
Reynaldo López was one of many 2026 Atlanta Braves pitchers afflicted by the injury bug this season. Injuries are brutal, because not only do the afflicted players miss time, but they also tend to perform worse before going on the shelf, or as they ramp back up to “game speed” after being activated. Something like this was the case for López, whom the Braves hoped would have a solid rebound season in 2026 after his fantastic 2024.
How Acquired
On November 20, 2023, the Braves signed López to a three year guaranteed contract with a club option for a fourth year. The deal was technically a $26 million deal, but it had a $4 million buyout should the club decide to decline the $8 million option for 2027.
Then, on November 2, 2024 the Braves restructured, the contract making it fully guaranteed through the 2027 with an AAV of $10 million. The deal also shuffled cash away from 2025 and into 2026, which may have helped the Braves in some minuscule way. The restructuring resulted in an additional $4 million guaranteed for Lopez, so it wasn’t a big deal and was more a show of good faith in his talent.
What were the expectations?
López has had a long career full of twists and turns. Once a top-30 prospect that wowed with his fastball-curve combo and figured to be an above-average starter in the majors, he was an up-and-down guy without much success in his rookie season, and then again in his sophomore effort after he was traded (with Lucas Giolito and Dane Dunning) in the Adam Eaton deal.
López never really met his expectations as a starter in Chicago. He was okay in 2018-2019, but that okay-ness was highly dependent on a lower-than-average HR/FB rate. After a 2020 to forget, he was then okay as a swingman in 2021, and then busted out with a 2.0 fWAR relief season in 2022. He maintained a quality relief pace in 2023 while pitching for three different teams, but it was just an 0.7 fWAR season as he couldn’t carry his 2022 dominance forward.
All of that brings us to 2024, where the Braves clearly liked what they saw, and agreed to both sign López and entertain his desire to return to the starting rotation. That ended up working out great, at first: López ended up with a career year (3.6 fWAR, 48 ERA-, 73 FIP-, 85 xFIP-) and his arm mostly held up (25 starts, over 130 innings, two Injured List stints). While he was again helped by HR/FB and his ERA was a farce, it looked like he had finally grown into the expectations from about a decade ago.
But, things quickly turned sinister. The throwing shoulder inflammation from 2024 that lingered into 2025 eventually became arthroscopic surgery, and López’ 2025 consisted of a single, poor start.
Where did that bring us for 2026? It was unclear. Would López be healthy, and if he were healthy, would he even be able to do what he did in 2024? Or, had that ship sailed, and he now needed a diminished role to go with diminished expectations? It was certainly a point for debate, but the debate also felt kind of moot because it wasn’t clear whether he’d even be able to take the field.
His projections varied from very effective swingman (ZiPS, 2ish WAR in 100 innings) to a quality part-time starter (Steamer, 2ish WAR in 150 innings).
2026 Results
Safe to say that due to injuries and a bunch of other stuff, he did not meet those projected central estimates. Like much of his career, López’ season was one of twists and turns, but mostly not the good kind.
After a reasonable Spring Training, alarm bells started to sound when his velocity dipped towards the latter end of March. The team explained this as “mechanical adjustments,” which made little sense, but, lo and behold: López showed up and danced through the raindrops in his first two starts (good results, bad peripherals) and then looked a lot more like his 2024 self in the two after that (worse results, better peripherals). But, he then had some kind of horrendous physical-slash-mechanical issue in his fifth start, and was moved to the bullpen, where he spent the next two months pitching what was basically and nearly exclusively mop-up work for an inning or two at a time.
The Braves then reinserted him into their tattered rotation, and he was… fine. A knee injury knocked him out for about six weeks, he returned with two more unimpressive outings, and then shoulder inflammation ended his season in mid-September.
In total, López had 13 starts and 13 relief appearances in 2026, combining for 79 1/3 innings. His pitching slash line was blah: 108 ERA-, 106 FIP-, 105 xFIP-. That’s a below average-ish starter, but since a lot of that came in relief, it is considerably less impressive or useful. He earned 0.6 fWAR for his efforts. While he was there for most of the season, he didn’t really do all that much to contribute to the Braves’ 94-win campaign.
What went right?
Well, he was healthy enough for those 13 starts, 13 relief appearances, and 79 1/3 innings. He wasn’t healthy enough to make it through the season as a starter, nor to avoid two different stints on the shelf — nor to stop the shoulder inflammation from cropping up again.
If we’re looking for positives, there are a few. For one, though it’s not clear he had much to do with it, batters didn’t make hard contact off him. Both his hard-hit rate and his exit velocity-against were quite low… though that’s more the province of batters that face him than anything he’s doing.
His fastball command was pretty good. His curveball, which he threw only about 11 percent of the time, had a very nice xwOBA-against (.236) as batters failed to do much with it.
His return to the rotation after pitching in relief was pretty decent: a 92 ERA-, 94 FIP-, and 95 xFIP- in six starts. If he could keep that up over much of a season, he’d be an asset to the team. Unfortunately, he couldn’t even last five starts before having to move to the bullpen for various reasons earlier in the year, and his knee gave way after this six-start stretch. His last outing in this span was probably his standout work of the year: 5 2/3 innings with a 6/1 K/BB ratio and no runs charged to his ledger in Baltimore. (The Braves won 3-2 in 11 innings.) He also had a similar outing against the Cardinals with another 6/1 K/BB ratio in five innings, where he was charged with a run in the first but then breezed the rest of the way. Would’ve been nice to see that sort of thing for more than six starts, though.
What went wrong?
Injuries, to start. The knee injury ended that nice span of starts, and shoulder inflammation ended his season. But, there were a lot of other disappointing things.
His velocity was incredibly inconsistent. It was in the 94-95 range in his first three starts, then dipped a few ticks, and then it bounced around hard while he was a reliever. When he returned to starting, it went back to 94-95, but then dropped off again.
Whether related to that inconsistency or not, his inability to provide useful relief was an issue. His xFIP barely declined as a reliever (4.38) relative to what it was for the season when starting (4.45). The Braves used him in lower leverage, and he still blew up sometimes. He also blew up as a starter here and there, and it seemed to be health/mechanics-related as much as anything else, so it was hard to trust him or know what you were going to get on any given day.
López struggled horribly with locating his slider basically all year, as it ended up in the dirt over and over. It did get a lot of whiffs because it was hard to hit when thrown around the shoetops, but it also made it fairly easy for hitters to just avoid spinny stuff.
And, of course, sometimes it all just came together to ruin his day. One of his worst starts of the year came against the Padres during his overall successful pitching stretch, as he gave up two homers in 4 1/3 innings (6/3 K/BB ratio) in a blowout loss.
2027 Outlook
The 2027 season, as it will be, could go in pretty much any direction for López. Is he going to be a starter? Reliever? Will he be healthy? If he is healthy enough to play but not to start, will he actually be a useful reliever? Steamer’s central estimate is down to around 0.5-1.0 WAR in 100 innings as a swingman who mostly serves as a relief role. That’s a big drop from what the central estimate was a year ago. The same can be seen from ZiPS (1.0 to 1.5 WAR in 100 innings). Basically, it seems like whereas the 2026 central estimate was that Lopez would be useful in an uncertain role, he’s now down to “a role player with an uncertain role.”













