It’s mock draft season and ahead of Sunday’s draft, any Lookout Landing staffer that Kate could beg/bribe/blackmail into taking part in our staff-wide mock draft has made their selections. As far as who chose to fake GM which teams, there were varied interests at play: some of us picked our “second teams” (may someone love you in this life like Isabelle loves the Rockies); some (Max) wielded their insider knowledge of the industry; some of us went with familiar AL West adversaries; others, like Nick, operated out of pure villainy and spite. The result is a very patchwork mock draft that honestly isn’t any more far afield than several of the mocks we’ve seen, because outside of the first three-to-six picks of this draft, there’s really just no consensus. Onwards!
First Round:
- White Sox – C Vahn Lackey, Georgia Tech (Isabelle)
Almost every mock draft has one of Roch Cholowsky or Grady Emerson going first overall to the White Sox, but I couldn’t resist the siren song of potential Gold Glove catcher who took his already strong contact-hitting skills and plugged in his power tool this season – without sacrificing said contact skills. Lackey excels at both the big and little pieces that make up an exceptional catcher, and he’s athletic enough to have some positional flexibility. This pick exposes me as a dedicated Kyle Teel nonbeliever, and I’m not that sorry about it. Catcher is the banana stand of positional player draft picks to me; there will always be value in them, especially one as athletic and projectable as Lackey, and I think the White Sox would do well to take advantage here. - Rays – SS Roch Cholowsky, UCLA (John)
I often like to consider myself the Mark Wahlberg of The Iliad, in that if I’d been there it wouldn’t have gone down like that. Kassandra, I hear and believe you, which is crucial because I’ve never met a gift horse I didn’t like. This one clip-clops into Tampa Bay’s hands, especially if, as Isabelle intimates, the White Sox were to take Lackey and potentially save a bit of money to splash on several later picks. Cholowsky seems like the real deal across the board, a powerful middle infielder who rarely chases or whiffs, the type of player that could fill the hole left by the appalling misconduct of Wander Franco and allow the Rays to swiftly accelerate their infield’s construction towards a full constellation of stars. - Twins – SS Grady Emerson, Fort Worth Christian HS (TX) (Jake)
Quick, before Carlos Correa signed his massive free agent deal back in 2022, who is the last shortstop you can name who played for the Twins? You probably can’t because it’s been a black hole of a position for Minnesota for a long time. (Spoiler alert: it’s probably Mariners legend Jorge Polanco who compiled 8.8 fWAR as a shortstop with the Twins.) Grady Emerson has the ceiling to reverse that weakness. He’s drawn Bobby Witt Jr. comps, was named the best high school baseball player in America, and could move through the minors pretty quickly despite his young age. A slam dunk pick for the Twins at number three. - Giants – OF AJ Gracia, Virginia (Ryan)
I’m the least qualified person on staff to participate in this draft, which makes me perfectly qualified to pick for the Giants. As far as I can tell, taking AJ Gracia at four overall would be a reach. But when I think Giants, I think versatile hitters willing to use the whole field. And Gracia, a centerfielder out of University of Virginia, is lauded for his approach and ability to go the other way consistently. - Pirates – RHP Jackson Flora, UC Santa Barbara (Kate)
I’ve seen a lot of mock drafts that have the Pirates taking a high school outfielder here, but my thinking is the Pirates competitive window is open now and they want someone who’s going to be fast-moving and fit that window. Flora is the best college pitcher in the draft, so I’m smashing the you don’t draft for need button here and taking the 6’5” flamethrower. I did debate going college bat here instead, but Flora is just too good to pass up, and the idea of Skenes, Seth Hernandez, and Flora as a three-headed monster should terrify the NL Central. Some folks are calling them Mariners East. - Kansas City Royals – SS Jacob Lombard, Gulliver Prep HS (FL) (Max)
The Royals would likely be thrilled to see both Lombard and Eric Booth Jr. available at their pick, and I think they’ll capitalize on the situation and opt for the immensely talented shortstop out of Florida. He’s arguably got as high of a ceiling as anyone in this draft and could be a transcendent talent if it all clicks, but the concern around his hit tool carries some pretty legitimate weight to it. Things are decidedly Not Good for the Royals after a few solid years, and Lombard could headline a weaker system as a way to kick off a potential rebuild. - Baltimore Orioles – OF Drew Burress, Georgia Tech (Kate)
