
Jesus Luzardo, who’s last start was back on September 7th, pitched five innings of one-run ball. It was easily the best-case scenario given how things could play out.
The Phillies’ offense entered this postseason ranked 28th in wRC+ and was without Luis Arraez, who was their cleanup hitter before a brutal sprained ankle took him off the postseason roster. Despite that and despite facing Chris Sale, who is nearly a lock to finish in the top five for the National League Cy Young race, they tacked on three runs. It was probably the best-case scenario.
Despite all of that, the Phillies just couldn’t muster enough to take down the Braves in game one. While
Cristopher Sánchez takes the ball for game two, 15 of the 16 Wild Card series entering 2026 went to the team who won game one. The Phillies could win the series still, but it would take a lot.
Everything seemed to go the Phillies’ way in the first. Sale was not sharp, struggling to land the fastball in the zone and get a strong feel for his unhittable slider. Kyle Schwarber worked a one-out walk that took seven pitches. After a Bryce Harper strikeout, Alec Bohm crushed a head-high, 99.1 mph fastball right after the head of a sprinting Michael Harris in center field. Schwarber scored easily without a competitive throw.
Luzardo’s first inning was like clockwork but the second inning featured trouble. He struggled to land his fastball in the zone for strikes and had no feel for his sweeper and changeup. He hung a changeup to Mauricio Dubón, who smoked a double down the left field line to lead off the inning.
After a Michael Harris sacrifice bunt, Ozzie Albies worked a five-pitch walk with Luzardo struggling to throw competitive pitches. He got bailed out against Austin Riley, who saw a fastball going right to his hands, only to hit the knob of the ball and squirt right to Luzardo. Dubón made a very smart play at third, getting into a rundown that allowed Albies to get to third with two outs.
On the very next pitch, Mike Yastrzemski punched a seeing-eye single right past Bryson Stott’s glove and the Braves tied it at one.
Neither Luzardo or Sale would run into issues for nearly the remainder of their outings. Sale coasted with the fastball and slider with an occasional changeup. There was an Edmundo Sosa double in the fifth with two outs, but JT Realmuto went down swinging to end the threat.
It was the Phillies bullpen that started to bring offensive life into this game. Don Mattingly’s first guy out was Alex McFarlane, the rookie right-hander with an overpowering fastball, who’s command has gotten better and better with almost every outing.
With one out, Michael Harris went to left field on a 101.6 mph sinker, tailing away from the strike zone for a single. On the third pitch Albies saw, he smoked a 99.3 mph fastball to dead center field but Derek Hill mistimed his jump and the ball went right off his wrist. Albies got to third easily and Harris ran home and the Braves took a 1-0 lead.
With one out and a runner at third, McFarlane was able to settle down, getting an Austin Riley groundout and a Mike Yastrzemski strikeout.
The Braves sent Sale back out for the seventh and almost immediately looked gassed. With one out, Bryan De La Cruz was hit by a slider and Bryson Stott punched a fastball into right field to put runners on first and third.
Mattingly went to his bench, asking Justin Crawford to come up in a big spot against Braves right handed Didier Fuentes. Both were rookies who made the opening day roster and play roles in both teams getting to this point, albeit Fuentes was significantly better.
With a 3-1 count, Crawford hit a pop up on a slider and the runners stayed put. On the second pitch JT Realmuto saw, he punched a 99.4 mph fastball right over Matt Olson’s head and down the right field line. It took a weird hop on the lip of the grass, which Ronald Acuña Jr. could not handle. Both runners scored and the Phillies took the lead with nine more outs to go.
Jhoan Duran came in because the Phillies have no other options. Asking Duran to get six, maybe even all nine outs is a task almost any reliever would fail at. But this is where the Phillies are at. There was no one else.
He worked quickly through the seventh inning and got the first two outs of the eighth with a manageable pitch count. It seemed like Duran was ready to potentially give them all nine outs for the Phillies to steal a game, and potentially steal a playoff series they have no business being in.
With a 2-0 count, Michael Harris swung at a splinker, that chopped right over Duran’s head and Trea Turner had no chance to exchange the ball from his glove and fire an out to first base. After that infield single, Duran hit Ozzie Albies on a backfoot curveball that put two runners on.
After a lengthy review to decide that it clearly hit Albies foot, Austin Riley stepped into the batters box looking for a fastball. He got that fastball, only at 99.9 mph but it wasn’t 102 like Duran was throwing earlier. Riley got the barrel to hit, 104.6 mph off the bat and barely over the large right field wall that swung the series. The Braves took a 5-3 lead and the Phillies went down in the ninth.
It will be easy to blame Duran for that, blame Mattingly for that, or whoever. The Phillies bullpen entered this series with two trusted relievers. The aforementioned Duran, who had a 1.82 ERA over 59.1 innings as the Phillies’ closer and Alex McFarlane. Both of them allowed runs, Duran allowed a three-run homerun.
However, the Phillies were asking for trouble when the best possible plan called for both of them to successfully pitch multiple innings to win a playoff game. Neither could and the Braves are in the drivers seat with a 1-0 lead in a best of three.



















