Daily Question: Which trade still bothers you the most?

TORONTO - OCTOBER 21: First Baseman John Olerud #9 of the Toronto Blue Jays bats during Game Four of the 1992 World Series against the Atlanta Braves at the Skydome on October 21, 1992 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. The Blue Jays won 2-1. (Photo by MLB via Getty Images) | MLB via Getty Images

Today’s question: Which trade, in Jays history, still bothers you the most? Well, the question was supposed to be “Is this team actually trying to contend or are they just pretending?“ but I didn’t think that would give us much to talk about.

This is an easy one for me, the trade that still pisses me off the most was from 1996, 30 years ago. You’d think I’d be over it by now. But no. In 1996, Gord Ash (actually, the top 10 Jays trades that bother me the most are likely all Gord Ash trades). This one though…this one almost had me questioning whether I wanted to be a baseball fan anymore.

Gord Ash traded John Olerud to the Mets for some Person (Robert Person). Olerud was my favourite. He was 27, just coming into his prime. He was a lefty hitter, I was a lefty hitter (and that’s where the resemblance ended). But he was a spray hitter, walked a lot, and could hit the occasional home run. Kind of the type of player I would have liked to have been, had I any talent at all.

I was looking forward to watching his career.

And we traded him for a pitcher who didn’t strike out all that many hitters, walked far more than any pitcher should. Person went 8-13 with a 6.18 in 61 games 22 starts, in 2 and a bit seasons. A -1.7 bWAR.

We traded him to the Phillies for Paul Spoljaric, who, in his second go around with the Jays wasn’t much better than Person.

Olerud? Well, in three seasons with the Mets, had a 17.3 bWAR and a .315/.425/.501 line with 63 home runs. He had the best run of his career. From there, he went to the Mariners, where he had a 17.1 over four and a half seasons.

The kicker to it all, was that we traded Olerud to make from for an aging Joe Carter to play first. Carter would hit .234/.284/.399 with 18 home runs in the season after the trade and left as a free agent.

Now why did they trade Olerud to keep Carter? Well, Cito Gaston liked Carter and he didn’t like Olerud. And Ash was a young GM, new to the job. Gaston was a World Series winning manager.

I’ve said this before, but a strong GM would have told Gaston that Olerud was a young star, and that we need to keep him. Barring that, a good GM would have traded the young star for, you know, a valuable baseball player. A poor GM would trade Olerud for Robert Person.

Now it is your turn.

Which Washington Nationals player would be the best in the NFL?

WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA - MARCH 16, 2025: Elijah Green #21 of the Washington Nationals bats during the fifth inning of a spring training Spring Breakout game against the New York Mets at CACTI Park of the Palm Beaches on March 16, 2025 in West Palm Beach, Florida. (Photo by Nick Cammett/Diamond Images via Getty Images) | Diamond Images/Getty Images

With the Super Bowl tonight, I got to thinking. Which Washington Nationals players could be NFL players? There are a lot of really good athletes on this team, so I had plenty of options. However, I settled on four players. Three of them are currently in the organization, while one is no longer with the Nats. 

The four players are Elijah Green, Trea Turner, CJ Abrams and Joey Wiemer. All of them are absolutely freakish athletes that would fit in on an NFL field. All of them have positions on the field that would suit them as well. Without further ado, let’s get into it. 

Elijah Green has struggled due to hit tool issues in pro ball, but the former top 5 pick might be the freakiest athlete of the four. He is 6’3 225 pounds with an elite blend of power and speed. Football is also in his blood, with his dad Eric being a pro bowl Tight End back in the day. 

When you look at him running, you can just picture him being a big safety or a sideline to sideline linebacker. Green is just a freakish mover for his size. There is actually a player in the Super Bowl with a similar combination of size and speed. That is Seahawks rookie safety Nick Emmanwori.

Green and Emmanwori have very similar measurables. They are both 6’3, but Emmanwori is 5 pounds lighter at 220 pounds. Emmanwori has been a key part of the Seahawks defense as a rookie. He has been a highly versatile defensive back who specializes playing in the slot. Green has the same sort of movement skills. Given his struggles in pro ball, this could honestly be something to consider.

The only former Nat I put on the list is Trea Turner. You just could not make a list of potential NFL players with Nationals connections without him. Even at 32 years old, Turner is still one of the fastest players in the league. He is also incredibly smooth and fluid as an athlete.

All of those things would make him a great wide receiver. At 6’1 185 pounds, he would probably have to bulk up a bit though. However, if he put on another 10 pounds, his measurables would be similar to Seahawks star receiver Jaxon Smith-Njigba. JSN is listed at 6’0 197 pounds. Turner is 6’1 185 pounds, so not too far off.

I actually think Turner is a bit faster than JSN. However, Smith-Njigba’s route running is what makes him special. Obviously, Turner would not be that level of route runner, but his speed and overall movement skills would make him a good receiver.

To stop elite receivers like JSN, you need lockdown cornerbacks. This is where I think CJ Abrams could thrive. A lot of the best corners are on the leaner side like Abrams. They rely on their speed and ability to turn and run. Abrams certainly has that ability to run, as we see on the basepaths.

At 6’0 191 pounds, he also just looks like a cornerback. He is a very similar size to former Heisman Trophy winner Travis Hunter, who is 6’0 185 pounds. Both also have dynamic movement skills and speed.

You can just picture Abrams running with receivers and matching them step for step. While he is not on the list, Jacob Young also has the natural athleticism to be one of the rare white cornerbacks. Cooper DeJean showed us it could be done. Maybe in another life, Young could have followed that career path. 

Finally, the last player I am going to talk about is not as well-known and is new to the Nationals. The Nats claimed Joey Wiemer off of waivers earlier this winter. They did so because of his defense, athleticism and power. He does not have great hitting ability, but he is a tremendous athlete. Wiemer can make highlight reel plays in the outfield.

At 6’4 226 pounds, Wiemer is an impressive physical specimen. With that size, he could play linebacker in the NFL. Fred Warner, the best linebacker in football, is a similar size at 6’3 230 pounds. Wiemer’s size and speed would make him a formidable backer in the league. He probably has the frame to add about 10 pounds if he really wanted to play football as well.

There are a lot of really high level athletes who have played in the Nats organization. Many of them would not look out of place on an NFL field if that was what they decided to pursue instead of baseball. Maybe we could have seen CJ Abrams trying to guard Trea Turner in another life.

I am very excited to watch the Super Bowl and watch these amazing athletes. Who do you guys think will win tonight? Also, do you think I left off any Nationals players who could have been NFL stars if they played football? Let me know in the comments.

Clay Holmes, Freddy Peralta see a lot of talent in Mets’ starting rotation: ‘It’s a great mix’

If you had to point to one area leading to the Mets’ dramatic collapse last season, it would be the starting rotation. 

A group that started the year consistently putting together quality innings completely faltered off down the stretch, and found themselves costing the team more often than not.

After disappointingly failing to make the playoffs, David Stearns knew he had to fix that weak spot this offseason. 

He ended up making just one addition to that group, but it was certainly a big one. 

After months of searching, New York was able to land the top of the rotation arm they’ve been looking for, landing two-time All-Star Freddy Peralta in a deal with the Brewers last month. 

They did have to pay a hefty price, parting with top prospects Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat, but it's certainly worth it to bring in an arm of Peralta's caliber. 

The hope is with him and Nolan McLean leading the way, their veterans bouncing back, and some of the other young arms chipping in, this rotation will be able to turn things around. 

Some feel another addition is needed, but the organization is said to be encouraged by what they've seen from Sean Manaea and Kodai Senga this offseason after they struggled mightily in an injury-plagued campaign. 

Whether or not it'll be enough to pitch this team back into contention remains to be seen.  

On paper, though, Peralta and Clay Holmes like how this group is shaping up. 

“I’m excited to see what we’re going to bring this season, I see a lot of talent,” Peralta said in Port St. Lucie. 

“It’s a great mix,” Holmes added. “We have exciting young guys that can really help us, we have guys coming back who have done things before and it’s just a matter of being those players -- we all have a hunger and desire to really push this team, and to come together as a rotation and truly reach our potential."

You can see that hunger and desire early on. 

Peralta, Holmes, Senga, and McLean are among a group of Mets who have been spotted at camp early. 

Pitchers and catchers officially report to PSL on Wednesday, Feb. 11.

Yankees Birthday of the Day: Fritz Peterson

(Photo by Bettmann Archive/Getty Images)

Some players show up to the big leagues just in time to win a championship, or two, or more. Many, many more completely miss the boat. Fritz Peterson was a reliable left-handed pitcher who despite his strong nine-year tenure in the Bronx worthy of a spot on our Top 100 Yankees countdown never appeared in a World Series with them. His career began four years after their most recent title, and three years before the next.

If Peterson had been part of a championship team or three, perhaps he wouldn’t be mostly remembered for an incident which made him tabloid-fodder in 1972: a consensual partner-swap between himself and teammate Mike Kekich. If anyone was going to laugh about the uproar which ensued, though, it would be Peterson, whose congeniality endeared him to writers and teammates alike.

Fred Ingles Peterson
Born: February 8, 1942 (Chicago, IL)
Died: October 19, 2023 (Winona, MN)
Yankees Tenure: 1966-74

Peterson grew up outside Chicago and remained in the state of Illinois for college after a solid high school career. With the Northern Illinois Huskies, Peterson honed his craft on the mound—while playing some hockey on the side. He began to seek professional offers after his junior year in 1963, two years before the advent of the MLB draft. He fully intended to sign with the Yankees, and in July, he got his wish.

The Yankees, of course, had just won the World Series in 1962 and 1961, and were on their way to appear in a third consecutive Fall Classic. While the Dodgers swept them that year, and the Cardinals dealt them a bitter defeat in seven games in 1964, it seemed like young Fritz had a great chance to taste championship glory in the Bronx.

By the time he made his debut, though, the dynasty had crumbled. The Yanks lost 85 games and tumbled to sixth place in the American League in ’65, and would finish dead last in ’66, even as Peterson came up and logged a solid rookie year. The southpaw pitched a complete game in his first start, limiting the Orioles to two runs on six hits in a 3-2 victory. He went on to post a 3.31 ERA in 34 starts—good for a 100 ERA+ in a very pitcher-friendly run environment.

Fritz took a minor step back in 1967 in another cellar-dweller season before enjoying a successful 1968—as most pitchers did, frankly. But a 2.55 ERA in 1969 after the lowering of the mound proved he was for real, even as he traded wins and losses at an even rate (17-16).

Peterson was a control maven who avoided walks like the plague. He posted a WHIP of 0.996 in ‘69, the best mark in the AL. That season was the second of five consecutive in which he led either the AL or all of baseball in walks-per-nine innings. Since Peterson rarely let a man reach base for free, his starts tended to fly by. “I like to pitch fast and get the game over so I can find out who won,” Peterson once said, showcasing the sharp wit which made him even more popular among writers than his expediency did.

Ahead of the 1969 season, the Yankees traded outfielder Andy Kosco to the Dodgers for reliever Mike Kekich. This seemingly inconsequential move on paper would become a deeply important event for Peterson, who became fast friends with Kekich. Their families spent so much time together that Peterson and Kekich would joke idly about trading wives.

Well it was a joke, at first. Then it wasn’t.

By 1972, Peterson found himself in love with Kekich’s wife Susanne. In December, the Peterson and Kekich families made a one-for-one deal. The rest of the world was not thrilled.

Peterson divulged the wife swap to the media in March of 1973, drawing the ire of fans and media. A columnist derided their decision and blamed a lack of leadership from manager Ralph Houk, who had defended Peterson and Kekich. Even the commissioner of baseball, Bowie Kuhn, came down from his perch to issue an unofficial condemnation.

If, to put it in sports terms, this trade had a “winner,” it would be Peterson, whose marriage with Susanne lasted the rest of their lives. Not so for Kekich, who split up with Peterson’s first wife Marilyn only a few months later; she hadn’t been that enthused about the idea in the first place. Kekich went on the record to say that he thought the swap should have been called off shortly afterward, but the Petersons refused. It all made for an uncomfortable situation and Kekich grew estranged, doing everything he could to distance himself from the story (and a now-seemingly aborted attempt by Ben Affleck and Matt Damon to make a movie about it).

Let’s skip back to a couple years before “the swap.” Peterson enjoyed the best season of his career in 1970, as the Yankees rose from mediocrity to challenge for the AL pennant. While they finished a distant second place behind 108-win Baltimore, their 93 wins were by far the most since Peterson arrived in the Bronx. Peterson, for his part, reached the 20-win total for the first and only time in his MLB career, while pitching to a 2.90 ERA in 260.1 innings. That earned him his lone trip to the Midsummer Classic; in the game, he faced Willie McCovey with the bases loaded, allowed an RBI single, and was relieved by teammate Mel Stottlemyre. The Senior Circuit won 5-4 in 12 innings.

The southpaw continued to pitch well in 1971 and 1972, but the Yankees had returned to their mediocrity, with consecutive fourth-place finishes in the AL. Following the wife-swap in December, Peterson struggled out of the gate in 1973. Fans and media naturally blamed the swap, but he had been struggling with arm fatigue and shoulder pain. In what would ultimately be his final year in pinstripes, Fritz went 8-15 with a 3.95 ERA. The Yankees finished fourth yet again.

Early in 1974, Peterson was traded to Cleveland after starting the season in the bullpen. He rebounded somewhat in 1975, then wrapped up his career after struggling with injuries and inconsistency across 13 appearances in 1976. His overall career numbers across nine seasons in New York: a 109-106 record and 3.10 ERA (106 ERA+) over 1,857 innings, with 893 strikeouts as opposed to only 332 walks. His solid career never coincided with a World Series appearance, but the Yankees would return to the Fall Classic in 1976, then win their 21st championship in 1977.

Peterson wore many hats on retirement, but started a writing career late in his life. His first book was Mickey Mantle Is Going To Heaven, released in 2009, a Ball Four-esque account of his old playing days with an Evangelical flavor. His second book, The Art of De-Conditioning: Eating Your Way to Heaven, was a more humorous account of his decision to stop watching what he ate after retiring. Finally, he wrote a more historical-minded account called When the Yankees Were on the Fritz—about the dim era of Yankees baseball which coincided with his career.

Peterson died from lung cancer in October 2023 at the age of 81, though somewhat oddly it wasn’t reported until the following April. While his exploits were largely overlooked and his career often distilled to a controversial life decision, he was a proud Yankee, even when being a Yankee wasn’t always something to be proud of.


See more of the “Yankees Birthday of the Day” series here.

Mariners News: Michael Arroyo, Dan Wilson, and Terrence Gore

KANSAS CITY, MO - JULY 04: Terrance Gore #0 of the Kansas City Royals rounds second base on his way to third during the third inning against the Cleveland Indians at Kauffman Stadium on July 4, 2019 in Kansas City, Missouri. (Photo by Reed Hoffmann/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Go Hawks!!

In Mariners news…

  • James Johnston is here to remind us all that the Mariners lineup has changed a lot this offseason, and it’s all for the better.

Around the league…

  • Three-time World Series Champion Terrence Gore, known for kind heart, and his supreme speed that made him one of the most valued runners in the league, passed away yesterday at the age of 34.

Nick’s pick…

  • A handful of neutral NFL coaches were asked to predict the Super Bowl and the Seahawks came out on top nearly every time.

Jared Young, blocked again

Last December, we took a look back at Jared Young’s 2025. It was an uneven affair, particularly at the major league level, but much of what made him an exciting minor league signing remained true. His Triple-A damage numbers were excellent, his approach solid, and his contact metrics viable enough to make him look like a useful depth piece. What was most exciting (to me, at least) at the time was that Young seemingly had a path to more playing time in 2026 where he’d hopefully get a chance to actualize those skills at the major league level.

Needless to say, a lot has happened in the intervening months. Jorge Polanco was brought in to play first base. Bo Bichette signed to play third base in January, and then Luis Robert was acquired to play center. With Carson Benge in line to get the first shot at the left field job and neither Mark Vientos nor Ronny Mauricio traded at this point in the offseason, there’s now no clear pathway for Young to get major league playing time. Per Roster Resource, he’s slated to start the year in Triple-A.

Objectively, this is all a very good thing of course. The Mets brought in several good players—ones clearly better than Young—and now have both a stronger major league roster and intriguing depth in the minors. You’d much rather be the Mets of 2026 than the Mets of the 2010s, who lacked the resources or savvy to make these sorts of additions and wound up relying on guys like Young with nothing even resembling a backup plan.

Still, I can’t help but miss those days just a little bit. There was something special, magical even, in the exercise of convincing ourselves that this washed up veteran or that former top prospect would work out, and that the Mets were geniuses were for scooping them up. Maybe it’s age, maybe it’s the state of the world around us, or perhaps it’s simply succumbing to nostalgia; whatever the root cause, I long on some level for that special blend of delusion and hope unique to going all in as a fan on this sort of player.

Overtly philosophical commentary aside, Young is set to play a similar role this season to last. He’ll likely have a narrow window of opportunity before the upper minors prospects—Ryan Clifford, Jacob Reimer, A.J. Ewing—push him even further down the depth chart. I for one will continue to delude myself into believing he’ll work out, and I hope he gets a chance to prove me right.

Guardians’ Top 20 Prospects for 2026 – Siterunner’s List

Dauri Fernandez home run

I have been enjoying seeing our site vote for their top 20 Guardians’ prospects. Allow me to join in on the fun by offering my own thoughts for the top 20 players in a loaded Guardians’ system entering 2026.

First, let me clarify that I am not presenting these as any more valid than our site’s voting or even than the rankings our writers and commenters might present. I offer my rankings based on my observations, my reading, and my analysis of available statistics.

20. Daniel Espino, RHP, 25 years old, appeared in Columbus to end the season.
Analysis: It’s the last time one can conceivably have Espino on this list unless this is the year he makes it all happen and stays healthy. But, due to his IMMENSE talent and incredible work ethic, I can’t not have him just slip on, even if he seems likely to have a relief ceiling at this point. I pray we call get to see his sensational fastaball and devastating slider in the big leagues. He deserves it. We deserve it.

19. George Valera, LHH OF, 25 years old, finished in the majors
Analysis: Similarly, I can’t leave Valera off this list. Yes, there are reasons to doubt him because he whiffs and he chases and his defense is suspect. But, his personal makeup is off the charts… i.e. he got that dawg in ‘im. He also has crushed RHP every time he’s been healthy. Get him in Cleveland let him show what he’s got.

18. Yorman Gomez, RHP, 23 years old, finished at AA.
Analysis: At the age of 22 in 121 innings, Gomez put up a 2.76 FIP, a 2.96 ERA, a 10.28/3.55 K/BB% and a groundball rate of 40%. His fastball touches 97 and he sits 93-96 mph. A lot will depend on how his secondaries (a solid slider and developing curveball) grow in the year ahead, but this is a player who got added to the 40 because he has backend of the rotation or high leverage relief potential. He is only 5’11” so he is probably not going to be more than that… but this is a valuable arm, nonetheless.

17. Alfonsin Rosario, RHH OF, 21 years old, finished at AA.
Analysis: Rosario put up a 129 wRC+ with a 27.5/10.4 K/BB% and a reasonable .317 BABIP. This included an .860 OPS vs. LHP. He’s a corner outfielder but looks like the kind of player who may be able to provide some solid pop as a fourth outfielder/lefty masher if he continues to develop. 2026 will be a big year for him to build on his success in High-A last year and figure out Double-A, earning a promotion to Columbus and putting himself in conversations to help out in Cleveland.

16. Kahlil Watson, LHH CF, 22 years old, finished at AAA.
Analysis: Handling a switch from shortstop to centerfield with aplomb, Watson put up a 129 wRC+ with a 27.7/11.5 K/BB% last season. I am concerned over how much he chases and whiffs, given this organization’s struggle to help those types reach their potential. But, there’s definitely a decent shot that Watson ends up being a 2-win centerfielder who provides a little pop. He will likely get platooned some because he has not hit lefties well in the minors.

15. Jaison Chourio, SH CF, 20 years old, finished at A+
Analysis: Chourio had a bit of a tough 2025, putting up a 103 wRC+ and a 22.9/18.4 K/BB%, and only stealing ten bases on 17 attempts at High-A Lake County. Over the past couple seasons, his splits are about even, but it’s looking like he may be mostly a slap-hitter who puts the ball on the ground way too often (north of 50% of the time). However, the amount of contact he makes and his potential to play centerfield, combined with his youth, keep him in my top 15 for now.

14. Josh Hartle, LHP, 22 years old, finished at AA.
Analysis: Hartle had a 2.54 ERA and a 3.04 FIP with a 8.50/3.10 K/BB/%. He’s a 6’6” lefty and I really like Cleveland’s chances of getting a little more from his fastball or his cutter and pairing that with a good changeup and a solid curve could give them a mid-rotation contract, making him a depth option in the big leagues by the end of this season. He has a good demeanor on the mound, for what’s that worth.

13. Joey Oakie, RHP, 19 years old, finished at Low-A.
Analysis: A 6’3” right-hander with a lively fastball pitching a solid 24 innings at Single-A with a 2.22 ERA and an 11.47/5.55 K/BB/9, Oakie is someone every Guardians’ fan should be aware of. I think this could be a very exciting season for him in which he could put himself in the conversation to end up in Akron IF the Guardians can help him further refine his control and command.

12. Jace LaViolette, LHH OF, 22 years old, yet to play professionally
Analysis: It’s a 6’5” outfielder with potential to play centerfield who hit 50 home runs between his freshman and sophomore year at an SEC school – what more do I have to say? Ok, ok, he had a disappointing junior season, which is why the Guardians were able to draft him where they did. Now, to see if they can fix his 2025 issues and get him back to the promise of 2023-2024. If they can.. LaViolette will be in the top 3 section of this list next year. So, a bit of a mystery box here, but one worthy of a little dreaming.

11. Juneiker Caceres, LHH OF, 18 years old, finished at Low-A.
Analysis: Caceres had a 123 wRC+ and a 12.1/12.4 K/BB% between the Arizona Complex League and Lynchburg. That is very notable production for an 18 year old. He had only a 7.3% swinging-strike rate. He hits the ball hard from all reports, but not very often in the air. It’s very hard to make defensive evaluations on an 18 year-old player, but general consensus is that he’s probably a corner outfielder. He’s certainly an exciting prospect to follow, but I’m a little more “wait-and-see” on him then some others are.

10. Angel Genao, SH SS, 21 years old, finished at AA.
Analysis: Genao had some injury trouble last year and ended up with only a 103 wRC+ and 15.8/8.3 K/BB% at Akron. His primary issue is that he hits the ball on the ground almost 50% of the time. However, he’s still quite young, and he looks to be a solid fielding shortstop. He was also 6 for 6 on stolen base attempts. Hopefully, he will come out strong in Akron this season and force his way to Columbus by the end of the year with increased stolen base attempts, continued fielding improvement and more effective lifting of the baseball, distinguishing himself from folks like Angel Martinez and Brayan Rocchio who began to show cracks in the foundation at the Triple-A level. Genao’s splits as a switch-hitter have been fairly even, solid against both LHP and RHP, so that’s certainly a huge plus. If he can be a 100 wRC+ hitter who hits LHP and RHP at that level and play good defense at short, that would be a 3-4 win player. I think that’s reasonably attainable for him.

9. Cooper Ingle, LHH C, 23 years old, finished at AAA.
Analysis: Ingle had a 139 wRC+ with 16.7/16.9 K/BB% last season. He struggled at the plate at Columbus, especially at the beginning of his time there, but that’s not unusual for a 23 year-old catcher. There doesn’t seem to be much doubt that Ingle will hit in the majors, and take walks. The questions revolve around his ability to stick at catcher, with his 5’8” frame and LIMITED speed not being a great fit anywhere else (perhaps he could become a Steven Kwan clone in left if necessary?). Personally, I think he can become an adequate catcher, defensively, and his successful attempts to decrease his groundball rate and increase his fly ball rate leave me optimistic he could be a 120 wRC+ hitter… against RHP, to be clear. Ingle will likely never hit left-handed pitching well, at all.

8. Kahl Stephen, RHP, 23 years old, finished at Double-A.
Analysis: Stephen is 6’4” and had a 2.53 ERA and a 2.60 FIP with a 9.61/1.75 K/BB% last season in over 100 innings between High-A and Double-A. He does not have an overwhelming fastball but has a good slider and changeup and an excellent curve. Folks, this is the kind of pitcher who, if healthy, EXCELS in Cleveland. In my view, Cleveland traded Shane Bieber for the next Shane Bieber, and I wouldn’t be surprised if Stephen is in Cleveland starting games by the end of this season.

7. Dauri Fernandez, SH SS, 19 years old, finished at Low-A.
Analysis: In 2012 in A-ball, a smaller middle-infield, teenager put up a 145 wRC+ with a 7.7/8 K/BB% in the Guardians’ system. In 2026, a smaller, middle-infield teenager put up a 136 wRC+ with a 12.5/8 K/BB%. The first is Jose Ramirez; the second is Dauri Fernandez. Jose was not pulling balls in the air as much back then, and Dauri does a pretty good job of it aleady. Fernandez also has a better swinging strike rate than Jose did that season and better stolen base numbers (18/22 vs. Jose’s 17/24 at the same age/level). Will Fernandez be another Jose Ramirez? Almost assuredly, no. But, he could still be a very good player, and may be able to stick at shortstop, defensively. He also has amazing work ethic. He’s my pick to make several top 100 lists at this time next season.

6. Juan Brito, SH IF/OF, 24 years old, Finished at Triple-A.
Analysis
: I may be the last man on the Juan Brito hype-train, but, here I stand, I can do no other. After a tough start in the cold April-May of Columbus in 2024, Brito proceeded to put up a 122 wRC+ and 15.6/13 K/BB% in Triple-A before getting hurt last season (hand and then hamstring). He hit 15 homers in 108 games (that’s a roughly 23 homer pace, for those of you counting at home). He pulls the heck out of the ball at all times and maintains a 40-45% flyball rate, while holding pretty even splits as a switch-hitter, but particularly handling lefties well. His defense is the question, where his arm is his best quality, but his range is sketchy at best. I think I agree with Keith Law that he can be an average second baseman, but he may end up getting time at first base or a corner outfield spot. In any case, I’m a believer in his bat and I think, if he’s healthy, he’ll get a chance to win a job on the Guardians in Spring Training.

5. Parker Messick, LHP, 25 years old, finished in Cleveland.
Analysis: Messick’s 3.47 ERA/3.67 FIP and 10.85/3.83 K/BB% in Columbus were impressive enough, but he followed that up with a 2.72 ERA/2.98 FIP and 8.62/1.36 K/BB% in Cleveland! Messick will probably walk more hitters than that, but I also think he’ll strike out more hitters, also. Maybe call it a 9.3/2.7 K/BB% and we are still cooking with gas for a midrotation starter. Messick clearly has the mindset of an elite competitor on the mound, also, which should not be dismissed in value.

4. Ralphy Velazquez, LHH 1B/OF, 20 years old, finished at AA.
Analysis: Velazquez had a 136 wRC+ with a 19.1/9.6 K/BB% last season. It’s easy to try to contextualize those numbers – i.e. “he had a lot of bad batted ball luck to begin the season” (true) or “He put up most of his numbers in one absolutely insane series in Pennsylvania (true), but, overall, his plain and simple numbers indicate that this kid can absolutely mash the baseball, and, from all accounts, his exit velo’s say the same thing. Ralphy has hit lefties and righties well, AND, I think he is a solid corner outfielder. I know folks don’t want to hear this, but I think this is your replacement for Steven Kwan post 2026 (or earlier if things don’t go well for the Guardians but do go well for Ralphy by July).

3. Braylon Doughty, RHP, 20 years old, finished at Low-A
Analysis: As a 19 year old, Doughty put up a 3.48 ERA/2.84 FIP and 10.44/2.43 K/BB/9 at Lynchburg. Those are truly great numbers. Assuming his late-season shutdown was mostly due to innings limits and not any serious injury concerns, I think Doughty has potential to put himself tops of this list by the end of the season. He is an efficient, strike-throwing machine with an underrated fastball to pair with an excellent curveball and slider, and a good feel for commanding all his pitches and managing a gameplan. All at 19, folks. Get excited. But, also, remember… he’s a pitcher. Pray for health.

2. Chase DeLauter, LHH OF, 24 years old, finished in Cleveland
Analysis: Speaking of praying for health, when healthy last year, DeLauter put up a 128 wRC+ with a 15.4/15.4 K/BB% and an unlucky .281 BABIP. He hits the ball hard (52% of the time) and doesn’t chase (ironically!) or whiff. If this kid can just stay healthy, he is going to make a lot of Cleveland fans breathe a sigh of relief when they see him playing outfield and hitting toward the top of the Guardians’ order. He has had some uneven performances against LHP, but has hit them enough where I think he’ll be above-average there and excellent vs. RHP (130 wRC+ or better) when he’s established.

1. Travis Bazzana, LHH 2B, 23 years old, finished at AAA.
Analysis: In his first full year as a professional, Bazzana had a 137 wRC+ with a 24.3/17.6 K/BB%. On the surface, those are very encouraging numbers. However, Bazzana’s slugging hanging out in the .430 range, his strikeouts being elevated from what expectations were, and his injuries (both obliques) have led to some serious doubts about his projectability being introduced. Also, fellow-2024-first-round-draft-picks Nick Kurtz (in the majors last season and incredible), Konnor Griffin (top prospect in baseall) and J.J. Wetherholt (top 10 prospect in baseball) have not helped Guardians’ fans maintain optimism about the Australian 1.1 pick. I am here to tell you to relax and trust the process. If Bazzana is healthy, I am very confident we will see growth in power and in strikeout rate reduction, which will put him on the major league roster by June. Also, I think Bazzana is Kipnis-level at second base defensively. Combined with the 130 wRC+ I think he will manage when established in the big leagues, that’s a 4-5 win player, and I learn toward him consistently putting up 5 wins for his prime.

Outside Looking In/Picks to Click: Gabriel Rodriguez, SS, Robert Arias, OF, Michael Kennedy, RHP, Andrew Walters, RHP, Rafe Schlesinger, LHP, Aaron Walton, OF, Nolan Schubert, DH/OF, Dean Curley, IF, Franklin Gomez, LHP, Austin Peterson, RHP, Jacob Cozart, C, Bennett Thompson, C, Will Hynes, RHP, Tommy Hawke, OF, and Luke Hill, 3B.

Let me know what you think in the comments below!

Snake Bytes 2/8: Superb Owl

Fans gather to watch a Cactus League game between the Cincinnati Reds and Cleveland Guardians, Saturday, Feb. 22, 2025, at the Goodyear Ballpark in Goodyear, Ariz. | Frank Bowen IV/The Enquirer / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images


Team News

Retired D-back David Peralta fondly recalls 2017 Wild Card, not a fan of boos as Dodgerhttps://arizonasports.com/mlb/arizona-diamondbacks/david-peralta/3610844/

Diamondbacks great Paul Goldschmidt heading back to Yankeeshttps://arizonasports.com/mlb/arizona-diamondbacks/paul-goldschmidt-yankees-2/3610931/

D-backs Outfielder Joins Team Netherlands in World Baseball Classic
https://www.si.com/mlb/diamondbacks/onsi/arizona-diamondbacks-news/d-backs-outfielder-netherlands-world-baseball-classic-druw-jones

David Peralta Opens Up on His D-backs Career
https://www.si.com/mlb/diamondbacks/onsi/arizona-diamondbacks-news/david-peralta-opens-up-d-backs-career

Insider Says D-backs Manager Torey Lovullo May Be On Hot Seathttps://www.si.com/mlb/diamondbacks/onsi/arizona-diamondbacks-news/d-backs-manager-torey-lovullo-hot-seat

Other Baseball

Reigning MVPs, Cy Youngs among 78 All-Stars on Classic rosters
https://www.mlb.com/dbacks/news/2026-world-baseball-classic-rosters-unveiled

World Baseball Classic roster takeaways: Team USA’s elite pitching, Puerto Rico’s missing stars, Team Brazil’s return and morehttps://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/article/world-baseball-classic-roster-takeaways-team-usas-elite-pitching-puerto-ricos-missing-stars-team-brazils-return-and-more-200115049.html

Terrance Gore, speedster who made mark with Royals, passes away at 34
https://www.mlb.com/royals/news/terrance-gore-passes-away

Terrance Gore, Royals postseason legend, dead at 34
https://www.royalsreview.com/royals-news-transactions-signings/93607/terrance-gore-royals-postseason-legend-dead-at-34

Former Athletics first baseman Mark McGwire returns to the franchise as special assistant to player development

https://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/article/former-athletics-first-baseman-mark-mcgwire-returns-to-the-franchise-as-special-assistant-to-player-development-163409875.html

Yasiel Puig found guilty of obstruction, lying to officialshttps://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/47852596/ex-mlb-player-puig-guilty-obstruction-lying-officials

Mexico Red tops Mexico Green in thrilling Caribbean Series final
https://www.mlb.com/news/mexico-red-defeats-mexico-green-in-2026-caribbean-series-title-game

Anything Goes

This day in history:

https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/february-8

This day in baseball:

https://www.baseball-reference.com/bullpen/February_8

The Hawaiian alphabet contains only 13 letters.

The Hawaiian alphabet contains a total of five vowels that are both long and short. It also contains a total of eight consonants. Hawaii’s alphabet represents all the basic sounds and phonemes in their language. 


Giraffes cannot swim.

A giraffe can maintain its balance on land due to its gait. However, research has shown that this balance is ineffective in the water. This makes them one of the worst swimmers in the animal kingdom.

Australia is the only continent without an active volcano.

The nearest active volcanoes are located off the continent of Australia but are still within its territory. One is located on Head Island and the other on McDonald Islands. The reason why Australia does not have any active volcanoes located on the continent is that it isn’t on a plate boundary.


Good Morning San Diego: Spring Training is just days away, several questions remain

PHOENIX, ARIZONA - AUGUST 06: Jake Cronenworth #9 of the San Diego Padres is tagged out at home plate by James McCann #8 of the Arizona Diamondbacks during the fifth inning at Chase Field on August 06, 2025 in Phoenix, Arizona. Padres won 3-2. (Photo by Norm Hall/Getty Images) | Jake Cronenworth - Getty Images

Spring Training is less than a week away for the San Diego Padres and once again it will not be a normal spring in Peoria, Ariz. The time has come once again for the World Baseball Classic and for the Padres players competing for their respective countries they will have a broken Spring Training. They will start in Peoria, then move onto their respective teams, and then return at the conclusion of their WBC runs. Cheri Bell of Gaslamp Ball gives a breakdown of what the Friar Faithful can expect this spring. She included a comment from one of the longest tenured Padres, Jake Cronenworth, who said some of the San Diego players will report to camp ahead of their scheduled date in order to give them some time to bond prior to WBC players departing to join their teams. We have seen these odd schedules in seasons past for San Diego. All we can do as fans is hope it does not prevent the Padres from accomplishing their regular season and postseason goals, which includes winning a World Series title.

Padres News:

  • General manager A.J. Preller has been referred to as the “Rockstar GM” in seasons past. Padres fans are hoping he can reclaim that title with a significant move to address roster needs prior to Spring Training, but there is not overwhelming confidence it will happen. A recent Padres Reacts Survey on Gaslamp Ball found 49 percent of respondents believe Preller will make a move that has a significant impact on the season prior to Spring Training.
  • Kevin Acee of the San Diego Union-Tribune provides readers with a breakdown of various possibilities that could take place for the Padres over the next six weeks. Some of the potential happenings listed by Acee are a new contract for Preller, a fifth starter for the rotation and the sale of the team.

Baseball News:

Better Know Your Blue Jays 40-Man: Tyler Heineman

TORONTO, ON - OCTOBER 05: Tyler Heineman #55 of the Toronto Blue Jays looks on from the dugout during Game Two of the American League Division Series presented by Booking.com between the New York Yankees and the Toronto Blue Jays at Rogers Centre on Sunday, October 5, 2025 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. (Photo by Daniel Shirey/MLB Photos via Getty Images) | MLB Photos via Getty Images

Tyler Heineman is a 34-year-old journeyman catcher. He’s 35 in June, so it will go down as his age 35 season

He’s played parts of six seasons in the majors. His 174 PA in 2025, tied his career high. Also, his .289 batting average was a career high, as well as the 3 home runs.

He had a 1.9 bWAR, giving him a 2.6 career number.

Tyler had a terrific start to the season, he had high water mark of a 429/.441/.625 batting line on June 9th, which slowly dropped to .289/.361/416 by season’s end, which is still pretty great for a backup catcher. He didn’t do well over the last two months, hitting .170/.264/.191 from August first to the end of the season.

I thought his defense was terrific. Baseball Savant has him at an 88th percentile for blocks above average, 81st percentile for caught stealing above average, 84th percentile for framing and 80th percentile for pop time. There were very few complaints about his work behind the plate.

And our pitchers seemed to like pitching to him. The Blue Jays pitchers had a 3.54 ERA with Tyler behind the plate. They had a 4.34 ERA with Kirk behind the plate. It might have been luck, I like Kirk’s pitch calling a lot, but I’ll be curious to see if Heineman has an edge again next year.

My wife would like to tell you that Heineman has an edge on Kirk with his shirt off, too.

Heineman is out of options, so he can’t be sent down to the minors, not that I think it is likely the club would want to send him out.

I wonder how often a waiver pickup has posted a 1.9 bWAR the next season. I’d guess that he won’t have a number that high again, but you never know. His defense is great and, this year, his bat looked good.

The Jays and Heineman avoided having to go in front of the arbitrator, with him signing a $1.2375 million contract for the 2026. I’m glad for him. I think Ross or Mark or whatever scout thought that Tyler would be a good pickup deserves a prize of some sort. Or a DQ Blizzard.

Steamer projects that Tyler will appear in only 25 games, hitting .226/.305/.331 with 2 home runs in 99 PA. I don’t know. I don’t see anyone taking the backup catcher job from him (at least not in the organization right now), and starting catchers don’t play 120 games anymore, so I’d take the over on the games played.

Which year changed how you watch the Phillies?

Jun 15, 2014; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Philadelphia Phillies hall of fame pitcher Jim Bunting (right) and outfielder Dick Allen react after Bunting threw out the first pitch before game against the Chicago Cubs at Citizens Bank Park. Bunting pitched a perfect game on Father's Day, June 21, 1964. Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-Imagn Images

At some point in our lives, we decided to descend into some kind of loathing. We decided to pledge our undying allegiance to a team that would simultaneously break our hearts and fill them with love at the same time.

We decided to become a Phillies fan.

But when was it? What was the year that changed how you watch the Phillies? There had to have been a time when the team did something that made you fundamentally change how you take in the team. For some of an older age, 1964 is going to leave scars forever. Mention 1993 to a bunch of fans and pain will almost immediately scramble their brains.

At some point, there was a year in which something flipped. What year was it?

How would you rank the AL East teams heading into 2026?

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 26: Giancarlo Stanton #27 of the New York Yankees hits a two run home run in the third inning against Trevor Rogers #28 of the Baltimore Orioles during their game at Yankee Stadium on September 26, 2025 in New York City. (Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images) | Getty Images

After finishing last in the AL East division in 2025, this offseason the Orioles have set to work re-building. They added power to the lineup in the form of Pete Alonso and Taylor Ward, a lockdown ninth inning in closer Ryan Helsley, and two starter signings, Shane Baz and Zach Eflin, to steady the rotation, although many feel they’re still missing an ace.

But how do these moves stack up with the rest of the competition? The AL East is always a behemoth, and several competitors have made noteworthy moves.

  • NYY: Last season, the Yankees finished 94-68 and lost to Toronto in the ALDS. This offseason, they re-signed Cody Bellinger and brought back Trent Grisham, plus they’ve got closer David Bednar solidifying their bullpen after last year’s trade deadline pickup.
  • TOR: The Blue Jays made it to the World Series and missed a championship by inches. Since then, they’ve loaded up on pitching with Dylan Cease (seven years, $210 million), Cody Ponce, and Tyler Rogers, and they also added power in the form of slugger Kazuma Okamoto.
  • BOS: After finishing third in the division last year, the Red Sox have gone big on pitching, signing Ranger Suárez to a five-year, $130 million deal and trading for Sonny Gray to pair with Garrett Crochet.
  • TBR: Tampa Bay finished in fourth place last season, two games ahead of the Orioles, and they’ve made a lot of minor moves this offseason. They shipped out starter Shane Baz to the Orioles for four prospects, unloaded second baseman Brandon Lowe, outfielder Jake Mangum and lefty reliever Mason Montgomery, traded outfielder Josh Lowe to the Angels and acquired second baseman Gavin Lux from the Reds in a three-team swap, along with veteran outfielders Cedric Mullins and Jake Fraley and left-hander Steven Matz.

So where do the O’s slot in in this group? I’d say third feels about right to me—good enough for a wild card push, but trailing the loaded Blue Jays and steady Yankees. Then again, maybe Alonso mashes 45 homers and the rotation exceeds expectations.

What’s your ranking, Camden Chat? Tell us in the comments.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Which Braves will play out of position this Spring?

ATLANTA, GEORGIA - SEPTEMBER 28: Ronald Acuña Jr. #13 of the Atlanta Braves runs to first base after hitting a two-run homer to score himself and Matt Olson in the first inning of a game against the Pittsburgh Pirates at Truist Park on September 28, 2025 in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Edward M. Pio Roda/Getty Images) | Getty Images

There is some video out there of Ronald Acuña playing second base. There’s also footage of Acuña crushing a pitch while swinging left handed. How bananas would it be to see him play 162 games as a switch-hitting second baseman? Ivan ran the numbers, and he said that he would be worth approximately 3700 WAR doing that in 2026. Honestly, right field and designated hitter is fine, Ronnie. Please take care of that lower body.

Spring Training is the time of year to see players trying out some different things. So which Braves players will play out of position this Spring? I would be curious to see Eli White playing some second base. I don’t think they see him as an infielder, but he might have to play there to make it as the last or second to last guy on the bench. There might be some center field in the future for John Gil. I don’t if we’ll see it this early in his career, though.

What does the Cardinals lineup look like without Brendan Donovan?

Jun 2, 2024; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; St. Louis Cardinals second base Nolan Gorman (16) celebrates his home run with shortstop Masyn Winn (0) against the Philadelphia Phillies during the first inning at Citizens Bank Park. Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-Imagn Images

It happened. It stinks, but it happened. The St. Louis Cardinals are in full rebuild (as evidenced by FanDuel’s 69.5 win total), but that reality has sunk in enough that fans seem to embrace the idea of growing pains with the young, but talented roster.

With the trade of Brendan Donovan, who it looked like was going to be heading to Jupiter with the team before the three-team deal with the Mariners, the Cardinals projected starting lineup has a total of three hitters over the age of 27, with one of them being the oft and currently injured Lars Nootbaar. That leaves Alec Burleson and Pedro Pages as the elders of the clubhouse as the team searches for their next leader on and off the field. Burly and Pages both have just over three years of MLB experience, so the team that we see taking the field at Busch next year will likely be learning the big league game together. Now that Donnie is in Seattle and the roster is complete outside of the rumored righty power outfielder, it seems like a fair time to see how that trade impacts the lineup to start the 2026 season. In case you missed it, I had Redbird Farmhands and Aidan Gray from Redbirds on the Arch, as well as Tampa Bay Rays contributor Roman Rodriguez on my podcast to discuss the trade from those sides.

Who’s on second? And third? And DHing? And playing the outfield? All questions the Cardinals must answer in 2026

According to FanGraphs, the starting nine for the Cardinals are 28-years-old or under, with Lars Nootbaar being the eldest of the group. The outfielder’s health is a problem of its own, but I guess until we hear any update on his health, we have to trust Bloom and expect that Noot will be healthy and at the top of the order. Interestingly, this FanGraphs projection also points out how the entire lineup consists of homegrown talent, with five of the nine starters being selected in the first and second round. For as much grief as Mozeliak gets, that entire projected lineup was acquired during his reign, and its not like these players are bottom of the barrel major leaguers. The vast majority of them, if not all, would be likely find a major league taker if the Cardinals were to simply cut these players loose like certain Cardinals “fan” social media accounts imply.

So with the departures of lineup fixtures Brendan Donovan and Willson Contreras, what does the Cardinals Opening Day lineup look like as of early February? This is probably easier to predict the players involved than it is to guess the starting five in the rotation at this moment, but the order in which these players hit is likely to be up for conversation for much of the season’s first half. The FanGraphs projection has Pedro Pages starting at catcher with Ivan Herrera at DH. While I think this could be a real possibility at some point during the year, I think it is more likely that Oli Marmol will stick to his word and allow Herrera the chance to start 3-4 times per week at the start of the season.

The other defensive question comes at second and third base, with each of Nolan Gorman and Rookie of the Year co-favorite JJ Wetherholt as the likeliest outcomes at those spots. Where they spend most of their time will again be a talking point, but it seems like Wetherholt has been spending most of his time, as well as being most comfortable, at second base. Hopefully, the Cardinals will not want to tweak with position alignment too much in Wetherholt’s rookie season, as we have seen what learning new positions in the bigs as well as adjusting to major league pitching at the same time can do to the beginning of a career. Because of this, Gorman will probably switch back to his natural spot at the hot corner, despite below-average marks there after bouncing back to third base at times last season.

Speaking of positions, I get irked at times when people just suggest that so and so should try the outfield or first base. While it is likely that these high level athletes can handle it, I see too many suggestions in-season for someone like Herrera to “try first base” while having a total of six appearances at any level at the position. I do believe that he is athletic enough to figure out how to play first, or even be a potential fit in the outfield, but again, we need to remain focused on one thing at a time and right now, I see that primary focus as offensive production for basically every person in the order.

The adoption of the designated hitter by the NL on a full-time basis was one I was against for the majority of my baseball life, but as I got older and the game changed, whether we like it or not, getting rid of pitchers (like myself) at the plate made the most sense for the league. What I have found interesting, though, is that the days of the big, beefy, bomber at DH seems to be gone and the NL has been slower to adopt to the DH spot being a position for homers and/or extending careers of those power hitters. According to FanGraphs sortable DH data from 2022 through the 2025 season, nine of the top 15 teams are AL teams when sorted by offensive value, because somehow defensive value is a DH measure available on the site.

Of the six NL teams cracking the top half, all six have been in the playoffs since the adoption of the DH, but the drop off in value from the top five to the next 10 is exponentially greater. For example, the Phillies rank 4th with a 131.2 value, while the Cardinals come in at 13th with a 32.1 value. The other three at the top are Yankees (261.6), Dodgers (171.6), and Astros (143.1). The Cardinals have not settled on one player being the everyday DH, typically using a rotation for players to get half days off. Personally, I think that they could have (the options are limited now), used the DH spot to invest in a Kyle Schwarber-lite and find someone who can hit 30+ homers to actually inject some life into the lineup while not blocking youngsters on the defensive side.

Back to the lineup. With Donnie gone, we can change our pencil to erasable pen that Wetherholt will be ticketed for St. Louis out of Spring Training. I fully expect him to break camp with the team, but I also want to be fair to him, the organization, and make sure to not get too far ahead like we did for Walker, Scott, Carlson, and so on, and so on…

The leadoff spot will be up for grabs if Nootbaar is not ready for the opener, and the in-house options look like Masyn Winn and Victor Scott II as the table setter. VSII has the gamebreaking speed to cause chaos, as long as he can fine tune his approach to get on base more often in 2026. He has spent nearly his entire major league career sitting in the ninth spot, the other, and potentially more likely outcome for Scott. Winn has been the leadoff man in 112 of his 316 games, with 62 games in the second spot, and another 61 hitting ninth. So far, hitting first has been a struggle for Winn due to his aggressiveness at the plate, but his refined approach, maturity, and health could make him an electric player to start the offense for the Cardinals. He has shown more patience in the minors, but asking for a walk rate approaching 10% may be a difficult task for Winn, and I would personally rather have him swing away than be passive at the plate because I believe he has some more power and speed potential that he is still hoping to unlock. I did see Wetherholt mentioned as possible in the comments, but I would be surprised if his debut season was spent at the top of the order until he proves himself at the big league level.

Two through four are going to be the engine of the order, just like most quality teams. In some order, I would expect Ivan Herrera, Alec Burleson, and then my pick to click for this year, Nolan Gorman. I understand those that have jumped off the Gorm train years ago, as I have been close, but I think this year is truly the season the organization learns who he will be. Yes, Gorman has the second-most career at-bats on the roster, but those 1500+ appearances have been unevenly spread over four strange seasons for the infielder. The pop is there in potential for all three of these middle of the order players, but we have yet to see sustained power numbers that could make the trio push for 90+ homers on the year. If we can approach that (75-80 this year), much of my offseason negativity towards the lack of home runs the Cardinals have had in their lineup for much of the 2020s, where they are 21st in homers and 16th in slug.

The bottom-third of the order is where we will probably have to wait and see Wetherholt, and with Marmol’s desire to go lefty/righty, his spot could be determined by wherever Burleson and Gorman end up. If Burly or Gorm end up hitting fourth over Herrera, we could see Wetherholt pushed down to sixth for whoever fills the DH spot, assuming Herrera is slotting in behind the plate. The lack of answer at DH could be a reason why Marmol would hesitate to start the Panamanian at catcher regularly, especially with Pedro Pages available to handle the pitching staff albeit with a needed progression on offense. That will be a probable outcome when Herrera needs a day or struggles defensively, but until then, we might see a mix of Gorman, Thomas Saggese, and Jose Fermin mixing in as the full-time hitter. Both Saggese and Fermin offer positional versatility, so they could also give Gorm and/or Wetherholt a needed day in the field and swap spots. Neither player, though, possesses the power potential expected from a DH, but both profile strong enough offensively to work their way into regular at-bats in this season of evaluation.

If Noot is healthy, this is also where Masyn Winn can slot in. As a six or seven hitter, Winn could find a way to tap into his offensive potential if the guys in front of him do their job. There will absolutely be extended period of lineup growing pains this season, but from watching the team nearly everyday, I feel like the lineup could be an underrated part of the Cardinals, while understanding that the low expectations is due to the overall lack of experience and production to this point. I believe, that a year of seasoning for the other nine in the lineup around Wetherholt, we have the potential of seeing leaps across the order, including who I see hitting eighth in Jordan Walker.

Had Bloom made good on his wishlist of wanting a power righty in the outfield, that could have spelled more trouble for Walker than Noot or Scott. As things stand, though, everyday right fielder makes the most sense, like it or not, for Walker and the Cardinals. Because of his mismanagement to start his career, Walker has just one minor league option season remaining and I would be shocked if the Cardinals burned that option in a year meant for runway and opportunity. As is the case in most offseasons, we have heard positive reviews on Walker’s work ethic and his positivity that he is going to turn a corner in 2026. If he is able to match the ZiPS projections set for him by Dan Szymborski, Walker would put up a .232 batting average with 14 homers and a much reduced K-rate. According to the site, this would put Walker at an 88 wRC+ for the season, still below-average but a massive jump from his bummer 66 wRC+ he put up last season. That type of production, along with gains in the stolen base and fielding departments, would do well for Walker’s confidence and future in the league.

The rest of the lineup could set up Victor Scott II in the nine hole, unless he gets a shot to prove his value at the top of the order sans Noot. We have heard about the adjustments he has made to his offensive approach, and hopefully those show up in the box score. Scott has set his goal at 70 stolen bases this season, but he needs to find ways to get on base more consistently for that to happen. With him hitting ninth with a walk or single having the potential to turn into a double really quickly, his presence anywhere in the order could do a lot to get the offense moving.

At this point, the starting nine looks mostly set with defensive alignment and slots in the order left to be settled upon. Heading into Spring Training, I admit that I’ll be more focused on the games than I have in the past with a lineup that had veterans entrenched into positions or a roster without much turnover. The pitching may be the ultimate competition in Jupiter, but the lineup construction will be an extensive story that likely won’t be settled upon when the team heads north.

SELF PROMO OF THE WEEK
  • I already linked the Cardinals on My Time where I spoke with the fellas from Redbirds on the Arch and Roman, the Tampa Bay Rays contributor. For those that followed COMT on your podcast platform of choice, I have merged with Redbird Rundown so all future pods will be posted there. Link to RR Spotify.
  • This week’s Random Cardinal of the Week featured the pitcher who threw the last no-hitter for St. Louis. I know this audience knows that without researching, but he is pretty random.
  • Finally, Redbird Rundown discussed the Donovan trade, Cardinals TV (where I go off on National broadcasts and MLB layoffs), and a short segment during February pointing out lesser known Black Cardinals during Black History Month. This goes live at 6pm on YouTube and audio.

Thanks as always for your support and feedback!