The Orioles are said to be in on college bats, and Burress, with his picture-perfect swing, is one of the best. He’s a consistently productive power hitter despite a smaller stature and would be able to move quickly to join the Orioles’ young core. He’s a good defender who could stick in center, even though the O’s have Colton Cowser manning things there for the foreseeable future, but Burress has a safer floor than Cowser, who has struggled to hit consistently in the big leagues. - Athletics – LHP Cole Carlon, Arizona State (John)
Sacramento is poised to pick three times in the top 75 thanks to a competitive balance round B pick after the second round, but they’ll be more limited than in many recent years with numerous excess selections. That’s where I see Carlon as a fit, with massive stuff as a 6’5 southpaw who was a strikeout savant at Arizona State University. He has a fastball-slider combo that is arguably the most potent in the draft, though his remaining repertoire is less advanced. Carlon is a stellar fit organizationally, however, as a player accustomed to thriving in the desert heat. Pitch mixes that elude bats entirely are crucial for a club that will be playing somewhere between Sacramento and Las Vegas in all likelihood by the time he debuts, necessitating massive contact prevention in hitter-happy environments. The A’s took a chance on Jeffrey Springs despite some struggles for getting deep into games, and seem comfortable with a high variance player. Even if things pan out frustratingly for Carlon in the third pitch department, he could swiftly be a triple-digit pumping closer, but the stuff is there for a rotation stalwart. - Atlanta Braves – OF Eric Booth Jr., Oak Grove HS (MS) (Kate)
Here is where the slide for Eric Booth Jr. stops. A Vanderbilt commit, Booth Jr.’s asking price might chill some teams, but he’s arguably the best pure athlete in the draft, and that upside is worth betting on. There’s also something about EBJ that feels very Braves-y of recent vintage, whether it’s the SEC football-playing father or very high Fun Factor in watching him play due to his outstanding athleticism and undeniable swagger. - Colorado Rockies – INF Chris Hacopian, Texas A&M (Isabelle)
When one Armenian has the chance to draft another Armenian, you have to take it. Blind loyalty aside, Hacopian is regarded as one of the most well-rounded hitters in the draft, with a career strikeout rate of 9.5% and consistent contact regardless of swing adjustments. He lacks speed and his defense is a weakness, making it likely he’ll transition to 2B or potentially into the outfield, but that can work for the Rockies, who have enough young athleticism to afford a little productive lumbering. This was a tough pick between Hacopian and Baby Kyle Freeland, Cameron Flukey, but ultimately I’m of the belief that the most successful Rockies teams will feature young 90s rom-com villain position players swatting the ball all over, alongside a stable of wizened, wily starters. Enjoy Flukey, Nats! - Washington Nationals – Cameron Flukey, Coastal Carolina (Ryan)
Everyone needs organizational pitching depth, the Nationals especially. Cameron Flukey is among the best in class, standing 6’6” with a big heater and a big bender to boot. He can access just about every velocity bin between 80-100 mph, though mostly sticks with the fastball and curveball. And he throws them from visually interesting (perhaps deceptive) over-the-top arm action. He missed a couple months with a rib injury, possibly impacting his draft position. It’s not often you find this much projection outside the top 10. - Los Angeles Angels – LHP/OF Jared Grindlinger, Huntington Beach HS (CA) (Jake)
The Angels infamously fumbled Shohei Ohtani’s stint on their roster. With a shot at a sliver of redemption, Los Angeles should be ecstatic to pick Jared Grindlinger, this draft class’s best two-way prospect. One of the youngest players in the class, Grindlinger is all raw tools and moldable clay. The Angels have largely focused on drafting MLB-ready college players over the last half decade in an effort to try and quickly supplement their big league roster. When I chose to represent the Angels in this mock draft, I decided upfront to pick the toolsiest high schooler available, just to break that mold. Grindlinger is a long-term project for their development group that could pay big dividends way down the road. - St. Louis Cardinals – SS Tyler Bell, Kentucky (John)
St. Louis has an enviable position in this draft. While they select just 13th overall, they boast the sixth-biggest draft bonus pool of any club in the league thanks to multiple additional picks accrued through competitive balance awardings and trades (including the Brendan Donovan deal). That’s not the initial draw of Bell, who is a college junior that had a taste of turning down the pros already when he headed to Kentucky for school after being selected in the second round back in 2024 by the Rays. Bell is versatile on both sides of the ball, covering the infield and both sides of the dish with aplomb. St. Louis has turned out many excellent multi-positional performers in recent years, including Donovan, Tommy Edman, and Edmundo Sosa. Bell is a superior shortstop to all of them, while rocking a well-rounded offensive profile that the Redbirds will be eager to cultivate. His selection here will open St. Louis up for several bigger swings in their next few picks. - Miami Marlins – OF Derek Curiel, Louisiana State (Kate)
