The Yankees bullpen has always been a key part of World Series championships, and it’s seen a host of exciting names throughout the organization’s history. The first name that comes to mind is Mariano Rivera, but after that, an assortment of names could fly depending on who is asked. Goose Gossage, Dave Righetti, David Robertson, and others are all potential candidates, but so is Sparky Lyle — one of the most memorable faces in Yankees history, he arrived from the club’s biggest rival and helped the Bombers on their way to multiple World Series championships. A beloved figure in those clubhouses, we celebrate Sparky today.
Albert Walter “Sparky” Lyle
Born: July 22, 1944 (Du Bois, PA)
Yankees Tenure: 1972-78
Lyle was born in July 1944 outside Pittsburgh in Du Bois, PA, and grew up in Reynoldsville, about a 15-minute drive away. He attended Reynoldsville High School for four years, where he played varsity football and basketball before the spring of his junior year, when he began playing American Legion baseball for the DuBois team. At the time, his high school could not field a team, so he had to find other outlets to play the sport. After trying out for the Pittsburgh Pirates (and eventually being rejected), Lyle was scouted by the Baltimore Orioles, who signed him as an amateur free agent.
Lyle spent the 1964 season within the Orioles organization, playing six games in West Virginia for the Bluefield Orioles and then the Fox Cities Foxes in Appleton, Wisconsin. He was used as a reliever in Bluefield, starting only four of the seven games he played. He earned himself a promotion to Fox Cities, where he posted a 2.31 ERA in six games, all six of which he started.
On November 30th of the same year, the Boston Red Sox drafted Lyle from Baltimore. Lyle started his second year of pro ball in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, with the Single-A Red Sox in 1965. He pitched in 37 games with only five games started, and it was not a pretty season. He finished with an adequate 5-5 record, but a 4.24 ERA with 79 strikeouts in 87 innings, along with 55 walks, was not where he wanted to be at the end of the year.
Following the season, though, he received a promotion to Double-A Pittsfield, but before that, he had a stop at spring training, where he had one of the most influential meetings of his pitching career.
Red Sox legend Ted Williams was a man above the rest when he was playing and even after. He was “The Kid” after all. And even though he had been done playing by the time Lyle got to spring training that year, it was Williams who taught him exactly what a slider was supposed to look like and do in the air. Williams told Lyle that it was the one pitch he had trouble with, and Sparky figured that if it was good enough to stymie the man styled as “the greatest hitter who ever lived,” then it was worth mastering. And from the time he was fully introduced to the pitch in 1965 spring training, it became a key part of his repertoire.
In 1966, Lyle saw a jump in his numbers with Pittsfield, going from a 4.24 ERA at Single-A to a 3.65 ERA in Double-A with 72 strikeouts in 74.0 innings pitched. He then made another jump to Triple-A to begin the 1967 season, while still working on his slider, and played 16 games (all as a reliever) with a 1.71 ERA, the best of his minor league career.
Lyle finally made his debut when he was called up to Boston after left-handed pitcher Dennis Bennett was sold to the New York Mets on June 24, 1967. It was on July 4, 1967, against the California Angels that Lyle pitched two scoreless innings to close out a 4-3 Red Sox loss, and he recorded his first career save 12 days later on July 16th in Boston’s 9-5 victory over the Detroit Tigers at Fenway Park. In 27 games during his rookie season, Lyle finished with a 1–2 record, five saves, and a 2.28 ERA with 42 strikeouts in 43.1 innings pitched, though he did not throw for the “Impossible Dream” Red Sox in the World Series due to arm soreness.
From his debut in 1967 to 1971, Lyle pitched for the Red Sox in the major leagues, and he pitched considerably more. In 1968, he threw in 49 games, and that number ramped up to 71 in 1969, the second-highest of his career. In those two seasons he also kept his ERA under 3.00 with 2.74 and 2.54 marks, respectively. And despite a bump in the road in 1970 where he finished the season with a 3.88 ERA, mostly due to (at the time) a career-low K/9 and a career-high H/9, he bounced back in 1971 at the age of 26 finishing with a 2.75 ERA in 52.1 innings pitched.
Nonetheless, the Red Sox decided to trade Lyle to the Yankees in March before the start of the 1972 campaign in the second- or third-most infamous Boston/New York trade in their long history. He proved to be a brilliant reliever in the Bronx, while the main man they dealt—Danny Cater—was never much better than an adequate first baseman.
