While the Yankees were largely quiet at this year’s deadline, making just two trades that they hope provide a jolt to a lineup that has been downright disastrous without Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, and Giancarlo Stanton, the Yankees’ division rivals turned the trade meter to high and spun a whopping 21 combined deals. Whether you think the Yankees’ promotion of George Lombard Jr. counts among all this is up to you. Anyway, with so much turmoil, you’ll be forgiven for not being quite sure what the rest of the division looks like, and so, let’s take a dive into what the rest of the AL East was up to.
Let’s start with the team currently occupying the top spot in the division, the Tampa Bay Rays. Heading into the deadline, Tampa Bay was in the market for a starting pitcher and another bat to add into the lineup, and with one of the league’s premier farm systems, they were in position to make a play for pretty much anybody they wanted. In the end, though, the Rays had a measured deadline, making three additions: starting pitcher Freddy Peralta from the Mets, platoon catcher/first baseman Liam Hicks from the Marlins, and reliever Tyler Wells from the Orioles.
All three moves represent high-risk, high-reward moves. One year after a top-five finish in the NL Cy Young, Peralta has been absolutely dreadful for the Mets, with a 4.99 ERA in 22 appearances. Just in his second season, the 27-year-old Hicks is a force against righties, slashing .307/.387/.489 this season against righties, while posting just a .200/.278/.238 line against lefties; his Statcast data, though, is not too high on his performance at the plate (he can avoid strikeouts, but doesn’t hit the ball hard). Only Wells, a reliever with strong peripherals, represents a relatively safe move. When you’re in first place with a solid floor, though, you can take risks like these to raise your ceiling.
Sitting right behind the Yankees in the standings is the Boston Red Sox, a team that started the season ice cold but has been hotter than hot over the last month. While, ultimately, they are neither as bad as they were to start the season or as good as they are now, their two stretches combined to put them right where everyone expected them — in the thick of the playoff race. As such, Boston had a very active deadline, headlined by arguably the highest profile addition made by an AL East team: Adley Rutschman, the now-former Orioles catcher who was targeted by the Yankees.
A week after sending Connelly Early to the Nationals for Curtis Mead, Boston sent its top-ranked right-handed pitching prospect Anthony Eyanson, outfield prospect Enddy Azocar, pitcher Kyson Witherspoon, and catcher Carlos Narvaez to the Orioles for the former No. 1 overall pick. The move represents a big risk with major upside for the Red Sox, because Rutschman has a career 115 OPS+ (identical to his cumulative performance this season), but he has just a .671 OPS since May 1st — and he’s currently on the IL with a wrist injury. Depending on which version of Rutschman they get, Boston will either see a major boost to a lineup that has been performing well, but has been very inconsistent this season, or will drop an anchor into the lineup.
Supplementing these moves, the Red Sox cut bait with 2021’s No. 4 overall pick Marcelo Meyer, sending him to the Giants for lefty reliever Erik Miller and minor league outfielder Carlos Gutierrez. They also acquired Eli White, a right-handed outfielder, from the Atlanta Braves; his overall numbers aren’t great (89 OPS+), but he has a swing that could play up in Fenway.
In fourth place, we have the Baltimore Orioles. Can you believe that the Yankees and O’s were battling for the division crown just two years ago? Aside from the 2023 and 2024 seasons, Baltimore’s stretch of tanking and retooling for six seasons has produced almost nothing. Earlier this week, they sent Dean Kremer to the Twins straight up for outfield prospect Jhomnardo Reyes. Yesterday, they sent outfielder Taylor Ward to the Mariners for a trio of right-handed pitchers in Alex Hoppe, Brock Moore and Harrison Kreiling. They sent Wells to the Rays, receiving in return Michael Forret — one of the players sent to Tampa Bay in exchange for Shane Baz over the winter.
And, of course, the biggest haul came from Rutschman. It’s a loaded prospect package to be sure, but you’d forgive Baltimore fans for not being terribly interested in talks about the future when Mike Elias made a name off doing that with Rutschman and company just a few years ago.
In a pair of minor moves, the O’s brought in minor league outfielder Christian Franklin from the Nationals, sending pitcher Joe Glassey the other way, and reliever Codi Heuer from the Brewers and outfielder Rece Hinds for cash considerations. Oh, and they also extended Yennier Cano, so there’s that.
Sitting in last place in the division, the defending AL champion Toronto Blue Jays engaged in a mixture of buying and selling that was clearly geared towards improving the team for 2027. They sent Kevin Gausman to the Chicago Cubs, Daulton Varsho to the Astros, Jeff Hoffman to the Twins, and Adam Macko to the Rangers. In came José Soriano (from the Angels), Josh Smith (from the Rangers), Spencer Arrighetti (from the Astros), and Team Canada alum Jameson Taillon (recently DFA’d by the Cubs). Through these trades, the farm added middle infield prospect Ty Southisene, outfield prospect Brett Bateman, left-handed pitcher Dasan Hill, right-handed pitcher John Klein, and infielder Dameury Pena, but subtracted top shortstop prospect Arjun Nimmala, minor league outfielder Eddie Micheletti and minor league righty Angel Rivero.
The end result? Toronto has basically pulled the plug on 2026, but is looking to get right back into the hunt next season.