The Marlins have prized youth and athleticism, specifically power-speed combos, with recent picks, but I have them pivoting here to take an established college bat in Curiel, a member of LSU’s title-winning team alongside Kade Anderson. Curiel, a draft-eligible sophomore, still fits the Marlins’ mold of picking young players, and provides a safe floor to counteract some of the Marlins’ bigger swings in recent years. I had hoped that Hacopian or Bell would be available here because the Marlins could use infield help, and debated between Curiel and one of the college catchers, who I think also makes sense here. - Arizona Diamondbacks – OF Trevor Condon, Etowah HS (GA) (John)
Few clubs target players like this the way the Diamondbacks do. A lefty outfielder with elite speed, a funky, line-drive oriented swing, and maximum effort play? This is the archetype from which Corbin Carroll was born, Jake McCarthy and Alek Thomas were hoped to mold into, and even what Ketel Marte began his career in Arizona as. Condon’s hack is almost a modern Lenny Dykstra, and the Georgia prep is in a position to be a huge asset for Arizona’s massive outfield while utilizing its spacious gaps to run wild and slash triples. While his name and Georgia ties might indicate a relation to UGA star and Rockies farmhand Charlie Condon, there is no connection. - Texas Rangers – LHP Gio Rojas, Stoneman Douglas HS (FL) (Max)
Rojas is far too good for the Rangers to pass up here, and their second rounder last year (AJ Russell) has a similar low-launch, fastball-oriented style that clearly popped on their model. Most have Rojas as the clear-cut number one high school arm in this class, and Texas’ farm system is in no shape to be passing up on potentially elite talent. - Houston Astros – SS Justin Lebron, Alabama (Nick)
I do believe that there’s an outside chance that Jim Crane might believe that he’s got a shot at signing LeBron James here, and push this pick through. But the real-life scouts and analysts would be delighted to find him on the board this late. They can teach him to put the bat on the ball. The rest (power, speed, defense, makeup) is already ready to go. - Cincinnati Reds – OF Sawyer Strosnider, Texas Christian (John)
This is a great get for Cincy at 18. Strosnider has the makings of an absolute star, in an organization that has been staggeringly bereft of consistency or competency, much less excellence in the outfield. The only four seasons with >2.0 fWAR since 2021 for the Reds have been TJ Freidl twice, who is having an atrocious campaign as he’s frequently been wont to do in between, and 2021 where both Jesse Winker and Nick Castellanos had big hitting campaigns. It’s a huge hole, but Strosnider has the goods to overcome it. He’s got plus power and speed, enough to be a center fielder whose skills around the diamond cover every element of the game. He’s only shown some occasional overaggression at the dish, but still draws free passes with aplomb when he’s not slugging bombs. - Cleveland Guardians – C Ryder Helfrick, Arkansas (Jake)
With Bo Naylor looking like a bust at catcher, the Guardians traded for Patrick Bailey to shore up the position in the big leagues. This pick in the draft poses the question, “what if you could have the next Bailey but add a league average bat to the equation?” Helfrick is the best defensive catcher in this draft class with 60 to 70 grades placed on his work behind the plate. He enjoyed a bit of an offensive breakout this year, blasting 18 home runs for the Razorbacks. He still strikes out a ton, which gives him a bit of a Mike Zunino-esque profile, but the ceiling should be high enough to entice Cleveland to pick him here. - Boston Red Sox – 3B Ace Reese, Mississippi State (Kate)
The Red Sox like power and Reese provides plenty of it, having hit 20+ homers in each of his first two collegiate seasons with the Bulldogs. Sure, he’s probably more of a 1B at the next level and he’s already not particularly fast, but no need to hurry around the bases when you’re knocking homers over the Pesky Pole. The whiff rate is a little concerning, which is why this is a pick at 20 instead of a pick at 10, and if it calms down in pro ball after the pressure of the draft is off, the Red Sox will have added an advanced power bat to a system that’s already rich, varied, and deep. - San Diego Padres – SS Archer Horn, St. Ignatius Prep (CA) (Max)
