The Colorado Rockies are a team in the midst of a rebuild. With this in mind, the staff at Purple Row thought it would be useful to revisit the “State of the Position” series that we ran in March to see where things stand. We’ve asked authors of the spring articles to re-evaluate their earlier remarks with an eye toward the August 3 trade deadline.
The Colorado Rockies entered the 2026 season with new organizational leaders, shifting front office priorities, turnover in prospects, and plenty of lineup puzzles to solve. When thinking about team needs, particularly for player depth, the theme of evaluation was key. This season was and is all about using the lineup’s fluidity to identify players that could be part of the team’s long-term plans and, conversely, to determine which players it might be in the Rockies’ best interest to move on from.
The first half of the season brought some clarity around those decisions, thanks in part to versatile bench pieces that emerged and allowed for evaluation. As we approach the trade deadline and more prospect call-ups in the back half of the season, we have a good idea of how Colorado is utilizing the bench and about its philosophy for the Designated Hitter position.
The pre-season hypotheses
The Rockies used 22 players at DH over the course of the 2025 season. Back in March, I wondered if the Rockies might be best suited to lock a smaller handful of players into the DH role, rather than continuing to use the platoon approach. That wondering was in part because of the success of other teams who used a consistent DH and in part because of an opportunity to capitalize on Mickey Moniak’s relative strengths and weaknesses. I suggested upping Moniak’s DH usage to give him the bulk of the starts there, also allowing the Rockies to explore their backlog of outfield depth.
Hypothesizing about the bench pieces, I mainly focused on the infield. Newcomers Edouard Julien and Willi Castro seemed to offer some much-needed flexibility, while TJ Rumfield threatened for a roster spot after an extraordinary camp. It also felt like Blaine Crim (after a stint on the IL) and Ryan Ritter would be in the mix.
At the All-Star break, DH usage is still in flux but a little more concentrated than last season. Some unforeseen faces have joined that mix, while a handful of guys are taking a bulk of appearances. As for the bench, Castro and Julien are slotting in around the diamond (the former performing better than the latter), while Crim has since been waived and Ritter is down in Triple-A. However, a mix of exciting bench pieces have filled those slots.
Continuing the DH platoon
The DH role is still fairly fluid in Colorado, but on a different trajectory than last year. Again, 22 players appeared at DH in 2025, with only one player there for more than 30 games (Hunter Goodman at 39). Tyler Freeman slotted in for 28 games, Yanquiel Fernández for 26, and Kyle Farmer for 24. Mickey Moniak was fifth in DH appearances with 15.
So far in 2026, the Rockies have honed in again on a core group of players to serve as DH, with others appearing less frequently but still pitching in a few games:
- The main contributor so far is none other than our All-Star Hunter Goodman who has slotted in at DH for 26 games in addition to his 64 as catcher. Perhaps the clues were there! He had a similar 2025 with 104 games as catcher and a team-leading 39 at DH.
- While the Rockies didn’t quite listen to me about giving Moniak the most DH appearances, he’s moved up the list to number two AND he’s already surpassed his total games at the position with 18 already this year.
- After that, four players have 10+ games at DH: Fulford (15), Troy Johnston (13), TJ Rumfield (11), and Sterlin Thompson (10).
- Julien and Freeman start to round things out with nine games each, Sullivan adds four, and Jake McCarthy pitches in two.
The Rockies seem to be continuing their approach from last year of using Goodman as the primary contributor while casting a wide net for DH spot starts. This setup has allowed the Rockies to utilize his powerful bat with lineups that play to the matchups, putting Goodman behind the dish most often against right-handed pitching and allowing Brett Sullivan or Braxton Fulford to start at catcher with Goodman at DH against lefties.
His batting splits seem to support that versatility. He’s batting .292 against lefties and .237 against righties. His positional batting splits are somewhat surprising though, as he’s hitting significantly better as catcher than at DH. At catcher, he’s notched 22 of his 27 home runs, logging a .286 batting average. That’s compared to just .174 as DH.
