When the Orioles purchased the contract of Reds’ corner infielder Christian Encarnacion-Strand back in April, it was just another one of those low-profile moves we see from Mike Elias and the front office all the time. It was the latest instance of the “buy low and hope something good happens” mentality that’s seen Elias take swings on Jhonkensy Noel, Rico Garcia, Jacob Webb, Danny Coulombe, Emmanuel Rivera and others.
Fast forward three months and the man they call CES is now in both the heart of the Orioles order and the heart of Birdland as we cling to playoff hopes that can’t decide whether to live or die. Encarnacion-Strand was called up to replace the injured Blaze Alexander with the thought that he’d be a bench option behind Coby Mayo at third. Instead, CES quickly overtook Mayo and started producing numbers we’ve never seen from an Oriole debutant.
Through his first five games with Baltimore, the 26-year-old infielder went 8-for-20 (.400) with three homers and eight RBIs, both of which were records for an Oriole in their first five games. He’s hit safely in six of the seven games he’s played, has a reasonable strikeout rate (22.2%) and has gone from a relative unknown quantity to one of the most productive bats in the Baltimore order.
The fact that CES is showing signs of being a truly productive MLB player isn’t completely surprising. He was a top prospect in the Reds organization, who once sat between former top rookies Matt McClain and Spencer Steer in the Reds’ top 30 prospects.
Encarnacion-Strand then burst onto the MLB scene looking like a player destined for stardom. After debuting just post the All-Star break in 2023, CES launched 13 homers in 63 games while posting an .805 OPS and displayed hard-hit rates that helped project him as a middle of the order mainstay in Cincinnati.
Instead of building on that success, however, CES largely became a forgotten commodity for the Reds. At 24 years old, he got off to a slow start to the 2024 campaign and saw his season end prematurely when he broke his wrist in early May. CES would return to Cincinnati to begin the 2025 season, but injured his back in mid-April, which caused him to go on the IL for eight weeks. Upon his return, he put up a respectable triple lash of .247/.273/.438, but was ultimately optioned to Triple-A for the last three months of the season.
He never made it back to the Reds, as he started this year in Triple-A Louisville before being DFA’d on April 8th. When the O’s sent cash considerations to Cincinnati to bring in the former top prospect, he seemed like natural insurance for Mayo. Both right-handed sluggers have prodigous power with 3B/1B flexibility, though Encarnacion-Strand had spent 81.5% of his defensive innings at first for the Reds.
The production CES showed throughout his stint at Triple-A Norfolk more than justified the front office’s decision to acquire him. After posting 33 home runs across in just over 500 ABs across three stints with Louisville, Encarnacion-Strand swatted 17 long balls while posting an .863 OPS in 61 games for the Tides.
Where the man with baseball’s longest last name goes from here is anyone’s guess. We’ve seen players come up to instant success without being able to sustain their high level of play. 2024 Heston Kjerstad prior to being bean in the head by the Yankees comes to mind. End of 2024 Emmanuel Rivera also had a good run. And who can forget some of the magic from late 2022 Kyle Stowers.
But if Encarnacion-Strand wants to be more than a fun foot note in Orioles history, he’ll need to stay hot while proving he can hit right-handed pitching better than Mayo. Through seven games with the O’s, CES is 7-for-10 against left-handed pitchers with all three of his home runs coming against southpaws. Against right-handers, he’s 3-for-17 with a double. Which is to say, he’s playing a lot like Coby Mayo across his small sample size.
Mayo undoubtedly has a higher ceiling, and not just because he’s two years younger than Encarnacion-Strand. Both of the infielders had power and arm strength as their best attributes when coming up as prospects. For CES, his power was graded as a 55 while his arm was a 60 on the 20-80 scale. For Mayo, both graded out as a 70. And while Encarnacion-Strand is currently a better defensive 3B, he’s still below average, and Mayo’s superior athleticism give him a better chance to become an at least average defender at the hot corner.
The arrival and quick success of CES came on the perfect time for the O’s. With Alexander likely out until September and both Aldey Rutschman and Samuel Basallo currenlty on the IL, the offense needed an infusion of talent and production from an unlikely source.
Now, they need CES and Mayo to continue to push each other and contiune give the O’s lineup length behind Pete Alonso, Taylor Ward and Gunnar Henderson. For now, both should be playing against left-handed pitchers, with one at 3B and the other DH’ing. Mayo got the start against Detroit right-hander Keider Montero yesterday; we’ll who Craig Albernaz turns to against right-hander Troy Melton later today.
Despite the natural tendency to think that Encarnacion-Strand’s recent success will ultimately just be a flash in the pan, there’s also enough reasons to believe that it is instead a talented player finally making the most of good health and an opportunity. At worst, he should be able to help bridge the gap until Blaze and the two catchers getting healthy. But at 26 with proven upside, he could also be the latest reclamation project that proves to have long-term upside.