Toolsy California prep with tons of helium? Sounds like a Padre. - Detroit Tigers – RHP Coleman Borthwick, South Walton HS (FL) (John)
Resist the urge to say his name in the cadence of Big man Blastoise as you might, it comes to you in the night. Borthwick is a 6’6, 260 lbs threat of a youth that is a straightforward answer to the question of “why is the United States so underwhelming at men’s soccer?” The athletic righty is a two-way player as a prospect, capable of being a third baseman who can slug, but it’s unlikely we’ll see him afforded the opportunity in the pros. Still, he’s sitting mid-90s with a great heater and multiple solid breaking pitches as an 18 year old, with a compact and tidy delivery he repeats well. While it’s unlikely Seattle goes prep pitcher from our perspective, this would be the guy if he falls to the M’s. As it is, I’ve termed the Tigers to take the polished prep, whose solid system is laughably tilted towards position players. - Chicago Cubs – RHP Liam Peterson, Florida (Kate)
The Cubs would be thrilled to see Peterson at 23: a 6’5” hurler who leads with his fastball but also possesses a wipeout slider, a hammer curve, and a changeup. With long levers and a whippy delivery, there are shades of Logan Gilbert here, although Peterson pitched against tougher competition in the SEC. Baseball America recently declared him, not Flora, the best pitcher in the class, so it’s bonkers he’s available here at 23 – not even the first college lefty pitcher off our board. That just goes to show you how polarizing this particular draft is outside of the top 5 or 6 picks (although we couldn’t even agree on those. Viva la chaos!) - Seattle Mariners – OF Logan Hughes, Texas Tech (Max)
I was lucky enough to pull the M’s in this endeavor and wound up going with a bat I really think could be in the mix for them at 24. It’s not the sexiest pick in the world, but Hughes is easily one of the most well rounded bats in this class and comes with a level of polish that’s hard to find this late into the first round. Being a left field exclusive at this point in your career is tough and definitely brings down the shine of his overall profile, but I went with someone that is both a great player and a realistic candidate to make it to their pick. Louisville outfielder Zion Rose was strongly considered, and though I think there’s a case to be made for him over Hughes, my gut says Hughes is more likely to be available when it all shakes out this weekend, and frankly, I prefer to bet on the bat of Hughes over the speed of Rose. Regardless, they are both talented players that could easily wind up being the Mariners’ guy on Saturday night. - Milwaukee Brewers – LHP Hunter Dietz, Arkansas (Jake)
An elbow injury derailed Hunter Dietz’s first two seasons at Arkansas but he returned healthy this year to post a 36.2% strikeout rate in 16 starts. He already possesses a plus cutter and slider and his fastball sits in the mid 90s and can reach 98 mph. His curveball and changeup are works-in-progress, but the fastball-cutter-slider foundation is so good that he should move quickly through the minors once he’s drafted. The Brewers aren’t exactly starved for pitching, but Dietz gives them a potential mid-rotation arm to bolster their big league roster.
Prospect Promotion Incentive Picks
26. Atlanta Braves – RHP Cade Townsend, Ole Miss (Kate)
Speaking truth to power (it’s me I’m power), I don’t know that Townsend makes it past the Mariners – he’s exactly the kind of college pitcher Seattle has had success with, boasting a deep arsenal over pure stuff with a real ability to spin the ball. Atlanta has valued something similar in pitching prospects, though, showing a willingness to look beyond pure stuff and chase long-term upside. The next order of business will be to properly anoint the Ole Miss prospect so he avoids the eldritch curse that hangs over Atlanta’s pitching. UPDATE: The curse that hangs over Atlanta’s pitching is so strong that apparently Townsend already has a shoulder injury which might push him a little further down draft boards.
27. New York Mets – 3B Bo Lowrance, Christ Church Episcopal HS (SC) (Isabelle)
After this pick, the Mets don’t have another until No.92. No pressure! That being said, it’s not my ass in the jackpot, so we’re swingin’ big with Bo Lowrance. BoLow is a Virginia commit and expected to be a tough sign, but you know who’s great at throwing money around? Your New York Mets.
28. Houston Astros – 1B Myles Bailey, Florida State (Nick)
Myles Bailey is the perfect pick for the Astros here. He’s a hulking lad with light tower power. That’s it.
Competitive Balance Round A
29. San Francisco Giants – LHP Carson Bolemon, Southside Christian HS (SC) (Ryan)
Carson Bolemon. The ‘D’ is silent in America. It’s ‘Bo De Le Monde,’ or Bole The Isle of Man, in France, or Boledman in Greece, or finally the vulgar Bolemon in South Carolina, so actually, we don’t know where he’ll be drafted until we hear his last name pronounced.
