There have been times in recent weeks when the Yankees, essentially, have been bad at everything baseball, whether it’s fielding blunders that lead to unearned runs, poor pitching, or a vanishing offense that’s set some club records no one would want.
But it’s hard not to believe they’re better than that, especially with a run differential of plus-87 (all numbers are entering play Thursday), which is by far the best in the American League and is fourth overall. They recently surrendered first place in the AL East, but they have the second-best record in the league and only six MLB teams have more wins.
Yeah, there are complaints to be made, but overall, the product is pretty good, despite their recent losing streak. And that’s come while they played all of June without Aaron Judge, the game’s best offensive weapon. Other injuries have affected them, too, but they are still an obvious playoff team that might just be better than the sum of its parts.
So keep that in mind as we run through some grades for major Yankees. At the end, we’ll deliver marks for Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman, too, as well as an overall judgment. If you’re a pinstriped hierarchy hater, you will probably be disappointed.
Maybe you’ll get your last laugh this October. But you might just be watching your “favorite” team in the World Series.
Here are the grades...
AARON JUDGE
The Yanks are 12-15 without him. Pretty telling. His numbers (.907 OPS, for instance) weren’t up to his lofty standard, but we don’t know how much that stress fracture in a rib was bothering him.
Grade: A-minus
BEN RICE
He’s bloomed into one of baseball’s elite mashers (.916 OPS, 22 homers), but his stats have swooned lately without Judge in the lineup.
Grade: A-minus
PAUL GOLDSCHMIDT
“Young Goldy” destroys lefty pitching and already has more homers than he did all of last season. His thunder has been invaluable.
Grade: A
JAZZ CHISHOLM Jr.
He’s got 12 homers and 26 steals, but his OPS is only .708, below MLB average. There’s more in the tank here.
Grade: B-minus
AUSTIN WELLS
If he were qualified, his OPS would be the worst in baseball, by a lot.
Grade: F
CODY BELLINGER
True five-tool player whose glossy offensive season took a hit with a recent slump. His grade, too.
Grade: A-minus
JOSÉ CABALLERO
An agitator who has lots of defensive value at lots of different positions and plenty of verve on the basepaths. Sometimes gets more overall love because he’s not Anthony Volpe.
Grade: B-minus
CAM SCHLITTLER
Best pitcher in the American League, even after getting clobbered in his most recent start. Full stop.
Grade: A
CARLOS RODÓN
Walks too many, but he’s very hard to hit.
Grade: B
RYAN WEATHERS
Eye-popping stuff, but he seems destined to join the bullpen mix once Max Fried is healthy.
Grade: C-plus
WILL WARREN
Rough June (5.49 ERA) clipped his grade, but he’s a consistent back-end arm.
Grade: B-minus
GERRIT COLE
First two starts made you dream, but a 6.12 ERA in June shows how the path back from injury doesn’t necessarily fastrack back to greatness. Yet, anyway.
Grade: C-plus
DAVID BEDNAR
Endured shaky moments, but he’s been hot lately (12 straight scoreless appearances).
Grade: B-plus
FERNANDO CRUZ
His splitter is one of baseball’s great pitchers. Brings nifty emotion, too.
Grade: B-plus
CAMILO DOVAL
Great stuff, right? Results less so – 4.96 ERA, career-worst 1.4 homers-per-nine. Bounceback would be huge for the Yankee pen.
Grade: D
AARON BOONE
The Yankees have the best odds in the American League both to make the playoffs and to win their division, according to FanGraphs. They are second in MLB only to the mighty Dodgers in terms of odds to win the World Series. Seems like they’re in a good place, regardless of how the online anti-Boone faction sees it, though Boone must find a way to keep these Yanks afloat while Judge heals. Boone, a player’s manager, is a solid front-facing executive for the Yankees. He delivers his positive worldview nightly (while some fans crave an eruption) and has navigated personalities and injuries thus far. If there’s a segment of fans who don’t like his message, does that really matter?
Grade: B-plus
BRIAN CASHMAN
See the above on their playoff odds. No one seemed to like the winter plan to mostly run it back from last year, since that meant there were no shiny new toys. But it’s worked. Cashman got Bellinger back, added Weathers to a nice pitching mix and re-signed Amed Rosario, a helpful platoon bat. Now he’s got more work to do – the Yanks need bullpen arms and perhaps a righty-hitting catcher. The bottom of the lineup sometimes seems like a hit desert. Cashman is always willing to attack the club’s weaknesses at the deadline. He’ll likely do it again now and that’s when a more crucial evaluation of the GM will take place.
Grade: A-minus
OVERALL
The Yanks are probably the best team in the American League, even if they got embarrassed last weekend at Fenway, have played poorly since, and have had other moments where it hasn’t looked pretty. They’ve missed Judge, Fried, Trent Grisham and Giancarlo Stanton, and seemingly are enduring another “June Swoon” (that’s carried into July, apparently) that so lights up social media. But it figures to be scary for the rest of the AL once they get their guys back and start playing better.
Grade: A-minus