In his first season in 1972 as the Yankees’ closer, Lyle pitched in 59 games and saved 35 of them, which was an American League record and a major league record for left-handers. He also became the first lefty to collect 100 saves in the American League. With an ERA of 1.92 in 107.2 innings during his first year in pinstripes, not only did Lyle make a great impression on Yankees fans, but he made an impression on the BBWAA voters as well. He finished seventh in the Cy Young Award voting and third in MVP voting, the highest finish of his career in the latter award category.
In 1973, Lyle’s ERA jumped a bit—not a surprise considering how strong a 1.92 ERA is generally speaking—but it still stayed at a 2.51, and he was awarded his first career All-Star appearance. And in 1974, it was more of the same, as he saw even more appearances (66 to be exact) and was even stronger, finishing the season with a career-best ERA of 1.66, a 215 ERA+. If he hadn’t proven to baseball fans that he was one of, if not the best, closers in the league, he had by this point. The 1975 campaign was one of his two worst seasons in pinstripes, even though a 3.12 ERA was still a 119 ERA+ for the season, but he took a step back to take three big steps forward, with the next three seasons being the best of his career as the Yankees finally surged out of their CBS Era doldrums.
Lyle in 1976 led the league in saves and earned himself a second All-Star appearance for the pennant-winning club, and in 1977, he became the first AL reliever to win the Cy Young Award, along with his third and final All-Star Game appearance and a sixth-place finish in MVP voting. He appeared in 72 games that season and registered 26 saves with only 68 strikeouts, but his 2.17 ERA did all the talking he needed it to do. In 1976, he broke Hoyt Wilhelm’s American League record of 154 career saves.
Not only did Lyle win the Cy Young Award in 1977, but he helped lead the Yankees to their first World Series championship in 15 years. Billy Martin deployed him in 14 innings across six games, and Lyle had a record of 3-0 by the time everything was all said and done Most importantly, he only allowed two earned runs: one against the Kansas City Royals in Game 3 of the ALCS, and the other on a solo home run against the Los Angeles Dodgers in Game 2 of the World Series. His highlights included saving the pitching staff by hurling 5.1 scoreless innings in ALCS Game 4 against the Royals, which was a must-win game. Had Lyle faltered, Reggie Jackson’s “Mr. October” moment might never have happened.
But despite Lyle’s 1977 Cy Young, the Yankees decided to upgrade the closer position following the season, and it was with one of the players we talked about earlier in the introduction: Pittsburgh Pirates reliever Rich “Goose” Gossage.
According to reports, Lyle was not opposed to the Yankees’ move at the time, but he later admitted that the Yankees front office should have gotten rid of him after they signed Gossage. He didn’t want the reduced role in the bullpen, and even though the Yankees won back-to-back World Series championships (a postseason where 33-year-old Lyle would only pitch one game and give up two earned runs in 1.1 innings pitched) with him on the roster in 1978, Sparky’s days in The Bronx were numbered. In pal Graig Nettles’ words, would go “from Cy Young to Sayonara.”
Lyle and George Steinbrenner could not reach an agreement on a contract, and as a result, Sparky was traded down south to a destination he had been clamoring to go to: the Texas Rangers (coincidentally with a future relief ace acquired in return). However, he was not the same pitcher at the end of his career. After a season and a half with the Rangers, Lyle was moved to the Philadelphia Phillies, where he spent three separate seasons before once again being moved, this time to the Chicago White Sox, who purchased his contract before eventually being released and hanging up his spikes.
Following his MLB career, Lyle published the famous book The Bronx Zoo detailing his time with the Yankees. Through both his amusing anecdotes within (and his many accolades in a Yankees uniform), he is remembered as both one of the best storytellers and relievers to don the pinstripes.
In 1998, 16 years after he retired from professional baseball, Lyle became the inaugural manager of the Somerset Patriots, now the Double-A affiliate of the Yankees, and he got to work. At the helm, he managed the team to three League Championship titles, seven Half Championships, and six South Division Championships. He was the Patriots’ manager until stepping down in 2012. Sparky remains a beloved figure in the organization, as his No. 28 is the only non-Jackie Robinson rumber to be retired by Somerset, and their mascot is named for him as well.
Happy 82nd birthday, Sparky! Hope you can sit on a birthday cake again today, for old times’ sake.
See more of the “Yankees Birthday of the Day” series here.