As for Moniak and his role, the setup allows for a good bit of flexibility in the outfield. Moniak has played more games in left field (29) than he has at DH, but fewer in center field (11) and right field (10). This has opened up various combinations of McCarthy, Brenton Doyle, Freeman, Johnston, and Cole Carrigg in the outfield, with Moniak taking more of a backseat there.
By the numbers, that has been effective. One reason it seemed like Moniak would be a good DH candidate after the 2025 season was because of his efficiency as a hitter compared to his struggles in the field. That has tracked into 2026.
Looking at where he stands in league percentiles, Moniak’s batting run value has been great while his fielding run value is on the wrong side of the average. In other categories, he’s excelling more as a hitter than in the outfield, begging the question about whether more DH starts could be useful. Looking at his batting splits by position, he’s contributing at all spots, but he’s actually hitting better when at left field (27 hits, 19 RBI, and eight home runs with a .290 average in 93 at bats) than when at DH (14 hits, six RBI, and one home run with a .241 average in 58 at bats).
Despite their dip in hitting production at DH — at least relative to their positional output, which could be due to a number of other variables — relying on Goodman and Moniak to carry the bulk of the load allows for a couple of the team’s leading hitters to get consistent work at the position, while both allowing for flexibility at other positions and capitalizing on pitching matchups.
It doesn’t appear that the Rockies are trending to be like other teams around the league that give one or two players 60+ starts, but by the end of the season they might have two players surpass the 40+ game mark, something that no single player did for the club in 2025.
Castro’s contributions
Willi Castro appeared at every position but catcher and first base in 2025. That level of versatility was an exciting addition to the organization and it’s playing out here in Colorado. So far in 2026, Castro is doing it all. While not leading appearances at any given position, he is the ultimate bench piece with 58 appearances at second base, 25 at third base, 19 at shortstop, 10 at first base, seven in left field, and two in right field. Starting where needed and moving around as games goes on, Castro racks up those appearances in a way that reflects and complements team needs.
Across all those games, he’s got a 0.5 pWAR (which is best among the team’s second basemen). By the stats, Castro hasn’t excelled anywhere. He’s below average in percentile rankings for batting, baserunning, and fielding value. Even still, he’s been serviceable overall and his batting ranks higher than many on the team.
More than anything, his positional flexibility has put him on the trade radar for teams across the league. Even if moved at the deadline, he served as a cheap and useful piece for the Rockies as they evaluate the roster.
An emerging bench and final thoughts
A number of positions around the field have taken shape (more on those later in this series!) and with that, so have the bench spots. Fulford is one of those pieces. He’s solidified himself as a strong utility piece this season. He’s mixed in well as a third catcher behind Goodman and Sullivan, making 13 appearances there with another 15 at DH. Johnston is another key piece with 38 games in right field and 26 games in left field behind, serving behind the leaders at each of those positions as essentially the fourth outfielder in the rotation.
Unfortunately, or fortunately depending on how you look at it, much of this reliability is subject to change in the near future. With Moniak and Castro tabbed among some of the top trade candidates that the Rockies have to offer, moving one or both of them would send ripples throughout the lineup. Colorado brought them on with short “prove it” kind of deals and they’ve set themselves up to bring a return back to the team with the contributions they’ve made in the first half of the year.
Ultimately, many of the bench pieces on the roster this year were never going to be foundational pieces long-term. The case could still be made to invest in Moniak and keep him around with the growth he’s shown as a Rockie. If either player is moved, their absence will be felt but it will also allow some of the top prospects banging on the major league door to make their way up to conclude the 2026 campaign.
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
- Fewer ads
- Create community posts
- Comment on articles, community posts
- Rec comments, community posts
- New, improved notifications system!
Please keep in mind our Purple Row Community Guidelines when you’re commenting. Thanks!