN - SEPTEMBER 27, 2026: Kevin McGonigle #7 of the Detroit Tigers hits a solo home run during the seventh inning against the Pittsburgh Pirates at Comerica Park on September 27, 2026 in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo by George Kubas/Diamond Images via Getty Images) | Diamond Images/Getty Images

Hello everyone!

It’s a Tuesday and the GM Meetings have kicked off in Las Vegas, so hopefully we begin to see some real offseason traction this week.

Let’s get to all of the latest news as you get your day started.

In Mariners news…

Around the league…