Justin Verlander keeps climbing MLB strikeout list, but Giants can't capitalize originally appeared on NBC Sports Bay Area
SAN FRANCISCO — Justin Verlander was a bit confused when some Giants fans started to rise and cheer in the fifth inning. The home plate umpire had stepped back so they could show some love, but when Verlander looked up at the scoreboard he didn’t see anything.
Verlander did, however, know that he was coming up on Walter Johnson on the all-time strikeout list. That was the message that flashed on the scoreboard for a moment before he turned around, although it was a bit misleading.
MLB.com, Baseball-Reference and the Elias Sports Bureau all have different career strikeout numbers for Johnson, who started his career more than 100 years ago. The most official of the three is Elias, which has Johnson at 3,515, six more than Baseball-Reference, meaning Verlander is still four shy of tying the Hall of Famer.
In a quiet clubhouse after a 2-1 loss to the Tampa Bay Rays, Verlander at least found some humor in that. He scrunched his face when told of the discrepancy and asked for further details about how it was possible.
“Sheesh,” he said, smiling.
That word is as good as any to describe everything that happened Saturday, both good and bad. On a positive note, Verlander became just the fifth 42-year-old to throw at least seven innings, allow just two hits and strike out at least eight. It was his best start of the 2025 MLB season, a throwback that had him talking about how his stuff feels as good as it did three years ago, when he won a Cy Young Award.
But there were a lot of other reasons to exclaim “sheesh.” Here’s a short list …
— The bullpen blew a Verlander lead for the sixth time this season, tying him for the MLB lead.
— The loss was the 15th in 16 home games, something the Giants had not done since 1901.
— They have lost all three series on this homestand and have dropped six straight home series for the first time since 2008.
— If they don’t win Sunday, they’ll lose eight games in a row at home for the first time since … well, July.
— A loss Sunday would give them a 1-8 homestand for the first time since 1993.
There’s only one word for it: Sheesh.
Verlander more than did his part, and when Christian Koss found a hole, he took a 1-0 lead through seven. For years, that would lead to a shutout for Verlander, but he was at 88 pitches and had gone seven full innings for the first time all season.
Giants manager Bob Melvin turned to a bullpen that lost Tyler Rogers and Camilo Doval at the deadline and is missing Ryan Walker because of paternity leave. With two outs in the top of the eighth, the Rays rallied for two runs off José Buttó and Matt Gage.
It was the kind of sequence that shows just how bizarre this slide has been. The Giants only traded Rogers and Doval because of that previous eight-game losing streak at home, but with the New York Mets playing even worse baseball lately, there has been a small opening to get back into the fringes of the wild-card race. But because they traded Rogers and Doval, the bullpen has not been good enough to finish out the close games that could have turned into needed wins.
“Look, we still had a great chance to win that game,” Melvin said. “We had two out and nobody on in the eighth and we can’t finish it off. It’s pretty frustrating.”
Verlander has tried not to show his frustration, although he admitted Saturday that for as much as he has enjoyed his teammates, this has not been that fun a season overall.
“We have a great group of people. I’ve enjoyed every moment that we’ve experienced in the locker room and off the field,” he said. “On the field has been a struggle. It’s been hard, yeah.”
Verlander is throwing well enough lately that it doesn’t seem out of the question that he would try to pitch a few more years and make a run at 300 wins. At the same time, his early struggles, along with the fact that he’s second-to-last in the majors in run support and has lost multiple wins because of the bullpen, have made 300 seem pretty unrealistic.
There was a version of this season where Verlander snagged a few wins early and then got rewarded for nights like Saturday. Perhaps he could have picked up seven or eight wins, getting into the 270s and making a run at 300 more possible. Instead, he’s sitting at 1-9, and the Giants are not playing like a team that will give him many more opportunities at victories over the final six weeks.
Verlander does, however, continue to make history. He got to 3,511 strikeouts for his career, and his next time out, he should catch Johnson on the Elias list. He’s just 24 away from passing Giants Hall of Famer Gaylord Perry and moving into eighth all-time. It’s one small thing for fans to root for in a season that quickly has spiraled out of control.
“I grew up a fan of the game and I think there’s just these names that come up and you’re like, ‘OK, you just passed so-and-so, and it’s like, I did what? Who? That’s a freaking legend,'” Verlander said. “You just don’t think about yourself that way. You just kind of [put your] head down, work hard, just keep plugging along, but I feel like moments like that — you hear Walter Johnson, even though I’m not there yet technically, I guess I’m in limbo — everybody knows that name.
“Every pitcher that has ever picked up a baseball and played for a significant period of time knows who Walter Johnson is. It’s pretty cool.”