30. Kansas City Royals – LHP Mason Edwards, Southern California (Max)
No qualified collegian struck out opponents at a higher rate than the 6’2 southpaw. There’s an element of Reid Detmers here for a pitching-savvy club to cultivate further, with a heater on the lower end in the low-90s, but bat-missing ride and VAA. His breaking ball tunnels brilliantly with the pitch, as a breaking ball that utterly baffled Big Ten opponents. There’s always some risk for pitchers who dominate with curveballs in the lower levels, as the big leagues seem to be better attuned to them compared to firmer sliders, but Edwards has one that could beat the odds.
31. Arizona Diamondbacks – RHP Tegan Kuhns, University of Tennessee (John)
Anywhere from the teens onward could be a landing spot for Kuhns, who has the type of stuff Seattle has often targeted as well. Instead, the Diamondbacks will get a chance to push the lean righty up their organizational ladder at a potentially rapid pace. Kuhns is a strike-thrower with a heater in the 94-99 range that he uses predominantly, ahead of any of his secondaries although they show promise. This is the second straight year the Volunteers of Tennessee have one of the top pitchers in the class with a profile arguably only carried by a single elite fastball. Kuhns lacks quite the hype of Liam Doyle, but he’s worthy of first round billing.
32. St. Louis Cardinals – RHP Joseph Contreras, Blessed Trinity Catholic HS (GA) (John)
This is a spot for a prep pitcher if I’ve ever seen one. I’ve given the Cardinals the leeway to make such a swing by snagging the stellar-but-signable Bell in round one, allowing them to swing that big bonus pool around a bit in Comp Round A. Contreras is familiar with big swings, and is presumably the only eligible draftee who can boast having jammed Aaron Judge for a GiDP in a live game. The 18 year old Vanderbilt commit pitched for Brazil in the World Baseball Classic this spring, showcasing major league stuff and high school nerves. His lean frame whips in excellent velocity and, most impressively, an elite forkball like his father. He is the son of Cuban big league stalwart José Contreras, who spent 11 years in the big leagues, debuting at age 31 after a decade starring in his native Cuba. The All-Star had his finest season as part of the Chicago White Sox’ legendary World Series winning 2005 rotation, part of the legacy of connection between the ChiSox and Cuba. His son may also be destined to thrive in the midwest.
33. Tampa Bay Rays – SS Connor Comeau, Anderson HS (TX) (John)
He’s no Perry, but this Comeau can flat out hit. The Rays have prioritized athleticism and contact skills in their hitters, and the 17 year old Comeau is promising in both regards. While the 6’4 youngster might drift to third base, he’s got the goods to stick there comfortably.
34. Pittsburgh Pirates – OF Zion Rose, Louisville (Kate)
The Pirates double up on collegiates in my version of a hard pivot from their past draft tendencies, but Rose is an exciting, toolsy player who was getting draft looks as a high schooler at IMG. He went to Louisville instead where he transitioned off catcher and into the outfield, a testament to his natural athleticism – he’s a double-plus runner, which should help him in the spacious confines of PNC Park. Hit-wise, it’s a contact-oriented profile that’s currently more hit over power, but a strong, athletic frame and quick bat should translate into better power numbers as he matures as a pro.
35. New York Yankees – 1B Gavin Grahovac, Texas A&M (Nick)
I picked the best available player with a beard, because the Yankees love to cause emotional pain.
36. Philadelphia Phillies – SS Aiden Ruiz, Stony Brook HS (NY) (Isabelle)
It’s hard to properly emphasize just how much of an exception Gage Wood was last year for the Phillies draft strategy. They like ‘em preppy and they like ‘em flashy, and Ruiz is one of, if not the best, defensive shortstops in this class. I implore you to watch some of his highlights. Forget Gold Gloves, this is the Golden Ratio of shortstop fielding.
37. Colorado Rockies – RHP Broccoli Rabe, Ole Miss (Isabelle)
Now you get pitching, Rockies. Rabe was an intriguing prep arm out of South Carolina, who underwent Tommy John before his freshman year and was used sparingly up until this season. He’s been a fast riser in recent months, powered by pinpoint control, stellar fastball and a very adult arsenal (a particular point of appeal in making this match, inspired by Antonio Senzatella’s success in throwing the kitchen sink this season). There’s a very real chance he is better than at least three Rockies currently pitching in the bigs. (Ed. note: this young man’s name is Taylor Rabe, despite everything we’d love to have you believe – JT)
WHEW that was a lot. And we swear we only made one of those names up. Here’s the full breakdown: