Boyhood Phillies fans McGonigle, Trout give Midsummer Classic more local feel originally appeared on NBC Sports Philadelphia
DETROIT — The first time Mike Trout played at Citizens Bank Park, he was the best player in baseball.
It was May 13, 2014. Trout was 22, in his third full season with the Angels and finally stepping into the ballpark of the team he grew up following from Millville, New Jersey.
He got the loudest ovation when he dug into the box.
Kevin McGonigle was 9 years old then.
Now he is a month from 22 himself, an All-Star rookie with the Tigers and headed for his first game at the ballpark he grew up visiting as a Phillies fan from Aldan, Pennsylvania, in Delaware County.
McGonigle has taken batting practice at Citizens Bank Park before. That is what he remembers most when people ask if he has ever played there.
He has not.
“I think it’s all gonna hit me once I get to the stadium, and they call my name over the loudspeaker and the national anthem, for sure,” McGonigle said.
Trout and McGonigle grew up in different corners of the region, at different times, watching the same team. Both were boyhood Phillies fans. Both now return as American League All-Stars.
The Delco boy has said that the three-time MVP texted him after he made the All-Star team, the coolest message that he’s received.
Fitting.
Trout, born in Vineland and raised in Millville, is an All-Star again after injuries kept him out of the event for years. He has made three teams since 2019 but has not played in the game since then. This season, he has 18 homers, a .390 on-base percentage and an .863 OPS.
McGonigle, who attended Monsignor Bonner & Archbishop Prendergast in Drexel Hill, has made his case quickly. He is batting .283 with an .812 OPS, 60 walks and 56 strikeouts, making him the favorite for American League Rookie of the Year.
He has reached base 162 times this season. Since the first All-Star Game in 1933, only two players age 21 or younger have reached base more before the break, according to Tigers PR: Trout with 170 in 2013 and Al Kaline with 169 in 1955.
On Friday night in Detroit, McGonigle added to that tally by taking the longest-tenured Phillie, Aaron Nola, deep with close to 10 family members in attendance during the Tigers-Phillies series.
“It was unbelievable,” McGonigle said. “I didn’t know if it was gonna go or not, so I sprinted out of the box. But also, it was a big homer in the game, which was nice to help this team. It was a cool moment to be able to share a field with all those guys I grew up watching and competing against.”
Their draft paths came close to the Phillies in different ways.
The Phillies did not have a first-round pick in 2009 after signing Raul Ibanez, a Type A free agent, following their 2008 World Series title. They would have picked 29th. Trout was already gone by then, selected 25th by the Angels.
Fourteen years later, the Phillies took Aidan Miller with the 27th pick in the 2023 draft. McGonigle lasted 10 more picks before Detroit selected him at No. 37, a competitive balance pick.
Athletics first baseman Nick Kurtz, another first-timer, is part of the local group, too, even if an IL stint has changed what his All-Star break looks like.
Kurtz is from Lancaster and grew up a Phillies fan, too. Matt Kirchoff, who coached Kurtz as a freshman at Manheim Township before Kurtz transferred, still lives near the family.
Kirchoff watched Kurtz grow up around Lancaster baseball and still remembers the early signs.
“We knew what we had,” Kirchoff said. “We didn’t know what he was gonna turn out to be, obviously. But we knew we had a really good player.”
Even after transferring and later becoming one of baseball’s top young bats, Kurtz stayed connected. Kirchoff said Kurtz has come back to work out at the high school, take batting practice and support the program.
“To have somebody like Nick that still comes around, that still follows our program, still comes to an occasional workout when he’s at home, that means a lot,” Kirchoff said.
For McGonigle, the area shaped more than his fandom. It shaped how he viewed the game.
“It was all about winning,” McGonigle said. “It wasn’t really about our personal stats or what you did that day. It just all mattered about if we won or not. I think that’s what really helped me get better and get me to where I’m at today.”
His favorite Phillies memory as a fan fits the era.
Chase Utley returned to Citizens Bank Park with the Dodgers in 2016, and McGonigle was there for the ovation.
“That’s my guy,” McGonigle, who carries similar grit, said of his longtime idol.
McGonigle had a harder time picking a cheesesteak spot.
“Dude, there’s a lot of good ones,” McGonigle said, before naming Delco Steaks, Phillips Steaks and Dalessandro’s.
“For me, just convenient that I live in Delco,” he said of Delco Steaks. “They’re a really good cheesesteak.”
For Trout, the connection runs deeper than fandom. Millville is still home. Roy Hallenbeck, Trout’s high school coach at Millville, made that clear.
“He’s never left,” Hallenbeck said. “And I say that as the most complimentary thing.”
Trout’s roots are still visible there. His golf course is being built nearby. Hallenbeck drives past it on his way to work.
“He’s still a hometown kid,” Hallenbeck said. “This is where he’s decided to put down roots, and that means something.”
Hallenbeck knew Trout before he was Trout. He was an assistant under Trout’s father, Jeff, who had coached at Millville. Back then, Mike was “little Mikey” running around the program.
Then little Mikey grew up.
Hallenbeck still remembers how Trout carried himself late in his high school career, when scouts packed games and the draft started to feel real.
“If you didn’t already know who he was, and you just came into our locker room or came to our practice, other than the physical characteristics, you wouldn’t be able to pick out the future first-rounder,” Hallenbeck said. “He didn’t act that way.”
That was the compliment.
Trout had every reason to act differently. He never did.
“He was a killer,” Hallenbeck said. “He knew how good he was, but it was never portrayed in an arrogant way.”
The moment that still gets retold came when Billy Godwin, then East Carolina’s coach, visited to recruit him. Trout had committed to ECU, but the draft was starting to make that path unlikely.
That day, Trout hit what Hallenbeck called a moonshot to center field. The ball got caught in the wind, the center fielder could not make the play and Trout never stopped running.
Inside-the-park homer.
“Once they saw what that number was, they’re all calling their supervisors,” Hallenbeck said of the scouts timing him around the bases.
Godwin watched it and understood.
“That’s the best bleeping high school player I’ve ever seen,” Hallenbeck remembered him saying. “He ain’t coming to East Carolina.”
The program later created an honor around his old No. 1, awarding it to a player each year. Before spring training, Trout would stop in, sign items for charity events, take pictures with that year’s No. 1 and make the kid a temporary celebrity with a retweet.
“He really went out of his way to take care of us,” Hallenbeck said, “and make sure that we had what we needed.”
For Hallenbeck, Trout’s return is not about needing another All-Star appearance to validate anything. But after years of injuries and missed Midsummer Classics, he gets another chance to play in front of a crowd filled with people who know exactly where he came from.
“To be able to play at the Bank, in front of essentially a hometown crowd, I just think would be a full-circle moment,” Hallenbeck said.
McGonigle is at a different point. He is still a rookie, still processing how quickly this has arrived.
“Growing up, I always had the dream of playing major-league baseball,” McGonigle said. “It’s just cool to see all my dreams kind of coming true right now, and I still have a lot of work to do.”
It brings him back to the ballpark he knew first as a fan.
“It’s just really cool that I get to have my first All-Star Game in my hometown,” McGonigle said.
There will be plenty of Phillies in uniform Tuesday night. Cristopher Sánchez will start for the National League. Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber will be part of the Home Run Derby.
And the two boyhood Phillies fans will be back in South Philadelphia and will take the field on the opposite side.