The San Francisco Giants are trying to get rolling early in the Tony Vitello era, having won three of their last four games after a 0-3 start to the season.
Vitello has shown excitement, passion and a willingness to share the ins and outs during his first year as a MLB manager, but some want him to tone it down.
Sports personality Chris Rose compared the Giants' skipper to Team USA manager Mark DeRosa in how open he was with the media during a radio appearance on The Morning Roast with Joe Spadoni and Joe Shasky on 95.7 The Game, the Bay Area's sports station.
"I think he's got a little bit of Mark DeRosa syndrome," Rose said on the radio show. "What I mean by that is D-Ro, who's a buddy of mine, I worked with him for a decade at Major League Baseball Network. To me, his biggest issue with Team USA was that he kind of let us in a little too much."
He added: "I know that's fun for us as people who are consuming and talking about content, but like, when D-Ro goes, 'yeah, the players, they invited all the coaches in to have a beer, and then the next day, some guys were hurting a little bit.' Like, that's okay to do, it's okay for the coaches to have a beer with their players and tell stories, and it's okay for players to be hurting a little bit the next day. Don't let everybody know."
Vitello has a knack for painting a picture when fielded questions from reporters. Rose is absolutely right, in a sense that it makes better for hits and clicks. But Vitello is seemingly comfortable with it and being himself.
The first-year skipper told media members how the team celebrated his first major league win as manager with a beer shower and other beverages.
"There was adult beverages, but there was other stuff mixed in too. So at some point I'll be plotting my revenge," Vitello joked with reporters after the team's first win and the first of his baseball managerial career. "I really get a sense like, no matter what happens, this group is going to get a lot closer together as the year goes on."
Rose supports Vitello and the Giants' hire. However, if there was one piece of advice he'd give him, it's to not give the people too much, but just enough.
"So you can't tell everything that's on your brain and have it come out of your mouth," Rose said. "And I would say, if there's one word of advice ... You don't have to make everything a story, I would say. But I find him fascinating, and I'm on board with him."
What are people saying about Tony Vitello?
Baseball experts are predicting the Giants and Tony Vitello to be just about average this season.
Baseball legend Dusty Baker told USA TODAY Sports on MLB Opening Day that Vitello needs time but should be alright.
"You just gotta give him a chance. That's the thing," Baker said. "You know, just give him a chance and then you got to give him more than a year to make the adjustment."
Yahoo Sports senior MLB analysts Jordan Shusterman and Jake Mintz said on an episode of their "Baseball Bar-B-Cast" podcast that they appreciate how candid Vitello is but admitted he might have to switch things up after being swept in the New York Yankees series.
"I do appreciate Tony's authenticity, it's so refreshing, and his willingness to just be like, "This is how I feel," and he, this is how he felt after the second game. That transparency and honesty is refreshing for us," Mintz said. "But for the purpose of the job and for keeping things steady as the unofficial spokesperson of the baseball team, that is the part of his job that is just so different now, and the part that he's gonna have to figure out how to manage."
He added: "It doesn't mean I want Tony Vitello to suddenly become boring, and I don't think that's ever really going to happen. But for his own sake, we're gonna have to kind of keep it, keep it a little bit more even keeled."
Bay Area sports radio host Markus Boucher of KNBR said he likes how Vitello watches the game and makes adjustments off of feel and what he sees on the mound.
"I love the fact that Tony Vitello went with the EYE-alitics, not the analytics," Boucher said. "You gotta watch the damn game, Tony Vitello felt that."
The Giants host the New York Mets at 10:15 ET on April 3.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Is Tony Vitello too candid with reporters? Baseball experts say yes